ML20203A795

Rev 10 to Callaway Cycle 9 Colr

ML20203A795
Person / Time
Site:	Callaway
Issue date:	02/09/1998
From:	Johansen B, Rios L, Secker J UNION ELECTRIC CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML20203A784	List: ML20203A795 ULNRC-03735, Forwards Rev 10 to Callaway Cycle 9 COLR, Providing Updated Modified Rod Insertion Limits for Cycle 9.Rept Submitted Per TS 6.9.1.9
References
NUDOCS 9802240115
Download: ML20203A795 (27)

Text

. .. . . - . _ _ - _ . . . - _ - . _ - . - . _ - - - - .

Callaway Cycle 9 .

1 . .

I l

CALLAWAY CYCLE 9 CORE OPERATING LDtITS REPORT

~

February 9,1998 UE NUCLEAR ENGINEERING REVIEW & APPROVAL.

Review We Date: _2 /,/fB

/ Engr.Reacpr Engineering ApprovedBr. dMA Date E!Ikf6 Su;u. Engr. Reac'or Engineering 4

4 9802240115 980218 ,

4 POR ADOCK 05000463 P PDR

.I '

4

i Westinghouw Propnetuy Clus 2C CAC 98-033 Callaway Cycle 9 COLR, Revision 10

.The COLR has been revised to provide new rod insertion limits for Cycle 9 operation. The new rod insertion limits will provide for operational flexibility. The W(z) data remain urchanged from Revision 9 of the COLR, but are transmitted again for completeness. .

Please fonvard any questions to the undersigned.

L. R. Rios (ND) '

l Core Anal si C l Date: 94  ;

Verified: dl h J. R. Secker (ND)

Core Analysis C Date: g[q/y Approved: JW-- r B. 5. Johansen, Manager Core Analysis C Date: g.q,qg I of 27 t I

.,' l Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 1.0 CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT ,

This Core Operating Limiti Report (COLR) for Callawt / Plant Cycle 9 has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of Technical Specification 6.9.1.9.

The Core Operating Limits affecting the following Technical Specifications are included in

' this report.

3.1.1.3 Moderator Temperature Coefficient 3.1.3.5 Shutdown Rod Insertion I.imits 3.1.3.6 Control Rod Insertion Limits

~

3.2.1 Axial Flux Difference 3.2.2 Heat Flux Hot Channel Factor 3.2.3 Nuclear Enthalpy Rise Hot Channel Factor 3.9.1 Refueling Boron Concentration 3

i

__U

Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 i .

2.0 OPERATING 1.lM1TS The cycle-specific parameter limits for the specifications listed in Section 1.0 are presented in the subsections which follow. These limits have been developed using the NRC approved -

~

.nethodologies specified in Technical Specification 6.9.1.9.

2.1 Moderator Temperature Coefficient (Specification 3.1.1.3) 2,1.1 The Moderator Temperature Coefficient shall be less positive than the limits shown in Figure 1. These limits shall be referred to as the Beginning of Cycle Life (BOL) Limit.

The Moderator Temperature Coefficient shall be less negative than -47.9 pcm/*F.

This limit shall be referred to as the End of Cycle Life (EOL) Limit.

2.1.2 The MTC 300 ppm surveillance limit is -40.4 pcm/*F (all rods withdrawn, Rated Thermal Power condition).

4

Callsv,ay Cycle 9 Rev.10

- 6 l UNACCEPTABLE OPERATIOil o

N 5

s (70%, 5.0)

D5 E -

\

U \

C .

\

$ \

8 4 ca i \

j t i

\,

t '

@3 e I \

)'

$ l ACCEPTABLE OPERATION e . .

\

$ \

E \

@2 \ l

) I

\

i \

l l I \

^

I i \

11 I\

I i \

0 l I I  ! l l l l Ib 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 PERCENT OF RATED THERMAL POWER Figure 1 Callaway Cycle 9 Moderator Temperature Coefficient Versus Power Level 5

/_ ,

Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 2.2 Shutdown Rod Insenion Limits (Specification 3.1.3.5)

The shutdown rods shall be withdrawn to at least 225 step 5.

2.3 Control Rod Insenion Limits (Specification 3.1.3.6)

The Control Bank Insenion Limits are specified by Figure 2.

e 6

Callaway Cycle 9 Rev,10 225 ~~'-

iii 1Iii! ( / i!I ' i 4 ii iii (35.76,225)l / (100,217.78)f3

/ I j/

/ /t 200 -' '

/ /

/ / \

,,4 BANK C .l ,e -

7

/

~

= / /

y 175 , ,

@ z /

'(l0, 165)l o /

5 / -

5 150 '

j m

/

w

/ BANK D j 125 '

/

o s E /

H 1

' m -/

@ 100 /

M li! ,

/

m o 75

/ i M

/

/

/

/

50 l

-'(0, 50)I 25 j i

0 ' '

l 'i

! I l' O 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 PERCENT OF RATED THERMAL POWER Figure 2 Callaway Cycle 9 Rod Bank Insertion Limits Versus Rated Thermal Power - Four Loop Operation 7

a .

Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 2.4 Axial Flux Difference (Specification 3.2.1) 2.4.1 The Axial Flux Difference (AFD) Limits are provided in Figure 3.

