ML20148K050

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Partial Response to FOIA Request Re CRGR Meeting.Forwards App K Documents.Documents Available in Pdr.App L Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)
ML20148K050
Person / Time
Issue date: 03/24/1988
From: Grimsley D
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
To: Weiss E
HARMON & WEISS
Shared Package
ML20148K054 List:
References
FOIA-87-714, REF-GTECI-A-46, REF-GTECI-B-19, REF-GTECI-B-59, REF-GTECI-ES, REF-GTECI-SC, REF-GTECI-TH, RTR-NUREG-0313, RTR-NUREG-313 NUDOCS 8803310001
Download: ML20148K050 (5)
v • d • e


Text

_______ -

U S. NUCLE AR REGULATORY COMMISSION  %*c sova aiovist %vsta.si

,p %e h, f r/ F0!A-87-714

,. i _ aismse mi

! * [1 RESPONSE TO' REEL M OF 'O  !'**' E I ""'

\,, f INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST g g 4 jgg oocur w . e i~.e..

KiOViSTim Ellyn R. Weiss Esquire e PART 1.-RECORDS RELE ASED OR NOT LOCAftD ISee c4ceed bones)

No agency records subact to the rMvest have been located No addetonal agency records subect to the request have been located.

Age ^cy records pepct to the roovest that are cer t#ed m Appendia are skeady avadaNo for OvN'c moection and cocyng m the NRC Pubhc Document Room.

1717 H Street, N W , WeoNngton. OC Agency records submet to the request thet are dentded in Appendia are boeg made ava. lab 6e for pubhc espection 34 copyeg m the NRC Pubhc Documer't N Room,1717 H Street. N W., Wuhngton. DC, in a folder under this FOI A number sad reowester name The nonpropretary verson of the orccows) that you agreed to accept e a teephone con =*rsaton uth a metter of my staff e no* teng made ave 4able for public especton and coymg at the NRC Pubbe Document Room.1717 H Street. N W . Washmgton. DC. e a fouer under the FOIA number and roovemee name.

(nclosed e enformaton on how you may obtam access to and the charges for copyeg records placed m tPo NRC Pwbhc Document Room.1717 H Street N W , Washegton. DC Agency records tubect to the request s'e enc 60 sed Any appkcable charge for copes of the records prov4ed and par r tent procedures as noted m the comments secton Records svbect to the request have been referred to another Federal agencytes) for review and dwect response to you in vow of NRC s response to the request, no further acton e toeg taten on appeal letter dated PART ll. A-INFORM ATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC OlSCLOSURE Certam eformaton m the roovested reco ds e be.rg anhbe.d from ocN.c doctoswee pursuant to the FOI A enerrStons descreed in aN 'or the reasons rated e Pan 11. sec-tons B. C and D. Aey re eased portons of the documents for whch only part of the reco'd is beeg *-thbeid a*e teing made avadaNe for public especten and cooYing m X the NRC Pwbhc Document Room.1717 H Street. N W Washcgton. DC. m a foeer under thrs FOIA nww aN requester name Comm.nts 8803310001 880324 PDR FOIA WEISS87-714 PDR e

sign T1 tCeca oms e 54%Qe CORDS , e f'

7 I C

__T _1 N AC FOR M 464 >e't b it m i

(

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT RESPONSE FOIA NUMBERISL b7*7)4 OATO MAR 2 4 888 PA%T 11 B. APPLICABLE FOIA EXEMPTIONS p Records subsect to the request that are described in the enclosed Appendices L are being withheld in their entirety or in part under FOIA Eremptions and for the reasons set forth below pursuant to 5 U.S.C. SS2Itd and 10 CFR 9.5(a) of NRC Regulatons.

1. The wthheld mformaten e propedy classefed puisvant to Enocutrve Order 1274 (EXEMPTCN 11
2. The wthheld informaton reistes soiety to the mtemal personnel rules and procedures of NRC. (EXEMPTION 21
3. The wthheld mformaten e toecahcany esempted from pwbhc deciosure by statute mecated IEXEMPTION 3)

Secten 141-145 of the Atomic Energy Act which prohbts the doclosure of Restncted Data or Formerfy Restncted Data ta2 U $ C. 216121661.

Secten 147 of the Atorruc Energy Act which probbts the deciosure of Unclawfed Sa+eguards informaton la? U S C. 2167L

4. The wthheld infomtation e a trade secret or commercial or fmancial mformation that a beirq wthheid for the reasorwel mdicated. IEXEMPTION 41 The informatnon e Cor*dered to be Confder$tel busangss (proprgtary) anformaton.

