ML20205S726
| ML20205S726 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 04/20/1999 |
| From: | Stewart Magruder NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Carpenter C NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| PROJECT-692 NUDOCS 9904270002 | |
| Download: ML20205S726 (47) | |
Text
-
_s e
,, [ l UNITED STATES g ,g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
'4 WASHINGTON, D.C. 2006H001
\.m./ April 20, 1999 MEMORANDUM TO: Cynthia A. Carpenter, Chief Generic Issues, Environmental, Financial ;
and Rulemaking Branch Division of Regulatory Improvement Programs Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation FROM: Stewart L. Magruder, Project Manager .1%J % . d Generic Issues, Environmental, Financial and Rulemaking Branch Division of Regulatory improvement Programs 4 Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF SEPTEMBER 2,1998, MEETING WITH THE COMBUSTION ENGINEERING OWNERS GROUP (CEOG)
On September 2,1998, a public meeting was held at the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) offices in Rockville, Maryland, between representatives of the NRC and the CEOG.
Attachment 1 provides a list of attendees.
The purpose of the meeting was to discuss a CEOG outage initiative related to alternative decay heat removal in Mode 6/ refueling. The CEOG representatives stated that unless the staff raised issues during the meeting that appeared to be unresolvable, they intend to submit a l generic topical report on this issue. The CEOG presentation material from the meeting is included as Attachment 2. !
1 The CEOG representatives stated that the proposal to allow increased options for decay heat removal in Mode 6 has several benefits. Among the benefits are improved plant safety resulting from less fuel movement and more time for the fuel inside containment. It would also -
allow for decreased outage time due to the ability to remove the shutdown cooling system frcm i service for maintenance. The CEOG representatives noted that changes to plant Technical-Specifications would be required to implement this proposal and the bracketed numbers in the k
FI i presentation are typical values.
Following the CEOG presentation, the staff raised several questions for the CEOG to consider:
- 1. Whit .vould be the safety classification of the alternate shutdown cooling system?
- 2. Does this proposal depend on containment cooling?
- 3. Does this proposal increase the importance of maintaining the cavity seal and nozzle dams?
- 4. Would the spent fuel pool purification system be secured?
O 4 6/973 an0Gl 4270002 990420 NNN 79"7f TOPRP EMVC-E P
C YH ,
L5 -
C. Carpenter April 20,1999
- 5. How would operators monitor cavity temperature?
The staff stated that, although they would review the topical carefully if submitted, they did not i see anything in the presentation that would cause them to reject the report.
Project No. 692 -
Attachments: As stated cc: See next.page
.f
C. Carpenter : April 20, 1999
- 5. How would operators monitor cavity temperature?
The sta# stated that, although they would review the topical carefully if submitted, they did not see anything,in the presentation that would cause them to reject the report.
Project No. 692 Attachments: As stated cc: See next page DISTRIBUTI N: See attached page Document Name: g:\msum0902.wpd OFFICE - PM:RGEB (A)SC:RGEB NAME SMagrudeM TBergmanN DATE 4/30/99 4/s.,0 /99 1
y
<. e
- l. .
w
- Distribution
- Mig. Summaryw/CEOG Dated anril 9n 1000 Hard Cooy
/ Central Files PUBLIC RGEB R/F
.OGC
.ACRS SMagruder EMail GHolahan TCollins JWermiel JHannon EWeiss MShuaibi JStaudenmeier -
RCaruso GHubbard .
DShum
- I VOrdaz SMagruder CCarpenter TBergman J
r t
l l -
)
NRC/CEOG MODE 6 DHR MEETING ATTENDEES September 2,1998 NAME ORGANIZATION John Osbome BGE Bill Dove ABB-CE Paul Hijeck ABB-CE Barry Lubin ABB-CE Eric Weiss NRC/NRR -
Mohammed Shuaibi NRC/NRR Warren Lyon NRC/NRR Joseph Staudenmeier NRC/NRR David Shum . NRC/NRR Vonna Ordaz NRC/NRR Stu Magruder NRC/NRR Attachment 1
2 t
n e
E I n h m
c E
N.
d'd V
I l
a t
t A
a Sk T v o
A I
mg T en EN I Rl i e
~
N I
t au ef E HeR
'. G y/
a6 A c e ed i
?>
T Do U
O eM v
i t
G a b'
n O r e
E t p u
C l A G o
r s
r e
n w
O g
n n
e e
i n
g n
E n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
6 E
D O
M_
N__
I r
e L m s
u n
A_ o t a -
Vm i t
c l
a v
r e
O , i t
r o p M s e m e T m
e E ;_ s R RRt l n a
T & a oo l A_
E m_ t s e uH P r s P
G _
I t a e o nO I _ S i t
vf s i oE s C Y t n ainyl s u e p A e r l u _
c r o r
r e a nt u G
C r ul t no u s
r e
n E
w O
CAACF g
) n n
e e
mmmmm 1 m g .
