ML20154P673
| ML20154P673 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | West Valley Demonstration Project |
| Issue date: | 03/18/1980 |
| From: | Regnier E NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS) |
| To: | Haughney C NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20154P653 | List: |
| References | |
| TASK-TF, TASK-URFO NUDOCS 9810230041 | |
| Download: ML20154P673 (2) | |
Text
)
sg s.
a e...
~
s.
-G p.,
p g
' g:;;g:[=.
MV 4
j $(,
,Q
~
fg.
J-
<r.
.. ~
v-1 3.:: l 1
c
. =.
=
q;=u;; 1 c
.', e. ' -- : _~ ', '.
!!AR 18.B80 m_..__t
_=
. +.. u. s
- =.w...
-..:, s..
. u..:... v...
- f. q :.
9
, ; i. -,..
s MM '
7.
d:e..
MEMORANDUM FOR:
Charles LJ. Haughn'ey
~
J..
'l ^
Advanced Fue.l and Spent Fuel Licensing.
~
- I..%~,.
>::==.
T.... FROMil.
Edward P. Regnier 1
. J d..
- c.
High-Level Waste Licensing'.c.t:-Management Branch d - Y '";76 6 Ml b.3@24 -
w
' 'c:..
4 Js
-9;Mi;:X:0...
- %;M."....L il y E__ M__ 6T.?'? 9 9.'s. '...:,
m.. - #.. ~ '
J.-.,.t. ~
- RL
, sy.z;. 5UB..J. E_CTF._WN'..' ANALYSIS OF AMENDMENT NO.1629 TO 7
1... 5Y.C....l i
-r-y
.M.
1; 2
% e.c.e):.c#n.4:
VAKLEY. WASTE. SOLIDIFICATION)m-i. nk. V.:.94
.r i.3. :05.7 C
N
? ::.
..c.
- a..
m_. n -. w : c.
w 2.o. '
i
+lIgQ 7.Y-t.;:*' %:M.:,.. *...
NJD. '...
W.... 'Es-M.6-7.@/L?d 9.4 '.E;:.M i;....-75 W 5 7 1.. _
\\
~
g
~
.'J
' P:
fr,% p. As,.-3*?l'--i-D.;.you requested. I,have reviewed the. ' *il:.i).-;;'..v
- .g.lr."**
- 7.,::::= :*,5.'.~+-.,. '. *
- n-..
Q-.-%~
t*.-
~'.;-.;****
... ~
- 2. u/
.w.
.I w.
n subject amendm.ent-from a' waste?: 9 v..
h :1 9:iQ. 7sanagement perspective. 'The following comen'ts andTobser'vations-are?-r-
.W@:.J:?##l
, _., ; c. M.i. G S:. e
.W.l wi
- d'@
offered for use in your analysis of.the amendments 2.w..
=_
. = s..
'. x',m q.;-r.L : :
' :.%: " The amendment requires ~ transfer of-title:ti the liguid wastes to DOE-~a'n{.. -
"1
~
- t.,....- placesfres. ion's'ioility f.o.r s. tor' ages solidification, trirnypartationT a-nd dT4FosT,1 : n 'Ml t'ac;;;'~ upon DOE.,The amendment woul.-..... -.- _d provide that essential 1y all
...ll
. ~
'N g;pg.
of these operations be borne b The amendmentu. M'% ' hl
@:s ' requires DOE to carry out the' y.the federal. government.
above functions and jirofi~deT ali a'uthorization g
appropriated for subsequent years cannot be used until. DOE takes / titles.
E d of $5,000,000 for initial work in FY80.
It providiis-~that any fundkO
~
J dy'i.#
A M!@..to the waste 'mandreachesiontractual agreenents 'with the State of New., d 5;;7.ss,
.sia
. M '- York relievin' -the State of any significant~ financial responsibility; W #~ OB9':M
- %
- ri
- :-:%w. u.. g :....
