ML20196H325

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Summary of 760525 Meeting W/Util & Westinghouse Re Proposed Approach to Solution of Reactor Vessel Lateral Loading Question.List of Attendees,Agenda & Viewgraphs Encl
ML20196H325
Person / Time
Site: Kewaunee, Point Beach, Prairie Island, Surry, Haddam Neck, Ginna, Robinson, San Onofre, Cook, Zion, 05000000, Trojan
Issue date: 06/29/1976
From: Trammell C
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
TAC-10754, NUDOCS 8803100182
Download: ML20196H325 (31)
v • d • e


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:r ~ .o. I >s 0sM 76 i. i e x \\- / \\ p I /. t v. w,.:. rd..e0,.1.;,. .c., ,.a s / 3<.A s c 0 C.l..%l,o.. o I [

.s..g /2y, 30-2-y 50 2f., 50 313, 50 2/2, 50 3p5,

.y.. r l "~; c.d s0.:, ':isecasin Public Service ("evaunce)

- ::c22S $. CII. TIss:

Scuthern California Edison (Ct.n Ce.ofre) J T.:sch) 1isce.. sin Ele:tric Po.*or (Pein: 4 Y:ah:e Atw.ic Po. sr (lMdd: '.kch) t, Conn:: icu C...c.1,a.a.., n (. 4. c,.) en Y1rcinis 21:::ric G Pcwer (Stir:y) T.cch: ster Gas ; 21ectric (Ginna) l Cerclinn Tcr.ce: 1 Li;5: ( obinsen) (Cc:k)

b. 3 inrican Ele: ric Pou::

h'erdern S::.tes Pouct (Prairie Isir.nd) 7o::1..nd Centre.1 E1e::ric (Trojen) N ' 0.' ' C..,"., P. w' "r.'.'. '..~6. '.s \\ i.' c.. ".' L.C..', P C..E.- ^ w.., L.,3..,y ,5, '.",a', l 1-.. 1 m.. l ......s ..u r a...,s t ..: t,i. w. i..s.. ri:S rg. :sen:atives of the t:ili:ics id:ntified 31:v ~ ) .,. 4,,.3. c...., e. s. c.. i c C.. c".. i. ca

  • o /.i. c us. s 23, im. s e r.::

1 '. s.'..>. i"... r. ... c.1 c '.. '... ..... c... s s <.1 '.... t... m....,. '-a4 i, ~ . r. ..,... T.. s..,,,. c,. t..c..... ~>.. s

t.. d a c.+,. y o '. v '. ~. "..,, w. s 2. e *......

t' c.. ,.,. ~. s 'is. o# Mir.hli; hts of ::a Natin,q.:s :t.nri:23 bel w. ,m 3 r >::i.; is atta:.ud. (<-} rt....te....r,e..c-.i m W.,e # r....' '3.. <.. i..,is. w. us s. .r. t s 4. 1 3 .. ~..

d.::ica with r: spec: to :

.ys.p.3.em> .. : - :s p-:up for the pur;. sc of : hin; c:ncer e c.ue s:Icn. C..-i:n :e ::.e n::.cr vessel st s er: ( u..u. ) s s.. c.... c.. y.. j e. .t...._.,,.4.,.,.. ..,s ,...,.....e; 4.s..,.:

e..g.. o..,

e s. i --t.. o .4

3.... e,.

.r .o.t.e ,2... .. g,.s.....,e3. ...g.. .,....,s ac..., ,, 4.... ...s.,t. o.

4.,...t,.

_....i ,a sa. e c s. 4...t ey. 4...... ..a . o.s..c.o. ,.,...,. a..e. g.. s.,.31w. .u .4 4.. i tn.a e.e,..i. v..,.., 2..,...,.... T...is nu,--.te d 1.m c:!ca .u'. d previ da increisc d r.s s ure.nce :S:t j r.a. m. s..- ret-tr:tr. }

: rie.l.

n .ta - s a c: o. v n s u r.....m e : i e r.: m.-T. :_.c r.: .... 4 n. 3.... t. c t. ..~. 2..... q e.,. s.. e. 4.,.. v.n. 33 s... a. t y.. y m..eg s ' :v t o b e r c : r: d fr.: celd l y inst.eetier.s. j ..e n..: s ::ull nc: /, e.,...,. - (...., c e...,..,.i n;, 4.,.,...,.,... i On

e. i....

[ ~,..w. $,... p..e. 3.- I s...,.. v., 4. L*., s t..:. w.. 3 l .,._.5.,.4.,., .... - At6- 0 :.. \\ .n. i. .s.( +.......rs.e

v..., 3 1 $ 1.2 \\. s }... ).

.i.. n. .,E. ce g ,.4 :,

e.. e s.
4. 4.. i. e.

q .r

a. 3 g,.........,,. :. J r.

$... L. a.... ..a. .... t ; c,. 4 ;,. s .a. >.......3 g...,. I l n I \\ t .._ _ _ f s 2 i: 5-i i g j ___.._,_.._.q__.._-- g n [- -x 1 \\ m s t...s v s es..e s s.e e s 3 .a .s. ...,.... ~ ~ d *.'.. : ~ di M 00182 760629 r ADOC4 05000206 P OR, s \\'

p 6 i / 0 c? 9 ~7(., i e / e i g

  • n.

t.;. q.\\ s.

u. L.g T.f *A O

2 }. ,.,......a.2 4.C } .S.e... g. 4 g. 1 g g..' O fil i. C *t' C Y. ' '. 9, ',' i. '.'.'. ', 6. c.... i w.i...

g.... i } q...a r.

