ML20137S597

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Rev 2 to Callaway Cycle 9 Colr
ML20137S597
Person / Time
Site: Callaway Ameren icon.png
Issue date: 03/31/1997
From:
UNION ELECTRIC CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML20137S595 List:
References
NUDOCS 9704150183
Download: ML20137S597 (25)
v • d • e


Text

- . --

+, .

Callaway Cycle 9 n ,.s ;

i .

1 CALLAWAY CYCLE 9 CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT March 1997 l

I I

l l

2 l

t 9704150183 970404 i PDR ADOCK 05000483 l P PDR

> i Callaway cgle o un ;

1

! l.0 CORE OPER ATING LIMITS REPORT This Core Operating Limits Report (COLR) for Callaway Plant Cycle 9 has been prepared in l

acconlance with the requirements of Technical Specification 6.9.1.9.

l The Core Operating Limits affecting the following Technical Specifications are included in this report.

! 3.1.1.3 Moderator Temperature Coefficient 3.1.3.5 Shutdown Rod Insertion Limits 3.1.3.6 Control Rod Insertion Limits 3.2.1 Axial Flux Difference 3.2.2 Heat Flux Hot Channel Factor l ,

! 3.2.3 Nuclear Enthalpy Rise Hot Channel Factor I I

3.9.1 Refueling Boron Concentration i

l l

I 3

l. .
  • j i

l Callaway Cgle 9 Ra 2 i I

i

. . j l I f 2.0 OPERATING LIMITS l l 1

, The cycle-specific parameter limits for the specifications listed in Section 1.0 are presented i in the subsections which follow. These limits have been developed using the NRC-apprmed l methodologies specified in Technical Specification 6.9.l.9.

l 2.1 Moderator Temperature Coefficient 1

(Specification 3.1.1.3) 1 1

2.1.1 The Moderator Temperature Coefficient shall be less positive than the limits shown in Figure 1. These limits shall be referred to as the Beginning of Cycle Life (BOL) Limit.

l The Moderator Temperature Coefficient shall be less neg::tive than -47.9 pcm/*F. ]

! This limit shall be referred to as the End of Cycle Life (EOL) Limit.

2.1.2 The MTC 300 ppm surveillance limit is -40.4 pcm/ F (all rods withdrawn. Rated i Thermal Power condition).

l i

i f

i l

l l \

l 4

. _ _ _ . .__.m. _ . . . _ - _ _ , . . . . . _ _ . . . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ . _ _ . . . _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ . . . . _ _ . _ . . . _ . - _ . . _ _

. Callaw.o Cple 9 R,;

]

7 l l j j;  ;  ; i ,

~~

I i lI iI l i i

, I l l l ii l l l l .

-6 N -

ll UNACCEPTABLE OPERATION I!

g 'ii {

U ,

l (70%, 5.0) s i Ii!

l- z5 I m \ l!

U \ i!

C \ i b \ l O 4 0 l il m

cr:

i \ li 3

I o t  : -

i e g l = ( l l $ 3

\ i -

i s \ l 8 l ACCEPTABLE OPERATION s \ l

$ \ ll' s2 ' I III i @- \  !!

I

\ II

\

l

\

1  !

\ '

\

l\

l\

l 0 I II l 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 1

! PERCENT OF RATED THERMAL POWER l

Figure 1 Callaway Cycle 9 I

Moderator Temperature Coefficient Versus Power Level I

5

i Callaway Cyle '8 R ., 2 2.2 Shutdown Rod Insertion Limits (Specification 3.1.3.5)

The shutdown rods shall be withdrawn to at least 225 steps.

2.3 Control Rod insenion Limits (Specification 3.1.3.6) t The Control Bank Insertion Limits are specified by Figure 2.

i i

i l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l 6

  • ,' s Ca!!away Cycle 9 Rn ;

225 l i 1/ (28,225) >i  ! i4 !  ! t /i (78,225)

/ Ili sii y i

/1 i ii ._i / ii

. / I l i tl fl il 1 .

200 / I I i i i i / I ii ri' f ,, , , ,

f , ,

j' i! .

I j' I i

/ BANK B l / i

^

/ / \

t

/ / 11 g 175 y j ,,,,

d / / (100,161) o / /

g (0,161) / ;f E 150 ,[ , ,j

E m >

/  ! . >

/ -

\!

j g ,/ BANK C l / i:

~ # ' I

/ '

125 1 z J J ' i o / /  !

y / /

u / /

- o 100 / /

a. / / t w / /

/ / .

m / / BANK D l c

o cz; 75

/

)

/

/

)[

/ /

/ /

/ /

f (0,46)

/

j

/ l 25 ,

l jr (30.2, 0) /

0 / I O 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 PERCENT OF RATED THERMAL POWER Figure 2 Callaway Cycle 9 Rod Bank Insertion Limits Versus Rated Thermal Power - Four Loop Operation 7

Call.iway Cycle 4 Res ;

i 2.4 Axial Flux Difference (Specification 3 2.1) 2.4.1 The Axial Flux Difference (AFD) Limits are provided in Figure 3.

2.4.2 The target band during Restricted AFD Operation is +37c. The AFD limih provided in Figure 3 also remain applicable during Restricted AFD Operation.

2.4.3 The minimum allowable power level for Restricted AFD Operation. APL'". is 907c of RATED THERMAL POWER.

l l

l l-I 8

s R e. ,'

Callaway Cgle 9

' ' i i t -

120 >! < <

i I i

i I ' .< ~~_l'__

i i I! _

110

,  !, ;l e i!

}i ii

! i >

,l,i i! i!

l

.i

(-17, i ii 100%) L_.__ (+13, 100%)  !

t j; i i i i , i i i i i ii i i i iii i i g

i ; , ,,., ,

100 , i i i :f

\

I g b UNACCEPTABLE /i \ UNACCEPTABLE E

$ 90 '-

OPERATION r

\ OPERATION I 2

- ,/  ; \\

l I I i 1

\ ' ' ' '

l, 80 I

/ ,

ACCEPTABLE l t \ - '

1 A

> ' OPERATION 1 i s i i m i '

a

$ 70

\ ,

l,

[

\

j:

a \ *!

