ML20147E336

Forwards Figures Depicting Inspec & Enforcement Indicators Based on Noncompliance for 1976 & 1977 for BWRs & Pwrs. Notes Unusually Low or High Indicators in long-term Are Not Offset by Sharply Improved short-term Performance

ML20147E336
Person / Time
Issue date:	10/26/1977
From:	Howard E NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
To:	Volgenau E NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE)
Shared Package
ML20147E325	List: ML20147E319 ML20147E336
References
FOIA-78-250 NUDOCS 7812210044
Download: ML20147E336 (6)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:t. ( (i). - Octobor 26, 1977 .~ HEMORfADUM FOR: Ernst Volgcnau, Director Offico o? Inspzetion & Enforecmont. HQ FROM: E, llorris Howard, Director, Region IV, IE ~ SUNECT: LICENSEE I!GPECTIO:l AND ENFORCEMENT..INDICriT0?.S UPDATE Encloscd are four figuren depicting inspection and enforecasnt indicators, based solely on nonccmplianca, covering tha pe* Qds January 1,1975 L through Juna 30, 1977 cod January 1, 1977 th','ough June 30, 1977, for both BWR's and PWR's. It it. interestinD to noto that unusually low or high indicetors in the long teral (Janutry 1,1976 through Juna 30, l977) are not off-set by drantically 1pproved parlonmuce in tha sho"t term. Indian Point is en er.collent c:'.c'.'pla of thort term improvem0nt with tha long tem rctord continuin] to rei'loct tha enusually brd rccerd.in Calendar Year 1973. The long run trend is a valuablo teol in datemining the irorovc..ecnt or degrtidction of a cit 0's rccord when cc:npared with a short tem ovaluation. These trends might also be ustd to detemino the offect of significant enforCG'ont action, which in uhnt occurred at Indian Point and Zien in tha second-h';lf of M76, with Indien Point she' ing marked improvcont in the first-hclf of 1977 and Zion sbauir.g n inarked dorin trcn'.1 in tia seca period. It will ha intoranting to detomitio the offcet of the IE caforco-uent activition on Zion's rocord in subscquent evaluations. Thoro nro' unlimited possibilitics which could be investigated with a strong robtibility thab reasona'olo, statistically cupportable, cenclusinna could be resched concerning tha liconceo's activitics, program ciYoctiva-IlGSS Ond P0pioilul inspO3Cion pOrfomancG. ' S There may nlso be a hint as to how the inspectnrn parcoivo the licensect mancgment 6ttitudes, particularly where there is a low subjcctiva rating und only a single deficicacy for cycr four hundred hours of inspectica offort. Tha conve.rno also occurred. .f 3 ,l s 'se

• I N*

781221GO 9' ' ~ o l o. t ~ anmse ~

.. A:. L ' E'rnst Volgenau, IE:MQ 2 October 26, Ifr/7- ....? 7'..; k.* { .w.- ... :,w:.n It is rascibin to drw conclusions over.thb individual functional areas, i.-2@Y4 an@f. 1,U8..t. most clot.a'ly by infennco fro 6 the total score for each functional !E at'ca. 1,: .w.e f g ' I.will ba glad to discuss any or all of these areas at your convenience...J ?.fr 2

wwg77 i;..

painas w ay. ...q:;,9; ,.,....... y. m.m.1. w

s w., noe. w,e ~;. ::

_......,.. n. Q,.,..,. _ v . -'cy.;.;7,y. / . s;.. r rw E. Iorcis.Howar.d .;.q <.t.*., gj poctop. <...,.y),w':tt;<; n. :. g. 6n.y Np r. . s. * .... >. *;. '.s. .,... mna..,:. ..j, .S. . b.C. y!. t.,.iq y : 1. t.. (;;.,y.,.

Enclosures:

i. c P

l' 1. Rolling Mctor Reactors . January T.197G Thru Juna 30,1977

d. :

2. Colling Water noncton. - Fir::t Half 1977 ? 3. PNr.urimd thtor Reactors - Januuty 1,1976 Thra Juna 30, 1977-n., ; '. ' 4. Pressurizcd !!ater Reactors - First Half 1977 7.~4p v.g,

.:.....,.. v., s s:.n....g:

... ;...1.~:; : e..< 4e Q. G. Davic, IE:HQ, u/ enclosures , 3"..,.'. < . fr.j,'[2.., cc: .*. =. ( fa .,'1,.3.,f 4,y. .,v 7t ; ' .;. ' + ..r.;e. .....x . eq ' W.7. : 73 s. + ,.e..

- *!,b.h,.

.'h' g ..y.c.

n

.s... p.1

3.,.p; G.../...