.. g. p., 9.. ~' .s .,,..,.J.,,,.t.e. g 1.., #. **.g .y . t '. d ' '. g. s.' '. 8 v e s c. '. w-.I '.....-.....* '6 o ". e.m e. l .e te.,.,r...- c v..c.. u.s. .1 p..., .,./.y.4 g g d (...se . t.. g. *...y . a,..,, g a.n,. f g *. p,i } e d 3 %.. t. _a -.. J.,. n .3' ... e,,g 1.. 3 f..._. o....,.,, s..._..i. - i.. . t. .s.. ..........3t. 3, 3 3,,,.. 1 i.g t.an: to the rue:cr s. m1 r. :-Ics vc. tid to :.:. out'the neck of i 6:irsd. !a 1, :a.1 that thase cerc :hs e,vertier.s for t/.tich t.asvers cr .'tu : fi::ll;* n:. ed, 0.2 questica.ut c.sks that a C.: nite d enslysis 5 7n:. *d e..ao rs.-Tet,, pr:. cs c s :.n ru -.:.te d ISI inste:d. t ::r.l. :::l, U;.1:5 Of th: r,vss: tea.*:t wo:v h:r.?:d cut r.t ths r.;ctir.c. '!: r.. red : M. c: :. :: gr.up that, in l'.cu of e.asectin; the questic.s, l ... 7.-.'.......,,,,e ..o ..,1_t.. c 3 r. .tt-..dva.

  • v,

. W.... c g,.i 3 4

v. i

.g fit 4' la.g. $f..C 4 T....r. ; ...., c.. c..... F.. - ("..., C ....,. C n g.g

e.. a..,*.t i } 4.tg.

t .e 0 E.. t. 4 3 4.... v s 4 ..r.. s. 1.1 s,. ...w.... ...g 1,w. A. ....,7 . s 3...?.-. e. .c.... 3 g.. ,s ...,..s ...v. s. ..r.. ......a... 3 c., i n* A.. g.,,g g o. .s m...'. S.g..t. s.., f..,.,k..g 4 .u.. .....t..J .c..s a... 3. ? L.. p.. .4. t... C. I ... o... F t i g...i.. 5 ' *.. 'T *.."'. ~... ' 1 1, I ". d '.* c '. '. '.. '.". *,.. '.' 4 crc in;.e.r. ters ?r ne:t i'l j f G Oivi:icn of Orcratir.; P.enctors i; ^ i6 ;' a .......-..,.s. l I . t g. .p ...ef,....,s

4. c......,1.,

I i 4 . y ;.,. 3.u l 0u.. { C:6.s: Tila.s (10 07.3

  • 1 Ee s din g S ub.i e :: File t

I ( t I 1 \\_ _ l l ! g.,.f... J.V ~l.... li ~. ., z. ! u S.,, ;...._,,. i.t.,a......, l 3 1 I .. ~ - ./.S.. g

.*.s.

. s. n.s...s.,... ...s a,e n.,s... w.... . w :w

i..

'...... g m u.."*i.,lgtinghov.5c Pl" o'7'"s j s i B. Grines i C, Knighton j e

1.'.ctar v:

B. Youngb1 cod 1.e:r.1 n':: li. ECSan

.C T!!::

E., th: sche D. Dunch J. Collins E. Crse j R. Boyd W. Kregor R. D01)nrd R. II in::s.an V. Stullo fl. Spangler H. Denton J. Stepp D. Skrwholt 1.. !!ulman R. Denbc T. Carter D. !)uYounn OR Pfl R. !!aveary S. Sheppard R. Fraley, ACRS(10) D. ) tor.s R. Todesco-O!(iE(3) OF.I.D K. Goller D tiisi.nhtjt Principn! Staff Partici?:nts I

v. tiooto T. B. Abernathy, TIC R. Vo11nct bec:

J. R. Buchanan, NSIC )!. t! rust W. Ga:>aill / P. Co1Hns C. !!citet es R. licusten Y. Spets R. Clark G J. Sto): K. r.nicl ~-

0. I'nrr N. But!ct D. Vassallo J. Kni);ht S. t'awlleki
1. Sihucil P. Check T. Novak
2. Ros toc:y V. Ecnaroya G. 1.ainns T. IppoM to D. IiC?dna

.G. l. car R. Reid I., Shao R. Bact 9

~ ' - - ~ ~ ' 1.IST OF ATTENDEE 1 ~~ ' ' ' ' ' ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l % PSACT0R \\~15SEL SUPPORT W.fTING '*557:NCHOWE OhNER$_ S "sy 25, 1976_ NRC i C Trs-rell L. Shso \\', Neonan T. Cc t. J. Stolt I C. Ftth1c R. Major E. Thro:n C. Hofnayer H. Shaw J. Hou R. Stuart l D. Neighbors I J. Wetmore P. Br.ranewsky i J. Knight iginthouse Electric Cors._ ~ T. Esselr.an D. Piller J. Chirigos E. Hughes

