ML20126H504
| ML20126H504 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Perkins  |
| Issue date: | 03/31/1981 |
| From: | Pfefferkorn W PFEFFERKORN & COOLEY, P.A. |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8104140469 | |
| Download: ML20126H504 (8) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:,- UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION S In the Matter of ' ) t-t f b [ 'O DUKE POWER COMPANY ) Docket Nos. STN 50-48v 50-4%)dpg23 ) 50-4! 9- %i (Peckins Nuclear Station, ) Z v.,, ka*sse /Sg7 Units 1, 2 and 3) ) G i M ) v>y e g rcer n~ MOTION TO REOPEN THE RECORD AND k REMAND FOR FURTHER PRODEEDINGS b N NOW COME the Intervenors and do hereby move tha t the Record in this matter be reopened and that it be remanded for further proceedings for the reason that Intervenors have just discovered that the Lake Norman Site "E" was not properly identified or shown by the Applicants and that the mos t recent site identified by the Applicants in the year 1978 and priot to the visit of the Staf f of the Nuclear Wagulatory Commission is a level site with no houses or business such as re f e r red to by the Staff in their testimony.and further that previous maps of the Applicant indicate a location of Site "E" were shown at two diffecent locations and the fact that a total of th r ee diffecent locations for Site "E" is shown on documents pro-duced by the applicant explains the difference in some of the testimony between Intervenor's witnesses and Staf f witnesses and further explains the Staff's conclusions th a t the Lake Notman Site ras not clearly superior even though the water issue weigheo heavily in favor of the Lake Norman Site and that the Site's specific matters mentioned by Staff witnesses-is not celiable in the light of this new information about the shift of location of Site "E" which most likely lead to the disccepancy in th e testimony. See the attached Exhibits which are incor poc ated by reference to be part of thic Motion. This the 31th day of March, 1981. ( ff b <4 i William G. Pfefferkorn / (/ Attorney for Intervenors OF COUNSEL: ~ PFEFFERKORN & COOLEY, P.A. ~ Ek Post Office Box 43 /x, ~ ' 202 West Third Street ?v Winston-Salem, N.C. 27102 !C [?,gpg 7799 Telephone: (919) 725-0251
- 7 Y
2 *~ ' 6, 6 s N e; h0 l M i j.t@ 810.4140 M g
e l O i , p. ' ' f'X 'g(y v' l , v :' W. b APR 7199g, i: Ai '\\_c.s l .A
- A 1
I D/ ' 'b l \\ ', - i .I l LAKE NORMAN Summer,1978 READING CONTOURS Full pond elevation for Lake Nortnan is 763 above sea fevel. The areas shown in light blue are within the allowable 25-foct draw-doan tevel (from elevation 700 to elevation 735). Beaters should exercise caution while boating in these arcas, particularly during periods of low lake levels. Also shown are tne 700 foot elevation, irregular depths at various locations, and a number cf strearn channels. IMPORTANT NOTES: Before using this map. please become familiar with water safety rules, waterway markers and j other mtormation designed to help ansure the safe and enjoyable uses of the lake The grid i system may be usefulin helpmg beaters and fishermen radio thest positions on the lake in cases of emergency or en relaymg other smportant information. This map is designed for recreational planning only. For the boat owner's convenience it shows anos to na vigation. but it is not 6.Yr aded to replace a navigational cha rt. Every eff o'1 has been made to make this map accurate, but no llaDelity can be assufred for any inac-curacles or omass#ons that may occur. The N.C. Wildttte Commission supervises the boatmg and fashing activities on the lake. For mtormation, contact: North Carolina Wildilfe Resources Commission. RaleiDh N.C. 27611.
m-_ ~;g. g g-
- N z,
u> + x a q. +E
- s J
D jIS k, L i ~ 4
- 1. &....%
I -'~., ^ f~ w.., , s'O 2.
- i.,.
,. - - +t 'r- . \\C. s g" i ~.3 l .l'o,. \\,, /- s 'e e',, ,.s ,e a. i 4 ...s k , ~ ~ 'g 4' -,, ' N s,. N -w + s . v. p.. r .~ 8C ' by C '\\ f ,9.. [. %,f k f l(h,[' ?[f )d yf h,4.. k .'.% { %4ih :... u.. yp.. c .. 4......; m,.- a s. ~ ,w" (=. --/ . g. I .fm,\\
- m
- .
j ), p~)fJ O l,' f ' l )u[f f,.' h.~, ~=-R Q ~ ,.: ~m,. 4. ?.; ,. x : '\\ A, 7 m,,y c> ~. .ny. >,.-. a.. a 1 \\ A,z e i, l l n. ~.. w. ...~ u n&- A .Q %?Ch 0, .w ~ gi
- /;'&, 91mNtgTi.
