ML20198H464
| ML20198H464 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Waterford  |
| Issue date: | 01/28/1998 |
| From: | HOLTEC INTERNATIONAL |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20198H363 | List: |
| References | |
| HI-91700, HI-91700-R01, HI-91700-R1, NUDOCS 9812290344 | |
| Download: ML20198H464 (39) | |
Text
- ..- - .. - . . _ , _ , , . _
/ HOLTEC INTERNATIONAL REVIEW AND CERTIFICATION LOG DYNARACK VALIDATION MANUAL DOCUMENT NAME:I-91700 (cenerie) HOLTEC DOCUMENT LD. NO. Not applicable HOLTEC PROJECT NUMBER N t applicable CUSTOMER / CLIENT 1 REVISION BLOCK QUALITY PROJECT ISSUE ASSURANCE MANAGER NO. AUTHOR REVIEWER Q & DATE & DATE & DATE & DATE
% 5+1- %M/GyMT' (7.,'t w U0 ~ br*%
SC1homas ulttlm 4, 5. #-/t -f/ ORIGINAL M . //-11-91 REV* 1
** DJi?&4 D M. 1/OYir A S . # z.7 9 7 fu -IM8 REV. 2 REV. 3 REV. 4 REV. 5 REV. 6 Must be Project Manager or his Designee.
NOTE: Signatures and printed names are required in the review block. This document conforms to the requirements of the design specification and the appl sections of the governing codes. g I i I 9812290344 981223 l PDR ADOCK 05000302 [ 9 04/ P PDR _
. l 1
~
REVISION LOG HOLTEC REPORT HI-91700 3. Revision 1 t-1. Added 60994. new validatiort problem 12 in response to NRC RAI for 3- ,
-Appendices Ki-K3 added as part of this new problem. h j
2. Changed(Section problem text pages 15).as needed to reflect additon of this new R 3. Renumbered section 15 to section 16. i l :: p i
- qu unun ~ .x w y-~.e - r ~'%- ?- 1~W- W -*
- TABLE OF CONTENTS Number of Paces 1.0 OVERVIEW OF DYNARACK 7
2.0 REFERENCES
3 3.0 VALIDATION PLAN , 5 4.0 PROBLEM 1 - LUMPED MASS IMPACTING A SIMPLY SUPPORTED BEAM 15 5.0 PROBLEM 2 - CANTILEVER BEAM WITH GAP . SUPPORT SUBJECT TO TIME VARYING FORCE 11 6.0 PROBLEM 3 - ELASTIC WAVE PROPAGATION IN A ROD 6 7.0 PROBLEM 4 - TWO DEGREE-OF-FREEDOM LINEAR
. SYSTEM WITH INERTIAL COUPLING )
4 8.0 PROBLEM 5 - IMPACTING PENDULUMS 6 9.0 PROBLEM 6 - SUBHARMONIC RESONANCE 4 10.0 PROBLEM 7 - SIMULATION OF FRICTION BERAVIOR 5 11.0 PROBLEM 8 - MASS WITH NON-LINEAR SPRING JUMP PHENOMENA 6 12.0 PROBLEM 9 - LIMIT CYCLE BEHAVIOR 8 13.0' PROBLEM 10 - STEADY STATE RESPONSE OF BOXES IN WATER 21 14.O PROBLEM 11 - TEST PROBLEM TO CHECK DYNARACK INPUT. CODING 3 15.0 PROBLEM 12 - RESPONSE OF A SINGLE BOX SPRING IN WATER 9 16.O CLOSURE 1 l
- m. . , . _ _ - _ _ - .
f TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) APPENDICES A-1: Input Data for Model and Transient Analyses for a Ball Dropping on a S.S. Beam 35 A-2: Beam Impact Problems - 5 Cases 35 A-3: DYNARACK 33 DOF Analysis with " Beam Springs" 29 B-1: ANSYS Input Data for Model Analysis ' 6 B-2: ANSYS Response Time-Histories 18 B-3: Beam Impact Problem Using DYNARACK with an ANSYS Comparison 27 C: Wave Propagation 27 D-1: Alternate Numerical Solution from Thomson Text 4 D-2: DYNARACK Results 10 E-1: ANSYS Example No. 6: DYNARACK Response of a System of Impacting Pendulums 13 l b E-2: DYNARACK Results for 5 Pendulum Impact Problem 12 F-1: Sec. 2.14 from Textbook " Component Element Method", McGraw Hill (1976) by S. Levy and J. Wilkinson (Subharmonic Response) 2 F-2: Subharmonic Resonance 7 G-1: Static and Sliding Friction in Feedback Systems 9 G-2: Friction with Dead Bands DYNARACK Data Files 12 H-1: Jump Phenomena Approximate Solutions 3 H-2: DYNARACK Jump Phenomena Simulation Input, Output 7 Files and Plot Code for Response Curve I-1: DYNARACK Limit Cycle I/O Files 8 J-1: Test of DYNARACK Effect of Equation Formulation Tee Section Problem 12 K-1: Copy of Reference (15.1] 13 K-2: Harmonic Motion of Mass-Spring Submerged in Water 4 K-3: Computer Files 38
i I 'r i 1 i i
- l. '
I -1 l 1 REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY l AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS.NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION l I 1 C
i l l l l 1 1 l i I 1 i 1 i l l 1 ENCLOSURE 10 (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 12 to W3F1-98-0016, dated 1/29/98) l 1 1 I l 1 i r
- a. -. . :.. .a..--. < ~ ,_m .. . ,
i
\
HI-M1465 USERMAN. DOC 4 h FLOW CHART FORWHOLE POOL MULTIBACE ANALYSE ] i 1 1 i ) ? l 1 e 1 I REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION 4 s s d' 1 i i 1
._ . -. . _ . ..- . . . - . . . = . .