3. M,turer N. 31-dord Others Newton, Wiscensin Electric Power M., Stern Kirc:nsin Public Service 3.11berr.an, Northeast 1;tilities Sen' ice Comany
3. Masolf, Northern States Power D. Katers, Csrolina Power 6 Light Comany P. Kilkens, Rochester Gas 5 Electric T. Taylor, Public Service Electric

& Gss J. Gsbals, Cor,-enwestth EdisenD. Banister, Fouthern Ca .\\. Rabe, Portir.d Ceneral Electric 9

~ O PRESEllTAT10:1 Of PROGRfJI 0F AISI - TREQUEtiCY NID LOCAT10:10F E. T. liUG!!ES IftSPECT10:1, RELAT10tl TO SLCT10:1 XI DESCRIPT10:10F IETI:005 - IIARDWARE AVAlpBLE, IT45PECT10 1 E. T. I!UGl!ES TEC1:ll! QUES 11111 011 CNiCC USED FRACTURE P4CliAfi!CS D15CU5510110F Al5! PROGRN1 W.11. !WITORD 1 LU:"tARY JUSTIFICATION T. C. E55Ett:ATI i i 1 i t f i i i I i l l

I f l 8 1 ko) E l 'I X 'k,%a a 3 l N N4 f ,5ovfN T h9 s 5 4_j u [ _.) g I i o k ~]b ,i!!S il@p.g [ iMM$8j\\! /**! 1{ j$!!E; /. ' f,D" 'M< O n t 3 e m 8 s E r 8 E 3-if k 5 ww \\ Y at x EC O i I ~ ~ - - ...ee-e -m - m T

~ inconel Buttering .,~ CS Norzie Type 310 SS og Forging \\ ////' %! !\\b 'l j l y .e L.A...e_./ . ann +m-d ID SS Cledding YYPO 4 Typs 303L SS Typs 309 SS 6 SS p e ',,':.. T f ype 31GL SS p oo .v ,-CSun,. c Y \\ .= 9991 2 r Y =.~.,... - s ^ j Mss ciseding ,g Type 5 O ~ .,.,,e e ee e4 e *.se e

  • 48W 98

s lWE 2.000.EXAlilATICf4 Af40 (14SPECTIOff Ta rL2 l',',3 2500 COI.'.PCN2.'4TS, P/..lTS, Afs'D 1.'.5THODS O? EXAfflN ATION E xa mination Cate : f jm Tayje C:r.p:ns;-tt and Parts o. h, a e:,0 3 to be Exam:ned Method s Rea:ter \\'er:st B1.6 EF Noz:It to safe end we'd: Velemetric tnd Surines CE0120 W-' G W 4 D e ge e -n- -w--,,.- y n--v- - - - -- - - --.+~--e w-w

l 1 l TAELE IWS P.500 (Cont) ip:AI4(NATION CATEGOR(ES Ar.EAS SU:rJ3CT TO 5):/.!!.! NATIONS E);YENT AND FREQUENCY O? E);Af.'.!NATICID l EF PP.ESSUP.2. P.ET/st:'th'G O!!SUllL/.R fl.ETAL WELDS I The crc:.: thall in:lvd3 dltalmilar metal wc!dt The examinations p:r,fermt:1 during et:5 l (e.g., t ft-:nd wsldt)*-li:tc. 2n comFnzti:r.s ins;t:ilon int:n:1 - sht!! eent ths of ctrbon, lav a.!!:y, or t.igh tentil4 sit:it and circumfertaco of 10% of the w:tda. l staintest atte!:, ni:t;e! ch : alvm iron alleys, c':t.g;. :pp,rr t!::yr. T.k: shtl! in::vda the tt:s materitt for, :t It::t, ens utt! O.i:':r,t:s 4 L.rer d the a:::: cf wild, (2514 !?!15 l l i l i I l O ~ , m yy,

1 l9 1 I i k8 i v I pc> u.MV i f v PRC.? CcSED :10 YEAR (NSPECTION i / UGl'.ENTED INSPECTION l SECTION XI 2 Celd Leg 100% cate;ory S.F 100'i et' story B.F 2 Het Le2 UT,PT Ph:t 31/3 yrtr UT,PT 2 C: J Leg 1C0% : ster:ry E.F 1 Oc::..d 31/3 yttr 2 Mct Leg 100% c:,utory B.F UT, PT UT, PT 4 Het Leg 100% category B.F 4 Cc!d Leg 100% c:utory C.F UT,PT Th!rd 31/3 yttr UT, PT i l i l t l l i i l l l 9 l , ev w y-.ww..

3 IN-SERV!CE [NSPECTlON TOOL FOh RUCLEAR REACTOR VESSEI..C \\o> ~w/ 1 1 l o b W6 WQ, .p, h 'hY' ' 9 p[d !/g[S..,M p r support shees f g;h A No en Reacter Internals 4

,y,,

,k .).i> - o / 6 'N o l.af \\ \\o I e.s -y

o' I '

n

on T J.~..

