ML20148G990

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Insp Repts.Forwards App B Documents.App a & B Documents Available in Pdr.App C Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5).Addl Info Available Under FOIA-83-408,FOIA-84-556 & FOIA-85-264
ML20148G990
Person / Time
Issue date: 03/23/1988
From: Grimsley D
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
To: Clint Jones
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
Shared Package
ML20148G993 List:
References
FOIA-88-92 NUDOCS 8803290285
Download: ML20148G990 (6)
v • d • e


Text

-* . vu e. s

. U.S. NUCLE?.R REGULATORY COMMISSION su s o a % r. .

p a$e.e t( F01A-88-92

.e s. W '

- t,,

e-5

, RESPONSE TO F EDOM l, ,

Q _I' N'- e-syl'f "

^"

( *****

/ INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST uur u. .s Meg,S-3-1988

u. wee Mr. Charles R. Jones l

PART t.-RECOROS RELE ASED OR NOT LOCATIO (See ca<csed boness No agency records subrect to the roovest base been loca'ed No addrterd agency records subect to ee roovest have been located Agency records subject to the equest that are K.,entded iri Appendes ._ _. 4 e a' reads i.edabie for pub 6c arspettiun and c% cog in the NRC Pubhc Do ment Room.

X

' 7 " S"' N W ***^*S'oa DC Agency records svDrect to tha roovest thet are ider tded in Append.m __ _. _ a o being ~4de a.saabie for ovN icspectir.r ard copyeg in the NRC P bhc %cumect X Room.1717 H Street. N W . W ashegton, DC e a foMe* under the FOiA number sec reowester aame The nonpropretars version of the pinpes.av- that you ayeed te accept e a te+ececce coasersat.on m th a memter of my staM is no* WN noe avt 'able fut pubbc escecton and coyeg at ur e NRC Pubhc Cocums.'t n.1717 H Street N A . Washegtoe DC . e a folde* nder tAs 50:A evrber as1 *eowc eame Enclosed rs eformaton on ben you may ottae sccess to and the cha'ges for cocvieg ecceds placed e t*e NRC Puohe Document Acm 1717 H S'<eet. N W . Was*.ngton. OC Agency records st.bect to the 'em.est a o enclosed Am appbcat e cha*ge 'o< cop +5 c Pe recor7s provided a^4 canwet p ocedw es a o coed in tre comments sect,on Records su'l ect to the request have bee 1 referred to another Fede al agencybest for 'es va aM dsect resporse to you In v4* of NRC s 'espoesa to this request no fur ?v actce is teq tanea on accq ePer cated ___ _ _ . _ _ _ _ . _

PART U A-INFORM ATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC OISCLOSURE Ce .a.n into, yon .n re 'mes ed rums 4 berg .tnreid f,om w< dee p,. 5.a-i io re <0 A eie tws m:.+ed e . - <., e reasor s stated in Pan ii. sec tent 8. C. sad D AT', fe4 eased pcWofs of the documeets fo' *M oNy Da't of ?* e:Ord 4 be79 *@hefd 4 s C+ng rea$e avaaa;* */ pubhc especton and copgeg in the NRC P t Ac Occumet Foc* 1717 H P eet N W . Was*gon DC. .n a feder caer tNs FO' A n umbe> aad westar eame Comtnents Add l tic: : records related to the subject of your request have previously been addrened under F01 A-83-408, F01 A-84-556, and F01 A-85-264 and are available for public inspection and copying in the NRC's Public f.ocument Room.

I i

8803290285 FOIA 080323 PbR PDR JONESe e -Oh,

- A . . . . _ . .

$4satt ~ a .

dEGTOR Ove jg A . ,

3l,,

^

' " 2 r_;,y __. y, [' a n * .. ks' .--:: ; $ -

5 ..

NEC FORM 464 Peo 4 it >

B FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT RESPONSE FOtA NUMBERrSi 88-92 PA$tiil 8- APPLICABLE FOIA EXEMPTIONS o^t M R 2 3 %

Records subject to the request that are described an the enclosed Appendices b __ are beng withheld b. their entwety or in part under FOf A Emsmpt.ons and for the reasons set forth below pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552(b) and 10 CFR 9 Sla) of NRC Regulatons.