I I l l ENCLOSURE 11 (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 13 to W3F1-98-0016, dated 1/29/98) ; l 1 I l 1
~ ~a .-e#uc%2,~2,3.,.2., ,,
3 H SEIMM1RUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF WATERFORD 3 SPENT FUEL RACKS T.e '1 ..TAats s.1 : ,
- w. -
y y; fl%S Mh.8) o.s cor,osa c l - / 4 i l 1 REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY I AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION l l i l 1 1
- ggop94 SEISMIC / STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF WATERFORD 3 SPENT FUEL RACKS A
% @ska > :M >
TABLE 5.2..
}. Q H f i l $} %l A% MO?%
i c M Mb)
+
o.: cor, one cas.
- . . 1 i
!I i 4 j i i 1 1 1 4 i i REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY l AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION l i i ) ' i 9
_. _. jeu. ,,
, . . ,, .-g ,m 4 .; s h*f, < , ' *. . , **' --.,. ..,,,.. " . ,ce:. 39 i .
SFmMTRUCTUML ANALYSIS OF WATERFORD 3 SPM M EM 4
~'
, ,m- cgamast
' gpl1
- <iy'ip;[ EA '
- M
\
a ' I m m.,inoaments ech**) 4 2 e.s cor,osa cm. i e 1 j s i
- l i i i I i
i 4 j REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY j AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION 1 i e a ?- r 'i ( i i
%' ' u
l l ENCLOSURE 12 (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 1 to W3F1-98-0040, dated 3/23/98) l l I
~ . , : . u < .- ~ w.- .. . .
Attachment 1
~, . / HOLTEC POSITION PAPER WS-121 Vb BENCHMARKING COMPUTER CODE FLUENT Revision 0: February 17,1998 FLUENT is a mature ccm yuimional fluid dynamics (CFD) code, generxlly recognized as the industry's most widely used computer program for solving a wide variety of problems involving fluid flow, heat, and mass transfer. FLUENT is a genemi purpose code which effects solution of the classical Navier-Stokes equations of fleid motion using robust and accurate numerical methods. FLUENT's ability of,providing reliable resuks is cc-To...ed by its successful usage in a wide variety of industrial applications including the power generation, environment, automotive and chemical process industries.
FLUENT has been implemented in Holtec International's nuclear quality system after extensive Whmarking. This posi*. ion paper provides a summary of the industry and Hohec's benchmarking efforts. REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION
f 9 ENCLOSURE 13 (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 3 to W3F1-98-0040, dated 3/23/98) ! i 1 l t 4
I I i i
?
REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION :
)
?
i Attachment 3: Schematic of Original Nodalization Scheme for Jan 21 1997 l Waterford 3 CFD Analysis Fluent 4.32 Fluent Inc. _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ . _ - _ _ . - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _^ . _
~ _"_ _ _ _ _
L L. ,x2 _ m._ ENCLOSURE 14 (Non Proprietary Version of Attachment 4 to W3F1-98-0040, dated 3/23/98) 1 I
s REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION Attachment 4: Physical Mesh Mapped by the Original Scheme Feb 081998 x Fluent 4.32 Fluent Inc. b
l l 1 I i i ENCLOSURE 15 (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 5 to W3F1-98-0040, dated 3/23/98) i I i i i i I l
d i t i REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY 4 AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION i t I I i s i l Attachment 5: Volumetric Heat Source Contours Plot Feb 081998 i x [ Heat Source (W/M**3)] Fluent 4.32 Fluent Inc.
