ML20206E318
| ML20206E318 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 12/29/1983 |
| From: | Roxworthy C NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20204G575 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-85-419 NUDOCS 8704130578 | |
| Download: ML20206E318 (12) | |
Text
_ . _ _ _ _ _ .
t t *
\ \
UNITED STATEE
/on288kk NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION g REGloN Ill
[
g y,
Tes RoostvELT ROAD 8, - OLEN E LLYN, ILLewoes 80137 IMD. & !.l!CH. ELECTR.t; L3.
December 29, 1983 #; L[,2@f Pj3
" ***' " * ; JM1031984
_(EhMU U N Ld D0!!Atu C. Ct:0K PLANT
. itS.tMGL9tAL
SUBJECT:
LICENSE APPLICATION PURSUANT TO 10 CFR PART 55 Dear Mr .
Receipt of the subject matter is acknowledged and the Docket Number indicated above has been assigned.
Preliminary review of the information submitted indicates that we have not, as yet, received the following items that are required as part of your application:
/_/ A certification from the facility licensee
- that you have learned to operate the controls in a safe and competent manner, commensurate with the class of license for which you are applying. (Reference Section 55.10(a)(6).)
/~ / A quantitative description, in your certification of competence, of the training, forr.a1 and operational, that you have received. (Reference Section 55.10(a)(6).)
/~ / A certification from the facility licensee
- that you have need for the license in the performance of your duties. (Reference Section 55.10(a)(6).)
/~~ / A request from the facility licensee
- that the operating test be adminis- ,
tered. (Reference Section 55.10(a)(6).)
l
/- / A signed statement giving us permission to give examination results to your facility management.
/_/ A completed Form NRC-396, " Certificate of Medical History," copy enclosed. J
/g/ Applicant's signature, item 17a, page 2 *(NRC Form 398 enclosed) ,
NOTE: *All certifications must be signed by the highest level of corporate manage-ment for plant operation (for example, Vice President for Operations).
(Reference 3/28/80 letter from Harold R. Denton, Director, Office of Nucitar Reactor Regulation to All Power Reactor Applicants and Licensees, subject:
QUALIFICATIONS OF REACTOR OPERATORS Enclosure 1, Page 3.
IND. & MICH. ELECTRIC CO.
D525NT
$f13057e a Go t h-S S~W f . h M 9 REBE A9 PDR YG 0;i:,..*.; 0. *;00K PLANT h.i.10NNEL j
v- u- -
.,. :. f ~( y
' ( .
- 2 Please note that all itens except medical information should be submitted in triplicate. You will be notified as soon as action is taken on your application, or if additional information is needed. .
Sincerely,
}
- Cindi Roxworthy, Licensing Assistant Operator Licensing Section cc: ant Manager Training Supervisor '
t f
1 l
l I
)
l oe e,
YoI A +i9 Gr \
. 4
-- . - - -- - ~~-w_ ;,_p n...m,-y..,
, - .n.__- -2 u.4
- j ..
soo-> w~ __
(
N[
- 7NAL.D C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT CONDITION REPORT f M# O .