N I '

\

l 60 ,

t s \

~ ~

/

g \

O '

I ,,

' ,7 50 , --! iii g I (+26, 50%) M I (-30, 50%) l o lll N 40

. I .

i I l

30 1 20 i 4

, l 10 i i i

i i

0 40 50

-40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30

-50 AXIAL FLUX DIFFERENCE (% AI)

Figure 3 Callaway Cycle 9 Axial Flux Difference !mits as a Function of Rated Thermal vower for RAOC 9

l c

C.diaway Cycle 9 Rn.2 2.5 Heat Flux Hot Channel Factor Fv(Z)

(Specification 3.2.2) p are Fv(Z) $

  • K(Z) for P > 0.5 P

Fn ""' l Fv(Z) 5

  • K(Z) for P 5 0.5 0.5 THERMAL POWER where: P=

RATED THERMAL POWER 2.5.1 FnRTP = 2.50 2.5.2 K(Z) s provided in Figure 4. .

1 2.5.3 The W(z) functions that are to be used in Technical Specifications 4.2.2.2. 4.2.2.3. j and 4.2.2.4 for Fusurveillance are shown in Figures 5 thmugh 17. 1 The Nog Operation W(z) values have been determined for several bumups up I to 18000 MWD /MTU in Cycle 9. This permits determination of W(z) at any cyc!c l bumup up to 18000 MWD /MTU through the use of three point interpolation. For i cycle bumups greater than 18000 MWD /MTU, use of 18000 MWD /MTU W(z) values without interpolation or extrapolation is conservative. The W(z), values were determined assuming Cycle 9 operates with RAOC stratege ^ lso included is a W(z), function that bounds the W(z), Curve for all Cycle 9 bumups. Use i of the bounding W(z), curve will. be conservative for any Cycle 9 bumup:  !

however, additional margin may be gained by using the bumup dependent W(z),,

values.

The Normal Operation W(z) values have also been determined for a range ut measured axial offset values for Cycle 9. For measured axial offset values within 37c of the predicted axial offset value, Figures 5 through 9 are applicable.

Additional W(z) values are provided in Figures 10 through 13 applicable to measured axial offsets within 37c of a measured-predicted axial offset difference of-2.7% Figures 14 through 17 provide W(z) values applicable to measured axial offsets within 137c of a measured predicted axial offset difference of -7.09. For purposes of bumup interpolation, a consistent set of W(z) values should be used based on the difference between the measured vid predicted axial offset. The W(z) set selected should be the set closest to the actual measured-predicted axial offset difference.

l Because significant margin exists between the analytically detcrmined maximum Fn(z)*P,,, values and their limit, RMicted Axial Flux Difference (RAFDO)

Operation is not expected to be required for Cycle 9. For this reason no l

10

l . .

canawa.v c>cie 9 n.1 2 W(/)u,u o., values are supplied for Cycle 9. -

l The W(/) values are provided for 73 axial points within the oire heiph  ;

boundaries of 0 and 12 feet at intervals of .167 feet between top and bottoin ol the core boundaries.

Table A.1 shows the burnup dependent Fu penalty factors for Cycle 9.. These {

values shall be used to increase Fo "(z) when required by Technical Specification -

Surveillance Requirement 4.2.2.2.e. A 27c penalty factor shall be used at all J cycle bumups that are outside the range of Table A.I. .

i l

l l

l l

t.

i d

J 1

4 11

  • ,' s i Callaway Cgle 9 go ;

TABLE A.I FvPENALTY FACTORS AS A FUNCTION OF CYCLE BURNUP Cycle Bumup (MWD /MTU) Fo"(z) Penalty Factor (9) l 150 2.04 l 4105 2.27 4277 2.90 4449 3.55 4620 4.16 4792 4.42 l

4964 4.32 l

5136 4.10 5308 3.79 5480 3.42 l

l 5652 2.99 i

5824 2.52 5996 2.10 l

l Note: All cycle bumups outside the range of the above table shall use a 29 penalty factor for compliance with the 4.2.2.2.e Surveillance Requirement. Linear interpolation should be used for intennediate cycle bumups.

l 12

C.illaw.is Cple 9 Rn

]

2.6 Nuclear Enthalov Rise Hot Channel Factor - F.n' .  !

(Specification 3.2.3)

RTP F3 n's F 3n g pp g,p )

l THERMAL POWER where: P =

RATED THERMAL POWER 2.6.1 FnRTP 3 = 1.59 2.6.2 PF3 s = 0.3 i 2.7 Refueline Baron Concentration (Specification 3.9.1) 2.7.1 The refueling boron concentration to maintain K,u 5 0.95 shall be > 2000 ppm. j l

i i

I l l

l l l

l I

l r '

i l

i l

i 1

4 1

13

Calla Aay Cn te ') Res _'

1.20 i i

i 1 4

! ! ' ' ' - i >'- - i '

i !ii i i i i a !i i i!t I!  ! .'

i ' i' i i  ! i i

!I  : l..

e i

  • i .i i!
  1. ! t ii  ! ! ! i t i 'i  !

i i i i i.

1.10 .

+

I i i i i ! I i i ,i i i ,,,, i , , ,, , , ,

, ,, i i i ii i ,

j (6, 1.00) I  !

I i i i I i 1 ii iiii i 1.00 -%-_ij , , i ,

i

-~ ~ ~ , i i  ; ,

~-c , ,

I i !I'i%

0.90 '

(12, .524) {

a i - r n !I i , ,,

-- 0.80 ,,

O ,

,i

!i O '

$ 0.70

l H

a I h

o 0 .60 i z

~ 0.50 ,

.u, i

M 0.40 ,

i i

!I t6 ie 0.30 i, I

f l

0.20 l

0.10 l i

l 0.00  !  ! ' i  !

