Text

Summary of IE Bulletin 79-01 Review,Balance of Plant (Inside & Outside Containment) NSSS (Inside Containment) for Class IE Equipment
	ML20126A893
Person / Time
Site:	North Anna
Issue date:	02/25/1980
From:	; STONE & WEBSTER ENGINEERING CORP.
To:	;
Shared Package
ML20126A875	List: ML20126A871; ML20126A888; ML20126A893;
References
	IEB-79-01, IEB-79-1, NUDOCS 8002260731
	Download: ML20126A893 (100)
	v • d • e

{{#Wiki_filter:- - - - - - - - - - O

SUMMARY

OF lE BULLETIN 79-01 REVIEW BALANCE OF PLANT (INSIDE & OUTSIDE CONTAINMENT) AND NSSS (INSIDE CONTAINMENT) FOR CLASS IE EQUIPMENT O North Anna Power Station Units 1 & 2 Virginia Electric and Power Company i 'O ~ 8

4 A

~ '""" ' '"!!NR""fs"s!""i"?As"" """ w L

4 IE 79-01 r TABLE OF CONTENTS PART'I QUALIFICATION BOP OPERATING ENVIRONMENT - DESCRIPTION (LOCA) (MSLB) PAGE Air conditioning inline pumps HV-P-20A x 1,b,c HV-P-20B x 1:b,c HV-P-4)C x 1 b,e HV-P-22A-x 1.b,c HV-P-22B x 1,b,c HV-P-22C x 1 b,e Air conditioning self-cleaning strainer HV-S-1A x 2,a HV-S-1B x 2,a Motor Oper V1v Units x 3,a-Air conditioning water chillers 9 HV-E-4A x 1,a. HV-E-4B x 1,a HV-E-4C x 1,a Cable - 5 kV Al Power (General Cable) NGA Triplex 1000 MCM 4,a NGA 3/C 500 Al Armor x 4,a NGA 3/C 1250 MCM st. Armor 4,a NGA 3/C 1250 MCM Al Amor 4,a NGA 1/C 1500 MCM 4,a NGA 1/C 2000 MCM 4,a NGA 3/C 1000 MCM Al Armor 4,a 'NGA 3/C #4/0 Avg. 4,a NGA Triplex #4/0 Avg.- 4,a i E , ~ -, +

1 J DESCRIPTION-(LOCA) (MSLB) PAGE Cable - 600 V Al Power (General Cable) NGB Triplex 500 MCM x. 5,a NGB Triplex 250 MCM x 5,a NGB Triplex #2/0 Awg. x 5,a x 5,a NGB Triplex #1 Aug. Cable - 600 V - Cu Power (Okonite) NGA 1/C 250 MCM x x 6,a NGA 1/C #2/0 Awg. 6,a x x 6,a NGB Triplex #4 Awg. x x NGB Triplex #6 Aug. 6,a x x NGB 3/C #8 Avg. x x 6,a NGB 3/C #10 Awg. 6,a x x NGB 3/C #12 Awg. x x 6,a Cable - High Temperature Cu (Cerro Wire) NGA Triplex 250 MCM x x 7,a NGA Triplex #2/0 Awg. 7,a NGA 6/C (2) #8 & (4) #12 Awg. 7,a NGA 7/C #12 Aug. 7,a NGA-34 -4/C #16 Awg. 7,a NGB 2/C #8 Awg. 7,a l - Cable - 600 V Cu Control (Cerro Wire) .NGA 2/C #2 Awg. 8,a x x NGA 1/C #14 Avg. x x 8,a NGA 2/C #14 Aug.- x ,x-8,a. x x NGA 3/C #14 Aug. 8,a NGA 5/C #14' Avg. 8, a-x x-NGA 7/C #14 Avg. 8,a x x NGA 9/C #14 Awg. 8,a x x-NGA-40 12/C #14 Awg. 8,a x x .NGA I/C #12 Avg. -8,a x-x 4 NGA 2/C #12 Awg. 8,a x x..,, ~ ~

DESCRIPTION (LOCA) (MSLB) PAGE NGA-47 4/C 612 Awg. 8,a x x NGA 7/C #12 Aug. x x 8,a NGA 4/C #10 Aug. x x 8,a NCA 4/C #10 Awg. 8,a x x NCB 2/C #8 Aug. 8,a x x NGB 2/C #6 Avg. 8,a x x NGB 4/C #6 Avg. Oa x .x s Cable - 300 V Cu Instrument (BIW) NGA 19/C #16 Awg. x x 9,a ,q NCA 12/C #16 Aug. x x 9,a \\_/ NCA 2/C #16 Avg. x x 9,a NGA 18/C #16 Awg. x x 9,a NGB 2/C #16 Aug. x x 9,a NGB 3/C #16 Avg. x x 9,a NGB 4/C #16 Awg. x x 9,a NGB 45/C #16 Awg. x x 9,a Cable - Thermocouple Extension Wire (Cerro Wire) NGB 1 pair #16 Cu-Const x x 10,a NGB 1 pair #16 Ir-Const x 10,a Cable - SKV Al Power (Okonite) NGA Triplex 1000 MCM 11,a NCA 3/C 500 MCM x 11,a O no^-,4 - Trio ex 4/o NGA 3/C #4/0 Awg. 11,a Cable - 600 V Al Pouer (Okonite) NGB Triplex 500 MC'4 x 12,a NGB Triplex 250 MCM x 12,a NGT-ll - Triplex #2/0 Aug. x 12,a NGB Triplex #1 Awg. x 12,a 3

DESCRIPTION ( LOCA') (MSLB) PAGE Cable - 300 V Cu Instrument (Cerro) NGA 19/C #16 Aug. x x 13,a NGA 12/C #16 Aug. x x 13,a-NGA 18/C #16 Aug. x x 13,a NGB 2/C #16 Awg. x x 13,a NGB 3/C #16 Avg. x x 13,a Cable-Thermocouple (BIW) NGB 1 pair #16 Aug. Cu-Const l l +,a x x Cable - Triaxial (BIW) NGA Triax x 15,a Cable - 600 V Cu Power Cable - Heat Tracing (Ckonite) NGB 2/C #10 Aug. 16,a x Chiller Room Sump Pump Motors DB-P-10A x 17 b,c Fan Motors and Motor-Operated Valve hY-F-40A, 40B x 18,a HV-F-71A, 71B x 18,b,e g HV-F-24 x 2 b,c, MOV-HV-115-1,2 x 17,a MOV-HV-116-1,2 x 17,a DESCRIPTION (LOCA) (MSLB) PAGE Level Transmitter LT-RS-151A, B x 20,a LT-RS-251A, B x 20,a Motor Control Centers 1-EP-NC-19 (11n-2N) x 22,a x 22,a 1-EP-MC-20 (IH1-2S) 1-EP-MC-21 (1J1-2N) x 22,a x 22,a 1-EP-MC-22 (1J1-23) x 22,a 2-EP-MC-19 (2Ea-2N) O 2-ze-ac-2o (2ia-28) x 22 a x 22,a 2-EP-MC-21 (2J1-2N) 2-EP-MC-22 (2J1-2S) x 22,a Motor Operated Valves FDV-QS-101A, B, C, D x 23 b,c FDV-RS-155A, B x 23 b,c }OV-156A, B x 23.b,c FDV-SW-103A, B, C, D x 23,a FDV-SW-104A, B, C, D x 23,a LOV-SW-108A, B x 23,a FDV-SW-113A, B x 23,a }DV-QS-201A, B, C, D x 23,a FDV-RS-255A, B x 23.b,c FDV-RS-256A, B x 23.b,c FDV-SW-203A, B, C, D x 23,a O >ov-SW-204^, n C, n x 23.e FDV-SW-208A, B x 23,a FDV-SW-213A, B x 23,a l Penetrations Type IA-Instrument x x 24,a,25,a 24,a,25,a l Type IB-Control x x x x 24,a,25,a l Type IC, IIA, IIB, IIC, IID, IE-Low Voltage Power Type III-Triaxial x 24,a 24,a Type IV-Thermocouple x Penetration Splices x x 26,a,27,a Teminal Blocks (Polysulfone) x x 19,a - -

i DESCRIPTION (LOCA) (MSLB) PAGE Recirculation Spray Pump Motors (Inside) RS-P-1A 28,a,29,a x x RS-P-1B 28,c,29,a x x Recirculation Spray Pump Motors (Outside) i RS-P-2A x 23,d,e_ i RS-P-2B x 23,d,e r_ t Salenoid Operated Valves h x 36,& f ASCO #HT8344 A71 ASCO #HT8321A5 x 30,a j ASCO #HT830281U x x 35,a,37,a T. ASCO #THT8320A102 M,a - 2 x x ASCO #FT83201A101 x x 38,a ASCO #HT834%11 x x 36,aw, Limit Switches For Use On: 1 1 MODEL # EA-180 x 21,a Switchgear - 480 V 1-EE-SS-03 x 31,a i 1-EE-SS-04 x 31,a 2-EE-SS-03 x 31,a j 2-EE-SS-04 x 31,a 1 Switchgear Transformers - 480 V 1-EE-ST-01 x' 31,a i 1-EE-ST-02 x 31,a 2-EE-ST-01 x 31,a 1 2-EE-ST-02 x 31,a- ~ i 1 l

m: 4. DESCRIPTION (LOCA) (MSLB) PAE Terminal Blocks t Connectron Type: 32,a NSE-3 x x 32,a NSS-3 x x 32,a PSU's x x General Electric Type: 32,a EB5 x x 32,a EB25 x x Marathon Series: 200 x x 32,a 1500 x x 32,a Thermo-Electric 32,a 3225's x x Westinghouse Type TBAL x x 32,a Terminating Material GO Okonite Tape - T-35 x x 33,a Okonite Tape - T-95 x x 33,a Raychem Heat Shrink 34,a WCSF-N x x HVT'T~ 39,a HVMC. 39~,a' '- Radiation Monitoring Pump Motor 1-SW-P-5,6,7,8 41 a 3 2-SW-P-5,6,7,8 41,a -.

IE 79-01 TAELE OF CONTENTS PART II QUALIFICATION NSSS INSIDE CONTAINMDiT DESCRIPTION OPERATING ENVIRONMENT Steam Generator Flow Transmitters l FT-1474, 2474 x x W-1,a x x W-1,a-FT-1475, 2475 FT-1484, 24% x x W-1,a FT-1485, 2485 x x W-1,a FT-1494, 2494 x x W-1,a FT-1495, 2495 x x W-1,a Pressurizer Level Transmitters LT-1459, 2459 x x W-2,a LT-1460, 2460 x x W-2,a LT-1461, 2461 x x W-2,a Steam Generator Level Transmitters (NarrowRange) LT-1474, 2474 x x. W-3,a LT-1475, 2475 x x W-3,a g LT-1476, 2476 x x W-3,a LT-1484, 2484 x x W-3,a LT-1485, 2485 x x W-3,a LT-1486, 2486 x x W-3,a LT-1494, 2494 x x W-3,a LT-1495, 2495 x x W-3,a LT-1496, 2496 x x W-3,a. -

DESCRIPTION (LOCA) (MSLB) PAGE Limit Switches for Valves as denoted HCV-1200 A,B,C x x W-4,a HCV-2200 A,B,C x x W-4,a TV-1%2, 2842 x x W-4,a Position Switch for Valves as denoted HCV-1201, 2201 W-5,a Motor Operated Valves I x x W-6,a MOV-1380, 2380 Pressurizer Pressure Transmitters x x W-7,a i PT-1455, 2455 PT-1456, 2456 x x W-7,a x x W-7,a l PT-1457, 2457 RCS Pressure Transmitters (vide range) PT-1402, 2402 x x W-8,a Solenoid Operators t HCV-1200 A,B,C x x W-9,a HCV-2200 A,B,C x x W-9,a LCV-1460 A,B x x W-lO,a x x W-10,a l LCV-2460 A,B i TV-1%2, 2842 x x W-10,a l HCV-1201, 2201 x x W-10,a l l

e 4 DESCRIPTION (LOCA) (MSLB) PAGE RCS Temperature Elements (Wide Range) TE-1410, 2410 x W-n,a TE-1413, 2413 x W-n,a TE-1420, 2420 x W-n,a TE-1423, 2423 x W-n,a TE-1430, 2430 x W-n,a TE-1433, 2433 x W-n,a RCS Temperature Elements . l (Narrow Range) TE-1412 B, D x W-12,a TE-1422 B, D x W-12,a TE-1432 B, D x W-12,a TE-2412 B, D x W-12,a TE-2422 B, D x W-12,a TE-2432 B, D x W-12,a 1 4 e 4 i i

r.. - _ -... -

.-2-.,_.

. -. ~..... GENERAL DEFINITIONS 1. Operability Requirements: Time and temperature conditions at which the equipment may be required to function, after the initial 60 minute transient period. 2. Operability Demonstrated: That testing done by the manufacturer for the stated I time and temperature conditions, demonstrating tne adequacy of the equipnent to operate during post accident conditions. The adequacy was determined based on use of the "10 degree centigrade" rule when evaluating the test data. Pre-test thermal aging was not considered. . NOTES 1. Radiation dose is sum of 40 year dose plus 120 day LOCA. 2. Adequacy was determined based on use of the "10 degree centigrade" rule when evaluating the test data. Ref. IEEE Publication 117 and 275 O l l l l l r l l l

1 l la l l \\ FQU I,P.NU.me=SL'BIPTION % "#,EK.NO. F FFCP I MIGN _=OF E%'T_FGT1Erf.r, OFEhASIL._ITY,R.dE JIEFENT .- -- T DE m m mm 12 -mmmm mm-m mm _mmm lCLb MSI.b in Tartir.e tidg.~ 30 minutes - 211 F & 1001 RM 0 1. iiigh ambient temperature 211 F P,0. tiA-247/12k7 for daration of steem discharge Norma l,Enviror.me nt Control % Felay Foom A C chillers in vicinity of chiller room air / 0 Westirghouse: intakes - 30 minutes. 104 F 1-W-E-kA. 3, C 2. High ambient moistare content QiTJtALILIT_Y_DFf0NS y g 2-HV-E-AA, B C saturated steem 1005 IGi for duration of steam discharge MLB 30 minutes. Nona Normal E_nvironment halel #PCOVid N.orma.l Envi_ronment-I Chiller room, Service buildire 70 to 104 F l Motors & pumps will keep ( tengerature above 70 F A g igCY_PFq g Ff g ] 0 Area has temperature monitors. Not required I ENVIROID M. TO WHICH EQJQ-,_IS (JALIFTED, m-m E None Normal Environment i 120*F f I t

,______...__.__m __._.._...___m.. i i I 1 i CALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES [1AM,0LCyLIFICATION q_;AyICATION ITX*3Cl? AKD REE04 ENDED SOLUTIONS __,ELB_ k_ __3 Mone sone -~' A. Defleiencies: Mormal Environs-nt, Norral Environagnt Equipment not qualified for exposure to: 1 Industrial Etendard Specification NAS-316 NES% NG 1

1) - Hign amtient temperature 211"F

2) faturated atmospnere,1005 R.H.

4 S. Solutions: There are three possible solutions as discussed telow: a. Include the chiller room inside the control room pressure toundary and eliminate its conmenication with the turbine building. This involves determining if the i compressed air system is adeq. ate to maintain pressure with the chiller i room included. Additional ducting must te added to provide cooling to r the chiller room. Structural modifications to block Spe:o;$s te turbine building and modir; door te be a pressure barrier. b. Replace unqualified egaipment with i qualified egalpment. c. Use equipment in unaffected unit to unintain control room environment. E ?""_1.E_nv1 9 33 None i i I a t m w

hm O 4 e .3 h* e Q

3 t2a r t*
p1 e

re ? H w h k)

k 5 *?

'. i3 'd A 4 4 4 W*td ."l

eeeepe 4 "

1 rJ

$$ g; ar4' e y 3 3 -,,. ~,.. t W 9, o ci o s'1 h 2 of Vi? Rb fli w E. r; t .n a r t7 O l J' b k. j $ Es, o n. x r g 4; 8 12 4 R n? p' h' g U.a<. o t @ ' - p3 e ,u w; S 'a 8 .O w$2, u

e

($ b g. ,.L o .w ,g n o r-C .- U P,5, t ", : e'b. C,a"C w C $,e ' iL~v a11 P. ". f.,. E n :' -., h,.. t,. ~ .-n s n-

nog, g

m' f.

- - Xe?

^* X 0 lX '. 8 ' Y rz e T E ;; s K N .R 9 >.o lo jc 4 ' o ll " ". 4 ""8E !!-r. E )cr.1 -f ih; U P, V 'N 4)h gb i ts ear

v. c : a w

M e e p <+ iy' !4 m 3: C[n .* " n f, If

3. %"

&%8 "l 7.

n s,

o. o c.

x 5

r c;;.3

!C p BU 7p 14 8 Ig p - a-u L'd F ;w v u >~ 3 s * '4 [G .W,2 e if'2 C A 8 cc e. s l:':

~ F ft:

~ Q *' ? C

l? E dC s

1 id

1 d

3 L, a $ec ja .R J.44 Is .g g g x m m m f. n i e+ pa i c. N I 4 v. ,c i n f U) 8 3 i O O

lb QUALIFICATION DEFICIDiCIES N1DF,,gg@yJ{0} g,gylgggy @ gyp _gQggg, MS.L. B. lC_.I,I_: Kone None A. Defl_cienci,es-Kormal Environment Equipneat not qualified for exposare to-No-mal Envirorent Specification NAS-31$

1) High ambient temperature 211 F Industrial Standard

2) Saturated atmosphere,1005 R.H.

EDM MG 1 P. Solut_!ons :, There are three possible solutions as discussed telow: a. Include the chiller room irJide the control room pressure boandary and eliminate its communication with the turbine building. This involves determining if the compressed air system is adequate to maintain pressure with the chiller room included. Additional ducting must be added to provide cooling to - the chiller room. Structural modifications to block openings to turbine building and modify door to be a pressure barrier, b. Beplace unqualified equipment with qualified equipnent, c. Use equipnent in urmffected unit to maintain c<mtrol room enviror. ment, f.gmal_Env_irogry None

2a y_OF gyCjgg OgEA E!iITY_REgl,MEh"rS, ESI3_ N 1 (ETRI_PTJON & MAFZ NO. Q RIPTI Air Conditioning Self-Cleaning JtELB in Turtine tl4 _Mcl4 1n_Turtine tidg. Strainers - Elliot Campany: 0 1. High amtient temperature 211 F 30 minutes - 211 F & 1001 Fat P.O.M 2W12?) for dation of steam discharge in 1 tiV-S-1A & B vicinity of chiller room air intakes. Normal Envirarmerf 2-HV-S-1A & B 2. }iigh ancient moisture content 70 F - 104"F saturated steam,1006 Ir for Model #ECA d.aration of steam disc'.a OPERA _BII.!TY EEMONSTF.AED r Chiller Em. Service Eldg. Normal Environment _yLB p T utine tidg. 0 i 70 F to 10 + F None Motors ard p g will keep ten:perature atove M Normal Envirormey f0kOF ENVIFONMD"r TO WHICH MUIP. IS (~iALIFIED

~ ~

~ ~ ~ ACCUPACY_FJggFQQ MSL_B in Turbine tidg. Not required None Norm 1 Enviroraner3 1 016 F i O I t

2 Q'JALIFICATION DEFICIEMCIES %M OF g'2LIFICATIg gJlA IFJCADO'i_Dogg AND REECtMD SOLUTIO _N_ . @_ In__Terbine bldg. MSLB_in Turtine_ tid. MS_LBJ n Tarbine_.tidA d None None A. Deficiencies; Norm l Environment _ Nor:nal Environment 1. High ambient temperature 211 F Industrial Standards 2. Saturated atmosphere AGE - VIII Specification #NAS-316 ASME - IX B. Solutions: 4 There are three possible solutions as discussed telow: a. Include the chiller room inside the control room pressure boundary and eliminate its emmunication with the turbine building. This involves determining if the compressed air system is adequate to maintain pressure with the chiller room included. Additional ductire must be added to provide cooling to 5 the chiller room. Structural modifications to block openings to turbine building and modify door to te a pressure barrier, b. Replace unqualified equipnect with qtalified equipment. c. Use equipment in affected unit to maintain control room erviror.:nent. gornal E=vironmenti None

2C Ey{ygglMEQQPg. gC_R{g!p__rg y (Igcq q gg?pyIp{g__gggfqp Propeller Fan - Aerovent Fan ELB in Tartine tidg. ELB in Turbine tlg Company, !ncorporated 0 0 1. High mz. blent temperatare 211 F 30 ricates - 211 F and 10M RH P.O. NA 2161/1241 for d2ation of steam discharge in 1-iiV-F-2k vicir.ity of chiller room air intakes Forral E_nvironme_qt 2-Ti-F -21s Model #7-216 2. High ambient moistae cartent 15 F aaturated steam, 106 Tai for Ins. Class F daatier. of steam discr.ar6e. OPPRABILITY DDmSTRATED Chiller rm Service tidg. yLB in Turbine _ tidg. Nor.nal Envir.o.rmnt----- - ~- 70 F to 104 F hutors and p.unpa will acep Nortal, Env_ir_or.meq+L temperature above 70% 120k 71NIRONVEf TO '1!ICH EQUIP.---!S Q'2LITIED ~ ACCL_TdCY REQUIRINDQ ELB in Turbine t,ldg. Not req 2 ired 0 1. High ambient temperstare 211 F at saturated atmosphere ?2TM*L EDl ?CG**?:.t l 0 120 F O

- - ~ _ - - - - k l l 2b l d I i QUALITICATION EEFICIDiCIES EN O{_ygLI._FICATIO!f {-g Ig T_I0N_DOCULQf AND FECOMENDED SOLUT!_m '? EL*B._iD. Turbine b1dg. !CLB_in Turbine _ bid - 6 TLI-3-29 W.B. Senu:mcher MSLB j Vendor's reply to TLX inquiry to J.E. Krechting i l h N_o_rm_a_l_ _E_nv.iro_nmen_t N_or.ma_l. _E_n_vi_r,on_me.nt-t } Industrini Standards ~ Specification #:;AS 15rTA f { None I ANSI B31.7 .I l. ANSI B16.10 ANSI Bifs. 5 I l l t i t ) I l l l i i I i e o i t .I i i k k i a l i t I i f a li 6 ~ ' .+*

dtcofU N N> r MM

dALG, h

eenhofop O C io o T VV NV z0vv u. rttrn t 0ie s I terh1

E E H 0sr r

M f h' ofoe f i l i V J' f,3 i n D-ol t a r ao O ar shr 22 l1 t nr p x nertat ooth 1% l01 al e T 9 36 o - C r awov e cc e a E cimetr 11 11 haFc t F cl h itip e F ilp vei &8 &1 leea d G d ra n ldln eselev 22 22 e dy V I nesvle ri a M .t e s e e s nP - l nesct r e O v I ti oearg o c.O C oh os N ria c.' h e c t .m a n r - t - ai c i wtc wlo ohnF F ar i n aaei A^ g lt ns F i =hc i tth J r iut t iae C 4ynp inlr N cw l .O eatca t# r :4 e n hes e3 v r5 i t 11 r s + a r m ut N D o EG c G na I r P gi !T 4 Q r e _O n _F v g ir [ o g nne G r p h t E.T I P CN g"D o? T O W C 5 N Me J y a I S q g' L I F Ip O

1 0 F#) i 10 [ I ,a_, v,, 4 f, y v, O i go 7-4 hl. $$ 6i i.1 $$ i a3 6R ,, } I i 1 hjNl Wil eq $ll' ci Wlj t5, di

5!

w 3 n; Dj l B, El 6 b e ,m E! e e

a v.4 x v.= u w u; ~ m.g o ~ < < WWh000000V ' 3 ER h k[ 'E $$ $ $'I' d M l g 'o 'f.. .g 1 w w w.)? n e r li 9{ 6 ~ g w w et a r:15 g 's s k-wr .o ~ ?2 ~% r ~ o E* m a k Li s '8": & E 2 5 5'8": 3 ~ n- ,, doo a a -E :ddd$Ug E 3 6Ef if nc u.8 ..b.9 6 w ,ga a : e s ~ 9, 8 g a 4, l W g " !C p{j r,I,g S. ItQ"

j "L 5 w TJ S Y G

'o y ~r*8*'y i' 1 o-ip r'M,o p; gan

p g

.J 3 o a g E_F'r.e - e 0 a!8 s.k-5 a '8 lW A; In 8 5 'r' 'B' it t ,b . : o :: g n n, y df,! p., l$e

s. 4

0 8 &

9, 1 a Sc~a Ln. n gaw g F

G tas -

k> N .b di @t w: n '>i pu iE in E m u 2 M [ . f1 u H g g ls g V = 2 p; ~ 4 % a 1: ap ~ c h L7 r; E if a o o :1 4 $ a v l,p" p* 8

1

~? 1 8 [ q o p ~ r 4 e in la 2 hj I n $) g P l l2 W c !m 0 o -a n -3 r r ~P y ry N N O O.

I ls QUAI.1FICATION DFSICIENCIES AND RECOMNDED SOLt"flONS MAnTR_OF_TMLIFICATICM giALIFICATION DOCU'6NT LOCA LOCA LOCA Test General Cable Letter dated 12-22-71 A. Deficiencies: Qualification Document la in letter form N_ortal Envirocment, (i.e. no forml test report data with Normal Environment approved signature and date) and does not Industrial Standard IPCEA S-19-81 specification NAS-lo8 address: f%

1) Accuracy of variables and test data

( )

2) Test monitoring sensors

\\/

3) Test facility B.

Soluti.ons :

1) Accuracy of instrument even though not stated, would c - ly be tl$

2) Test monitoring sensors, even thou6h not identified, are assumed to coa: ply with Industrial Standards for their type of application.

3) Location of test facility, even though not noted could be obtained from Vendor Becords.

The letter is a summary of the nuclear incident environment tests performed on similar constructed cables, which General Cable has stated are applicable. Npreal_ Environment, A. Deficiencies: Nornal ambient temperature us; ( exceed cables maximum continuous ambient teicperature. B. Solution _: a) Maximum temperature is of short duration. b) Catles that are used in CAT IE circuits are not carrying full dersted current continuously. Their load is in the range of ";O to 7;$ of derstad full load carent with the exception of emergency diesel generator which doesn't operate continuously during plant life.

5a ymm-trcm q7*:_t. ;p n_;;g, E qR g D LOF E.WIROIENT OJERABILITY EQBggg P.O. NA-256/ 25c Losa_of Coolant Accident [LOCA) 1 f40 V Alua. Power Catle Loss of Coolant Accident (IACA) } Gene.ral Cat..l.e. )__ _ ____ 530 F 0 to",36' min 120 day @ 150 F d NGE-5 Triplex 500 HCM to 150AF 30 to 60 min OFFyEILITY_ DQGSTEAyM2) NGB-7 Triplex 250 w M 1500F >oo min wCA NGE-ll Triplex 2/0 AWG. 45 psig O to 30 min 1t3 hr @ 2t'O F NG3-12 Triplex #1 AWG. Red xe from k5 to O psig 30 to to min Post IDCA thermal aging is O psi 6 >60 min equivalent to 490 days @ 150 F 7 7.2 x 10 rada(1) Spray: O-k hrs. Solution of toric acid (2000-2100 ppm boron) buffered Jacket Neoprene to a pii of 8.5 to 11 with NaOH. > b tra ACCISCY R_ gEDgrS Q S Insulation: Ethylene Propylene Babler similar solution with a pH cf 7 to 9 WCA Inside and outside Containment ENVIROTC~f TO h_'iICH EQUIP. IS q'f g TLED Los_s of_ Coolant Accident. JI4CA) Irradiated to .55 x 10 rada 100 psig @ 3kOoF for 4 bra. 62 psig @ 3100F for 1 br. 20 psig @ 2tX) F for 43 hrs. 2.5 paig @ 260 F for 5 days Spray: h oughout test cycle solution consisting of a 2000 p;n solution of toron as boric acid buffered with NaOH to a pii of 9.0 Irradiated an additional 1.k5 x 10 rgda 3 tringing the total exposare to 2 x 10 rads. O

m i l 5 QUALIFICATION DEFICIENClIS MANNER OF Q'RLJF_ICAHOM QALIFICATION DOCUMDIT AND F N T E ED S0 w f!ONS LOCA LOCA LOCA Test - Sequential General Cable Letter dated 12-22*71 A. Deficiencies: qualification Document is in letter form (i.e.. no fornal test report with approved signature ani date) does not address:

1) Accuracy of variables and test data

('~

3) Test facility B.

Solutions;

1) Accuracy of instrument even though not stated, would coursonly be fl%

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to comply with Industrial Standards for their type of application.

3) Ioeation of test facility, even though not noted could he obtained frtus Vendor Records.

The letter is a sumary of the nuclear incident environnert teste performed on cables of a similar cocatruction, which General Cable has stated are applicable.

(4 FQUITSEiT LEECRIPTION & MARK, NO. gg g, g O_P.ERAJILITY FFR3FJi@TG F.O. EA-123/1129 LOCA 600 V. Cu. Power cable Loss of coolant Accident (trEA) 120 days e 1504 2SODF 0 to 30 mi.n Okonite mLa Bedre from 280 F H O days d 15u% ~ c NGA 20 1/e 250 FCM to 150 F 30 to 60 min o 15o r > 60 min NGA-21 1/c 2/O A E GFERAEILITY DFlG3TRATED (2) NGB-15 Triplex #4 AWG 45 psig O to 30 min NGB-16 Triplex #5 AWG Reduce frca 45 30 to oO min LOCA NGB-17 3/c #6 AWG to O psig NGB-13 3/c #10 AWG o psi 6 i60 min I 304 F - 3 hr 20 min 7.2 x 10 rads (1) NGB-19 3/C M12 AWG 340 F - A hr 27 min 0 0 250 F - 1 day Jacket: Neoprene 0 pray: 0-k hr Solution of boric acid 212 F - 100 days (200-2100 ppm boron) buffered to a Insalation: Ethylene Propylene Rabber 0 259 F - 10 hr gi of 8.5 to 11 with NaOH 7 4 hr O 3A y - le hr Inside and Outside Contairanent Similar sa'ution with a pH of 252 F - 7 days 7 to 9, Post I4)CA thermal aging is greater tnan Main Steam Line Break (IC3'L) 2,9 years @ 150 F 43OOF 0 to 2 min 2SO F 2 to 60 min O McLB 150 F > 60 min 45 psi 6 0 to 30 min see above Redace from 45 to O psig 30 to 60 min O psig, 2 60 min 3 x 10' rads ACCURACY R%UIRF2G~PS LOCA & K'LB ENTROICENT TO MIICH EQL7P, IS qyALIFIED Loma of Coolant Accident (LOCA) Aged 168 hr @ 121"C Irradiated to 2 x 100 rads IVR exposare: 60 psig @ 3240F For 4 hr 16 psig @ 2520F For 7 days Spray: 10,000 ppa boric acid tuffered with NaOH to a pH cf 10.5 througnout tne IMR exposure period. Boiling Water Feactor Exposure (iMR) A serica of transient cycles each con-i sisting of a rise to a specifjed press i and temp for a specified time and a I gradal return to init111 conditions. Following transient cycles 100 day D exposare to live steam o psig, 212 F i iMR exposure inc1Mes a transient cycle { at 10!. psig at 345 F for 3 hr and N min. ELB Same as " Description of E:rilrcament" i l

e. 6 QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES MANNER OF C'JALITICATION QUALIFICATION DOCW ENT AND RECOWE!CED FOLUTICE LOCA LOCA LTA Test - Sequential Okonite's Engineering Report A. Deficiencies: No.141 dated 2/29/72 Qualification document does not address: Additional Supporting Documents . 1) Accuracy of variables and test data

2) Test monitoring sensors Outline of Frark M a Institute

3) Test facility Research Laboratory report F-C3694 B.

