05000331/LER-1978-030-01, /01T-0 on 780617:water Leak Found in Area of B Recirculation Sys N2A Inlet Nozzle Caused by Wall Crack in Nozzle Safe End.Lab Analysis Will Be Performed to Determine Cause of Cracking
| ML20148N582 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Duane Arnold  |
| Issue date: | 06/30/1978 |
| From: | Vansickel J IES UTILITIES INC., (FORMERLY IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20148N579 | List: |
| References | |
| LER-78-030-01T, LER-78-30-1T, NUDOCS 7811270150 | |
| Download: ML20148N582 (2) | |
| Event date: | |
|---|---|
| Report date: | |
| 3311978030R01 - NRC Website | |
text
/
LICENSbb EV bN i HbFUH i
~
CONTROL 6 LOCK: l l
l
}
l l
l (pt gAsg PRINT OR TYPE ALL REQUtnEO INFORMATION)
M IlA l0 lA (C l1 l@l0l0l-I0l0l01010l-l0101@l4lil1l!!!I@l l@
11 FS UCENSEE CQOg le it blCENSE NUMSE A 25 2h UC&h5& TYPE JQ SJ CA f $4 CON T i
oIii [y,"C lL}@l0l5 l0 10 ! 0 l 3 ! 3 l 1 l@l 01 6l 1 l 71 71 Al@l 016 l 3 l 0 ! 7 I 9 l@.
8 60 66 QQCXf7 NUMeta tad b9 LVENT QATE d4
?S R(PORT QAf E 80 EVENT DESCRIPTION AND PAC 8ABLE CONSEQUENCES h o Ia1 l Durino a special drvwell inspection a water leak was fofmd in tha araa n J
~
--o131 1 f the "B" recirculation system N2A inlet nozzle. Further investication I
i
- oi4II revealed the leak was the result of a throuch will crack in tha no rPl a I
o Is1 I safe end acoroximately 4 to 6 inches in circumferential lencth. Radineran I
.o is 1 I hic and UT exam revealed susoect indications in 5 nther inlat nn771a saf I j o lil I e ends none throuch wall. Two safe ends had no susoect indications.
I o Ia 1 l Primary system structural intecrity recuirements in Toch Snec 1 6-G.
I
- Q 1
es SYSTEM
CAUSE
CAUSE COMP.
VALVE CCQE CCCE SUSCCCE COMPO'.'ENT CCCE 508C00E
$USCCOE
, o l 91 l C l B l@ l X l@ l Z l@ l P lI l P I E l X l X I@: 101@ l.1J @
i 8
9 to it
' 12.
13 la 19 20 StOUE NTI An.
OCCURRENCE REPCRy AEVISION at CCCE TYPE N C.
gnfmo EVENr YEAM REPORr NO.
O"y(ugg I 71 81 1-1 101310I I/I 10 f 1 1 IT I 1-1 laj 21 22 23 24 26 27 28 23 30 31 32 N AC C Q P NY 2
MQuMS
$3 i PC A M 3,
$UPP q,j g MA UP 4CTU A (R I Xl@l Al@
l C l@
l Z l@
l2I9l0l0l l Y l@
lNl@
l Nl@
l Cl3 11 l0 !@
33 J4 33 24 3J 4o 48 q
43 44 4;
CAUSE DESCRIPT1CN AND CCRAECTIVE ACTIONS Ii Io l I Unknown. Laboratory analysis will ha dona on a cracked safa and fn11n i
I Ii Iii I wine removal to determina the causp nf the crackinn. Dir*nnt minne 2*n t i 171 I to replace all efaht safe ends with new safa ends nf an imnenved doefgn-r i l 21 l l
ii mI I
.o
's*Tik7 oTNaasTArus h EsEo E v' sPoweR oisCCv(RY CESCRIPTtCN
- i I$ 1 l Gl@ l Ol 01 Ol@l NA l
LQJ@l Soecial Inscection l
c$teNr ACTivirY aucuNr op 4Crivify @ l ioCArieN or anEAsa @
cetrasto
- - s astrase I
NA I
'i (6 l NA 7
.4 9
10 11 44 4%
43 PtMSONNE t. I APC5084 81 Nuutta fv't C ESC A;PTION I !Il 0
00 l
bl4 PtR5CNNE iNjunit$
NUM9(4 O(SCAL
- TION
- - m I a n PJei u
i 7
8 9 11 12 30 W,5 a'C"'VC.? c" '" @
E
! o l l L l@l NA l
i is:uto_es::mPioNgi 7811270to Pv.uk y,cus,csc, 2 ' oj l Yld Pres s Release, 6-19-78 l
l!ItiIti!I ii!i 8 1 33 48 ed 90 3 NwE OF PREN AE3
'- Y30 S i C '< "l
}l9~35l~5 ll PHON E -
"*4
/
. F**lE ARNOLD CLERGY CZirzER Icma Electric Light and Power Company LICENSEE EVCIT REPORT-Supplemental Data Docket Number 030-0331 t.icancoa Event Report Date:
063078 Reportable Occurrence No:
78-030
Event Description
On June 17, 1978 during weekly control valve testing an automa' tic reactor scram occurred due to reactor protection system relay problems (see R0 78-031) and the CV testing.* After the plant was shutdown a drywell inspectior, was made to detemine the source of drywell unidentified leak of 3 GPM.
Technical Specification 3.6-C limits unidentified leakage into the primary gantainment to 5 GPM.
Water was found leaking from the shield blocks around the "B" recirculation system N2A inlet nozzle. The '
reactor was placed in a cold shutdown condition and the shield blocks removed for further inspection of the nozzle area.
The. leakage was found to be the result of a through wall crack in the nozzle safe end approximately 4 to 6 inches in circumferential length.
Ultrasonic testing and radiographic examination were then begun to detemine the full extent of the cracking in the N2A nozzle safe end and to check for similar problems in the remaining 7 nozzle safe ends. The examinations revealed suspect indications in 5 other safe ends, none of which were through wall cracks.
The remaining 2 nozzle safe ends had no suspect indications.
Primary system structural integrity requirements are listed in Technical Specifications Section 3.6-G.
Causa Description _
The exact cause of the cracking has not been determined.
Following removal, a
laboratory analysis will be done on a cracked safe end to determine the failure mechanism.
Corrective Action
Current plans are to replace all eight safe ends with new safe ends of an improved design.
b 9
o f.'
1 wT I
w