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 CORE HEIGHT (FEET) l l

l Figure 4 Callaway Cycle 9 i K(z)- Normalized Fa(z)

As a Function of Core Height 14

_ _ _ . . . _ m _ . . _ . . . _ . . _ _ . _ - _ . . .

C.ill.tw.n Cgte 9 R e'. 2 n: m a:

1.6C i PEET ar *,

j  ;

. _l l l ll ,

  • i i

.n av i s

, * ..in l l t..u n l l l * * '

  • tsoO 1 a: >

ll 1 1310 g' 3 3.649 I l l

  • 0.433 L )2JJ
  • 1.000 4 0)JO
  • 1.147 1.71J3
  • 1.333 1.nM 1.500 . 0300 1.5C
  • 1 "' 8'"'

1.033 1.3133 I 2.000 1.2917 2.167 1.2701 1 2.333 1.2405 2.500 1.2271 2.667 1.2092 2.83J 1.1976 3.000 1.1902 3.16T 1.1940 f 3.333 1.1770 1.4C 3.uo 1.1692 3.667 1.1633 3.033 1.1611 ,

4.000 1.1584 4.167 1.1547 j 4.333 1.1506 i G 4.500 1.1454 j 4.467 1.1405

- l 4.833 1.1345

^ 1 5.000 1.1279 0

^ 5.167 1.1210 8 1.3C 5 3'3 **"3' i

g ,,

a 5.500 1.1039 l 5.667 1.0992 a 5.833 1 1036 6.000 1.1125

& 6.167 1.1241 l 6 ' 8 333 60 1 13'3 n 6.500 1.1439 6 6.667 1.1530

, [ 6.833 1.1621 6 6 7.000 1.1723

! 1. .'I C 7.167 1. u a e 6 7 333 1 1932

.A' A 7,500 1.2006 (a

,, 7.667 1. f 'J 61

%, 3 7.033 1.2143 La a 8.000 1.2190 n, , s.167 1.2232

{ -0 O 6.J33 1.2291 0 8.500 1.2376

{ 1 8.467 1.2440 l

4 i, 0.033 1.2447 1.1C 'j 9.nc 1.247s 9.167 1.2575 9.333 1.2744 9,500 1.2913 9.667 1.3063 9.033 1.3205 10.000 1.3345 g 10.167 1.3475 l

  • 30.333 1.0000
  • 10.500 1.0000
  • 10.667 1.0000 1.00;;_;;  ;,,; 1 l . 1,. 33 1. n 00 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10'" Il I2 *

"8"

  • 11.167 1""

1.0000 1

BOTTOM TOP

  • u.333 1. 0 0 n l I

CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

  • u.5n
  • 11.667
1. o n 0 1.0000

!

  • 11.433 1.0000
  • 12.000 1.0000 Figure 5 '

\

Callaway Cycle 9

W(z)no at 150 MWD /MTU

J 15 I'

i

a *

  • C.dlaw.ty Cycle u- Res. 2

{

= _,

HE**H7  !?,3 ff f f f l f l

' l l

  • 0 3.as' a.M' l

\

l f l 3

  • 0.333 1.20?'

I  !

  • 0.533 1. 33:

l } l

  • 0.46* 1.)JJJ .

l '

  1. l t l
  • 0.833 1 130*

j .

  • 1.030 1. H 1. l l l
  • 1.14' 1.7073 1
  • 1.333 1.0001 I f
  • 1.500 1.a000 (
1,5C
  • 2 "' 1 c "'  !

1.833 1.4009 h 2.000 1.3760 I 2.167 1.3507 f 2.333 1.3253 ,

2.500 1.2990 1 2.667 1.2754 2.033 1.2584 4 3.000 1.2475 {

t 3.167 1,2385 f

' j 3.333 1.2202 1.4C 1 35" 2 2202 j 3.667 1.2147 3.833 1.2102 l 4.000 1.2051  !

4.167 1.1991 '

4.333 1.1926 6 4,500 1.1653 )

4.667 1.1773 4 4.833 1.168e '

3 5.000 1.1595 N $ i 5'l'7 ****** '

- 1.3C ..

o 5 332 1 23 '

g l f 5.500 1.1279 '

[

5,667 1.1164 a 5.833 I

1.1170 '

6 6.000 1.1205 L

6.167 1.1303 0

4, 6.333 1.1412 a

6.500 1.1523 6 0 6.667 1.1633 04 , 4.833 1.1741 1.2C '

4

,0 Al 7.000 7 2'?

1.1443 1"2' l

4 A 7.333 1.201J '

di ii 1.500 1.2000 l y A' A 7.667 1.2136  !

O g 7.833 1.2173 j

" 8.000 1.2100

  • 0 8.167 1.2200 >i u -

8.333 1.2261 i j, a 8.500 1.2304 I 0.667 1.2323 c.433 1.2341 1.1C " '*8'"

9.167 1.2505 9.333 1.2650 9.500 1.2009 9.667 1.2978 p.833 1.3155 10.000 1.3331 10.167 1.3408

  • 10.333 1.0000
  • 10.500 1.0000
  • 10.667 1.0000
1. 0 g % _ . _ _ _
  • 10.e33 1.0000 j

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ~~~f-1 12 * "*'" 2*""

  • 11.167 1.0000 l BOTTOM TOP
  • u.3n 1.00u j CORE HEIGHT (FEET) *"5"
  • 11.667 2""

1.0000 i

1

  • 11.033 1.0000 )

,

  • 12,000 1.0000 l

[ Figure 6  !

i Callaway Cycle 9 ,

j W(z)no at 3000 MWD /MTU

  • 1 a

Top and bottom 15% excluded as per Tech Spec 4.2.2.2G

! 16

,w, - r - - - - . , - , n , - = - - . -

v

. . . -- . - . . . . . . . - . - . . ~ . . . . . . . _ . . _ . - _ . _ ~ . ~ . - ~ . - . - . _ . - - -

l*- '

C.dLma> Cg k u R.s 1

l l urr ai .