Solution: i IEEE Transaction Paper T 74 044 b

1) Accuracy of instrument even though not stated would e - ly be fik

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to comply with Indastrial Standards for their type of application.

MSLB 3) Location of test facility even though not noted could be obtained from Test - Analysis FSAR Section 3C and response to vendor's records. Additional supporting Coment 7.17 (Note to be revised documents indicate that some tests were )ttrimum calculated surface temperature to include this item), performed at Fracklin Institute. durire limiting M3LB is 335 F which does not exceed qualification temperature MSLB of 345 F given in BWR exposure portion of LOCA qualification. Qualification based on independent test and analysis. Each of the qualification parameters (obtained from independent test and analysis) exceeds the corresponding MSLB requirements. Amend Fr.AR as stated in " Qualification Document". l

oar

IJN IJE EmNNNN' e i.P CH gr I

preE naO na eec ns scA scA 3sAMG3 rgO G r iA ek uk AA rh. i anr-toc 1 d le le1 - - - - - - o at3 a t,5 336311 TN w e it 5 i s x t: t: 741375 WeA 3, o s i C ic - .n r p i o o oA1 rp3 lr ers qa n

nS6

ns7 ee5 t

i1 b r9 p_ uyr a l e& aa/ E i e i s nt 1 s Sc& i rpq StN da3 e n ea u m lnE io ioG dmi ls3 2476TT Ce9 n 5 e p r ie3 i // a t c c / /r r n f.s e t c cE3 ccii bC n o d oR3 or7 pp la r na4 nm

1. 1. 2ll et o

f eb ei 611 - ee l N pao b d 62#xx We olr Re R A 8 s sl ar a WAA

2 t

t b b WWn/0 a25 u oh b b ate e e dO s 4A W y ch r r x cei irn

WM w

d s .o eii 1 ntd 2 teem A s 4 S H sF p1 tR ooS 2I wM30O4124 p Sp( S 7 OtRb1tR2 L R a S p - e6 ie ffp 7r 5593 iH2p oe55oe9 o E m L rC rC md r br e xpp 0 M 1iisF*00 m 0r 2p d 0 d0 s S e B a2 i C eu bba Ca A sap 0 io0a sO.pc s 1{ u s C y7 oF c aey Fd FF lf0y xi cF R a 5 d we rr: i 0gsi a gpei Ce o I s w0 a id oa fa 7 g r.3 2 1 s g O _f P a wt t ntL ot 1 0 if Ff T L' si i ht ea re Ur t s500 I 6r r _C T n t5 o ads d a o o 0 - o o o O e bd i s s t 1 d lt 4 r a m o N s ui cp p5 w 2t a uop a l c fc us r ba2 o E t ph d 4 2 a O r fa ti ap ot h i1a r a 5 8 n F i et g ys reh r2 o1 0 t p re s i irr n b ( 0 E t es pf cg c x woS 1 F A N M i d no o co wiro ) c V o t t r na aof 1 itol _c I n wr y t n cn 0 ia t id it 1 0 h )t 7 7 _e N thnu i R o tt h n .d a 2 d O @M N i f h e u1 i r 63 620 aabo t 3 O63 0 u E i i6 nh a 00 0 Oun o0 00 t E Nn r rk ir d tt pHf t t a e dO r m Ca F 4p ,s fo P mt moo H>ef mt omt o ( i dn m r io i io io L e [_ t n62 o 4r n 3n 3 O n r i o ar 5 0 f eb 6 0 t 0 C c te oa M o m hdo 0 o A v pi 0 r e po mi 7r r m m ) an r e r e pl r md p s in ti m i s i d s i n t oc i n i n n Hi a xw i n o n n t e o n ii g E aa cr f mt M 9 c f u ah i t t r. t a d 9e h s ea M _T s e p l ,t e ys M 7 c o ,1 l i t d f u h a i 7t e y e 2i d 0on pps N A S M eP L2 T O 1 M 1 L _O S qo t 7 ~A P 2 s 2 O o C e P t C e d6 L 2 s ~CA M s A B E 0 t 0 C E G B 1t a v F' F r d d A e A b a P a a J q C o lW ff I y y I u Y v eC oo L s s L i e nA rr I I r F t _T T R' e t 71 Y Y d th 2 1 1 oe d D 5 5 E y_D r ah a D 0 0 M 6s y r 4 5a s 0 F F U C l N I d S E G aa T E _T yg _R M S si A n D @g H r 7 D _r a s 11 5s 0 F

5 7 QCALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES PANNER OF QUALIFTCATIDN QUALIFICATION DOC 3M AND REmWJ3DED SCII" IONS wCA wCA wCA Test - Sequential Franklin Institute Research A. Deficiencies: Laboratory (FIRL), Report F-C2657 Qualification doczents do not address: Cerro's Supplemert to FIRL,

1) Accuracy of test data and variables Report F-C2657

2) Test menitoring sensors

3) 2760F, O to 30 min vs 1*3OoF b) 1,750 ppm baron vs 2,000 rpm FIRL, Report FC2750

5) Iong-tem post-accident operabilities not demonstrated Cerro's Supplement to FIRL, Report F-C2750 B.

Solutions:

1) Accuracy of instrument, even though not stated, would cm mocly be i1%.

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, Main Steam Line Break (MSLB)

MSLB are assumed to coeply with Industrial Standards for their type of application. Temperature - Analysis FSAR Section 3C ami response to

3) The above 2760F through first 30 min is within re a mt 7.17 tolerance of the MCA temp transient profile -

ISAR Fig. 6.2-62 (Amendment No. 65) Maximm calcu3sted surface temperature during limiting NSLB is 335 F whi?h does

4) The cable jacket is of an asbestos braid which 0

not exceed q+miirication temperature of Rockbestos' letter dated k/25/77 has been shown to be resistant to all diluted bG FF given in Rockbestos" (fomerly MCA qualification documents alkaline solutions. Therefore, we believe that since the IOCA spray is in the rar4e of a Cerro) letter dated 4/25/77 diluted alkaline solution, it siculd have no significant effect on the cable.

5) The cable (taa-15) insulatten is rated for 1250C Fressure and Radiation - Test conductor temperature at rated empacity, it can be c

shown by stanlard industy practices that the 4 Refer to LOCA 4:alification cable is capable of operating in a 1500F ambient continuously. b f {LB Each of the qualification parameters (obtained from independent test and analysis) exceeds tre corresponding i !SLB requirecerrts. 6 h i i l l I l

Ba E N D % Y,M. DgRIy_ ION OF_ IMIM'f3 OgBAEH Ty g Ry g Lgss _ f_Coolmat A.ccident (LOCA) LOCA y g V nt C Cerro Wire and Cable Company 290 F 0 to 30 min 120 days 4150 F - "'' ~~' Reduce from 230 F 30 to (0 min NCA-19 2'e #2 AWG to 150DF NCA-3h 1/c #14 AWG 150 F > 60 min OPERABILITY DDtONSTRATED(2) NGA-35 2/c #14 AWG 45 psig O to 30 min ~ ' ~ ~ " NGA-36 3/c #14 AWG Redace from 45 g NCA-37 5/c #14 AWG to O psig 30 to to min NCA-33 7/c #14 AWG 270 F for 12 hr O peig 7 to min NGA-39 9/c #14 AWG 7.2 x 10' rada (1) 1L0 F for 6 days NGA-40 12/c #14 AWG Spray: NCA-44 1/c 412 AWG O-k hr Solution of boric acid Post LOCA ther:nal aging is equivalent 714,y g 15o$ NGA-45 2/c #12 AWG (2,000-2100 ppm boron) buffered NCA-47 h/c #12 AWG to a pH of 3.5 to 11 with Nadi NGA-49 7/c #12 AWG NCA-57 4/c #10 AWG > 4 hr similar solution with a NCA-77 4 /c #10 AWG 242 F for 395 hr pH of 7 to 9. NGB-k3 2/c #3 AWG NGB-kk 2 'c F6 AWG M3LB Post ELE thermal aging is equivalent to NGB-k5 h#c #6 AWG 2 yrs. @ 150 F. 0 o 430 F 0 to 2 min 0 280 F 2 to 60 min ACC"EACY R$L3?p!M Jacket: Neoprene 150 F '60 min Insulation: Cross-lir.ked Folyethylene 45 psig O to 30 min Jot required Reduce from 45 to O pais 30 to (O min 0 psig > 60 min Inside and Outside Containment 3 x 107 rads ko yr. dose ENVIRCNENT TO WHICH 3' P f y,SygF Q _ I J LOCA Irradiated to 2 x 103 rads MSLB So psig and 27toF for 12 hr Spray: Last 2 hr of 12 hr period with a Thermally aged for 1300 hr 9 150 C solution of torated water containing Irradiated at a rate 0.30 x 10j rads per approximately 1.720 ppm of boron as boric hr for total dose of 2.01 x 10 rad. acid. Spray: Solution of c200 ppa icron ar4 Redace to 5 peig and 16k"F over an un. hydrazine solution maintaLned at a pH specified time with spray continued. value of between 8.6 and 10.0 for y)9 hr 100 F at 5 psig for the remainder of the 3704 @ $8 psig O to 13 min 7 day period with no spray. 37t F @ c2 psig 13 to 15 min i 3tia F @ 62 paig 15 to 20 min ] 3370F @ 60 psig 20 to 25 min l Pedace from 337oF 25 min to 3.6 hr T 8 60 psig to 242

8 QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES @m OF Q'3LIFICXAON. qJ_ALIFICA_T_I0_N D0%q AC REC _0_ JJ:DED SOLI?!*IOhL W _LOCA_ - LOCA LOCA Test

Sequential Franklin Institute Pescarch A. Deficiencieh Latoratory Report F-C2357

-- ~~-

1) Accuracy of test data and variables Cerro's Supplement to F.I.R.L.

2) Test monitoring sensors

3) 1,720 Fps borm vs 2,000-2100 pra Report F-C2857

4) 276CF 0 to 30 min vs 260 Y C

B. Solutions:

1) Accuracy of instrument even though 6

not stated would catenanly be fl1

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to comply with Industrial Standards for their type of application.

3) The cable jacket is of a neoprene material which was shorn to be resistant to all diluted alkaline solutions. Therefore we believe that since the ILCA spray is in the range of a diluted alkaline solution it should have no eignificant effect on the cable.

4) The above 2760F through first 30 min is within tolerance of the LOCA temp. transient profile - FSAR Fig. 6.2-82 (Amendment #65) MSLB @LB MSLB Test - Sequential Rockbestos Company A. Deficiencies: Report 13-10 W -E)S8-13-2 Test was performed on cable

1) Accuracy of test data and variables of a similar construction as

2) Test Monitoring Sensors that supplied in P.O. NA-312/1312

3) Qualification temp. is belor propose accident temp. 430 F for 2 min FSAR Section I and response to vs 376*F for 13 min Coment 7.17 (Note to be rev-ised to include this item).

B. Solut_i_on_s :

1) Accuracy of instrument even though net stated would te f1E

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assmed to comply with Industrial Standards for their type of application.

3) Surface temp. will reach a enzimum 5

0 of 355 F after 2 min @ 430 F therefom we meet the temp. requirements.

N N' N N' E N N N @ 3.PH I I J GGGG GGG 0 cD n n a nn i s c EPBBAAAA o 0.O oe s I u k s to d l e $ 4337t f ,t tvN P at e a ie t

t 50950987 o

A V _n In2 N E n a i mc n o Is0 T tl O

n N

nt5 ea d nb e sr/ D o au1 E e u p lm2 S os t C r 4h321211 aec C n s r e 5///3/29 t n5 R t i o n /ccc /c// et I ch d s e c c cc d P la e s c T at Wa I s C l NNNNNNNN ib O sa o i .o.o o.o.o.o.o.o rl N r n n ee Ie t k E a e a u i d II1II11I n M cs n t t 3 nt 66t d A ie m P .C K R rd e o EAANAAAA c n l dWW#WWWW a ui t y GGGGGGGG t N in e l .O t s t e .s i h ) d y e lene s wsS22I L E 3OtR412EC S Wa o f 2 p.7 O t R 41 t R 2 so(S I D k oe55oe8 O E a iop 03r O oe5533 C ltlr50r g o xp d 000L l 0 r 2p d 0 d0 C S m n 1isOxp e ahaa 0 0a ,A t.8 0 a soup 0 00B 1 D A C u y xi csF5rF R r tyFFd s7FF a ti: i 0g p e i i52: gpei 0e I t s sho aaa N 7 s g o 1 1 a g P aen ttt M af nt0 0 if Ff Q' l T e E r gr o00 7 gr r D" apohO4d N a o w o o O e tifr 5 T d m i1p kr m m N s i i op t a t1p a c o a.0 u s p o T h h mhs k 2 O r nd gia O 5 w rs 5 3 F i j2hgi1 aibs ( F N 0 o g

'W to 0

E fm0o p t u x phrs1 f i tmt2 I i oo) V o Neo 4t 1 C hnl I n adl2 l oa)a 00 W O a5h 0 i fO t o Htr rm E Hbi M C f o hsir J (3 0t 20

7) uo t 3 0t3 0

tr na J 40 o fn 0 o0 E 8o d I t tt t4f h t t n rp a P mt omoo o eo t omt o T v ,8 o e io i hrf mo io nr n 3nt 2 9re i 3n c 3 ir 5 i I t 0 o sdt nL 0 X 0 S o m o O ) m o ao _b3 n wsd m ai str m m i ^ s i in i oi m i m i e tbw i n n m c i n i n n hoi n i a n n _I t rt L l a aih I apc c F rHi 0 a d _E a .0c D 1i 9d S A S M tP 22L O 1 'E 1L O L L e C e S oo 05O F 2 2O P e C e s 50C F 0 0C E U B ot F4A 0 R B ~A R a E a p A d A A b eL E d a B a:- C o rO ff I a y I r Y v aC oo L y s e e tA rr I s J R i T e _T Y F rt 2 A* Y q gh 4 1 q e D 1 5 R rr hm E 5 o M f em ri 0 G D g a sn F al F E i S B M ra T g eg E g S mi A SE en T ng E t D si s ( ]2 not ega lva lent

9 QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES MANNER OF Q'ALIFICATI_0N TIAM FICATION DOCL' MENT AND BECCf4EhTEEL_LTIONS_ J LOCA !DCA IACA Test - Sequential B.I.W. Letters dated 1-17-72 A. Deficiencies: 12-14-71 ~~ ~ 1. Accursey of variables an:1 test data 2. Test monitoring sensors 3. Test facility k. 8-8,5 pii vs 8.5-11 pH 5. Time, temperature errvelope not [, sufficient - t B. Solutions: 1. Accuracy of instrument even though not stated would c% be t1% 2. Test monitoring mensors, even though not identified, are assumed to comply with Industrial Standards for their type of application. 3. Location of test facility, even though not noted, can be obtained frcra Vendor records. h, The cable jacket is of a neoprene material which was shown to be resistant to all diluted alkaline solutions. Therefore, we believe that since the IDCA spray is in the range of a dilutad alkaline solution it should have no significant effect on the cable. 5. This instrument cable has the same QB, MSLB jacket & insulation as the 600v Control Cable. P.). EA 312/1312 page Temperature - Analysis FSAR Section 3C and response % which surpassed opersbility C. Wautimum calculated surface to comment 7.17 req 2irements. We will get further MSLB is 343,during limiting temperature test data. F which does not B.I.W. letter dated 10-12-76 exceed quallrication temperature LOCA Qualification documents of h60 F given in B.I.W. letter dated 1012-76. Pressure and Radiation - Test refer to LOCA galifiestion

