Press Release Discussing Credibility of H & D Stiner Re Welding Practices| ML20141N294 |
| Person / Time |
|---|
| Site: |
Comanche Peak  |
|---|
| Issue date: |
12/18/1984 |
|---|
| From: |
CIRCUIT BREAKER NEWS |
|---|
| To: |
|
|---|
| Shared Package |
|---|
| ML20141N291 |
List: |
|---|
| References |
|---|
| FOIA-85-799 PR-841218, NUDOCS 8603060064 |
| Download: ML20141N294 (1) |
|
|
|---|
Category:ARCHIVE RECORDS
MONTHYEARML20116A0341996-07-17017 July 1996
Rev 0 to Temp Vs Distance Profile for 10 RHR Line Containing Stagnant Water
ML20058Q4061993-08-30030 August 1993
Package Consisting of Employee Concerns Programs
ML20128G9491993-01-22022 January 1993
Calculation of Weights Due to Fire Protection Matl
ML20128G9551992-12-29029 December 1992
Design Validation of Conduits W/Thermolag
ML20128G9861992-10-0202 October 1992
Ampacity of Power Cable Wrapped W/330-660 Installed as Free Air Drop
ML20105A7981992-08-14014 August 1992
Rev 0 to Calculation of Thermal Response for Sprinkler & Raceway Supports
ML20101G0471992-06-17017 June 1992
Rev 3 to Calculation 2-FP-0085 Raceway & Firezone R Cable Supports Analysis
ML20115B6851992-03-0202 March 1992
Rev 0 to 2-NP-GENX-544, Reconciliation of Local Stress Evaluation Using ME215 Analysis
ML20104B4001992-02-13013 February 1992
Rev 1 to Calculation RXE-TA-CP1/0-027, Undervoltage/ Underfrequency Reactor Trip Setpoints
ML20127H2091991-11-12012 November 1991
Calculation 2-NP-GENX-551, Evaluation of NUREG-0797 Suppl 1A (Sser 14) App a Sections 12.1 & 12.2
ML20082U5851991-05-0808 May 1991
Liner Attachment Welds Serviceability
ML20055E2881990-03-12012 March 1990
Package Consisting of Event Notification Worksheet Re 900312 Inadvertent Safety Injection from Single Train.No Equipment Malfunction/Failure Noted
ML20072A8471990-01-23023 January 1990
Rev 2 to Calculation 071, Review Statement for Safety Related Calculations
ML20042D3711989-09-28028 September 1989
Audit Rept ATP-89-146S, Scaling Calculations, on 890821-0928
ML20247G4111989-03-31031 March 1989
Transit Time Flow Meter Calculations
ML20151T3841988-08-0101 August 1988
Protocol Between OSP & NRR for Technical Review of Comanche Peak Fsar
ML20151K5841988-04-18018 April 1988
Page from Draft Rept on Plant Safeteam Activity & Ofc of Investigations Review
IR 05000445/19820141988-03-11011 March 1988
Draft of Insp Rept 50-445/82-14 Originally Withheld from FOIA-84-210 Response & Typing Cover Sheets or Transmittal Pages of Documents Withheld from FOIA-86-181 Response
ML20148F8201988-01-21021 January 1988
Rev 0 to Investigation of SIF for Weld Shrinkage
ML20148F8631988-01-21021 January 1988
Rev 1 to Parallel Snubbers
ML20148F2151987-11-19019 November 1987
Rev 0 to Potential Binding of Lugs in Axial Supports
ML20237K9771987-08-19019 August 1987
Press Release 87-115 Informing of NRC Release of Documents Re Investigation of NRC Actions Involving Plant Under Const. Portions of Documents Deleted for Personal Privacy Reasons or Prospective Personnel Matters
ML20151M9601987-07-20020 July 1987
Package of NRC Administered Requalification Exam Results Summary
ML20148F2521987-05-22022 May 1987
Rev 0 to Evaluation of Fluid Transient Cutoff Forces & Development of Screening Criteria for Piping Sys
ML20237K0381987-05-14014 May 1987
Record of 870514 Telcon W/S&W & Util Re Insp Requirements for Pipe Supports (Ref Item 4,SWEC NA-1140 Rept)
ML20237K0201987-05-13013 May 1987
Record of 870513 Telcon W/S&W & Util Re Insp Requirements for Pipe Supports for Plant.S&W Does Not Consider Insp of Designs to Be Warranted
ML20236M4011987-04-17017 April 1987
Package Consisting of 870417 Request for Premium Cost Mail Svc & Unsigned & Undated Ltr to Util Forwarding Draft Insp Repts 50-445/87-02 & 50-446/87-02 & Notice of Deviation
ML20128G9681987-02-24024 February 1987
