ML20153H352

Responds to Portion of Appealing Dh Grimsley 880526 Response to FOIA Request.Denied Portions of Record Can Now Be Released

ML20153H352
Person / Time
Site:	Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png
Issue date:	08/17/1988
From:	Stello V NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO)
To:	Belair R KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART
Shared Package
ML20153H356	List: ML20153H352 ML20153H410
References
FOIA-88-63, FOIA-88-A-34 NUDOCS 8809090156
Download: ML20153H352 (2)

Text

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .

l pa me rg4

, ,9,

• UNITt9 STATES

, y h NUCLE AR REGULATORY COMMIS$10N r,  ! waswiworow. o. c. rom

• +,*....* i' AUG 171900 I L

Mr. Robert R. Belair Kirkpatrick and Lockhart South Lobby - 9th Floor IN RESPONSE REFER i 1800 M Street, W TO F0!A-88 A-34 i Washington, OC 20036-5891 (F0!A-88-63) i

Dear Mr. Belair:

This is in response to that portion of your letter dated June 23, 1988, in which  !

you appealed Mr. Donnie H. 9 rims 16y's response dated May 26, 1988. Mr. Grimsley's response partially denied om record identified on the enclosed copy of Appendix ,

D. Acting on your appeal, I have carefully reviewed the record in this case and i have determined that the denied portions of the record can now be released. [

Those portions of the record are enclosed. [

The Office of the Secretary and the Freedom of Information Act staff will respond under separate t.over to other portions of your letter. l Sincerely, l \

/ -

V kT' i St to Jr.

xe tive i ctor for Operations l

Enclosures:

As stated i

I l

I I l l

i

[

eso9090156 000017 PDR hh$A1 8 A-34 1

1 i I I I

Re: t01A. 88 63 ,

APPENDIX 0 l

, RECORDS PARTIALLY WITHHELD leyM)(R RAR DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION _  !

1. 4/29/87 Memo from Steven A. Varga to Thomas Nrley, subject

Task Action f Plan for Staff Evaluation of 1!LCO'S Requett to Operate shoreh6m i at 25% Power, (1 page), released, with attachment: Task Action Plan (19 pages), withheld, Exemption 5.

l l

l f

i >

1 1

I

]

1  !

1  :

l  !

I t

l 1  !

I f

l f

1 f

i

{ .

1 J

j.

I i

l

)

i i l i

i _n

U S CVCat Am CtquLAtoaf COWMill'0% *..e...... s.e eie

<* - .g * - 'OIA.88 63..$.ei....

.f 0 '"'*.

) RESPONSE TO FREEDOM CF k""-

\ r INFORMATION ACT IFolAl REQUEST

...'..*' UAY 2 619!I u.i%ee. , ..

e. a. i e i.  :

Robert .R. Belair i P a n t e . al C 08 0 6 e4 64 a 6 0 0 04 8 eof LOC a tt D e see en. seed me.ee, one serir, am p e e.*mi w we

• m' 4'e t=* ==*' W j ene esenere e,re, , men e.eeci = ,e *eur seve tue i.uw~

1 nes,v, erwon umi w me some' *** re see8.e * *e.r*e me wwe, e.weee se e*,== ee.eei.e we wovg e se sieC p.em 0o.. s l t7it a seer 4 w . wm any.e DC a

• N e CC *e**ee .aee *.8: 4 .... ee ... .. .. 4. .eiei.+ e. .e . . + , . .: , i . .. e e n s .

• 6 * *** % 8 : ***'4..***

. ,.: r a s,e ei *e we 'ee er * = *

• epi 4: e a a so e . . . . . .

e.n 13 * . se .  %*

. ,,e ew., .e r e i e e.ee i *ei ve. es e se en oc . e eee**. ev., w .a e .w v .. iisa e e. wy w . . ic e. 4 . e.,

,,e se,e,e e ** 'i' C Pv** De ". s era 1757 w s < in a a um,,,e. oc . , e . ., . smo s oia ,-w eg ..u , .,,

' q eemmes eo c e,.ei.a s. e e. = e 'b. aeen to .M pe s*rpen *, i.e, =g .me.m pec ee , we %a e p.ne $w. ., a i?i3. g , n, e n,p,er DC

,,, .e e,e, n .eu , . 7. 4 . - c e e . e. e e. .- . ee e. , .s.,

n .

e ,,; ; ei. r ee -e ,r,.e.i.e. .~ . i. .e.