1 10m E.C.e@%_I TESCRIP"' ION TT __!%_ RT Wo. DE:SCR._I_M._I.ON_OF ET_ilBOM.'" OM.A E I,ITY RE'13F,P.O..._3.,.. m. mm b P.O. NA-252 Loss of Coolant Accident _(LOCA) Sermocogle Extensicc Wire Kot reqdred i (Cerro Wire and Catle) 230 F 0 to 30 min g Redee from 230 F OFERALILITY IUCCTRATED EF-US 1 pair No. le Copper-to 150 F 30 to to min Constantan 45 psig > to r.in Sct reg ired NSD :9 1 pair No. la Iron-Eed re from 45 0 to 30 min Constantan to O pai6 30 to LO min ACC"JRC RAUI?lM'TS - - - = = = - = - - Jacket: Neoprene 7.2 x 10 reds (1) Not required Ins dation : Silicone Rat.ber Spray: 0-h bra Solnion of boric acid Inside and Outside Containment (2000-2100 ppm toron) b dfered to a pd of 8.5 to 11 with haOH > b hrs similar soldion with a pli of 7 to 9 ? ???Y SUS?ES Tm NOTE: Irrediated to 2 m 10 rads 50 paig at 27LOF 12 hrs i;nder f atter investigation it was fo cd that these cable are not used Spray: Last 2 hra of 12.*r period in the systems that are required to soldion of torated water containirg mitisste a insip Essia Accident, approximtely 1720 ppm of toron as toric acid. Reduce to 5 psig and itAOF over an una cified time with spray continued. It. at 5 pai6 for tLe re,at:hier of 7 day period without spray. F-C2750 indicates that in an earlier test the sprey was buffered with 5aOH to a pH of 9. O o

10 QUAI.IFICATION DEFICIENCIES $9 OF Q3LIFICATI0l"4 CytLIFIglTION_DocLHF3 AD RECObt.ENDE_D SOURI0_NS_ .-M W_ .LogA_ Test-Sequential Franklin Institute Besearch A. Deficiencies: Laboratory Report F-C2857 ~ " - ~ 1. Accuracy of verisbles and test data Cerro's Supplement to F.I.R.L. 2. Test monitoring sensors 3 27o F for O to 30 min is telcer Franklin Insitute Research environment of 230 F for 30 stin 1 Test solution is 17*,0 Pin boron vs Laboratory Report F-C2750 8 2000-2100 pga baron. Cerro's Supplement to F.I.R.L. Beport F-C2750 B. Solutions; 1. Accuracy of instrument even though not stated would c<eennnly te tlk 2. Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are ass'..med to en=pir with Indastrial Standards for their type of application. 3. 27t,F for first 30 min is within tolerance of the LOCA temperature transient profile - FSAR Fig. 6.2 @ (Amendment No. 65) 4 F-C2750 ind.icates that in an earlier test the spray was buffered with NaOH to a piri of 9 Furthermore, cable, Jacket is of a neoprene material which has been shown to be resistant to all diluted alkaline solutions. Therefore we believe that since the LOCA sprey is in the range of a diluted alkallne solution it should have no significant effect on the cable. I I

lii1 F W. IG; M F @ 5,F .T. ' C IJ t na A A 4~ A' Y.e.0 t sc si le 13ib n M I uk a d at 3 k iAX e t tlA Ti~ i eu - .m 3 C o ) o nN 7 n e 5 L t o P/ F a p o1 I i Cr w3 C r re e7 P on r5 I m M e se n a C a I t l 4 b C in 3TT3 e s /rr/ e ciic d pp M ll5 A ? bee 0 X P xx0 o l / .p y 01ki 4 e 0/ A 0 0 M' t h W0 y G W l F d e E3 n M e A li 2 L E s& AL N 7 1, [ C s o o T y rO o o t r x s I sce r 2 s C s I t l a m s I r m1 M .m s A1 1 f i e a a x I e o r l c I M 1 r f O' s2 E 0,. s t E C I 0 n C t n r C Et v o O e v a o ia c T eF i r o r n l rm r a l g e a T ep c d a C .n-n O de r s r. F r .e W-dr t t n ( A a a e t .X A t n 1 rn I t c C au t ) c e c C nr c I E i H te i l d d J e e F vs e C s n Q eo n / ?,EC nc t s t I' ti ( it .? t ( l o L h 1 a 0 ar O n C I t s CA A S i 1 ) o ) n 0' {A 0 LIF IED l E 7 o' C

m. C A

1 t yC N m.L 2 L f c c o o a Or 2 s E C r x a t s IG C m s E _3 F' a 1 A a x r A l 0 o E 1 o E e _C "a f I 1 f I q E E 0 L ~Y u n r C I n 7 C I ir _R v a o T v o TY y e .3-i d c T i o r l d r l o a 5.R .U o a r n _I r n .P e t n t g e U J e _y n A I n A r t c t c ? Q_ C J c c y r i i d ri .s d yA ( e e n T n t t ( ii L C' OC A A ) ) l la O j 'li1fll1,l

n =- 11 G LIFICATION DEFICIENCIES . tBEER OF QtMLIFICATION QLIFICATION_ DOC'@L_3 g REC _OKfQED SOLL_TIONS LOCA LOCA LOCA i Test Okonite's Engineering Beport A. Deficiencies: Normal Environment Additional Supporting Documents Qialification document does not address: Itdcstrial Standarda, IPCEA Outline of Franklin Inst'tute

1) Accuracy of variables and test S-IPB1 '

Research Laboratory heport da ta; F-C3c94

2) Test monitoring sensors retention IEEE Transaction Paper T7h 0i.4 4 of records (i.e. traceability of instrumntation)

3) Test facility Normal Environment 5.

Solutions: Specification NAS-lOS

1) Accuracy of test data and variables even though not addressed would connonly have been made with instruments having acceracies of ilk

2) Test monitor in6 sensors, even thou6h Lot addressed can be assumed to be i

i of typical types,

3) Test facility could be determined frca vendor records.

Normal Environment A. Deficiencies: Eorum1 ambient temperature may exceed cable saxi!aum continuous ambient temperature. B. Solotion: a) Maximam terperature is of short daration, b) cable that are used in Cat IE circuit are not carryiryg full rated current continuously. Their load is in the ran6e of 50 to 75% of derated full l load current with the exceptior. of emergency diesel Eenerator whien is intermittent daty. i i l =

I IJ 3 N S N .O 6.P q n na G c .k 0 s sc E33B .o 0.O J' I i uk .n d le 1175 iV P t.t 21 t K t a e m .e A A . l - a i n z% c e a3 d ao m% i D O p nf E c r l u t Ee TTTT n3 .s tn rrrr R i he iiii - P% I d y pppp o P e l llll - w T e eeee - e I C n xxxx r O o e N n - C a* P a r t i o l N n p d25 e A m y 1250 E e l /00 X n e 0 M N t n A mC .iW A e .O i MM .G e R 2 ber B IA mY g c f,2 p o W aNb(S 7 oOR41tR L D X a u rg e55oe o E 91 c tp cAi Wip52w S23 R re V r 2p p d 0 d s S ad - 0oirc l .iif0a I saup 1 s C e0y xiicsF5x 20nmecsi Rt r24E d R F 1 des sen h a 0 0x i1 O o r0: ggei 0e _o I 2di s ir g e yFFp a6 N f>e - 1 g 0 f F .F*y i r r t e W atau si xN: o t8 M d,2 0 f Ff T pa aas e P 7b 0 7 r r C I o d e is a oO 0ttu dt J t1 - o o o _O e.n n t sH - r r T tho0k r m m o N x aagoe a 418e t or 0 a l p n fr rt 60: oa T a d 4 2 a O o gdo eoh t O 9 S pS a 5 3 n _F sFr fth rpp 2 ip p o 0 t uoat re p a ss 1 rldeaaa e Sii x2 i:V mHa l ( t i u 1 o F^ A D ek4p r nc rp ogg 1 T lobt ) c T rst iHl 1 C afoi c I t e iio o u 0C H r ro i R v oi rser .d o t 0 s.8 a n d O' nraen fi W n e q_ W' l6 e t tE c r o5)o c3 063 n i tut x 1e a I l f 00 00 t vturocp 0 d I at t erre y o . o s an acs 5f .P to b st ost f i o io io M sr f le o1 r n 3 n .f tJioser tbf0 I n1 i M 0 einrpse hco S c O me e sniace : orrt ww m ui o g ii a m i m tn ia g c7 tt c i n i O tsfc h 4 hh i n n cip ih oad d pyaee ucah I aclcd tiyr F il i ds I 6e f t E s i h D e e d N A 2P 2322233IO 1 C A 2 g o C o 52515 45DM t C 9s 2 k9 2 6 o 0 G t 0 y FFFFFF4_A d A re A eL J 1 M _C q aO _I y Y rC u _L s sA 7k11 i I s r d a.r.h _Y R_I P 001k3 _T r F @t dh 0 ed h arh dh i 1 g 1e y r E 5 F t ay D 0 5r s K g0m y K 0a s 22 F J Fl 70 A r Q F a mm g ii n i nn A O r T q E E D S is ( 1 2 2 g ) a reater t han j ,l ii !1

12 QMFICATION DEFICIENCII3 "#N # NNY_ 99fME_ Egg QFKMMIED S0ggg 1 Test - Sequential Okonite's Engineering Report A. Deficiencies No. 1h1 dated February 29, 1972 Qualification Document does not address: Additioral supporting Doctanents--

1) Accursey of variables and test data

- ~ ~ ~ ~ Outlinc of Franklin Institute

2) Test monitoring sensors Fesearch Imboratory Feport F<3694

3) Test facility fmI IEEE Tracmaction Paper T 74 OW 4 B.

Solutiorm: t

1) Accuracy of instrument even though not stated woald enr=wmly be 11%

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to emply.

with Industrial Standards for their type of application.

3) Test facility, even thcugh not idecti-fled, could be determined frca vendor's records. (Additional supporting docu-ment indicates that scuse tests were performed at Franklin Institute.)

s

u iv,.. 2 8.o I a' da O b" d 'in 2"g I <g. R 8y g* h'" j "3 -n o " 8 wmg-~ L u .w-am onn d; g y; f~ k ' WWFET yn R o g. U k 3' S mmh'MM SV 5'

;T 9

>.:,s > li i h~ bbbbb k a,. t,,', " I'. n b a 2 IC a b E!{B! !*h "%I*,Aa r t $ k ~$2 e d" ~6$ p ~o 2 %sE==+==g-L=Lw i Tf~~ o089 4 c.,c $ $ I N e e I El l 4 ~a ~.,,, w e ag g p e, e.. ,8

,. o ny y

g $ g k u o R$$ j f eg? al l 8 E~ %,,,{ydo, y d 1g ET " E y r. a e. e,, a ng es x 1 e i~r% ~r q~ n a a o p: w%) b, o a qg

- a a

q< e a; p@g rl p' g 3 a v ;r - -o E r- .: n o s o a 3Ig V t: " E l'a ~ o It 4 5. ". p @/ E R c: e r 8 y' m ... P 3 Ji . fV ~a %*g "C u n 3 d 3%, N g g o. ;; v v o y g g eggmewwwgo g ggogmo n, ggoggo h >'^ gr,47GU".C 4 EeinGG 5.~ % n sin.G 4 6,,.., 6 2-EgS8

u s*

go Dgo D o g a P. -EE wr Er ld S .C^ S F I.2 Eg ~a E bb U E'Eb I5 E t' "U c p .Er y-g .a Unf di + w .*n Nh g lY0,0 lg up b3 h)* OI,5l**'$,'9IU O P N 0 8 G 3 ,6 y A e 2 i 5% a !0 a e ?,a %la fE

s s

y-. a 9 y', 1 !l a. 2.~ p -e i e. i., f y F C S l l 3- .e h 9 O O

t 13 Q'.IALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES E CER OT ylALIFICATI$ @IFICATION DOC'FENT Ap_RECO_tFFICED S0t,UTI0 tis IDCA LOCA I4CA-- A. Deficiencies: Test - Sequential Rocktestos (formerly Cerro) Qualifieetion docum:ct does not address: Letter dated 2-21-79 and its - 1. Accuracy of variables and test data attached report 2. Test monitoring sensors retention of records (traceability of instrumentation) 3. Test facility NOTE: Dosimete-a are addressed S. Solution 1 Accuracy of instrument even thou6h not stated would coussonly be t1%. 2 Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to comply with industrial Standards for tneir type of application 3. Test facility could be determined frtza Vendor's records 93 . W. ELB FSAB Section 3C and respocse Qualifiestion based on independent test Temperature Analysis Maximum calculated surface to coment 7.17 arxi acausis, temperature durring limitir.g Rockbestos letter dated Each of the qtsklificatice parameters (ob-MSLB is 3430 which does not 4-25-77 tained from indeperulent test and analysis) . exceed qualification tem. LOCA galification doeuent exceeds the corresponding MSLB requirements pratttre of bMP given in Rockbestos (formerly Cerro) letter dated 4-25-77 Pressure and Radiation - Test Refer to LOCA Qualification i o ? t

81 M >* *4 f*; "A 4 HI-. {' '*) if* W ". *d .E QE M. d s.o U $ D p' " 6 r-S' 7...% 3.v ,h.y j s.. 1 p O IM y l' " E 3 d[' M [~s. g". .o o G t) 3 "a W 7 h., ~I-1 . ~ $"9: p ~ 4 0 ,2 A

t.

.: B d ,m. - o, o St M#

9 Y*

p*- ( *e W

2 %

.,. E * :* g' Fy ." n si o, n u n, O. p

n

( p O f3 re 4 l *i p. n H r

L16 H

n. f. V P' M ft l dkU '[ " O N' n L r + g 41 3 I {, p p rn 89 ft) H 6ja; o ,U.,.p eo.fu 4 O e M. r. H# 'e F no sk rea O u o + (. .] %, O r H 4. > l' = Da orj H of s N 'r.i (a l 1'. to o (s 'E l 61, w P.. "J: $4 t p W O L. . v r,. ' Hs o c.e-D P W w > .o..n > rb.; s

m..

ld, d >* \\C r 8 H 't ha P* R e [v+ ore ~ o. o -3 or,- e e 08" gl,_;

f.,',.n

,4 ag# n H -a g g,. P {} h 3 y ,Ro T. 1. g i., E.