n E
n i
o t
s u
b -
m o
C
- d e
v o
r p n t o
i m y s i
t e
_ - i g i
a l
i b
n v i a
o x h e c m l e
e r
f d
Cl b S e s Ri E
t a
e s
a e
n o
Nsos V h r c
i t E p I
T y
a n a c Hd n c
e i
y i
f T a s C
i c
K d
r b
e e
p Omn ai o T rt i
o mtnS J
B Mfs i e a No l
ga c
An e mc t
ri f n O O- Rio gpi I
pi c
Gtp t ai u hc T ne op y uq Ood fe t o e T As e t lS m Re s a s e g n d T ena c P a s ai e c e N min
- et Gr c na ri c v i
s v
E mh p
u e r e S oec G o
r m
Onl pDs e R. E C s
r e
- E I
+ + PR+T O n
w
- C+ i g
n r
e e
n m a ig
_ E i
t n
n o
s u
b
_ m o
~ C
o T s ,F nedF os oS
~ i t ah c aBt e m i~ c n o r- oMrF i
e f l
pi n pate t
/o e-Gy O
f Aci aT n o /f t r t o
r pic eet l en e l
s P c pA m a _ hs nS o e o l f v G,
i l
b CaOo c nncieM al s gi _
G. t i s a Et e i
t hoe l O i s chu e
yD ExTCF E l C- l a /e hg g n _
ns cl ip eii n i da baolwdu p
l ni c G u
o r
hn c ot l c s
r u
e ir r sl n O w
TP BEAI g n
n e
e n
a m ig E
n n
i o _
t .
s u
b _
m _
o C _
d e
o t
ht a e e d p o o M c mc o s y t e
i f ck t a i_
c c r i
c n e Ao a p
r e
Sp__ e s
oW Tc i t ayl yC it A t
t _ Udr e i
vr va n g_ o e n a e m gC o lag P y T deCnf e
neGf ao Ft r
g i oNntoht s eO c uf i
e l
s ag
_ i c B d e
uxO OE n e
og y e /o ta /o D as a t ent B G_ i c
MBInHI n a
.y f s G i c
s s e r eh C e dd t t s O_
E oa pMoRt aha t n
C S L O P a p t t nnt w/wl o F oP G
u o
r a aela s
r Fl l e
m FSF s
l l l O P PH - - - A i g
n r
e e
mm m i E
n g
n n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C _
- t f
B e
r r o
e os g 3
2 o FCe
> T erL S c o t U. g, de iF o n r o v T- i l
i u N re ]e H e q S me A_
T u e n mrTah f
e R i a of f S_
C. R n T
r F
r e I
, i a mO R.
E 6
d e T r g n
di t ty e
vr i uin i
_ o g l o oc N n o E Ml i o C o mhi e V R8r G _ l a o n e Tg v C w eeh o n o BpT N-E. m w dt t nr n e o n auI R R d *g h eu Cohn s R_ t t a unS e ht i dr e m n ia [1 ito _
U= -
C HS ar ni u r oa r p u
o TTe r
y ee o q G s
r a npeec i s pl t O
u w
c OOSR e hUA T
a.
gi rm D m m
- ig E
n n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
r
) o e to _
F d
t S mNs a
r ,I _
n / s 1 F nyt o 'n n eri c o
( I r mceva S d o e inC To U__
T i
rB ud rCe h u
qn o nT A
T S
eA Rl a s
ho 1
in t
u he v TOl i C
I m
I o
]M m UCDW BLnl ,
R Pe eo a E
G Rsn hr oov Nm 0 t
ar T Bm E 0 e ec d ye
. 0Hn AnBR G_,_
T 3
[ yo wcaC we nta e
N oeno o v iHd E .
. l FDi t l F r e p R D yd u o
C eca o r
G R Chu s r
e t l Doi Dr eo O n
w U SBD SADl F i g
n r
C e
e n
m m ig E
n n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
d e e c t
n nu ed e vol m E r a u t Pr c al t u
eo hl i a e TWNr l
ahD rT o W_.Nl A O
L F _
t u o d aT n wt oaO he SHMh f
C T
e C ,; i a
Ve vr ed s e s
s yP naGh oc g D
S _ I sVe s i t e aD0 o ]0 u ah eb uf 0 r l
T 3 l
U v TO lc O [3 h T o ;
as n O
I m_ m mty ois Ct nho aw e r vt a nleuTl I
T _ RF o F I _ t a nCl e io gP a
ipmr c
e n W_ Htci nrtnyi nAoo Mt i
a yele aPs l p
u av c nfuMts dc ehu c G
s o
r eoet r our r e
n w
DCRAFMMi i C
O L
g i
a m a h E
g n
n o
it s
u b
n a
C
ll i
]
[4 gs
)
t uia ny d
' oliD t b o n-o As B ][2 et C
(
I r
gu ao et b W-O-
t a
WO uA s L ynI F
C wir t voe at Ay v
D _ Cno I c S . ekn T heU Te e U _
o Wr l _
i O o H _- BoAo1C t T
I T s T p u
o er e G r
W i mumo i O s
r e
n w
THT h g
i s
i r
m i E
g n
n i
o t
s u
b m
o C
e ord h l a Tad T c y f i n at gn s,s O nheeit c n nat c S n n o gweDml n oTe e onl o ai t v vCI s Pa i
lotd s io ye r E
V ouAtaMF Chl e nl S Ft und ai s I ]
T __ POel Ff S s s t r e e u gS t
aMno t
A_ S VAgsF I g [
u indAC t
e s g T l oio e rdnUpnn ei e i Nzy I
ci od oLt c vd I Pnaouwcterl c e yR p n NeAcL l I a a o
Gg g ut pI yI sf i
t O y, Fi vh eA l a
,l ecee i
c a E t n a Tn t D pH o v e C _ eC f iol p gO S S l o S n gc tampmt e n aT ct i
el i s eiinf R Cmne oeic p u
o r
G Uul f oe ct a t ghcb j s r
e oeope TRCSHNATS oueu O i
n w
g n
i sn m m i E
g n
n i
o t
s u
b m
o C
Y 1 w
m T
I w
y T
U O
W a
V L
w m.. .