1*60 ? **

I lli

' l ,I ll ll IfI ll ll l ll 'i

  • '.4 214"

+

t na-I l l' 0.331 1, 005

  • 0.500 e ' ??

0.667 .H3*

,__ 0.031 1.07?)

1.000 1.0003 1.167 1. D O M

-h-

  • 1.333 1.0000 l l l
  • 1.500 1.003a 1.5C 3
  • 1.657 t 0000 1.833 1.3569 2.000 1.3409 4 2.167 1.3244 .

2.333 1,3076 l 2.500 1.2905 '

2.667 1.2732 4 2.633 1.2564 3.000 1.2425 3.167 1.2344 3.333 1.2323 1.4C 3.500 1 2300 i 3.667 1.2362 3.833 1.2221 .

4.000 1.2179  !

4.167 1.2142 4 4.333 1.2108 4.500 1.2047 4.667 1.2019 3 4.033 1.1963 a 5.000 1.1995 g a 5.167 1.1031 [

^

w 1.3C 5 333 1 1177 '

g n a 5.500 1 1700 db 5.467 1.1662 6 6 5.833 1.1704 6 6.000 1.1705 6 36,,66 <> 6.167 1.1997 gh digo 6.333 1.1972 3 a 6.500 1.2051 dL 4^ 4, 6.667 1.2129 i 6.033 1.2205 06 0 7.000 1.2209

"* " l 1.2C .

a 1 157 1 33'1 i

", , g 7.333 1.2435 A 7.500 1.2406  ?

O d' 7.667 1.2523 -

A 7.833 1.2544 0.000 1.2540 l 0.167 1.2539 8.333 1,2515 8.500 1.2461 8.667 1.2430 9.833 1.2466 ,

1.1C 9.000 1.2535  :

9.167 1.2639 l 9.333 1.2749 l 9.500 1.2848 I 9.667 1.2936 ,

9.e33 1.3021 l 10.000 1.3102 10.167 1.3173

  • 10.333 1.0000
  • 10.500 1.0000 l
  • 10.667 1.C000 1.00,__..__,.__._ i
  • 10.e33 1.0000 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 11 " O 2 0 "'
  • 11.167 1.0000 BOTTOM TOP
  • 21 333 1. n 0 0 1 CORE HEIGHT (FEET) * "5"
  • 11.667 S""

1.0000

  • 11.833 1.0000
  • 12.000 1.0000 Figure 7 Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 10000 MWD /MTU

17 i

. . . _ . . . . . . - - - - . _ . . - - - . . ~ - . , . - . . - - . ~ - - - ~ . . . . . . ~ - . . . . ~ -

l* **

C.ill.m.i> C3 Je " R n . .'

us::w- its e 1.60 'T d :

-I I i i 1 1 l ;i, - 0- 1 >>

  • t.,

0.3.-

l

0. 3 n 1. 3 .

0.5:0 1

  • 0.441 1. ? ) U 0.e33 1.J);
  • j 1.000 1 *N 1.147 1. '. 3 3 :

1.313 1.3133 1.500 1.1503 1.5C

  • 1.667 1.0000 l 1.033 1.3044  ;

i 2.000 1.2941 i l 2.167 1.2031 2.333 1.2699 i 2.500 1.2547 2.667 1.2425 2.933 1.2202 3.000 1.2190 J.167 1.2171 3.333 1.2215 ,

i .1.4C 3.500 1.2257 3.667 1.2283  ;

3.833 1.2305 .j 6.000 1.2324 '

( 4.167 1.2349 4.333 1.2383 4.500 1.2407 ,

4.447 1.2415 .

4.433 1.2411

,., 5,000 1.2390 gg 6 5.167 1.2300 1.3C

6

." 64463 a 5.333 1.2363 gg 5.500 1.2344 l ^ '

, Jhad6A 5.467 1.2337 6 0 Od6 6 '6 5.833 1.2367 l

A 6.000 1.2477 O 6.167 1.2613 3 , ,

ai 6.333 1.2720

[ ,g s---

'a o j,36 6.500 1.3028 t 0,

1 6 ,, ,6 6.667 1.2921 l i

.a- 6.833 1.2992 7.000 1.3043 1.2C 7.287 2.3878 7.333 1.3001 7.500 1.3066 7.667 1.3029 ,

, 7.833 1.2948 l 9.000 '1.2874 8.167 1.2700 0.333 1.2719 0.500 1.2716 l 8.667 1.3731 i 8.833 1.2778 1.1C 9.e00 1.2sas 9.167 1.2854 f 9.333 1.2047 l 9.500 1.2041 l

9.667 1.2025 9.433 1.3777 10.000 1.2757 10.167 1,2763

  • 10.333 1.0000
  • 10.500 1.0000
  • 10.647 1.0000
1. 0 4,;; _ _ _ _ _ _ ;; ,
  • 10.e33 t.0000 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
  • 11 "' 2.""
  • 11.167 1.0000 IBC)CD1?C))f 1?C)ES
  • 11 333 1. " ' '

CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

  • u.u0
  • 11.667 1.0000 1.0000
  • 11.433 1.0000
  • 12.000 1.0000 i

F icitJrte il j Callaway Cycle 9 l

W(z)no at 18000 MWD /MTU j

. __ _ = .. . _ _.

.. U.tll.m.iy C:.Je 9 Ro : i e ...

ast m ux l 1.60 '

96E* .i

  • l.

6 l l'l I ll i

l l l l'l

  • 2:a ' '2P l, I I 3 l  ! lli .

