Text

Forwards Resumes for Listed Applicant Witnesses.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence
	ML20154Q262
Person / Time
Site:	Braidwood
Issue date:	03/18/1986
From:	Kruse G; ISHAM, LINCOLN & BEALE
To:	Guild R; BUSINESS & PROFESSIONAL PEOPLE FOR THE PUBLIC INTERES, GUILD, R.
References
	CON-#186-467 OL, NUDOCS 8603210093
	Download: ML20154Q262 (24)
	v • d • e

.

. gELKIED_ CORR 979E@

u ISHAM, LINCOLN & BEALE

f COUNSELORS AT law DOCgiED THRE E FIRST NATIONAL PLAZA TELEPHONE 312 558-7500 '86 MAR + 20 t1i.l :00 EDWARD S. ISHAM. 1872-1902 1120 C E TCU A NU . N W LIA G EAL 1 1 3 WASHING D C 20036

' ' *2"o March 18, 1986 Robert Guild, Esquire DOCKET NilMBER BPI 109 North Dearborn Street PROD. & UTI L FAC" * * * * * * *** **

Suite 1300 Chicago, Illinois 60602

Dear Mr. Guild:

Enclosed with this letter are the resumes for the following applicant witnesses:

1. Joseph R. Vannier

2. Randall L. Kurtz

3. Michael R. Dougherty

4. George F. Marcus

5. Larry J. Koch

6. Ernest B. Branch

7. Richard A. Donica l

Applicant has previously indicated the subject matters about which these witnesses are to testify.

! Truly yours, a f 'b W Gary . Kruse GAK:sb .

i

Enclosures I 1

cc: Attached Service List hso 3 G603210093 86031B PDR G ADOCK 05000456 PDR L _ ___ _

SERVICE LIST I e Herbert Grossman, Esq. Mr. William L. Clements Chairman Chief, Docketing and Services Administrative Law Judge United States Nuclear Regulatory Atomic Safety and Licensing Commission Board Office of the Secretary United States Nuclear Regulatory Washington, DC 20555 Commission Washington, DC 20555 Ms. Bridget Little Rorem i

117 North Linden Street Dr. Richard F. Cole P.O. Box 208 4

Administrative Law Judge Essex, IL 60935 t Atomic Safety and Licensing i Board United States Nuclear Regulatory Charles Jones, Director l Commission Illinois Emergency Services j Washington, DC 20555 and Disaster Agency j 110 East Adams

Springfield, IL 62705 a , Dr. A. Dixon Callihan

Administrative Law Judge i 102 Oak Lane William Little, Director' Oak Ridge, TN 37830 Braidwood Project Region III Stuart Treby, Esq.

United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission i Elaine I. Chan, Esq. 799 Roosevelt Road i Office of the Executive Legal Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 Director l United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Janice A. Stevens i Washington, DC 20555 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission i Atomic Safety and Licensing 7920 Norfolk Avenue Phillips Building l Board Panel Bethesda, MD 20014 i United States Nuclear Regulatory i

Commission

, Washington, DC 20555 George L. Edgar, Esq.

i Thomas A. Schmutz, Esq.

3 Newman & Holtzinger, P.C.

'. Atomic Safety and Licensing 1615 "L" Street, N.W.

Appeal Board Panel Suite 1000

. United States Nuclear Regulatory Washington, DC 20036 i Commission l Washington, DC 20555 I

i t

a k

,f Ni

! DOCKETED UNITED STATES OF AMERICp %RC NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND In the Matter Of: )

)

COMMONWEALTH EDISON COMPANY )

) Docket Nos. 50-456 (Braidwood Station, ) 50-457 Units 1 and 2) )

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Gary A. Kruse, one of the attorneys for Common-wealth Edison Company, certify that copies of the Letter to Robert Guild from Gary A. Kruse dated March 18, 1986 have been served in the above-captioned matter on those persons listed in the attached Service List by United States mail, -

postage prepaid, this 18th day of March, 1986, unless other-wise indicated.

J' _,/

/. . / A/lt' o"A

- yy1.Kruse

ISHAM, LINCOLN & BEALE Three First National Plaza Suite 5200 Chicago, Illinois 60602 (312) 558-7500 DATED: March 18, 1986 i

1

N[ SERVICE LIST l 1 Herbert Grossman, Esq. Mr. William L. Clements Chairman Chief, Docketing and Services Administrative Law Judge United States Nuclear Regulatory Atomic Safety and Licensing Commission Board Office of the Secretary United States Nuclear Regulatory Washington, DC 20555 Commission Washington, DC 20555 Ms. Bridget Little Rorem 117 North Linden Street Dr. Richard F. Cole P.O. Box 208 Administrative Law Judge Essex, IL 60935 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board United States Nuclear Regulatory Robert Guild Commission Douglass W. Cassel, Jr.