T
.. a. #.. -* -
. F The amendment.ex
- . ;.. : v. :*N :.nm. +.L:;
~
-?
sa * *~ m * -
r;:E.R' authority..N: upressly disclaims having any effect on any HRC: licensing @
,m I
.~.,?
.. ' e 4.., -
- . g:
9l.M..J.is
/'l
- a=:
=G-
-.F h*. & ::;. % f
- r;% f::.
lf~.du
%i x.. ~ e..c m%.c.%--
~~
~~ '.w:w : 1
=
w w.a
..:. =..
.e:.
. ::.ir
- ~ '
W'%"
.-*4 s.~'
M E..;. -
While not expressly doing so, the amendment by implication may require the 7if.1 - DOE to make an immediate or near-tem delection.of the fom of th'e solidified' *
'W A Y ~ " waste penduct. This is of particular interest to;the Waste-Management...Didsion' -
b~
~ 1.'."
as such.a. requirement ~does not appear to bT.cond.is reflected in the Vivision's. sls.f.e waste disposal which was eisponsed by.the.IRG an
. - ~.
current draft regulations.
In particular, the sentence starting at.line 10, page & of the amendment reads:
.. 47
. M.:
v.
g
- f. -
?The secretary shall carry out the project by vitrifying the high-
. S : >.f Y ;,,.
..y..
level liquid nuclear wastes located at the. Center or by employing... -a..c.g 4
- e... '
'the most effective technology for solidification available?c...
.T..".:.,w u.
- m.,:.
..g
~ > - While ambiguous, as it doe's not'specify how or when the "most effective T.-
_D" y&y technology" would be selected, an interpretation that the technology should be selected imediately would be reasonable, expecially in light of the
~.
my 'e-deq wr./cyed b 'hc cacdat.
R U.e.. e h.; L ; L L i
-m?I* t ie ".most ef..f.et tive t..ec..h.nol ot y" appear.~to he acce"ntable alternat ves.
~c- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~-
~~ ~~ -- -
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~~~~~~~~-
~
,e--m >.
................................... - ~ ~ ~..
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -
~ ~ " ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~~~~~~"""~""
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
....n.u......eu.~nu u n. n e.. e. e... n... n.
9K.W
....... n. n. n..n.. e m.nu.............u......
" * * * " " ~ " * * " * -
I aan 9810230041 800505 PDR ADOCK 05000201
.O.
PDR 2
s; I...
~.
... @ #..1E..
-.. u n
.E i
N
, n>
o
- v.. :.
t,
.m....
v
~
" Charles J.~tughn2y.....
.g,8 7080 x.w x.
- 7
.~
L2-,
m
... g. :.
E Tbb reference to "long-tem burial" at a federal repository on Tage 2. line 25
( :.
.. 8 probably means disposal and would be clarified by using theword dispo, sal.
~ "
p.
~
} ~..,,'-The allocations of costs between the federal and state government is-.
M
=
susceptible of ambiguous interpretation. While it seems that the " appropriate -
"T.
ofee" to be paid by the state for perpetual care and maintenance (page 3, line 4).
J.;5.1 is distinct from the state's share of the costs of the project (limited to a
~
' maximum payment of 10 percent of the cost) (page 3, line 21), the inclusion of -
.,.. ', thh existing perpetual care fund.in the items to be credited against the state's
-i,
. his interpratation.e
-29, k.,.,..,W.= l b
..u h..-E. i?.u.. :..sh.ar.e. of...t.h.e.. c. ost. s o.f....t.he t pr.oject casts - dou t: on,.. t
.=:..,..%+.,.s.s.W,...&._.........
r...y
..*.,.,.~..,.~~.N
. _. r. l.._,.:
..Q..03t..:...
44,. i..i.....;.~.. ~ ".
s.., c.
- ".. m M-
.,.._..g,.h,.:s...,..,...,,..,..,.,.........
- 1. e..= a.
.....-' ' -l a a.: u.
.:.
- W'.j..? r.. r *.. 4 :n %...;h. r '......
.~
..z
-ta w-2..~.s.et..
.....?*
n y h ;. ~. *;* . %.' -
,,.,r,......;,
,.s..