The information a Coredered to be propretary informaison pursuant to 10 CFR 2 NidN1L The information was submit'ed and recerved in Conhdence from a foregn sovrCe pursuamt to 10 CFR 2 790 ldh 2 5, The utnheid eformaton coesists of eteragency or intraegency records that are not avadeone through escovery dureg Irtgaten. Dsclosure of predec+onal mformaton would tend to phibst the open and frank eschange of dess esserital to tne deltberat%e process W+ere records s's wthheed in thed eetrety, the facts s's enestncab8v

.,- nedmovery indirect wih eg,edoc mtt ufo,maton.

predeceonal process The,e ,so 3,et E of the agency noAEMPTION

,eas.agseg,egab.e facw pon.oes beca.se me ,.0.e of me facu woo.d perma an

6. Th. smheid mfo,maion e e emoted fem pubi< duiome becaos. as dyiowe owd ,oun in a ci 4y on.a rented m,ason e ce,sonai on,acy. (ExEuPriON e
7. The wthheld informat@n Corests of investgatory records comcded for law enforcerT3t pv posese and a becg wt66end for the reason (s) undicated (EXEMPTION 71 1

Orsciosyre would intedore wth an geforcement proceeding becesse it Could reveal the ecoce, d rection, and focvs of efitorcement eHorts and thus Could poss@ry allow them to take action to shecid potential *rongdoor$g or a volaton of NAC reqvvements from evergators (EXEMPTION 7LAll Desclosure wov6d Constrtvte an unwenanted inbasson of personal prNacy (EXEMPTION 7tCH Ihe nformat@n Consists of names of edNdwa's ard other informaton the d'sclowe of nbch would reveal dent $es of Contdentel sources (EXEMPTION 7 ton PART fl C-DENYING OFFICIALS Pursuant te 10 CFR 9 9 and 'or 9.15 of the U.S. Nwdeer Regulatory Cemason roovtstions. it has been oetermined that the informaton *,thheed e enempt from producton or escioswee.

and that ets producten or declosure e contrary to the pubaec interest. The persons responsibee for the den al are those othcGis denter e d below as denyng officWs end the Duettor, Dmsson of Rules and Records, othee of Ad%n<straton. Mr any denials that may be appeased to the Enocutrve Director for Operatens itooi DENYING OFFICIAL TITLE OFFICE RECORDS DENTED APPELLATE OFFICIAL Edward Jordan Director, Office of the "' ~

App. L ["

Analysis and Evaluati ca of Operational Data I

1 l

PART ll D- APPE.AL RIGHTS The denial by each denying of'.cial identdeed in Part fl.C may be appeated to the Appellate Officialidentified in that section. Any such appeal must be en wnting and must be rnade withnt 30 days of receipt of this response. Appeals must be addressed as appropriate to the Executive Director for Operat ons or to the Secretary of the Commisson, U S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC 20555, and should Clearly state on the envelope and in the letter that it is an "Appeal from en In#tial FOtA Deceson.

senc Fone one iperi a is asi U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION

l I

Re: F01A-87-714 APPENDIX K

1. Undated Enclosure 4 to the Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 90 Proposed Final Revisions to Property Insurance Rule, 50.54(w). (19 pages)
2. Undated Enclosure 2 to the Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 80, Offsite Emergency Medical Services. (5 pages)
3. Undated Attachment 2 to Enclosure 2 Compilation of CRGR Recomendations for Changes to Proposed Policy Statement.

(3pages)

4. Undated Enclosure 3 to the Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 98, Review of Proposed Resolution for USI A-46, Seismic Qualification of Equipment in Operating Plants. (67 pages)
5. Undated Enclosure 2 to the Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 82, CRGR l Review of the Proposed Final Version of the "Insider Rules".

(15pages) 6 11/25/85 Memo for Bernero, et al., thru Sniezek from Taylor, subject: Sumary and Issue Identification for CRGR Heeting No. 83. (7 pages) 1

7. 2/21/86 Memo for Bernero, et al thru Schwink from Cox, subject:

Sumary and Issue Identification for CRGR Meeting No. 85.

(13 pages)

8. 4/16/86 Memo for Bernero, et al, thru Capra from Conran, subject: Sumary and Issue Identification for CRGR Meeting No. 89. (9pages)
9. 5/5/86 Memo for Stello from Sniezek, subject: Minutes of CRGR Meeting Number 89. (39pages)
10. 5/28/86 Sumary and Issue Identification for CRGR Review Item i MeetingNo.90.(4pages) 11, 7/11/86 Sumary and Issue Identification for CRGR Review Item No.