TO: PLANT MANAGER ff, fe . g ef" y c e t-g oferd#
(2)' DATE: 5-3-84 TIME: 1000 (3) Category A ,
~
(4) Classi5ed By: ,th;M (5) I'ER/AEO NO M LER DUE BY: 8 /t/ 5 ((* 'D / /f4 W 0 6//N t i 1
(6) Item Reported O.n ~ ~ ~ '(7 ) Plant Conditions: N/A Reactor Operator Ren al _
License No. Unit No.1 Mode N/A Power level N/A %
Unit No. 2 Mode N/A Power Level N/A % l Description of Condition / Event Date 12-23-83 Event Time N/A Unit Affected N/A h(8) On Decembe 3,1983 a license renewal for was delivered to the NRC (License '
No. . During a review of STA Requa ica - ecordsonA3-84,itwasdis-
[d
\
covere this application had been made without STA Requalification requirements as required by ec having completed the 1982-1983 on 50.54(1-1) c610 CFR 50.(,& 1 h tk.J uan f p** ti--s ,(k- .St.g e rts. 2VOME ~
f-D wJ m so mf)rJT T# C C*) SM'W ' !)#-
R
() Additional Pages Reported By: , b Initiated JO blo. /,s.b r
E (9) Corrective Action Taken:
Began imediate investigation to ensure that ad not been allow to perform licensed duties. Investi ation revealed letter from~ . . Smith t dated September 1, 1983 stating will not perform any licenses requir d ac ivi ies until Requalification
-- s' '
j ;
,, . Af ,U W y
(10) Off- Site Notification: Made By: N 8. (Complete Telephone Records & Attach)
( ) AEPSC ( )I & M )N ( ) Michigan Not Applicable (11) Investigation Assigned To: I. d M/T#/AII(12)QA Findings:
kLtdMR S H u 4To r m - ? 1gt 84-n cv "
J as m' m'r J (13) Investigation Report t" U C c'w4d yrA*'<. cen. Mg
?(g Q p). yc,w fu fr, pcpv e r gitc.39%
& ,', i, r po 1 t
( ) Additional Pages Completed By:
(14) Preventive Action Taken
( ) Additional Pages Dept. Head Approval:
(15) PNSRC Review: Date Meeting No. PNSRC Secretary Comments:
gg (16) QA Classification: [
(17) Distribution: Plant Mgr.. Aase. Plant toer.. O A supw.. PNsR C Seeretary. AEPsc Mar. O A. Deparemment Head orignatina Departament _
F02M Mo. pnep 93w m yy nn, , ,,, s, .
- f
~
May 7, 1984 '
l CATE:
INVESTIGATION REPORP CN LICENSE hWML SusJECT: DATED 2-11-84 J. D. DICKSON FCOM:
W. A. NICH2S TO:
his information is provided to assist in describ the _ts leading to the BO License No. being renewed for under questionable circumstances, the controls in p preivent usage j of the license.
l
- 1. Mr. license was due to expire Normal Training 'on pre re is to start ~ process paperwork 4 about 90 days prior to expiration. Several licenses were due to expire at this time and paperwork was started on all of them.
l
- 2. At this time Mr. d not empleted his Requalification Program ;
requirenents inc '
annual written exam. On 9-1-83 the Plant Manager gave instruction by letter to the Training coordinator that Mr. was not be perform li nsed activities until his Requalifica on ficiencies were corrected. PIhis was erroneously listed in the Cmdition rt as a letter !
from W. G. Smith to Mr. ) Mr. s verbally notified of the letter ~ ~
perform licensed activities and has not been performing licensed activities in the interim period. Further, he will not perform any license '
activities until this condition has been resolved.
- 3. % e first step in applying for renewal of licenses is .I performed by clerical perw=el. His consists of empiling j current and past work history frm files, training personnel, i and the applicant. His informatico is then placed on NRC l form 398. During this ocmpilation attention is paid to J
Bequali _ Program deficiencies. It was noticed at this time Mr had deficiencies existing in his records. He was ins tio sign his license application with these g deficiencies existing by the Training Coordinator. i
- 4. % e licenses are then sent to the Training Coordinator for Training Section approval indicating all Requalification .
requirenents are or will be coupleted before license renewal
- would be accuplished. Normally the licensee would have signed the application prior to this activity.
gp( g - 8 b G\
l IN T R A.SY ST E M ,
\ .
>- \
I Inve tig tion' port on License Renewal fo May 7, 1983 1 .
- 5. It is apparent that at this point the current license l applications including Rod's were resented to the Training Coordinator for review. Mr had not signed his application at this time. All of the then curren license applications were then signed on Line 17c of NRC Form 398 by the Tr Coordinator on 12/8/83. He stated that he knew Mr had not signed the application and was aware that he was current in Requalification Training. Mr. Nelson verbally the responsible clerical personnel not to send Mr. t lication until these deficiencies werg wucced.
s lication inadvertently got further processed which led to the renaining items. l l
- 6. The license applications were then sent to Cook Plant '
Managerial where W. G. Snith, Jr., signed on Line 17c on 12-10-83. The applications were then forwarded to AEP where M. P. Alexich signed on the same line on 12-16-83.
