ML20199B634
| ML20199B634 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 05000113 |
| Issue date: | 11/13/1997 |
| From: | Williams J ARIZONA, UNIV. OF, TUCSON, AZ |
| To: | NRC |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9711190047 | |
| Download: ML20199B634 (6) | |
Text
- _.
. y, *,
Nuc! car Reactor Laboratory Ec UNIV [RSTTY OF John O. Williams, Director
- "g.OJ0ft" >
-"i:
8 8 Tucson, Arizona 857210020 DC50N AN 5 0)b219 9 o
FAX ($20)621-8096 November 13,1997 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission -
Document Control Desk Mail Stop PI-37 10CFR50.71 One White Flint North 10CFR21.21 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville, MD 20852
Subject:
Facility License No. R-52, Docket 50-113 Informat:on report, concerning malfunction of Mode Selector Switch The occurrence 6ocmnented on the following pages was reported to the NRC by telephone and fax on 5 November 1997. This report supplements that information and includes analysis, conclusions and remedial actions that will be reviewed by the Reactor Committee for this facility.
lf{
Jofm G. Williams, Director Director, Nuclear Reactor Laboratory 3GW/dg enclosure copies:
Non-Power Reactors and Deconunissioning Project Directorate, USNRC Mr. Marvin Mendonca, USNRC Dr. M. Cusanovich, Vice Pres. for Research, University of Arizona Reactor Committee Members f
\\
i 1 C C D D. ~
9711190047 971113}_'
PDR ADOCK 05000113 ll ll ll l ll
-. ~ - - _ -
FACILITY LICENSE R-52 4
Malfbaction of Mode Switch la Pulse Mode November 13,1997:
Descriotion of the Occurrence On November 4,1997, a pulse was performed with the mode switch in i:s Pulse High setting and with the transient ni anvil set for a $1.75 pulse. The trav ent rod operated normally, fuel temperature rise was recorded showing energy deposition in the ratp expected for a normal pulse and the timer scram operated normally. No valid indicut.on-appeared, however, for the peak reactor power or the integrated pulse energy. The right safety channel indicated a trip on reactor power.
A digital data acquisition system connected to the right safety channel showed that the signal on that channel displayed a normal reactor period of approximately 11 ms, but th...
saturated. This showed that the channel was connected to a valid indication of reactor power level from the ion chamber that is normally connected in steady state mode, not the high range ion chamber which should be selected in pulse mode. The trip on the right safety channel was attributed to power in excess of 110 kW, which is the steady state limit.
Testing of the mode switch revealed that changing the switch from its manual to pulse positions did not reliably switch between the normal and high range signals. The problem was corrected after removal of the rear casing of the mode switch and application of f
switch cleaning fluid. After reassembly, the system appeared to behave normally. The reactor was then operated at 95 kW steady state while the high range channel was calibrated and shown to behave normally. A pulse was then performed and normal indicatioas were found on ah channels.
Analysis and diannosis of the caum A malfunction of the mode switch was the cause. It resulted in failure to pick a r_elay which switches from the normal to the high range channel when pulse mode is selected, and which also switches in the nyt circuitry that indicates integrated pulse energy.
The following symptoms demonstrate that the high range channel was not engaged, but instead the nomial range uncompensated ion chamber was operating: (a) the reactor tripped on a high power scram from the right safety channel, even though the calculated peak power was less than 100 MW, and the trip was set at 1000 MW for pulse mode; (b) fuel temperature indications showed a peak temperature of 186 C, in the normal range for a $1.75 pulse, corresponding to energy deposition of 9.3 MW and peak power of 92.4
- MW; (c) a digital data collection system connected to the channel (after the switching
+
relay) saturated, though it should not have dorse so be;ow 1100 MW; (d) prior to saturation, the same data showed an exponential increase wnh a period of 11 ms, normal for a $1.75 pulse, an indication that the channel was connected to a true power indication, though not the high range one.
On November 10,1997, the mode switch was removed from the console for inspection and cleaning (see attached memo and part drawing). As a result of this inspection it was determined that the problem had actually been caused by a mechanical misalignment of the rear wafer of the switch, not by dirt. This was attributer.o wear and aging that had kmsened the nuts holding the rear case. 'Ihis also loosened the wafer assembly which is held together by the same nuts. The problem was corrected not by the cleaning fluid, as initially supposed, but by the retightening of these nuts that occurred on reassembly.
Corrective and remedial action The immediate poblem was corrected before the reactor was placed back in service on November 4. Tigh:ening of the nuts holding the casing of the mode switch also secured the switch wafers in their correct operating alignment.
To prevent a recurrence, the Electronics Technician and the Reactor Supervisor have proposed a small modification in the switch assembly, so that the wafer assembly is held together independently of the nuts which secure the rear casing. Details are given in the attached memo from Mr. Lohmeier. Them proposed changes will be submitted for approval ta the Reactor Committee before implementation.
Conclusions A malfunction that was attributed ira part to aging was found in the Mode Selector Switch (General Atomics part number ELD 239-4300C). It was corrected by tightening two nuts. To prevent a recurrence, a minor change in the assembly has been proposed.
Licensees of other facilities using this GA part may wish to consider the applicability of this experience to their systems.