1. The wthheld mformaton is raporty classfed pursvant to Esecutive Order 12356 IEXEMPTf0N 11 2 The wthheed m'ormaton redates solety to the etemal personnel nAes and procedu res cf NRC. (EXEMPTION 21
3. The wthheid anformaton a specnfca#v esempt from public doctosure by statute indicated. IEXEMPTION 3i Secten 1411a5 of the Atomic Energy Act whch prohbts the disclosure of Restncted Data or Former+y Restricted Data (42 U S C. 21612165L Secten 1a7 of the Atom.c Energy Act which ;)tohbts the deciosyre of Unclassifed Safeguards 6nforma'en ta2 U S C. 2167L
4. The wthbend eformation e a trade secret or commercel or fennces eformaton that a beeg wthband for the reason ' andicated' (EliMPTION 41 s

The information a conseered to be conf 4ectel business foropreta vi eformaton.

The eformaton a consdered to be proonetary eformaten pe swantr to 10 CFR 2 790id3tti.

The informatuto was submitted and recerved in conteence from a fore.gn source pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790+ds2s

5. The whheid eforw4 ton corsats of eteragency or etraaaency records that are not evadadie through d.scovery ownng btgation. Doctsure of predec sonal informaten would tend to meet the open and frank enchange of deas essent.at to the debberative process. Where reco ds are ethbeid m thee entirett the facts are inestricaoN intertwined wth the edeC$onal .nfntmaton. There also are no reasonably segregabie factual pof' tor's because the release of the facts would perrrut an endirect nowicy eto t predeciscFaf Drocess o( 'he agency (EX EMPTION i 6 The wthhou eformaton o enamoted from public d sclosure teca se ris d4 closure would resw et e a cieany v e *a~ anted evasen of rarsonal omecy (EXEMPTION 61
7. The wthheid eformaton consets of evestigatory records compaed for law enforcerneet purposes and 4 bemg weeid for the reasontsi edcated. dE.XEMPTION 7s Discloswre croyed ete14ere wth an edorcement proceeding because d could reveal the scope, defecten, and focus of erdorcement efforts and thus could possCly ailow them to take acten to sneld potentel *roegdoeng or a violation of NRC reownem nts w from eve t>gators. (EXEMPTION 71 An Oisclosure wowde constitute an unas ranted evason of personal pervao (EXEVPTION 7tCO The informat.>e cons 4ts of names of ind .idwais and other informaton the d sclosure of *nich we cd reveal ceatities of confidental sources. (EXEMPTION 7tDo PART 11 C-DENYING OFFICIALS Pursw .t to 10 CFR 9 9 and or 915 of the U S Nociest Regulatory Cormosen regutetens. n has been ortermined that the e'ormaton ethheld o enempt from producten or disclowe.

r and thatof Onnson itsRs.s producten or dOne aroeco,ds. sclosu e o coetra*yfortosev of uminstraton, thedemas owblicmat eterest may The be appepersors ed torespons;o,te for the to,

e. E=ec+e Orrecio, denial s't those Operaiens oMc+s identif.ed teicw as denyng offscens noo, MNgG OmCIAL TITLE OmCE RECOROS DEVED APPELLATE OWCIAL SFca g y a sty goo James A. Fitzgerald Asst. General Counsel for App. C x Adjudications and -

Opinions

~

s PART 11 D APPEAL RIGHT;.

The denial by each denyog of'icW ident4ed in Part II.C may be appealed to the Appellate Official identif.ed in that section, Any such appeal must be in writing and must be made within 30 days of receipt of this response. Appeals murt be addressed as appropnate to the Esecutive Ovector for Operations or to the Secretary of the Commisson, U.S. Nuclear Regutatsy Commis,sion, Washington, DC 20555, and should clearfy state on the envelope and in the letter that.it is an "Appeal from, i - an inital FOIA Decision."

Mac FoRea ese tPa,i rl is asi U.d. NUCLEAR REOULATORY COMMISSION FOIA RESPONSE CCNTINUATION

A

, Re: FOIA- 83-92 _

APPENDIX A RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG PDR FILES NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION Categories One. Two, ard Five

1. 6/8/87 Inspection Repert 50-267/87-12 Accession No. 8706160054
2. 7/30/17 Inspection Report 50-285/87-15 Accession No. 8708040419
3. 1/27/88 Inspection Report 50-285/87-29 Accession No. 8802030160 4 1/27/88 Letter to NRC fron R. L. Andrews,

Subject:

Special Report on Inoperability of Fire Door 1011-4 Accession No. 880202095

5. 1/28/88 Inspection Report 50-285/87-33 Accession No. 8802020297
6. -

Inspection Report 50-346/87-14 Accessien' No. 87093003S9

7. -

Notice of Violation Accessier No. 8507160655 Listed below are inspection procedures which are available in the PDR. They should be requested under NRC Inspectics Manual.

