ML20136G520
| ML20136G520 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 12/30/1985 |
| From: | Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Bernero R, Miraglia F, Novak T Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20136G524 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8601080314 | |
| Download: ML20136G520 (8) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:. . .-= - . - - . .. .- - g .. 1 l DEC 3 0 E ( 4 MEMORANDUM FOR: Thomas M. Novak, Acting Director - Division of PWR Licensing-A Frank Miraglia, Director Division of PWR Licensing-B Robert M. Bernero Director DivisionofBWRLIcensing William T. Russell, Director Division of Human Factors Technology Themis P. Speis, Director Division of Safety Review and Oversight Gary Holahan, Director Operating Reactors Assessment Staff
-. FROM: Harold R. Denton, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
TRANSFER OF RESPONSIBILITY FOR GENERIC ISSUES SCHEDULED FOR RESOLUTION The three branches within NRR that are primarily responsible for managing the resolution of all generic safety issues are the Reactor Safety Issues Branch (RSIB) and the Engineering Issues Branch (EIB) in the Division nf Safet . Review and Oversight (DSRO) and the Human Factors Issues-Branch (HFIB) in y I the Division of Human Factors Technology (DHFT). Enclosure 1 provides the listing of generic issues that are~ assigned to DSR0 for resolution. Human factors related issues will be resolved by HFIB and will be identified later. Generic issues currently being resolved by other NRC offices (RES and IE) will j remain with these offices, although DSRO will monitor their resolution. j The original task managers will continue to be responsible for resolving and closing-out the generic issues that are listed in Enclosure 2 even though changesintheirjobresponsibilitieshaveoccurred. Generic issues 66; USI A-3, 4 and 5; B-64 and III.D.3.1 are not being transferred because they are to be completed within 60 days. These short term issues have task-managers assigned for resolution and closecut. Three generic issues . .\ l emee> . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...................... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . l euammeb . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...................... ........................ ..........-......... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . l use y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .................. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . uncsomusiano - _ nFFICIAL RECORD COPY uwe mi-mm d.;_.__.--___,.___.____._
= - gCSS I (GI's 83, 86, and 91) have longer range scheduling, but still will be m.S:D. resolved by the assigned new division. It is not practical to reassign these
,.x . S M.p issues because this would interrupt the continuity of the work. Generic MMy Issue 83 will be transferred to RSIB/DSR0 after the specific plant inspections Q g .>V:
and associated reports have been completed. .1M,i.,$
$<; :f. .~;.M . ,m Future assignments of task managers for all subsequent new generic issues approved for resolution by me through the prioritization process will be consistent with the functional responsibilities of DSRO.
%@;('/3T dl v..N~.N ;Q r y . .y-The purpose of this memorandum is to authorize formal transfer of generic M g ;/ M. .
issues from old task managers to the new DSR0 task managers. Both the new x.f O ?.J ,6 and old task managers associated with each issue are identified in Enclosure 1, along with their present line organization. In order to .k pn,p.02l? '; & .s. j. minimize the effect on the resolution schedule of the generic issues involved, th %:1.9 the transfer should be completed by January 3, 1986. To this end, I request that each division director make sure that the old task managers in W. GO @ your present line organization (regardless of where they worked before) N E . ,. K g h 7 i. establish a schedule for contacting and transferring resolution responsibility to their new counterpart in DSRO. A formal transfer gb,W 99: memorandum need not be issued, but the present task managers should id[;. W. ':G^ .-T' consolidate all pertinent information needed to resolve the issue, i.e.,
/
background information, technical assistance information, associated $d8 %. 4 ;. 3 .; W .' personal and branch files, word processor diskettes and any other material needed for an orderly transfer process, and hand it over to the new task manager during a detailed briefing. hMM
% W:. U.
j gdi;i.y. Safety Review and gversight should be kept informed.If changes in assi nment o
;- i M @h ,.
c . m.s.
. . .c; . . M Originel 31ned by [ NGMj. r n..
g p.j .g. Darrell G. Esenhut , [g/Wg[.3 g
.37,.v 9
Harold R. Denton, Director '.7, . 5.9.$? Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation K . hd @l ;
Enclosures:
9.g;f .>
- 1. DSR0 Responsibilities for Generic W i MN. 4; Issues
- 2. GIs To Be Resolved by Original NRR Task Managers d@(N
>N. :- Y cl y:-
. i.h I cc: R. Minogue, RES J. Taylor, IE .
V. Stello, DEDROGR ggw 2 3 V D;PPAS Distribution: see xt page %j y.$ , 6 Af 3 4A JFun es OSee previous concurrence ipg g b e\W .4,4((f .saen
--l . ' .
