ML20151C220

AO 12-75:on 750521,excessive Operator Freeplay Noted Due to Loose Locknut on Core Spray Valve Operator.Caused by Design Deficiency.Locking Nut Tightened & Staked W/Pin Punch to Drive Sleeve.Investigation in Progress

ML20151C220
Person / Time
Site:	Big Rock Point File:Consumers Energy icon.png
Issue date:	05/23/1975
From:	Sewell R CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To:	James Keppler NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
Shared Package
ML20151C218	List: ML20151C215 ML20151C220 ML20151C225 ML20151C228 ML20151C230
References
AO-12-75, NUDOCS 8103110739
Download: ML20151C220 (2)

Text

,, . ._ _ . _ - . . . . . - . ._

U g -9,pe-r-----,y , _ _ - ._ _

{ \' .,]

• 10

( ve-upn: /-t:--

lJf:'p.jm. gly;.tr -t]-[(L C.

..- lWj? -

r(0. 4 + a 4

W ' )

m. C -

-- _ _. __ . . ___m . c, jl% r, u._

. .. p 1

, "' '+ r., 4: og +

l l

V EB219( 15 57 ) ( 1 -03639. C 14 3) PD 05/ P 3/ 7 5.1551 ' I

( TLX -C ONSPOWER JXN gf3 J , y l ZCZC 002 gJACKSON MI .HIG AM ?3-71CNd300X E0+M

' * ~

PMS: USNRC Ib 2 -.

t n h o!CN'2.b

• LY.)2Lb I'

MR J~G XEPPLER l.. errtm:0:t O T0 e- .

799 R00SEVELT R1 5'S - b --

DIC3 fggs 70ELD -[Df 4 GLEN ELLYN, IL 61137 ,

c Sc& 75d% 0$5f r,

m THIS TWX IS TO COW T RM AN EVENT REo 0RTED BY. TELEoFONE 'S E DE "000 c' TO D KILEY AT l 600 HOU.M:5 ON Y,AY 22, 1975.

t q 1. REPORT NO A0-12-75. D OCK ET 50-15 5 A

Y

( 2 A. REPORT D ATE - M AY 23, l'975

29. OCCURRENCE DATE - M AY 21, 1975, CL ASSI7IES AS A 0 0'1 5- 0 0 - 7 5 SF-1201 (RSG9) 5

3. F ACILITY - BIG ROCK POINT PL ANT

(

1

4. IDENTIFIC ATION OF OCClt9RENCE - CORE SPRAY V Alt!ES CoER AW LOOKNUT LOOSE o +.

- ,5. .C ON D IhISON. ., M.IOR . kOCCliRRENyEN' .r Pi.MIT. IM: C'0! D:.. 7HUTDo'..'N C OD 40 5-75 v of 7% g an r MODIFIC ATION ACTIVITIES ASSOCI ATED 'd!Tu M0/705) 3EING TESTED FOLLOYING REL OC A TI ON .

. . s

.( .,

,6. DESCRI'PTI ON '0F OCCURRENCE' - ENCESSIVE' CoER ATOR FREE

~ ' ,

AlOTE9 SMRIhG V ALVE REVE'oS AL OHIiN ' TEST OPko dIhD Tut out.noy CORE SPR AY V ALVES M0/7051 AND M0/7061 AT l*00 40 CN 5-21-75.

'( INSPECTION. OF THE DRIVE MECH ANISM REVE ALED THAT A LOCX SF 1201 (R&69) n 5e f/o 3//o 73 .

t u a

l 6- - ii - -9 .-

,. 5 l

,,_,_..._,.m._. I'. i 2. .< 1 pa 7 ~ r r EIErr r. -

j- ift. pM ti t, _

t

+annLVmLLl.a - -- -ha " um mm =

W L_ .

(

TPE L TKING

. H AD LOOSE 9ED SEVERAL TIRNS IN E ACH V ALVE OoER AT09.

NUT WAS TREN TIGHTENED AN D ST AXED '/I TH A PIY PUNCH T1 THE DPIVE SUBSEQUE'JT TES TI NG SM0' LED P RO?E9 OoE9 ATI Of.'

ON 5 l 5 .

SL E EV E. ,

u

7. DESIGN ATI ON 07 AoP A9ENT C AUSE Or O*CUooE"C7 DESI?" F ICII'!C".

A" 9

g. AN'2LYSr.S 07 GCCUo9ENCE - THE V ALV ES DID V'u e $1 L T O Do ro 6T E H0VEVER, TH E P OT E'! T I AL C OR C A I LIR # "X T "TO '(

THU3 N O H AZ ARD EXISTED.

TPE ?ACKUD ^G'"

ON BOTH VALVES IN THE P RIM ARY C ORE SD R AY SYSTEv.

SP R AY SYSTEM VALVE OPERATORS ape FP ov ANOTuER N'UTATV'E9 A '! D P A" " (

^"D POTIO~

BIEN Co ER ATION il AS RE^ UIRED BY T ECF' IC AL So r'I !0 ATI ^9

~"I "'I"^ Y C

v Vo.ES T HUS WOULD H AV E o 9 0V IDED C Uf:C TI ON S L PE^"I 9E"E'? TE 17 CORE SPR AY SYSTEM H AD AILED DUE TO TuE DEFECT.

~

(

f F.17,1 (R.5-0)

9. COPR EC TIV E AC TI O' - IvvEDI ATE C ORREC TIVE AC TI O" 59 DESC9IPES IM ITE'i 6 M AS M ADE TWE 'INITS OPER ASLE. INVEGTI G ATI O" IS I" Pa?t;arqs TO DETER"I"E IF OTHER CORoECTIVE vEASuors AqE NEcEgg qv, t

10. rAILURE DATA - MOT 9R ODE 9tTORS AoE PHI t sDEi. oui n ;r s.: i,7 v i .

T JR7UE MODEL SM A- 00.

I

. CC: - -

D I V I S I O !,'

0F RE ACTOR .LICENSINA , , ..

,3

. .i. ., - ,

WA S HI N G T O'1, .Sc. ,3, . , . . .. . .. . . . . . , .., .

C J HAoTMAN, 3IG ROCK D. .~. . . , -

, R B.SEVELL . .

s,,i., ..'Q1 m .,* L E A D L I C E S S I t'c SOM I

C ON SUMERS P O'JER C O ALL HO 1

1 y st y y I