The system failed safe causing actuation of reactor scram at 110 kW. The reactor did not operate outside its normal envelope, and there was no threat to health or safety'of the public.
guk 4
- J. G. Williams, Reactor laboratory Director
Date:
11/13/97 To:
Dr. John Williams
/
A From:
Wayne Lohmeier p
Subject:
Mode Switch Problem Dr. Williams, On November 4, the day of the pulse problem, the Mode Selector Swe:h (P/N ELD 239-4300C) rear case was removed and contact cleaner was sprayed on the svitch contacts.
The case was then re-installed and the reactor functioned normally.
On November 10, the switch was removed from the reactor console and cleaned.
Cleaning involved removing a foam like rt:idue from the spray contact cleaner. There was no obvious " dirt". The switch wafers are constructed with clear plastic in front of and behind the switch contacts. Although not hermetically sealed, the contacts are protected from the outside elements.
The following observations were made in the switch construction. There are two screws approximately 3 inche ' long that hold the switch fraine, the front case, the wafers, and the rear case. The assembly is secured by the screws and a washer, a lock washer, and a nut on the outside of the rear case.
My recollection of removir.g the rear case on November 4 is, the rear case was not aligned with the front case (off by approximately 10 degrees) and the nuts holding the rear case were not very tight.
The wafer that picks the " Pulse High/Lo" relay is the "D wafer" located at the rear of the assembly. I suspect the problem was, the rear wafer was lagging the mode switch knob because of the mis-alignment and nuts not being tight.
Harry could feel a binding in the switch when going to the Pulse High/Lo positions prior to removing the rear case and cleaning. When the re-assambly was completed, it felt smooth, and an audible sound of the switch engaging at each position is now present.
Corrective Action:
1 Shorten the rear spacers between the rear wafer and rear case by the thickness of a lockwasher and nut.
2 Assemble the switch wafers to the switch frame and front case using a lockwasher and nut. Wafer assembly will now not rely on rear cover for mechanical support.
3 Attach rear case using a lock washer and nut.
s.
e 9
vorurm norrcret oss wtriew L
Su on= DB p (g)i.
3
,3 1JD3 11 j
II h
l b
/
\\ rt Q g.,
/
n ews
~l0
/__
U" l.
10 s
_ -[ ]-_ ]-[
'~ [ f
[ SU OWld
~
~
qL. J x
</
dJ
\\
N N
SCALE: 2-1 9E 4
0
-l ASSEMBLY 15 P304 14 J304 I
I 2.37
=
'0
- .218 os t
3 1
iWP$s 'N%-
1__
23, L
/_.e' i4 I. -
7
'S a,s om a i
1 DETAll ITD4 9 e
.p
.____-__x_
._______________1____
- g..
m_
m
.~_. <
m4 -,
m.
+
(, gj ---':+
- i i
)
'. g i
F
/
,sy tu ---
-i ? Pt8 cts l[~
jg/ ;,
r
~~~Y -
g i
.3;1 P cy'-
y I
- (5f -
.y,
- 42 :
w m
--w--
.u. 4. -
g l-(
j
. I i
e,
,g;J
~ ~
s'_-
J
-J q
l
- (
I t
.-1.2$ ~
3s--
-- - tso _ _..[-
l._- 2 2 s ---.
+ v l _F -
Rtr DETAIL : g iN
..,.315 DiA
',,(
}
=-,
^,.
4
\\ g.
28,0 p 3G 9
.4 '
'U 42 7 f
L__.p._-h)
~p
.3\\ ;
w*
/
in 4
?T'..
t t.
e --
t2s J-_
v_,
7[..- u s +
.. u.-.
li i. - 2 50 W-7s-nF-.
DETAtt E l
'1'
'A
'~523M' SC EMCT
- Uv p3cy p'I'iT G PI ~M"Cdtby" erv s r mpng a-Pl%7~
4 i
4 26d0
-.n' iA
- 9 PW t
i t$
2G-l'%
7 50CAET J304L i
i
- 4
'7FU 3 5 tockEr.
TGi95
'l PIN P303.
4 I
Ti~
o o
JD3 i
i 12 l20-2il fo%ECTow 5 PW AMwiNat
{
Z lt 4 404 3Wif ' aCREW PANHD STEEL CAD PLAT ELEC170iN'T Ag AR to
- 3 Gff0MME T STRIPPING E
2 4
GTE,71817 4 A 2 4 ~'PY411C FAB.LENQPE FSE
\\4 '4 8
2jQS SPACEP. FrBRE #4 X v4 H.H SMITH I
I
'l int tAtz. RE AR %mWT f 7.S.
e n
6 240 W F C@R 3/4 WGH HRO 6
1 5
24E'OA BOX 2 V4 H1G H-
' FERO s..-
4 4 4
T t o ?. -
smTc.H DEC.W-f it.
RU 3-ELUB9-4301 SC HEMAT IC
\\
Z
-1 Attr ugty i
N i-
-t ASS diBL Y -
q -g
~
i
=
mn, s.,a
.....,nn....
ti 3
p ELD 239-430001 iMode switch assembly 1
^-
l
~'
- ~. - - - --