ML20136G133

Summary of 850517 Meeting W/Util,Bechtel & Westinghouse in Houston,Tx Re Audit Design Documentation of Mechanical Components.List of Attendees & Agenda Encl.Record Copy

ML20136G133
Person / Time
Site:	South Texas
Issue date:	06/11/1985
From:	Nerses V Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8506270081
Download: ML20136G133 (7)

Text

-

~

e. A f

_1 $8 a $ ffG Docket Nos.: 50-498 and 50-499 APPLICANT: Houston Light and Power Cenpany FACILITY: South Texas Project, Units 1 and 2

SUBJECT:

MEETING SLTPARY On May 17, 1985, NRC and applicant representatives met in Houston, Texas to perform an ASPE components documentation completeness review. Enclosure 1 provides the list of attendees to this meeting. Enclosure ? is a copy of the meetina notice and agenda. The agenda identifies the ASME components

- for which a documentation review was done. From this review a list of specific docurents were identified in Enclosure 3 for the applicant to submit to the NRC for detailed review. The applicant agreed to submit the Becthel documents by May 31,.1985.

/3 J Victor Nerses, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 3 Division of Licensing

Enclosures:

As stated DISTRIBUTION l Docket - File -

LB#3' Reading JLee Vfferses Pradambi GWKnighton Y $

3 DL:LB#3 L:LB#3 s PVadambi G Knighton 7/85 g/7/85. / 7 /85 e

75b6270071 a

p rar

( ) ^)

.' 'o,, UN@ED STATES 8 o NUCLEAA REGOLATORY COMMISSION h WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555

%,*****# JUN 111985 Docket Nos.: 50-498 and 50-499 APPLIC. ANT: Houston Light and Power Company FACILITY: South Texas Project, Units 1 and 2

SUBJECT:

MEETING

SUMMARY

On May 17,1985, NRC and applicant representatives met in Houston, Texas to perform an ASME components documentation completeness review. Enclosure 1 provides the list of attendees to this meeting. Enclosure 2 is a copy of the meetina notice and agenda. The agenda identifies the ASME components for which a documentation review was done. From this review a list of specific documents were identified in Enclosure 3 for.the applicant to submit to the NRC for detailed review. The applicant agreed to submit the Becthel documents by May 31, 1985.

. Victor Nerses, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 3 Division of Licensing

Enclosures:

As stated l

. t > )

South Texas Mr. J. H. Goldberg William S. Jordan, III, Esq.

Group Vice President, Nuclear Harmon, Weiss & Jordan Houston Lighting and Power Company 2001 S Street, N.W.

P. O. Box 1700 Suite 430 Houston, Texas 77001 Washington, D. C. 20009 Brian Berwick, Esq.

Mr. J. T. Westermeir Assistant Attorney General Manager, South Texas Project Environmental Protection Division Houston Lighting and Power Company P. O. Box 12548 P. O. Box 1700 Capitol Station Houston, Texas 77001 Austin, Texas 78711 Mr. E. R. Brooks Mr. Claude E. Johnson, Resident Mr. R. L. Range Inspector / South Texas Project Central Power and Light Company c/o U. S. NRC P. O. Box 2121 P. O. Box 910 Corpus Christi, Texas 78403 Bay City, Texas 77414 Mr. H. L. Peterson Mr. Jonathan Davis Mr. G. Pokorny Assistant City Attorney City of Austin City of Austin P. O. Box 1088 P. O. Box 1088 Austin, Texas 78767 Austin, Texas 78767 Mr. J. B. Poston Mr. A. Von Rosenberg Ms. Pat Coy City Public Service Board Citizens Concerned About Nuclear

• P. O. Box 1771 Power San Antonio, Texas 78296 5106 Casa Oro San Antonio, Texas 78233 Jack R. Newman, Esq.

Newman & Holtzinger, P.C. Mr. Mark R. Wisenberg 1615 L Street, NW Manager, Nuclear Licensing Washington, DC 20036 Houston Lighting and Power Company P. O. Box 1700 Melbert Schwartz,Jr., Esq. - Houston, Texas 77001 Baker & Botts One Shell Plaza Mr. Charles Halligan Houston, Texas 77002 Mr. Burton L. Lex Bechtel Corporation Mrs. Peggy Buchorn P. O. Box 2166 Executive Director - Houston, Texas 77001 Citizens for Equitable Utilities, Inc.