2.4.2 he target band during Restricted AFD Operation is 13%. The AFD limits I provided in Figure 3 also remain applicable during Restricted AFD Operation. '-

j 2.4.3 The minimum allowable power level for Restricted AFD Operation, APL'*. is 90% of RATED THERMAL POWER.

e S

. _. .. _ . . _ _ . .___ _ __ _ --_-- - _ -. _ . ___ _ .. - _ _ --.m.. ~ _ - - .

g 4 j Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 i

i

+ e l

120 '

i i 110 , j ,

i i ,

(-17, 100%) L ___ (+6, 100%)

f- .

l 100 l, ' ' ' '

s l \

e N

UNACCEPTABLE i \' UNACCEPTABLE p o

90 ::

OPERATION J

> i i

OPERATION  ::

A i iI '

t il ( ,

\

. 4 80 #

• 4 g / ACCEPTABLE \

l m / OPERATION \

j $ 70 [ \

i o

m i

/ h' x

! E-e g - 60 J 7 \

\

. g I 'n o I

\

- 50 E4 2 -

$ ---i (-30, 50%) i (+26, 50%) F-- -

y 40 m

4 4 . 30 y

a 20 ,

4 10 ,

t I O i 6 i e i

-50 -40 -30 -20 10 0 10 20 30 40 50 AXIAL FLUX DIFFERENCE (% A1)

• Figure 3 Callaway Cycle 9 Axlal Flux Difference Limits as a Function of Rated Thermal Power for RAOC 9

Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 2.5 Heat Flux Hot Channel Factor . Fn(Z)

(Specification 3.2.2)

- F oRTP Fo(Z)5

• K(Z) for P > 0.5 P

p air F(Z)5 n

• K(Z) for P $ 0.5 0.5 THERMAL POWER where: P=

RATED THERMAL POWER 2.5.1 Fn"" = 2.50 2.5.2 K(Z) is provided in Figure 4, 2.5.3 The W(z) functions that are to be used in Technical Specifications 4.2.2.2,4.2.2.3, and 4.2.2.4 for Fnsurveillance are shown in Figures 5 through 17.

The Normal Operation W(z) values have been determined for several bumups up to 18000 MWD /MTU in Cycle 9. This permits determination of W(z) at any cycle bumup up to 18000 hBVD/MTU through the use of three point interpolation. For cycle bumups greater than 18000 MWD /MTU, use of 18000 MWD /MTU W(z) '

values without interpolation or extrapolation is conservative. The W(z),, values were determined assuming Cycle 9 operates with RAOC strategy. Also included is a W(z),, function that bounds the W(z),o Curve for all Cycle 9 bumups. Use of the bounding W(z),, curve will be conservative for any Cycle 9 bumup; however, additional margin may be gained by using the burnup dependent W(z),,

values.

The Normal Operation W(z) values have also been determined for a range of measured axial offset values for Cycle 9. For measured axial offset values within 3% of the predicted axial offset value, Figures 5 through 9 are applicable.

Additional W(z) values are provided in Figures 10 through 13 applicable to measured axial offsets wiihin 3% of a measured-predicted axial offset difference of 10.3%. Figures 14 through 17 provide W(z) values applicable to measured axial offsets within 3% of a measured-predicted axial offset difference of

- 14.0%.

For purposes of bumup interpolation, a consistent set of W(z) values should be used based on the difference between the measured and predicted axial offset.

The W(z) set selected could be either the set c!csest to the actual measured-predicted axial offset difference or a consistent set derived by linear interpolation on the measured - predicted axial offset difference between two of the W(z) sets closest to the actual measured-predicted axial offset difference.

10

. [

Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 Because significant margin exists between the analytically determined maximum Fo(z)*P,,, values and their limit, Restricted Axial Flux Diff:rence Operation (RAFDO) is not expected to be required for Cycle 9. For this reason, no W(z)uroo values are supplied for Cycle 9.

The W(z) values aie provided for 73 axial points within the core height s boundaries of 0 and 12 feet at intervals of.167 feet.

Table A.1 shows the burnup dependent qF penalty factors for Cycle 9. These values shall be used to increase Fo"(z) when required by Technical Specification

. Surveillance Requirement 4.2.2.2.c. A 2% penalty factor should be used at all cycle burnups that are outside the range of Table A.l.

w w

11

. _ _ . . . _ . _. _ _. _ _. _ _ _ _ ._ _ _ _ .....__ ___ . _ _.-__..._ . _ ___. _ _ _ ~ . - ....._.. _ .

Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 TABLE n.1 FnPENALTY FACTORS AS A FUNCTION OF CYCLE BURNUP Cycle Burnup (MWD /MTU) Fo"(z) Penalty Factor (%)

494 2.29 '

666 2.54 838 3. ' .

1010 3.56 1182 3.19 1354 2.92 1526 2.70 1697 2.51 1869 2.29 2041 2.06 3761 2.15 3933 2.63 4105 3.07 4277 1.48 4449 3.88 4620 4.23 4792 4.41 4964 4.30 5136 4.08 5308 3.77 5480 3.40 5652 2.99 5824 2.52 5996 2.09 Note: All cycle turnups outside the raag: of the above table shall use a 2% penalty factor for complimee with the 4.2.2 2.c Suiveillance Requirement. Linear interpolation should be used for in ermediate cycle br nups.

12

Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 t

2.6 Nuclear Enthalov Rise Hot Channel Factor F,w" (Specification 3.2.3)

F,u" 5 F3 n""[l + PF,w(1.P))

TIERMAL POWER ,,

where: P =

RATED TIERMAL POWER 2.6.1 F,u"' = 1.59 2.6.2 PF 3 = 0.3 2.7 Refu;I:nc Doron Concentt: tion (Specification 3.9.1) 2.7.1 The refueling boron concentration to maintain K,y s 0.95 shall be ,>. 2000 ppm.

= _

13

Callaway Cycle 9 Ret 10 1.20 i i ,

1.10  !

(6, 1.00) [-'

1.00 ,

i Ld{ ~ ,_

, ~

0.90 I tili (12, .924) [

U

- 0.80 - ~

?

o  :

N 0.70 3

8 o 0 .60 Z ._.

g 0.50 i

M i 0.40 _ __.