/o

.g o

,...b..%.. Y. '. $.. 5. '=>q'y u<..w;,. d,;.c,..9 &:A s.<. - .o A.y.0;. p.:.ofo,.p.de o.,0 p.m > :t.a:e.&. p-J G2.t d ' Qv i.n.c te.go..cpy % @9 L.%4a q]u o a .cefo.g;;c .:gg@8. ~d, _. fa / J&&bj@Q959:%'.*m.ei U) ( Q... y' c ' o:s

  • V.%
5D@
V'D w R ; D;&#Ch %$:0f.pj

&/

%%r:$qP V 47 o}'ge/J 9M.

o+t c: : ' w -e ?,(' i k'a g b 3 R: RM. h g9(4O - v v p g. ns nee.s;o..dqA a u t r x.

m! b.

s.o. w t m i.W,e.n pA.w.1 h.a #s = ,t.,oc.g.. 3 >.n:?.:Sy 1.) y,a .v..o.o a: 00. <.wm w' w9

  • . b Q

o M nr.s.c

  • S?LCIQf IntCfGCIS

' {' g,y r.. m o.s ,,. e ..n:c.. CCP.U!! Irr,r g;r t,t cf *C *l IN Hif G (P.0IZIt 09d Illng! I:Tantr) (sh'.; wing intunt't). P, h1 ;;g S';i thrc ;5 *.h3 P.07,II; C N nirit tr. tht iPtitrit?!. i l C f.I',' 'd: " L A r;;; ;; :: l \\g 1 I

g... ~ ~ .^ I I 6 ,.. ; c. -c, e..~.r 'qf:. ~,..,.'.~.;.* .) O .T ... ~,, - - 3.s.,r..s. i, n.

/ ', g hl 4,5 ),s.g..h..

. n i f.. r.t,.,.' .... b.. ,*k%?. t. t;t.,c. f ~\\^. s N... $.,. } I. N. x-Q,.

  • f4"\\lpp'

,...MY.'d. D;. . ' ~. \\ i. , % M,u m. ~ s" N n. ,~..:]**.97.r... ' ;. "'s

..~~...,..-.'.) " 's fiy.;f.',,'.;M.,,;il.u c

t l J L . m. <.v,.4.. .3 - ~, _, 0,.* ,s ,/ i.~, '.,, y.. s ,e - i ',j,. " T j i ./A. '.f 'k, l f r [f, ) ~j i o ,t .l. / .:i f,) ; ./.. .,l.. 4 i ..s / e' '] 'j ,N if,'1 ,jl i / ) ~ i p. I

).

w...

t..

~ / 1 O Eutt We!d Inspecticn Otvica in SwRI tcboratory Y- ,. p., ......-.._....-,..._..-u.,.w.,,. 7........- '. I tru.' o. n ~ N

,'/. s. '1.

\\ 3.l l. t.c.;. t.. <_x. n. l.>;'e,t._.. q ;1.cy..\\ s' +

m. u 1 i. '.' ;, ;',.

., '...f, 9 - a j/~ W'\\'\\.. t, \\ ) ,\\ f,. - t n, - :... '..o A,,5, ; '

  • t;,m 5..

.n. C f,. A. j '(;*y ll:&. '. ' ~ ? !'{ ~.

t
.-
  • -+

Y ', '

.'t...,-

J., E...;) l,*},'E..' t ;.,t'.' Q'

  • 1

' ~". # r4 ' yV f : j'\\,.,,,*r..- t../.*:: ,~.*r i%@. .} 4 r.% .,,w,. t,.c _. y, e .(.i ...s. t' a ,.t..,.. p.- < a. e .,s,c.t .t .s .-..M.......w-~ .y. \\ s ,.2 L_ (..- Zen.'.;M 1: :;;;Uca Ocvice in v. r.t Fuhshima (Icf t) cn:f Ate:hs (right) 0 v.e..d I

,,,n-

r-P I 1 .QJ GUTT WELD i!4SPECTIO!4 DEVICE l 1 s I f Th Fv.RI Butt Weid tr.src;'ica Ocvice it designed t: remuely Ms;t:t 6: re::!s.te.tsf a snd, tsfe end. t:.;:!;hr, ar.d pip!r.g hu:t s.* !ds on elmar pressurl:sd Mag r.u:'or p v,tr systerrt. Optrati:n of this (' c'tvi;t reqv. t; ths Ir.1:adst:en cf a tra:k, grntrs:ly @%e./A} c: 5: l t S

tr.'
*.tr,tiy me.r.u d ento the nort's er p! ping in 5.*i:t c:n b pit:td d tri to b3 in:;t:ud,The c:

y ent: c: tra:% 6:c:t minett:y cr ter.otely and esn t: ;::: 23 entirriy remotcly, f,'ormally, a modula c:nu:nir.; thre: citrieoni: transductrs is utilized, but g:vstal ether me dult are s','ailsbit fer ute in l

Wal t;;: tions. Also ynder devtfopment is a l

e3 r;!:'t! sda;ter that wou!ct attea remote liquid

. ntirant exam'nttica cf the ssfe er.d welds.

s Conceptual drawing showing optration of th: Gutt Wald Inspection Osvlet I SPEClFICATIONS 1 l i l Similar System Used fer Feint Es:ch 1 and 2 LaCresse (L ACBWR) San Csef te 1 Pilgrim 1 Peach Bottom 2 and 3 Rchinson 2 9C9123 Fukwshima 2,3,4, and 5 R.E. Ginna l Ate:ha fi:Ister.s 1 Cere :ti:wt Yanke ... snd cthers i l l \\ b- ...-.-.....--------**~--S . - -. ~. f

