ML20154C535

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Comments on Proof & Review of Tech Specs,For Consideration in Developing Final Draft
ML20154C535
Person / Time
Site: Vogtle  Southern Nuclear icon.png
Issue date: 09/02/1988
From: Bailey J
GEORGIA POWER CO., SOUTHERN COMPANY SERVICES, INC.
To:
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
Shared Package
ML20154C537 List:
References
GN-1483, NUDOCS 8809140400
Download: ML20154C535 (35)
v • d • e


Text

r -

Geo'Q a Naef Cornovy Fbst Off c: Du 282 W:yeescoro. Georg a 3c;30 1e e&cco 404 554 9%1 404 724 8114 Souteern Cortpa y Sery ces Inc Nst Off.co Box M25 Bengham, Aabama 35202 b

re.erxe rcs .'" "

Vogtle Project Septembe r 2,1988 U. S. Nuclear Reguistory Cornission Logt GN-1483 Attn Document Control Desk Filet X7N16 Washington, D.C. 20555 NRC DOCKET NUMBER 50-424 CONSTRUCTION PERMIT NUMBER CPPR-109 V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT - UNIT 2 PROOF AND REVIEW TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS Centlement We hsve reviewe.1 the Proof and Review copy of the combined Technical Specifications for Vogtle Units 1 and 2. Enclosed are our comments for your consideration in developing the final draft. The comments consist mainly of eittorial co m ents, the incorporation of Unit 1 Technical Specification (

amenleents c~1 change requests that are anticipated to be approve $ in the near future, ani the ad11 tion of Unit 2 specific information relative to heatup and cooldown rates.

The encionures inciule a brief description and justification of each proposed I chsnge to the Proof sni Review copy. Since some changes involve more than one page we are also including a table thst lists each page on which we proposed a change anl the justifiestion applicable to that page. The enclosures incluie a list of open items that we have yet to provide to the NRC. ,

The enclosures are t (1) a list of chsngel pages and the justifications for the changes, (2) a list of items to be providei later, and (3) markel-up Proof and Review Technics 1 Specification pages with figures.

Sincerely, i

J. A. Bailey Project Licensing Manager JAB /si Enclosures xet list sttache1 l 'f

, oc k

\ b FDR S'S09140400 ADOCK Gr000 m

S8090('

s4

r U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Consission September 2, 1988 Page 2 xc3 NRC Regional Administrator NRC Resident Inspector P. D. Rice J. P. W ne R. A. Thomas B. W. Churchill, Esquire J. B. 11opkins (2)

G. Bockhold, Jr.

R. J. Goddard, Esquire R. W. McManus C. K. McCoy R. P. Mcdonald Vogtle Project File

(

1 1

16047

Geors'4 PDwee Comoeay .

Poet Ott<e hos 262 Werettora Geor94 30430 Woohcee 4*A SM 9961 404 724 4114 Soutrem Company $ ewes. Inc.

Post Ott<e Son 2625 Beruqum. Alabama 3$202 ve-e 2es m. "

Nh PW September 2,1988 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Lost GN-1483 Attnt Document Control Desk Filet X7N16 Washington, D.C. 20555 NkC DOCKET NUMBER 50-424 CONSTRUCTION PERMIT NUMBER CPPR-109 a V0GTLE ELECTRIC CENERATING PIMI - UNIT 2 PROOF AND REVIEW TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS Centlement We have reviewed the Proof and Review copy of the combined Technical Gpecifications for Vogtle Units 1 and 2. Enclosed are our comments for your

, consideration in developing the final draft. The consents consist mainly of editorial comments, the incorporation of Unit 1 Technical Specification j amendments or change requests that are anticipated to be approved in the near future, and the addition of Unit 2 specific information relative to heatup and cooldown rates.

The enclosures include a brief des.ription and justification of each proposed change to the Proof and Review copy. Since some changes involve note than one page we are also including a table that lists each page on which we proposed a change and the justification applicable to that page. The enclosures include a list of open items that we have yet to provide to the NRC.

The enclosures aret (1) a list of changed pages and the justifications for the changes, (2) a list of items to be provided later, and (3) marked-up Proof '

, and Review Technical Specification pages with figures.

I Sincerely,

! 9 4. My J. A. Railey Project Licensing Manager JAB /ss Enclosures

, set list attached l

O i l

11. S. Nuclear Regulatory Coesission fleptester 2,1988 l Page 2 j i

4 f xc NRC Regional Administrator  !

NRC Resident Inspector  !