?d. : _\\ / .y-i; -f.... (. 7 1.. N._.*'- ). \\ i e + /- .'A, D( k k*, r,' E ., 4 u- ) u !. p \\,g. g f se '. t - T ' I';i ! t m ' ll..-Q ;!,$ %. /l? ~ yi c, ~ ~.. N,. ~ .h I l l' lQ,/y 3# (!dfL'5,eL 4 n ,'ff 'y,o '1 i n ,s -~. 'r., s, 7 j { / 90M -s l .....- v00 % ,A ./ '~., i 9, x -= esme m}._,1, '
- Q v.
// I \\ n f 2y ff) m. "N I l c0* y'/c 'l s. -[ h? '") ' $,'. j,. /. s \\ 2 / it:\\Q ~. ~ 1'5
- nog, S'-
~ g /e ' 4'. \\. \\ ':e me N.gi,7 \\, P W,ooo. Q ,c q o l jy ? 50 ,= ,c x N x. s / 0 C S 4'> . Y, ,e - NN ' rr \\ N. s \\ m x 'f' 6
- Tdr9-'4l-4M+
wt-Jhd'3-4p m e g a tw M 'd7rw'-- 8-eW 3w1-w see =utwi-M-g- ---teragpt y -" w f a *M1 Q
- 'yyTvr7wyr. yea rg p y
- y e-yy1 "et
=*ygrM -$ sq=gw g-7,ia yqv g-ydq'WP-ge-+e'-'rwgr+1-g i.997-re-gw'
- eyd g'
s$*-y.' mea 4e w+ wp t4-e---..p
{ J AREAS DESIGNATED ON THIS MAP AS h A NOT E'. ARE PROPOSED STE AM GENER ATING PL ANT SITES, WHICH ARE~. EXCLUD E D. FROM THE PROJECT AREA. i .r - SC ALE: I"= 2000' ,/ CRESCENT LAND 8 TIMBER CORP. = 0RJ S ~~ A ~~ O\\ COWA\\S / MEC KLEN BURG, LI NCOLN, IREDELL a CATAWBA ~ dO UNTI E S, N C. k DWG. NO. C.L.T-K 8 . ~.. 1 t' ( ,r ,,,.. --.-we- ,m-- ,, -.,m..,r-%.,, --,iv ,.me w, ..,,-v.. -re a -, re, ..,.r. y. ,,r- ,,, mew.p y..#-r, -yr.-- Pg n,, -
,-m.- w A e w n, N l % . ) / '} t m. &f ~.' s.. f. )%~'==%%. _s%. .i hf Y l )EY I b v < $s I 1 / } \\ la ca / \\s,, f y, ~ D I
- /
L i i ,f' !w % {e! 4 Y u L l_ _ A , \\, iy i 0 .il / - 4% 3 s t-s; u,si %L L - 3. ' M z .y ,J ! \\ r \\, I i j, '$, '\\ I L_l _.. A 1 o p e E2 p\\ ! if' 4, . s.'s,
- g' 3,;'-
r .J, g %~ u l I ,o u 3;: $q,$ m[ 3k n? bk l y. ; . = !, J - W, .~ f ~ i l. // \\ %m:'i,;by Q, p,+: ~---d.,9._ v s-( %,d<k s, u 'D g, Y ,25$ g m p. W u 'l f e f .\\ J e4 ^% /*j u / > ~ o G o. W .L 'e l f pv j, V' g [f, g%gl ,}g\\ f.), 'f'!' 4 3 \\ A I , ' ' lx MM L E./ [ M, k ~. c.' ,-!,' _w p, ng.. g i : i i J 1 v xv + s, y 4o-. A = m, e m pl - y g&:f k.3 / 3,,,-Q# 9 #v y\\)e l4 +q ~3g v a=- AN s y, n y: >S. /
- e., a.,
y , 9+ n ~ s f N# ,/gc 3i y ! **-9; i $1 (./ '/ 7 9 4. ( 4,+. \\,s /- /-
- 0. fg# y/
9^ \\ t: 1 f 4 i, N- !, agw -/ /
- l Ch' M
s j -b i'44L Tip n / N ..Jw' J, ' 4l h,,, jg ]' y;7
- j. I 2";
& m- ~,/ [ g.": W M/ v % v _1 i
- s. o,r i
a L!S eE E* \\ $.f. $ C> /,/ t y- {.f. r %*%l 5 -l,g%get \\( C i 3 _./ 3 i o 1,..,,( ),)/ s *' 9'- g). . 2: ? i mm 1 i e i ys 'e m a, .w /.c l !I ~%A ma : ~ l' f r r? 1 w
- , w m. ',
, v ._] Es N j .:-N'kk t( yr m,i ~' ~~ i ky a gy~.r?, ~* - g/s sa,3 m. . g { s. y c s e s s ~ ~ - - - _w..3g n Q- $.o '[~ ~~. l ~ - - f y ,.4 t y. -_,,..~..,,-,v ,vr --e
N OTE: AREAS DESIGN ATED ON THIS M AP AS ,h,AND I ARE PROPOSED STE AM GENERATING PL ANT SITES, WHICH ARE EXCLUDED FROM THE PROJECT AREA. S C A L E: I"= 2000' CRESCENT LAND 8 TIMBER CORP COWA\\S =0 9 J S ~~ A -~ O\\ MECKLENBURG,LINdOLN,IREDELL & C AT AWB A-C O U NT I E S, N.C. t I i 1 ) i i DWG. NO. C.L.T - K A W8 j. --~r J e r c. , ~.. c
.2ta u 4 -1.%2 _e4 + 5 -B._,.y5 Ei 5 m P M b n, g [. . ~, 5 .I' 9 p p sc 5 g . t m 1
- ms,m,