._.~.______..,-..;..y..__~-.__. n 7o l . h SliA(LAR & DISSl[AILAR IAETAL WELDS (l4 P(P(NG i., l i 4 1 d j, 'c 1 f Exam. Surf ace Profile of valve body, / ""0I" **I 'PU*E' ~ j AB connection i j .^ <--t - 1/2" 1/2" ')I l A,_ 'f - ,s 1. j_ h ).D f t C__,)_\\/;)_ l Y Y l lb )- A. ) _ 'J l <- t 1/3 t 1/4" 1/4" 9991 17 Er.am. Vol. :- M t C.D.5.F ficm, pip: ti:e 4 in, and recter t ? 1 4 i 4 i 4 ....._ ~ l ..w,.~. ..r

J+

~ 4-4.LLOW/:3f.E PLBR AR Ih'DiC ATIOIG t ': ttrist: Austeniti: stects that me:t the requirements of minimum yield stren;th of 35 rei cr less at 100*F tem;ntature. VOt.Uf.1ETRIC EXAf/,1!!ATIO.'! f.1ETHOD Y.' ail Thi:k t, {cchss,0.312 or less 1.0 2.0 3.0 Freservice Examination: 4 t;-a ct Surfsce Su' rurface Surfa:e Subsurface.Su rfs:e Cub s.,rf a c e Surft.:e Subsurface e c tio'. Indic.ttien Indication 'In dication Indication 'Indi:ation Indiestion Indication Indication a s i 1/ alt. % alt, % 3/ e/t, % alt, % 3/ a/t,% a/t, % 3/ a't, % alt, % 3/ l 0 9.4 9.4 3.5 8.5 8.0 S.O 7.G 7.6 ~ 0 :- 9.6 9.6 8.G S.6 8.2 S.2 7.7 7.7 , C10 9.8 9.8 8.8 8.3 8.3 8.3 7.8 7.3

  • 15 9.9 S.9 3.9 S.9 E.4 3.4 7.9 7.9
0 10.0 10.0 9.1 9.1 8.6

':.6 3.1 8.1 ' t ;5 10.0 10.0 0.2 9.2 S.7 0.7 S.2 8.2 030 10.0 10.0 9.4 9.4 8.9 8.9 8.3 8.3 C.35 10.0 10.0 9.5 9.5 9.0 9.0 8.5 i ,O 10.0 1070 9.7 9.7 9'.1 9.1 8.6 ( III ~ -- -7 T E ~ ~ 0 '5 10.0 10.0 9.8 98 L 9.3 9.3 S.7 8.7 0.50 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 9.4 9.4 S.9 8.9 Partice Examinstion: 0 11.7 11.7 i 10.6 10.6 10.0 10.0 9.5 9.5 C 05 12.0 12.0 10.7 10.7 10.2 10.2 9.G 9.6 1.10 12 2 12.2 11.0 11.0 10.4 10.4

9. 7 ~

9.7 0.15 12.4 12.4 11.1 11.1 10.5 10.5 9.9 9.9 0.20 12.5 12.5 11.4 11.4 10.7 10.7 10.1 10,1 0 25 12.5 12.5 11.5 11.5 10.9 10.9 10.2 10.2 0.20 12.5 12.5 11.7 11.7 11.1 11.1 10.4 10.4 0.25 12.5 12.5 11.9 11.9 11.2 11.2 10.6 10.6 0.40 12.5 12.5 12.1 12.1 11.4 11.4 10.7 10.7 0.45 12.5 12.5 12.2 12.2 11.6 11.6 10.0 10.9 0.10 12.5 12.5 12.5 12.5 11.7 11.7 11.1 11.1 1.' For intermediate f a n aspt:t ratios a T, and thickntsst", linear i..tr rpo!ation is permissible. 2 "t"is nominal v.all th:ckntil er actual wall thickness alifvivrmint:1 by UT examination. 3' The tots! ds;th ef suhtstf a: india.at!on is 2a. ggg 3,p .. - + + - - - - - - - " - * - ~ - " " --2.. r-

i t i ,.., +. ~ (m I i ALLOWABLE PLANAR INDICATIONS fl.='crish Aut.d.:nkic Nec.'s thst rr. set the. requiremen'.s of rdnfmum yia!d ' ettench of 25 hs!c ls:s d 100*F temp:rsture, r Sarface Examination t.'.t th o d Fressr.ics Extm. Nom, wall c.:chness indica: ion Length

c..

t in L' J, inches V 0.3 k 2 et less 1/8 1.0 3/16 7 2.0 1/4 3.0 a.d ov 3r 1/4 Inst:vics Exan ination 0.312 cr less 0.2 1.0 0.25 2.0 0.45 3.0 and ever 0.65 9991 21 e e ____-_-.._2- - _ _ - _ _ - _.. _ - - - - - - --.- A

p e l .m e-t

f n

c1 l C) I b l + l l Ne-1 se 5 o H t 2, e o a s 's.5 o -n w O C =, o = 1 -r vs xd U d e o e v= C .2 2 ~ .2 0 2 ~ es . A 4e %., p.** *