0.30 0.20 -

0.10 0.00 i  !

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 1:. 12 CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

Figure 4 Callaway Cycle 9 K(z)- Normalized Fo(z)

As a Function of Core Height 14

• Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 ht1CNT 1.60 II 150.

l littti e 0.000 will

__... 1.0000

• 6.161 1.0000

• 9.333 1.0000

• 0.800 1.0000

--- e

• 9.441 1.0000

---

• 0.033 1.0000

• 1.000 1.0000

• 1.161 1.0000

• 1. H1 00000 i 1.50

• 1.$00 1.0000

,

• l'"' "

~~~~ 1. 0 H ' .' "H 2 4 1

3.000 1 3913

-- - , 3.147 1.3690 8

i "

3.333 1.34H

. . ..i - -3.500 1.2310 3.461 1.3093 3.8H 1.1910 3.000 1.1903 I

l 3.167 1.1043 1.40 -- 3.3H 1.ttt!

3.500 - 1.1695

. 3.461 1.1636 3.033 1.1414 4.000 1.1608 4.16? 1.1580 4.333 1.1509 4.800 1.1461 4.661 1.1407 m 4.033 1. H 40 a

t4 , 8.000 1.1301

- 1.3C  :-

6.161 1.H13 lE bg -

8.3H 1.1 H1 l.800 1.1043 l A S.661 1.1003 S.033 1.1054 6 6.000 1.1130 6

( 6.167 1.1191 i,

• 333

. 1.1360 i6 6.500 1.1339 6.661 1.1404 A 4 1.2C 4.033 1.1473 a 1.000 t .16 H a

i,6 1.167 1.1579 3 1. 3 H 1.1610

, 4 7.600 1.1644

'A _a MAA"

'8 6 "

7.667 1.1460 6',

' ,6 i '

7. 8 H 1.1664

,,-6 0.000 1.1640 n' O.141 1 1834 i .6 4.H3 1.4435

'-g '

'i 9.500 1.1631 1.1C ' '

i l 1 8.667 1.1800

.0H 1.1 H S t,000 1.1530 9.167 1.1611 9.3H 1.1733 9.500 1.183$

9,461 1.1935 9.0H 1.2093 10.000 1.3386 10.167 1.1409

• 10.333 *.0000 1.00 .- --

0" - - '1 - 2 ...._-- . . . . "o t *'n 5 ", * * "o "g 3 4 5 6, 7 8 9 10 11. . . . . .12 3',o

. a. H lun BOTTOM TOP CORE HEIGHT (FEET) .II:$$3 l'.illl

• 11.500 1.0000

• H.661 1.0000

• 11. 9 H 1.0000 {

• 13.000 1.0000 Figure 5 Callaway Cvele 9 W(z)no at 150 MWD /MTU

• Top and bottom 15% excluded as per Tech Spec 4.2.2.2G

.15 n . .

. Callawmy Cycle 9 Rev.10 kt!GMT 3000.

g (fttt) wit)

~~~~~~'

• 0.000 1.0000

• 9.167 1.0000

• 0.333 1.0000

• 0.500 1.0000

• 8.667 1.0000

• 0.033 1.0000 1.000 1.0000

• 1.147 1.0000 1

• 1.333 1.0000 I

• **S 8-1*SC

• 1.467

- 1.0 "000 l

1.833 1.4004 I 3.000 1.3716 i 2.147 1.3504  ;

3.333 1.3363 3.$00 1.3990 3.647 - -1.3785 '

3.033 1.3$36 t

- 3.000 1.3470 3.167 1.3309 le4C -

3.333 1.3304 3.500 -1.3306 .

3.667 1.3153 3.033 1.3107 4.000 1.2014 4.147 1.1996 A 4.333 1.1930 4.500 1.1017 a 4.667 1.1777

,== 4.833 1.1693 64 1.000 1.1990

==* 1.3C i $.167 1.1501

• DE 5.333 1.1399 5.500 1.1378 a 5.647 1.1301 5.833 1.1311 ,

a 6.000 1.1381 4,

6.147 1.1304 u 6.333 1,1347 a 0 4.500 1.1381

..0 4 4.647 1.1413

,, 4.833 1.1448 1*,b' 7.000 1.1483 a a 1.147 1.1509 n

7.333 1.1634 >

L o a 1.500 1.1639 ,

a 7.667 1.1615 a ],,aana4<'00"Adi? .'33 8 000 I*I4'?

1.1491 ia g ,- 4.167 1.1536 o A 0.333 1.1534 01 4.500 1.1548 8.667 1.1549 1*1C 9.033 1.1533 9.000 -1.1533

.9.167 1.1570 9.333 1.1657 9.500 1.1734 9.667 1.1900 3 9.833 1.1900 10.000 1.2007 10.167 1.3308

• 10.333 1.0000 1

• O C ._ u . ;;

m . :.

I-

. .. n . ; m . *l.'",

10 64 1"

1.0000

. 0- 1 2 3 4 -5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 + 10.833 1,00ot

• 11.000 1*0000 ElC)1???Ctbi CDC)P

• 11.16, 1.0000 CORE 11EIGHT (FEET)

• 11.333 1.0000

• 11.500 1.0000

• 11.407 1.0000

• 11.033 1.0000

• 13.000 1.0000 F:Igure 6 Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 3000 MWD /MTU

• Top and bottom 15% excluded as per Tech Spec 4.2.2.2G 16

. Callaway Cycle 9 Res.10

. 1,6C Mtt$NT 10000.

4 Mit71 utti

• 0.000 1.0000

• 0.147 1.0000

^

• 0.J33 1.0000 i '

• 0.100 1.0000

• 6.467 1.0000 l

• 0.033 1.0000 j

• 1.000 1.0000

• 1.167 1.0000  !

