ML20127B507

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents.Forwards App E,F & G Records.App E Records Available in Pdr.App F Records Being Made Available in Pdr.App G Records Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)
ML20127B507
Person / Time
Site: Palo Verde  Arizona Public Service icon.png
Issue date: 07/31/1992
From: Philips J
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To: Bradley Jones
AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD (FORMERLY AKIN
Shared Package
ML20127B172 List:
References
FOIA-92-88 NUDOCS 9301120307
Download: ML20127B507 (5)
v • d • e


Text

v uw%m n n,an i w.

.w.

,,,.., m% w FOlA -

92-88

/y...s\\

my0,5 2 n us e i m W-RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF Insu l xlraanal

d

/j I'

INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST oan a

s..v..a.#

JUL 311992 DUC D l. I N V4'bl R i$ 5 r/fsN 4 4/se) lil OUt s i t h Mr. Bradley Jones PART t,-AGE NCY RE CORDS HE LE ASE D OR NOT LOC AT ED I&t check ed bonest No erncy enords tutect to the request have ta'en located No add tionai agera y rec ords sutyec t to the reyvest have been lot ated RequestM records are avadat4 through another pubbe distribution program, $ce Comments section,

)(

Agergy records subject *o the request that are identified in Aprend;s tesL[

are already evadable for pubhc inspection ard copying at the NRC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street, N W, Washington. DC.

Aymcy rnords subjKt to the request that are klentNed in Appendinfes)

E a'e being nwie avadable for pubhc inspection and copying X

at the N AC Pubhc Document Room 2120 L Street. N W, Washington, DC. in a folder under this F Of A number.

The nonpropr-etary vers >on of the propose (s) that you ayeed to ett est,n a triephone con e rsabon with a mernbet of my staff is now being made avadable v

for pubhc inspMtion and copying at the NHC PutAc Document Room. 2120 L Sucet. N W, Washington, DC. in a folder under 156 F Of A number.

Agenc y records subs ct to the request that are ittentified in Apr.end'a tes) may be inspnted and cop,ed at the NRC Lot al Pubhc Document Room identif>ed in the Comments section.

Erickned is mfumation on how you may obtain acce',s to and the Wrrs for com mg records located at the NHC Pubbe Document Room,2120 L Street, N W, Washinyon DC Agancy records subjett to the request are enclosed Records subjet t to the request have been referred to another f ederM apncybest for revien and d rett response tn ynu T ees You ad! be bSed by the NRC for fees totahng $

You wd! retene a refund from the NRC in the amount of $

in v en of N HC's response to tNs request. no fu ther ac tson is t e'ng teen en appr al let ter dsred

.No r

FART 11. A-INFORMATION WiiHHf LD F ROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURL Certain information in the teauested records is being withheld from pubhc disclosure pursuant to the enemptions discribed m are for the reasons stated in Part il, B, C, and D. Any released portions of the dacuments for which only part of the record is being withheld are being made available for pubhc inspection and copymg in the NRC Pubhc Document Room. 2 t 20 L Street, N W, Washmgt on, DC in a folder under the F OI A number, COMM E NTS 9301120307 920731 PDR FOIA JONES 92-08 PDR SIGN A t uk ilf

't, Ol V. SN dil400M OF l' WY ATION AND PUB LICA f t0% 51 R VICf 5

= i 3..

s P

j 3

s :.

.~v._.,_.

---,y..,.

. ~ -,

e f (n a eye,se { p ig i OAtg RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST FOIA -

q2_88 JUL 1

(CONTINUA 1 TOM PAHT 11 B - APPLICABil L ALMPilONS Records sutyect to the rNuest that are dew nbed m tLe encbsed Apben6 le1L_G__.a,e t.e,r.,. the.,y n the,, entaet, or.n part under the i semption No Is) and for the reason (s) gwen t>t%* pu'suant to 5 U S C. %W and 10 CF R 917M of NRC repet ons

~. _ -... _....... n.s pra e",i ans Aett pvm. ant to ( semi.e Orden (E nemptnan 1) wthh st uba et,o t