Washington, DC 20555 Timothy W. Wright, III BPI 109 North Dearborn Street Dr. A. Dixon Callihan Suite 1300 Administrative Law Judge Chicago, IL 60602 102 Oak Lane Oak Ridge, TN 37830 Charles Jones, Director Illinois Emergency Services Stuart Treby, Esq. and Disaster Agency Elaine I. Chan, Esq. 110 East Adams Office of the Executive Legal Springfield, IL 62705 Director United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission William Little, Director Washington, DC 20555 Braidwood Project Region III United States. Nuclear Regulatory Atomic Safety and Licensing Commission Board Panel 799 Roosevelt Road United States Nuclear Regulatory Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 Commission Washington, DC 20555 Janice A. Stevens (For Addressee Only)

Atomic Safety and Licensing United States Nuclear Regulatory Appeal Board Par.el Commission United States Nuclear Regulatory 7920 Norfolk Avenue Commission Phillips Building Washington, DC 20555 Bethesda, MD 20014 George L. Edgar, Esq.

Thomas A. Schmutz, Esq.

Newman & Holtzinger, P.C. l 1615 "L" Street, N.W.

Suite 1000 Washington, DC 20036

f 4

l,1 RESUME JOSEPH R. VANNIER TITLE: Senior Level III Q.C. Engineer REGISTRATIONS: Certified welding inspector by the American Welding Society (AWS-CWI certificate No. B0061541).

Certified Level III by the American Society For Nondestructive Testing (RT, UT, PT, MT) certificate No. HA 786 (MT certificate expired).

Certified Level III inspector Sargent and Lundy Visual Welding, NDE and Vendor Surveillance (Mechanical)

Former Certified Level III inspector NDE, Visual, Mechanical and Welding by The Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company (Corporate Level III, acting).

Former Certified Level III with Blaw Knox Foundry and Mill Machinery Company, Crane Company, Great Lakes X-ray Service.

j Former Certified NDE Examiner Navships 250-1500-1.

Former Member, Board of Directors, Chicago. Chapter, ASNT 1954.

RESPONSIBILITES: Mr. Vannier is loaned to clients by Sargent and Lundy to serve on their staffs as a Senior Level III and Senior Welding Inspector. Mr. Vannier serves as arbitrator in third party decisions.

Mr. Vannier is responsible for the review and verification of client and contractor quality control, welding inspection and NDE procedures. He witnesses and overviews tests and inspec-tions and evaluates the adequacy and completeness of the tests performed.

Mr. Vannier reviews documentation in order to insure compliance with applicable codes, standards and specifications. !

)

qi I

EXPERIENCE: Mr. Vannier has 37 years experience in the inspection, quality control, and quality assurance fields. During much of this time he was in charge of moderate to large sized inspection groups and has trained, certified and supervised dozens of inspectors.

From May, 1983 until the present, Mr.

Vannier has served as a loaned servant Level III third party welding inspector arbitrator for Commonwealth Edison at two nuclear power plants.

From April, 1981 until May, 1983, Mr.

Vannier served as acting corporate Level III and certified welding inspector for Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company at their nuclear power plant. During this time, Mr. Vannier developed Level II and Level III training and certification programs and procedures. He trained and certified approximately 60 inspectors.

He also developed numerous quality control and quality assurance procedures.

From June, 1978 until April, 1981, Mr.

Vannier worked at Sargent and Lundy as a quality control engineer developing a training program, doing vendor surveillance, as well as writing, reviewing and veri.fying quality control and nondestructive examination procedures.

From June, 1977 until June, 1978, Mr.

Vannier worked at Blaw Knox Foundry and Mill Machinery Company in East Chicago, Indiana as chief radiographer and super-visor of NDE training and certifications.

From June, 1973 until June, 1977, Mr.