- 7. The applications were then returned to DC Cook Training to be sent to the NRC. They were sent to the NRC on 12-20-83 and they were received by the NBC on 12-23-83.
1
- 8. During processing by the NRC it was noted that Mr had not !
signed his application and it was therefore re im with a letter of explanation requesting applicant's signature on Line 17a, Page 2, NRC form 398. This letter of explanation had cc: for Plant Manager and Training Supervisor. The letter was received by Cook Managerial on 1-3-84 and forwarded to Personnel where it was received on 1-4-84.
- 9. E en Mr. bived the above request from the NRC, and his license app tion with signatures fran Training, Man =y=mt, and corporate levels in place, his opinion was the .
requirements nust have been met with the existing -
deficiencies. He therefore signed the application and sent it baci to the NBC.
- 10. The NRC, upon re i* the signed application, then issued a renewal of Mr '
icense based upcn examination of his t qualifications, .inc the representations and infomation I contained in his application for license. i e
g o t A - O E-449 H
2 /IAPA3 Sw. - .. . . _ _ _ _ . _
j
\
Inve:tigationi port en License Renewal for May 7, 1983
- 11. r indicating renewal of Mr license effective ~
was then sent to Mr. Simns wl cc::~to IGt Electric
, DC (bok thiclear Facility, PO Box 458, Bridgman, Michigan 49106. 'Ihis letter was received in Managerial on 1-13-84 and forwarded to Personnel on 1-16-84.
'Ihe above is a reconstruction frczn records that to the best of my knowledge is factual.
l If I may be of any further assistance please let ce know.
/1 -
/M/s /
J. .' DICKSCN,'Trauung 'InstructoM cc: L. J. Matthias D. D. Nelson l TD File l
e e
II Em a-s s-e9 Ge \ i 3 /IApA3
_ . _ . .. w __ _ ._
^1 -- n. 1
__m._?
. l / o~ f I
( , *,tmcaw coc e,
,e [o INDIANA & MICNIGAN ELECTRIC COMPANY AEP "Owgg gygTE*
CATE:
k W 1,1983 ,
SUBJECT:
i l
FIOM:
W. G. GII'Di, JR., Plant Manager D. D. NEUSCN, Training Ooordinator
'Ihis is to infom you that *11 perfom no license required ification Training program activities until deficiencies an have been corrected.
(Aik b t M W. G. SEDi, J1e. ,-Plant Manager
/jc cc: BQ File g
t e
6\
- w. _
^'"""=~-=~~-v..w__ , _ _ _ _ , , . _ _, . , , _ __
.e -
. . A - .
.A y. .t e.
. g ausaton, Co.-..
p m,a,,c,g gqeg,g g y g3~-
asio es as PERSONAL QUALIFICATIONS STATEMENT -LICENSEE DEC 2 31983 1
,A AT1. ..,..~ .. .T...o...C.T..,~.~...,..-.
. 1
,,,,,, a.a.,,, cat -
i . 4 Aeoa.. ,, . . . .. n p.Coto 2-sIComo CsTT IAos TAf tsats le* Coot tasa T
. as - t 2-Ta'ao MI 9085 . v camos - l, ' . sisapeteCafsom,maeven u- asouts_ino.
- 3. CfTage asneser GAG 3 1 esaTM oa18 6AGs g g,gg,34;ggg, g-08t A L 3 taassf to STATES 2-WalMIN #C.mpery
..T...,, g s-s=vtafoa l l
- o. TVPE 08 LICtesst APPteto f o. (Att S. PatWo us Lecterstas) Det LD lam
' ' ' *p a orgmaTon a SoCKEYesuaseln g o LICtsett seueseta ,,,,,,, ,[, ,0 ,], l . FACILITY o. Cut? esunsete i o m .o. ..Toa . - -
1
- e. LeastTto sao ,e s F s* 88sas***, @ 315.316 s sessTRUCToa CtafspsCATeoes I anaest os ArrteCassT1 f u'Lovga sana 90. CunRENT rosafsoes af F Acettiv IAsa Indiana & Michigan Electric Company ,,,A,,,,v,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, .u,,,,,,,,A,.,
Apoft(ss GAL 5
- . Av.,,,A.,Tuatimt Ynaa GustotwG,
- h. assistant PLA8ef suPtRiesTgasotNT tout,nsessent E E ortmaTo8e PO Box 458, Red Arrow Highway -
, ,,, , ,v,, ,,,,so,,
'*c'**'o*"**'*"'
cf.. .