I 6

! a. 0.149 1 OJC7 1 g g '

, l l l ) l ,l

  • 0.313 1.00 '

l l l

  • I_ .  ! 6.510 1 O!!'

l l i

  • 0.44* 1. M ' '

l I l

  • 0.033 1 001) j g 1.000 1.C0)}

} g 1.167 1 00H

=

1.333 1.0402 l 1.500 1.0030 1.5C  ;

1.667 1.0303 3,,,3 3.,23, 2.000 1.3986 2 2.167 1.3720 2.333 1.3471 2.500 1.3204 i 2.667 1.2963 2.933 1.2790 a 3.000 1.2601 3.167 1.2587 3.333 1.2450 1.4C 46 3.500 1.2424 3.667 1.2422 3.433 1.2446 3 4.000 1.2467

. 4.167 1.2492 4.333 1.2526 6 6 4.500 1.2550

==

4.667 1.2558 N 16 4.833 1.2554 w ^^-

0, S.000 1.2541

$. 0 5.167 1.2523 1.3C 6 a gp 5.333 1.2505 3 ,,,,, 1,,,,, ,

6 6a0 5.667 1.2479 I a 5.033 1.2510 6.000 1.2621 gnaa,,3 6.167 1.2764 Am,64 ,0 30 6.333 1.2875 6.500 1.2976 6.667 1.3069 6.033 1.3142 7.000 1.31b4 l

y gg 7.147 1.3224 7.333 1.3232 1

7.500 1.3217 4 7.667 1.3179 7.033 1.3118 j 8.000 1.3025 0.167 1.2927 l 8.333 1.2866 l 0.500 1.2462 j 8.667 1.2879 8.833 1.2929 1 1.10 - -

- 9.0n 1. 2 n 2 9.167 1 " 15 l 9.333 1.J140 l 9.500 1.3300 l 9.667 1.3440 l 9.833 1.3606 10.000 1.3750 10.167 1.3884

  • 10.333 1.0000
  • 10.500 1.0000
  • 10.667 1.0000
1. 0 0,,;; ;';, . ;; _  ;,,;; . . ;; ,, ;; _
  • 10.e33 1.0000 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
  • 11 '" 1""
  • 11.167 1.0300 BOTTOM TOP
  • 21 333 1""

CORE HEIGHT (FEET) * "5"

  • 11.667 1""

1.0000 l

  • 11.833 1.0000 I
  • 12.000 1.0000

. Figure 9 Callaway Cycle 9 Bounding W(z)no

,

I* C.dl.swas C.wle 9 i

Ro HE ! .W" 14J 1.70 t ij PEE

  • d 8'

)i  ! l

' I'. . [',N {1, l

  • 0.311 1. 0 U 3
  • 0.500 1.021;
  • 0.641 1. O s00
  • 0.el3 1. f 3 0 0
  • 1.000 1. M10
  • 1.141 1.0007 1*6C j
  • 1.500 1.00M ,
  • 1.467 1.0000 1.03J 1.2002 2.000 1.2581 2.16' 1 2350 .

l 2.373 1.2127 2.500 1.1919 2.,67 1.1755 1*SC  ?.000 1.1599 J.167 1.1544 l- 3.333 1.1484 3.500 1.1409 l 6 3.667 1.1360 3.633 1.1369 3 4.000 1.1358 4.147 1.1312 6 8.333 1.1243 4.500 1.1195 '

4.667 1.1144 o 4.033 1.1080 e% 5.000 1.1013 i D4 - 5.167 1.09a5

%e 4 5.333 1.0948

$ - 5.500 1.0906 i

5.667 1.0971 4 1 -

5.833' 1.0$04 y gg 3 6'l 6.000 1.0975 6.167 1.1086

~

4, 6.333 1.1207 A 4.500 1.1326 A 6.667 1.1409

,, 6.633 1.1465 7.000 1.1601 6 g 7.167 1.1740 )

7.333 1.1859 j d i 4 7.500 1.1977 )

1.20 o 7,667 1.2134 0 7.e33 1.2362 4 6 0.000 1.2510

6 0.167 1.2646

'A a.333 1.2744 l

0.500 1.2053

L u'

'6 " 0.667 1.3026

, 83 I 3o l

.g - --

9.000 1.'3104 6 A 9.167 1.3214 1.1C w" 6 0 n 9.3n 9.500

1. 3 ni 1.3054 9.667 1.4132 9.833 1.4311 10.000 1.4436 l 10.167 1.4540 j
  • 10.333 1.0000 ]

l

  • 10.500 1.0000 )

^ ^ '

  • 10.667 1.0000 i
  • 10.033 1.0000 )

0 1 .2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 . _ . . 11 . . _ . . _ . _ . .12

  • 11.000 1.0000 1 BOTTOM TOP * **'* * * " "

I 11.333 1.0000 i CORE HEIGHT (F 5ET) 11. s o 2.0u0 l

  • 11.667 1.0000
  • 11.033 1.0000 l
  • 12.000 1.0000 l

Figure 10

. Callaway Cycle 9 i W(z)no at UC MWD /MTU
Measured-Predict a c,xial Offset = -2.7%

.i e

a . . ~ . . ,. - , _ . - - ,

  • ** C.dl.tway Cyk 9 - Re.. ;
  • ... x : n- m.

4FECT Ws

  • * *s .,a);)

l 1.70  ;; 4 i

o. m t.r n l l l l ' .  !. i . 0.33i 1. u n

! , , )

  • 0.900 1.30J3  ;

l

  • 4 . 4 4 1. M 0 0 l
  • 0.033 A. 3Jn )

1.000 1.0000 1.169 1. 0 3 n

  • 1.333 1.0000 l l
  • 1.500 1.0010 1.6C . 1.6s7 1.0000 1.833 1.3459 2.000 1.3402 l 2.167 1.3134 l

[ 2.333 1.2073 "

I '

2.500 1.2617 l 2 . s 6, 1. n , .

2.933 1.2251 '

3.000 1.2157 1.5C 3.167 t.207. t 3.333 1,1983 3,500 1.1907 3.667 1.1970 6 3.833 1.1950 j 4.000 1.1815 l 4.167 1.1747 6 4.333 1.1653 4.i00 1.15 1 l ^

1.4C ' " ' ' ' 2 5 "

4.e33 1.1415 5.000 1.1322 m di 5.167 1.1226 8

, g 5.333 1.1204 l  %.,

5.500 1.1143 g u 5.667 1.1061 5.833 1.1036 3 .

g 6.000 1.1054 4.167 1.1147 1.3C a 6. n 1. t2 n .