. 4.,.. .; : - r

.e<

... :.,S.;t..m 3.,. :.. f4 .3 ..f ..:., 3, .. ~ v4 .h,:..,k ?:.1

• ...,'t.,

.;;y f

4.,., ' '

',.,$,,'? ',*h*, %. '.G. A.r.'.. ~. .d s* ,o fM,., D. ;t.,.. s ..r.. ..'.Lt... yl:., A.y e,-

r..

• * ~

l ..s.g. g L ...w. .'<- r.t... v.,.,. s . y.,. v..

d)..y.l, o.

. '. :. i.,.. a. 7.~. '. s,... .c.. .3.. . g3 ~ . ~g s.: v ,.j,..:....:.;y. 9.,,:.4 . ~ '.. v. \\.s:. v. ...a., 1 '. . :p.s!. 9 \\ .. t,;,. e .. s. ,,..i.4*- 'e 3, ' ..e. ,%.'.T %%,...,m. P - - 91I. O

h,...e. _... _ _. U -.4. i M. . Q9 34 b D M rd + D-O 3; 86 Z 'M .h..:[5 MW. N U .7 U ((y[;e.... N$E-WQ.'*p""f fb $'s3':'"'.J:,. J i w b 0 5 b...:.n,, T#3h.. py ;r:' ... ~ ~ v M g s,,

• . m..q+s: -

v.' r1 &Q,;f;,;M

b-W.?Tfq;,'

s nn s N G?%e .O ? W ,v. re p O a-s. 2 h {. f. M P \\U s ~d ? R -? 4 3 4 X, M.' f .o.a. P4 3 'd

• t N

q bc W o, u 2: en S .o t',0, * . o ?$ * $$ M 9 Y A e 2 M o ..h 13 H a* \\Q* re V. t% 1d p e. nc et x y i t d tv. 44 l*. C.a LA. m b., m. ~. 4. ts tw e 3 m so. m. to. W. Lt> Q O (J e V) 80 p ta q c,a o t a w=. o = c 4 c o-. cs di o O 4 e e a e I8 8 a I s hl t' 4 t-e 2 I! 3 l b'./.L' n +-, .c E' 'rt d o).c8 GQ (6 r)(L v. 4 .G t) C:) bb .En J, .d. a a.4% m c,4 o c < p.a.> ,G,O.2*d *d c3 t eY 1o ad af b 'r.1 o (t s c.r .I d 4 *d 4 M O m n. 3 HA c3 F m.6 s.'n eJ r.t to dG* op c) <d i U) J 4 :l av h-M t> o ts Vu M Cf4 0 0 %q %;f4!. h 4. OM% .....+,. .. so o.a M a4 an so tw ...., e. e4 m =52- % m tw to tr. +-- e-. m a m +-. W w '.,. e...... ..m--... .g... C 43 'O O t3 f. . c.J N q to co .eqa-M N e.4 1

a.: : ~ ^ x.. + .

• a:

.eA, G'J y 9 e .e mo 5 / 6.,-c-r4 Q:!pgO, ",' figblS,%. %,,: f J..a 9-u '4 4Q 5 ?. A . s?h .?: f.}... o g .c+qsh .r aws 2 e j W x. = $913 $ *0H ' os .-4 tw t'. th + NJ 'A h g-4 4 M rJ }. O e.n 31 Cl s 7 k ~ l N O t p + O D3 t* bd n, 'A C 2 44 W, = ttO =g 14 sa ~ M e O ~ $3 ao 4 N

• I N,

H 2 iT Td u 84 O sft m v

m. t. to N N. O t>> e4 eks. C. ed. C. o N.*

• • . n g

o ta o ca c o Q Q Q 4 O c c +. w ta o4 e-. e-. e 4 8 4 4 4 4 8 i Mt n.") g 9 va-Ti 'Q d d]') Ta W Cad JI d tJ L* c) t) *Q s* N 4.6 p ga 5' M ) Q *sj e ga t4 d 4 o e A O. *d,i ed; 4y (s.) kJ

• y r* s).g

. ej = l t-s. m 't1.(n) C4 r. l t -* o.y.* .i e 44 tl A-NO U t.) ) SL

• d t f.')

rI de' O t 4 e.j G Q G.x,L' *1J: ( o () t)fc

• o t,

4 k_:*(v f.# O 3 M C 4 h 4, o J2-A4 m- .....,, e, w N to N sti % tw M m w w.,~-..v ,*-_. m ds.s . <*> w w m .y 4.n s..,. w c c3 o O c Q + d ..rea - me. n

