ML20148G778
| ML20148G778 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Millstone, Dresden, Palisades, Oyster Creek, Haddam Neck, Ginna, San Onofre, Yankee Rowe, La Crosse, Big Rock Point  |
| Issue date: | 01/18/1978 |
| From: | Ziemann D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Eisenhut D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8011130358 | |
| Download: ML20148G778 (6) | |
Text
'
('.;
^
JAN 181978 MEMORANDUM FOR:
Darrell G. Eisenhut, Assistant Director for Operational p
Technology, DOR THRU:
Dennis L. Zimann, Group Leader, Systematic Evaluation Program Review Group, D0R l
FROM:
Richard D. Silver, Systenatic Evaluation Program Review Group, D0R SUR1ECT:
SUM!%RY OF MEETING ON JANUARY 5,1978, TO DISCUSS THE SYSTEMATIC EVALUATION PROGRAM (SEP) REVIEW OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION OF ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT On January 5,1978, the 3RR staff met with representatives of the licensees involved in Phase 11 of the SEP to discuss the review of environmental qualification of electrical equipment.
The meeting was. a followup to our letters to the licensees dated December 23,
,1977, on the sane subject.
A list of attendees is presented in Enclosure 1.
]
D. Eisenhut, Assistant Director for Operational Technology DDR, nade the presentation for NRC.
Mr. Eisenhut discussed the background leadin't to the December 23, 1977 letter, the relationship of the review of the environmental qualification to the renainder of the SEP, the content 4
of the sutnittals to be rade in response to our December 23 letter and 1
the NRC plan of action for conpleting the review of the subject.
Mr. Eisenhut emphasized the following points:
l 1.
MRC has reviewed enviror.nental qualification of electrical equip 1ent at operatino plants previously; at some plants nore than once.
The total SEP is expected to include NRC's final review of this topic for the eleven plants in the SEP.
2.
Since the December 23 letter was issued, the staff has perfor:ned a detailed search of docketed information and has accumulated
'I i
a considerable amount of information which had been sutritted during previous reviews.
V THIS DOCUE.iENT C0t!TliiNS POOR QUW N.GE3 l
l 80111&o 3 s e
!j
(
Darrell G. Eisenhut Jff! 10 G78 3.
Environmental qualification licensing criteria for construction pemits have changed since the staff last reviewed environmental qualification at these plants. The NRC staff will review existing qualification infomation to see if consideration of current criteria would change our previous determinations of acceptability.
4.
The submittels should include the licensees' rationale supporting its conclusions regarding the acceptability of equipment and acceptability of safety nargins.
5.
NRR review teams will visit each plant in aHut two or three weeks.
The teans will include members of the SEP Group, electrical instrumentation specialists, and the DDR Operating Reactor Project Manager of each plant.
Mr. Madden oave a prepared statenent on behalf of the owners of eight of the eleven plants in the program.
He expressed great concern thet a segregated review of individual topics would destroy the approach for integrated plant review which is basic to the 5ystematic Evaluation
/
Program.
- t. _ 3.i..u.;3 tY
' Y. c k %D. c( IJ N1M G Riclard D. Silver Systematic Evaluation Program Review Group Division of Operating Reactors
Enclosure:
List of Attendees cc w/ enclosure:
See next page m
gg ma:st?'
x Og
.Rol ve nan DLziec. ann.
Os but 0
1/8/78 1//4/78 l{
8
v 3-JAP ' e ic?$
cc w/ enclosure:
Dairyland Power Cooperative Rochester Gas & Electric Corporation ATTN:
Mr. John P. Madgett ATTN:
Mi Leon D. White, Jr.
General Manager Vice President 2615 East Avenue, South' Electric and Steam Production La Cresse, Wisconsin 54601 89 East Avenue Rochester, New York 14604 Northeast Nuclear Energy Company ATTN:
Mr. Donald C. Switzer Connecticut Yankee Atomic Power President Company P. O. Box 270 ATTN:
Mr. Donald C. Switzer, President Hartford, Connecticut 061 01 Post Office Box 270 Hartford, Connecticut 06101 Jersey Cer. tral Power & Light Company ATTN:
Mr. I. R. Finfrock, Jr.
Vice President - Generation Madison Avenue at Punch Eowl Road Morristown, New Jersey 07960 Commonwealth Edison Company ATIN:
Mr. R. L. Bolger Assistant Vice President y
Post Office Box 767 Chicago, Illinois 60690 Consumers Power Company ATTh:
Mr. David A. Eixel Nuclear Licensing Administrator 212 West Michican Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49201 Southern California Edison Conpany ATTN:
Mr. James H. Drake Vice President 2244 Walnut Grove Avenue Post Office Box 800 Rosemead, California 91770 Ycnkee Atonic Electric Co pany ATTN:
Mr. Robert H. Groce Licensing Engineer 20 Turnpike Road Westboro, Massachusetts 01581 g
l l
ENCLOSURE LIST OF ATTENDEES SYSTEKATIC EVALUATION PROGRAM ENVIRDNMENTAL QUALIFICATION OF ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT MEETING - JANUARY 5,1978 NRC Yankee Atomic Electric Company D. Eisenhut F. Greenman D. Ziemann J. Stacey N. Anderson S. Bryan Rochester Gas & Electric Corporation P. DiEenedetto H. Fontecilla G. Daniels R. Klecker C. Mambretti H. Schierling R. Mecredy J. Shea
.R. Silver Northeast Utilities R. Cudlin J. Guibert L. Davison D. Mcdonald B. Ilberman E. Reeves S. Nowicki Consumer,s Power Company G. Lear W. Russell R. Cherba G. Vissing L. Hausler
- 1. Wambach W. Beckius J. Slider D. Bixel T. Carter Jersev Central P ;er & Ligh_t_Coyany J. Telford 3
D. Tondi D. Davis T. Crimmins, Jr.
G. Zech D. Ross R. Bevan T. Tipton K. Goller T. Madden A. Szukiewicz J. Burdoin Co,nonwealth Edison Company B. Grimes R. Reid M. Turbak L. Shao L. Reiter Southern California Edison Company E. Butcher W. Moody K Baskin
2 Westinghouse D. Lorentz R. Miller T. Christopher Nuclear Energy Services R. Milos Dairyland Power Cooperative E. Trennel W. Nowicki R. Shimshak l
l l
l
(
_0ISTRIBUT10N n
DOCKET FILES (50-10/40-2'9'/f 0-155/50-?06/50-213/50-219 50-237 / RQ44 / 50-245/ 50-255/ 50- 409 )
NRC POR Local POR NRR Reading E. Case V. Stello K. Goller R. Baer W. Butler B. Grimes L. Shao
- 0. Ziemann A. Schwencer
- 0. Davis G. Lear SEP Reading File S. Sheppard R. Diggs C. Parrish R. Ingram A. Burger T. Wambach G. Zech W. Russell R. Bevan E. Reeves J. Hannon S.. Nowicki G. Vissing N. Anderson S. Bryan P. DiBenedetto H. Fontecilla R. Klecker H. Schierling J. Shea R. Silver OELD R. F. Fraley, ACRS (16)
I&E (3)
.