1 i t<

t l

eid intoerr.ne e *,!,!cs soie y to the rtemei prwone' ven and p> ot edwes c1 N4C d mempt.on 21 s

2 t he w bo e

3 n.e...uw...o.. am r.s spem,n, e.e,..gn,..o,s p..m dos,c i., w. m.m a.rrmon a k-tions 14114$ of the Ato<me (nerpt Act. nNth prohtets the deiowe of hested Dats ta F ormerly flestorted Data 142 U.S C. 216121tM c

.. - ~

Set t ion 14 7 of t he A t ormt E <se> g t Act e hgh peukb ti the dwuwe of UN inst ' e:1 $a'egvanis IHomsten 142 U $ C 21th 4 T he withhekt *nf urwate in a P a1e seteet m ( m re en # m he am 4 m' vet C e, t' at a t.em9 * *e110' t's n otor si nksted il sempt4on 4) l he et ef orttige ost,g g g,r. b uie't d t o It I tw b4 h t ' d 14+' +t $ 5 p' t l ' +t F, e I' l u + ai (n p nel to 10 L 5 84 7 ? !*L 1-tt T he.,,t oo,,nu.,s a m sdeed to t e pu oneia's ett " at" t

I T he adu reah n w a s s utet t ed and en ew ee in < w '.e, c pa s a-1 t-

(,8 4 ? 1% ud ?

r l

._._._.4

(.-

1

-. -..(( mempt on $1 Appocatne P,.vi;e p

! t>

f t, v. H Acio vem v4. t %sig etacnym,ma w eu, nec 1 m e e e, -, n.,,u t 4,

.p 44

, e, t a w I t.# r e a

$ e p SISuas e ssennai to u-e cent vatme pecu ess

. ~l Debt.e"at w e h m e ss D stiwe v pu un sIow s& note am i 1A e t i. r *"tU t' s een riOr6 cat Where ve: md a'e wit Ac a e lhea entsety the f r_ t s ca m e '

s.

' mere 1 a 40

'. a u-f

<rs ' + r +r T he e # roaen

'e aw ate, se yegatae f or tsal g li pcet.or a t.et avse the *eme c1 the f as is w nW paa-oet i + 1e 1 -w 9 l -

+%

M"+arii tr W =t

_.... + - -

A t t y's.r, Ash 4.s ie1 {.s s s't f

  • 1

. 4"tgt e a

t a

A

' r (Cord aem a; tum'Ne <a14isa iti4 *t n a% a'f u ne v emi es *-er cf vie t

- d..-.-,. r t cy ne r o em pr tv. e s

1_.

,e.,, m. - i r t.

m, m,,

.,.n r.,,

ii. _.

._4-

-. _. ~ _.

t * "Q A.q f d.g d 6-:p e *+ e s a % uh ' % 1 s' 4j d di e d ([ R effipT 40n 7 }

t

{mf i ':*

dA 8^':"4"'t''

p e r'l"; 8 et 1

'A T b e W-thbeifj sefT h p14 ifT fLFl'Si s t ' !t ; "dh.

1 7

-__.a DEaws s esti ream.v., be ap*. ted ic iv 'e' e a to er

~eme ie e r i "y te ear 1 cam vena "e su s e d mt.n.. a d f arm of Lov4 pm tdy sew 'ec p+ is to tan e ac t on M 6ed potrot e' au P. og to a s Ur-m of NRC e,w eemenu erlo< cement e'fu tt en t t.

r

{ btm.nveogmes y nempejon 7 ( AD Dist 4swe w ouM _ ws,1 tute an v a a" anted r.su " to ersv e or.sc, (E mempt rn 7(CH

~_

' c' m.- i a ce of

,t++= sin 1

< re 1 r e.

e vo e,% r c e+o s u names.