sTaua.,p., Coot.ao. . m ,,.......a .
] , of,,in ,s +,
Bridoman llI I 49106 r . smn Cat ne,sw*ep t thGsNt tR Aowesoa S Smaast os AppggCahT1 F ACitfTV tapp e gassf auCToa Donald C. Cook Plant !s' "ACettiv
" " " " * ' oOCaET 315 -
. si=.oa Co Taot aoo.s
~ o*EaaToa 9 AppaT eossaL P ACALsTT ooCEE Ts gas.ee.4sm., &ss.eeen, sama 316
--] = Co Taot aoo- o ia.Toa u souCAT, .An I
. c= sC-cot . wason Aaraision sfuo, "T/1.", - a voC*T*'aunC"*c^t J:7o*'v" ci"!k
",JM"; l o'6.ay,c,gt,5,'y,q -*
X c=Aouan cio ov.vaa.sCv.
' a5'a' '"'a6 " > '* <
il *- *' T m o' Taa'='~o '"
- l*-= oat Nuclear Pwr Plant Oos 12 X ;
,,, of..a g '-etan"C"" Defense Physics 4
. u .. o. n aas of CG4LEGI 4 3 l,'ff'd*[,,' t.anouane School 7 X j I 4-asAsT8 m fcur (4) ls-coCToaat it.TRAeassaec gavl l 13 EEPEastesCE 4AW) l eesoasTMa%ovgan e asuneeta e esOeTwassovgan e asunsef st {
emons to "" " g e mons to a.esWCLE AR PourtR PLAast Fu8soatsf esTALS ar- - -
- 8/80 9/81 16 l 8sAVY*-ao ,
a.eLAsef sysTsaan -soon,erno
(
eLA= e 8/80 12/80 15 3-e-s, :
ents.AT.o .
s.artCATessc PaaCTsCE l .-sasta.
s-of sat a ,3 .#,,
Co Trot moo. ontaaT.o.,s
- -utAf oa o,e = A 7.o s , c ,
.11/80 6/83- 05 *-o*a a a
- g usaToa aversgeproddy Phusi Daisy s , estin
-' :-su,sav son RDFs -tT~~
, 4 :::na" X us .o 6 o-ofana a c+,
, 7.*.T!* * !:.."',n , . 211 ; a
.. sao .=sf avCT o= ' .
p-,
co==aacialauct N'".TACfon o ..To.w Aa,11C8MfgdRh
- s. t a van s'apsom og snes T 2/B2 pres. 2?
st.sges. cat 0,emafoa
- e-ciouaussca7:04 1/31 Dres. 12-s**T suesavison r . of as e as.~.*,
12 is. stare,smei sasce= ra (STA) .Nuc. Enn ineer Lover) se-aus ,sou
- easo=tsCausson oesn. Tom
- Ts-PL Aest STAFF 96.oTMia is.sy.fyd ARMY -- -
17-RO SM 1 and 5'1 1A Plants A/69 12/70 21 P o t Pr - t> 3 " 'r1 T I
Cl T '..
-(
. s u o...C. u. . .. ,
- r. ..., ._
Provide technical advice to Shift Sunervisor SHIFT TECHNICAL ADVISOR DC COOK HUCLEAR PLA!!T during normal plant operations and provide 8/80 to 4/82 '
INDIANA & tilCHIGAN an i'ndwendent assessment to Shift SuDer-visor durinn abnormal nlant conditions.
l .