• 1.333 1.0004 J 1.5C * '" 2'"" '

~ * 667 1 1.0000

,,__, 1.033 1.354) 2.000 1.3404

! 2.167 1.3143 2.333 1.3076 I 2.$00 1.2907 2.667 1.2734 1 2.033 1.2867

~ 3.000 1.2438 3.167 i.2342

!, g,4g 3.333 +

1.2321 t

3.800 1.2299 i 3.667 1.2360 3.033 1.2219 4.000 1.217I A 4.167 1.2141 4.333 1.2109 4 600 1.2061 4.467 1.2018

^ 4.033 1.1963 S.000 1.1994 U 1.3C "' 12H8 g n . 23 3

$ 1.1774 4

5.500 1.1701 a 1.667 1.1463 A g,g33 5

g,3999 a

6.000 1.1760 6.167 1.1825 OO 6.333 1.1971 d

ig^ 6

6.500 1.1937

,,0 6.667 1.1 72 4 A

'* ^^' 6.833 1.2006 1,2( a [ , 7.H0 1.2031 A

Ah 6 a 7.167 7.333 1.2041 1.2037 g a a A " 7.500 1.2017 A A 7.667 1.1984 7.033 1.1936 0.000 1.1964 0.167 1.1794 8.333 1.1752 J 9.500 1.1701 7 6.647 1.1643 1.1C 8.833 1.18'5 9.000 1 1621 9.167 1.1646 h 9.333 4.1720 9.800 1.1990 9.661 1.3115 9.033 1.2314 10.000 1.2501 10.167 1.2601

• 10.333 1.0000

< 1.0C.,_. , _.-.. . . .

• 18 58' 2 8"o',

. So,ss? 1.og 0 1 . . 2, 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11. . .-.12 10. u s 1.0000 1

BOTTOM TOP *. u:u3

.  !!'"l 1'l$$

CORE HEIGHT (FEET) 1:e000

• 11.300 1.0000

• 11.667 1.0000

• 11.833 1J000

• 12.000 1.0000 i

Figure 7 4

Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 10000 MWD /MTU

• Top and bottom 15% excluded as per Tech Spec 4.2.2.2G 17

I '

. Callaw ay Cycle 9 Res.10 Mt1CNT 10000.

2.00 t ! '

11 ) ' '

' ' tfttT) Will

. 0.0c0 1.0000

i i I

... . e s.141 1.0000

• 4.333 1.0000

• 0.500 1.0000 d

I

• 0.661 1.0000 1.9C . O . I H, 1,,, 1.0,00,0 1, , ,

• 1.161 1.0000

• 1.333 1.0000

• 1.600 1.0000

• 1.661 1.0000 j'

' t' 1

1.833 1.3096 I gg 3.000 1.1961 l 3.14' 1. 3 5 M 3.3H 1.3100

.. 2.500 1.3660 3.647 1.2436

= 3.833 1.3304 3.000 1. 3 n e 1.1C 3.167 1.2171 3.333 1.3313 3.600 1.3355 3.661 1.3383

3. 0 H 1.3304 4.00 1

1.6C 4, n,0 1.333,3 1,3 n 4.333 1.3381 4.500 1.3405 4.461 1.2414 4.833 1.2410 1 e 1.000 1.3391 tl 5.141 1.3319

- 1.5C 5.3n 1.3nt

,'E l.500 1.3343 5.667 1.3339 4

$.833 1.3375 4.000 1.3434 6.167 . 3493 1.4C 4.H3 1. 35 H

= 6 $00 1.3565

--- 6.667 1.3587 6.633 1,350s 1.000 1.3170 7.141 1.208 a 7.333 1.2410 1.3C *  ?.500 1.3403 7.667 1.3309 6 --

7.333 1.2194

'. m . 6.'a" _7 A6 0.000 1.2013

] "

pp-'unaa "a, , 3.161 1.1613 uaA ^

9.333 1.1408 1.g( r. 8.500 1.1734

, a, ya 3.ui 1. u n l

_4A" 9.tH 1.1183 9.000 1.1916 9.161 1.1836 9.H3 1.1856 i 1.1846 1.1C 9,.50,0

,n 1. n el 9.633 1.2004 10.000 1.1131 10.167 1.3303 i! ~

• 10.3 H 1.0000

• 3" 2 ""

I

1. 0 c. ; ^. c. ; . . ;; .I. ^I -

_ ;. e . . ; ; . . ; ; . -

• 10.661 1.0000 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 . 10. e n 1.0000

• 11.000 1.0000 BOTTOM TOP - u.16, 1.0000 CORE HEIGHT (FEET) . u.3n

• 11.500 1.0000 1.0000

• 11.467 1.0000

• 11.333 1.0000

• 13.C00 1.0000 Figure 8 Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 18000 MWD /MTU

• Top and bottom 15% excluded as per Tech Spec 4.2.2.2G 18

i

,. i Cs!!away Cycle 9 P,cv.10 i utt0NT mu 1.6c i agru um i l

• 6.000 1.0060 .

• 0.141 1.0000  !

.

• 0.333 1.0000 i

• 6.500 1.0000

• 0.667 1.0000

• 0.8H 1.0000 l

• 1.000 1.0000 i

• 1.161 1.0000

• 1.333 1.0000 1 1.50

• 1.$00 1, u ,

1.0000 1, u n l

i 1.033 1.4004 t

. 000 1.3196 i 2.141 1.3804 8

• 2.333 1.3383  ?

2.500 1.2990 t 2.467 1.2786 l 2.833 1.2586  !