Route 1, Box 1684 Brazoria, Texas 77422 l

, )

s 2-Regional Administrator - Region IV U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 611 Ryan Plaza Drive Suite 1000 Arlington, Texas 76011 Mr. Lanny Sinkin Citizens Concerned About Nuclear Power 3022 Porter St. N. W. #304 Washington, D. C. 20008 Mr. S. Head HL&P Representative Suite 1309 7910 Woodmont Avenue Bethesda, Maryland 20814 I

k l

I I

.....o -. * - * . - . - , - -

- ~ - - . - * . ~ --- - - ,- && h 4 I

7.. p . .. .. , . , .

...4 ' :  :-

)q . . . . _,

j .. . : .,.j .

j MES/.5 672 M& ..

j'  !

z. ..

A1Af 19,19 2.f~.. .... . ...{..l.

g . .

y.i .

y.

h.. . ,. .j.u

, .I _J ! . ! . .. . .-

4. . _; I I

j. , .  ; ...Nn W - . -. i : ..c a suens y . ._.....L.rif4.(

y .1 { .L i j' ' . . .

7. 4_p .

J .

. ,.;.,. ...._. . . , .! 4 1-e M.V..ceNrisor i-

. SscHrrc . . Pafar P434o- En&wgenu <r k, CA.4Jf C MSN 5- pt. Ar4T S.b.IWN - L tab

1 -

b $k. .NoYkQW

. NYbh/j'?. 44f 0

} mhed thsd soecr m g1. _

MNeet, Acwachaerniy

Jos LJ k O < HL+P Pr a ,,j.u l Q - A m <, .

j; ' . S /4s 4d ^ 7, 1

gw .

1 . .. .. . .

{...Bluwlss.1911w .n fr.Eng,isev /.Phykl Desifr

g .

~~~

'O M @

.. N 6 LEV H PU,. . . . , .Dw, ye c.

I Out e-

~

z VoO { 6 n HSQ $ . Cngi.,wln $

1

] . DEN lose 88/Wk W . FEprHMENT~ Saetters Stre, ;

Whlias K6aen'x W duffear. Ne kh.-dorded& 7

. . ..i .

. ..._.4 ... .

[

Sen. w. v e- ( f . M o o tt- NAd&AfL . . %s)v ; ..Q&*fisl l .! j r, .

__._..__..J  ;,.,  :

f- T'"> 12. W!t,4Ed NkC

. . _ . . 7/2 o T E s i /)fitni M R.. t I ,.-

(

IL.-

W WI $ .

flflAI6 96&lGil i.lbl. \flCAh0 A i i . . u ; .. -

{. p ey l Mlarry R - . .

'B.j i YA lEmkr'M 6- L--'

t f.

r

-'0/CK [0/1f.

i P//fAlf CoMbAlffs Ud/AlTfb l

. : ...< p. .ni. ,. a . .

ANM 6f f d '

. . . dkCCWJ/Mc j l . ..i..,

(

l. .

f Enl,jk/prov Q& ll4 t ,

&~r-4E6 fb.Dm.r.g ! .

Q. /Cy l : \ .i  :

. Eve- /P 4 b g k #M d,,is*/fa #  ; j.i.j; . ..

f

. . . . . .. 2 . l.;. . ,

e , . .

U

.; . }._.

4 i

y . ,

-. w .-...-.

.l

.. - . . - . - - . ~ ..

.u.._...,-.

i . -

-..-.,--.i.-.

- i i ;

. . . . ). - - . -- . . . - -- . ) -- . s . . i -

)' . .. .. ._, . . . . . _ .!. .._..- ,

l

',_4..._... _N y1 M L'"~ ..

_ . . , . . .: .___ .-C G)*1 9/f N M, .,  ! i TI T L s' .

' .I . .. J i ... . .._}. . .. . .

.. .H.. a%Irw.. . .I

.- .- . pect/752- 4 - K. 6. . . .

Q. . . &. fN&N. . . 1. . . .. . . . -. ..

. .. _ . . J,c.Pstet_,'. "

. ... . . . . . . . _ - . . _ . . .. . . . I. j.--__..E 4. . . .

i Q. .

h .

,i u w t. h gpg"

,4 , ..4 . . . g. w. ev s 5 e _ :sec.cre ' .

r pc ,

i [V)#

I iti ;as.cw m a W

i . .. -. 3 m.uh bha /,.sw - e i . .

1. cs streu TL ii

( . Tokn_ ' ' 0 '

. l D . TL-

.l

' TenyCanada. , l.wbs

,e n

(-

8c05:02 kl46aa. . .

P D e, y -- .

I!.

G E b yr.f9prh ,

t 3

.. j . i .j ;

Hanwnn -eArrk-d .

n .

~

. _Pz'rL i v - .

i . . . . .

. j . . -

.g a  ! ,  ! . ,. i i e i

. .j t

- j i t

!  ! j *

• 4 .j.

}i

.} } .. ., ..l '

, 1  : , . 1

. . . , . ,i 2 .. - , , ,. ,

, i 4 . . .

i I t-. y.

i i l .I

. i i

e I i - * - - + .

. )

i , . .

' 3 . .

t .; , ,I -

l '

._....t... ,

6 4 3 i

g . ~~ -

i i ,

i i

. . 1

, )

4 . ..

.l .

• 3- ' ,-. '

' 4

. . . 1. .

l

. . t .

.). ,

{ l

, I ,

. -. . 4

>a ,.

t -

l

• g . j 4 ..

3, . - .

. . , l  !

{4 j .

, . _..; 3-

{. {. i I . , ,

9 ** , -

' { '-

$ J . .-

J l t ,I .. ._. .

! 3

. - . . . . . . - t 3 4 . ,

i #

. .; 4 .1 . . .i.

I

- 4 . . .

j. . . . .,. . . .  ! ' 3

i

[ '

.y - . . .

.h _ ! { j '

! -.l. -.

1 ' -

l i j

.r i .

' I . -

' 4 .

t -.

-j- g*f i-i

. i

. . .. _ . . ._. .. j . . .

} .'. ;.

r l

J.

f J

. s t

..4... - .

7._..a -  ;

I a_ .

._l  ; d. . , 4 ., . .

g

i , i . 4 .

3 >

I (  !

9 .. , , .

4 _

[.-..4 l ; 7. . .

! I

.i.. ' . .

Ii

, .. . _. . .-f.. .

8 I

il ' .

^

1

! . 4 4

. . 1

)

.. 4

. MEETING

SUMMARY

DISTRIBUTION t

Docket.,No(s):.50-498/499 NRC POR Local POR NSIC PRC System

-L83' Reading Attorney, OELD.

GWXnighton Project Manager VNerses JLee NRC PARTICIPANTS .

S. Moore V. Nerses 1

bec: Applicant & Service List 4

8 lwa U95MG k

[9,9 UNITED STATES

[ g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

$ :j WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555

• • O 'S 1985 Docket Nos.: 50-498 I and 50-499 i

MEMORANDUM FOR: George W. Knighton, Chief

! Licensing Branch No. 3 Division of Licensing FROM: N. Prasad Kadambi, Pro.iect Manager .

Licensing Branch No. 3 l Division of Licensing

SUBJECT:

NOTICE OF MEETING WITH HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER SOUTH TEXAS PROJECT TO AUDIT DESIGN DOCUMENTATION OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS DATE & TIME: May 17, 1985 Begin 8:00 am LOCATION: HL&P Offices 5400 Westheimer Avenue Houston, Texas 77251 PURPOSE: The discussions at the meeting will be based on the review process shown in the enclosure.

PARTICIPANTS: NRC HL&P BETCHEL

_,N. P. Kadambi M. Weisenburg, et al. D. Ashton, et al.

S. Moore, ORNL E.Rodabaugh,ORNL-/y WESTINGHOUSE W. Garrin et al.

f% ,

N. Prasad dambi, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 3, DL

Enclosure:

As sta.ted i

cc: See next page NOTE: NRC Meetings are open to interested members of the public to attend as observers. Those who wish to attend must contact P. Kadambi,-(301-492-7272) j before May 14, 1985.

1

.?n 1 (~ 4 l .

I

• Q)

] -

I, (Proposed)

AGENDA i

NRC MECHANICAL ENGINEERING BRANCH AUDIT ASME COMPONENTS DOCUMENTATION COMPLETENESS REVIEW ,

MAY 16, 1985 (9:00 AM)

Design documentation, including design specifications, stress reports and/or calculations, will be reviewed and identified for detailed

' NRC review for the following ASME components:

I I. NSSS (Westinghouse) 4 l

I A. Reactor Coolant (RC) Pump B. RC Pump Supports (

(C . RC Loop Piping f D. Class 2 Motor Operated Valve (MOV) from Containment i Spray (CS) System E. Roto-lok Reactor Vessel Head Closure Systems II. BOP

'2-

, A. Component Cooling Water (CCW) Pump B. ' Main Steam (MS) ' Safety Relief Valve '

i C. MS Piping between Steam Generator and Isolation Valve (MSIV)

D. MS Piping Support III. Summary - List of Requested Documents k

- . ~ , -- _ _ . . -- _ . , ,. . . . , _ , . - - . . ,. _

( - - - . .

ENct OSup4[3

. t> S,/)7l8r

% H? T<u.1/ H.v> /,,, P/L

. e.+

h v., . .

Esaip. sp . 9s 2 7 2 i , ra <. y ,

f/st/,s ' ll

&c.a , e../.e ta 7 . .

W c-rs t a v 2 , teca. 2, T/z/75 m.a.c a.ia ,

y, ,u..u in, u m,9 a a re,a, )

rnea.4 ai. i ,e, J

.Diti.' .u:<r (Pe r. 2 hJ v- x W E m b , E. M. S3S/

kath Texa, (P 'e et (4 ,,/ stru . ), /M U Jo o &ack, Ca.i J fuovy ,

fw (L u- d. <, Su ese ~~ry WyJ , 2/25~l8/

ww o, e.n. m 2, e<<.1 s/n/re , Va.r. is z as a , n e s ca a a - , e, - c. e~ n, n..s 9.,1 k)& 1H D, G. tif, [OQ b At /. /, 2ll2l7 7, Mas ws re- e P -

ca na,s Hoge pay, bds l

r N e . .-

• 9 h+

-e , . , - , -. -, -,. g

1

. I

. ( pA Tuas /Nowas P/L ) g/ir/s.r Jef h 5 - Mo he of<rahd fake- d a,k w. ,:,, .. r G.

% erat G Vs2rs0 , n. o, y'x y'n '

M.hr ofeaald Casa vake r, i; . !s 84 PY sk, .LA- f, cia, / 2g 3 In hio m !?ts. / ,. llll8 /

ic : 95 22 7 Y, R e .r. Y,

//'t ajyy flamfJg$rof>'=Ad I*

(< /< % 4e s, is ; <. :: 4 4 t*Y Sea, Lii~ H Dress d.7d f.e V)<sho n howe Gls:: / Hvc les. Vo/w.t , 4 ind,4j'aye s yah (a/en kr hetkgJhvsal'ddab

f. M. No. s/5 V, /1}!L/ 77, Yo!;. 1 & 2r p< wry >:

• 85 7 317 9 l -

fe w. 3 O

4 t

S'.

i s

t t *

} S/ '!!/E f 8

h' >*

• K Tece3l#, a s h r# L &a pip a, Llea w ><y 9k fy< Des ty., statn, astus 2  % 6/ ass 1, hr Ka>lrQ yh/u,

.a e.n c , . g , s..u ran , er a, ww u n.a D

, 93 331$i . Us e fs l a.] 2 , '

t tu. e tofu 72 So us rA u alsove b d wifG ffe nsio n /

doldllS/lC5 - _ - -

WEAP 913 C , fuly IT)T, Shuc hed Ase ut of /fu ch L / d La f, Fe lia LA rent <%p), .- /> 14 2, Va. I, 19.,9si>st & rs.l Cet.J % Rpig RPT-M fD- PCC-v77, I?es. o, ///7/H