4 P. D. Rice i J. P. Kana R. A. Thomas  !

3. W. Churchill, Esquirs  !

J. 3. Hopkins (2) i I

G. Rockhold, Jr.

R. J. Coddard, Esquire j R. W. McManus i C. K. McCoy [

R. P. Mcdonald  !

Yostle Project File l 6

i I

t f

h l

l i

l r

i f

f l

9 1

l 1604V j l

1

l

{

ENCLOSURE 1 TO 12TTER GN-1443 i List of pages with proposed changes and justifications.

Change Pages Justification to i IV 3 3/4 3-10 1 VI 1 3/4 3-11 1 VIII 5 3/4 3-13 3 x1 1 3/4 3-14 )

xv1 5 3/4 3-15 1 XXII 2 3/4 3-20 1

]

2-2 20 3/4 3-21 1, 4

l 2-3 1 3/4 3-25 13 25 1 ,

3/4 3-30 1 3/4 0-4 1 3/4 3-31 1 1

3/4 0-2 1, 11 3/4 3-35 1 j 3/4 1-3a 3 3/4 3-40 1

3/4 1-3b 3 3/4 3-44 13 3/4 1-3e 3 3/4 3-50 19 3/4 1-33 3 3/4 3-51 1 3/4 1-4 3 3/4 3-52 1 3/4 1-6 1 3/4 3 -54 1 3/4 1-7 1 3/4 3-56 1 l 3/4 1-11 3 3/4 3-57 1 l 3/4 1-12 3 3/4 3-59 1 i 3/4 1-16 1 3/4 3-40 1 l 3/4 1-18 1 3/4 3-61 1 3/4 1-20 1 3/4 3-42 1 i 3/4 1-21 1 3/4 3-46 1, 19 j 3/4 1-22 20 3/4 3-49 1 3/4 2-1 1 3/4 3-72 1, 19 3/4 2-3 20 3/4 3-74 1 3/4 2-5 20 3/4 3-76 1

! 3/4 3-3 1 3/4 3-80 1 3/4 3-6 1 3/4 4-3 1

l t

l ENCLO8tRE 1  !

Pase 2 t I

3/4 4-5 1 3/4 7-21 1

[

3/4 4-6 1 3/4 7-24 20 3/4 4-10 1 3/4 7-28 1 . l 3/4 4-16 1 3/4 7-31 1

}

3/4 4-21 15 3/4 7-32 1 [

3/4 4-22 1 3/4 8-1 1 I 3/4 4-26 20 3/4 8-2 1 3/4 4-30 5, 1 3/4 8-5 1, it i 3/4 4-31 5, 16 3/4 8-6 1 3/4 4-31a 5, 16 3/4 8-7 1 3/4 4-32 5, 16 3/4 8-9 1

[

3/4 4-32a 5, 16 3/4 6-14 19 3 /4 4 -34 5, 1 3/4 8-21 8 I 3/4 4-35 5 3/4 8-22 1 f 3/4 4-35a 5 3/4 8-23 1 I 3/4 5-1 3, 1 3/4 8-24 1 .

3/4 5-4 12 3/4 9-14 13 L 3/4 5-10 3 3/4 11-1 1 3/4 6-3 1 3/4 11-2 1 f 3/4 6-7 1 3/4 11-3 1 .

3/4 6-8 17 3/4 11-s 1  !

3/4 6-11 1 3/4 11-9 1 f 3/4 6-12 1 3/4 11-10 1

[

3/4 7-1 1 3/4 12*3 1

3/4 7-3 1 3/4 12-4 1 j 3/4 7-8 1 3/4 12-5 1 j 3/4 7-14 6 3/4 12-5 1 i 3/4 7-16 6 3/4 12-9 1 3/4 7-17 f

7 3/4 12-10 1 3/4 7-19 1 33/4 0-4 1 I

l

ENCLOSUILE 1 l Pane 3 l

l 83/4 0-5 1 5-6 1 33/4 0-1 1 6-1 2, 1 33/4 1-3 3, 1 6-2 2 53/4 2-2 1 6-3 2 53/4 2-3 20 4-4 2 33/4 3-3 3 6-5 1 33/4 3-4 1, 14 6-4 2, 10 B3/4 4-7 5, 1 6-7 2 53/4 4-8 5, 1 6-S 1, 2 33/4 4-9 5 6-9 2 83/4 4-9a 5 6-12 2, 1 B3/4 4-10 5 6-13 2 33/4 4-11 5 6-14 2 33/4 4-12 5 6-20 1 33/4 4-15 5, 1 6-24 2 53/4 5-1 3 6-25 2 33/4 5-2 3, 1, 12 Title Page for 1 Bases 3/4.6 33/4 6-2 1 33/4 6-3 3 33/4 7-1 1 B3/4 7-7 1 -

83/4 8-1 1 83/4 8-2 1 ,

33/4 8-3 1 53/4 9-1 3 5-2 20 5-3 20 5-5 9 9

i e

t 3

ENCLOSURE 1 l

Pase 4 t

JUSTIFICATIONS FOR CHANGES TO PROOF AND REVIEW DRAFT

1. Description of the channe L l D VI Change "Loose-Parts" to "Loose Parts".

XI "Change "MOTOR OPERATED" to "MOTOR-OPERATED".  !

