ML20207F648
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
| ML20207F648 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Prairie Island  |
| Issue date: | 12/17/1986 |
| From: | NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20207F539 | List: |
| References | |
| 50-282-86-01, 50-282-86-1, 50-306-86-01, 50-306-86-1, NUDOCS 8701060169 | |
| Download: ML20207F648 (6) | |
See also: IR 05000282/1986001
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:.._
*
4
SALP 6
APPENDIX
SALP BOARD REPORT
U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
,
REGION III
SYSTEMATIC ASSESSMENT OF LICENSEE PERFORMANCE
50-282/86001; 50-306/86001
Inspection Reports No.
>-
Northern States Power Company
Name of Licensee
i
s
Prairie Island Units 1 and 2
Name of Facility
December 1, 1984-May 31, 1986
kbk UkDbN Nb$b282 Assessment Period
O PDR
l
n-
-
* nmw- v w yyp --
--
---en c --4- -7 -,w+ -q- 4, e-..-7-w - --mw- rw----
9- iwe
1
I
J
i
Prairie Island Plant i
i
Meeting Summary
'
The findings and conclusions of the SALP Board are documented in Reports 4
No. 50-282/86001; No. 50-306/86001. They were discussed with the licensee I
on August 20, 1986, at the Region III office in Glen Ellyn, Illinois. The !
licensee's regulatory performance was presented in each functional area.
Overall regulatory performance has continued at a satisfactory high level
during the assessment period. This level of performance is exemplified by
the fact that six functional areas remained a Category 1 from the previous
rating period. A Category 2 rating was given in the areas of Plant Operations,
Surve111ances, Fire Protection, Administrative Controls, and Training and
Qualification Effectiveness (a new functional area for SALP 6). This
represented a decline in performance in the Fire Protection area. We
continue to rate Prairie Island's regulatory performance as one of the best
in Region III.
While this meeting was primarily a discussion between the licensee and the
NRC, it was open to members of the public as observers.
The following licensee and NRC personnel were in attendance on August 20,
1986:
Northern States Power Company
C. E. Larson, Vice President, Nuclear Generation
W. A. Shamla, Plant Manager
D. E. Gilberts, Senior Vice President, Power Supply
F. Fey, Superintendent, Radiation Protection
L. R. Eliason, General Manager, Nuclear Plants
D. Musolf, Manager, Nuclear Support Services
D. Antony, Superintendent Operations
D. Nevinski, Superintendent Engineering and Radiological Protection
K. Albrecht, Director, Power Supply Quality Assurance
L. Waldinger, Superintendent, Radiological Protection
F. P. Tierney, General Manager, Nuclear Engineering and Construction
W. Albold, Superintendent, Maintenance
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
i J. G. Keppler, Regional Administrator l C. E. Norelius, Director, Division of Reactor Projects
D. C. Boyd, Chief, Projects Section 2D E. R. Schweibinz, Chief Technical Support Staff J. E. Hard, Senior Resident Inspector R. B. Landsman, Project Manager, Section 20
i !.
. . - - - - - - - . - . - - _ - . - . - . _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -
PHWCIPAL iMPECTOR <Na v us, &st ana mu*.mt.att
NRC FOR M68 * U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
u s3, . .
"'""'
INSPECTOR'S REPORT R , y ,,,, R
Office of inspection and Enforcement
INSPECTOR 5
^ DOCKET NO 88d gas:OR LICENSE
'
LICENCE E ' VENDOR Tv,
NO 48Y PRODUCTi 1p dag tal go SEQ Mo. YR
'^~""'
Nor//rers: Slales Brur & o s o o o ae a r & s t *
*
P mitie n/and _
* - " '" o 5e o o n s6 r 1, o l C
D - DELETE
R REPLACE D
'i 2 14 15 18
4 EseOD OF WVESTIGATION< tNSPECTION iN5PE CTiON Pf RFORME D BY ORGANIZATON CODE OF REGONIHQ CONDLCT-
lNG AC16VITY iSee IEMC C530 * Mat; power Recott-
FKOM TO M 1 - REG'DNAL OFFICE ST A5> CTHfR ,
PEGtON
yy p
DT iSf0N
..
BRANCH
MO DAY YR. MO DAY YR 2 RESIDENTINSPECTOR
glR d Olf de fl6 1 - FERFORMANCE APPRAISAL TEAM
26 32 33 34 35
20 25 - 31
TiPE OF AcirviTV CONDUCTE vicheck one bon oNvi
REGONAL ACTION
" " ' "Y 02 - $AFETY 06 - MGMT. Vs9T 10 - PLANT SEC. 14 - INQUIR Y
_
03 - INCIDENT 07 - SPECIAL 11 - INVENT VER. 16 - !NVESilG ATON
t - NRC FOPM 591
G4 - ENFORCEMENT 08 - VENDOR 12 - SHIPMENT, EAPORT
2 - f.EGIONAL OFFICE LETTER
05 - MGMT. AUDIT 09 - MAT. ACCT, 13 - IMPDR T
36 37 38
4N5PECINN iNwE5TiGAT*0N FiNOiNG5 TOT AL NUMBER ENFORCEMENT CONFERENCE REPORT CONTAiN 2 M LETTER OR REPORT TR ANSMITTAL DATE
(Chart o*w bos wvb INFORM A YtON
OF VOLATIONS AND HELD
A S C D DEV1ATICNS NRC FORM 591 REPORT SENT
TO HQ. FOR
X X 1 - CLEAR
OR REG
LE T TER 155UED ACTION
* 2 - VIOLATION
VR YR
3 - DtviATION A B C D A B C D Al8 C D MO DAY MO.l DAY
,
4 - ViOLATON & DEVIATON , , , , 1 - YES 1, YES l l l l l l l
40-41 42 43 44 49 50 55
- 39
MODULE INFORM ATIGN Monu:FiNsonMatmN
" MODVLE NUM8ER INSP. 6g 9 MODULE PEQ FOLLOWUP MODULE NUMBER IN$P yg 9 MODULE REO FOLLOWUP
jO
. _ e-r5 go _
-
_ r-rs, so .