% ]O F
P F
A e S
[
Y m..
m.
C i
t n-g
- m s
R m m
N O
I T 1r h Oe C i
r Y
t r
?!
E V
N OA o j-._
T w s
n N
I W
C L
A r,d
( -
C e:
u w
C L
F
]
P R
U T
A A
w F N _
S
- a [
w
- c. I E w R
w .
z -
s p _
u G
o r -
s r
e m
a G .
g n
n e -
e -
m g
n E
n i
o t
s u
b m
o C
e g
y t a
r l e s u o t d
F a O i
e ne i
f ebl l
ode
_ hl t b d tat a s npe
_ ia a
- Wl yv i
a i
yc eh c e e
r c
S l b at a n
T -
I t
f eA i s
s t i arp I F ayc olao o S p vr T E n , op e N nel ai l mp E ,
wgvn o e a u rht D B . oiob ot i
. dt t mt n e e ewe a s uo g hC Rmhs e S l ta t taur tu i
e a
_ nHd da e o c
e de ts t ra Otiy ye rl i nit ye nd p _
aiat a
emtri eb p u
o r
e st e o x G
h d c xt e s
r e
nde hl n w
EAD++
O _
SF g _
n n
e m a E e
m g
n n
i o _
t s
u .
b m _
o C
]
o FF TS -
d[
ef dO e y
_ t
_ Ne P ]M vi a
__ lyG C y
s l
a0 g r0 S e0i n T n1l e[ e S u O ;
Gwf s oe C g nl o F R
_ iem t
a t o
c a r
_. deo i
f i
uF q/
odT M Ag n p t
no wi l G u
o r
al l o s r
e l o O m
s PAC g n
n e
e n
m ig E
n n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
1 I
o n T i
o t w c o e l v F n d o e C c T
P l
t a
r u
F B
r o
y E - a N y C ,
y t
i N B v a
d e
O _
y C w C =
t i o va m l Gw; C
o r
l A
O ,- o F t n
E T l
agC e C vn Dme
_H t a
e ol e
i moSot u
v o
y R C oM p u
o _
a t ] G r _
c e awhl e
t i e u O s
r e
n w
D H [S WF i g
n r
e e
m m mm i E
n g
n n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
)
1 h n
. . c e
- 8. hi r h N -
O I
, 9.W 3 ouW e -
T - Onsh i c -
Co n rv
- e A .
i C -,
Lt a o Se I ,
c e r L f si f o P T f i ic vT o
P P l
e r C Cpo A E-D r Sf t _
LC- S AN elad v c e f s e
T O.
I l ai nu r Os RC Ch c nU
( e c s rd AF. t e u e PO nTe a s b t
ef i
T -
l Pa o Ri c e
N r op E
R G
Oly C Ht '
F Sr D To R
U
- ens Ce r t
OF p u
wad o
r C - e r o G
s r
e e n
nul l os O w
OCANU g
n ir e
e a
n
, m ig E
n n
o it s
u b
,- m o
- C
S N k r
O o
I T W .
n C
I i o e c
n t
R a
a _
T yt r n
e S n e l
C n r t I -
Oe O i n
R sP /
d a
et s n n M Ue A e v
d m l e in a p V
i u o
f i a G r
ct n C s
r e
e n w
po D O SC S i n
e e
n g
r ig m
m E n
n o
i t
, b s
u m
o C
I :
1ll s
n w i o -
l o t a
F t r
) d e d_ n n
' e n A P t_ o. d e
t n y C. e t
(_
Sm i
z g
r m
n i
va e i C N n e- t a n O
I e s n o I
l Tm D nC e
, o s ve Csu ns o p i
t s L Ig g a r e R. i t
u m e c c
t o
T l t
udl A o -
i D gspea F S_
E o e c t
e 3
R. S CigC nl r oid r 2
e e p R rh a t CDs ol v
o G u
r s
o ob r .
e n
l w NCPohaNlACA O
g i
b e -
mm mu a h E
w g
n
=
=
n -
i o
t s
u b _
m o
C -
=
r e
b -
m u
N -
n Y eA es R Bff O- sl i -
T-- aC S
I Ht s r s s e He L clevm o al e
Ams rCb Pt o r
N GAP Oul I
T indt A, oUh os oe u C yit R-E -
el ivlus W
P t f as e O ns r ei m
Cm p
r x
t e cTc s
r e
n w
l uf O ASO i_
g n
r e
e n
m i
g n
E n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
d n e w i n
o t a
dt b u O S
E S
h S
O n
t D
a a
A B;
_g t
c a
t np a
t e
l p c L
m Pn do A I eaC C
I C Lf R f O I N Oes N_
I C ht gU n -
E __
i s i l _
Wn T m_ kar u e o i at c _.