2-3 Align the margin for Equation 2.2-1 over the word '

"where".

2-5 Cha nge " y, " to " > " .
3/4 0-4 Remove the page number and plant identification from the.

title page for Section 3.0 and 4.0 and move the title i page to the front of Section 3.0 and 4.0. i i

3/4 0-2 The period after "common." in 3.0.5 should be outside  ;

the quotation mark.  ;

j 3/4 1-6 To eliminate confusion for items that have two footnotes [

one indicated by

  • and the other by **, replace the **

l with d. (The **" and "**" look like * ***" in some v cases.) i

> c 3/4 1-7 Insert "and" af ter "72*F" in Specification 4.1.2.1.a. [

This is consistent with 4.1.2.2.a. '

i 3/4 1-16 Adjust the left margin of line six such that the word "Pressure" begins beneath the word "Break" j

3/4 1-18 Replace ** with f. See justification for change to

,page 3/4 1-6. t 3/4 1-20 Replace ** with f. See justification for change to l page 3/4 1-6.

3/4 1-21 Replace ** with d. See justifiestion for chanse to I page 3/4 1-6.  !

I 3/4 2-1 Replace ** with d. See justification for change to L page 3/4 1-6.  !

3/4 3-3 Align table entries for Table 3.3-1.

(

l l

[

t i

L ENCLOSURE 1 1 pane 5 i

1. Description of the Change (Continued)

M

. 3/4 3-6 "Under voltage /under frequency" should be "undervoltage/underfrequency".  !

j

3/4 3-10 Remove the extra space from the column headings and correct the l alignment for the table entries for functional Unit 12. p

, 3/4 3-11 Change the dotted line to a solid line to separate the footnote from the remainder of the page.

3/4 3-14 Eliminate the space between table notations (16) and (17).

  • 3/4 3-15 Move the word "where" to align it under the word Equation and
reduce the space between "Equation 2.2-1" and the first ters of I the Equation.

i

3/4 3-20 The hand-marked *'s on functional units 4.c and 4.e should be  !

j typed, align "loop 2" in functional ueit 4.c. j 3/4 3-21 The hand-marked "*" on functional unit 5.c should be typed. I i 3/4 3-30 This page was inadvertently omitted from the Troof and Review l copy. A copy of this page is included for convenience, i I I

3/4 3-31 Change the location of the i to appear after 18.5% for items l l 6.b.1 and 2.

1 3/4 3-35 Align sargin for the table notations.

I 1

3/4 3-40 change the location of the ** to appear af ter "High-High" for

ites 5.c.

) 3/4 3-51 Align "(basemat)" beneath the word "Unit" in itee 5.a.

3/4 3-52 Align "(basemat)" beneath the voed "Unit" in ites 5.a.

l 3/4 3-54 Delete the spurious mark E. j

! l 3/4 3-56 Delete the "LP" from ites 3 of Table 3.3-7. [

! 3/4 3-57 Realian entries in the table, f

1 3/4 3-59 Realign lustrument numbers. [

3/4 3-60 Realign entrant in the table.

k

_~r

ENCIASURE 1 Pase 6

1. Description of the Chante (Continued)

Page 3/4 3-61 Delete the "s" from "requirements" and capitalize letters as indicated.

3/4 3-62 Delete the "s" from "requirements" and capitaltre letters as indicated.

3/4 3-66 Realign entries on Table 3.3-9.

3/4 3-69 Realign entrant in the table.

3/4 3-72 Realign entries on Table 3.3-10, 3/4 3-74 Insert "the" between "if" and "inlet" in ACTION statement 4.9.b. Add a period st the end of table notation f.

3/4 3-76 Realign entries to Table 4.3-6.

3/4 3-80 Realign entries to Table 3.3-11.

3/4 4-3 Change "50 'F" to "50'F".

3/4 4-5 Change "50 *F" to "50*F".