92.(3pages) 1

12. 7/23/86 Minutes of CRGR Memo for Meeting Stello Number 92.from (27Sniezek,)

pages subject:

13. 8/11/86 Memo for Bernero, et al thru Zerbe from Polk, subject:

Sumary and Issue Identification for CRGR Meeting No. 94 (15 pages)

14. 9/9/86 Memo for Stello from Sniezek, subject: Minutes of CRGR Meeting Number 94. (6pages)

l Re: F0!A-87-714 l APPENDIX K j

15. 9/16/86 Memo for Bernero, et al, thru Zerbe from Schwink, subject: Sumary and Issue Identification for CRGR Meeting l No. 96. (5 pages)
16. 10/3/86 Memo for Stello from Sniezek, subject: Piinutes of CRGR Meeting Number 96. (6 pages) 1
17. 10/10/86 Memo for Bernero, et al., thru Zerbe, from Conran, subject: CRGR Meetin Material. (13 pages)g No. 98 - USI A-46 Review, Supplemental
18. 10/14/86 Memo for Bernero, et al., thru Zerbe from Conran, subject: Sumary and Issue Identification for CRGR Meeting No. 98. (5 pages)
19. 12/22/86 Ltr to Sniezek from Smith. (2 pages)
20. 2/3/87 Memo for Bernero, et al., thru Zerbe from Schwink, subject: Sumary and Issue Identification for CRGR Meeting No. 108. (8 pages)
21. 2/13/87 Memo for Beckjord from Sniezek, subject: Proposed Amendment to 10 CFR 50.55a - Codes and Standards. (2 pages) 22, 2/24/87 Ltr to Smith from Sniezek. (2 pages)
23. 5/6/87 Memo for Jordan, et al., thru Zerbe from Conran, subject:

Sumary and Issue Identification CRGR Agenda Items.

Meeting No. 114. (3 pages)

24. 6/10/87 Sumary and Issue Identification CRGR Agenda Item -

Meeting No. 116. (6 pages) l l

l

Re: F01A-87-714 APPENDIX L 1, 12/5/84 Memo for Triner from Sniezek, subject: AIF Comments on NUREG/CR-3840 Relating to Cost Estimates made for USI A-44 (Station Blackout) (Letter dated 11/30/84 to W. Dircks, EDO). (5 pages)- Exemption 5.

2. 5/7/87 Sunnary and Issue Identification, CRGR Agenda Item -

Meeting No. 114. (6 pages) - Exemption 5

3. 5/22/87 Memo for Jordan, et al. , thru Zerbe, from Conran, subject: Summary and Issue Identification CRGR Agenda Item, Meeting No. 115. (6 pages) - Exemption 5
4. 5/27/87 Enclosure 2 to the Minutes of CRGR Meeting No.115, Proposed Final Resolution for USI A-44, "Station Blackout".

(52 pages) - Exemption 5 l

1

g e, ,

l

+.*

HARMON & WEISS 2000 S ST RECT. N.W.

SulTC 430 WAS HINOToN, D.C. GooO9-us5 O AIL MCORE EVY M ARMON TELEPHONE ELLYM R. WCISS (203)388 3800 OIANE CURRAN DE AN R. TOUSLEY ANDREA C. rtRSTER Cetober 20, 1987 W OOM ce INF0 msAt m Director ACI REQuf,st Division of Rules and Records Of fice of Administration U. S . Nuclear Regulatory Commission g g , /dg -43

,7 g- [7 Washington, D.C. 20555 RE: Freedom of Information Act Request

Dear Sir / Madam,

Pursuant to the federal Freedom of Information Act, I hereby request the following on behalf of the Union of Concerned Scientists:

1. All cost-benefit or value-impact analyses done since September,1985 in connection with the consideration by NRC staf f of generic or site-specific backfits.
2. Any and all lists, compilations or other identifications of potential generic or site-specific backfits under consid-eration by the NRC staf f at any time since September,1985.
3. Any and all memoranda or other documents since September 1985, f rom the Committee to Review Generic Requirements

( "CRGR* ) containing requests or direction to the NRC staff to perform, modify or reconsiden value-impact or cost-benefit analyses regarding any potential generic or site- ,

l specific backfit.

l l

4. Any and all documents containing guidance, criteria or l examples used by the NRC in deciding which generic or site-  !

specific backfits are appropriate for cost-benefit analyses 1 under the backfit rule and which are not so appropriate. l l

(y R n m AJ'% -LR R 0 L .L.W W 7W @ ,

, ,, NARMON & WEISS 2-request.

Please call r.e if you have any questions regarding this Very truly yours, ,

jdOb Ellyn k. Weiss HARMON & WEISS 2001 S Street, N.W.

Suite 430 Washington, D.C. 20009 General Counsel Union of Concerned Scientists l

l l

I j

i j

i

_ . - - .

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20148K050&oldid=3361608"