Review plant condition reports and operat-
, ing exoerience reports from other plants, and evaluate their impact on our olant.
I"' CLEAR Afi0 C0:!PUTER DC COOK NUCLEAR PLANT Duties include nuclear reactor technical ENGINEERING SUPERVISOR INDIANA & P11CHIGAN studies and tests, fuel manaaement straten- ,
4/82 to present '
. ies, safe nuclear and thermodynamic opera-tional limits of the nuclear reactors in
. compliance with technical specifications.
Maintenance and pronrarrriina of olant com-puters. Supervision of ten personnnel.
...e .1..-, _: . . . ~ . ,
- 10.8 #13: currently holds a Reactor Operator License at the Donald C. Cook uc ear ant 7 His .iob duties include that of Nuc. lear End< Computer Enn.'ineering Supervisor for the Technical Department. -
- 17: United States Army, Ft. Belvoir Virginia and Ft. Greeley Alaska. Nuclear Power Plant Operator and Electrician oosi~t ions held. -
90 t A -SS-4 W
" Gi\ . ,
soaaac ust I l lus tis atoviatus=Ts l l cots act asagt atooingue=Ts i i
s a.aC pona8 3D6 CtafePaCATI of a.f D* CAL games.4&TIOas tamp l l e is ATTAcceE0 l ltWILLBf90awanDED
,m. =a = . - - . -
.=_..__.g.,
- =:: ,2 ::~
=,= ::::. =, .:= ~.=#. . . ~o.=:~,. ~. ::: .. t .= ~~.~;:r. ,=r.~. ~
1 I L g
s smarvas - vaa.=.=G ooono.maron l cava sec=at um a. s o4,g
=:':.',=:.:.r.:: ~ ~ :: -;.: u.: . .~~ ~~ ~ ~~~ ~~g gst,t,t~ go,sgoaromata ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ manaceans%t . '= c ~ ~ ~ ~
l hw88/ntzfr$r ,Ap&Tk-~ rz.hdb A --
gf.7/ []
s.. .... . ........ .oon .. coa , p . .dn ' si 'i c'<-mewn>r2o ...- . o., .
1
. r,. - -
( y.
- p.l;p fj.g .(-
, i 3.fe--
t' . t6 I
( f//l* h y .- .
. PMI-7080 ,
ATTAC3DiENT No. 1
~
INDIANA AND M.ICEIGAN M CTRIC COMPANY DONALD C. CCCK NUCLZAR PLANT l
\
NRC DOCUMENT PROCESSING FORM , _ . j
,_ _DC_CUMzNT.NUMBEa: IE INFORMATION NOTICE 84-11 TI"'LZ : TRAINING PROGRAM DFFirTFNETF9 DISTRIBUTION
. n _,, Acticn Info ,
Actien Info Adminisyative/TP4(-) @ Operations @
Info, a5d Reccrds Center C @ Cutage/ Planning O-Maintenance O O oualiti Assu=ance O O O
~~
O
. Managerial: ._ . Stores .- .
Plant F.anager~__
~~
Technical O .
Asst. )_lant Msir. - Mai=t. C.
Technical sTA's @ ..}
Asst. }lant Mgr. - Oper. E
~ ~
O Isa p- t==ctica
,. staff [Lssistant othat. A tah n P @
. . _.. . Fire Protection O O G' E .
g d.h '-b Aut % f.4 . 6aw- vmMQ
. ..eIf any.of.the following requirements are answered.Yes, the apprcpriate _.-
- - - portion.cf'the.docu=ent must be distributed by the-Inforsation and Records. :
.. . -- Center.and posted by the recipient within two working. days of receipt ; ..
pursuant to PM50.006.(e.g., 10CTR19.11e). --
. A)[ - oie require =ents by Crfer of the NRC7 Yes No @
g.,.