6400 Fire Preventien/ Protection 64051B Procedures - Fire Preventior./ Protection 07/01/79 (CN 79-13) 64053B Fire Locp Installation 07/01/79 (CN 79 13) 64100 Postfire Safe Shutdown, Emergency Lighting and Oil Collection Capability at Operating and Neat-Terri Operating Reactor Facilities 03/16/87 (CN 87-09) 64150 Trienn ul Postfire Safe Shutdown Capability ReVerif tcation 03/26/87 (CN 87-09) 64704 Fire Protectien/PreYention Program 02/12/86 (CN 86-08)

Cateaory Three

1. 9/17/85 SECY-35-306 "Staff Recomendations Reaardina the Inolementation of Appendix R to 10 CFR 50," Acc. No. 8510150157
2. 3/11/86 Memo for Comissioner Asselstine from Victor Stello, Jr.,

subject: "SECY-85-306 - Staff Recommendations Regarding the Implementation of Appendix R to 10 CFR 50," Acc. No. 8603170475 1

Re: F0IA- 33-92 APPENDIX _A (cont'd)

RECORDS MAINTAlt!ED AMONG PDR FILES

' NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION Category Six 1 8410040113 v50s.0213 NRRD 84/09 67540 R e s.ip on d s to 840224 di f ier ing pr of opintun i DF O s re fare 260 pret ec t i on. L1 censee has pr c.v1 da:rd edequate Justat1cet 2 8512230205 NRRC 85/12 34037 R e s,por id s to 840502 dafferang prof optn1on (DFO) re new 236 interpretations of-App R concerning fire protection 3 8512230366 NRRE 84/95 34038 Nottfacatton of 840508 meeting w/Denton b NRR f1re VC's protection engtneer to discuss di f f er 1 rig prof opinio 4 8512030391 NRRJRIC 85/02 34038 Subnit t s ststus of daffering prof optn1on (DPO) re 030 interpretation of App R. Requests e:: t ens i on of schedu 5 8604250085 NE RO 85/10 35735 Respcnds to Coa.a.1ssion 551 of.' request ior d1ffertng prof 060 opinton iDFO) .Or a ginat or s wil l wrate summary s t e t e.rie nter N, f 4E XT , FREV. S + ar Saa e or N for New i n d es: , or D to chenge dtsplays . , _

0005 out of 00007 Rc+elts of Seerch , ,

Inc # } ey i n d et- value Date Issued MF Addr 1 8606260332 NE ED 85/11 367'9 Advsses of f11ang of difforsnq pr of opinton (DFO) re 24 proposed interpretettons of App R concerning fire pr 2 8606260338 NIED 85/11 *6799 I

i l

1 i

l l

1 1

Re: FOI A- 88-92 APPENDIX B RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE ABOVE REQUEST NUMBER NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION

1. 7/1/81 Fire Protection / Prevention Program Implementation Revision
  1. 64704 (4 pages) - (enclosed)
2. 8/15/81 Fire Protection /Preventior Program Implementation Revision
  1. 64704 (4 pages) - (enclosed) l l

1 l

Re: F01A. 88-92.

APPENDIX C RECOROS TOTALLY. WITHHELD NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION

1. 5/29/84 Memorandum from Trubatch to Garner, Joosten, Chestnut.. Austin, Meyer, subject: "Guidance for Implementation of Fire Protection Requirements for Operating Reactors, 10 CFR 50, Appendix R," (7 pages) - Exemption 5
2. 10/9/84 Memorandum from Trubatch to Garner, Chetnut, Austin, Meyer,.

Clausen, subject: "Nuclear Utility Fire Protection Groups Comments on-Proposed' Interpretation of Fire Protection Requirements in 10 CFR Part 50, Appendix R," (6pages)-

Exemption 5

3. 10/24/85 Memorandum from Malsch:to Palladion, Roberts, Asselstine, Bernthal, Zech, subject: "Staff Interpretations of-Appendix R,"

(20 pages) - Exemption 5 I

[

i i

t v

f t

l

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20148G990&oldid=3361919"