M4 i , RSIB:DSRO* RISB:DSR0* EIB:DSRO* DD:DSR0* ep .................. . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . n..e..r..s..RBo D:DSRO* DD RR D
. .gg j
_3 L ...R..i.a.n...i..:.s..im.. WM.i n. . . ...
......sn. .ak 1UU/M...... . 12/}3/85.., , , .,12/J#/85,. , 12/,18/85.,,,
. . . . . . BSh..eron
. . . . . . . . TS..peis .
D ut- . .n...
- --y 5=-- -
p 1.2/20/85,,,,, , M/fC_ ,g/gp_. m ooao m cuano OFFICIAL RECORD COPY uscao mi-mm b a i
DTO ? 019I3S = u - b i DISTRIBUTION
- J. Jackson
? C. D. Sellers
- N. Wagner 1 0. Chopra
> D. Thatcher C. Hickey E A..S. Gill . F. Eltawila i K. Shaukat H. Conran F R. Kirkwood - E C. Liang ' [ J. Page L. Heller T. Chang P A. Szukiewicz ._
=
C. Ferrel F
- 0. Rothberg S. Hou
[ J. Ridgely Y. S. Huang P. Norian = l _ J. Mazetis
- g. N. Anderson a R. Bosnak - -
i W. Minners ' - B. Sheron i T. Speis I L. Riani i J. Funches ' k D. Eisenhut/H. Denton , E DSRO C/F [ E RSIB R/F Central File L. Riani c/f = h -- S Q. -- - g . 1 { A&w _ . '44" i L,. 4 ~. n
-Mf;.- h;pf,p j A-[.bb .kf9 4=
L = MQ f
&s%D p
) ,,
,.E ,,
,i',._,~
if j e5 _ &i- * - J c',37 -i N, l 3,N. gig g 1 1 Li ' 9 u A-c.y'. ' j,rkh n. , 3.- h.
- m. g_ _ _ . s-
..:'": .. .., p g '.-
,, , . .. g n [;5 =;- : TM
,,j ,e 3. , _,
~ ~
" 050RE.14 ,
DIVISION OF REACTOR SjirdY AND OVERSICHT RESPONSIBILITY FOR GENERIC SAFETY ISSUES SCHEDULED FOR RE5GLUTION . Responsible Current Div./ Branch Date Location of Current ! Issue and New Task Approved for Old Task Resolution ! j Number Title Manger Priority Resolution Manager Date i ) 23 Reactor Coolant Pump Seal Failures DSR0/EIB H NRR-0P DSR0/EIB 07/86
, J. Jackson J. Jackson 29 Bolting Degradation or Failures ir. DSR0/EIB H NRR-0P DPL-A/EB 08/86 Nuclear Power Plants R. Johnson C. D. Sellers
- 36 Loss of Service Water (Calvert DSR0/RSIB NR 02/15/84 DPL-B/EICSB 05/86 Cliffs Unit 1) L. Riani N. Wagner I 48 LCO for Class IE Vital Instrument DSR0/EIB NR 10/25/83 DPL-A/EICSB 02/87 l Buses in Operating Reactors D. Thatcher 0. Chopra i 49 Interlocks and LCOs for Class 1E DSR0/EIB M 07/31/84 DPL-A/EICSB 09/88 Tie Breakers D. Thatcher A. S. Gill
! 51 Proposed Requirements for Improving DSR0/EIB M 06/03/83 DPL-B/EICSB 05/88 i Reliability of Open Cycle Service C. Hickey N. Wagner Water Systems l i 61 SRV Discharge Line Break Inside The DSR0/RSIB M 11/30/83 - DSR0/ RIB 03/87 i Wetwell Airspace of BWR Mark I & A. Serkiz F. Eltawila Mark II Containments 65 C nent Cooling Water System DSR0/EIB H 07/28/83 DSR0/EIB 07/86 i F re J. Jackson J. Jackson 67 Steam Generator Staff Actions DSR0/EIB M 03/28/85 DBL /EB 12/87 K. Shaukat H. Conrad j l 68 Loss of AFWS Due to AFW Steam HELB DSR0/EIB H 04/24/84 DBL /PSB 10/87-K. Shaukat J. Ridgely 70 PORV and Block Valve Reliability DSR0/EIB M 05/14/84 DPL-B/RSB 02/87
- R. Kirkwood C. Liang