.I i
s
.g 7 ENCLOSURE 16
_(Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 6 to W3F1-98-0040,-dated 3/23/98)
i s, t REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY , AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION
)
i Attachment 6: Refined Nodalization Scheme to Demonstrate Feb 081998 1 = 11 Mesh Size Convergence Fluent 4.32 J = 89 Fluent Inc. ; 4
.. = -. . . . - - . . _ _ - .. . . . . - . - - - - - - . . . - . . . - . _ - . . -
( I l l ENCLOSURE 17 (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 7 to W3F1-98-0040, dated 3/23/98) a f
k t i I REMAINDER OF DOCUM'ENT IS PROPRIETARY AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION l i Attachment 7: Temperature Contours Plot with Original Mesh Jan 21 1997 Temperature (K) [Waterford 3 CFD Analysis] Fluent 4.32 x Tmax = 3.616E+02 Tmin = 3.241E+02 Fluent Inc. ,
\
I
i I l I ENCLOSURE 18 I (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 8 to W3F1-98-0040, dated 3/23/98) i i i l l J I
m-a.--- i
'i i
I l I i I REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION
- l t
k 1 I J.49Ctus: - Attachment 8: Temperature Contours Results with Refined Mesh Feb 081998 l x Temperature (K)[Waterford 3 CFD Analysis] Fluent 4.32 Tmax = 3.621E+02 Tmin = 3.241E+02 Fluent Inc. i L
ENCLOSURE 19 (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 9 to W3F1-98-0040, dated 3/23/98) l l
I 1 i l l l l REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY . AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION l ATTACflMENT 9: MP3 SPENT FUEL POOL TEST LAYOUT O 1960994\lR\R01\9I
i I 1 1 1 I l i I l ENCLOSURE 20 l (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 20 to W3F1-98-0040, dated 3/23/98)
y REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY . AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY yERSION , i : l L
'i i
Attachment 10: Millstone Unit 3 Pool Transient Heating Profiles
l l l ENCLOSURE 21 1 (Non Droprietary Version of Attachment 12 to W3F1-98-0040, dated 3/23/98)
'i i
. t-REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION I
i ii
- i
~
l E Attachment 12: Base Case Waterford 3 Temperature Contours Mar 121998 x Temperature (K) Fluent 4.32 ; Tmax = 3.613E+02 Tmin = 3.241E+02 Fluent Inc.
1 l l l l l I I I l 1 l l ENCLOSURE 22 (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment 13 to W3F1-98-0040, dated 3/23/98) I l
i REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY i AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION i Attachment 13: Perturbed Case Waterford 3 Temperature Contours Mar 121998 x Temperature (K) Fluent 4.32 Tmax = 3.604E+02 Tmin = 3.241E+02 Fluent Inc.
I 1 I l l 1 l l 1 i 1 1 l 1 ENCLOSURE 23 (Non-Proprietary Version of Enclosure 2 to W3F1-98-0100, dated 5/19/98) l I l i l
...-_---._.--.__..-.e.
- . .,~;.-._
- := -w .,y ,,. u , w m ._-.-. _-.-.
. _ .y g .,. .c~..,,... m l
l i O enciosure 2 to W3F1-98-0100 I Page 1 of 10 ENCLOSURE 2 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REGARDING TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION CHANGE REQUEST NPF 38-193 DYNARACK USER INSTRUCTIONS i The attached pages contain excerpts from the DYNARACK user's manualbnd are provided to assist in the execution of simulations. A set of execution instructions are
- also provided, including a flow chart of the process required to perform the simulations.
l l
. l O .
l l a l O ( T
l Enclosure 2 to W3F1-98-0100 i Page 2 of 10 l O DATA INDUT RetMITHfB FOR PREnyMA l M S 6 *
+
REMAINDER OF DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION
i ENCLOSURE 24 (Non-Proprietary Version of Enclosure 3 to W3F1-98-0100, dated 5/19/98)
( c l ? l ENCLOSURE 3 CONTAINS PROPRIETARY INFORMATION CONTAINED ON THREE DISKS l l THE INFORMATION INCLUDED DYNARACK (SINGLE RACK VERSION) . l SOFTWARE EXECUTABLE FILES AND THE INPUT DECKS REQUIRED TO L ! PERFORM THE SINGLE RACK SIMULATIONS FOR THE WATERFORD 3 SPENT FUEL STORAGE RACK PROJECT l , I l THE REMAINDER OF THE INFORMATION CONTAINED ON THESE I DISKETTES IS PROPRIETARY AND IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS ! NON-PROPRIETARY VERSION I I f l I
_ ... _- .. _.. . _ ._ ___..---.m. . .___ . -. . . . . . . . . . . _ . . _ __ .--_ 1
.1 ~
i I e
.-(
i
.i l
i e I I ENCLOSURE 25 (Non-Proprietary Version of Attachment to W3F1-98-0096, dated 5/28/98) i I
' s .. i .g i
1 0
.' p-J.:4f e'
3 4 e _,c - y.-- -y r- -. - wy-, -.c- ,
.3 ., .,.m. ,m,,.y-r-}}