5 #$ $5 E !$ $$r a 45 h5 5 . #$ h5 . E ! $$ $$r 3 . #5 h5
e s
i. !:s5
95
Ea
s ; 5 ;gifs
5 65a
gra
r8s
i :.
:; I
s2 8s
35 23 s
-
c ?
s :
I ;5> ss
> E3 s
e
e 5
* E
s5r Eta
;agifs r8P
a
L I
: :sut 8s
E? s
: ? m f
8 l h [[ClYgd g ZJ[ # l / g et g g g ll g l s j [ j j l l l l l l ll l l
*
i/i a ,, , IiiI e
i i i i i IiiI
'
.i i i i liil '
i i i i i liil
o
i, i , i liil o , i , i i liil
^
s i i liil ^
ii i i i liiI e i i liil i i i i i lii1
l
-
ii , i , i , , i
- , , i , , ii,i
c
ii i i i li,I c
i i i i i liil
o
,, i , , 1,,1 o
i , , , i l..I
a i i liiI ^
ii i i i liil s i i lii !
^
i i i i i Iiil
a
ii , , i liil e
i i i t i liil
c
ii i i 1 1,il i i i i i Iiil
o
ii , i i IiiI =
, , , i i IiiI
^ ^
l > i i liil ii i i i liil 4
i i liiI i i i i i liil
i e
ii i i i lii1 e
i i i i i iiiI
c
ii i i i liil_ i i i i i liiI
O CIRCLE SEQUf NCE IF O
i i =
vot aTION OH OEV1ATION [ ] l t
l l l g [ [ g l l [ ] l
l ib >i. p 20 ,2 ,3 ,, ,. ,. ,, x 2, 2. ,i, 31 4 is 20 ,2 ,3 ,5 ,.- s. ,, , ,, 2.
]
.
.
SIRCFORM M A KEPORT WODULE NUMBE A .(, +
CGCxEY NO 48 dttsiOR LCENSE
" "' 80
IE C 0636 NO SEO l* l l l* l l
'
INSPECTOR'S REPORT "
"ToTY#M" nEEEo "-
a ,c
(Continuation) , , 3 , , , ,
.
. Office of Inspection and Enforcement c so-
0 2' 2a zu
vcLAscu On OEvsAicN wnter : o no 2400 eneree ters tor esen otem It the test onceeds unis numcor. st win ce necessary to paraphrase L6mitlines to 50 characters each.)
1.
2.
3-
4.
6.
s.
7.
e
9
10.
11.
12
13
1.. ,
is.
16
17.
18
19
20
21
t
22
23
21
!
ts
71
21
2n
29
30
1
31
32
33
34
3s
m
37
h
2 5i
m sawa' U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMhlSSION
( ,
r- -
9mC FORN DOCIET NO (8 d'0'isiOR UCENSE FEMRT MOOME WBE A
M31
it UCOS3% , , NO (SV PRODUCTHt3 dets) NO. SEO \ \ \ \ \ \
INSPECTER'S REPZRT ^ ogneo sun.
"TO "l="
e
(Continuation) , , , , , , , ,c
Office Of Inspection and Enforcement C eo-
D n u a
i
scLATDN OR DEvnATON lFnter up to 2400 characters for each nom. It the rest escoeds this number, N ants be necessary to paraphrase Lomit IInes to 50 characters each.)
1.
2.
3
A.
s.
e
7.
a.
9
s
10
11.
12.
13.
11
13.
16.
17.
is
19.
20
21.
22.
23-
24
(
n
a
21
2e
29
30
31
32
33
3a
35
as
37
h
2 Si
e *> E 7-est U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
'
.
, W pQaM M A DOCKET NO (859ts OR UCENSE
REPORT MODULE NUM ER 4;,
,cJt \ NO (BY PRODUCT)(13Ogits)
st MC 0535 NO SEO Pl l f l l
^ *Ts".LVO" Rd'#,o
INSPECTOR'S REP!RT suet.
' e ,j, o ,c
(Continuation) 3 , , ,
Office of Inspection and Enforcement C
p 2'
8o
2s ze
' VOLAtCN OR DEVIATCN dnter up to 2400 Characters Mr enCh 6 tem. H the test onceeds thus number. st wil be necessary *4 perschrase Limut Hnes to 50 characters each.)
1.
2.
3
4.
a
*
e
7.
a
e
io.
11,
12.
13
14
is _
16
17.
is.
to
20
,
21
22.
23
24
2s
26
21
28
2s
v
31
22
33
34
O
=
37
h
__
4a
2 st
*4 a :r m U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION }}