ML20150E450

Informs of No Legal Objection to Substance of Proposed Rule Re Misadminstration Rept,Per 880205 Request

ML20150E450
Person / Time
Issue date:	02/11/1988
From:	Rich Smith NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC)
To:	Mcelroy N NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS)
Shared Package
ML20150E436	List: ML20150E433 ML20150E439 ML20150E445 ML20150E449 ML20150E450 ML20150E452 ML20150E459
References
FRN-53FR21627, RULE-PR-35 AC69-2-5, NUDOCS 8807150147
Download: ML20150E450 (4)

Text

i

• ' kM4 l PDA l

.)

' j i .?

ji' FEB 11 1988 i

NOTE TO: Norm McElroy IMAB, NMSS FROM: Ron Smith OCC

SUBJECT:

FEDERAL REGISTER NOTICE -

DIAGNOSTIC MISADMINISTRATION REPORT FORM As requested by you on Februarv 5, 1988, I have reviewed the proposed Federal Register notice concerning the above subject and find no legal objection to the substance of the final rule. However, I would note some deficiencies in form as follows:

1. As you intend to make the rule immediately effective upon publication and without public comment, a justification for that action is required.

See section 5.9(f), NUREG/BR-0053, Rev. 1, November 1987, Regulations Handbook. However, none of the examples provided therein appear to apply to this situation and the comment in your final rule on this issue does not appear to be appropriate. Therefore, it is suggested that the following statement be 8ncluded in the Supplementary Section:

"This amendment is a minor administrative change to an existing final rule. It merely adds the form number for an NRC form to the ccdUled rule. The number had been omitted because OMB had not completed its review. Based on this, good cause exists to find that the notice and public procedure provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act are unnecessary pursuant to the exemption provision found in 5 U.S.C. 553(b)(B). Therefore, the amendment is effective upon publicatica in the Federal Register."

2. Within the categorical exclusion for an environmental statement, the reference to paragraph (c)(14) is unnecessary and should be deleted.

The words "for this final rule" should be added at the end of the

. statement.

3. The Regulatory Analysis, Regulatory Flexibility Act, and Backfit Analysis statements have not been included as required by the Regulations Handbook. (However, I can see where they don't necessarily appear to be appropriate. You may wish to discuss these matters,with Rules and Records Division to see if there is a compromise or exception option available under this circumstance.)

(

8607150147 880629 l PDR PR l

35 S3FR21627 PDR

}

% kM-A .

- PD P,

4. .There is a typographical error in the List of Subjects- section in that "Health devices" should read "Health facilities."

5. The words of issuance- under the section Regulatory Text are not in conformance with section. 5.25 of the Regulations Handbook.

6. The Authority citation must include the whole authority citation as it now reads, i.e., the sections issued under authority of 9 223, AEA.

Cw 0 on Smith 4

AUA4 POR

, N poR3 en U S. NUCLE AM MGULATO4Y COMMIS$10N u apure vo uw OWs 10 CF2 e:3 31 3150 0140 twees 5 31 E4 OlAGNOSTIC MISADMINISTRATION REPORT IN I) UCEN8Et Naut liN2n LICENSE NuwstR 1 I l-l l i I l l-l l iN3) CIT y INelSTAft tNSI EVENT OA 's tN61 R E POR T 0 A T E MONIM OAY VEAR MONTM OAV VtAR l l I l f f l (N717YPt 0F uiSADMbP $T R A fl0N IN43 OIO TME w&ADMINeSTR ATION INv0Lvt AN IN9s NVuetR O8 PA f stNTS WMO RtClivEO ISOTOPtOFIOctNE A Wi$ ADMtNISTR ATiON UNDER TMis RE OR T 1011 WRONG 102 DOSAGE DipFERING

. R A 0iOPM A R MAC t W. .C h l F AQM P45$CRiggO gy $Qg IO3t wAONG P ATIEN s l 104p wm0NG ROUTir l1999)YE1 l l (11tlNO IN10) IN T E Not 0 IN10AliNitNCEO IN113 GIVEN toel ULTRA 50uNo stuoY CMt CAL