I 3/4 4-6 Correct indentation of Specification 4.4.1.4.2.2.

3/4 4-10 Align margin in Specification 4.4.4.1, 3/4 6-16 Capitalize "specification".

3/4 4-22 Align "V0GTLE UNITS - 1 & 2" with the left margin.

3/4 4-30 Delete the spurious statement "FIGURE 3.4-2".

3/4 4-34 Insert "Specification" before 3.4.9.3.e in two places and change

3/4 5-1 Move "gallons" to before the parenthetical statement and relocate periods in 3.5.1.b r.nd 4.5.1.1.a.2).

3/4 6-3 Add "ani" af ter ites d.1) and change the coms: to a period after ites d.2).

3/4 6-7 Move the word "location" such that it is directly above items a, b and c. ,

l

ENCLOSURE 1 Page 7

1. Description pf the Change (Continued)

U 3/4 6-11 Insert "Specification" before 3.6.1.7b in ACTION statement b.

There is no apparent need to hyphenate the word "isolation" in 3.6.1.7a.

3/4 6-12 "La" and "Pa" should be "L," and "Pa " in Specification 4.6.1.7.2.

3/4 7-l' Move "Specification" to the next line to avoid confusion of 4.0.5 with 4.7.1.1.

3/4 7-3 center "Valve Number" over the appropriate section of Table 3.7-2 and add a period af ter the abbreviation of inches.

3/4 7-8 center the title above the lef t-hand column in Table 4.7-1. ,

t 3/4 7-19 Replace "** by "d" to avoid confusion due to two footnotes on the same item in Specification 4.7.8.b.

3/4 7-21 Relocate the "+" in the equation in Specification 4.7.8.e.3).

3/4 7-23 Change "B305" to "B003" and adjust the spacing of the column in Table 3.7-3.

3/4 7-31 Capitalize "specification" in ACTION b.

3/4 7-32 Change "3/4.7.13 (Continued)" to "PLANT SYSTEMS (Continued)".

3/4 8-1 Move "of fuel" from af ter the parenthetical statement to before the parenthetical statement.

3/4 8-2 i should be a superscript.

3/4 8-5 i should be a superscript in ites f. the word Specification should be inserted before 4.8.1.1.2 in footnote e, and .007%

should be written as 0.0071 in footnote d.

3/4 8-6 Correct the spelling of arachronized.

3/4 8-7 8 and di should be superscripts in ites 7).

3/4 9 9 Delete the underline from the word "and" in the footnotes.

3/4 8-22 Add " " between Motor and Operated in the title of Table 3.8-1 and indent the phrase "ACCVS outlet Header" in the table.

l 3/4 8-23 Add "(continued)" after Table 3.8-1. Add "

  • to Motor-Operated.

e ENCLOSURE 1 Pete 8 _

1. D,ese_ription of the change (continued) 7.81*

3/4 8-24 Add "(continued)" after Table 3.6-1. Add " " to Motor-operated.

3/4 11-1 Adjust the margin of the ACTION statements. l 3/4 11-2 capitalize "Waste Vater Retention Basin" in Table 4.11-1.

3/4 11-3 Indent the second itne of the definitions of equation terms in Table 4.11-1, table notations.

3/4 11-8 Add an "s" to Specification in ACTION b.

3/4 11-9 Add V0GTLE WITS - 1 & 2 and the pafe number to the bottom of the page.

4 3/4 11-10 Correct spelling of "omitted" and indent the second lines of the definitions of equation terms in Table 4.11-2.

3/4 12-3 Add V0GTLE WITS - 1 & 2 and the page number to the bottom of the page.

3/4 12-4 Add V0GTLE WITS - 1 & 2 and the page number to the bottom of the page and adjust the entries of Table 3.12-1 to align ur3er

the headings of the columns as marked.

3/4 12-5 Add V0GTLE UNITS - 1 & 2 and the page nusbar to the bottom of l the page and adjust entry of ites 3.c as marked. '

3/4 12-6 Add V0GTLE UNITS - 1 & 2 and the page number to the botton of i the page and adjust entry 4.c as marked.

3/4 12-9 Add V0 m .E "NITS - 1 & 2 and the page number to the bottom of the page.

3/4 12-10 Add V0GTLE UNITS - 1 & 2 and the page number to the bottom of the page.

33/4 0-4 Delete page number as this is the title page for the Basos for  !

3.0 and 4.0 an.1 delete the unit designator at the bottua of '

the page. '

B3/4 0-5 Delete tha page number and delete the unit designator at the bottos of the page.