Vannier worked at Crane Company, Chicago, l Illinois a producer of nuclear valves. l l

Mr. Vannier was chief radiographer, radiation safe.ty officer and navships 4

250-1500-1 examiner. )

I l

1 i

)

'1 From 1959 until 1973, Mr. Vannier owned his own testing and inspection company, Great Lakes X-ray Service and served as manager, Level III and supervisor working for clients such as Commonwealth Edison Company, Peoples Gas Light and Coke Company, Natural Gas Pipeline Company of America, Northern Indiana Public Service Company, Illinois Power Company and others.

From 1948 until 1959, Mr. Vannier worked for Industrial X-ray Engineers and its subsidiary "INOX Corporation," a testing and inspection company, serving as supervisor and eventually manager.

i l

1 q

i 4

4 i

1 1

l, y.' SARGENT & LUNDY Resume Randall L. Kurtz l

Title Supervisor, Project Section Quality Control Division Education Purdue University - B.S. Metallurgical Engineering - 1976 Certification Certified Welding Inspector, American Welding Society Responsibilities Mr. Kurtz has overall responsibility for the supervision of all project section personnel. He establishes and monitors compliance to the quality assurance / quality control (QA/QC) requirements of the assigned projects. He also provides technical consultation and administrative direction to project section personnel. On assigned projects he assists in developing the scope of work and man-hour estimates for quality control, supervises the assigned Divisional personnel and monitors the quality of their work, and is responsible for the on-the-job training of Quality Control personnel.

Mr. Kurtz conducts training sessions and seminars on various Quality Control topics.

E xperience Mr. Kurtz has experience in all aspects of quality control in 8 power plant work at increasing levels of responsibility. He has progressed within the Quality Control Division from QC engineer to QC coordinator to senior QC coordinator and is now the supervisor of the Project Section. His work has entailed review of radiographs and nondestructive examination procedures, vendor surveillance, review of specifications, evaluation of vendor bids, review and dissemination of supplier procedures, Quality Control audits and surveys, training sessions, and coordination of these activities by personnel assigned to him. He is qualified to ASNT-TC-1A Level III in radiographic testing, liquid penetrate testing, magnetic particle testing, and ultrasonic testing; is certified as a Certified Welder inspector by American Welding Society; and is a member of Sargent & Lundy's Structural Welding Committee.

Before joining Sargent & Lundy in 1976, Mr. Kurtz worked as a procurement inspector at another major power plant engineer-constructor. He performed vendor surveillance inspections, preaward commodity surveys, and postaward nuclear audit work. He was qualified to ASNT-TC-1 A Level !!

in radiographic testing, liquid penetrate testing, magnetic particle testing, and ultrasonic testing.

D 97L 343 022M 6 f

R:sume 2 cf 5 SARGENT & LUNDY Randall L. Kurtz Memberships American Society for Quality Control American Welding Society Edison Electric Institute's Metallurgy, Piping, Welding, and Corrosion Task Force Publications " Cost Effectiveness of Vendor Surveillance inspection," Ninth Annual National Energy Division Conference, American Society for Quality Control, October 1982

" Flaw Detection and Assessment for Nuclear and Fossil Power Plants," to be presented at the American Power Conference, April 1986 9

970,MS 3

022586

SARGENT & LUNDY Sei.ct d Experienc3 Record 3 of 5 R ndall L. Kurtz h

(s Power Plant Design Projects Rated Gross Operating Assignment Station - Unit Fuel W Date(s) Client Assignment Date(s)

Schahfer 18 Coal & 393 1986 Northern indiana Coordinate all 2-84 to present Oil Public Service QCD activities Company Narble Hill 1,2 Nuclear 1175 Cancelled Public Service Coordinate all 4-76 to 1-84 (each) Indiana QCD activities Gibson 5 Coal 618 1982 Public Service Coordinate all 5-81 to 2-83 Indiana QCD activities Power Plant Betterment Projects G Rated Gross Assignment Station - Unit Fuel W Client Assignment Date(s)

Gallagher Coal 150 Public Service Quality Control 1985 to present Indiana Specialist for ,

plant life ex-tension project Eastlake 1-3 Coal 125 Cleveland Quality Control 1985 to present (each) Electric Speclafist for Illuminating plant life ex-tension project Powerton 5,6 Coal 828 Commonwealth Coordinate QCD 3-84 to present (each) Edison Company activities Michigan City Coke / Coal / 652 Northern indlana Coordinate QCD 3-84 to present 2,3,12 Coal & Gas (total) Public Service activities Company Wabash River 1-6 Coal 886 Public Service Coordinate QCD 10-82 to present (total) Indiana activities B

