ML20129A128
| ML20129A128 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Wolf Creek  |
| Issue date: | 02/05/1985 |
| From: | Martin L NRC - WOLF CREEK TASK FORCE |
| To: | Rowell K AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20128R100 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-85-161 NUDOCS 8507270169 | |
| Download: ML20129A128 (12) | |
See also: IR 05000482/1984033
Text
g% b - 5 3 - su -
>A
f e f st e f- r c '
FEB 0 5 35
Kenneth Rowell
9
Dear Mr. Rowell:
Enclosed is a copy of hRC Inspection Report 50-482/84-33.
This report
relates to inspection of the Heating and Ventilatior, and Air Conditioning
(HVAC) systers.
Section 2.g. addresses your concerns regarding HVAC
installation and inspection activities.
Should you have questions cor.cerning
the enclosed repc.rt, please contact this office at (817)E50-8153.
We appreciate your interest and concerns in the safety of the activities at
the Wolf Creek Generating Station.
Sincerely,
.
O
m' ST ed By:
3. TIN"
L. E. Martin, Chief
Wolf Creek Task Force
Enclosure:
As stated
bec to DMS (IE01)
bcc distrib. by RIV:
- RPSI
P. O'Connor, NRR
K. Kneil, NRR
- RF52
- Resident Inspector
R. D. Martin, PA
- E r i,:05
'Section Chie' (F:E2!:)
- FIV File
, :q-ise, : :U
T. Westerrr
M, r or. La rr a r , E L L , VM E ( 2 )
J. Har risor., F III
Lc' 5A5 ST ATE DEPT. HE ALTH
- RSTS Operator
- P. Weiss, LFME (A~-2C15)
,4.
Madser.
CERTIFIED Mall - RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
[
RDB2
g.T
//'
'
GLMadsen:gb
LEMA
in
.. / t' /85
. / 4/85
>[ b
8507270169 B50603
STEPHENB5-161
-
-
.
. .
?.
.a -Ji-ts
.
. . ,
//
gy A-7r
-
a n r,n , l' n dpn t'
/. C la s a / <
^ i -,
39 - s g .
~
2.
R.
& w < r/
- e x s +. n, a //es.r l
-
n /p a,,
/ a. ,
-
. i/2. tn - eo ,, f., - -s>
,-
a.
,
(foyee S4s,,<y/C #
4
o cow.u
-
.
7
-
2/)85
3
L#m
m a. / ./ 7;
4 .-<#. i n ,
.
5
I Oc /><6.,wr w X.
g (cg-n ?7 r
y.&v-n.o)
^
'
0l0pel
- 9/6 /ff .
,
i
(
,
..
- . .
. - . - .
- . - .
.
-
._.
.- -_. - -
_
_
_ _ _ _ . _ _ _
-
.-
--
- . , - - .
, . .
w.. u
. , . .
v
--*
=;
- t
.,ju l
.
-
,.a
.<
, , , .
.
.
3 j[ .
!
.
'
a. m 3
.
.
..
.
-
-
m.
.
.
-
.
,,
.
,s
. .i
.
.
-
- . -
-
y
- :-
,
.
,
_
.-
- -
(3
2-
-
.
- . . .
4X3
.-
ff .,
.<
..
,(
2
cn
4,
.
,
,.
.,
-
e-
-
-
.
.-
<
e e
e
<
,
.
o
-
-
,
.r
..,
.
.
-,
-
-
!
t. ,
-
ws,r -
-
czU
m
-
,
a
,
.
-
r
,
3
. .. -
~
1
. , .
.s,.
- =
..
h .,
-~
-
i.
.
.
-
. - .
- -
.
.,
.
.
-
1
.
s. .a
-
-:
-
N
,/
.
.
-
..
,
N
t
<
_ _ - . _ _
-' y
ac
..
.
.
"
-* -
(r.
==_
=
-.
.-
<
-
r
-
.-
-
-,
_
.-
,
-
.
--
s
-. - -
..e
>
.
.
.
s,
-
.
~
.
Nh
-
,.
G. x - w* k 5- 4. : . D. '.
'
~ .1 'i ?. - ., : f.'s :
-
.,
..:
<. , .