y7 u n-,4. . gss ./,. y' ~,. __ ' f , e k,2. _ _. \\,_ a ;,_ n3._,.. 4,_ g...., L a.up __ \\ . 7 _ a/ K _ w . /,, w v e, n, ' N k$ ~vq% s ra $[ [#,. P M3 ,[ 4 e,,, %. \\ ' [//; 5 e,os )' J'I \\;-k,; \\ 3_sm f*1 ' ' ' ' ~ ~ s.,,7 " . w= ~' f s as s ' ' ~. f 1 *"' i _ .. n j __I g ,, / j-C _ 7x 5 33 , 4 i ~ ' ~ ~N 5-cs: r i .,-b '-4 'u l wag [, T7:2 !!7 1 34 _ j / Q> y j s-n., \\., -~./ ( 5 4,7, ,, m,s s 7,[,N. 's r \\ .\\ <, n. '\\ s., ,/ ~( 5 72 5, ,.1_ ,u %'(g?/ ' \\f @/ g-[7 a,y / j g t (3 77, s
- #8 I 5-se y
s ~ 5~go_r,. .$.sLl> c,.n p,, f xY>,,s,. \\ ~ ' - q l )- \\ SW j i J ..,e igg ( ,1 1 \\ \\ 3 so, s~ w l \\ / 3,'\\ ) s-n (s-7s T(t %y, N g, l .s 5 "" A 3 s.,. ~ ge,*y, y s } 5-#'S 7 j 1,, h 5 7"* x \\. 5-ses N Sa, / %Q /, e 3-m lh,?Y,8kg,;}i n,, a g m \\ n'\\[%. %N,, ~. { ikllll
- 5 D 1[fh~~
y- ~l y a M ;_ f, 4..... l},:, ( .r;,w, Q i / e r.s.s w.mh et -i .is m.s,.,q, 8 w, s 1 ,a ,1 ,e.s - s y n s-mz g sens ) p, - 3 so wrcu i,. - 9, ,,x 570.j.N' s: 9 f, -, e$,s j, s-a74 \\ a n. y. [- s 'A 4 7CO [ 5eS4.\\, [~22.{ 9 y x r s e_ -g; y s i / j C - f,.- \\,- [s \\.\\ - fj 9 g, 3.,,3 ~ 5'90\\ n \\. i, ? \\ f 6g 'v tr*/ ( },' 'N r / l ./ ( ff h \\ th's I ow 3 sw w, y,\\ '\\ N 'g \\ g x ', 5+97 -) i / -{ 33,3 ( S t ?p*, j,3 h s =
- )
- 7
. c,_t,y y- .e 3* s e
a f CERTIFICATE'OF SERVICE I. hereby certify' that copies ~ of the Motion to Reopen. the ' Record L; - and' Remand for Further Proceedings have been served. on th e - following by deposit in the United States Mail.this. the. lst day [ of April, 1981. Elizabeth S. Bowers, Esq. Charles _A. Barth,.Esq. . Chairman, Atomic Safety Counsel for NRC Regulatory Staf f and Licensing Board Of fice of the Executive. Legal + U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Director- [ Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commissions j Washington, D.C. 20555 washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. Donald P. DeSylva William A. Raney, Jr. Esq. Association Professor of Special Deputy Attorney General Marine Science State of North Carolina Rosenstiel School ~of Marine Department of Justice-and Atmospheric Science . Post Office Box 629 Univer ity of Miami Raleigh,' North Carolina 27602 Miami, Florida 33149 l William L. ' Porter, Esq. i Dr. Walter H. Jordan Associate General Counsel 881 West Outer Drive Duke Power Company Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 Post Office. Box 2178-Charlotte, North Carolina 28242 r Chairman, Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mr. Chase R. Stephens U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Docketing and Service Section Commission Office of the Secretary - Washington, D.C. 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Chairman, Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Mr. J. Michael McGarry, III U.S.. Nuclear Regulatory Debevoise and Liberman Commission 1200 Seventeenth ' Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20036 Dr. John H. Buck Mr. Richard S. Salzman Atomic Safety and Licensing Atomic Safety and Licensing l Appeal Board Appeal Board U.S.' Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washing ton, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 i Mr. David Springer The Point Farm 7 Mocksville, N.C. 27028 a./ \\ k j WILLIAM G. PFEFFERKORM 'l AttorneyforIntervenors) PFEFFERKORN & COOLEY, P.A. Post Office Box 43 202 WestLThird Street Winston-Salem, N.C. 27102 j Telephone: (919) 725-0251 I ~, -..,... . _, _ _ -... _. -.. _ _....}}