- ut _
hmA ga l p
u l
o u c m G o
r ag n s
r e
e o _
m ie r O s .
DR BF i g
n r
e e
n m m i
g n
E _
n it o _
s b
u _
m o _
C _
t u
o ht i
w g s e
_ nCt a S
i wS Dr s e
E S __
oh o ht i l w i t
i s
e c
n e
r
. S wfy c e A.
B ,
s gi n n v t l of e
f i
oi a vd L i t
l o c wr e A _
a o c
/er l o ut C
I l
ue c r o
c f
n /s a
r o n o e e N-_ r p l
a c o i I
I C6 ta i t
a c
tum a e e e l r t C l po d u i
f i e e E _ c r
t a pt a
T -
i cMi nl al a c t r
s m m e i y yo x t -
r mr i
t P r uCit vi r p u
v p o r
t s otaDa n nS c a p c a G
s r
e n
r O w
i F + + + + + g m
r e
e n
m ig E
n n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
r )
H
/
l a
U M i c
T , P Fa p B
l e G20 My n
s s 0 P (t T
1 o e v
0 1 /
F GFa N .
i l
l r 3
- 4 a 0 7
9 9
A i
e )g 9 7 /
F
. M v ; 1 L 2 (
o i n )g ~ 5 P S_. 1 F r n ui g:
8
- y a c r n s G N_
l 5 e u i e e 1 l r S c o u NI O t a 1 t e e s ot a m u r C re I
T K I, i
x )r o f o r e F p oeb e o F RD p w A: )g r
po si n B f S m e AN g Apet r a (w (e o e b
s mT ot
- l l r u e F r l r le d ut ap F I C af u /o u t
MO_-
I C of L o pC a%mD r oCt e
D S p a
r e
TO w/ t N t e
E B
- e1 eS H0 yuDTa el yt ut Tt t
a a m) l F
ol I
yy t n
p u
o o
r a c t G c oihvt wCiii s
r pv v e n
w eb ai oDy a a O D(aCwl F S (t CC g
n n
e e
n a m am mm i E
g n
n i
o t
s u
b m
o C
e he t r l
e r f t u d e y oar t
ei t l eep D D mo oM S
mvd a a 1F r
I r c om f l S po Me ar mC o r s a n
Y L
m_ d a t
c D d Fi T r o ff t
no ei s e e s s i
A _ pr Cu en c n me ,l F r o i e N..
A uh l t
,o t e
t f ao t ui t ai f
f ei m o
G
- yt da de dl s s yeu rd en cD-po s e aa s n N
I t
el s ptev mc ey a
pO K , nusl uo,c aoc l
, a t t
r a yn Bi R y, l a re nL id xe n Ag o; dd noiy oc s u ne M t d o a s I __ s i
s e nh niy evtai nb a e g lu I l e et imCo c ne C __ d imfod rl e wa r _
idx o odl e eto Vl o s N
- i _
eeMmu med ec l p E r ad fl o r
o nohen G B edd oo oD l s r r T+
wOmTRa +
o CmMPC oF O w
e n
g n
n e
e m
m m m E g
n n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
1I Y
T I
V n
e An c
e n
e i
a C m aL s
_ / me n
e r
s
=u e
R 7 _
g y
_ _ [v v Om m
s
__ T T m i
x v _ -.
C n--
A s
w w e e E
- v
'w v
e l l w I-- o s
v "
R
- r. m "e c _
nm s, .
F -
- e. -
m Oi m
- m a
u v W
O L
F D $s.
F P
S T -
L i.
u u
E s a
D 1 O G p
u o
r M O s
r e
n w
g i
n
^ r e
e n
g n
E n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
O O
W l Q i
- )
1 99 Oo ' ' .":', :
I'T' '???
g ?. il. -
- <v
- r_y5;v3:mn.r?. - ; -~- :~- s.4
~.. ;;_ ,:. g;_;; g jj : f'eM O p h.
g M h G~%;:,n.a+ A g :, a X e;;,'gs%.
. . , ._ "j w ,Cl;. - yn
? t 1[fr
... *~ . - p .
3 l*.
4o' -o =G =
^
G I -
M' = G$
i l C -@
7 D G, I
1
>d :L n ,
>< i sm.
.21,',A .;d ec,. e r *:1.+ m w e <u%wel.ta-
@d
- OStaiW 4thrXxe 4' 0 M42bi.4%.?