.
- . .W [. :'
w' O.,
, . . .x t .x*'.he
. :.
. , . - -
.
-- .-
- ..
. . - .
- ' . , . -
.
v 3 . ,.
v.p. : ,
-
Y. ,. .
. . . ..s. . - -Ad' .r.
. -r
, T .
. .,
. -
.- -
' ;y .
, . . -
. = ~
.
-
._
- . ,, % -
- s . s c' ;.-
'n-;
.>
p. . v.,y
.
..
. -- ..
-
.
- 4-
K
,e
.a
-.
--
}\\ .; j ~Q,5.~: .*: ~
.,. y--
.
.,Y.
h'd
'
'
r,u % .:F P
'
.
4-
t..
'
.. .
- . W ,- p; , r.:
.l ;k
w
, %;. ~y . , -
..
.
-
.
. . . ..
.e.-
.
-
_-
..
-..-
...
. . - . ..; - , , - - .
,.;
-
..
_ ..
.:
, . . .
a. ,. ,y, .y.
.
-
.
..
.
ra
.
.
.
- .
.
.
.: .
g . ,, , .
- .*.,.,
-
.
.u
.., ,
..
..-
..
-
.
...
s
.
.
.
-
.
c.
.a - , , . .
. .. ,,y
-
e
..
1y . .
.
.: -... ., . ~ y - .
.
-.
.-
, . . .
.?.
g, . :.: s;. 7 > .
.g:
%;- ~
u..- -. - : p :. p :. ~ :. ,. .,.4,;
&
, :--2.W
- .
,
. --s.
- 1,p;.J,; #. -;a v. - . ' ~
.
= 'a. --g .
~
.w. s f:.M.'G.:r - Q, Ni'??.?:'t:.
.-. %;
-
.s;.s?4f<%H L.M
-
.
'::s m i
.
-
v.... % .'i 2i :WPlgV
d
-
-
.- r
-
5 1.;: .;
.
QR
~ . - : x. - .. .:..
. -
. . ~u .
.o
.-
~
.
-
~
.
t,gy..-g.,
.
..
. .Y .y * Q
.
-- ..
}
.
": .
s 4-. . < L-
'
+ - -
_
.
. .
,
.
m
,
'
- -;.g.i3rr
-
.~-
. .-
v.
-
.
.y%
....:
.
^
' . ;.,J < ir. W
.-
.:
..
'
s
.c.
--
t,
..',.-' g;*--
. . .
'
..
, ,
,.
b
-
.C
+ .:-J
- - : ;- > '.~. c. -
.. .
.T-
..
.
y
-
-
- .
l*
.:-
f.
..
c
.,
-
'
e
t .
.
.
.
-
- - -
.
,
y
.
,
i
- .
x
l
',.,6,
-
..
N
. . ".;-
s
-
,
.
.
,
- , .
,.....'%-
-
.
.
- -
. *
\\
-:. q ,
.
-
-
~
'
y.
..
-
.
.
,
.,
..
.
_
7
-
.#
..
.
,
.
-
- :
...
.
..
-
.
-
, .r-
, g-
,
. . . ./7
y* L
.
,
2
.
. .
--
.
-
, - -
.
9: a
a v
- ,r.
,
.
,,
. . . ,
..,;...*
i
-3
..
- f .,
- . .
r t .. '
.
- .<.*. . . *c,
-r.-
-
.
.y.
t ,, -,
, . ..
.
!
.
. ;*., . :
.
.-
-,
.-
.
.
, . .
-
-
. , ' .i.
.
. < :, a 4,.,,i ., .
.y *;'s.
- .
. .u-~
- .
..*
i ,. . $.. .
-
=s
- .
~ ~
..r . .
~
-
.
,
- ...-
<-
,.
,
. ;, A,.:,}
-
- -
-
n,s
p.
...
. .
-~
.
.
.
.
- , *
g. . f . *.
,r , ; . L. ., - .
.s.*
l
7 ;,
. . . .
.
.
.
-
- .
.+
.
- '
C
,g.
. .
,.
,
. , , . .. " . . . . , .p' c .