1..t.

soo tes it iempnor' 7 tD J iort

  • m a r

U! q h P ART ll C - DENYING Of FICIALS

~

- - - - - - - - - - - ~ -

u ' *" * * ' t r e t '+

4. t mat +"
  • t %i U s e a rmp' h um p' c Pe n,mt te t o C F R 9 25 t a s<v,, 0 7t h i cd :N U C N.;

e r l' + o a' t", Dws ' ' '

4 r r mn t tas ei de de t r to d u nsee ewf te e s p-o f m t a o ao ei e 1te' Pry to' + pg Jt N"5' Ite one s 't w 5eto iteOrna rettmec ta t.a i.dem f ed t.e-o* st devmg s

ut4 ai v a the D m tw. D,un o'Inew "o'i ' ;~ r on and 6V < v om k, i n h" t t of A m " d C te n aco a > 9 e m.s v tie era a ed to ter I secute D reef o' for Ow ai i ns tf DO.

Of M tNG Of fiCI AL 18 h 6 05 8 Ki Af C OROS DI MID AWlL( All OFICAL i._.~.

_.- Q _.. ( Do..... i tr c..P..E. f p v I-. - w G.

i i

4 ___.h_-.-

~

X

_DrmIhomaLE. Mur1c{ Directar. NRR q Appendi.x_G _.

I 4

1 i

_.m..

- - ~ _ _ _.._-j l

l i

-. s -...

- - - ~. _ _

~

--...-a.-.

-.--.k.. - -4 __.k' ___ -..

I i

I i

i i

I 1

1:

1

_ + -

__m

..y--__.-_.-..___.--.

I PART ll D - APPE AL RIGHTS The dema! tiy each denymg orc a< *nent,f=ed en Part il C may tie appes+1 to the AppePate Off e a'.nent f ed the,e. Any seh sopeat must be er.ede n wotmg e thm 30 days of etre pt of the teiponse. Appea s must be addrened. an apprope 4te, to the E secut we D rector f ar Operates to the Secrewy of the Com%snon, or to the lospecto' Greerat, U S. Nscler r

Ngu'<atoiv Comm:ss.on, Wadungton. DC 20%5 a%t showd ciesdy state on the envelope a4 m the lette' that it :s an Arpest f'om a** Imtust FOl A Der t>on."

U S. NUCLE AR REGULATORY COMMISSION NflC FORM 464 (Par 12) O 91)

. ~ _......,. _ _. _ - -.

i Rot FOIA-92-88 APPEllDIX E RiiCORDTt_MAIFTAIED_AtiO!1G PDILFIIES UUMDliB DAT13 INERIPr10H 1.

8/20/91 Inspection Roport 50-528/91-32-(63 pages) Allo 9109090003 L

4 1

a g

---.c-

,wm, y,

e..-v....

-w.%#4-#,.--

w.,

-ree----

r-cyr,--

e

-e

.m.-

s- - - ---- - - --

--ti* - - *=

i Ret FOIA-92-88 APPEllDIX F EliCREDS Dell 1G__PIACED Il[r0 Tile PDB Ul4 DER TIIPEVE_ REOUEST liUMBEB NUM13ER p1LE DI,SCRII' PION 1.

11/8/C9 Multiple Equipment Failures Following Load Reject and Reactor Trip, Event Followup Report 89-038, Event date 3/3/89 (45 pages) 2.

1/18/90 Memo to R. Zimmerman from T. M. Ilovak re: AEOD Input for Commissioner Curtiss' Visit to Palo Verde 11uclear Plant on 2/1/90 with attachment (16 pages)

P i

r

)

o-. - _

m.--.,

n,

\\

Re:

FOIA-92-88 APPENDIX G RJ: CORDS PARTIALLY WITilllELD l{QJiijfB DE M DESCRIPPION & EXEBPPION 1.

11/9/89 Memo to R.

P. Zimmerman from G. W.

Knighton re: Palo Verde SALP Input (1 page) (Released) with enclosure (12 pages) EX. 5 2.

12/12/90 Memo to R.

P. Zimmerman from C.

M.

Trammell re: Palo. Verde SALP Input (1 page) (Released) with enclosure (3 pages) EX. 5 i

l g-v--%-

g eg, e

c9

-p a-t,y y

w

-g-w* gor -

w

-rg-E-tv r'-F-Mv--e w

---Tww-g'

--M-7-F'-e

  • --PT'P-

-MMP v'm e-g w g e'sr w - p wrW wtF-T -P y#

r

_._m s.