EHOIASURE 1 Page 9

1. Description of the Change __(Continued)

S*K*.

33/4 0-1 Adjust the margin for this page. t 53/4 1-3 Change FtH to F2H under 3/4.1.3 ites 2.

n3/4 2-2 Change toF{H in the title line for 3/4.2.2 and 3/4.2.3 33/4 3-4 Insert the word "ani" between "instrumentation" and "corresponding" in Bases 53/A,.1.3.3.

33/4 4-7 Adjust the subscript of "1gg" such that it doesn't overlap the line below it.

B3/4 4-8 Capitalize Ef fective Fut' Power "ears.

B3/4 4-15 Change "10CTR50" to "10 CFR ! 0".

B3/4 5-2 "rT2 should be changesd to "2t 2 ,

Title pate for Bases 3/4.6 - Delete unnunhered page entitled "Basea for ft tion 3/4.6".

B3/4 6-2 Change "each" to "the" and change "el.3" to "c.1.3" in Bases section 53/4 6.1.6.

B3/4 7 1 Adjust the astgin of the definition of"SP" and "V and add a period at the end of the definition of Y.

33/4 7-7 Adjust margin of the title for Bases Section 3/4.7.13.

B3/4 6-1 Chaute "V0GT1.E-UNIT 1" to *V0GTI.E UNITS - 1 4 2" at the bottom of the page.

B3/4 8-2 Change "VOGTLE-UNIT 1" to "V0GTLE tNITS - 1 & 2" at the Wttom of tt page.

83/4 6-3 Change "V0GTLE-UNIT 1" to 'VMTLE 1 NITS - 1 & 2" at the bottom of the page.

3-6 Add V0GTLE UNITS - 1 & 2 and the page nuriber to the bottoa et the page.

6-1 capitaliae "Senior operator" and place the "d" synki as a Jupe rsc ript.

6-5 Change "not* to "no" in footnote **.

I

l ENCLO.M 2 't Page it. _

1. Description of the Change (Continued) fagg 6-8 Add "Yinal" between "Vogtle" and "Safety Analysis Report" in item e.

6-12 Add a period at the end of 6.4.2.8, item 1.

6-20 Change 3.3.3.10 and 3.3.3.11 to 3.3.3.9 and 3.3.3.10, respectively, in Specification 6.8.1.4 Justiff. cation for the Changes These changes represent editorial, format, spelling or is ntar changes that de not alter any requirements.

Pages Idfected See the Description of the Changes for affected page numbers.

. a om

ENCLOSURE 1 Page 11

2. Description of the Change This change incorporates Amendment 6 to the Unit 1 Technical Specifications into the Proof and Review copy of the Cosbined Unit 1 and 2 Technical Specifications. This amendment replaces organizational charts with more general organizational requirements.

Justification for the Change This change has been approved for Unit 1 and is also applicable to Unit 2. The change is consistent with NRC Generic Le'tter 88-06, "Removal of Organizational Charts from Technical Specification Administrative Control Requirements," issued on March 22, 1988. Additional information concerning the justification of tre change is found in Georgia Power letter SL-4752 of June 1, 1968 to the NRC, that requested the change, and in the :(RC letter of July 11, 1988, that issued the change.

Pages Affected XXII 6-8 6-1 6-9 6-2 6-12 6-3 6-13 6-4 6-14 6-6 6-24 6-7 6-25 0

4

- _ . = _

ENCLOSURE 1 Page 12

3. Description of the Change The Proof and Review copy of the combined Technical Specifications is revised to show changes to the Unit 1 Specifications that are applicable to the se and operating cycle of Unit 1 but are not applicable to the initial operating cycle of Unit 2. These changes incorporate different Moderator Temperature Coef ficient requirements, RWST Boron Concentration requirements, SHUTDOWN MARGIN requirements and high flux at shutdown alarm requirements.

Justification for the Change The Unit 2 requirements have not chan;ed, they remain the same as those approved for the initial operating cycle of Unit 1, which are described in the FSAR, addressed in the NRC's Safety Evaluation Report, and currently reflected in the Unit i Technical Specifications. This change to the Proof and Review Copy of the combined Technical Specifications incorporates changes only for Unit 1, second operating cycle. These changes were requested by Georgia Power Company letter SL-4682 of May 19, 1988, and are currently under review by the NRC. These changes are proposed to the Proof and Review copy of the combined Technical Specifications in anticipation of their approval for Unit 1.

pages Affected IV 3/4 5-1 3/4 1-3a 3/4 5-10 3/4 1-3b B3/4 1-3 .