~

1061 NO CLahiCAL PROCEDUR E

~

WILUCUPIES ISOTOPS C",'O"h ' 57VOY MILLicuRits' ISOTOPE p0 w sivoy lo6) NUCLEAR ME0tCiNa

$Tuov scomeme #006 CT 87VOY Oto W g39, gy,t STVOY h

'07) X M A Y S TVOY lillCTHER-fM12) PRICIPITATOR 171) Rif ERRfNQ PHYSICI AN ( ) }gg[f/df$)fff)- M _

176) MOT LAB TECHNOLOGIST t r2) wARO NuRat arrl auAciNo fsCHNotooisY (73) WARD CLERK t7t) CUNIC R(CEPfl0NilT (74) NUC'.E AR PMARWACY (791 $CM400UNO TECHNOLOGisf NAW4 07 NUCLEAR MARMACT gggg paygggy l CITY l$TAft 1811OTHER tN131 ERROM MOT LAS RfFERRAL A DMINISTR AflON OTHER f

I l11) Me5LAttLEO A SYRINGE (Ill SELECTto WRONG vl AL f4 uisuNOERsT000 t301 SELECTto WRONG l 440) Spee#

WHEN DR Awi% DOSAGE RE F tRRING PHY$1CJ AN $ P A TitN T -

(12) WisLA8ELEO A vl AL RE0utti OR vial SMitLO 00sf SR A TM ERto A T1 0 (141 g g,g (31) 113) R ECONS TITUTE D (171 MISRE A0 00St FOR OTHER P ATitNT wmONQ REAGtNT Kjf - CA LitR ATOR _

(ISI MISuNDE RSTOOO (22) Recut 4Tf D STuov (321 BRoucMT wmONG

_ R AD#OPM A R M ACluTICAL FOR wRONQ P ATIE NT _ PATitNT TO CLINIC (141 PLACE O RECON $TITUTE D OR 00$ AGE ORotR vlAL IN WRONG 3MsELO _ t331 pSEL,ECTE,D g WRONG g CART (Niel CONTRituisNO F ACTORS INtli ACTION T AKEN TO PMEVENT RECURRENCE 1806 t'uotNT TECHNOLOGtST 185) REQuisiitON NOT CHECKID IC63 R $ Pt Ry l$lON suPLEMENT NEW PROCE00RES FOR pp igliestw EMPtovtl isos PATIENT CHART N0" (Cil vEmiFICAfiON OF REcutST

~

(021 FOREIGN LANQuAcg IC2i M ADe0PM AR WACluTIC AL LAS$ LING AND M ANDLING (C7) NO ACTION

($31 PAf ttNT INCOHERENT On ta 71 NEW PROCT 0VRE IC3) VEmisiC ATION os P AfitNT (C8t OTHER

- UNCONSCIOUS - -

IDE N TIF #CA TION -

488) ME Avv WORK LOAD 184) 10 SR ACE LtY NOT CHECKED , IC4) REINST AUCY PERSONNEL ICS) R EPRiW AND PE RSONNE L (N161 IFFECT ON PAfif NTS l NONE APPARENT $tf ASSTR ACT IN17) A8$TR AC7 f(f mer9 EParf 4 r#Wwwpd etterA #detacedf sAsem) f Y rM A O L4 W ^O?O$

P ' fle 0L e

[9 Nl 0 NUCLE AR RtGULATORY COMMIS$10N U$t

.:N i si IN isi (N20p RE GioN AL LOG IN2tl ACCElllON NUW8ER IN221 Nefi ALS A$ NUWSER 49995 's t 8

' " " No l I III IIIIII I III I  ;

l l

l

AMA4 POR,

, NPC FORJ 473 U S. NUCLE A3 f.EGULAf 0 AY COMMIS$ TON 14 8 % Apuro e4 by 098 to CF A e 35 33 3150 0:40 E evni t 3188 DIAGNOSTIC MISADMINISTRATION REPOFIT (Nil UCE Nill N AWE liN2l UCENSE NUWSER Il l-l l l l l l-l l tN 2) Cif Y iN8' ST Af t #N5i EvtNT cart .Nel REPOR f cart MONfM QAY vtAR UCNIH OAY TEAR l ! i e i l l