AKIN. GUMP, H AVER & FELo. L.L.P.

ATTORNtys AT LAW

,,,g y

4,oo r.as t c ee, e t N ? t s, a 6to stt at o uw tt 0 use ut t PaatNt a5+*

m coNoatsh avtNut ippo,*ac tr ic a vt Nut

'NMC *G *C' t SS'CN' C D*PC** T ONS A u st i *. vtus 7e70s ist2169 6200 l

8 cattas st mas 752ondece i333 Ngw gAppgging Avtygg yw

    • '5'69#800

)

guetc 4oo

,Soo u,, ossa,s, gay, 300 coNvtNT stec t?

j es avtNur Lovest es*o7 w ASHINGToN, D C 20030 san ANTONto itus 78205 i

iO50 eava5tts attoivu i

I

~

1512:270 0800 dotti 32 2-535 29 o r A nn (2026 887-4289 4558 7 n, ou,s,,s,,,,,c c,

e n t s e s co n e c t co s t h v.' e t e aose ser MountON T E KAb 77002 t 7631220-5600 February 21, 1992 4

p_Y llAND DELIVERY FREEDOM Of INf 0RMAll0N Donnie H.

Grimsley, Director ACT REQUECT Division of Freedom of Information hp _9g g g and Publications Service U.S.

Nuclear Regulatory Commission g,g Washington, D.C.

20555

Dear Mr. Grimsley:

This is a request pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C.

552, and 10 CPR Part 9 for documento relating to Palo Verde Units 1, 2& 3, and more particularly described below.

For the purpose of this request, the term " document" means all memoranda, letters, filings, testimony, exhibits, contracts, transcripts, minutes, notes, dra f t s, studies, analyses, reports, maps, diagrams, charts, books, articles, pictures, printouts, tapes, or other written, graphic, or computerized information in any form which constitutes agency records under the Freedora of Information Act.

The documents we are requesting can more particularly be described as:

1.

All documents, other than the NRC Augmented Inspection Team (AIT) report forwarded to Arizona Public Service (APS) on April 19, 1989 and the Diagnostic Evaluation Team (DET) Report forwarded to APS on March 16, 1990, which discuss, evaluate, analyze or otherwise address the causes of the 1989 outages at-Palo Verde Units 1, 2, and 3; and the basis for the NRC Confirmation of Action letters issued on March 3, 1989; March 7, 1989; March 28, 1989; June 28, 1989; and December 24, 1989 that addressed the Palo Verde Units.

This request includes, but is not limited to, documents which address the causes of the shutdown resulting in the _1989 outages-at all three Palo Verdo_ Units and the causes of the 1989 outages exceeding the formally or informally scheduled or planned outage durations.

f aAn;30W c

  • pw r u-e r

v-

p

-m-m e.--

-e.

e--

,si--ii.-.-4m

+

a--

=-

+we

+weey,*,e

-mr.,

--ws.,-y e.---Nw-r-.--w

.s-<-,

I

> a Gute HAutn & Ftto. L L P Donnie H.

Grimsley February 21, 1992 page 2 2.

All transcripts, tapes or other record of interviews conducted during or in support of the NRC Augmented Inspection Team's review of the March 3, 1989 trip of Palo Verde Unit 3.

The AIT review was reported in an AIT report forwarded to APS on April 9, 1989.

3.

All transcripts, tapes or other record of interviews conducted during or in support of the Diagnost ic Evaluation Team's review of Palo Verde performance. The DET review was reported in a DET report transmitted to APS on March 16, 1990.

PurSJant to 5 U.S.C.

G552(a)(6), a response to this request is required in ten days.

We are willing to pay all necessary search and copy fees associated with this request.

Please notify the undersigned at (202) 887-4558 if these fees are expected to exceed $450.00.

If any portion of this request is denied, please provide a detailed explanation of t he reasons for the denial, as required by 5 U.S.C.

C 552(a)(6).

Sincere f f l,<,~o nradle a. a.ie s

_ _ _ - _. - _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -. _

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20127B507&oldid=4270448"