. y : n.,::;_,,.,...
v.
,-w.
.......,a...,p.
s.
,,. g
.,7..,. ;.. ;.;
.p.,.p.,...........,y.....
yn ;,.,.,;
...,.v
.....,....a..:.;g...,..-7 s_,
.s.
... a.
m.. a;.
, %. > s
- ..v.
a
...g.
..,.a.
j~,.
- ,,.. a
- ,,,
,.3,...4..,;.,....,a.~,......
g.
..y.. _
s.a;.
.?.,..,
=.:~1.,.,..
..,w..
.s
.21,-,,,,=........m.,n_r.o
.s.
, g
,.-y 1
.....,;. z ;
,g,,
..e.
..y...;....
~*..,...
- s.. ; 4,,,r... :,..
.: g. v, ;._
s.
q
- v..
4
...'.s.
.~.
High-level Waste Lic.ensing....,.c:f
. tG. w
.v..-.
..:w
. s y:....._3 Edwar.d-P. Regnier..
- c, s
. :p.*..~.
v.-
,..., ~.
.s m.C,., :.
- e..c c&... -
4. ". E.... =.. c. -
l 9
e... :...
A..-
'.,g@.
.,.:..c. ;.f,8.,.mn.
.. m...
- m......
- s...... :.21. m. =.. '.., A...,q.
.cct
. i..;.a.:
. 9/f.;.7 -
- Manage, ment Branch....
c.
.. 2. _
.c r,..c.
w
.-. c..
..y
.. =..
....c..
.....,..c m ;. ;
.,.g*.
. u l
..6..,
...2.#
b.
-...J
..t
..u....,, i
....'.'t,. =.
.~
,u...,...:...
n:. 4.-u...
......,.;.7,...:.... g....,....,,a..-
-.,e.....
.... DISTRIBUTI.ON.
HMSS 800256 e,
,.=...w
?....^. WKriL Subject File.
- ^.
,l~ 5:- n
. a <_
....A..-
J-..
.a..-
. /.:.:=.:.1.u.... a ;. ~. n6. %. g. -,m r. :.. X. 3. WM rj.f (. s,t,.-
.:'y w*.
..m.,. d..
n
,....e....
v HMSS r f....
. s..,.,.
..... :,w...
.....z..
v,. m, r..
. m.. o.r..-
...A...
. /..n.. ERegni er ?. "_.
+
... ~..
.. s....
.... ~._ - 3Malaro..
.,y
- ..= ~.
a.
.m.._,.
.v
.....:, w.
.y
-. w.~.
m.
a.,._..
...,.., ".. ~... +
- ....... REBrownin.
-. =.
,....x.--
". n..
u
.u.
-..s-
.... =
- a.
.u
. : a..
+
..,..- ~.,,..,.. ?.
3BMartin..+.,
.:........../.,-..n.
~.
..s.
..,r y...,...
. ~..
.u.......
c....
.t.._.
ja)... ~...
l
. ~....,...
n
_...n m..=
m-.
- y, -
. k..
,.r.,.
.y
,f"'%,
Q Q Q.....*,.
........,a.
. 8.a.
.... g:...
.e.
.. _a....
...+..:...
~;
.~._a..
.r.n. s..
. s.
c.
.e
.y.,,.
s.
.. s.,
..q.
w
- .:a
..s
.. - ~. -
, r
. u z
., s.#
+;...,s....,...
.;=.--
w.
7
.u.... -...
.r
=
m.
._.,c..-.
w -
.s.
..-a
. ~..
. r.
[
ygg, 6
.mc+
...........u......
~
E.R.e..g n i.e..r..:..p.r.h...
.8..,.....o...............M.. & [pp.............
.e.c. o-
.. 3. J.1.../.8. 0.........
......*$Q.... S..O....
M.... 2. b.....'.......
.y w+
s'i
% ~ ~ ~n~~
-~um~~
ac rosa ye o.m uncu ono e
1 1f.v.
,.,m u.,.
4 g_