..
t.2
-
p
,,. .,
.
.
.r.
.
'
..-
s.
.
. -
.
>
+4
,;-....1: ~ . .
.
. , , . . . .c...,...-
. - r. '.s. . . r .s. .
.
. .
c. .-
.
.
.. .
.
. . 4
a.
-
s.
. *- -
.
..
.
..
...
- '
. ..
, . . . w. . . - . .
. . . -
.
..
3
..
- J g.. . . ~ .
m
n
.
w.,..,,.
,.
.
.
3
t
. . .
b'M .W, s .
.;
. .. :. : =:.3.! ,.v.. ,r .
. -
e . f . .- e. f. . n
-
L ) ' ;;. Mry,R..A
y.
ao
.
,
-
. s.
,
s
4
.
.
7. -;.
.
, .
..;. n ..: -
.
_
t,
.w Qa
..
e
.
,
.
..
. dN.&. - .. Va~' W X %.A.a W W +.7,;h.M y
.
.
.,
. . . . ,
- :
rs.a
e
).
$
,
f,.
I
h
.N-
f,S
.
'
.
..
. s+-
.
- . .
.-
.
5. E4.%.. ,..) Y ' %. .% 9 $ 2 *; 4 .:.:. 1. %y
,y
<o
.
.
....-
. . . . . . , .
.
..
.
- .x?srV.
. 1-
.
. ..
, ...
.
.
m
,
.
..
'
,
. . . ..
'
.
,
.
. g . . e .u m . . . u.
,
_
.
.m.
. ..
..
-
.
.
.
.. . . .
.
_
'
um TED STATES POSTAL SE. NICE
r
]
m.cm
SiEDia6865U.UCifiOist
E
d
_
a
e
g)
"' "' * *"*
e ,
e..s
ucos.a
w.
o..
came== nome t. 2. and 3 en .e smeena
L"3
e
Annaish.as.:===w.ess m
.
.n. s. ms .e .nass
Emmans sesi. -a.en. acessi aeossame
.
edgesmas as ausness.
aETuaw
TO
Nuclear Regulatory Conmission
(New dSeds)
611 Ryan Plaza Drive, Suite 1000
(,1icest or P.O. Imm)
Arlinoton. Ty 76nii
.
M..
-
(Oty Sasa,and ZIPCode)
0.plMSEO
.
t
g
.
--. - - . - --- -- -- - - -
- - - - - - - - -
43
4
hI'l A ='7Cs Y F2 A - 79 , y. / y. Ar . ,o
A G de a.
Centre nac.s !. 2. esd 3.
-e.vae wree mi N -tITusue 70* ayme an
ace
p,
I 1. N f.fm erske is regseceJ (ctack ame.)
.;
C 57.w to ss.n and ice 2e . .ett& ...........
e
j'
C % = u . , en, <*a e4 . .' eu c4 ..eer?. . .
4
C RISTRICIEDIfJiM
s.- s,. w -ot..,: _ e.......... _ .I
a
C RISTRKTEDDE1.f. LAY.
Show to ehn Ja.s. a d O hem cf fe':- y $_
.
(Cohsi't.T P06Th1ASTE FOR FUS)
-
t uruu *:nasmus n
5 lenneth Rowell
'
i
I.
s un ,:ta e,c c a w m ,
u - .a..s
.
. . , , . .
_.
3
P26 572511E
!
G,=evs own monatwo of ssMresort er agent)
g
. t '.s e rhme3 the car te :cu .le abova.
I
t . 0 *?.7*. M
Ch*e
sened w
S
d-1 . <
'
i, ,
__ ___
!
"gff[~'
{N '$
la
y
.n.a
_ .,_......
4
1303
.
r.
k 3 useASLE TO DELPWER C1(.,Aust:
ME S
masteALS
I
E
QGPQ 's47o ** a
b-00-0 *79
)
e
ALLEGATION R[ VIEW
Date: F ebrua ry 28, 1985
CASE NUM8ER
4-83-A-079
DATE OPENED
10/17/83
FACILITY NAME
Wolf Creek
50-4L2
SU8 JECT
Intimidation of craft
and workmanship problem
!