~

IN1) TYPE OF ui1ADwiNistR AtlON IN8 OoD TMt WisADuiNesTR ATiON iNv0 Lyt AN IN91 NUMBEtt OP P A ritN rg w.eO RgCgag to ISOTOPE OF IO0iNE A His Aousmisf R A7 SON UNOf A TMl3 REPOR f 6011 WRONG 102) DO$ AGE DiF F E RING

. P tDeOPMA R MACEUTIC A L - PROM PRESCRitt0 9Y 50%

1031 WRONO PATIENT fosi WRONG Routs l 19901 Y ES l lfililNO (NIO) INT E NDE D IN t0Al INT E Not o LNIil G VEN CMt 1051 NO CUN6C* L PROCEDVRE 10010LTR ASOUNo sfuCY weLUCURall ISOTOPE CMEgCA y0 L STUDY WILLICURIES ISOTOPE po Cu ' STUOY (061 NUCLEAR df 01 CINE

_ s M CT87UDY STUOFICompee'ED W _

[k, D (10l NW STUOY 107) N MAY $fv0V di tt OTHER :

int 21 PRECIPf f ATOR 171) REFE RRING PHYSICS AN 176) MOf LAs TECHNOLOGasT (721 WARD NURSE 177) IMAGING TECMrsOLOGIST (7h WARD CLEME (731 CUNiC RECEPflONIST (741 NUCLE AR PMARMACY (79) SCHEDUUNG TECHNOLOGIST

~

NAME OP NvCLEAR PHARMACY ggog payiggy l CITY l3 FATS 180OTHER-(N138 (RROM MOT LAG MtFERRAL A0 Mini 3 TR A flON 01MER liti WISLASELf D A SYRINGE till SILICTED wmONG vial (20) WISUNDER 57000 1301 SE LECTE D WRONG 140) Saec fr WHEN DR awing OO$ AGE REF ERRING PHY$1CI AN $ PATitNT 1121 Mi3LAEELED A vlAL REOyggf Om vl AL sM8 ELD (ISI SE E UtRATOR '3 U '"I 0 pog orggn ,N'f(0E0 (2H RIOUESTED WRONG M PAG (13) RsCONtfiTUTED (173 WISRE AD OO$f 8 UO E 4ygggy wmONG REAGENT Klf _ CAU9A ATOR _

(18) WisuN0E RsTOOO (22) R EQUESTED 5fuCY (321 BROUGHT w11 TONG

_ R AOiOPM ARM A C EUTICA L FOR wmONG PATIENT _ PATIENf f0 CUNic 19 41 PLACf D RECONSTITUTEO OR DOSAGE ORotR ve AL IN WI,0NG SMIE LD 1338 stLECTED wmONG 3TRiNGE Frow 00$ AGE i CART l

Intal CONTRISUTING f ACTORS INi'A ACTION TAKEN TO PREVENT RECURRENCE I

(80l lTUOf Nf f ECHNOLOGest t3SI REOutsiflON NOT >ECKED suPLEMENf 4EW PROCEOURES FOn IC6s uPmO UPE R VISION

_ _ pp l (pt) NEW EMPLOYgg 186) PATIENT CMART NOT (Cil vtR F6 CATION OP RIOutsf i

CHECKl0 - -

1871 FOREIGN LANGUAGg IC 21 R A 0iOPMARMACEUTICA L

- - LA8EUNG AND MANDLING (C7) NO ACfiON l 183) P AYlE NT INCOME R ENT OR 184 NEW proct 0URE

- UNCONSCsOUS -

IC38 vtR18lC ATION Oi P AfitNT IC81OTHER IOt NiiF sCA TION -

El HE AVY WORK LOA D (34* eO GR ACILET NOT CHECK 80 '

IS9 OfMtR-iCS) REPRlW AND PER$0NNEL IN tel 5F F ECT ON P Afif NTS l NONE APPARENT Sif AS$TR ACT

m i n A . . r R AC T ~ ~ . ~ ,,,.A M, , s.,, ,

1 e

i J V

l I

1 NUCLE AR REGULAYORY COMMISSION USE tNiti IN2n ACCgss#ON NuveER iN22i iNiti A Ls IN.its A N20tNuo Rtca.ON ER AL LOG 1999:YES (I t il NO l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l