3/4 1-3e B3/4 3-3 3/4 1-3d B3/4 5-1 3/4 1-4 B3/4 5-2 3/4 1-11 B3/4 6-3 3/4 1-12 B3/4 9-1 3/4 3-13

ENCLOSURE 1 Page 13

4. Description of the Change Add a footnote to page 3/4 3-21 that states:

"* See Specification 3.3.3.6" Justification for the Change The "*" is already placed on the table on page 3/4 3-21 but the footnote to which it refers was omitted. This footnote does not include or alter any requirements of the Technics 1 Specifications. It alerts the reader to the fact that the instrument to which it refers appears elsewhere within the Technical Specifications. This cross reference is made in a '

similar manner for other pages of this same table.

Page Affected 3/4 3-21 e

ENCLOSURE 1 Page 14 _,

5. Description of the Change Add specific references to Specification 3.4.9.1 to address separate heatup and cooldown curves for each unit. Revise Figures 3.4-2 and 3.4-3 to apply to Unit 1 only and add new figures for Unit 2. Add a new Figure 3.4-4b to address separate PORV setpoints for Unit 2 and revise Specification 3.4.9.3 accordingly. Revise the Bases for 3/4.4.9 to explain the reasons for separate Unit 1 and 2 heatup and cooldown curves.

Justification for the Change ,

None of the Unit i requirements have changed. The heat ap and cooldown curves for Unit 2 b3ve been developed using the same critercia and methodology as was used for Uait 1. The Unit 1 curves are not applicable to Unit 2 because the Unit 2 material has an initial RTNDT which is greater than that for Unit 1.

Pages Affected VIII 3/4 4-35a XVI B3/4 4-7 3/4 4-30 B3/4 4-8 3/4 4-31 B3/4 4-9 3/4 4-31a BS/4 4-9a 3/4 4-32 B3/4 4-10 3/4 4-32a B3/4 4-11 3/4 4e34 B3/4 4-12 3/4 4-35 B3/4 4-15 I

ENCLOSURE 1 Page 15

b. Description of the Change Change 80*F to 85"F in Specification 4.7.6.a, and 850 CFM to 1500 CFM in 4.7.6.e.3.

Justification for the Change These changes were requested for Unit 1 by Georgia Power letter SL-4685 of May 19, 1988 and issued as Amendment 9 to the Unit 1 Technical Specifications by NRC letter of August 17, 1988 It raises the allowable control roes temperature by 5'F and increases the required pressurization flow rate in conjunction with the removal of portions of the partition betwcan the Unit 1 and Unit 2 areas of the control room. Since these portions of the partition will be removed prior to Unit 2 licensing, the change had to be made initially for the Unit 1 Technical Specifications.

The Unit 1 Technical 3poeification change also included additional requirements (in the form of footnotes) that apply only to Unit 1 and only during the period of time from the removal of the control room partition until licensing of Unit 2. Those footnotes do not need to be included in the combined Technical Specifications, because they will no longer be applicable af ter Unit 2 is licensed.

Pages Affected 3/4 7-14 3/4 7-16

0 l

ENCLOSURE 1 Pase 16

7. Description of the Change Provide a space for insertion of Unit 2 Piping Penetration Area Filtration ard Exhaust System flowrate in Specification 4.7.'/.b.l.

Justification for the Change This value is to be provided for Unit 2 following completion of system preoperational testing.

Page Affected .

3/4 7-17

?

F o

}

9 9

f I

t

=,e--.---e --w, , , , . . - ,_ . , .

ENCLOSURZ 1 Page 17 I

8. Description of the Change Delete "during shutdown" from Specification 4.8.4.2.c. ,

l 1 l Justification for the Change Some of the overload protection bypass devices can be tested at times other than during shutdown. This change was requested for Unit 1 by Georgia Power Company letter SL-4737 of June 7, 1988 and issued as Amendment 10 to the Unit 1 Technical Specifications by NRC letter of August 24, 1988 and is also applicable to Unit 2.

Page Affected 3/4 8-21

}

1 I

J

ENCLOSURE 1 Page 18

9. Description of the Change Insert "Unit 1" af ter t'ae fi st word of Specification 5.6.1.1. Delete Specification 5.6.1.2 and ren taber 5.6.1.3 and 5.6.1.4 accordingly.

Replace "west" with "'Jnit 2" in Specification 5.6.1.2 and change 2.4% to 1.13% in 5.6.1.2.a. Delete "west" from Specification 5.6.1.3.