->G
. !l di
~i nic- @
- i .
p[~I.Y.bFM.NY.h*befNkhk5k,
~uLwawsonw . aa 9. maw lg
& ' ' n,c..Ewar..-e.h??w, :in.n.. @_
l M
Z l O g O
eo a
5 8
h e
u
/ 8&
4 48&
4 H?R
. 8:
- 83 L 8 E E g
n no h i
. 8" ot
- s. oce e .?O D
c e
Cvc nn a a wof 8*
O Mm r
oCu dl t a S 8*
ur e Im h u SaF hN t er 8 M Te m 8 t
i o m g
WNr
- f o
. ?*
L S1 S 8O 8O m
A VO : 8?
- 8 p )s e
.?"
t a
u in O
I U ma m.m
.m
.w w
f go n ini t m
o r
+g 8S m(
RS em i
T S T c
l
,na oe ov Cn o
- 8*
N A =- t nCe w
ol c d rafa ut ur
. ?"
. 8~
ERi u
- h SNaS 8~
n ooe e a
MEN I Pm M
k NNr- - F 8*
8*
. ?*
DMRE *_.
c.
8*
8*
8*
E N T 8"
.?" p u
o r
8" G O
f-r s
- 8-r e
n 8 w O
g _
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 i n _
3 1 9 7 5 3 1 4 7 5 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 s sr coy:lsiEEeF i g
n -
E n
i t
o s
c b
m o
C
I S
E S 0 0 s 0 0 5 A 8 e1 y3 8
1 1 1
9 9 7 8
4 3
0 4
C .
0 0 L
E
)
_m Z
s e
y0 1 s
0 8 0 5
7 0
1 2
0 1
4 0
6 -
I
.3 e O3 /n0/o 6 y 0 0
8 3
0 9 2
M ,_ es 5 1 1 1 9 5 -
e c
L y0 a f
r A _ 4
/
3
/o n3 0
1 0 3 3 2
9 5 0 u
- 9 9 4 S N _ e e
O I
s_ s e 9 5 0 0 8
9 0
F r -
S m .
2 y0 0 - 1 1 6 -
o r
m N
E .
_y 4 2 7
1 f
n o
o Mm1 1 1 9 i t
n0 0 - 2 2 7 - c e -
I s v
) n 1
t i
n mm p p F F m
p C o
G p
u o
r U gg o o g E -
s d
c l a
r s
r e
n w
e N e s
- C P s
a el po r o o r s o /c t a
u O i
g n
O CDF r
a y c pc n N e
e n
C NS S B TTdQ i i
E g
n n
i o
t s _
u _
b _
m _
o _
C .
, ow N
, oa - N
_ . onoW a +- oemv-E
. +
l
- - : onmv-o M ,oee.e I m:-
l
, ooe *-
,owse-w T m 5 6
/
s "P
"- \
\
- omwe-
,onwg m
e \ - -
S s - - C ,
a D m l"l C -
S ,owvv Vm 5 -
w.
,oaue >-
=
p - ..
. 4
/
b, -
3 , owve-m P s E
. . _ e F s -
,oenv m S . .
C a
R e ,oume-w -_ l r e a
i m
7 e
s l
\ -
,ooae-U T a C -
s C t - - , oomv- )s l a e
_ v lN N - .
T , owev u
~ - t e
r w, u
C C . . , omov - in m
t D . .
P A a . (
t - F r a S .
S, . omoe -
e e
N, o .
m_ .m -
p -
C ' m C w . i R
D -
D ,o8 T
.e '
S 2 - . S ,
o e _.. , oanc 1
T s w E w a _ .
l . .
8 o C _
o 1
e l
e s
+ owe P
x P s a .
. a , oms C
.a.
C .
l
\ , ons Mm m.
- _ , oww -
E a , oow m . _ .
, own T
i _
m a .
. , omv _
n .
a _ , .
, oav _
L m
, . , oen O- .
, _ : oom p u
, onn
,- o r
O , om--
G s
r e
P : oe
, on. -
O n
w g
0 0 0 0 0
O
'o n n
e e
5 0 5 0 5 n 2 2 1 1 ig
- n CS 2Bgh* E n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
d -
t e .
a v g -
e o in F h m li o g t e S n u r o :
i o t b e o ht a < c e n l_
o C. y n i
w h y u e
r e r
e a a P-F-
t io c r e
t f f
i _
de DM
)
vit d e 2S- a a c r l p e P
&d u l a m d r G _
ot e e luut 0 1 n t a c s a h t ea t a sf t c a0 e e r i a, Inr e8 0 t
s aC h hu w l t p - _
CD.
c s e s o o 0 l
l a al o Ne0 m0 -
t eo s r ol i z p nT6 S-u o
el s o pi b
f o io ty:
h-t a o@ a e t i c
Pr t a s a r al o c v w i ht 1 fe 2 f o c F p u
o e s e r p - o W b s ns u a e r
e r
G r
s r
v e
aa r a t s o o O n
w I nCt C a (E CC i g
n r
e e
mm m mm i E
n g
n n
i o
t s
u b
. m o
C
lll l ,
)
yF n a o d 1 ito
/<
h l a
c e u w n c c l
o t oi n i r
1 F. l l
e ~
eC r
el P wf f a F_
S ,. s ee oi f
d t r
u
- o. rt e a 4 a a r N_ pr u (N
&w,g 3 g mntaM oi o r s lo; ct eP eFgg ;r a pG s C tyo m 0 Dipe S v 0
CaC_ D a aTv 5 o c e y ~
S_
l t
t tode tv i w
a a t a o e ar m_
r.