970,345 022586

SARGENT S LUNbi seicctsd E,pecienca Record 4 o' 5 Randall L. Kurt:

Power Plant Betterment Projects, Continued Rated Gross Assignment Station - Unit Fuel MW Client Assignment Date(s)

Mystic 6 Oil 150 Boston Edison Metallurgist - NDE 1985 Company Level III for Iife extension project Mitchell 4-6 Coal 138 Northern indiana Metallurgist - NDE 1985 (each) Public Service Level 111 for life Company extension project Susquehanna 1,2 Nuclear 2097 Pennsylvania Power & Prepare b aring 1985 (total) Light Company specifications Trainino Experience Assignment Topic Client Assignment Date(s)

Visual Weld Acceptance Commonwealth Edison Conduct training 1986, 1985 Criteria (NCIG-01) Company Visual Weld Acceptance lilinois Power Company Conduct training 1985 Criteria (NCIG-01)

Use of visual Sargent & Lundy Conduct training 1984 examination equipment Training of weld Commonwealth Edison Deve r sp and imo'ement weld 1984 Inspectors Company inepectIon training p. g.am Training of weld lilinois Power Company Evaluate training program and 1984 inspectors recommend improvements Materials and power Sargent & Lundy Conduct training 1984 plant construction 9

970,345 022586

, Sele:tsd Experience Record 5 of 5 ,

SARGENT & LUNDY a,no,ii t, gor,, t 4

Training Experience, Continued Assignment Toolc Client Assignment Date(s)

Liquid penetrant Sargent & Lundy Conduct training 1982 testing Quality control Sargent & Lundy Conduct seminar 1982 overview i

S l

9 970,345 022586 9

. i j i 4 n j i RESUME FOR i j MICHAEL R. DOUGHERTY i

PERSONAL: Born August 28, 1948 6'0", 200 lbs. Married Excellent Health Two Children r

l l EDUCATION: - Indiana State University

- Portland Cement Association - Nuclear Concrete School l

Portland Cement Association - ASME Level II Certification Carboline Nuclear Coating School and Inspection Certification l

PROFESSIONAL LICENSES / CERTIFICATIONS: Registered Professional Engineer (CA)

ANSI N-45.2.6 Level III PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE:

]

1984 to Present Braidwood Construction Assesment Program, RSCAP Supervisor j responsible for the review and assessment of eleven (11)

} significant corrective Action Programs. Supervise staff of six (6) Quality Engineers.

BCAP Training Coordinator responsible for training and training documentation for all BCAP personnel.

1980 to Present Walsh construction company, Corporate Quality Assurance Manager responsible for development and implementation of Walsh Quality Assurance and Quality Control Programs at various project locations. These programs were approved for work under ANSI, ASME III Div. 2 N-Stamp, ASME Div. I,

and DOE CQC Requirements.

1973 to 1984 Walsh Construction Company, Quality Assurance Manager, ,

LaSalle County Nuclear Station responsible for development I and implementation of Quality Assurance and Quality control Program for Civil / Structural Contract for Walsh and j Subcontractors. Trained and certified Level II

, Inspectors. Nuclear Security Administrator responsible for I

development and implementation of Walsh procedures for access control, background investigation, psychological profile testing. Walsh representative for NRC security inspections.

Page 2 - R2sume for Michul R. Dougherty 1970 to 1973 Walsh Construction Company, Quality Assurance Engineer, Zion Nuclear Station responsible for inspection of post-tensioning shop and field operations, vendor audits and surveillance, concrete placement and inspection, resteel placement and inspection, nuclear coating inspection, and documentation. Also responsible for the preparation and qualification of Welding Procedures.

1968 to 1970 Field Engineer and Office Engineer responsible for drawings and specifications interpretation, checking for compliance of pre-concrete placement with design drawings and contract specifications, placement card sign-offs for release of concrete, quantity take-off, and drawings and specifications control.

i I

3/3/86 1

4 RESUMEOF GeorgeF.Marcus EDUCATION: Bachelor of Science Electrical Engineering, Illinois Institute of Technology - 1953 Masters in Business Administration (Honors),

University of Chicago, - 1963 PROFESSIONAL: Registered Professional Engineer - State of Illinois Member - In_stitute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers EXPERIENCE: (Commonwealth Edison - June 1953 to Present) 10/30/85 Assistant to Manager of Quality Assurance Assigned to the Braidwood Nuclear Construction Site. Manage personnel responsible for quality assurance activities required to prepare for License Hearings. Also, responsible for oversight of site quality assurance activities associated with construction and start-up of the Braidwood units.