34 L',.

a e m, .. a n o. -e s,. . y n; g il o -. o s. 's-a r - r.: H k ) J) H O (a v .$.,.}1 0 9 M r*

f c r k', e r+ La (,

e t< a e- ( g , a v v o p: r8 L. g q 9 " "8 E, Y.; EE YJ n t.., g /> se er P 7. f,i e Pi, E li o, f-8 UE S n Y p %. er i l s. o o EE8 E o "- E E p (D 9 C' (.s 'n 4*' >o M, f, f >; m... >C ~ o a n "' F e-11 P n sC" E. o o .n s jt+ fa b) M>^ }*-. V V* O t. >=- 6-G

fT: 0 MR?:

K t".9 .',h il. gh .".igO n 2 p; 2 S; s L< c.* o , r. v r* &4 }e e %l % I;! lN m a

i.,

M j!'l y1 F d, 4,1, e b P 'l J >-5 9 O

il i1i 1)' jl l e ne a s: p va r i ev i s eh m el e t e 0 y o tl r en r f 0 ,y hl r aaoyr a i ao 1 sl 6pr f m f al c i d t 2 en d mi oerli a an l oa ooe d et rpaf d o 0 t mr hch e n esk t if 0 ami t t n d etSAag l o t t o 0 i ov o rn i n s n 2 rca nt r m pa C i k eey a h e o r es .Le ot Ods l s tt t s vd vdf e e ei v l s ee t nis t o o drl dut ms e s neun d n i n non ,ud d aeohl ast o awe ss r riti e S t rn i ,m rsa e f t d v E2 n soe t a u oad 2 e es c u td r s n .b oeu e a. IC m l na l aet neacd s on l tl cahe CN u t er o d s s ert ol i osifdt c sst s sn saSi u t sol a o i ) t ei. t o I d n .t e uc CM r4,o n s r f g ,l a c ennt eo I ar o eihl ndac t siviagh e F n vi .iyr tltt i E s: o eiiyicclhnsh r e. t t c ai t nah rirl DD at a t e i f o aib N c a i( nir s: f wf oft pi oJsA rt i t oti tl ot ot i s pl c l e in OF oe it uaiees a ve o c c yn eca n ynd yncd crl a eh n I e i cosral o c acoenf a t wd1 t ot T l f amd t fo a h. m a m d I of rs e1 ic AT e i r rr mn. i t r r i uwnut oeht C M nt e i l ut ott o u +iuf hytd ] E f a cs cut c s s 2. r coecsdiyeehhia l t s neil lf F5 e ATr1ceen.T0t e e o ch+ ce If D 4 soe Att aTnwtTvTwd vis S L. 5 'A / X O@ f A 12 3h B. ) } ) ) )) )) i 3 4 1 2 T O' de "J t X a d F s W re t T t A e C l 1 I ?7 F 57-I W7k I A 71 E Q im I. 71 i 2 E211 E I' TAC I l F a I i X tn ( eq F e O S 8 y t G ) s c / y e F t T G O

174 EETC tIPTION OF ESvTraENT OuEPMILITY F5(IFgD] E{PMENT DESCRIPTION & MAFK NO. P.O. KA-k22 /lb22 Loss,of Coolant Accident,,(IOCAl gas cf Cmlar.t ' ler.t (i,0CA) Triarial Cable (Loston Ir.aclated Wire & Catle) 230 F 0 m 30 min 120 days @ 150*r ~ ~ ~ ' ~ ' Reduce from 2300F NGA-72 Triaz to 150 F 30 to (0 min 150 F >fC min OPERAEIUTY DEWt.STFJTED(2) 0

==-~~--- - Jacket: Hypalon Bed ace f:w 45 to Ma_of, Coolant Accident forg) Insalation: Cross-linked Polyethylene O psig 30 to to min 0 psig 7to min 13 days e 252 F 7 rads (1) 17 days @ 200 F 7.2 x 10 Inside and Outside Contairment Spray: 04 hr. Solution of toric Post IDCA therr.1 agir4 is acid (2,0CO-2100 ppm boron) b Jfered equivalent to 2.1 years @ 150 F to a pH rf 8.5 to 11 with NaOH.T k hr Similar solation with a pH of 7 to 9 g?Acr_qJIRg Et reTaired ENVIRONNENT((ICH F4UIP. IS_qlALIFIED LOCA Irradiated to 2 x 10 rada 300 F @ c0 psig 0 to 15 min 0 Redme to 252 F @ Ici psig 15 to 45 min 252*F @ 16 psig b5 min to 13 day Spray: Throughout 13 day period. A sol tion of 2.000 ppa toric acid buffered to a pH of 8 to 8.5 with Na0B. Following above, an additiaral 17 days exposare to 200 F @ 0 psig. O

.. ~... .-~ 15 Q'JtLIUCATION OFJICIE.WlES EAM & QMLIII_CA_IIg g g I lF CAf g _ Q g. Ap F m g p E m_03 -IDCA Inga LOCA Seq.wntial B.I.W.'s Engineering Coments A. reficiencies~~~ No. 2&x5-EP Fev. 4 ~ (speifically Test No. 75C008) qualification document does not address: l

1) Accuracy of variables and test data

- -[-)

2) Test monitoring sensors VI

3) Test facility k) 2750F at 30 min mark vs 280 F

5) 35 pig at 30 min mark vs b5 pig

6) pa of 8 to S.5 vs pi of 8.5 to 11 B.

Solutions

1) Accuracy of instrument even though not stated would caemanly be 11%.

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to emply with Industrial Standards for their type of applicatim.

3) Test facility, even thou6h not identified, could be determined Vendor's records.

4) 2750F at 30 min mark is within tolerance of the LOCt temperature transient profile FSAR Fig. 6.2-82 (Amerzhmet No. 65).

5) 35 psig at 30 min mark is within tolerance of the IDCA pressure transient profile FSAR Fig. 6.M3 (Ame L % No. 65).

6) The cable jacket is of a typalon material which wha shown to be resistant to all diluted alkaline selutions. Therefore, we believe that since the IOCA spray is in the rarge of a diluted alkaline solution it should have no signit-leant effect on the cable.

I l

I Is M C 0.P B (t n ne s sc S a 0.O E i ul o d l e C n P i.V e at l 3 M t: t A a i n oM 2 )e C. b C .a C d np / c 4 M 0 P/ l ol F i Ca 1 w k G ts rn 0 eO i o r4 I d s A m e s W C G a 3 C l t a i i M n n e t k a e H J i d e M n a m P t e o 1 .n l T y r N e a .O t c n i y n l g e ne J o,2 S dt f IA I o rg D O HMt aE7 OtB41tREL U p p i acp. oe55oe5o 0r 2233 3 R 2R31R2r2re C v f o.O f i r 2 p ia@ya 1613 4 i Se41i5 bad A I' d 0 dUs r Hfda soap ngp 2555 c1s 0 d. c3s03cd R 45 c %s c 1a f e y xi cs 4 c. ? e 1 i1 O r(: 1 s g f P Hp F 7' 4 F O1e c E gpei 0e o I F3 !p F Fa4 B 7 > d,2 e t //// / t /e/st/d t n tp C 00 if Ff T O2b9 1po 7 lio7afed E t4 0 - 7 gr r C I eo o 395 1s 0tlg 0yoda N o t0k o o o G bn p 3i3 o3 3 r y T ho0 r m = o 39ot sppp g b p bp p t s 9 r - ba l 1 ri iss s p c s lp cse7o T a2rd k 2 a O 1on giii s iks 0ir a O S 1 s 5 3 n F d.1 n a ggg i / og / oa5 V mH0ol c F gOi Fg id. t a o g ip0S( 0 t J y au F dy 2 i i l) ? A X ss sx5 lop u c { p I l erty 0 C a fp i t c I J rr o 1 0 H r i iarf 07 odio 0 E s.8 o t3 0a3 O a g b n 00 00 e Q o5c t t n n .d i c r r j e a l ro mt omt o t t a3 a 3 utof io io ec1 d 0 0( d Tdi s .P ton)o o n 3n.tO O 3 i t, n L o dd o1 1 a I n1 r m m C tt a 11St555a5350 0 n S i m im aoby

4) 1 o

n d vw c i n i r ) A l h hhhdhhms t Q ii n n 2.1 J p dhhr8rrr rrie o a fe arr 1 ne g M' tt ah 5er y thaaa0tt 1 e L x ri ttornnc oott 0 d I a aeo too dd4s oo F 1 dd o 1 e55 s a I 01 k11 551c 35 e t D 0vs 3 5 0 hh c gc 1d h mm rrhm r tl ahr iis ri arha dy r nne n da t a e .& dNi y sao t mn o i of tP 2 L C gO p W L oo 7 o J o s s i s 2t d s s n p N 3 a A 1I y o o j s f I Y f I di L 8 L aA 9 C I C _g y o st 2 o N 9 oo f h 1 l 1 l se 2 a W Y a

~

r a n r g 1a F t 3 t 50l A W F A I c W c E Fa c c E 6 i i C i d d L e T e s n O T r t M ( s t D ( L L T C ) C O C. / A ) ) va l l u e m nt

y s: lr s o g e en r ,c i d s sov d e ec a a l l h b td t a al s i iu t r r ron t a aw e v,m s v u eo d dd r d n ne t a as s u S t s n l E S-n a aei IN e t tr C O-r. a ad h e DT t d dd t I c a i$ I" o t t wl CL d s st t I C e eo e FS n t tndf E o ao LD

i f

fh m y t o og s NC r a u ne O c y n: yo e i I r-r i c o ch ec e T i f a i at b a ? A! c i r t r r CO i l u u un eu II f a c l ce vc FF e u c o cv ac I. P D Q A E Aeha I A AO C U? O QA L A, ) ) 1 B 1 yro t 6 a tO ro t k a 4 L 0 h 17 6 c a r t a n T e T s I r In e g e r __ C E n p / a ? e it P t r u n pi v o I ti% N t u t O I s r S c n3 a T I 0 l s A ar an C nF I i o r F lt i T I k r t L A no i E A C ap d E O re d E f r, L FF A I NO IT AC I F I LA Q" l F a C i t F n E eu T J J T qe IF L S G

l, E /y 'l 't T T e 9 5 5555 0, P ' _. ' ~ i yyyy .r I~ hhhh neen a. a mv in ???? g 'l l61 g, eau ~o e 'sla = = lh Y E E l r r 2 g o >k 8 h E E k l3 h!$ E I' E f> ! .: [ g

a- [

W 6 g u t,mEnc ; nag m. 4.-- y a a -> y y egn w -e,, e a s a " r n a a.: r g a 2 " 8. E. " " - P-o 3 [- g W d W P, n w & S, 8 F !g A o I n NRM- [ lgg e 25; FEl.l f lLl. E E t I f J I "H b8 in

EE E B d

r -s s g a IE e r r r a ni r w rp B s a y n l;,

b E"

B n l' Q

bdel # Type Tf2V 2. High ambient moisture content - l 10 + F satarated steam,1005 RH for Chiller rm Service bldg. duration of steam discharEe 30 minutes. GPERAEILITY DDONSTRATED i 70 to 10+ F Motors and pumps will keep temperature above None 70cF. ENVIRO!CCiT TO Wif!CH EQUIP, IS 4KLIFIED Normal _Environner:t )GLB i_n T_u_r_b..i.r.e.. bldg. H1 h ambient temperature 211 F 1. 6 at saturated atmosphere ACCURA _C_Y F_GQPpFLTS Normal _Fgyironmen_t None lOi+0F O 17b QUALIFICATION DEFICIE!CIES , MANNER CT (JLLyICAROM g,%LIFICATION_Doci g AND RIr0tNENDED_SOLifrI_0NS K B in.Tw biye bldg. gQin_Turbineid. MSLB in Turbine bldg. 6 Vendor reply to TLX inquiry TLI 3-28 John Anderson to J.E. Krechting A. Deficiencies - 1. High ambient teeperature 2110F Hormal_ Environment Norma 1, Environment 2. Saturated atmosphere Industrial Standards Specification NAS-427 B. Solutions : O IEEE ll2A 0 Substitute EPT liner to withstand 310 F ANSI B3. 15 ANSI B3. 16 ASME PTC 8.2 There are three possible solutions as discussed below; NEMA h01 a. Inclaie the chiller room inside the control rocun pressure boundary and eliminate its communication with the turbine building. D is involves determining if the compressed air system is adeqtate to maintain pressere with the chiller room included. Additional ductir4 must be added to provide cooling to the chiller room. Structural modificatkms to block openings to turbine building and modify openings to turbine buildirg and modify door to be a pressare barrier. b. Replace unqualified equipnent with qualified equipment. c. Use equi]rumt ha unaffected unit to maintain control rean p envirereent. g '%./ Nomal Envirorm:ent None I i 1 1 16a MUI.P_'cL'_r _ DES._CR_IPTTO'I & MARK N.,O. DECCEIPTIO,N OF__EF_iT_ROKMENT _-,OPER_A 5IL. I.T.Y._R.Q= U.IR.C. C._iT_S ---nn . = .= = - - ~ - P.O. NAQ/12% LOCA LOCA Centrif9 1 Fans - Buffalo Edrge 'do. ' l. Radiation zone IV k0 yr dose + 1.04 x 1M rada 1-HV-F-kOA, B LOCA dose = 880 + lto = lOi+0 rada 2-HV-F-360A, B Normal Favironment _ _No.rm_.a.l__En_v_iro.nment. o 0 50 F to 120 F area has temperstare monitors OF;EEA_B3 TTY,EEMrriSTRAg Aaxiliary L1dg. QRR_OAiENT TO V;fICH_f4UIP. IS QUA,LIFIED

LOCA, 4

LOCA 7x 10 rads Radiation dose of 7 x 10 reda No_rnal_En_vironment Normal Environment 50 to 120 F t0 M ACCLTaCY REQUIRDE_rm, m-Not reqaired O E S, S 1 !Cg I 8 I ET LU OL I O t FS n E a DDE N T_ o T J_ O r I i CW v A n E I FE l I a L A e m e UM A c n r n o o o a QA L N N N re h c W n 3 e 0 3 h M q S S D P, 4 m r G Wr o n i r o I Nh t i i I v t A - c n a C 9e E c 1 2 r i J - K l f I 3. a i L A n c 4, c X E. r e o L o p 3 L TJ N S yr iuqn Oj i Q XLT d t r { o r i l t P i I m w: L y n a A l o t p r S M e i r v l n aI d. 'r E_ s iCrM EC 1 t o 9 dM s A d. uA r 8O e nE L V E IN O O l?sc 6dM!UE9IPTI 33_,IM.K_J. IMPTION_OF _EINIROT43 0.P W J E ITY PITu_7f M M P.O. NA 201/1201 LOCA I4L" l-HV-F-71A B 1. Radiation W yr dose - 1 x 10 rada 1 x 10" rada 2-HV-F-71A, B Normal Environcaent Normal Enviro:nnent Axial Flow Fana-Joy Mfg. Co. 70 F to 120 F 70% to 120 F area has temperatare monitors O_MAEILITY IDt)NSTM, TION ENVIRO?CC T TlO m'iICH GITIP. IS_@AL_IFI@ LCfA LOCA None Model#t40263-5533 Nr.e Norral Environment o Safe 6 e rds tidg. 70 F to 120 P NC N 1_Env!rocmeg 120 F A,CCTnACY FIQUIRDENTS Not Beqaired O t i l 1 16b l i QUALIFICATION IEFICIENCIES - 1 M OF QOLI F @ ygg q"=JLLIFICATION DOCUFEIT AND RECoreEEDED SOLUTIONS L _OCA L_O_CA None Bone Deficiencies i Equipment not qualified for exposure to: 6 1. Radiation - 1 x 10 rads Ngmal E vi,wy,nt Normal EmrironmJe l 3 _ I Icdustrial Standard Specificatioi #NAS-219 Solutions: KD% Mll Peplace drivers with qualified motors j Replace motors have been purchased capable of withstanding the radiation done D of 1 x LO reds. Norm l Environment None \\ l I MC o e e.P PPR Q n oo d n l n a.O s e nyec i d lest t P e c aroE D-Nt larA C 5 r f_ t o 5aoiC3 T n 3l noo1 t enn3 D a pI t/ E o n T_ C n 1 - a1 S i l.c n e i3 C m y r R e s mom 3 I n u iNe D t l nan T f aXt I o l_ O n E R e b l l e o_ c c_ t M k_ r A _i s i HL ca _ l 3 1 + BS T i 223222222 R kT SI F 3Ot B.112L h ai 990397335 a S oe5503 $ kaaS .k S* 1tR2 L E 4 ao cp e55oe& o E 01 f' l e n T30) 2 d F F F F F M5 23 V xp d 000 1 hp ir 2 d 0 d s S l' 05 a r g 3 00 0 0 1uf C F%et soap 0 0 C oida _i I xpsF5cY _s R r e FFF a T 1i sFFF a x ri

a N

0gpei i ro(y t eo l i ei 0e o I 7 e g t sf2= 1 6 f P dn o if e i.8 W 0 0 f Ff T a Ur 1 tb g @d@@@9@@@

n gr a

s r r C I a o s O o o o O p0oa i _L T d m m5 t r m m o N s r r ig 7o g Eh54b54A2 2 a i 2o a l T 4 i lt1 d k 2 gp. n 7 7 t. 937555 5 O 5 n ao0k a 5 S .a O m7 3 r F oop1 e r 0 f 0 p p 5ppp x W t M i 1 h ( 0 sp spp sss i B s1p o 1 E rfri9 0 isisepiii 1 I r o.p u ) c V A N r 0 F gigiieggg 0 C e l0ar c !i 2 a0 g gg i 7 _H a a s L3 t f g 7 k twt d e i K O0 p o r q iios e X ap r a 4t 3 OD 20 0.' 3 O n E 0o0 O (M otr-hm m ri 7 115 4 2 Q t 3 O h nhol t 0 .t JI t tt S nu tC n 4 50 Oo0 .P yst omoo M ia i wN)t o t t ( T tt5 t u rio i i mo o I h ttoo tt to n 3nt 2 ) tC o 3i O r oo t ooo n I d c 0 o h.tibn 0,t 3 C 15o 3 i S o c m u o 0 A 310 1960 s m Es m mi a fo m ) 05 m4200 e m i in ff i m m mi 0 a i n n 7Se n i i mminm sse n erb n n iin iseec L tyeo nn reec I oodr . c F m i Ig 9 itco h A ep =O 1 g 6m P 1 O e C qo rP 2 2 t C s .V E 0 E J' it R E s' r i v P A d A e B a N aL I y y E q lO / T' eC C I u L s s L nA / I I i T 1 r P t 2I T A e t 5 Y 5 Y d 1 0 th 5 U oe 0 E 5 R mD 0 F F I r F R 4m 0 F" y D 2a g? E 9l ES 1 1 N da 9 T -R 9 3 yi A y f ag 0 a sn t T 1s g @g r F. D i -( 5 ]2 0 F l l jlI 1ljll llll; l4l llllllli 19 QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES MANNER OF Q!JALIFICATION QUALIFICATION DOCJG3T AND FJrOttGNDED SOLUTIONS Canar Corp. Test Test Beport IPS-lJ7 Qualification document does not address:

1) Accuracy of variables and test data Conas letter "qualifiestion of

2) Test monitoring sensors, retention Electric Penetrations" of records (i.e. traceability of No. IPS-bll, P/N 7290-10001-01, instrumentation)

IPS-369 IPS-325 dated 1/5/80

3) Test facility b) Test solution - 1,900 ppa boron

{ vs 2,000-2100 Letters frtsn Union Carbide, Witas, g, J., dated 12/19/67, Solution _s 5ew Jersey, dated 1/22/68

1) Acecracy of test data and variables even though not addressed would mly have been sade with instruments having accuracies of 11%.

