ML20147F102

Forwards Value/Impact Assessment to Provide Guidance to Applicants in Meeting Minimum Requirements for Containment Isolation of Fluid Sys

ML20147F102
Person / Time
Issue date:	12/31/1978
From:	NRC OFFICE OF STANDARDS DEVELOPMENT
To:
Shared Package
ML20062F876	List: ML20062F875 ML20147F102
References
REGGD-01.141, REGGD-1.141, NUDOCS 7812210321
Download: ML20147F102 (3)

Text

.

insda.w ')i O

' - VALUE/IMPACiSTATEMEf1T I. The Proposed Action 1. .

. A. Description - The proposed action will provide guidance to -

/ .

applicants in meeting the miniinum requirements for containment isolation of fluid systems. '

B. fleed for the Proposed Action - The SRP gives current staff

. 2 .

~

practices. For this important t'opic, it would be desirable to

~

_s.. .,, .

issue a regulatory guide in order to afford a wider public review of this topic. A national concensus standard has been developed which could provide the technical basis for this guide. - .

e-

~

C. Value/ Impact of the Proposed Action -

1. 11RC operations 'Since th'e guide reflects current licensing

.. .,;z .,. ~. .~. : ? - ,

• ~ ,

practice, no impact on flRC operations is anticipated. _ '

.) ..

2. Other Government Agencies - tiot Applicable. " 'i ' '

t

~ '

. l

' i l

3. Industry - Same as for 11RC operations. .. l

+

4. Public - tiot Applicable

• 781221 32/' ' '

/ ".' -

.. c .

. j' .'

. . , 1 . .

~ -

D. Decisio,n"on the Proposed Action .

Guidance should be furn'ished on containment isolation of fluid . -

Systems.. * . . . H' '

. ,~

m : 1:::, h i ~ ' . * . '. . '. .

TY *-l. ,,. . . ej[., c.'V'"..

- ~' ,

~*

1

. .w ..

.. .i.. :.s ; .. . . .

r ..... : . . y. ..,.,.. .

o.

~ .. .

.......m Technical Ap. .. .

, , II. proa,ch .

.' c

w . n . . .

...u .

. . .. . ~ . . 2 , a.

A. Technical Alternatives ..;. . .

Since the guide gives the current methods used to meet the

. . y, . . . .

i:

. ..~.: . . . .

t. regulations, no techni. cal.. alternatives are now being considered. .

j-

, , , . . , . - . 4 ..

. " " '. . ....a.

,' ,1 -

... ,, J + , , . . ,

,.,v.,,.....

un.. ,.:.. , . .

....4 .s...- . .. . e

.. .. - < =-

.2 . . . . . . ' .

... . ..s .

,. f .< , . . . .... , . . .

B. Discussion.and Comparison of Technical Alternatives

. .. . .. 7. y . . .. .. ,

Not .s.

Applicable . ' - ' ". M ~t.. ' .

{!

- ,. .. .. c ..

,.9'..... . ...., . . .  ;

.a . .. .. u,- ...?-- l: .

.?.,

-t/ . ,.

~ ... . .

lIl w . .:. . m. .. .

,1 C.

Discussion .,

of Technical..l Aiproach .

l e i. . . -

,e. . . . ',..,'..t.,;.,..w.,w, ., , , s' ' .

• j . . i

~ .;. T' c 5; Not Applicable ..aA% - .

=

( .

m. .s.

..u.

4

.. .. . .~

..-. . - . . ~ . . . . . . . .w.w , ..u ..;;..y',c.a.

< . . . . - ... a+ .... ..e.;.~

1 n

x.- ..

+

t H '. -

l I I I . P. ~.ro. +c.,~:., e dg u, ral:p.App . . , . . . ,. r.,o _ %.. a s. c,h .' ,. ,., ~ '. . .., - . '. ~ .. ;':'."; . . .. . '. %; . . ... '

-1

..s . ..

Procedural Alternatives A. .., -

-~. .

s

. . . . .. c.

- ... . ... . . .;.a.

Potential SD procedures that may be~ used to promulgate the

..(

~

m .,i .

. . .:: . . .c . ~ .

3' propose'd action and t'echnical approach include the following: $. 5 I . : .. ," - . , -

. . . t

( . .- .. - . '

" Regulation . :

- ' Preparation or Revision of Reg. Guide

.i 1

ANSI Standard, endorsed by a Reg. Guide j v'

,.-f.'. .. .

~

=

z .:;, f .

NUREG Report " .

.. c .. .

[

~

c m, .a . . .

' n . '.y - . ..

-- .* }

Branch Position,

,.,c'....

m s

s. *'

, , , . 4

-e- . .

,.c, ,'

r g j

.ed... *r. g .** .

,, , , j

., .,. n. . . - - .

r f ,. , . . . . . . ,

. .. ll

. . W;' : *.

i

.' . ., ....; f. 2...- -

. . _ .. c.:

)

. . . . ~ l

.. s ,

, c .: ,.

B. Value/ Impact of Procedural Alternatives The endorsement of the~ standard is the most efficient alter-

_ . ' , f native since it requires the least amount of time and effort to accomplish the task.

s t e

l 9 9

b 9 -

i l

4

- e l

" e t 9

f f

e ,

e 1

• l s

.

• s  !

, s ,

e

, b 4

9 er, t'

, . 1 1

.t '.

,4 - l

.r, .

1

1. 9 s

08 e

= . ..'

1. t

', > s

.. e f,

• • W 9 4 I g M t , e ,, , e p 9 b 6 . *

$ q

- - v. .

s,.. . . f'

, .u -.': .

s g' 3 . . ;

t * .

&' 9 8 9 .

• ,t g, .I .s - 4. .* #

,,g, + - **J . s ,, e p- .s..

,, , .