Cable Ampacity Derating Factors for Conduits Boxed in W/ Thermolag (TSI Product)
ML20236L9091987-02-19019 February 1987
Rev 1 to CT-1-137-701-S25R, Pipe Support Calculation
ML20236N4981987-02-0202 February 1987
Package Consisting of Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Design Change Authorizations & Evaluation Summaries
ML20207D7231986-12-23023 December 1986
Pipe Support Calculation:General Calculation for Richmond Insert/Tube Steel Connections Design Mods
ML20207D7481986-12-23023 December 1986
Generic Calculation:Evaluation of Npsi Rear Brackets, Dimension for Design Calculation
IA-86-386, Package Consisting of Potential Violations Not Included in Proposed Enforcement Package & Violations of Little Safety Significance Not Included in Proposed Enforcement Package1986-12-16016 December 1986
Package Consisting of Potential Violations Not Included in Proposed Enforcement Package & Violations of Little Safety Significance Not Included in Proposed Enforcement Package
ML20211P4701986-12-16016 December 1986
Package Consisting of Potential Violations Not Included in Proposed Enforcement Package & Violations of Little Safety Significance Not Included in Proposed Enforcement Package
IA-85-799, Partially Withheld Package of Info Re Plant Investigation, Including Draft NRC Ltr to Aslb,Partial Transcript & Handwritten Notes1986-12-0101 December 1986
Partially Withheld Package of Info Re Plant Investigation, Including Draft NRC Ltr to Aslb,Partial Transcript & Handwritten Notes
ML20214R3351986-12-0101 December 1986
Partially Withheld Package of Info Re Plant Investigation, Including Draft NRC Ltr to Aslb,Partial Transcript & Handwritten Notes
ML20235S1101986-11-15015 November 1986
Package of Documents Re Nomination & Authorization for Cash Awards to NRC Personnel Involved W/Insp Efforts Re Implementation of Util Comanche Peak Response Team Program
IA-87-528, Package of Documents Re Nomination & Authorization for Cash Awards to NRC Personnel Involved W/Insp Efforts Re Implementation of Util Comanche Peak Response Team Program1986-11-15015 November 1986
Package of Documents Re Nomination & Authorization for Cash Awards to NRC Personnel Involved W/Insp Efforts Re Implementation of Util Comanche Peak Response Team Program
ML20210E5991986-11-0707 November 1986
Rev 2 to Calculation 020-040-M19, Clip Stiffness Production Value
ML20210E6811986-10-31031 October 1986
Rev 4 to Calculation M-03, Cable Tray Properties
ML20236L8891986-10-31031 October 1986
Rev 1 to CT-1-137-702-S25R, Pipe Support Calculation. Supporting Documentation Encl
ML20210E5221986-10-15015 October 1986
Rev 2 to Calculation M-10, Cable Tray - Clip Angle Stiffness
ML20210E5751986-10-10010 October 1986
Rev 2 to Calculation M-12, Qualification Procedures for Cable Tray Support Evaluation
ML20148F4591986-09-16016 September 1986
Rev 0 to Fatigue Cycle Determination for Pipe Supports
ML20148F4921986-09-10010 September 1986
Rev 2 to Documentation of Use of Low Strength A563 Grade a Double Nuts on High Strength SA 193 Grade B-7th D Rod for Richmond Insert Bolt Connection
ML20210E6261986-08-31031 August 1986
Rev 0 to Calculation M-28, Justification of Clip Modeling Procedure
ML20148F3351986-08-28028 August 1986
Rev 2 to Development of Method for Evaluating Local Stress in Pipe Support Members
ML20210E4611986-08-25025 August 1986
Rev 3 to Calculation M-25, Base Plate Prying Action Factors
ML20236L9371986-07-31031 July 1986
Rev 1 to Calculation CT-1-032, Texas Util Generating Co Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Containment Spray Sys 15454-NP(H)
ML20211K2971986-06-11011 June 1986
Partially Withheld Package of 850711 & 860611 Lists of Allegations on Comanche Peak
1996-07-17
[Table view]
Category:PRESS RELEASE OR NEWS ARTICLE
MONTHYEARML20237K9771987-08-19019 August 1987