5/20/85 Special Assistant to Manager of Projects Assigned to the Braidwood Nuclear Construction Site. Supervised team which performed analysis of various aspects of construction work to determine status and effectiveness.

2/17/75 Director of Quality Assurance (Engineerina/ Construction)

Assigned to the General Office. Managed Quality Assurance personnel assigned to the LaSalle, Byron & Braidwood Nuclear Construction sites. These personnel performed audits, survelliances, and oversight of construction and startup activities. In addition, responsible for supervision of the site Independent Testing Contractor which performed civil and non-destructive acceptance testing of construction work. (NOTE:

From Feb. 1984 to May 1985 directly responsible for Byron and functionally responsible for Braidwood.)

Responsible for Q.A. Coordinators who performed quality assurance activities in the Station Nuclear Engineering Department. System Operational Analysis Department, System Material Analysis Department, Purchasing Department,.and Station Mechanical Engineering Department. Also responsible for audits of off-site vendors performing work for nuclear stations.

3/18/74 Staff Assistant to Manager of 0.A.

Worked on the developw nt of the Quality Assurance Program and establishement of the department to perform quality assurance for construction and engineering of the Edison nuclear power stations.

4 10/16/72 Fuel Agent Managed Fuel Department which was responsibic for purchase of nuclear and fossil fuels for the Edison generating stations.

10/04/71 Distribution Planning Engineer Managed the Planning Sections of the Distribution Engineering Department. Responsible for planning the electrical distribution system from 138 kv down to 12 kv and the 480 volt network system. Responsible for procurement of transmission substation and system distribution transformers.

6/03/68 Distribution Deslan Engineer Managed the Design Sections of the Distribution Engineering Department. Responsible for the design of the 138 kv transmission substations and design specifications for the distribution system and equipment. Responsible for procurement of the electrical distribution system equipment.

. 11/02/66 District Superintendent - Crystal Lake Managed a district office which included the following responsibilities: overhead and underground electrical construction, meter reading, field engineering, customer service, municipal relations, and marketing.

1/17/66 Supervising Engineer - Chicago North Supervised a section of engineers who performed design of the I

overhead and underground electrical distribution system from 12 kv down to customer utilization voltage for the north third of the City of Chicago.

6/22/53 Various Engineering and Staff Positions Worked in 10 different assignments most of which were involved with the planning, design, and operation of the electrical distribution system from 34 kv down to utilization voltage.

(NOTE: From November 1953 to November 1955 was on active duty in the United States Army Signal Corps, assigned to the NATO Headquarters in Paris, France).

PERSONAL DATA i Harried 4- Hlfe: Aloma Children: George, Jr. (19), Paul (17), Julie (15)

Residence

! 324 Maplewood Lane Crystal Lake, IL 60014 97450 3 - . , , --- - . , - , - ,-~_ , ,... -. ,,.--~ r--._.m.- m- -

. o .

c,

( RESUME LARRY J. KOCH PERSONAL: 8030 South Neva Burbank, Illinois 60459 (HOME) 312-599-0984 (WORK) 815-458-2801 Ext. 2349 DATE OF BIRTH: 11-14-58 .a Single, Excellent Health Willing to Relocate EDUCATION: Moraine Valley Community College Palos Hills, Illinois Associates Degree in Applied Science for Non-Destructive Evaluation Reavis Community High School Burbank, Illinois CERTIFICATION: Certifiable Level II in accordance with N45.2.6 for Visual Weld Inspection, Mechanical Inspection and Document Control Certifiable Level II in accordance with ASNT-TC-1A (June 1980) for the following Non-Destructive Evaluation:

Liquid Penetrant Testing Magnetic Particle Testing Ultrasonic Testing Industrial Radiography Certification of completion for the American Welding Society in the Fundamentals of Welding Inspection

[

EMPLOYMENT: PULLMAN SHEET METAL WORKS, INC. (HVAC)

Braidwood Nuclear Power Station Braceville, Illinois May 1980 to Present QUALITY CONTROL COORDINATOR '

Responsible to the Quality Control Supervisor for assistance in the coordination and direction of inspection activities.

Interface with Quality Assurance, Engineering and )

Construction personnel to resolve and/or clarify quality concerns related to quality activities. In addition, responsible for performing and documenting training sessions, as necessary, to assure all Inspection personnel are trained to the established procedural requirements.