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not addressed can be assumed to be of typical types

3) Test facility could be determined from vendor records.

h) The teminal block is of a polysulfone caterial which has been shown to be resistant to all diluted alkaline Test solutions. Therefore, we believe that since the IACA spray is in the range of a diluted alkaline solution, it should have no significant effect on the terminal blocks. 20e QQIENT DECRIPTION & MILRK NO. LEOCRIM310F EWIBO9CT O_PERAEIL!TY FqqEDEN""g Specification NAs-90-22 LOCA & set.B P.O. No. KAj 33/13J Loss _of Coolant Accident, _(LOCA) ' ~ ~ ~~ 230T O to 30 min 120 days @ 150 F Level transmitters Reduce from 280 F Gems #XM-29400 to 150 F 30 to to sia LT-RS15u. B 150"F 3*to sin CPERAEILITY DDGS"TiATED LT-ES25M. B h5 peig O to 30 min ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~" Bedace from h5 LOCA & E LB Gems Sensor Divisian to O psig 30 to tO min Delaval Turbine O psig > to min After test, transmitter functiord 7.2 x 10I rada (1) properly. Nanufacturer's normal Inside Con *ainment environmart is rated to 3004. Spray - O to 4 hours solution of boric acid (2000-2100 ppm boran) buffered to AMrACY REIIFIMFA] a pii of 8.5 to 11.0 with NaOH. beyond k hours similar solution with a 7 to 9 LOCA & ELE Main St_eam. _.Li_ne_.B..r.e.s. _t _(E.. LE..-) t 5% of range 290 F 2 to 60 min _ACC_"uTA__CY_ _DD_GS_TR_AT_E_D_ k5 psig O to 30 min LOCA & ELS Bedr e from 45 to O psig 30 to to min 1.1% after test 0 ps 7 to sin 3 x 10 rsis k0 yr dose Eg@W4TO__gIgyf]f,.,I!.gMFIR Laca 53651 4 0 to 60 min 230-150 F > 60 to 130 min 1504 190 min to 14 days 45 psig 0 to 60 min 45 0 psig

to to 150 min 13.5 psig 150 min to 14 days 0

Radiation Exposure 2 x 10 rada Spray - 15,0C0 ppm boric acid buffered to a pli of 10.5 with NaOH sol dion for 4 hours. Spray density = 0.15 Epm per ft2, E_.LE_ As etce 20 QUALIFICATI0ft DEFICIEfCIIS PJL'fNER OF Q'.1ALIFICAT_IGT QUALIFICATI0ft DOCL q AND_RECOMNJ2.TE SOLUTIO]h Loch 3_53e Im 3 MLB Loch Test - Sequential Franklin Institute Radiation arx1 Environmental Research Labomtories Kone Exposure. Spray Exposure (FL%) Report F-C3834 performed on a seperste Isomedix Inc. Test instrument. Report dated Nov.1975.

S A.

Deficiencies: Test Temperature of 282 F is below j accident temperature of b30 F B. Solution: As measured by thermocouple en circuit board internal components reached qualification temperature 2820F only after 27 minute exposure to 450 F. Actual reg'd exposure at 0 4500F is 2 minutes, therefore, qualification is satisfactory, w v 21a MP_IMCBIM@ & %f_g (F y l M ON_ M y E Rg M _ OPMERm RF.6H_RDCTIS O to 35 m}in ~ -Q4CA LCCA & ELB NATO >bdel EA - 190 Loss of Coolant Accident Limit Switches 5800/ ~ ~ ~~ "- ' ~ ~ Located on the following Reduce from 230 F valve to close within 60 seco:xis of Control Valves to 50 F 30 to 60 min isolation sigral; switches shall not 153 7 00 min fail so as to reopen valves. TV-ED 100B, D, F Steam gen blowdown k5 reig 0 to 30 min TV-CC 1013 R.C.P. Thern tarrier Reduce fresa 45 ) TV-CC 102B, D. F R.C.P. Return header to O psig 30 to 60 min GPERABILM DFMotiSTRAITD >to ain " M % L3 TV-CC 105A, B, C Cont. Recire Air Coils O psig 7 ~ TV-DA 100B React cont s ap pp diach 7.2 x 10 rads (l) Liiit suitchs shown to operate TV-DG 1003 Pri Drn. Efer pp disch Spray: 0-4 hrs solution of toric acid after sequential testing. TV-RM 1000 Limit av on tv ra 100C (2000-2100 pga boron) buffered a pii TV-VG 1008 Pri drn afer tk vent of 8.5 to 11 with NaOid hr similar TV-SS 100A Pressure liquid space solution with a Tri of 7 to 9 TV-SS 101A Pressure vapor space ACCURACYE3UIREMENTS TV-SS 102A Primary coolant cold leg Main _St_eam Line Break,(MLLB) sus Q iTfea " - ~ TV-SS 10l+A Press. relief tank gas sp 430 F 0 to 2 min 0 TV-SS lorA Primary coolant hat leg 230W 2 to (4 min TV-SS ll2A St gen surface sample 150w > 00 min 45 psig 0 to 30 min TV-BD 200B, D, P Steam gen blowdown Reduce from 45 TV-CC 201B R.C.P. Thern barrier to O psig 30 to do sin TV-CC 202B, D, F R.C.P. Return header O psig y t:0 min 7 rada TV-CC 205A, B, C Cor.t. Recirc Air Coils 3 m 10 TV-DA 2003 React cont s e p pp disch TV-DG 200B Pri drn. Ifer pp disch ENVIRGICCfr TO WHICH M'nP. IS Cda_LIFIED TV-RM 200C Limit sv on tv ra 20CC El TV-VG 20CB Pri drn xfer tk vent A TV-SS 2004 Pressure liquid space Heat aging a 200 F for 200 hrs, mechanical TV-SS 201A Pressure vapor space aging 100,000 cycles under electrical load TV-SS 202A Primary coolant cold leg TV-SS 203.A Press relief tank gas sp 3400F 0 to 3 hr TV-SS 20rA Primary Coolant hot Leg Reduce from 3 d TV-SS 212A St gen surface assple to 1200F 3 to 5 hr 5%UENCE REPEATED Inside Contalment 250 F to 3.5 days 2OfF 3.5 to 30 days 70 pai O to 8 hrs 10 psi S hrs to 30 days Radiation Exposure 2.Ok z 1[ rada Spray: Boric acid and water buffered to a pil of 10-11 with NsGi solution for 4 1 days, water spray for 26 days, spray density =.015 gpa/ft ME5B Maxim m surface temperature is 205 F per ESG calculation 11712-ES-197-0 dated 3-16-78 and is well below g alification temperat re Ra.iiation Exposure see LOCA Test. I 21 i Q'MICATIN DUICIDCIES

- " # S*""

TMIJICATI@ DOCTM AND RIrO+33 RED SOLiqTS LOCA. _LO_C_A_ Sequential Test Peport Entitled:

1) Accuracy of variables and test data

" Qualification of NA2 controls limit switch Mode EA-190 to IEEE

2) Test monitorir4 sensors Standards 3Ms ('75) 323 (*74)

3) Test racility and 382 ('72)"

dated 3-3-78 and revised 4-7-78 3. solutions:

1) Accursey of instrument even though not stated would commonly be t1%

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to comply with Industrial Standards for their type of application ELB PGLB

3) Test facility, even though not identified, could be determined Calculatica ESG Calculation llT12-ES-197-0 fro:t vendor's records.

dated 3-16-78 <:,.{ :<<.

e

a E C C L1 G N U R E!rb '.a

'A g b bbbbb cn. s xae u %ee A e h C o -D Irj j 5: go N a a a. f { f.!N M I i-mn>a w e - y w" ~, r l, T.{%,o 4 g % s ii. n.. - ,.3 I D U,- i a 6. n

al 1

e i 5 g ~l gr M g vr 1 u l: 5 %?., tj h. -,1l p> r ~ n '~ g ~ ~ o g n t. p ~* g T.* ) 5 e 8 8 i ,3 a [#] 0 j,? h gE 4 0 0 ED 3 l% I on y [3 CdW~E r; g *: u e" ? B~81 ?; y %3 9 <6 ? 2 m t,. 8 l T, Sg aLG a 3 ~ u e a \\ n.

r o

n p o, y j ag ,qgc= I -l i m Ef h *,j k 2* U M C 4) O M C ~ !,?) .8 D M N W I lb N N k h o W ? % 4 )' E 3 8 ~. $ 'u e $8 9 4 3 s P m ~ w e n .c, ~ o 4 r g .4 ~ E ri o C F q' c n n 8 d de 5-8 d 2 s ,1 f a S l"a n r E o at m e g. a s w w a m 2 .tj 3 El 9 d C. L f i a M u e U-e s. 1: 1: o l l l l l i i 1. 22 QUALIFICATION DEFICI E IES FANNER OF QUALIFICATION QUALIFICATION DOCUMEltT AND RECOb? ENDED EOLUTIONS [ Test LOCA LOCA Klocir.ner-hoeller Letter dated A. Deficiencies: Nor m l Environment 3/16/79 i Qualification document is in letter Industrial Standards Norm 1 Environment form (i.e. no foral test report with NEMA ICS(19%) approved signature arri date) and does Sect. 1-106. Specification NAS-213 not address:

1) Accuracy of variables and test data

2) Test umitoring sensors

].

3) Test facility I

B. Solutions:

1) Accuracy of instruments even thou6h not stated would commmly be t1%.

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to comply with Industrial Standards for their type of application.

3) Ihe letter is a smwary of the radia-tion exposure test successfully completed on sample electrical components

[ used in the listed ICC's. Certified data is available from Klockner-Meeller Corp. Fairfield, NJ. Norm l Environmnt L A.. Deficiencies: Norm 1 abmient temperature may exceed BCC mximum operaticnal temperature. L E. Solution: Area is equipped with an ambient temperature monitor that will signal at 101 F and alarm at 10+oF. l l I i ( I l t I I l l l I 23a I g'IPMENT DESG IPTION & MABK NO. {ESCRMON OF ENV! eof;'ENT OPLRAhTLITY REQJIFggTr; Motor Operated Valves Loss of Coolant _ Accident _(LOCA) LOCA LLaitorque Corp P.O. No. 194/1194_, Flanged a Wafer Type _ 5.4 x 10' rads Batterfly Valves 5.4 x 10 rada (based on 120 day LOCA) inc141ng D the 40 yr dose. l'.o_rmal Env. irarm.- _t MOV-SW-20"A. B Normal Environment 120 F MOJ-SW-113A, B 0 (Ca.rpanent Cooling Heat Exenan6er Iso. ) 50 to 120 F OPERABILITY DEMONSTRATED Model SMB-0015 ENVIRONMENT TO WHICH EQUIP. IS QUALIF_IED J_ACA MOV-W-213A, B 0 (Fuel Pool Cooler Isolation) MCA 2 x 10 rads Model SMB-000-2 g Auxiliary Bldg. 40 yr integrated - 2 x 10 rads Normal Environmeg MOV-SW-lO3A,B.C.D Normal Enviror.mer.t 120"F continmus MOV-S'4-203A, B,C, D - ~ ~" ~ ' ' - ' ~ ~ MOV-W-lOLA, B,C,D 120 F continnoca f.CCL' RACY REQ'TIREMENTS MOV-SW-204A,3,C,D (Recire. Spray Seat Exch. ISO) Not required Q.S.P.H O i n. ..c~. .. - -.. ~.... 23 TJALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES M m OF E M ECAE @, QLIFICATION_ DOC'HCfT Ard EEC34rCED SOMMS 2 LocA LocA LocA 2.0 x 10 rods seurs radiat. ion Limitorque at Isomedix. Inc. Parsippany, NJ. Report No. 20003 None Dornal Environment Normal Environment Nornal Environment Industrial Standard Limitorque VLVC0 USAS Nuclear Qualification None for Safety O Related Services Nqus n/1/79 9 Y O -e l 23c EQi!I_MCiT DESCRIPTION & MAEK NO. DESC,RIMION OF ETri!Rn'CF,5T C,PErAh!LITY EDJIFDENTS = -=n-r-w-==- P.O. No. 2k2 /12k2, S.S. Valves 2 1/2" and larger, Limitorque Corp. Lo.sa. of Coolan,t, Accident _(LOCA) WA SOV-QS-101A, E, C, D LOCA HTi-QS-201A, B, C, D 1.Ok a 10' rada 6 (Contairament Iso. ) 1 x 10 rada (based on 120 days LOCA). In addition, tr.e k0 year radiation Nornal Enviraranent dose of k x 10" rada must be MOV-RS-155A, B considered for a total possible 120 F MOV-ES-255A, B radiation dose of 1.04 x 106 rada. l (Containment Iso. Suetion) OpAEILITY EDONSTEATED l Model De-0-7-1/2" Norsal Envir<uunent l urA ElV-RS-1/A, B 70 to 120 F g MOV-RS-2$rA, B 2 x 10 rada (Containment Iso. Suction) ENVIRONMENT TO EiICH F4'~TIP. IS Q';ALIFIED ~ N_o_rc_al_ _En_v_ir_o_nm_ent Safeguards Building - ~ ~ 120 F continuous 0 40 yr integrated - 2 x 10 rada Npram,1 Environment, ACC'mACY KEqJITNT 120 F continuous Not required O 23b QUALIFICATI0tt DEFICID.*CIES N E Q M IFICATIOJ (MLIFICATION DOCLHENT AND_ N _SC,LL30]h L.O_CA_ L_O.C. A. 0 Limitorque 2.0 x 10 reds ga:ms radiation Peport No. E0003 None at Isomedix, Inc. Parsippany, NJ E0"*1_92 F0Fvj N y _1 _ Environment 1 r Limitorque VLYCO None Ind::strial Standard USAS Nuclear Qalification for Safety V Related Services MQDS 11/1/79 23e I R q @ TJ ESgt M @iS_E q,Ij0. (FSCRIPTION OF ENIROliMEiT QPERAEILITY__EE(fI3 CJ S gq ptoys Loss of, Coolant Accident (IDCA.) LOC.A_ 6 T.O. No. 127/1127 Recirculation Spray 1 x 10 rada (tesed on 120 days 1.0% x 106 rads Pa:ps, General Electric LOCA). In addition, the LO year radiation dose of k x 1 r rads Norma _1 Environaeg 1-RS-P-2A, B mat be considered for a total 2-RS-P-2A, B poss}tle radiation dose of 1.0i6 1200F x 10" rada. Model 5K6328IC20.A Normal Environment _ ORAEILITY DFJtCaiSTEATED Safegards Building 0 70 to 120 F IDCA Class IE redundant ventilation system 1 x 10 rads ENVIRONMENT TO WICH_ EQUIP. IS gJALIFIU) .N.o_rmal__En_vironment 1 x 100 rada ACCEACY REQUIREMEN_T_3 Normal _Envirorment Not required 120 F O l + 23d QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES $ NNER OF Q"ALIFI Q Q Q g IFICATION DnCif g AND RECO4GNDED SQLi31T 0NS LOCA LOCA Unknown Letter from Vendor C. Bell (GE) March 10. L'Il9 A. Defielencies_: Qualification doceent is in letter Specification NAS#W form (i.e. no formal test report with ( Norm l Environment approved signature and date) and does not address: Indostrial Standards No_rmal Environnent 1. Accuracy of variables and test data 2. Test monitoring sensors Specification NAS-W 3. Test facility 1GRA E1 & IEEE 112A B. Solutions : 1. Accuracy of instrument even though not stated would coemrely be ill. 2. Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to coeply with Industrial Standards for their type of application. 3. Test facility, even though not identified, could be determin=d from Vendor's recorA. Norml Envircreent Kone l

gg $

g. u y.k. 3' : S g4 a 8 o.0 p ~ 4 rv R 3 o [? : N" g [@ .... s s.4 g r

:: r.; " ".'.