Justification for the Change The current project nomenclature for the spent fuel pools is to refer to them as the Unit 1 or Unit 2 spent fuel pool instead of the east or west spent fuel pool. The criticality analysis for the Unit 2 spent fuel storage racks has been resubmitted to the NRC in Georgia Power letter GN-1479 of August 12, 1988. The revised uncertainty allowance changap from 2.4% to 1.13% for the spent fuel racks in the Unit 2 spent fuel pool. Specification 5.6.1.2 was deleted because it was a duplicate of the information provided in Specification 5.6.1.3.

Page Affected 5-5 i

d I

a 9

1 1

ENCLOSURE 1 Page 19

10. Description of the Change Change "Appendix A of 10 CFR 55" to "10 CFR 55.59" in Specification 6.3.1 and add the following sentence at the end of the specification:

"Personnel who complete an accredited program which has been endorsed by the NRC shall meet the requirements of the accredited program in lieu of the above."

Justification of the Change NRC Ceneric Letter 87-07 stated that 10 CFR 5:5.59 content requirements (formerly Appendix A to 10 CFR 5.1) can be met with a performance based program for a facility as approve. by 4 the NRC. Such a change has been requested by Georgia Power Company in its letter SL-A744 of Jena 14, 1988 This change incorporates the wording of the proposed change to the Unit 1 Technical Specifications contained in that letter since it is anticipated that it will be approved by NRC prior to the issuance of the Unit 2 license.

Page Affected 6-6 i

1 0

4

ENCLOSURE 1 Page 20

11. Description of the Change Replace "as well" with "as appropriate" in Specificatica 3.0.5.

Justification of the Change The terms "as well" could cause confusion to the reader of the Technical Specifications where parameters are identified for each unit specifically in either parentheses or in footnotes but not addressed specifically in the APPLICABILITY section. The combined' Technical Specifications were written with the intent that the APPLICABILITY section would be applied to each unit separately unless otherwise noted in either parentheses, footnotes, or the APPLICABILITY section as appropriate. It should be noted that the Specifications contained withis sections 3/4.11 and 3/4.12 are considered to apply to the Vogtle sitt and are not to be construed to apply to either unit specifically.

Page Affected 3/4 0-2 e

4 ENCLOSUnE 1 Pm 21

12. Description of the Chant.g Add a footnote applicabla to valves HV-8809A and B stating that either valve may be closed in F9DE 3 to allow testing pursuant to Specification 4.4.6.2.2.
  • Justification for the Change This change has been requested for Duit 1 in Georgia Power Company letter VL-36, dated August 12, 1938, and is eldally applicable to Unit 2. The  !

change clarifies that either valve HV-88d9A or B may be closed in MODE 3 l to allow leakage testing of RCS pressure isolation check valves. This test method has been reviewed and approved by the NRC as documented in Supplement 7 to the SER. The NRC requested that GPC apply for this Technical Specification change by letter dated April 15, 1988.

Pages Affected 3/45-4 B3/4 5-2 4

e I

P 1

ENCLOSUll',1 Pase 22

13. Description of the Change Replace "the" with "either" when referring to the spent fuel pool.

Justification For the Change As described in Georgia Power letter SL-4780 of June 22, 1988, the spent fuel storage area is a common area containing 2 spent fuel pools that are joined through the spent fuel cask pit. Fuel is expected to be moved from one pool to the other and in that sense the pools are common. The common Fuel Handling Building Post Accident Ventilation system serves the area. There may be times when one of the pools contains spent fuel and the other one is empty. In order to avoid any confusion, due to Specification 3.0.5, it is necessary to state that the operability requirements apply whenever spent fuel is in either pool.

Pages Affected 3/4 3-25 3/4 3-44 3/4 9-14

~. _ _

ENCLOSURE 1 Pase 23

14. Description of the Change Change "neets the requirements of Regulatory Guide 1.12" to "meets thc.

recommendations of Regulatory Guide 1.12".

Justification for the Change The current Unit 1 Technical Specifiestions uses "recomendations" rather than "requirements" in referring to this Regulatory Guide in this bases section.

Pase Affected B3/4 3-4 I

i I

Q ENCLOSURE 1 Page 24

15. Description of the Change Insert the following statement into Specification 4.4.6.2.1, "The provisions of Specification 4.0.4 are not applicable for entry into MODE 3 or 4".

Justification for the Change It is not reasonable to perform a Reactor Coolant System (RCS) water inventory balance during transitions from COLD SHUTDOWN to HOT STANDBY.

The RCS water inventory balance should be performed when the RCS pressure is at 2235 + 20 psig since more accurate information about RCS leakage is obtained at full pressure (check valves seat bitter at full pressure).