. e, .8e e - . e ,e v e o , .. ee we e..es Bay _1._19aa . I sa.A.2 7 L east u a.in oeuno= wn==eto enow eve 6 c o, cmv v . - -

Ceresi emeracea e fis 's.wes*8 'm** 8 ***9 "**8 6*'a s6ans se ion e pww to s% 80ia eieviere oms.ees e we se , p guere ones e s m e e as e C we 0 aa, aemanes saa e re es ce em we 'e e*e ero sem o# wie e *

• te aq == eses we seg eas e.e.e e, pass ,es.co. ye eve,q ,

J p. ImC P@ng Desw eP4 here,1 19 e seum. II . wanPwfor DC e e tener p C SQLa ansf.ee, are reemmer 8.ae e

eW pett'Ge evir$s:sm enAll Ceept b,, ._

f

',9 -

e c C e..ee .. 1 eo

. FIN ETO4. OF IseF'Op. Aatic CT 7ESPINSE ,o,e %y ,,g g g I')l A-88 6.*

Msti et s . A P48Ca ett f ois t alvef sOtel 0**'hY 2 6 BBS i

c,co,,e e.cect to t*e e,M ***t s'e deSct*1 a 'M ea(Seg.g a go,ao c es O e e te

• g em i1.a e tae . eass et, o.

g,emier.6 ** 4 fo' the eenc*6 ett 'o'im te C,* ow' sweat to $ U 5 C S*Jito eas 10 Cs a b__o' t4 go., uno,. g cia

'eaC Repsi.ons I t tie m ete*4v. e t sced, cease.'*o owwsai se t eec w e o w 12y4 t a t W ".o's i e

e i

2 Yhe enereene etoe-euv ee se soar, te me eie mei pe eenaed v e .se re pMeo ,se es e,e; .tagwet,on,2, 3 The mayeene ade**4w e soudca e s oseacies '+ona oww.c accio+w e 6, sies e w ie cocaise it81wefioN 3 Secoma tat 1el s' Pe Aie'*8 I95 Ac1 **** Pohens the socicew e 08 Rest *<ted Date , s,.e,., nnwc,se Date 642 U a C 21612106:

e Sec ea set c we e a a < t ae<g. A c' ** <* paca.e.'s +ae esees. . os varass wo $s'eg.a et **r 4'ea e2 . $ C 2147 4 tme mavene eso *ew e e s'aoe tec'e e' cea**'c o' e* haeace c'eamica t*e' e ce ag a.- ee 'e t** ew 6. es.ce eo IatWpfios e l

The r orvretea e e carwaeree to Pe coa'4eaie' hwoaassa trerete*ve efp**etoa tw yie,wetoa e care es se to to Poo'esere e8wastea owsem to to Cf a 2 7soiswti e

tw v rneten me earwnee ord 'eceves e corddence hwa e 'we.pa towece owesweat to it CFm 2 7toivili g gge m etereewe carnea of ete'ogeacy es etseegeac, teceros test see act evedeems thfEhsg> escovery energ Ingstea Decleew e of poenceenef yder*eiea e

y g gy,q gg ye,esi ye gem rueee--e.e. lire escurge of ,e usees eneeateses.,0 to te sedee.a.tswo.FMeed uI*ere recFee De es ftse e per yttaeg , pie legg ere re X

-s'*,,,,,, ,,ep"'.m

• s' e'*a "

v s.. .so ae .eesoaeu, e 2,,e, r ,e ==ewee ce emme.e w eene .e.,e - ,,

e g the emovese efe,weme e segue hora ptehc encsoew e bocevee sie sectoow er newes seews t e e osea, umweaemes eveessa er porgew gewec, itEtWatu0es ga 7 The sepcene cierwesem creen et reseetgetry recerse congees ter new eafercerecat pu poese r yW e eseng emWNas ter N egeocrag ytecates IDEWPTION 71 e e sw.re. ,, ee sen re amm wi ere sce*eme pocesorg toceime a conde erveef we ocase. eseceen. sae tec.e et . w a sse o,w ww pu esiae geengey see. per* W ehe acesa M ePese acteataed es'orgeomag er o veoisten of fe e C eegw a y=or*1e hora c=esgaterg (QtWrTpQsg N Al) rw , novas cremes en ummer'emme e.nea of portener pa e6, :(ItW9TICAg hCll The ederwe4em crease of sus *ee of r*=Wwee true othee eforwaea she sectoe.ve of e*=c+ ease revees aseaetes se cocee,=ter now,ces iQtWyttog tipu P A RT 00 C - OlafTileQ oHICiALS w is io Cesi e e re e s 's d c't's iewc o e seea oe, ene pei ,e - -e.e. e e ue e e,s t b ,

I n i. e c.e. i tre

,acer, C.am ee w eeer

e. c<e.

eet e, se.enweiene e = eg t.=w ee w.e ie. we w. ce eene 9 eeeecae de,se,e ce o.xi. e.e e,,, ,,,, se

% es n,,me ,,,u, sea e, ~once

,e n ec,. . w rv .is,<ce e a. awa e, eer.e o.wie, i one,eie e .too, oo vi c onica. -Tht on Ct enosos oo to asewit on, Cia 6 Director eNRR Appendix D uceme. eoo Thoemas E. Mpriev X