_ _ _. _ . ._ _ _ _. __ __ . . _ _ .- _ _ _ . . _ __. ~ m Tab M (centinued) N ',, R:spo(n a le Current Div./ Branch Date Location of- Current .- Issue and New Task Approved for Old Task Resolution Number Title Manger Priority Resolution Manager Date-77 Flooding of Safety' Equipment DSR0/EIB H 09/08/83 DPL-A/PSB 08/86 Compartments by Back-Flow Through D. Thatcher A. Singh Floor Drains ! 79 Unanalyzed Reactor Vessel Thermal DSR0/EIB M 07/25/83 DPL-B/EB 09/86
- Stress During Natural Convection J. Page M. Hartzman Cooldown 82 Beyond Design Bases Accidents in DSR0/RSIB M 12/07/83 DHFT/TSCB 09/86 1
Spent Fuel Pools E. Throm M. Wohl 84 CE PORVs DSR0/RSIB NR 02/27/85 DSR0/ RIB TBD l S. Diab V. Leung ! 93 Steam Binding of Auxiliary DSR0/RSIB H 10/19/84 DBL /PSB 06/87 j Feedwater Pumps A. Spano T. Chandrasebarn l 94 Additional Low-Temperature- DSR0/RSIB H 07/23/85' DPL-B/RSB 10/86 l Overpressure Protection For E. Throm E. Lantz Light Water Reactors 99 RCS/RHR Suction Line Interlocks DSR0/RSIB H 08/13/85 DPL-B/RSB TBD i on PWRs A. Spano E. Lantz 3 i 101 BWR Water Level Redundancy .DSR0/RSIB H 05/06/85 DHFT/TSCB 09/86 J. Joyce K. Desai l ! 103 Design For Probable Maximum DSR0/EIB 01 09/04/85 DPL-A/EB 07/86 i Precipitation L. Heller R. Ballard l 105 Interfacing System LOCA at BWRs DSR0/RSIB H 06/11/85 DBL /RSB 07/87 l H. Woods G. Thomas a l i
r Div./ Branch Location of Curr:nt Date Issue and New Task Approved for Old Task Resolution' Number Title Manger Priority Resolution Manager Date A-17 Systems Interaction' DSR0/EIB USI 01/79 DSR0/EIB 08/86* D. Thatcher D. Thatcher A-29 Nuclear Power Plant Design for the DSR0/RSIB M NRR-OP DPL-A/PSB 05/87 Reduction of Vulnerability to A. Serkiz A. Singh Industrial Sabotage A-30 Adequacy of Safety Related DC Power DSR0/EIB H NRR-OP DPL-A/EICSB 02/86 Supplies D. Thatcher A. S. Gill A-40 Seismic Design Criteria DSR0/EIB USI 01/79 DSR0/EIB TBD S. Shaukat S. Shaukat A-43 Containment Emergency Sump DSR0/RSIB USI 01/79 DSR0/RSIB 10/85 Performance A. Serkiz A. Serkiz A-44 Station Blackout DSR0/RSIB USI 01/79 DSR0/RSIB 12/86 A. Rubin A. Rubin A-45 Shutdown Decay Heat Removal DSR0/RSIB USI 02/81 DSR0/RSIB 03/87 Requirements A. Marchese A. Marchese A-46 Seismic Qualification of Equipment DSR0/EIB USI 02/81 DSR0/EIB 02/86 in Operating Plants T. Chang T. Chang A-47 Safety Implications of Control DSR0/EIB USI 02/81 DSR0/EIB 12/86 Systems A. Szukiewicz A. Szukiewicz A-48 Hydrogen Control Measures and DSR0/EIB USI 02/81 DSR0/EIB 12/86 Effects of Hydrogen Burns on Safety C. Ferrel T. Su Equipment A-49 Pressurized Thermal Shock DSR0/RSIB USI 12/81 D$RO/RSIB 03/86 H. Woods H. Woods
*I .-
u i- yk
- .' .? ?.k :.
?.5 e y.u:; +, ...$0 ? . ;;p.. s , -e.- _ .y ,[., ? ,;a q ,-q...u., ..%
?
...- : , ; sy. : - ; . .,; .
g,gy,_. gs , . .,.< 9..u; 4,.n.1, 7., .x:;y.c r .+w. . , , g ,, ;. ..... -;. g,;. . ; . .a _.r_. n,;- - .. 7, > f:;: . 5:, r - , i,- - - , e. .m.
;,. gYu y; A..=.?
,4 .:-
4 ' <
. 5;G ,ds..;: r:rTn~.-. p. a ., . . . . .;. ;%; l.J _ %. : u.s..:.:,.L' o
~
=
= ,' t'?*M.a
%- sy. .o.
*u.
'i J :-l &?7h 6..i. (.;<( f a"A : ' ~; ' :-." L <R.7.'
% .'l.L .. ' ..h - (.;....,s ;,t.)