  • pr' g

d o' i l / e u n u ~;. - w O v sle g e W e ,1,;, cyj 3 o..._..____.__.. J>,, s d,. N. "8. S l em . =..= u

  • J
  • 3

.b X G5 5 ez= s-o c. e 3 l C:3 LS l l "U M"$ N 0 8 e / q r4 e t 4 e a e g F &=4 eees & *S* * ' ' ' * * * * **

s i O - -... - ~.. 1 1 t i i } 7..r,.y 1 .e. . t..~i.

s..

t .r.. g .... s. A,.. 1 I l . i,.s . i. i t I I 1. .%,, s.". i. 1 l .c. e l .... s .0 rw..

s. >. *.... s...,...,-...,

. a i .. - -............ a l L. l l .5' Shu r Yhv:. Thrc ;S r';;d f.httl I t I l .l I ( l-Jr.,..., l \\ i ,.t.r. . a t t t i. t '/. 1 i 1 's [t, \\. t .o s........,., ' - s d... e _.. s u ; s p .i 8 ...f j .--....-...-.2. t...-........

. ~,.* o..
g... ~..., t,..q...y.r.....,.,.u. g...t.,;

e.,.,d. 1. 0 I I I i O e-e... ee.. .e -eD* ...F. 6

    • F.*

'***9 g

1 m=.. s '.e' .f f. B. e

  • ' /'8.I.,)/.s f e.e s.t ;i

.? ,3 .g s'.- 4,

  • d

,r. .L 4 4 .j .g si .s 1 .f .) .4 s i k I t I ) g *. .[ g ' e .i.).t (s '4 /.' t5... i,w k ;l l / L y s...... %,.. w. s..,. s - L..._......~..'........_.._....._. .e.. ............,,,. a 4 45' Shsar Wsve. Threugh Sage Matti i .er . r.os rr.,... t t . ~!. -' e /.. ..I ,,, e i

  • 1 p

l i., l

o..'

4 'l i r .\\ r .n..,L........t.i......... ...... ~ _. 40 '5' F.cfrt:t. l.e,C. Wtd Thre;h E::2t/.itti

e. e..e.1 2 3 9

1 i e e e . __ ~_.-

.) } l 1 i r............._.... r 1 t c u/,'., .,1. .j. l t t i ..i;. ;.a t.. t t e 1

w *.,, o I

r W "isUi. ~.. , rY ~;~ Jf.'C j '/ U <,, 3 i I ) P. ..g.8 i w" ', .. g e -l i J ) .i .. a. I 4 !.1 i '.. :.). I r ! 't a s I.: W.., s i..... w I s..,. l s S. s./~' l e 1 3 i .o; .,...,. c....., > ... s. l _..a ..... ~ I i t.5'shtar V!tvs Through Bus fi.ctal j h I i i I 4 i !9 y t~ = ig/ [ y. I a,.,4,(/. 4' #

  • /.,: :

l j / t t .a l i i t i d I s i 4 l 1 4 i I h>l,........\\..n _. t. _t......, s.)t...... _ e ..~.,........__..s_A....., .e t .....e...~. I 1._. / 3.'5' Rett tet. t.cr.c. Yh.c. Through sess.Y.s:ct gpg129 i 1!S .i I s-D g

-. _ - _.. -. - - - =. 1 4 ) l f' 1 i Tut Dirc: tion 4 4 t a 8 l 1 t =2 - 20% Feti;.: Crack 't r ] l t t t l 1 ,i 8 i t t i f....._.........-.....--------~~~* l i 9, i 1 1 i -1 ft t

i 1

s-i 1 j i ( [ e L j 1g .I I'\\, .'\\ -..../ % -; i / %.. ?.j i ..... /. ,..r../ :.w.,..-y - u.~ 3 I .,; p. ..e-i ...;...........---...~~..----.--.-" i A 2 + 4 b i RL.UT Responta from "crt:k"Semple =2 right to left C99114 4 1 l 4 Y 4 i al@ 4 -...- n W 1 W,----- T M*W* M M w--w & m. 9p 4

l l i I i I i ..a Test Dirc: tion t g /. r-i 610%. Fr.tigu: Crack =1 { ,4 I 1 i 4 I n 4 l 1 I r l a ~ I a, 1 i, i. 1 3 \\ \\ N...,..,../lh, 'I \\. '\\. \\

n..,sN...

,.s...... ~..--..-u..-~...~,_r.w. r ~... r.. ~.:.' ~ -. 7 -..r L. l-12 RL.UT F.e:;onss from "crack" Sempts #1 right to kit S291 11 i 4 I I i 4 I 1 ~ ~ ~; --- '** - ~ ~ ~ ~ ' ~ ~ ' ~ ' .a l -~~ .. ~. --##W'8'"'WWNwr y up oww

l l I / s / i. i / .on / A 5 / i. u.- f / V =. ~ / c o a. l A ( _ ~... c / ,. p c. . ': s. S c, 0 4 i

g. o I

e' 9 e i \\ FAT wa. Cn Ac t< Geww ?; / la l tf \\ucoua. Gon.. i: '. i / G is t A. ENVir.c NMti4T i' 7.G - Goo F : a i i g. o 75 F g'. f..... _:._i _....__. _ L... / e" . c.oo n ";,;'j';.! / .I u.u

t. x a s s.)