Press Release 87-115 Informing of NRC Release of Documents Re Investigation of NRC Actions Involving Plant Under Const. Portions of Documents Deleted for Personal Privacy Reasons or Prospective Personnel Matters
ML20212M6231986-05-23023 May 1986
Package of News Articles Re Case Opposition to U Removal from & Delivery to Plant
ML20210M8841985-05-0202 May 1985
Press Release 86-30,announcing Proposed Civil Penalties in Amount of $370,000 Due to Failure to Assure QC Inspectors Organizational Freedom to Identify Problems & Util Failure to Comply W/Const & QA
ML20141N2941984-12-18018 December 1984
Press Release Discussing Credibility of H & D Stiner Re Welding Practices
ML20136B7151983-10-11011 October 1983
Press Release Discussing Release of Insp Rept 83-27 Re Allegations Made to NRC About Facility.No Violations or Deviations Identified.One Previous Violation Re Improper Documentation Corrected by Licensee
ML20141N2931982-09-15015 September 1982
Press Release Discussing Util Refutation of Allegations by Intervenor Witnesses,Including C Atchison
ML20141N2921982-09-14014 September 1982
Press Release Discussing Resumption of Facility Licensing Hearing & Claim by C Atchison
1987-08-19
[Table view] |
Text
- 1 . ygu * &
l t e j YY ,
,,. t0O 7~"}d " *'s O O r.3 4- - t} c-
-I
( .) .w f f
j,lV
- ~hl'
, w.y
- < A . ag .,x, ;..... . .. ' , . . , . .
,;, .. i s d ^ Gib.,.
? 1 a.
<a u J%).'p-
- 3.
.s*1essn s .4.,8*g/q Txm**v. swa J c4'$-:
m*s gegh:d, ,I0 s.
g).u i g1 i . t,,v, h.
. '. 1 4
- . /
s.
)., .;# v)
Decenher 18, 1984 h '
k; lb 4.
c" f> e IS ASLB FINDS S'"INEPS TO BE WITIIOUT CRelDIBILITY A %,
The Atornic Sa fety and Licensing Board has concluded that 7h_,((f IIenry and Darlene Stiner, former Comanche Peak workers who made. .
numerous allegations concerning welding practices, are not Q credible witnesses.
"The record demonstrates that Mr. and Mrs. Stiner are individuals who possess me:nories that produce different versions of the same facts when questioned at different times and possess selective rocall of facts and details favorable to their claims, accompanied by a fai. lure of memory 4:s to other facts regarding those claims," the board concluded in a memorandum issued late lionday.
In contrant to tho Stiners, the board said it " finds no inconsistencies from (the company's) witnesses which would call '
into question th>ir credibility."
l The ASLB ruled that with two exceptions, the allegatice;.
raised by the Stiners 're without merit. The board said it att11 had questions rogarding two welding practices, but said "there is reasonable .nourance that these allegations are not re flective of any condition that could adversely impact the safe operation of the plant."
The board sc.id part of its conclusi.on that the Stiners had no credib!Iity i te.r mo d "fron our realization that both of the Stinera m i sunJ. + c o tood the echnical foundatim for the weave welding procedure which waa the crux of a subs?antial portion of their complain *. about the plant."
4 I'u r the rm o r e , the board said it fou.-M that llanry Stiner Uin fired because o f a long-standing absenta.4iam problen at work, not, ,
as he claim"d, becau.e he reported a problem to a OC in,pector.
The board noted a number of incon3istoncio end contra-d ic t i o n.; in li a ' , - G*ic>r's to;-*imony 1 at S , o t. 'b > in hoarings in Ibrt 1 orth and point ad o ir S t ine r ' n "w ' !. i i ru; '"n , to provido adverne teatim>ny to (the c omp..n y ) u i '. h o u t non :i ' i sri ty to 'hother .
tha mattor i.. beyond hia exp.ertina."
Darlene S t- i n e r "a ppa , ren t ly r" i i< " hean i t / n:. .sh a t- her hoaband told her" and " r e n pe n s! .; to queatiac., by cign i t i. m tly o /ern t atla;;
the face:.," t h- boats aid. ,,,.
~
0603060064 060114 f 1 <
PDR FOIA I e GARDERS-799 PDR - g