SOURCE OF ALLEGATION
L. Wiezork, welder
j
K. Rowell, welder
'
NUMBER OF ALLEG.
2
i
ASSIGNED TO
RPS C
CROSS REF. NO.
ACTION SCHEDULED
Inspection
.
FIRST/LAST NAME
W. Johnson
DATE ASSIGNED
10/17/83
REPORT NUMBER
1st:
2nd.
Lst:
FT5 NUMBER
8-728-8100
DUE DATE
ALLEGATION SUBSTANT
SORT CODE
C
DATE CLOSED
ACT10h 0FFICE
RIV
MAN HOURS
REPORT PREPARATION
ASSIST
DET AI LS:
1. L. Wiezork told SRI that on 10/13/83 his
~
'
,
'
'
tF eate ed bin if he (b'e: en ' mace allecatic s te NP: atte
- '(:: . se':
6. E:.+'
- . ' c : s:. .:
-Is.
,c
- ea.a
- ; a;
E:: . 'a--
Ro.eli Kne* of quality construction ' colen.s;
2. Investigation turned over to
KG&E with SRI monitoring; and 3. As of 10/18/83, KG&E state
appeared to be substance to quality ( pects of allegation.1_d to SRI that therel 0]
incicates that Ro.eil has gone te Billy Garde (GAD) with com:laints that 60'.
proviceo improper info.
DOL call on 1/26/84, that case has been opened on
Rowell. DOL has ruled against Rowell. Combine with 4-83- A-75. 01 went to site
9/15/84 to evaluate KG&E Quality 1st Progran from the investigative view point
and will review the intimidation issue. Technical Insp. 84-33 closes technical
issues. Need to contact alleger. Letter sent to Rowell 2/5/85 returned. 01 memo
of 2/5/85 to RIV E0 closed out 01 interest.
s
L
-
.-
.
.
,
nn17 7 g
-
l
& t.s/ S h ~~
~
%n
cis , 4
~
gQJ
-
-
(
.
/Wf2
a44,
Ss.
u4o
M a
J.
,l ,
/
r
'7
I
i
~N
l
D
.\\N
f
-
,
.
.
7
AQ ~26 %
)
(
-
2
-
7) b & :
'
.
'
I
.
w~
'
(b l &~
,_ _ _ l e 5 Y
E
N=
,-
y
r
o
T
s
M
.
t
.
.3
N
(M
i.
71 g
A z t, e n ~ - %,
ta-a
<
g
5 % _.e.:
g',
.
P,
~
N
N
~
,g g ,
.
C:UCLt40 CEGUL ATCClY COMMISSION
I
[
Itt Gio4 iv
, [
4,$,, ,,,,,/
011 avale PLA2a Daivt 8pl18 Iggt
ant ctos, venas non
,
MEM3RANDUM FOR:
Allegation File STN 50-482; Case A-84-A-58
F R0".:
R. G. Taylor, Reactor inspector
!
SU5 JECT:
ALLEGA110N A-84-A-58
j
1.
The above noted allegation (s) as extracted f ro'r the notes of the NRC
pe rsor.r.El Wh; TE;EivtC tht allegatiers gia a teleph0rit call or $/2C./64
werE:
?
8.
t.
Bt 'ie ve:' the ret; reasor was his firidirgs n.aae curir.g er aucit o'
Ch*'s (Cc'strat:1or W e Ferrits) ir. sol.1r.g c1sasser.;iy of pressort
bouncries without Q.C. being present.
2.
The essence of the above extraction was reaffirmed based on a memorandur
of phone call betweer. RIV personnel and the alleger or. 6/1/84.
~.
Inspt; tion Findings:
l
a.
e
b.
Iht accit sett'or supt r y '. s t r c or.f i rrit: thEt tht a.eff"
'
had DEE*
e,
,p;
,,.- - :.
.
.,9
.. , i,
g.
g,-
,
- .
,.. -, ,- .
.4
,
^
'*
e'
,
- .
t.
- ...:
-:'E
- '
- : . .:
'
.
.
"'
( c' ' . ' i ' *. L . T.; s t '. , 44.661, wi"t ot '. f.; C 1 s i s s t '.; . t * * . ' o - . t r. t
'
-
.
prEse'~t (A
('. C . PE r s c'r.nt l .