I ....,.i O ..,..i..../ 4 .l t I ) I $'., f u !.'4'i E* 4 V.w Fue e c. Qusea SK 6ei G.') L--.

-1 l 1 I 1 1 3 .i .i s s l

b. s.,

i \\ 0 t o(. i fs .g. C .s Q 0 o t J oo. 'c g .s J so - ~. N e 00~ 4 c :s /. c c.o.. c a sg~ a u v rgs t 4 o,r: p I 4,, - u ~- .n c. p* 4,3 t,9 j 6 0 c. j... o <.!. e a c,# .v U U I g.J.*

  • 1, Q

.Li . T. . c. t g a, w. .g.,, l 2 ....... l... :..... i. .Q. u-F c n s u a Q.u.cn Greuna 3 6 O C . )..:.i -. i 18'o 334 t.hjb 344. : 57/*'%. D. i . e /.. r-i 1, rf.* p.( /Jft GNVIP.CS.tA'5.NT. ; [.. i (I' ". 50 0 C:7.,C P ' L V. x (?. t.,) ...r.... .t i i -e rC 1. 07.14 t o n4 r5 ; - t. 3d, ...;.... ;.... a J...' .f

.,. g,,

t, z,s. a l,ggy. q %..t.+....6..,'}s g ..,i.. 4 .j g 4 4 gn-p;,a ...3 a c: c. -...........,. g.. g t L. y.c: .49 33?!I.. J 4.} ,...,. i I 1,,.i,.y... l n* T f a,,I s / i. a *,, y,..h,e. .e.. t., i-

i

_.......... p. p ,...,.. [. /,: . e, p.. '....... :.p.... i

p. "

j,.....: . - i. i,;

;.g.g ry.;3.;..j.,..

-........ 3, e I t i 1 ,6 + (..t. ',. t*{

r. 4 *
  • d ' '

l 4 .t e .....,i... i i .......i.....:. r .-..........-.1 i t 2 ,i i. i

l..l... J.

4.. j .g i ,. i I, 4 i f I p. ,e ID I;O 1,..., .. C.,.., p....,. ./, p ( t:s t s'*.-) ...i <r ..w, j

........ :.: t, .s. e. s.s .[.j.! s s....-.n... I . t.. i....a. ,a..........<

j...

i. ,-...;. ip-.. ,Z'(3 - -.... ~..,. s ,.g- [ "- r --l l I : 6..__.... ..f.... ..I-.g.

7. 7.i -- H.g;a I

s ( l.j 3 ,_.,.. q...g.. / {; , 77"4 pl.3,.=;4 p.... .....l. 7 ;,.g.1. L. j - f... l.. e. "' l. -J .I ....4..6.

  • }
l. -

.8 Ie

    • d ~ h "...^=.;

.. j. 3., f., t ,3 o. t. t. 4 j 1

s. j g

.[ .....'.-i.4 i : !. ,... d.. li. !.. .s i. .. 3 ~. v..... -.. W _.y.. L., a. I . -. r. 7 f___,_........ .o ..i...._. . f..\\.... .7 ....a...... t. [e. . s.y s p-;, j -;. .i.. i: i ... l i. ,.._,.a-.,,. j.;,. I.

  • *,_j -

i -l. F .h,,. '. p. 4,. !, ! 1, e lE l I ( L_.!. l O

I 1

....t..'. i'M ' 4. ,li -i-... '-.., 1

  • r _ _;L -.I..$._-*i..
c.. L. i...

t. v ri, 4 w y r. .,.,. i,i i. A e ri .... p :.. ....l. t _....Y. _4.. m. l .o....!.. i ... /. p..

4. x.
.t....
:

J. . j c' 3 p,, t L.l..... [....j. ; -h ..;j X. . x. g ,,c q s a'y lit -}. .../.. . a '

  • .). n.4. j[; ;g a i ;

.) 1 i t ..;.p i.; ' /.$ p' ..y,,. ; f. ... {...;. m...;.. '... t jl;. fi. I' 6

1.,, _ j..,.

t y i. j A i g G .L.. g ...l. !... ~,.. l. '. E- ./ . ~.. ' ; '.:'A ..4 4 4 y i. J 4, e,,, .q *4 li-h.o i ! t s. i i ! l o .pe.o 3,. [.,.,, . n.. i i* p.. 3.')5 .....t s I. n. i. .l. ......i..... o ,....-.n..3-.... ,...s. ' d..,j...,.K. /.. g. I, ' A lO' h,L. 3 i,.. . % &.Ir p ...j.. p. q.,... l i L ..4 1..!.. .m t,) J. 1 ..-. }_..i... .. g. 4... l-.1 g, .'J. .1

1..!