..n-- .g. 4.. s n..,.- + d o>.'.,,..::..... $ i *... vs. ',. sY -0 E.w,- ...>..:,Yh.W.I. 1 s:<; - o 9 s ...e ! OM,i, ;.... 'l.. O ' w.,, p.th oM ,. g N Mv.:w ' ab4M.lb.[.;;3jh-h 'd m.m ) n '?.u..D .g. 'm co y -s '

t..

d os. 'e 9 satts ati .Q O oa en tu J M w eq % e. p . e e .M 3 ooh ** i e

2 O

. at) - N

• n.

ta !? p

• 7,
• .o u)

Q ( o n w tA s n a = Y Y en u 4 c Ci +u - w o 4 a c = A. c4 m 25 ~ F M, .re S **2 % 2 d ot H O t-U. g f UU l** g y s1 t o. a. q eg. M t

• o w rw to

' w o.: w c4 9 o. q ris a v4 La e M ' e,.0 ~ 5 -';7. p. ik) w o, ' '2 e.: if d 9 'io e.s fo t,u m tu v. m. try. w w m a d 'a v v W.5 l r/2 = a s e e e a e c W' N ..a IM f.) N Q va. N O W h h Ch Q,-. Q Q - Q D Q Q Z e d 1 8 0 $ 8 I I 8

• Se,

.;-l to o p us e, N .cs t-4 ma 'tt, -4 ) b N i u.1, s* 'tj %L s m 1 .o tJ 4 d4 d e3 O' t I r* r. r* O d 7 :] d .r:8 ?? clb 11 r.}

• Q
• 4

= l'Vi oo .4 >-4 a 1 .d d u) in ' t-u '<. 7 y D. p <.'ti ( CD D .4. t. oh 6 t La G 'n t 'n t, n c. e3 ~ ds <h

• 1 ti dv

. 4J e h.t Q O l UO a A* r* d e

2 i ' r0 ta v.r. ' 'cd (f; s)e 4

I ic' t7 o.. d ';i

• , o P
• s t 4 1

8 t, o.c od* O 4 ub O C H b. d' 4.: h. Q v) %j a %: j u r4 r t~ r 4 Q ,.N.o w an % W to c e-, m - n %.m N uo a:n, .e3 % eN to ay m -. wsw c's C (*) O C3 O. c,2 I O Ch in up n; e4 I $?NI]cNY00??0N 05.))l0&lh

au ~J .; :l s e s m n NO

• ?,

-4 ~ \\ N$ A-O3 3 4 y e c .t .~, 1 "S 1 m .H. -$ '9 x 4 2 e$ d, + ~ 4 d 9 a3 J U6 $f N , ei N.i j4 I + iur..M I $.[ fj;n.'t@ < hq f 4.' TW,pj$p.; es tw ( g hdddd,;..Qt sMIN$isk~g.uolO N S o3 l

pry r %;g w

6 gggg %

x. m $3;yfq: n..i m p m ;p. 4 O(b5 ~ 'hk E. 1 T'1 ".~ W. N O eo N a i 'e e ag e c. s

• a O

C4 .? m e a.o N O 4 v N a. O c,'a 5 3 L 15 'OH .

• c4

-c e) H o u'l s;: CD (Ld 343 v4 p{ 4 0Q r.*, O. C4 e. 'n

• to ty 3( w N

2 -<4 W* 4} C 4 23 .. v m k. c. o m .e.. en e6 e, tu g n. y N NNN H 4 l M $l) .e rd i a c/. M.3*o +4. %. +4. m., N to t> m. 4. e-. e-. t An. cr m.3. w. 5. to, + e. va o b, dj C2 N O O N N Q (N CM Q Q = t;3 tb w Q C'a Ca Q Q e e a 4 4 4 a t a 3 ge4 ew M.

• T M

w w s vs 'I g w 12 'tj ,o cJ rJ 4y 4-{ s* H 61 M.t).tt 'Q s A, r r3 c.) rp 0 .c d .t s o it ~ t> .o.t ed t-4 . e. e u cJ tl M.o N C4 w G C4.CL e o r> t) d.t e,. h tf c3 b{ h T' % U cJ C 'c! f//. IQ r.9 (_. mg .4yry*b-'s. s Og _ O t

n U eJ r) (3. e4 t d t; M l

42 s ;t ' .r> t.) r* r* 'd' :d !!

1) o s.

a t>' . sf

• Q r.

c;p 74 t* % 4 . 'o t) 7,wto O d M l.$.4),'1*sb t;> u)pa.Abt-9 #:l H. t ** ' c A { - tjt. o' f y o d U l w w en.%.m. o es n o. .s-. N m % m % N os o O .O- . e.... e % e-. w v, v - eq 6 Q C o C O c'8 ca) %? r;;3 to vrf m g SL%f}}