3.000 1.2479 3.161 1.2389 g,4( 3.333 1.2321 ll 3.500 1.2299 3.647 1.2242 o 3.833 1.2304

'~~~~

4.000 1.3333 A

• 4.161 1.2347

4. 3 H 1.2381 4.800 1.2405 3 4.667 1.2414 4.833 1.2410 5.000 1.2397

$ 1.3C o 5 "?

N 5.333 1 '. 8 8" 1 2362 l.100 1.2342 a S.667 1.3339 O

l.833 1.2318 u

g o"A 4 i

6.000 1.2434

,, ,,A A 6.167 1.2442 u

O oAA

m' 'asa 0 A 6.H3 1. 2 S H 6.500 1.2565 u 6.667 1.2541 A 6.833 1.2541 1.20 --

? 008 1 800 '

A o 1.161 1. 3 S M +

i -.-

" t.333 1.2478 no 7.500 1.2402 1.667 1.2308 l 1.833 1.2194 '*

8.000 1.2013 9.161 1.1913 4 H3 1.1900 9.800 1.1134 8.667 1.1111 1.1C s.eu 1.1183 '

l 9.00 1.1816

. 9.16,0 1.1926 9.333 1.1956 9.500 1.1990 9.647 1.2115 9.533 1.2314 10.000 1.2501 10.161 1.2681

• 10.333 1.0000

1. 0 0 . .

• u 508 1 '8"

• u BOTTOM TOP * " " ' 1""

CORE HEIGHT (FEET) .!!l ,

• 11.500 10 ll I'.ll000

• 11.667 1.0000

• 11.I33 1.0000

• 12.000 1.0000 Figure 9 4

Callaway Cycle 9 Bounding W(z)no

• Top and bottom 15% excluded as per Tech Spec 4.2.2.2G 19

. Caliawmy Cycle e Rev.10 NtleMT 150.

2.00 i i "t ""'