/Ceuke do e/oa / . 4 o .,, Pipc<ry Pm Ocsi ar daIculafa ,3-for luolf C<vek it.,if 14. I f. RAP) f W. . I (Sc P)

. CdUcusy

/va ^  % 1%ds

[ En fra au m. //al, Je h c.J uli/t r c.) ao n wrH & de>,, < f. a- S. w14 T:. < > . ) yre usikdre of wIraf PdaJed e</c->a/,o. of hjo, chese a? e eiso ,

(it.~ asa y.o aaans: o.> -.f-< - a a n .O

~

~

h & ,

(Q4 yqg g ,'y & he l

l oe =

w

-M _ p.eeg - e w , gne ---Aq-

^) @r/rr

.Sa a N *,Tua.1,I Lik Pf L

$ o~ff

$offoas & Primey Lt > fu~f r 1.

G.-951H Y rfeak &JM yZsk seme,/ Supp.cl.c .bitsv1 tw.0,9/t/W .S xa6 , knG 2C  % > (fe s w se A ,

. . P., etv 4 f e w y .< )

953s33 (Lie ren.t .s ) sradas 4-rhh fer. 0, 3p/17 C- 15'Z( 2 Y (=a be o ebei /b"'re*'*eaAs =G< & thek- ado f Ssk' y

/f tre. I ,I /75 Ce' grund SverAh Wcnp W ? C,moaeft f'ed - shn /vra M,rg w o F as w z., sc w a. . . ea - -

hA. 2 (Q,sa.4% of wh.) wit /

_n k dw ha .%M Te. car J

.R SSDC1.3 (f , J.dA Tecas )

w --

.8

~

., 'y "

j R -- # _, _^_ -

Yet,1 An V J. 4 cla.s.r / , s u . p t<<y p ip i- y__

%.t.s - upx V't i J ~ nr 4 3 ..__. ...._. -_. . _

_ _ . ._...m.__- = - -

Sauft, Tues / N.<6 r/ l

.,'  : U y 5l'TlH

@, f

W - rt.+.t. a .

9 y x.. cuc - an - 1.,, , ,w e - ..

/Hac.Jan 1 fn e* ,,

14 .,n;o .t 4 Phal C. kal, dye.~4 he Se-/f 7tu s th}r f,

2 WC4 P- N17, Go t. - L.x et.2 ,n s ia.-

. ys Develop .a Ass ~ vy3 9 b (b1 n.n a., t.-a e i pi - reee edwa s & b ai *e a yr..,4 -

s

-e e

C e

e h

i t

s .

.-.ee...q-,,---.,,+-,.

__ . _ - . - .y _ , , , , _ _ , * ' - ' " - - ' ' " - " " ' ' ~ '

A 4 ew**G 4'* **w* 66 *h a 4 ,gg , , , _ 4 49, %--

O &

i._) ..) r//?ps 5"/R rem L k- FVL

$ gG eaua_

~ ~

.T_ . ' ,

P FgmL CC W jwaCl 3 '{,

1

,a-g* ,$ .

~~. .

3 $ ?e 9 /Y S0o J/

. ., ~ ) (%. O, ' / 7l.?f wo Q Ada&duM.5 / eud 3

2. 'f

• 2J.J, ), a

$J U h n f D.*tC h a } t - ,

__ = - 3.

O

_t Se ua.c b < /y su rcyad Gee b42 No. >y 91 G -1012 - ore n -cyr 1,/>y,/gS-mm --

_~- - 7 ~ .

+

a l

i b

i T * - ,

b S-l

• f

\ _ H M liza rlHousc6 <> Pp L _) s/tr/gs

@ *f f5cchkl Ma<rsh-,y.tr r9" sin %t ,

.A & A sra,a a-.i .ry g y v. m i '**

Des,y,

+E 97 9 SJoe s Ck 2e.J3 '

Kens , 3ll aft $*

Bda Ed.r :F e 0/9 & YY 7/ '/, .%4 / -/ 8

)

, Jelsews c quak),Qp .wt a b;/,,ty A + 19EStosg I YA $f

• f r~ ]N.92 6 - Yd3Y- 0102.f- BDT

% .v a m WsLt I Vf 2 4 - Yuz y - are 2 9 - 6 0T Foot [. t Sk T<siq JY 9 24 ~ fo 31 - 0 o o 2 - A p.t I e O =

Sy u (ofJ) yew we n Sfe. ( Sm hWe o.aberc :p M thr. 0. )

9 O

t

.. \ pg g.

$n/rs k)

@ of[

EaJkJ

>; ny :

9 2

~

u. SS/0yt?TIoro Rin16 5 Due  ! c;];,., j, , rs)oqtt2Iojo y,l'f,s,,1 h(in ,

$< s. '), 1o}9/19 .$, , t.fm h a P 4 L.

.L;oe List, CL n 9P Goal, Fy s 3 2 Fa t,<icain, Sk.( , */Lo 2 o fJ p / o a f

• /

Rd SA0/0PS002 '

Sh.e Geor< h is fe.se inhs C4/c. /'4, 2 eld /fcroar

^

M oes Ek.n a Lis e .Gek) Ne/J Sif i ?py ) N 1 % CcIc 2 b)

Crofer;A for Pt(my De.s.y S L 61 M P l001 M..u w a. ., su n, zi oro ec coio cae .

p c7,y 1.

,3,,a; finrx A A st.s C,., h ei a slo l0itq/o0'2.

), .

ihem+

"l'?l#5 Sn ) ke,

~

//* 4 <. P4L _

)

@u4 @

__Suppe&s S te & '

Ag u Supp.< /t far AJMS 22C hpm; 'lL 280 75 low for % ksfon L FF L ,

VL ly'75 Jose Ru.4,'//t/tS P.y s1p,a 7 w y s p aa (easticah]

3 C - A*J- 900 ! - n't So l (, N 23 -* // MJ u:M %g, MS-9*ol-ML S~*! G [3 sheets) tz _ L ,j -T -. _ ??

c oies ui. rm y pp.i a 1 +

b Znr/a%)mr Zor/m/am No./2> P' y.

NPs1 - rp - o 3- sre, 6 <. 9 , .clica s- ajs a.,4 7 -

O

-t

• *J.

E, . , '.

o hf f$$ $

.