6 0 6.500 1.1409

) d' 6.667 1.1511

' 6 A 6.833 1.1564

, ,, 7.000 1.1730

" 7.167 1.1945 I

7.333 1.1949 O

' a 7,500 1.2051 l '3 " 7.667 1.2100 1.2C m 3 7.833 1.2373 6 8.000 1.2516 6a a i

3 0.167 1.2621 .

d' 6 O.333 1.2713 a

g 8.500 1.2770

, 0.667 1.2904

' 0.833 1.2970 i

O 9.000 1,3023

'A~n 6 9.167 1.3141

^^'

1.1C .

"3 ' ' " "

9.500 1.3742 9.667 1.4040 l 9.833 1.4256 10.000 1.4421 l l 10.167 1.4554 l

  • 10.333 1.0000
  • 10.500 1.0000
  • 10.667 1.0000
1. 0 0 . . . . . . . . _ . .

l

  • 10.833 1.0000 1
  • 11.000 1 0000 0 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 . _ _ . . .12 . 11,1., 1 ,,,,

BOTTOM TOP

  • 11. n 3 1.0000 CORE HEIGHT (FEET) ((:lllllllll
  • 11.833 1.0000
  • 12.000 1.0000 i.

. Figure 11 l Callaway Cycle 9 l W(z)no at 3000 MWD /MTU Measured - Predicted Axial Offset = -2.7%

j

21 1

f

, ,, I. .I 1, 4 3 .

4 og M833M7 6' 10 '

PEE 74 d a.

1.70  ; i -

jjj

  • 3.070 1 340' l  ; )  ;

l l ll! . 3. g o i on,

  • 0.331 1.03J) l
  • 0.500 1.00*3 .
  • 0.467 1.3JJ7 1 l
  • 0.033 1.0003 '

I

  • 1.000 1. M
  • G ,
  • 1.147 1 0000 l
  • 1.333 1.0001 l' '

a 1.500 1.C000

  • 1.647 1.0000 1.033 1.3230 2.00v 1.3060 2.167 1,2470 i 2.333 1.2701 2.500 1.2534 '

2.667 1.2177  !

k 2.033 1.2231 1.5C 3.000 1.2109 3.167 1.2030 3.333 1.2023 +

3.500 1.2002 3.667 1.1982 3.833 1.1967 6.000 1.1941

' , 4.167 1.1895 0<

i- 4.333 1.1031 l 1.4C -

4.500 1.1790 1 4.647 1.1742 l

4..n 1.14..

m 5.000 1.1614 .

i b3 5.167 1.1551 6 5.333 1.1570

$ 3 5.500 5.467 1.1559 1.1534 A

5.033 1.1564 6, 6.000 l 1.1626 1.3C

^

l g aw '

6.333 1.1029 6 ' 6.500 1 1932

[# 6.667 1.2000 db a 6.033 1.2041 7

7.000

<5 a 1.2161 I

0 7.147 1.2179

  • 3 7.333 1.2369

^ ^

46

"' 2 1'2C 'me - 7.667 1.'2570 8 '

OA

[ 7.833 8.000 1 2750 1.2886 A g 0 0.167 1.2964 d

6Ld644 s.J13 1.2976 0.500 1.2941 0.667 1.3016 4.833 1.3101 9.000 1.3167 1.1C 9.167 9.333 1.3281 1.34s6 9.500 1.3704 9.667 1.3995 l

9.833 1.4111 10.000 1.4173 10.167 1.4214

  • 10.333 1.0000
  • 10.500 1.0000 1.00lk

..

  • 10.467 1.0000 h "- p'~ 2 * (('l'l j',ll"l

~~

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 '~ T2 . , 3 ,

DCTTOM TOP 11.1o 1.0000 CORE HEIGHT (FEET) ' ((j " [ll*  ;

  • 11.667 1.0000
  • 11.833 1.0000
  • 12.000 1.0000 Figure 12
Callaway Cycle 9 j W(z)no at 10000 MWD /MTU i Measured - Predicted Axial Offset = -2.7%

4 -

---_-.~~~_,--~..-n- .n.~. . . . . - -- - . . , . . . . . . . - - . . _ . - - -

. . 8 C.LN.1% 4% Q.de 63 (.g, }

l

  • MSIGHT 10000

. FEE 7e Wisi 1.70

  • 0.000 1.0o00
  • 0.167 1.0000
  • 0.333 1.0000

__

  • 0.500 1.0000
  • 0.667 1.0000
  • 0.833 1.0000
  • 1.000 1.0000 1.167 1.0000 i
  • 1.333 1.0000 1.6C
  • 1.500 1.0000
  • 1.667 1.0000 1.833 1.2759 2.000 1.2626 2.147 1.2476 2.333 .. 2335 2.500 1.2206 l 2.667 1.2075 2.433 1.1957

.1.5C 3.0a 1.leso  ;

3.167 1.1070 3.333 1.1910 l l

3.500 1.1960 I 3.667 1.2003

+

3.833 1.2049 4.000 1.2003 l 4.167 1.2090 4.333 1.2100

' 1.4C s.500 4.667 1.2122 1.2130 04 4.833 1.2121 i

" 'O m 5.000 1.2106

{

N g 5.167 1.2087

%s 6 5.333 1.2155 g 5.500 1.2195 5.667 1.2202 t a 'Sa 5.833 1.2219 -l

'[ 6 6.000 1.2309 1*3b u- 5.167 1.2444 l

l

, 6.333 1.2576 l A "-

6.500 1.2701 6.667 1.2785 1 0 6.833 1.2410 1 0 7.000 1.2907 6 ,, 7.167 1.2977

^

, , 0. 7.333 1.3011 1.2C 6

p ai Mh 00 466 7.500 7.667 1.3035 1.30e7 3 0 i 4,6 7.833 1.3101 l l 8.000 1.3222 0.167 1.3213  ;

I 0.333 1.3188 l 9.500 1.3206 8.667 1.3331 8.833 1.3429 9.000 1.3475 1.1C ' 1'? 1 85'?