• 0.000 1.0000

,--.,

• 0.167 1.0000

~~~~'

• 0.333 1.0000

• 0.lH 1.0000

• 0.441 1.0000 1,9(

• 0.033 1.0000

• 1.000 1.0000

• 1.167 1.0000

• 1.333 1.0000

• 1.$00 1.0000 I

• 1.661 1.0000 l 1.833 1.f0?1 1.00 ----

3.u0 a.lut 3.147 1.1635

. . 3.333 1.1401 3.500 1.1198 3.461 1.1043 3.833 1.0950 1.7C 8 '" 1'"'

3.10 1. H 43

• 3.333 1.0713 3.800 1.0111 3.441 1.0404 3.433 1.0404 6 4.400 1.0614 1.6C ,, 4.1n 1. c o t 4.333 1.0$33

^ 4.$00 1.0860 4.661 1.0633

^ a 4.033 1.0413 1.000 1.0433 f.1.5C g -i 51" 1.3 H 2 ""

1.0374 I i 3 5.500 1.0343 5.667 1.0367 a l.033 1.0418 6.000 1.0599

) 4.161 1.0130 1.4C a 6.H3 1.0943

• I 6.$00 1.0944 I 6.641 1.1099 6.033 1.1363 u 7.000 1.1459 1.161 1.1113

^

1.3C '*8" 8""

1.$00 1.3193 1.661 1.3333 7.0H 1.3113 0.000 1.3161 0 4.147 1.3059 3 i 0.H3 1.3380 1.2C - e.800 1.s ol 9.467 1.3839 0

A 0.0H 1.3960 9.000 1.4133 9 ,

9.161 1.430

' 9.333 1.4661 1.1C a 4'

' ' " 8*"'

i.M b 9.441 1.5303 fg 4 9.t H - 1.507_

en ..

10.000 1.6901 b -" 0 30.167- 1.6041

- "i

• 10,333 1.0000

' I *"5" 1 8"'

1. 0 0 ..

~ . . . . . . . . . . . .,.--

10. 6 n 1.0000 0 1 .2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 . . . . . . .12 10.033 1.0000

• 11.000 1.0000 BOTTOM TOP 11. lo 1.0000 CORE HEIGHT (FEET) . H.H3 1. 00 n

• ".1.500 1.0000

• 11.667 1.0000

• 11.033 1.0000

• 13.000 1.0000 Figure 10 Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 150 MWD /MTU Measured-Predicted Axial Offset = -10.3%

' Tcp and bottom 15% excluded al per Tech Spec 4.2.2.2C 20

. Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 2.0c Nt!$NT 3000.

i i i.

j 6

i *i treets witi

_ l

• 0.000 1.0000

• 0.167 1.0000

i

• 9.H3 1.0000 *

• 0.l00 1.0000

• 3.667 1.0000 1.9C

• 8. 8 H 1 H00

• 1.000 1.00f0

• 1.161 1.0000

• 1.3H 1.0000

• 1.800 1.0000

• 1.667 1.0000 1.433 1.2006 3.000 1.3643 3.167 1.3314

~ 3.3H 1.3110 -

3.500 1.145$

3.667 1.1647

3. t H 1.1806 1.70 ---- 3.en 1. u u 3.167 1.1343 S.3H 1.1344

.. J.800 1.1106 3.661 1.1158 3.833 1.100 1.60 "' ****

f, 4.147 1.1050 4.333 1.0979 4.500 1,093l 4.667 1.006) y 4.0H 1.0791 a 8.000 1.0135

- 1.5C 5 18? 1.8581 g n S.3H 1.0610 5.500 1.0160 u

l.467 1.0$f4

___,, 6 5.9H 1.0631 4.000 1.0734 1.4C a 6.167 1.0,830 6 H3 1,0 1 u 6.500 1.1005

" 6.667 1.1106 6.033 1.1339 3 7.000 1.1411 1.167 1.1641 1.30 o O  ?*3H 1H" 1.500 1.2071 7.667 1.2170 7.833 1.3333 E o 0.000 1.2896

• 0.167 1.3939 la 4.3H 1.2C c' l

1.3363 g O.$90 1.3163 A

9.667 1.3193

• I I.8H A

1.3945 9.000 1.4103

t., , 9.167 1.4313

y "' J 9.333 1.4583 1.1C '*SH 1""

"h." I A- 9.667 1.1140 4-n g,-

9.433 1.5399 10.000 1.5650 10.167 1.5014

• 10.3H 1.0000

1. 0 0.. .. - . . - . . . -

• "5" 1'"'

.2

• 10.667 1.0000 0

1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 , -12

• 10. 8 H 1.0000 BOTTOM

• 11.000 1.0000 TOP *lt.u? 1.0000 CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

• H.H3 t.nu

• 11.800 1.0000

• 11.641 1.00'e

• 11. t M 1.0006

• 13.000 1.0000 Figure 11 Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 3000 MWD /MTU Measured-Predicted Axial Offset = -10.3%

• Top and bottom 15". excluded as per Tech Spn 4.2.2.2G 21 l

Callawey Cycle 9 Rev.10 uticut 10000.

2*OU ttttfl will

• 0.000 1.0000

• 9.161 1.0000

• 0.3H 1.0000

• 0.$00 1.0000

• 9.441 1.0000 g*gg ,

• 9.8H 1.0000

• 1.000 1.0000

• 1.167 1.0000

• 1. H 3 1.0000

• 1.$00 1. f,0 *J e

.

• 1.441 1.0000 1.IH 1.3480 1.8C 3.0u 1. H H 3.161 1.2134 3.333 1.1949 3.500 1.1780 l 3.461 1.1H O g 3.033 1.1489 1.7C -

3 ' '" 1 * "' 8

,,,_ 3.161 1. H 00 3.333 1.1316 3.600 1.1369 0

3.461 1.1351 3.IH 1.1341 4.000 1.1316 1.60 g 4.ut 1. H e 4 4.3H 1.1143

-- _. 4.500 1.1118 A 4.667 1.1005 m 4. t H 1.1041 t4 1.000 1.1000

- 1.50 S.167 l.3H 1.0914 1.0911 lE p 5.500 1.0959

^

l.641 1.0999 S.433 1.1090 6.000 1.1309

. 6.167 1.1337 1.4C a 6.3H 1.1439 6.500 1.1533 4.667 1.1650 a 6.833 1.1789

^ 1.000 1.1954 1.167 1.3119 1.3C 1. H 3 1.2416

, , ,,n, 1,n n 3" 7.667 1.3686 o 1.833 1.3904 6 i 8.000 1.3998 0.161 1.3339 A 8.3H 1.3514 1.2C -j c. s.100 1. H u i <, a 9.667 1.3904 f_

A 9.833 1.4045

[.

A i 'l 9.000 1.4334

1. 4

' 9.167 1.4431 9.H3 1.4611 1.1C

aAAA'~"5o4 ,

_s' ' ,1 ,.H0 1.50 u 9.661 1.1134 9.833 1.5924 10.000 1.6146 10.167 1. 6 H 4

• 10.3 H 1.0000 1,00- . . _ . . I * **.100 1.0000

• H'ut -

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 . . .11 12 . u H3 1:Ono 100u BOW CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