3 '^ y W' pl 8 o ...~ 0" g.4 k s: < M (;; : b lJ' g ' h..O . :1 li'! R o ". $ ,$0 gEEES. !.n r. E E i E s 1 3 s e f $[j ' 4 4 g tK s: ,1 4 hd. k 4 F E w 0'!G "" T O U { f 7 '] 'E 'Q ? ".* N 9 "'.# o s'5 0 s "'", { 7,j R ;'n W u c :: $ $ ~ l1 :. !Q P.*8*3*1[g3-[8 d; t p,. a m. . c r yf.

@2r e se$ e c.'

w.1:7

'" ' R ~ ~r 2 'N h..,

. 8. s t

'.' L< E ** $8 e i I -4 in l 55 s5 k hokh 3 0 0 h g4 + s. I.,

a s, r e.l a

nsac e r n ta ~ ~ s

sgs_,

) i-i, 0 o.s., a i n; ..g. 2 .o 0:r - o x 9 ~ 5 ;.: s$"13 in tg 2 : f. g E c '. U-l~ 1 o n.g-w o.s o a 2 R s. ,.4 n r,. 8 -e ges n, g 2 cs sr m a o ok o P. o 4 .n ~ u S EbS u. !D c.1"i p f. N c a o W g 5.~ [ E.. [ n ti g'! E {-too M y g rW ~ g.. nsss y Eg!! sSww .a sene ymh nnn at l ys. ? CT is l*f 02g P if $1 ~ d 0:d R 2 e 2 W s 3

a q

w.= a .o .n E a ~m n e U( $ f, c A 4 e !r 4 "g' g $ !.Ij p.! i a" g .v. m .I lL,I g Ilg I c 1 ,o l O O .--..J 2k Ag"ALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES Q PAN or QUALIFICATION g LLIFICATIy g g y REC _OMMENDED SOLUTIrE;S, LOCA LOCA LOCA Penetretion assemblies were testad ty Conax regert " Maximum Emergency A. Deficienetese using a prototype with characteristics Environmental Test Peport for pertinerit to each individual type. Electrieel Penetration Assemblies"

1) M of chemical spray was 5 This was firet exposed to radiation No.

IPS-73.h dated 5/13/75 to 8 for duration, not 8.5 then pressure and temperature and to 11.0 for first h hr or finally chemical spray. Pediation Test almaras service 7.0 to 9.0 for reenirmier test canax report IPS-137.

2) Temperetare range was 1%O to 1700 from I hr to emi not 150D

3) No calibration information or instrument error range was given.

B. Colutions: 1) The electrical penetration i assemblies are fabricated from Conar letter "Q alification of the following non-metallie Electric Penetrations

meterials: polyimides and polysulfone.

These materials have teen shown to No. I PS-h11, P/N 7290-10001-01, te resistant to all dilut.d alkaline IPS-369. IFS-325 dated 1/5/80 solutions. Therefore we telieve that since the LOCA spray is in the range of a diluted alkaline solution it should have no significant effect on the penetration assemblies. 2) Very short duration of temp. below 1500 u+.en coegered to total test duration sakes this item acceptable.

3) Typical irstrument accursey can te cryeeted to be 21%, tolerance on the pressure and temperature curves used will altos for this accuracy.

) 6 I i w sn um m W RD ' f "o !!l v u$D lh Y he , s' 1 :c

fu e

~ [ *p a Bf!. ! 0

.4 k

E I K

rl g?-tr g.

<=r 3W D X F f, $ k l In g 3 $l4 48 3 I.3 s 1 !qs .s gu r-b 15 F o # ;'gI'*g s',h" i d , n $-{$ w; y n '0: F o g

50 "5 if E

"' i t nE 1 O i A [b. y- ~~ e-a %.r 3 ~3 a E. nx r a ? %' E 4 P o-.s g S I ld $'N h l3 4lE !? 5 -3 B '1

N

,q w -, L I Q i.9 6 M gd <x h O n y.e { O p w((g,, g - s o s s e 51 O NO g to c ro c se . wEs_c no 8rz -

b. z

- = m g c, (* (~ f P.,h g E (* ? f. D 8 g 3 f E e x b

P 6 Li; I

E J,. S F l5 ::d f6[j s o E r e y 2,5 y, .a n n I hj

R

j

.s" a ;; 8: a. x e,, t y in U k

s) a r.i s-b'

%Yg y

q l!El r

g .3 h Gr 9 O 25 QUALIFICATION DEICIENCIES WLMNER OF QUALITICATION SUALIFICATION _DCcJMDIT AND RECorC4 ENDED SOLUTIm3 MSI.B MSLB ELP Penetration assemblies were tested 1. CONAI Report " Maximum Emergency A. Deficiencies: by usirg a prototype with Environmental Test Report for characteristics pertinent to each F.lectrical Penetration Assentlies. *

1) Pressure excursion was maintained for individus1 type. This was first No. IPS-73.k dated May 13, 1975.

30 min duration not 60 min. ? exposed to radiaticri then pressere and temperature. 2. FSAR Appendix 3 C " Safety Related

2) During the text in QalificationDoement Egalpment Temperature Transients

1. no accuracy was stated for the During the Limited Phin Steam instruments used.

Line Ereak" and NBC Ccmuneet 7.17 of the same sabject. B. Solutier:s :

1) Pressure should have no significant effect on the splicing material.

Conax letter " qualification or

2) Typical instreent accuracy can be Electric Penetrations" expected to be il$, tolerances on No. IPS-3611, F/N 7280-10001-01, the pressure and temperature curves IPS-3t9, IPS-325 dated 1/580 used will allow for this accuracy.

1 2ca 61MLEE9I.UMMM23 ilESQiPTIOff_ogfiiggg 07sA3,{LjpgqgEns%g Itea 2 of 2 Loss of Coolant, Accident.ILOCA) Losa of Cociant Acc_ident_(LTA} P.O. No. I;A-313/1313 Sp12ces (Field and Factory) 230 F 0 to 30 min 120 days s l>O"F Fedre fra 2'iO F O Caaz Corp (S :pplier) to ISO F 30 to to min Kapton Ir. sala Lon 150*F > to ain OPEUSII.ITY DD40NSTMTE]' " ' ~ ' ~ ~ ~ - ' Inalde & Cutside Containment 45 peig O to 30 min hed re from 45 to Less of Coolant Accident (LOCAJ O psig 30 to 60 min O ps16 > 60 min 10 days @ 140 F k.2 x 107 rada (1) Epray: Post IK.A operations do not meet O to 4 hra solation of beric acid operability reqairemer.ta. (2.000-2100 p;xa Lore.) b Jfered to a pH of 8.5 to 11.0 with EaOH beyond 4 tra similar soletion with ACC'JEACY EFGJITN7S a pH of 7 to 9 Not reqaired EgBCM'MFNT TO WhTCH__F4^ CP, IS_qdLITTED LOCA 5f aJ - From 06 -2ho hr spray continuously with a solution of the following contents; baron content =.23 aclar (1,900 PPM) NaOH content = 10-4 to 4 x 10 2 IO1A1 is! = 7.7 to 7.8 2% F @ L5+ psig O to 30 vin Bed xe from 4') to O peig 30 to fs0 min Bed x e from 290"F to 144 F Raised from 140 F 30 to t>0 min 0 150 F 1 to 240 hra 10 x 107 rads gm radiatio.gminh 26 MANNER OF QUALIFICATION QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES QUALIFICATION DOC'JM 3T 8 AND RFC0!44 ENDED _SOLL_"r_IO_N_S LOCA ~~ LOCA LOCA Cor:ax Report " Test Procedure and ~ Splices were nede using various Report on Electrical Terminations A. Deficiencies-representative cable types and sizes Subjected to Design Fasis Accident which had teen attaebed to a prototypa Envircoment " 50 IPS-107 dated

1) Chemical spray solution had penetration essembly. The prototype was first subjected to radiation pH of 7.7 to 7,8 not 8.5 to 11.0 for first is br, exposure, then temperature, pressure Radiaction: Alraras service Test

2) Temperature below 150* to 13:0"+

armi chemical spray concurrently. Canax Report Ti

37 on various occasions darirg test

/""]

3) The instruments and/or monitors used were not identified, also accurney or error range was not stated.

b) Time, temperature envelope not adequate Conar letter

Qualification of B.

Solutions: Electric Fenetrations" No. IPS-411 P/M 7280-10001 41, 1) The Penetration splicing material IPS-3t9, IPS-325 dated 1/5/80 is a }clyolefin naterial which has been nhown to be resistant to all diluted alkaline solutions. Therefore we believe that since the IOCA sprey is in the range of a diluted alkaline solution it should have no significant effect on the splice material.

2) Overall temp was within test tolerances,

3) Typical instrument accuracy can be erlected to te fl%, tolerance on the pressure and temp. eurves will allow for this accurney, h) Tha splices are qualified fer 120 days @ 150DF per Cenar letter

[sj " Qualification of Electrieel () Penetratie-r," fio. IPS-hil, F/K 72 O-A 10001-01, IPS-369. IIS-325, dated 1/5/80. I KC IPFP F nao t ee. ( Fenm sp n p m e e.O 2 it a d o. i2roK z l t t M er C c ara &Io eot N nr sfiC3 T Oap (2nr3oo1 mD us. f st ! tl E sa i a1 _S C it( e ~- i3 dis l n1 ,3 eoa d C=3 I np Ce m_I"I C p a M" n ~ o l n t G n i d 'X t e E _N a r f l ) a e r' c c t t _H o - r _.A m.M r i t y c ) ~ a N l .O 2O%OthtR2thto a o a 3o a o a E 3 OtR4124M ,. L B EN oe55d3 a _E n n2 l t V 4p d 0O0i E 5p + t 5 e % e %? a 2 s'L C o1g 2g E I s O e p %F %n a O xip e5e R xi s E d3 g s20 O gp ei S .I f N 1 s g t ..I' 1 i4%1 1 0 4F4 g Fr V 0 if e mT .a 7 p 0 k f o E b g r m,I r O s 0 r m N o o T m r i F i* a g m 1 r L d 0 m d 5 n a 4 i 0 s ) 2 a e _F g 5 F W .L i Y = 3 F 0 I r V F N e _.I e _R O / ~t r E 40 3 O>2O( .W a31O6 3 21 0 Qy i0 0 0 000 r C .. E t4tt .N i tt tt t mt o o o I. mT amoom t oo o rio m h ti i o n 3ic 2) in33n e 32 3 0n4 o 00 0 0 I d ( nt t 4 m ,S o O m omao mi s s m mi m ic m in e g e m i in i2nc2 i n c i n n n A' n n4 i0 4 L m I h n F ar r IED L M A eP .L @ G 1 ,G Pi S C g o o Q2 _D _E t C as .V L 0 B U lt E R r R v d ._A .P e A aI _P a B E q C l Q y / _ C. Y eC c d s nA2/ I _.I _I 3 r F t 5I T K ta e t5 Q1 Y d 0 JF U oeF F 5 T r - 0 F 4m o g l 2a1 F L y g _I' C 9lA E T da _F _E f ag h g;i S yir _C i ans @g 2 i 1s ( 7 5 2 a 0 } F O I; ..m ..~._ _ m_ mm.. ,-_m-.,-._ _. m_ m m.. ..m_ ... _ m. _ _..,......... - m m ~....... .___m o ..m_.~._,....___. _m 27 QUALIFICATI0ET DEFICIENCIES EA>" TIS OF QUALIFICATION gLIFICATITI DOC'JMDrr AND FJr0MMENCED SOLUTIGIS_ MSLB MSLB MCLB Spitees were made on various 1. CONAI Peport " Test Procedure and A. Deficiencies : rM eesentative entle types and Report on Electrical Terminations sizes which had been attached to a Subjected to Design Easis Accident 1. Pressure excursion was naintained for prototype penetration assembly. The Environment

No. IPS-107 30 min durstion not f4 min prototype was first subjected to dated October 5,17/3.

rediation exposure, then te:cperature 2. The instruments and/or eitors used and pressure, concurrently. 2. FSAR Appendix 3C " Safety-Related were not identified in Qualification Equipment Temperature Transients Doctanent #1, also accurney or error i During the Limited Main Steam range was not stated. Line Break" aM NRC Corsnent 7.17 of the sem subject. A. Solutions: Conar letter " Qualification of 1. During the LOCA test the pressure was Electric Penetrations: No.IPS411, held for the req 1tred time period. P' N 72'30-10001-01, IPS-3*S, IPS-325 dated / 1/5/80. 2. Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to comply with Industrial Standards for their type of application. Typical instrument accuracy can be expecto,1 to be 21%. Tolerances on the pressure and temr-perature curves used will allow for this accuracy. n G s i 2Aa hi1Y881@D3E3-N 7 E IAN,OF_ENVIg{ g OPlE%PILIT_YRML'IFJJC.1 P.O. NA-355/1355 Loss of Coolant Accident (LOCA) -~'- 120 da;s @ 150 F Inside Fecire. Spray Pg Motor 200 F 0 to 30 min 0 General Electric - 300 hp. M4 v, Fed xe fra 200 F 1.15 S.F., Class H insulation. ISO"r 30 to w min OPERAEILITY DDGSTRA*E (2) Model: 5K6319XJIB 150i T M min ' ~ 45 peig O to 30 min 130 F - 750 days 1-RS-P-1A, B Reace from 45 1-RS-P-1A, B $O O pelg 30 to (4 min O psig > (4 min 7 rad (1) Inalde ContaLane=t 7.2 x 10 gp Spray: 0 to 4 hr solution of boric Not regaired acid (2000-2100 ppa toron) buffered to a pH of 8.5 to 11.0 with NaOH. beyomi 4 hrs similar solation with a pa of 7 to 9. @3 MET'lF4ICHTgIP _lSyW.IFIP 3 Loss _of Coolant _ Accident _(_IDCA) Pres _sure and_lemperature - 45 psig at 275-2600F frcus O-30 min. Pressare was U redaced to O psig at LOO F within next 30 min. During this to min. steam exposure motor was sprayed with ch*=ical solution at 20 gym. Motor was at full lead throughcut. Four cycles were run as descrited above, stopping motor tetween each cycle to tate readings. At the fifth cycle till end of 7 days, temp. reduced to 150 F at O psig aai spyed ccmtinuously with chemical solation. Badiation - Mogor was exposed to an equivalent,0 dose of 2 x 10 rada at a dose rate oft 0.5 x 10 rada/hr. Chemical _ Spray._- Spray continuously 0-7 days witn a water soldian of boric acid, lithium hytruzide, and solium hydroxide with the following concentrations: Loran - O.23 molar (as boric acid) Lithium hydroxide - 1.0 x IQ-4 molal 3 molal Sodia hydroxide - 1.0 x 10 "he moove will result in a pa of 5.5 to r..$ .n .n . - ~.. s 28 Q'.1ALIFICATION DEFICIENCIIS !GLWER OF QUALIFICATIGE QLIFICATION IOCLHFTr! AND P&OMMENDED SOLgI_ON,S LOCA IoCA LOCA Motor was tested negaentially by Topical Report on O.E. Vertical A. Defleiencies first subjecting it to t.he cumulative Induction Motors Inside Containment radiation dose and then the steam /- Recirculation Spray Pump Motors - 1. Accuracy not stated in test report chemical spray with elevated temperature surry power Ctation - Second for pressure and flow, and pressure. Addendum to Cover !! eat Aging, 2. No accuracy given for ar.y data Radiation Exposure, Vibration, gathering instruments used. Steam / Chemical Spray Exposure 3. T o t report is not dated on Qt:alification Tests - Docket Number signature page. 50-280 and 50-281 by M.W. Eheets, 4 Chemical spray pH levels in test Vertical Motor Products Sectim do not agree with design levels. fg 4 General Electric Company, 5 Temperature varied from 275-2900F. Sat Jose, California June 12,1973 (pages 36 to (A) B. Solutions: 1. The mettal max pressure taken fre [ the LOCA pressure transient profile (FSAR Fig. 2.4-1) is 36 psig. 45 psig i is a conservative value and the test pressure accuracy is considered to be within t9 psig. 2 Accuracy of instruments, even though not stated, would comonly be 110 3. Test report even though not dated i on signature page, is osted on cover sheet. 4 Lower EH levels (5.5 to 6.5) mintained during motor test have been reviewed with regard to motor sterials and it has been determined that the higber design pH levels would not have any additional effect. 5. Temperature variation of 275 F to 2WT falls within the tolerance (265-280 F) of the IoCA temperature trans - 0 ient profile (FSAR Fig. 2.4-2). P i i l l l l i 2ba [11MSEMGT1YEh3- [9I_E?_ CF_E{L?gM.] 9MhfdTUKWf@Q_ 1 P.O. K-355 /1355, _hain Steam Lir.e E:reak_(MS!JJ 120 daps d 1500F Inside Eectre. Spray P2=p % tor L30 F 0 to 2 min OPE:AEILITY EDONSDATC (2) Gaaral Eleetric - 300 tp, AfD v. 26CPF 2 to c4 mi.n 1.15 S.F., Class H itsdation, 150 F Pr4 min 130,F - 750 days Model: 51631 W 15 45 paig O to 30 min 1-RS-P-1A,5 Red xe from 45 AqJRACY_FnLTFj0ENTS_ 2-RS-P-1A,b to O peig 30 to to sin O psig ?60 min Not Eeqdred Irside Cor.tainment 3 x 107 rads 40 yr. dose EE@WlWF33?2-IS QLIFIED