h euc hae s e l
f e
- o. % r o
r o
p u
%mCC o
r 5
N 9 5 G
s r
e m
u mm mm O i
g n
r e
e i
n g
n E
n i
o t
s u
b m
o C
e r
u F a
t a
r 4
e e p l c m o n e o e P t p r e
]_
F S
[
l o
o s
e s
f f
i
. p a D 7h. e r e t F 2 c r
&i. y9 o e s n u 6, W . i t 9 a i t aM 5
C ,x_ vf o C a wF oa eP r
s c e s 3 pG r e l
eDm s S ,1 t o
u u c F0 1
] m0 a t t FoT0 e0
- t. m a ad e Ft -
C u_ e r r e S el o :
6 o_ h e pw [ r uo pw h_
t i ht mo el f
ot a s r ol o
f T] Fa s e W_ f ol P6 ape t f e
l l
o o F yymo p r r o G p
u o
r A P [S b BteCC s r
e m
w mam m mm O g
n n
e e
i n
g n
E n
o i
t s
u b
m o
C
ht i
w w w w s n l o ol o w_ a F l F F ht lo_ r
]
P C n o
F_ , e F S Di tc
] . w [ S Pm o o o e F l t t v n
8 [S _ Fa dd a a o e
sd _
4 o oC an. e r )3 L Ll a Ca t ue t t s a a u r
Cy aa e e t D. rCHHa e
p( e e N S _
ht mChh eDt f ft mp i __l TS y
o o 5
g W on%%4 ol 0 0 7 p
u o
r G
Po4 6 3 s r
e n
m mmm O i
w g
n ._
r e
e i
n g
n E
n i
o t
s u
b m
o C
- ll n
i o d t t
a n r l t s a e v
L u n e r
l a
c e C
E i r i c u t
D C i
f f
a r m o
O l a
r e
o c
e p f r
M u s s m d
e LL t
a a e t i n
p AE_ Ns e r b y f o b t
a N D o
et u d l
s O O d a na ore g e
u s
e u
S M m I
mpn l a
v l
a v
ND l a miei x l a ht nt EF_
MC o id s
m r
o l c
o i
w n
I
__ na nf :
o D e s D l
e s
- _ meFC ds i
r a
E i t oet ps Dra i
N -
s e
s mimfc ol f
i p
u o
r O ewU DoCC G
s r
no+ l n F e O w
Of l Cv+ g i
m r
o m m ig E
n n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
F 1
cc t -
- Y. C
[: *- -~
N
~ U U j
-3 3 4EA 1,
_f -t II1r ii r11 1111 1,1yi
- r 1 ,1 . Tm n' F1 n ri N 11 11
'-11
=$ A
. 17 1* rim A1 in n1 Ig[h
's s'. n n F1 A E A & M'M Y Y Y Y Y I T u 11 1F '
E- ' u mmaarn i / / / / ^
"lix "
.. , < ==_,.
l n1 ? 1 Y Y '. . .' ,'ln':.' .^m I I I I I _1.-',1 1,' 1,I 1,1 1,f 1,,, ,,I 1,, ,,1, , , ,1' s
, 1 I - - u 11 1111111 M, ..a'1mArmIAGWWW
! j j j j j ;I ; ; ; ; ; ;1 u i i i i l'
'!MWWWW 3 ,I ,I ,I ,I ,
1
.I .I .I .I .I Q ~n. ,
h Rip 3l
_} . I i i i i i iiiiiMN1' +
h_1M n I I I { I s s ss s - ,- , __-
', , 4Nfy]
i I I I I E E E m = = = n ,n n dNW
}l I I I I I I I II . ._ 'l "
k f l l l ,' l " T~i~,' ;{ w& _,h+ CRY y l l l l l 'Hi ,i
, , 1 , - - - - , ,Eu-----
u, u
u Q wi 3.; : '. l l l l H .= n. .'
I g i I I n 1 m 1 1 - -
$1 y; I I I I I I-8 555 5 v~~ - o - '
g g ; ; j _ . . . . E N,y,' i a G: y/, I I I I I l' ~ ~ u u m usnne
- q
- < y ; ; j g .1 s 1 m m av s m.a.
i l I i 1 - -e--e
--l
- - m- e- m.m. nma'u n -
- rw 1 n -
q? g I I I I I E z n m 1 msnimm - m I
h I II I I ," " ," , " , ~ ~ ~ ' _: >
Mi ;
I i I I I1 I III 1 ~.:--, '
[ l i I IE II I I I I _,
^
Wi i i iI I II E I I I E I s - -
l 1
I I I I i ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! -- - ' - ~
iM(( $
Y
?; " II II I!!"!!! !". .
nI i i I m," '
M
(-ly W1 ' ,", " " : " .' '_'. tl1=_!