. f f

• 11.500 1.0000

• 11.667 1.0000

• 11. 8 H 1.0000

• 13.000 1.0000

- Figure 12 Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 10000 MWD /MTU Measured-Predicted Axial Offset = -10.3%

• Top and bottom 15% excluded as p r Tech Spec 4.2.2.2G 22 i

J

i

' ' i Callaway Cycle 9 Ret 10 '

, i 4

l

-p nicut 18:00.

2.00 < i i i 'i '

trrtt) will i

I

• 0.000 1.0000

)

• 0.141 1.0C00

. .

• 9.333 1.0000

• 9.600 1.0000

• 0.661 1.0000 g 9g

• 0.033 1.0000

-___

• 1.00 1.0000

• 1.161 1.0000

• 1.333 1.0000

• 1.500 1.0000 J

• 1.667 1.0000 g,gg 1.833 2.000 1.2042' 1.1912

' 2.167 1.1787

! 1.333 1.160$

2.500 1.1470 x

2.461 1.1341 2.033 1.1230 g 7g 3.000 1.1150 3.167 1.1143-3.333 1.11??

a 3.500 1.1230 a 3.661 1.1111 3.433 1.1319

. 4.00d 1.13h1 a 1.60- .,3 , 3,3 n, 4.333

,6 1.130%

4.500 1.1430 A 4.681 1.14$1

.! n *-

4.833 1.1463 N 5.000 1.1464

- 1.5C 5.161 1.1441

$ . l.3n 1.18tl

• l.100 1.1999 5.667 1.1636 9

5.033 1.1730 A 4.000 1.1053 6.167 1.1966 g,4g , 4.333 1.20$9

,, 6.$00 1.2149

,__ 6.667 1.2240

~' '-~

4.833 1.2350 a 1.000 1.3492 7.161 3.2679

.A,, 7.331 1.3811 1.30 c i 7.500 1. nt s 4

6 1.661 3 3068 7.033 1.3081 0.000 1. 3 M S

,? 4.167 1.3373

.O 1.2C a

t . 3,3

,, , 3, 1.311,9 3,n 3

--- - 8.661 1.3931 1 1 M t.833 1.4259 o .

A.*,M l.000 1.4463 4 9.147 1.4639 Ao ' '" -- 9.333 1.4031

,y. ,

i I 9.500 1.5032 1.10 I i t 9.661 1.5239 i f.433 1.5523 10.000 1.5694 10.167 1.5119 1 l

• 10.333 1.0000 i i *2'*5" 2 ""

1

• 0 0 ^ e . . ; ;. ... - , . ;

o  ; .. . . ;; _ ;;, ,

• 10.667 3.0000

0. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

• 10.833 1.0000

• 11.000 1.0000 BOTTOM TOP

• 11.16t 1.0000 CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

• 11. n 3

• 11.500 1.0000 1.0000

• 11.661 1.0000

• 11.833 1.0000 i

• 13.000 1.0000 g

Figure 13 Callaway Cycle 9 2

W(z)no at 18000 MWD /MTU

~

Measured-Predicted Axial Offset = -10.3%

• Top and bottom 15% excluded as per Tech Spec 4.2.2..:G 23

. ~ _ - . . ~ - . - _ - - - . _ _ - . - . . . - . . - . - _ - . _ . . - . _ . _ _ _ _ _ - . = . . . .- - . _ - _ .

OHaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 ett GMT 110.

g

• gg 'r ' g i strtti

• 6.000 uttl 1.0000

• 0 '.67 1.0000

+ 03H 1.0000

• 0.800 1.0000

• 0.647 1.0000 1.9C

• 1.0000

, . 9.8,33 g,,, 3,,n, I

• 1.167 1.0000

• 1.333 1.0000

• 1.500 1.0000

• 1.641 1,0000 a 1.033 1.1496 +

1.8C i 2.00G, 1.141 3,3 n ,0 3,n

.. 2.333 1.1016 ,

^

2.500 1.0809 --

2.447 1.0641 1 2.433 1.0111 4 j 1.7C p 3.00,0 3,gg 1.06,1,0 g,n 3.333 1.0410 a 3.100 1.0363 3.667 1. 0 H 9 3.033 1.0347 i o 4.000 1.034J 1.6C 4.ut 1.0309 0

4.333 1.0259 4.800 1.02H 4.667 1.0200 s

& 4.933 1.0115 5.000 1.0123 t4 l.lat 1.0104

.- 1.5C , 3.us, 1.00.,

'.E 1.500 1.00t?

3 5.641 1.0136 4 $.833 1.0269 6.000 1.0410 6.167 1.0549 1.40 i 6.3n 1.0607

6.500 1.0828 6.661 1.0988 ,

u 6.s33 1.1116 i i 1.000 1.14n 1.167 1.1760 1.2111 1.3C ,

7, . 3,3,3, g ,3 3 n 1.667 1.2564 a ,

7.133 1.2021

• I.000 1.3166 I.361 1.3516 2 8.J33 1.4013 1.2C - e.500 1,43,2 8.467 1.4656 a f.833 1,4341 9.000 1.5061 9.167 1.$362 A I

" 1.$131 l

j 9,.333

.n0 1. nu 1.1C _ ,

9.667 1.6526 9.933 1.6924 A b 10.000 1.1223

&~

, 10.161 1.7334

%'6~" Y'6A. . A

• 10.333 1.0000 1

17'" M e '

• u.600 1 .

. go,,s, 1.0,4,00 ,,

1. 0 0_. . .. . .

..-...- . . . 2, 0 .. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 , 11~.~ . 12 10. in 1.000e 1'0000 TOP *. 11.000, BOTTOM ti.16 l'0000 CORE HEIGHT (FEET) . u 3n l.0ce0

• 11.500 1.0000

• 11.661 1,0000 11.333 1.0000

• 12.000 1.0000 Figure 14 Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 150 MWD /MTU Measured-Predicted Axial Offset = -14.0%

• 5p and bottom 15% excluded as per Tech Spec 4.2.2.2G 24

Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 2.00 m 1Cx7 3000.

i irt m wili

• 0.000 1.0000

• 0.161 1.0000

.

• 0.333 1.0000

• 9.500 1.0000

• 0.661 1.0000 1.9C

• 0 su 1.0000

• 1.000 1.0000

• 1.161 1.0000

• 1. H 3 1.0000

~~-

• 1.500 1.P000

• 1.667 1.0000 1.8C 1.033 1.3400 3,000 1,3330 3.167 1.1943 3.333 1.1698 3.500 1.1443 3.661 1.134$

,, 3.033 1.1114 1.7C 'h;o 3 080 I.HI8 1.167 1.0963 a J.333 1.0865 3.500 1.0914 a 3.667 1.0797 3.033 1.0106 4.000 1.0760 4.147 1.0107 4.333 1.0634

^ ---- . 500 1.0$86

'~

4.647 1.0131 a 4.0H 1.0443 h