.d. ] .,J..,..., ..9 i ),#r )1...$p QS $ ./ ._.._..f._ I.. 4. '.. 4, g 1 l* 7% ,. 7 y .i ...l.., ... ;. t.,9v.g.. f.wn,,@ gm,1:. 4 a ), ..._. l.. ;.., i l i : i... .. i 1 I, '4 . S,s. o...M., d.1 3.. . s .1

i...i e

.a g...i.,.. % v ....._j..,. g l-. ytj.i ). h '.. :t.......s.ua. m..s..a,m. mA i 8

  • I ll l

F I ........ 4. u. n W I l x m. N' E!., i, Mt. I e i

  • l, 8

p 1-i. 1 l :I ' 3ok d dc N Y.,.... !i . p l.@.'. n .,..4..I -..l .t .i .J ' l ..4 . M..., .4

f. o 'm' '.'.. t. o o', t 4' 3.y.:..',

p._ . r..... ":..-. '4..3 t ' '. ' t... a'. . 0, '. -. ; i .. I...'.j.1,...l +,' ' ij.i.. y a n H o.. p d r__ 4.. g _ H.,g.ipi, <. 7. 3,. q. .. i. __._..___7.,... ............,...,....r...., 1.. i. l. ~ .I d. i 1.,... Ii, g:,< 1 g a ,..** l -. I'.j 4 ...j 4 g. . l j$ 1 .t i ...[.... i. e .I I i l 1 1 t /.8 ..,....f j 1 7g !i / \\ .........i.!.! i i .f.

4. t j

2 v } t ie t s ...i.,. o no x Rmo. 6k ( @T m. ......~.- 5 4 m i h e,. m Pie;te. -V

'AT l GUE Qiu K bR0WTW Ps G.SUCf 3 TY PI C. AL No nt ti SAFE FND RsGioN = \\ W m At Po tvo t AT E.r; PLAW GROWTH F t.u w Du>vn 3 n Az u 4 w.Ans D w. An s 60 ei..t O. too .O. (00

0. i OO 0.\\00 0 i '.

o. 2.co 0.20t o 2.01 0.202 0 2C' O.sco O.koi 0303 0.305 0.32 0.400 o.403 0.405 0 4.oh 0.4LC 0.500 0505 O Soc)

0. 5 ( '5 0.5 c:.c; o.'10 0 0.110-0.'722 0737 0.rj a 4

PO ST U L A.*T E D FLAW C o tS lC, U P, AmO W

^ g... N ZE101G & FORTIAANN DATA 100 304 STAINLESS STEEL (nEFEltEpCE 12) e a ? g 6 O ~ S 4 asC 2a M-j g" -r-{ 3 1 L I E = 0.4 (o p ' "UTS O i y 2 1 \\, n pt i 1 1 io

, O t

i I I I I I I 10-1 2 3 4 5 6 7 g 100 2 3 4 g 7 3 10 10 1 = af }l(t l ? i

4 E'

[. ll' 53 v.msn N<uinalitt:tl C83<i L P"il re.irsu..i. d F..alc :e St's: I ? i

l i I o V.,

  • l av ww w

inD ~ 8 %.' s 6,- I x 1 N. H <: L ^s s o pn u = 2t \\ u C i3 N r. a.. \\ 2 -: ~ ~ f,*'s (,i.'% l' '$..r h?'s ~ -7 2 r. ' . --,.}<f. y,s.1 l r e l ~i. ',..,)

. = INTERNAL FP. ESSURE

.j _ _ _l I I 3r-, 100 2 4 G 8 101 A = t/ fRT / .... -...........,,...r..

n....,c..., g 3 ;

.i s. S.

-l 1 J-NTEGR AL AN AL'/ SIS d-I tJTEG R P,L. o l l / ) J / IC = i i j / i I j [ i / / O ,/ o/ Ib ,/ Ic, , v, 1 I l_.. \\ _. ,.. _\\.,. _,, __,, _l.,

  • e -.

vs'. Cel,.- h, {', -.Q, .. n ... _.........,.,d,C s g ,,,, {, [,,

- r
....,.,..,,

\\..(g g,f, 4 it- it. ...<..i4. J

.-,m, ) 14003 o RADIAL \\ 12003 ^ /

)

I 7,j, S / 2oy 1 'o:03 / O \\ I I o O .I e:. j id C000, - [ / O AXt AL & .J z (' CIRCUMFERENTIAL O n Q t

  • Lt s

j / / .d. (333 k l D/ Oo ... I,~, '/ w LEGEND: j [ k,-f O O 2T-CT AXIAL

  1. 0'O

~ \\/ O 2T-CT CIRCUt.*iFEF.E.!TI AL 7 JIC = 4000 61T-CT RADIAL [3 [ j JlC =4300 1033 EL/ ju / l l l l 0 0.00 0.10 0.20 0.30 040 0 50 CR ACI' EXTENSIO!J.h (INCHES) CMi*'03 ' Fernd 304 Siciniest Steel. G2001 .lC

V a 14.0;3 --~ =-- LEGEf;D: x O 27-cT Axi AL \\ 0 2T-ci ciacut,',FERENTI AL C'30 l,' l '0:33 Og tn./\\_.2 er / 2.. y a / g c:a 3 l O ri O Q f / E ( e c::: i-< n / I~T / O Q / i.e 3 o

l. a

./ ( JiC "2003 2.33 -/ ~ / r i l 0 0.03 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 C.', ACl; 3) TENSION Ja (INCHES) , ; D: :rt.i:,tc.i:.. C:-t 2iC C;:. int::: S:::t G f ?? F OU -}}

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20196H325&oldid=4111682"