L : . .' ,n
- h. L;.acq63@.L'n C.P Nj ? n *
- 4:..+ *:;E . %. i;7 2% : ,. 9
~
i ~ ' * . - ; 9 's : - :
- a:b.E W:-{ 5 i:).'W.Y;.;,D*l .
- ( . :;.e - : r. ? .~ d : .
_ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.m__. m._... .m .,_.._...~._m ,_ _ m _.____.-._._.._ ._ ._ _ ..._. _ . _ - . . _ . , __, . . j q Tab >-4 (continued) [, I Respo(hl ale - . Div./ Branch Date Location / ' Current . . Issue and New Task Approved for Old Task Resolution- ' Number Title. Manger Priority Resolution Manager Date > 1 B-5 Ductility of Two Way Slabs and DSR0/EIB M NRR-OP DBL /EB- 09/87 l
- Shells and Buckling Behavior of 0. Rothberg 5. B. Kim Steel Containments ,
i B-6 Loads, Load Combinations, Stress DSR0/EIB H NRR-0P DPL-A/EB 10/86 ! Limits J. Page S. Hou B-55 Improve Reliability of Target Rock DSR0/EIB M NRR-0P DSR0/EIB 12/85 : Safety Relief Valves F. Cherny F. Cherny j B-56 Diesel Reliability DSR0/RSIB H NRR-OP DPL-A/EICSB 05/86
- A. Rubin 0. Chopra ,
i
- B-61 Allowable ECCS Equipment Outage DSR0/RRAB M NRR-0P DSR0/F08 11/87 Period A. Buslik E. Chow
! C-8 -Main Steam Line Isolation Valve DSR0/RSIB H NRR-0P DBL /PSB 12/86 ! Leakage Control Systems S. Diab J. Ridgely. l II.E.4.3 Containment Integrity Check DSR0/RSIB H NRR-0P DPL-A/EB 10/86 i S. Diab Y. S. Huang } II.E.6.1 Test Adequacy Study DSRO/EIB M NRR-0P DSR0/EIB 05/88 ! 0. Rothberg 0. Rothberg 2 3 i 1 1 i
n.) . ENCLOSURE 2 .
- GENERIC ISSUES TO BE RESOLVED BY ORIGINAL NRR TASK MANAGERS IN NEW ORGANIZATIONAL UNIT Responsible Div./ Branch Date Current Issue or Task Approved for Resolution Number Title Manger Priority Resolution Date ,
___ = 66 Steam Generator Requirements DORAS/BWR NR 11/16/83 11/85 E. Murphy r A-3, 4 Steam Generator Tube Integrity DORAS/BWR USI 01/79 12/85 and 5 E. Murphy B-64 Decommissioning of Nuclear Reactors DBL /PSB NR NRR-0P 12/85* F. Witt III.D.3.1 Radiation Protection Plans DPL-A/PSB H NRR-0P 11/85 R. Serbu 86 Long Range Plan for Dealing with DBL /EB NR 10/01/84 04/86 Stress Corrosion Cracking in BWR W. Hazelton Piping 91 Main Crankshaft Failure in DORAS/BWR NR 07/08/85 06/86 Transamerica DeLaval E. Murphy 83 Control Room Habitability (CRH) DPL-A/PSB NR 08/83 TBD J. Hayes
- Generic Issue to be transfered to RES by end 1st quarter FY-86.
e' kk: }4 ,j' q igr' Yl((
~
jv .
! ' .k _.-Q .' { ' , ' , ' l' $ff! 'f3'N -
Y?,% ?? & ;-WY: Ei Q;n:>NQiRi%lf..?3)@?i-%. ;f- ' .;f. ,_.',Nl'(Q . & * % Y~.:+p .i~.'- n : G ,.M-, V ii & ;
~
% % . ;y - 4 c: -LT .- N t . M.c- ,+$.
; \.+- f , :z y
- q,g.4.. . %.6 4- hyp -
,.; f:.i.. A : 2 3v w. d.se:/ rs - . - 0- - .; f; r: . .< - ..x p q.;qa.g .. ,p , ;< >
3,3 -(fe p p,. . g ly'g;y;;.; .;. V ),c. Y. ; . ; , . ;: ; ,_ ;[pg;; q. :. ._,
. g , ..t ;;, s t .
..-f. .7-g' -,.s.v.'
a *vy:;. yh. J.,5: p
- r. m ._ qq .
. .y, x,,Ji,j m y .,,g :. a .,,,N y.c, 3 . .;-a p p. ;. _
X, s ,.. .n . < e .-_ + .~ a wyn.
- u. ~ . ~ , ? , .y n
, , n. , . :, z L.. . . . -; < . . , . . -
,c- a ; . % ..}}