9.333 1.3590

! 9.500 1.3776 9.667 1.3875 0 9.833 1,3347

  • 10.000 1.3000
  • 10.167 1.3772
  • 10.333 1.0000
  • 10.500 1.0000 1 . 0 06.. *10 u? 1.0000 0 _ . . _ _1, . . - . . _ 2 10 . . _ _ 11 ,
  • 10.833 1 0000 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 . _ _ , .12 33,,,, 3 ,,,,

BOTTOM TOP

  • 11.167 1.0000 l CORE HEIGHT (FEET) **E"' [l',"

j

  • 11.667 1.0000
  • 11.833 1.0000
  • 12.000 1.0000 i Figure 13 4

( Callaway Cycle 9 l W(z)no at 18000 MWD /MTU i Measured - Predicted Axial Offset = -2.7%

o

. . - - . . ,~

-. . - - . - - - . - . . . . .. . . - ~ _ _- .-- - . - - , -- - ._ . - . - - . . ,

-* C.tll.iway Cgle 9

(-

  • Ro 2 '

! e ,

l

  • n .

xx: art 15: i 1.70 . FIST. edess

} l } ;1,

  • s.000 1.o00s

! ,,

  • 0.1o 1.ecca  !
  • l ii
  • 0.333 1.0000
  • 0.500 1.0000
  • 6.667 1.0000 l
  • 0.833 1.0000 a
6.
  • 1.000 1.0030 16 l
  • 1.167 1.0000 6 I 1.6C
  • 1.333 1.0000 i

6 * '1 '. "6 6 1.0000 7

1.033 1.2275 2.000 1.2042 .

-2.167 1.1787 i'

2.333 1.1553 2.500 1.1354 2.667 1.1214 2.433 1.1151 1.5C ' ' " ' **** ~'

3.167 1.1076 '

3.333 1.1026 6 3.500 1.0956 3.667 1.0943 3.033 - 1. 0 9 a 2 4.000 1.0995 A 4.167 1.0936 0' ' 4.333 1.0a21 1.4C c 4.500 1.077a 4.6n 1.0725 4.033 1.0656

-= 5.000 1.0587 h4 5.167 1.0519

  • 5.333 1.0647 b i N 5.500 1.0693 -

6 5.667 1.0679 5.833 1.0692 6.000 1.3C ,,3n 1.073,5 3,,,3 6.333 1.0990 6.5G0 1.1144 6 6.667 1.1214 6.033 1.1215 7.000 1.1406 6 7.167 1.1599 a 1.333 1.1757 7.500 1.1931 1.2C 7.667 1.2220 a 7.833 1.1662 u

6 0.000 1.3043 0.167 1.3310 6 " 8.333 1.3470 8.500 1.3417 .

46 0.667 1.3965

  • a a 8.833 1.4096

-6 ' f- 9.000 1.4111

'O 1.423e y yg A w'

9.167 no "

9.333 1.4662 A A 9.500 1.5361 l

'a 6'00, , 9.667 1.5846 6 9.033 1.6002

'6 10.000 1.6184 10.167 1.6246

  • 10.333 1.0000
  • 30.*00 1.0000
  • 14.667 1.0000

.-........; ....;^.......

  • 10.833 1.0000 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
  • 11.000 1.0000 BOTTOM TOP *****"***"'

11.333 1.0000 CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

  • 11.500 1.0000
  • 11.667 1.0000
  • 11.e33 1.0000
  • 12.000 1.0000 1

j Figure 14 l

Callaway Cycle 9

)'

W(z) at 150 MWD /MTU Measured - Predicted Axial Offset = -7.0%

_ _ - . . _ _ . _ . . _ _ . - . . . . _ _ . _ . . . _ _ _ . _ . . _ . _ _ . . _ _ _. _ .. _. _. .. _ .. _.. . . _ _ . . _ . . _ y C.dl.m.0 C b e4 l Res. 2 I

  • . 1 ME13W7 1000 j

-F7e Wis) 1.70  ;  ; g j;; . .

3,, t,,3,3 .l 0.167 1.0000

, l

  • 0.133 1.0000
  • 0.500 1.0000
  • 4.667 1.0000
  • 0.013 1.0000 l

_ 6

  • 1.000 . 0800 g

d,

  • 1.167 1.3000 1.333 1.0000 1.60 . 1,3,, 1....,
  • 1.667 1.0000 6 1.933 1.3097 2.000 1.2024 2.167 1.2535 l

__ 2.333 1.2264 '

2.500 1.2019 2.647 1,1020 2.033 1.1717 1.50 3.000 1.158' 3.167 1.1506 I

3.333 1.1505 3.500 1.1434 6 3.667 1.1426 3.833 1.1447 4.000 1.143a 4.167 1.1357 6 4.333 1.1216 1*40 4.500 1.1146

" 4.667 1.1071

A 4.933 1.0970 I

, 5.000 1.0683 g 5.167 1.07e9 w h 5.333 1.0096

^

g 5.500 1.0925 6 5.667 1.0965 5.033 1.0022 j 6 6.000 1.0012 l 1.30 6.167 1.0e97 6.333 1.1057 6.500 1.1226 O 6.667 1.1314 3 6.033 1.1331 7.000 1.1522

-1.367 1.1703 6 0 7.333 1.1047 7.500 1.2005 1.2C "7 **82

7.033 1.2693

^ 0 0.000 1.3041 6 6 e.167 1.3204 y 0.333 1.3437 6 d6 8.500 1,3538

^0

9,667 1.3434 00 4.433 1.3977 g 9.000 1.4024 6 6 9.167 1.4159 1.1C o 9.333 1.4553 di A"6 0 9.500 1.5237 u

9.667 1.5742 9.e33 1.6021

( 10.000 1.6167 10.167 1.6262

  • 10.333 1.0000 l
  • 10.500 1.0000 l
  • 10 5 1 0000 1 . 0 0. . - . _ . . . _ _ _ . . . . _ _ , , _ . _ .