". A JtN P PiV711
'__"n.m f
t, 1
11 =,, u1 s_n . . . .. .m _ , =x 1 . 1,u p aw -
l 3
h;
- L t" 'd 'd 'd 'd 'd '1 ' " ? m
- g ; '1 .u. r n r1 n ,^1 m r1 nr1 - 1 im
@; 's 111111' - 11 l' W P% s sg sg g 's -g ',; '; g ',, ij 'g '; ; '; g f X w !
r-m 0
X L V u.1 -a w !!
U f 3 i I' _
! h
?
- n F O co l
u :
%c l
4 W l 8 l o
.o E
O U
1 1
!. 8 7 .
9 44 nc
~
eE ~
~
9 1
6 n n t
I t
nV 1 e
u e u a "R -
l u l FF l
N J -
l 4' pW i b
l% l a&R M icM tM EE l rSK e e& R d vE
-M '
o s{:
ej
[
s 2
M 0
- r. E
+
u 3
1 t E; 5 5 D ai f_
l y
5
=
F rfUK j
5 i
n m
C eW pAJ m )
L 2
0
+
A W RE 2 ( 6 mSE t e0 r
u 57 a
eMi 2 L pe x r =
T% ^
E U e FTL mam d
i 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 p u
0+ 0+ 0+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0+ 0 0 +0 +0 +0 +0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 x o u E E+ E E+ EEEEE+ E+ E+E+ E+ E+ E+ E+ E+E +E + + +
+
E E E E+ E+ E++ EE + 4 E E+ EE r I
7 0 9 9 8 7 7 6 5 5 4 4 3 2 2 i 0 0 9 8 8 7 6 6 5 5 4 3 3 2 7 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 1
G 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 z s l g}*
r e
F n
g
I w O
g i
n r
e e
n ig n
E n
o i
t s
u b
m o
C
O e ..
8 7 n..
c 9
9 4 n 4 I a ,.
1 t t 6 n n 1
e u e u l ., l ul l
- p. J FF .
l, a .,
t -
n o .,.
z.
i .,.
- N 4'
o l .
e or .+. .;
g.,.
d h gm .
w o .m D*
s ;gs 2
M er , e:
,2 2
0 E
2 5
4
+
D ,.
u.sm.%.
2 5
=
Ft as.--y -.
i n
m C er ,. L m
. 2 0
+
~ )
ps
,. RE s ( 0 e2 r
u 7 ms_ss a 5
, t 2 r =
L p ex e ~, .
~
. E U e mam T
FTL p
d 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 u 0+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + o r
E E+ EEEEEEE EE E E+EEEEEE EE iEE 0 E9 E8 E7E+ E 65
. E+ E+ E+ G i .
. 2 t 0 9 8 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 I 7 7 7 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 5 5 5 5 5 0 9 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 t 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 4 4 4 4 4 z s u
5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 r
. e
? 3 j n
O w
l .
g F. i n
r e
e i
n _
g _
n E _
n _
i o _
t s
u b
m o
C
s e .
r t
u a
r e l e
p v m= l e F 0
F a
e- -
5 6 d 1 l
eT- i m
1 0
1 dd oe l o
Mrsu P o
D a.
Fe e CM g n
- s. a F F v l F
a 8
a 4
d=
t e r o
1 1
1 1
t c c i-d, a e p u
e R G o
r r s P-r e
s s n e a d O w
= s e e g n
a r ir e
=
C MP ig E
e n
n n
o
, i t
s u
b m
o C
8 7 . -
7 9 44 I nc 9
1
-- t t r 6 n n
=3 1
l e e u u l
ul m
e J FF p
s y
g g ,
ngg , '
ogg ig ,
5 * -
g .
t g
g.
l ugg.i g
f e b g-g .
g.
g - l' d ri g3i g.. .
o ts3 g~ .
- y. -
l 3-g7 ' $ _
j g.
f -
i ggdy M
, 3 j; u i
0-D g_
g..
ji.7 g =. _
} ~ '
ll - '
E I
0 D y g-g .-;
g hl S.
.' [~!'
~
([
9 4
=
F t g. g 1
g
- -, n g ! i g * " ) m Cigcg g g
g p
E' S
/
F t
E oqm f
(
sr oE4 1
0-lw t c
e 3 e& a s
w V 88 y
2 i t =
L c x Ve n.<.
E o a U e m FVL l
m; _
~ p 1 1 1 1 1 n 1 1 1 1 1 I l 1 2 2 2 3 u 400 0 0 OEEE 40EE 0 0EE440 EE 44401 EE EE E0E- 0 40E E0 E01 E 0 E0 0 0 40 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 -
- s. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - x o -
". EE EEEEE EEE r e
3 3 3 2 2 2 2 i 8 5 2 9 6 30 7 4 t l 0 0 0 0 9 9 9 8 8 8 8 7 7 7 6 6 81 5 2 0 8 5 2 9 5 2 9 6 30 7 4 G
y l.