- 1.50 l.000, 1.0404 5.14 1, H 6 4 g .

l.233 1. b H S 5.500 1.0300 1

5.667 1. H19 5

l.033 1.0414 6.000 1.0533 1.4C 6.167 1.0499

---

3 6.3H 1. 01u 6.500 1.0869 6.667 1.0994 A 0'03I I.IIII 7.000 1.1305 1.167 1.1699 g,3g 7.333 1.2019 7.500 1.2360

, 7.641 1.3409 0 1.033 1.3636

8.000 1.3995 n 4.167 1.3410 1.20 ^ f.333 1. H 9 3 a -

i.500 1.4354 4 8.661 1.4601 6 3,333 1.4825 9.000 1.5040 9.167 1.5308 D

9.333 1.5644 g*gg ,  ? 9,500 1.6004 g ie, 9.647 1.4350 I

% ,g, j. 9.833 1.6469 oO A 10.000 1.6944

., / '. k 10.161 1.7143

.._6" 44 l

• 10.133 1.0000 1

• 0 0. . .. . . ... l 14 i

• 10.500 1.0000

. . . :. : . . :. :. ..=.

• 10 us 1.0000 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

• 10.en 1.0e00 BOTTOM

• 11.000 1.0000 TOP

• H.161 1.0000 CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

• u.3H 1.0000

• 11.500 1.0000

• 11.461 1.0000

• 11. lu 1.0000

• 13.000 1.0000 Figure 15 Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 3000 MWD /MTil Measured-Predicted Axial Offset = -14.0%

• Top and bottom 15% exclud u as per Tech spec 4.2.2.2G 25 i

1

.. ~~

'Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 Nt!;MT 10000.

2.00 I i l

'""' "In .

• 0.000 1.0000

• 9.167 1.0000

• 0.333 1.0000

• 4.500 1.0000

• 0.661 1.0000 1.9C * " 1""

• 1.000 1.0000

-* 1.167 1.0000

• 1.333 1.0000

• 1.500 1.0000

__

• 1.667 1.0000

1. 0 H 1.2001 1.8C 3.000 1.1,36 3.167 1.1131 A 3.333 1.1640 d'

3.500 1.1310

, 3.661 1.1339 3.033 1.1091 1.7C 8 ' '" 1""

3.167 1.0931

" 3.333 1.0896 3.500 1.0896 3.641 1.0093 3.IH 1.0006 4.000 1.09 9 1.6C 7 4.161 1. 08 u 3 4.333 1.010 4.500 1.0114 x 4.647 1.0147

^

4.tn 1.0106 4, 5.000 1.0618

$ 1.50 h 5 '. 8 "

5 333 1""

1.0618 N a 5.500 1.0699 5.667 1.0744

-. J'- 5.833 1.0069

.,, 6.000 1.1010 F i 4.167 1.1147 1.40 j 6.H3 1. H 66 3 4.$00 1 1389

__ 6.667 1.1533 6.033 1.1109

[ T.000 1.1935 7.161 1.3339

• '"8 ***5" 1.3C A 7.$00 1.3101 i

1.661 1.3913 g 1. 8 H 1.3119 0.000 1.3410

, 0.161 1.3743 3 9.333 1.4154 1.20

9.$00 1.44 4 O.667 1.4136 0 @ l 9.833 1.4931 A A t.000 1.1169 4, .'

9.167 1.543l 1 .A t.J33 1.5740 b

• 9.500 1.6314 1.1C  %  ; i s.ut 1.6715 i

wi.s4gs 9.8H 1. 7 3 H 10.000 1.1134 10.147 1.1461

,

• 10.333 1.0000 l

• 10.500 1.0000

1. 0 ( ,, ; _ ;, ,, , , ; ;,, , _. ; ; 2 _ .1. . te..., 1,o,co 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7. 8 9 10 11 12

• 10. 9 H 1.0000

• 11.000 1.0000 BOTTOM TCP

• 1t.162 1.0e00 CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

• 11. 3 H 1.0000

• 11.500 1.0000

• 11.647 1.0000

• 11.333 1.0000

• 13.000 1.0000 Figure 16 Cal'hway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 10000 MWD /MTU  ;

Measured Predicted Axial Offset = -14.0%

• Top and bottom 15% excluded as per Tech Spec 4.2.2.2G 26

o' . . ,*

u

• Callaway Cycle 9 Rev.10 ut3GM7 10000.

2.00 '" "

'

• 9.000 1.0000

^

• 6.161 1.0000

• 0.333 1.0000

• 9.500 1.0600

• 0.641 1.0000 1.90 * '"8 8 '8"

• 1.000 1.0000

• 1.161 1.0000

• 1. 3 H 1.0000

• 1.500 1.4300

• 1.467 1.0600 1.8C 1.433 1.1664

+

3.000 1.1930 3.147 1.1361 3.H3 1.1300 3.100 1.1073 3.667 1.0986

' 3.833 1.0641 1.70  ;- " 8 '8

." 3'.'167 3 1'.0"170 3.333 1.0000

^ 3.500 1.0038 3.667 1.0913

" 3. 8 H 1.0941 1.60 4.000 1.0999 6 4.161 1.1030 4.3H 1.1 H 6 A

4.500 1.1076 4.467 1.1101 m 4.833 1.1106 N -

" 1.000 1.113%

- 1.50 -

8.167

• • E , 5,,n 3.1185, 1,33,

'~~

5.500 1.1375 g 5.647 1.1361 5.033 1.1496 6.000 1.1641 1.40 l 6.161 3.17?l g 6.3H 1.1ses 6.500 1.1999 6.667 1.2135 6.033 1.3375 a~ 7.000 1.2463 7.167 1.1730 gg  ; 7.333 1.3014 7.500 1.3197 6 7.447 1.3363 1.033 1.3403 0.009 1.3634 3 8.161 1.3903 4 9.H3 1.4333 1.2C -

s.lu 1.4534 6

" 4.661 1.4934 3

6.933 1.5159 3 9.00d 1.9434

, a ----

-o 9.161 1.5647 F 9.333 1.5911 1.10 g =

ot& 1.6183

,e y 9,.500,

.66 1.5453 9.833 1.4901 10.000 1.4991 10.167 1.6995

• 10.333 1.0000 1

• U C do m .. ..;;,. l

• lt.500 1.0000

.

. ; , ; ;. , . ; ;. . .

• 10.667 1.0000 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

• 10. s u 1.0000

• 11.000 1.0000 BOTTOM TOP

• 11.162 1.0000 CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

• H.H3 1.0e00

• 11.500 1.0000

• 11.661 1.0000

• 11.833 1.0000

• 13.000 1.0f?0 Figure 17 Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 18000 MWD /MTU Measured-Predicted Axial Offset = -14.0%

• Top and bottom 15% excluded as per Tech Spec 4.2.2.2G 1}