. lo,033 1,000, 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 . _ _ . ,12

  • 11.000 1.0000
  • 11' l'""

i BOTTOM TOP

  • 11.333 1.0000 I

CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

  • 11.500 1.0000
  • 11.667 1.0000
  • 11.033 1.0000 i
  • 12.000 1.0000 l j

! Figure 15 l 4

l j Callaway Cycle 9

) V.,z)no at 3000 MWD /MTU L Measured - Predicted Axial Offset = -7.0%

.- . . . ~ . .~ a .- _ _ _ , - . _

l a

C.dl.tu .i> C We9i Rn 2 o

  • A eg
  • ME 0H7 1)301 1.70 l , ,

i i l lt I i, a am i.;00

  • 0 14' t 0000 I
  • 0.1)J 1.)]G4
  • O $00 1 % 30 I
  • 0.669 1. M ? 0

(

  • O 433 1.2006 i
  • 1.000 1 0730 i
  • 1.141 1.0000 i

I I I

  • 1.J33 1.0000 l*
  • 1.500 1.3000 l -

OO

  • 1.667 1.0000
1. 33 1.26 6 l 3 2.000 1.2501 l 2.161 1.2291 2.333 1.2100 a 2.500 1.1941 2.667 1.1007 2.033 1.1698 1.5C 3.000 1.1602 l 3.167 1 1547 3.3J3 1.1544 6 3.500 1.1526 3.667 1.1534 3.933 1.1559 6 4.000 1.1559 4.167 1.1500 6' 4.333 1.13e0

' 1.4C S" 2*11

O 4.667 1.1301 4.033 1.1237 on 5.000 1.1165 g 0

! 5.167 1.1102 i  %,

5.333 1 1260 g 5.500 1.1333 5.667 1.1329 l

5.033 1.1339 6 6.000 1.1372 1.3C ,

4.167 1.1459 6.333 1.1600 6.500 1.1740 0 a 6.667 1.1796

,, 6.033 1.1779 7.000 1.1956 0 7.167 1.2132 l 0 7.333 1.2263 4 6 7.500 1.2400

{

1.2C H

1 "7 12"'

7.933 1.2080 i ag - 0.000 1.3426 6 h 8.167 1.3644 a 8.333 1.3716

,0080 '

'6 g e.500 1.3711 u ,, 0.667 1.3954

'6 A 6" **833 l 'll'

,0 l 9.000 1.'4179 9.167 1.4311 1.1C 1 9.333 1.4667 9.500 1.5203 9.667 1.5691 9.e33 1.5ssa 10.000 1.5869 10.167 1.5002

  • 10.333 1.0000
  • 10.500 1.0000 l
  • 10.667 1.0000 1.00 .. .. .
10. 33 1.0000

, 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

  • 11.000 1.0e00 l BOTTOM TOP *((j[:llll CORE HEIGHT (FEET)
  • 11.500 1 0000
  • 11.667 1.0000
  • 11.033 1.0000
  • 12.000 1.0000 f

4 Figure 16 Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 10000 MWD /MTU Measured - Predicted Axial Offset = -7.0%

- Cill.iway Cycle 4 Rn.2 0

% aw atwr le m

~

1.70 . FEET

  • d s' l )l l' },i; *
  • 20' "*

l l 3.141 1.0030

  • 0.33. 1.0000
  • 0.500 1.0401
  • 9.667 1.0000 9.63) 1. 0 0 H 1.000 1.0001 1.167 1.0000 l

I I '

  • 1.333 1.0000 t

1.60 . 3.3., 1,,,,,

1.667 1.000J 1.633 1.223e 2.000 1.2084 La 2.147 1,1904

'$ . 2.333 1.1751 2.500 1.1634 2.667 1.1523 2.833 1.1436

  • 0 * * * " '

f 3.167 1.1306 a 3.333 1.1442 3.500 1.1485 6 3.667 1,1554 6' ' 3.033 1.1639 6

4.000 1.1697 4.167 1.1696 4.333 1.1646 l

4.500 1.1667 46" 4.667 1.1674

'l 4.033 1.1457 m 5.000 1.1637 N 5.167 1.1617

%s 0 5.J33 1.1821

$ 5.500 5.667 1.1957 1.19A5 a 5.833 1.1982 6.000 1.2040 1.3C .,

6.167 1.2164 0 6.333 1.2332 6.500 1.2497 db 6.667 1.2547

,06 6.033 1.2539

- 7.000 1.2690 g 7.167 1.2421 g 7.333 t 1.2900 a 7.500 1.2905 l <>

i 1.2C e 7.667 1.3179 i 0 7.s33 1.3522 l A

6 4.000 1.3777 1 AO AdL66. ,a 8.167 1.3906 6 s.333 1,3939 6

g 0.500 1.3991 46u 8.667 1.4292 0.033 1.4472 9.000 1.4511 9.167 1.4554 1*1r* 9.333 1.4780 9.500 1.5275 9.667 1.5557 9.833 1.5561 10.000 1.5471 10.167 1.5300

  • 10.333 1.0000
  • 10.500 1.0000
  • " "' 1'"'

1 . 0 0. . .. _ . . _ . . , . - _.__,,J.;.__,.

  • 10.833 1.0000 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
  • 11.000 1.0000 1

BOTTOM

  • 2"' "'

TOP

  • 11.333 11'.'0000

, CORE HEIGHT (FEET)

  • 11.500 1.0c00
  • 11.667 .1.0000 i
  • 11.0.3 1.0000
  • 12.000 1.0000 Figure 17 ,

i

Callaway Cycle 9 W(z)no at 18000 MWD /MTU Measured - Predicted Axial Offset = -7.0%

}

! 27

\

! _ _ _ _ - .~

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20137S597&oldid=2829902"