8 8 8 7 7 7 7 6 66 5 5 5 4 4 4 3 3 3 3 2 2 2 8 151 29 56 3545 9 1 s r
y e
~. n
- n. -
g ' - w
~-
O g
n n
e e
i n
g n
E n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C
_ h t
- r e
_ n e i g Co -
l a v e D Sl C
_ r E W e l
u g t s o u
_N t a na l e i a TF _
vW i
l R e a -
s i o o v n _
t .
t Bms l i l
o l t i u e v a s i
s N W na e s o R )s w
t b r
e]
YLR M t
e l e a l t P l
g a Be 0 P AFS Rn Ali R l l
e n H (1 e
G 0 F l e[
o w o c a F b Mo o l o Wir s a o t
00 81 S a
i aT F 1 Vg u F
~ ~
MC t y i nl a c c )s @bb yy ai n
o Ue t i vde r mimlb i
ge e I sG S a at eC nruu r gs CiR a0 i l
nI m m d n0 y1 oa t t a i or d oi o e r l l e d1 oa l
t TL or c o( Cpp e e o o e n P o r s e mmCL A r o gF oi d e yl i ve e t t et Ct a nt d t t a p
=, e u el i
l uHn u o
aelr o n
a ed n G u
o r
gc r f uht l
l aB r o e c o
p rHa el l o O s
r e
n w
r t l f g ai ei mf t uf n LCRWSOA++AFOii l l r e
e n
g n
E m a a m m i t
n o
s u
b
_ C m
o
r N i o
r e W e pc i O t a d v -
D r er r e -
o i s T _ e r p u qm U . l o eo H S ,., uc r n r r S N,, e f _
Og ni b t -
I I
T, I ww o o we n
T dt n om npi I
A l ul i W Lw= hs w l
l i
u q
N Ug7 Gg e e we s t y O
I E.
t a
l r ue r ue n n a e s a T R-C -
s u
p c s e i mg s n s n A t a anseiv R t S
e r e ot nwso s o p E
u T
t n mind t am ke r G
o r
s r
e N e r o aus O n
w I r NMhiRt s o i g
n r
u e e
n mm i
C a g
n E
n i
o t
s u
b m
o C
l
)
e e m
_ a l
u g s R n s e
i f h N
l n o s O i o c o i l
p W s u l
t n o V o v R m
o O
D _
i s e fo r
e kiis n c
c a
T V d U - t s
r mt u e a
r d e
e e
HS S N~
P a
i mgn l i
n a
r n
s a
n i ni s t s
I I
O. O may r a
e m
I. d be l
TT ms l i i e n t I s to o i w y o
A>. B a e r
s a l a
c W I d
d e
g i
u q
h t
f e
g r
d e
wa i
d h N U- t e
l e
a wsFrt e .
n l
t i
w O G.
p o T i a d ,d C i 3 r e yd o I I c k nS 2 t h t iah T R c Rt a t s i
t i v ot e
n a dn e ha l a l C
f b c fo m A y ab l t a n et e A
t d g s i t a S ar n e r a c e Te p wo n R
i a r c l l
o c r p l a t a e l e no E
l l e/
l p wfd l ul t p m e r g e s u
o T -
I v e r n ui t r
e i
C e
c r na f a t s G
r s
r N
l l e a t c a r o e n
- . / w ht r a NF r tc O I m F op e e r e uf f g
n BOW ++Ce i ir 3
i n 2 ig e
e n
Mam n
m a E
n o
i t
s u
b m
o C
1 ,
{
s a
t o c s s
g i r n eC n e o uR s
i d
s ni net a m
i s N r a o gl o g i t e u
__ c l
a t e ahg i
t la r .
r ict e
r S_
n oci s C f r en hc pns t R
i c
N_
m e eheN r c u ehw pi t o
A. t l ateqh s ed Lx d c e r
t s
. l a nt u P eic i c o i
f pfi e wni hs G_ i t toigeio c n nde n c e ut a hsc a w Oe eipa gl e sh c louteb Ey y d r n i e gc e e ye nt a C_ n glaodrnnieib h f i
ot r at e.
= a apt i e nc et s t t a uwps s iri c oi r e no s el p ga o r mof pic id t t c r p
u o
r d u upohl uaapnnip G
d b pe nt s r
e n
AS s s Cs P ct a hop O w
g i
e mm m m i E
rm g
n n
i o
t s
u b
m o
C _
9 5 :
- I CE OWNERS GROUP Project No. 692 cc: Mr. Gordon C. Bischoff CEOG Project Manager ABB Combustion Engineering M.S. 9615-1932 2000 Day Hill Road Windsor, CT 06095 Mr. Ralph Phelps, Chairman CE Owners Group Omaha Public Power District P.O. Box 399 Ft. Calhoun, NE 68023-0399 Mr. Ian C. Rickard, Director Nuclear Licensing ABB-Combustion Engineering, Inc.
Post Office Box 500 2000 Day Hill Road Windsor, CT 06095 Mr. Charles B. Brinkman, Manager Washington Operations ABB-Combustion Engineering, Inc.
12300 Twinbrook Parkway, Suite 330 Rockville, MD 20852
. .