3)[ Mcdify, suspend or revoke a Licehs"e'?'G. ,.. ',3 r Y,es No i L x .* 5 i t O .t f ' .', -
C)[ Contain a Notice 'of Violation 1s'v6.171ngI s'd.d. Yes No radiological working conditions?
a g( D) ~ Prepose the 3-esitien of Civil Penalties? Yes O so 5 L.blV- CCMMtNTs: Wii% - A1 CE s'i% :.a*.J . .! at.- .i % , L,-
I \ S\ a - i
$ -u P 0 DA I CF RICII;T: 3/2/84 DATI RIV_rsc: k7/f/
_ _._..r.Ar r.ANAc:2: u.vM No 645'- +W G I . _ .
em so ameom. t.m e
,M *
( . , . (, /" ' f piCAN ELECy
.- p"c-
\'
INDIANA & MICHIGAN ELECTRIC COMPANY AEP Owg, gy gid ,
CATE: March 19, 1984 * 'ID 7662 SU2 JECT: IE INFORATICN NOTICE 84-11 i
FCous W. A. NICHOIS TC W. G. SMITH I ccmpared the Licensed Operator Peplacement Training Program described in Section 12 of the DC Cbok FSAR with our present program to ensure we meet our FSAR ccumitrents as related to IE Notice 84-11. ;
l The FSAR ccumits us to provide formal classroca lectures, training at a research reactor, on-the-job training including simulator training, an audit exam prior to the NRC exam, and review training. All of these ccrmitments are included in our present program in nore depth than )
described in the FSAR. We do not have any deficiencies regarding the Operator License Training Program cocpared to FSAR crnmitments.
I did cone across one item of concern related to STA's that I want to bring to your attention. Section 12 of the FSAR states that:
" Prior to selection to the program, the SIA candidates shall have been working at the Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant in a responsible capacity for a minimum of one (1) year and shall possess a Bachelor of Science Degree in an engineering related field. In addition, each candidate will meet the one (1) year of professional level nuclear power plant experience requirement outlined in Draft Standard ANS 3.1 dated Decenber 17, 1979."
'Ihis statement may be a potential problem area in that we are hiring STA l candidates without DC Cbok Plant experience.
4 j sw~:q .
If you have any questions, call me at Ext.1386.
5.
1 c.ec:.4 .-l sJ 3 .g.:; .
I p,:.
N. O.
W. A. NICHOLS, Acting Training Coordinator nn r mes. mm. to. .
i gy ", spp:.q.grr)-(s;;;--
y.n;. >' \. f -
~~ a q ;\ \
uc r 2 ! /jc 'l 7 li- 1
-3 -
!.s APR 2 51994
. rd-12 cc: TD File Pcplacement Training f.j Administrp [.
k -
i PER-020-06-01 cn O ,
LONA!!s c. COOK I4Ai; l e.c.t m m:.t:a ,
F o i A-es-+tg l INT R A.5Y ST E M k
o a n ,n .>.u
'/
2ACS V _E 7ANSV A_
om orn 2s.1, J. S. \RC R' ;;Im, 1 HOUR V' APPROMA v A _A.\ TA, GA. 0, Jane A. Axelrad --
(NAME)
EWW 359 (LOCATION)
Analysis of Report of Investigation ,
I i 46 applications, representing 33 applicants for R0/SRO license contained We training entry that the CEtrol Room Operator Oval. Card (QC) was
. completed -
Investigation disclosed -
12 applicants never worked on a QC 13 applicants started but _never completed a QC 8 applicants completed only the System Knowledge Section of the QC, failing to complete the Practical Factors Section which had not been implemented at the time the applications were submitted -
Ti~ Total Applicants Investigation further disclosed -
that the 33 individuals above also had other errors and discrepancies /-
deficiencies in their RO/SRO applications to the NRC, including, (1) incorrect course durations, (2) training courses listed on the applications which are not documented in training files, and (3) training courses listed on the applications in which applicants admittedly did not participate -
Additionally - investigation disclosed that 9 other applicants (these Og 9 applications did not have the entry Cold License Operator Qual. Card listed) had errors, discrepancies / deficiencies noted in their applica-
[# '
tions, including, (1) incorrect course durations, and (2) training courses listed on applications which are undocumented in licensee training files / records. , pg _ gg49 HI
.. e. . -.m. .