Since RCS pressure isolation valve leakage has a direct affect on the RCS water inventory balance, the provisions of Specification 4.0.4 should not be applicable for entry into MODE 3 or 4 for Specification 4.4.6.2.1.d as well as for Specification 4.4.6.2.2. This chanSe Will provide consistency between the requirements of Specifications 4.4.6.2.1.d and 4.4.6.2.2.

Page Affected 2/4 4-21 1

DiCIhSURE 1 Page 25

16. Description of the Change Revise the label of the temperature scale in Figure 3/4-2a, 3/4-2b, 3/4-3a, and 3/4-3b to state "Lowest Indicated RCS Teoid Temperature

(*F)".

Justification for the Change This change is intended to emphasize that the lowest indication of RCS temperature should be used in conjunction with this figure. The change does not represent a new or different requirement. It is intended to avoid any question that might be raised concerning the use of the figure.

Pages Affected 3/4 4-31 3/4 4-31a 3/4 4-32 1 3/4 4-32a l

I; l

l l

l l

l ENCLOSURE 1 Pase 26

17. Description of the Change Replace "be" with either "place Unit 1", "Place Unit 2" or "place the applicable Unit" as appropriate in ACTION statements a, b, and c. An additional change to ACTION c is proposed to change "other than ACTION a and b" to "other than that defined in ACTIONS a and b above".

Justification for the Change Tne use of "place Unit 1". "place Unit 2" or "place the applicable Unit" clearly indicates the aa.ic to which the ACTION should be applied. The proposed change to ACTION c better defines the situations when ACTION c should be applied. This change is requested to enhance the readers' understanding that ACTIGN e applies to the situation where there is abnormal degradation of the structural integrity which is not addressed in either ACTION a or b.

Page Affected 3/4 6-8

ENCLOSURE 1 Pase 27

18. Description of the Ch g Delete footnote ##.

Justification of the Change This footnote provided a temporary exemption to the requirement to verify mercaptan prior to fuel addition to the diesel fuel oil storage tank.

This exemption was needed for Unit i but is not required for Unit 2 -

because the mercaptan verification program is now in place.

Page Affected

3/4 8-5 e

4

DICLOSURE 1 Page 28 i 19. Description of the Change Add the word "Common" or "Common System" as appropriate, to Specification requirements which are common to Unit 1 and Unit 2 per Technical Specification 3.0.5 and change unit designators f rom "1" to "1/2" for components that are identical on both units, as described below.

3/4 3-50 Add "(Common System)" to title 3/4 3-66 Add "(Common)" to item 3c Flow to Blowdown Sump 3/4 3472 Add "(Common)" to item la and Ib.

3/4 8-14 Change tage from 1 to 1/2 in LCO ,

Justification of the Channe Making the Technical Specifications a conson document that accurately describes the systems on both units requires all Specifications that  ;

apply to both units to be designated as "Common" (see 3.0.5). Equipment ,

tags that are called out in the specification should be designated as "1/2" if identical equipment exists on each unit. Common instrumentation is indicated by an instrument number beginning with the letter "A" in the ,

current Unit 1 Technical Specifications. For these cases the word '

"Common" has been added per Specification 3.0.5.

t ,

Pages Affected Affected pages are lir,ted in the Description of the Change.

I i

I p a

l

!, [

[

i l

1 4

l

ENCLOSURE 1 Pase 29

20. Description of the chanae The Proof and Review copy of the Combined Technical Specifications did not include figures. The proposed figures are added.

Justification for the Change These figures are the same as the current Unit 1 figures and are also applicable to Unit 2. The unit designator on the bottom of the page has been changed to indicate that it is part of the Combined Technical Specifications, and some corrections to the use of capitalization and title locations have been made.

Pages Affected 2-2 3/4 1-22 3/4 2-3 3/4 2-5 3/4 4-26 3/4 7-24 B3/4 2-3 5-2 5-3 i

e

3 ENCLOSURE 2 TO LrrIER GN-1483 l Open Itess To Be Provided to the NRC l

l

1. Camera Ready Figures.
2. Eductor test flow rates for 4.6.2.2.d.

3'. Test flow rate for Piping Penetration Area Filtration and Exhaust System for 4.7.7.

4 Provide revised action statements in the instrueentation and HVAC Specifications to reflect the combined control room design.

5. Addition of Unit 2 rooms to Table 3.7-3, Area Temperature Monitoring. l e

t 9

1604V

. r

?

e ENCLOSURE 3 T0 m cy_14g3 I

m

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20154C535&oldid=3352545"