- l 1

1 1

1 l __

I

1. Att 110 - APPE AL Ricacts i

n, agereal try uch am efa ces dentered e Pvt il C may be espeated to the Acce r.as Oef,cial aseat.f+d e that secten Amy such secesi must be e I 4

aprgq W m st be w rest meDun B seV1 of recett 0 that f etccese Apoeoi mlstwbe sodisted el sc9rocaiste to the Laocwtsvg Owestor fee Oper#1cm3 or to e,w Seuetary of tu Co camem U S Nwenee, megw' story Comm u.on, WHA.ogien. OC 20%5. ead showid ciese, sta's on the om,voce end e the ietic n,, . en wceev es pied 808 A. On+ca "

seC *eems see esa ti U S NUCLE AR REGULATORY COMMISSJO'

.us . FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION l

. . . . . . . . ... .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~- -

Re: 601A. 88-6' APPENDIX 0 RECORDS PARTI ALLY WITHHELD NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION

1. 4/29/87 Memo f rom Steven A. Varga to Thomas Murley, subje::: Task Action Plan for Staff Evaluation of LILCO'S Request to 0 erate Shoreham at 25% Power (1 page), released, with attachment: Task Action Plan (19 pages), withheld, Exemption 5.

l

KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART SouTN Lo68Y f noce g,: w g4

. . usmrr... ,, m, m., l tAsa:NcToN. O c :xm Tu'=^"* I

..:n anx5m l n = = ~- T,S'","

tsua nx. ,

N orum a v = ,rmaxa ,4 aw im moeur a sELAR W125 mee aan rsen January 27, 1983 HAND DELIVERED MMM OF KCRI,'.Wm ACT REQUEST Director, Of fice of Administration Nuclear Regulatory Commission Room 4210 FOIA-/[=6J Maryland National Bank Building 7735 Old Georgetown Road D d /-d7-fp Bethesda, Maryland 20814 Re: Freedom of Information Act Request ,

Gentlemen:

On behalf of our client, Suffolk County, Long Island, New York, we request, pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, as amended, 5 U.S.C. Section $52 ("FOIA"), and the rules of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") issued thereunder, 10 C.F.R. Part 9, copies of any agency records in the possession or control of the NRC relating to the following:

1. All records, including prepara*.ory materials, contemporaneous notes, post-meeting discussions or analyses, and information submitted by the Long Island Lighting Company

( "LI LC0" ) , relating in any way to a January 14, 1988, meeting involving NRC employees, of ficials, agents or representatives (including Messrs. Reis, Johnson, Scoto, and Olmstead) and representatives of LILCO (Messrs. Earley, Frielicher, Reveley,

• and Irwin) concerning matters relating to the shoreham Nuclear Power Station.

2. All records, not served via the service list in 50-  !

322-OL-03, 05, or 06 dockets, relating in any way to any other communicatior.. during the period March 1987 to the present between LILCO, including any person acting for or on behalf of LILCO, and NRC employees, of ficials, agents or representatives, '

which concerned any matters pertaining to the Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, including without limitation, LILCO's request to operate Shorehas at 25 percent power, any Federal Emergency

Management Agency review of revisions to LILCO's emergency plan, Yh &

K1RKPXTRICK 661.OCKHART Director, Of fice of Administration January 27, 1988 Page 2 any further exercise of LILCO's emergency plan, and any proposed procedures or schedules for any review or exercise of LILCO's emergency plan.

In the evert that access is denied to any of the records responsive to this request, please supply the fol*owing information:

a. Identify the record or withheld portion of the record and specify the statutory basis for the denial, as well as your reason for believing that an exemption applies, as r.,quirad by 10 C.F.R. Section 9.10(b) .

b. Segregate the nonexempt from the allegedly exempt portion of any withheld records and release the former, as required by 10 C.F.R. Section 9.5(b).

c. Supply a detailed statement of the conteent of the with-held document or portion thereof, along with the date on which that document or portion thereof was written; its section heading or t 4; and an identification of any persons or entities who have aceived copies of such records or portions thereof, as required by applicable case law. Vaughn v. Rosen, 484 T.2d 820, 826-827 (D.C. Cir.1973) .

d. Separately state your reasons for not invoking your discretionary power to release the allegedly exernpt records or portions thereof.

The undersigned will pay chargen for search time and copying fees, as provided by NRC regulations, 10 C.F.R. Section 9.14. If search and copying fees to be incurred by the undersigned will exceed $?00, please notify Lorraine Gibson at (202) 778-9118 before this sum is exceeded. Any questions or comments concerning this request may also be directed to Ms. Gibson.

We expect to receive your response to this roIA request within ten (10) working days of your receipt of this request, as required by the FOIA, and as set forth at 10 C.F.R.

Section 9.9(a). -

/

Sindere , j

a. ~*/ <, ,

j '.I V-Robert R. Belair