- .
rt.'t.
- t't t
- i *. 'i t a': c'st.55' *i w't'
tri sw:t ,is r
'
c'.sclest
tr.t auc'.1 na: Det' ir.itiatec t,7 ort auci*.C' writ hEi
reassict.f c h reascr. ci pror:.tior ; contirus; by th6 allEgfr
- and the cortir.wed by yet an
- ther auditcr untii*
concludec.~ The conclusion resulted in issuance of a " Quality Prograr
Violation" and fairly extensive corrective actions, mostly of a
'
procedural type.
d.
The audit section supervisor provided the inspector with infortnation
to the effect that the alleger
The
~
,_superv,iser provided the inspector with the name and location of the
The inspector interviewed the person (on-site) and was
u
,
-
n
.
-.7
.
Meno for A11egatior. File 5th 50-48?;
Cast A-84 A-58
-?-
provided with a narrative [ by the inspector and-
, The narrative was reduced
to a short written statement
I
e.
During a second interview with the (udit section supervisor, the
supers 1sor offqed the opin1or that
~
by yet another party who was ano still is a high
level manager / supervisor in the organization the alleger was
auditing.
The audit section supertiscr could offer no proof to
support the opinion,
f.
The inspector reviemec a file it. thE pos s e i!,1 or-. of tht licerset'$
se: writ
ct;t rir,et t pe rte,r ir; it the alleg .
T r.t fiit ( c.r ta i nt :
lThefilealsocontained_
,,
Tntre was
's in acc1 tion, the file contain.ec
'The
J
c.
At the con:hticr. o' tr.t first phase o' this 1nipt:tior., the
inspe: tor juegtd that:
(1)
-
(2)"
-
%
(3;
1
(4) Given (2) and (3) above,l
-
Since a degree of uncertainty ren.ained concerning the',known facts and
h.
Ithe inspector presented the
p,o RIV management and subsequently to the personnel of the
-
.
L
'
-.
-
_
. . -
b
-
I
.
Iteme fer: A11egetien File ~ $1N 60-492;
Case A-84 A-68
- 3-
e
'
I
'
01 Fiels Of fice. j
.
<
J
i.
Take". or balan:e,
,
,
-
1
4
The substance of the above will be do:umented for the re:crd in inspe:tior
report 50- 462 /6t.- 21.
i.
e m
e
- k. 6. %)lI ~
'
Rea:ter inspe:te.'
.
_ _ _
__ _ ______ _ _
_ _ _ _ .
,
-
, ,
- ,*
. ,,0 .,: m
.-
[.
, . .
C'UCLE AR RtGULATORY C2MMissl0N
l
.
.
$
l
atsion tv
%
A
ett n,am P6 Ara Darvt surta tem
.
\\ ,.,,,,/
Amtm ofon. u nas a mi
1
O
MEM3RANDUM FOR:
RIV Enforcement Officer
O
'
FROM.
R. G. Taylor
SUE.JE C1 ;
IDENTIFICA110h Of PERSONS, ALLEGi110h A-BA- A-58
Reference:
Memt to Allegation File STN 50-482
1.
A11eger:
,
e
-
2.
h
3.
AucitSe:tior.SupervisIr.
Roberta M. S t amt.a.;g *
4.
High level manager / supervisor in audited group (startup): H. Handfinger
Please note attached statement which is not typed.
'
aylor
React r Inspector
l
!
!
!
1
(
.
.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .
_..
.
,
..
.
.
..
.
.
.
~'
we.' 1$,. .<:.' . . . .g y'MfQ cJ.sp,/h. elf
,
,
}
i
.
I .lF. 4xa, u, ., %ls, .6,'s,&
,..%.
, ; y ,. g . ,,, ,.
. .
, . .
'
,16 4 s..v(,e93.YAs Z,,..,.4' c,, ,',. 4 , ,.. g.' ., . V'
.,, ,;-
.
..
' h .
d'. W f. A : .a d.- 1 / s. v ,:<. f i
G
-
J, .
,
i
i
!
.