1s_St**=lird 3reaa Mel Temperstare_- Motor na qalified to the design enviror. ment by analysis.

Pres _sa_e - See IDCA galification for this motor. Badiation - M*a na exposed to an ~k d dldt done of 2 x 163 rada at a e dose rate of 4 0.5 x 100 radfnr. O .e ~_ _ _____...__._.._.-___._._m ._.m m. m .m., 29 QtJALIF1 CATION DEFICIENCIES %g 0F QUALIFICATION glMIFICATION DOCUMENT g FR U4 MENDED sot #rIO'IS. NSLB MILB KILE The motor was qualified by utilizing 1. Final Safety Analysis Report - A. refi_e1encies: the IDCA qualification test results Section 3C. (pages 1 to 21) 1.e.. radiation exposure, ten:perature. 1. Accuracy not stated in test report pressure. A beat transfer calculation 2. Topical Report on GE Vertical for pressure. [ was performed (Ref. FSAR. Section 3C) Induetton Motors - Inside Contain-to obtain the aristum surface tempera-ment Tiecirculation Spray Prep 2. Test report is not dated on signature ture that will be experienced during Motors - Surry Power Station -

page, a MSLB. This value (271 F) was then Second Addendum to Cover itent compared to the value (2800F) that the Aging, Radiation Erposure. Vibra-3 Pressure was unictained at 40 ps!6 motor was tested for. Since the motor tion, and Steam / Chemical Spray for 30 min and not to min.

was qualified for the IDCA at a temp-Exposure Qualification Test - ersture of 2&fF. the lower surface Docltet Number 50-280 and 50-281 B. Solutions: temperature of 271*F proved the by M.W. Sheets. acceptable operation of the motor Vertical Motor Products Sectio =,

1. The actual ex. design pressure is during a MSLB.

General Electric Compny - AO psig. These motors were tested San Jose, California for 45 psig (ref. IDCA gelification for June 12,1973 these motors). bo psig is a conservative (pages 36 to th) value and test pressure accuracy within t5 psig from 45 psig tested would be reasonable to assume. 2 Test report even though not dated on the signature pge is dated on the cover sheet.

3. In the G.E. IDCA test, the motor was tested for five cycles at 45psig for a period of 30 min per eyele. Therefore, the (4 min MSLB requirement at hO peig was exceeded.

30k MEESNEkUMY_b f97dOIME9NN9 EESA3NE_tINEN9 Solenoid Operated Valves Ausmatic k ss of coolant Accident (ILCA) IKA Switet. Cc., Adel (HT8321A5 1 x 106 rada (based cr. IDCA). In altiticc, SCV will perform its function of cicsire the 40 yr radiation ese of 4 x 104 rads the isolation valve witnin tC sec of DOV-B>10GA,C.E Steam Generator Slowdown 150 Isol Vlv mt.st be considered for a total pasible receivire signal. SOV-CC-lOCA,C E Contalment Recirc Air Clr Outlet - Outside Cost radiation dose of 1.04 x 10D rsds. SC W CO-lOCA RCP Thern Barrier Return Her EV-CC-lO2A,C, B RCP Coolers Return Rar Sov-CO-lO3A,B RiiR ifeak Ex~aye Return TV-CC-lOLA-1,2 BCP Coolers I=let - Od side Cont A Normal Erivirorcent Normal Envirome::t 2DV-CC-lOwB-1,2 RCP Coolers Inlet - Outside Cont B NV-CC-10k-1,2 BCP Coolers Inlet - Outside Cc.ct C $O0 to l?OGF 120DF 20PCW-15CA,B,C,D Costaiment Vac Pt=:p Setion E W-DC-i n Pri Dru Xfer Pp 2DV-D!-lOCA Radiation Monitor WW-SI-lOOA,B Nitrogen Supply Line F3iVgje'ZC _TGyCHJU2T. IS QJALI_FIC OFEFAB_KITY LDp?CT_ RAID DOV-SI-lOlA,B Nitrogen Supply Lir,e SCV-VG-lOOA Pri Drn Ifer Tk Vent IKA LOCA EV-B>@CA.C.E Steam Generator Blowdown Isol Vlv 2DV-CC-26,B,C Containment hecire Air Clr OLItlet - Outside Cost Valves re;;t specifically tested to Soli perfomed required safety SOV-CD-2OlA hCP Thern Barriers Return Eir 1.t x 100 rad integrated dose. When function after receivirg SOP CC-202A.C.E RCP Ccclers Return fidr exposed to 5 x lOI red, leakage devel-radiation dese. GOV-CC-203A,B K:iB Eeat Excr. anger Retarn oped unica extausted tr.e pressure vessel. !KR-CC-204A-1,2 RCP Coolers Inlet - Outside Contalment Solenoid valses will have acr.ieved their SOV-CC-2045-1,2 BCP Coolers Inlet - Outside Containment safety-related function within M see of SOV-CC-20<- 1,2 RCP Coolera Inlet - Outside Conttiment an initiation signal. The lord-tem EDV-CV-250A,B,C,D Contalment Vac Pup Suction failure mode will not reintroduce air to EDV-LA-20GA RC Sap Pump Disen a control valve, therefore, the valve SOV-DG-2OGA Pri Drain Ifer Pw.p Disch will maintain its fail-safe pcsition. EDV-hM-20GA Ra11ation Monitor 2DV-SI-2CCA,B Mitm6en Supply Line 2DV-SI-2OlA,B Hitrogen Supply Line SOV-VG-200A Pri Drn Ifer T1 Ver:t Normal Envircreent Normal Enviroment 32 to l?@ F 17@F Auxillery Buillird ACCURACY REQUIREKDf"S n .g. u, p, Ct. 12 c g 3.g., 5; g 3

E3 vs n,

b;#sT" ( EU$Y J 4$$f# 6

8.. e)

'd?"% 09.I Y t E= j-tr.t tgal e 5yl E B$Q#3 y e a e"j $ $d g 4 E.. 13 +:':o E e r 8: s .nem g up 2 h" 8-ll 6 3 9 EE t, s E. D " l ~ s#, A E a u. g ta sl ". ei 'a el n w g t. 26 8. h AH c; S W L' ^ e h- :t: a,; - t' ' i 8 t y %.2.i 3 ; S $ 6 9, B 9 a e6 e O L'* t! R t-v -. a y s: 3 E f 15 '.,i E F, 4a.1,: 4.6 a 3 a a a y e k t 2 b h 3 u e -I wl .t ei k[ p ef 5A l O O i g i ;>:n n u n ni:Jy x mm t an a [l3 $5 A$$$ E:0I t' 2

m A l,4 a.. g a p a.s.

'1 e n('. h L Yb a ,,.~,..- .,.,,n t' E', fi g [4 c[c t p L: M 1"[!!! c:c== e: d e d k i .n f. M n Elo p: ...tu.~ ( [ 4 p

g n s g

hg r o e o p y g a '* Jj s w ,.i i,. l: o

i.

8 h" I

,L UH " [. 8 n

o

:' k; k.g E

D r .d 1, i; r, f?

n a

" 2 P, C E ~- 9 i"t 8 ", i. [' ;' r A aE 3 n a a y "4 K g ys *; g n r, " tp g c r r o u 3 k _* n g,, [; <-p \\' ? h,y

k hN Y.b g

i?> o ,,N D .4 L g{ a(p(4, E F if,1 - F F {

g g

i 8 PL g ye 3 $e i; y :s. g r. g 0, ,9, t, o g ge a ra f a g n e Il le S h 5 8 n Ir1 e h b t. l O O t i 31 QUALIFICATICN DEFICIDCIES AND FICarFEhTED SOLUTIONS QUAL 1rICATION DOCUMENT PRNIFF OF QUALIFICATIg LOCA Loss of Coolant Accident Loss of Coolant Accidect Later Tested Later i Nor-al Fnvironment Normal Environment Nor-al Evirorent Indastrial Standard ANSI C37.20 Sec 3.1 Specification NAS-34 A. Deficiencies: Normal amtient temperature may exceed switchgear's maxim:nn operational temperature. E. Solution: Area is equipped with an ambient temperature monit 5. hat will signal at 101 F and alarm t at 1% F ? t t l l I I I t 32a FRDEElEON MNEE @~RUTEN OIMLNM UFMITY__WIFF9 Marathon Series 200 and 1500 loss of Occlant Accid *=t (LOCA) ILCA Temiral Blocks (Phenolic) 1 x 11' rada (based on 120 days I4CA) 1.CA x 105 rads Cormectren Tyre !i:3ic-1, In additipn, tt.e 40 yr radistion dose h 3, an1 Fai's Temtr=1 cf k a 10+ rada must be considered for krr.al Envirc:anent Blocks (Nylon) a total pasible radiation dcse of 1.0a* x 10' rada. k0 r-12CPF Thermo-electric Temir.al Bloci Tuo. 3225 (Themosettird Fhee.lic ) Exceptioca: OPERABILITY DDLEXPA_TIO GE Teminal Blocks a) Auxiliary Building Pipe Tur.nel IDCA E55 and EB25 (Pterclic) El 24 *-6" maxia m radiation 3 rads dose 7 x 106 rada (1) Phenolic 1 x,10 Westiretouse Type T E Rylon 1 x 10' rads Tem 1Lal Blocks (kylon) b) Safeguards Buildir4 maximum radiation dose 5 x 10b rada (1) Normal ihvirorment Outside Contairament 120DF liomal Envircraent Nost severe temperature will occur. ACCfMCY RMUIFJ3.TNrg for Cat II systems in Main Stream valve House e l3FF kt required F*._M._L W_ M W1%%E ISi@I._W._ wcA Unfilled phenolic can wittst.a1 a gama erposure dose of over 10d rada and snow minimal effects due to radiation. Ilylon can withstand a Eam.a exposare dose of over 100 rads Nermal Enviroinert This temperature range is well within the nomal continus service tes:perature. t 32 QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES EE8__UNET.T02 g kIF_ICATION M g AND N STEDED SOLUTIONS LOCA I,0CA MCA A. Deficiencies: Terminal Block material was empered with identical eterial for the effects PIIC Report No. 21 Badiation

1) Exact spec. of naterial is not high level radiation.

Effect Informticut Center, available from most afr. Columbus, Ohio. bucharan Product 4 14 nual Insert 2.1 Fev. 8/23/7b

2) Bylon terminal blocks, which are located in the auxiliary building pipe tunnel & sefeguards building, Normal Environment may not withstand the radiation Industrial Standards

~ ~' ~ '~ ~~ level above 1 x id> rada. ~' ~~~'" Norm l Environment Underwriter's Lab UNDEFWRITERS !AB B. _Soluti_on_s,1

1) The general ankeup by phenolic or nylon will not vary enough to effect the test results.

2) Nylon terminal blocks will be replaced with phenolic or poly-sulfbne in the pipe tunnel and safeguards buildir4 9

m I

T O 5 c

k z 39 a 9 i 55 n F d i e JI t d an e C cs o ka T n el e mD t t a r n gn

y a

it r i ni

i m

g a e T t J Q n aT i t p a o ep n 3 e T..i a p e j g% F i g e ld P urchased L R412b so(S7OtEh1t B2 L O i IA P {U 3Ot E h W rg 4 S

F oe559 m o f 2p.

oe55oe3 o I a xp d 00O i l 0 r 2p d 0 d0 s m L e F g a s A d" twSl6R re 1 C I soup 0 o n u.8 0 a sOapcs75xF _s e E xorni h ip u 0 ad cs : FF t 0y xi R g 1i pladssE etr E d gpei 0e o I 0gpei S i5 - : 1 s s D f a old tex happx i1 7 a g t o 2 M s sou tirp I y ssp a0 if e nt 1 0 if Ff awaenio % :i i1o t 8 gr sr a o00 7gr r C p Ts1g8s e rilmges t a o m u 0 - o o o g o dt D en p sa e i,0 @ 9 c i r 7 d m i1 4r m m o e gr. o r s t e foe x 0 e t s L t1p a l c ottf f: pt023: oa T 4 i s p hd k 2 a C r ruoa o o 0 s' 2 t O 5 n wmra 5 3 n Q i larr t s 24 2 e ai 0 .t p inn rr aap 00 1 W tbs ( 0 F A phao1 B t vs aia r pFF x2 g rl) c J r i eit sn epa 1 g e Eou c T o eosea r ff 1 C f a oant i g n sn p t p boo 0C 7 k fO)i 7 d J7 ttiete eoorr g y >t H o e o e ncon rfr 7? bn t 3 Ot 3 0 n 3 Ot 2O (E f acii t i i7k r a o0 o0 _t g 40 4 mytfa o1c a t4fo t t t tt E cii c d.0 dh d aao s .P mt omoo L o ff mt ost o (I n Olaesy . 5cy u io i B he io io v e l dp c e s ctce td s I t 0 o eo 6 0 + 3 D i ps el isr n 3nt 2 J 9rrb n 3n 0 C 11oiis h S o a Sdr 0 4 A f m mb mtc m i m i i i m m ) 6, 0nmf rb g m i i 0deie ou i ea uf i n n io i n i n n l a n n e 0dt adc gf t 1ain h he L aac 2y o dp or I r i I ti d F p n rc ue F saeo td E sn D ,s Q N 'A 2P2 1 L P ~u "'O o C o1 2 O E t C 9s2 ~C "T 0 CA A U t ~A 'M r ^B y F - d h 'M I e A eI a q C a4f y L E C {T d Y rco L s sAr 'n m QY r q" @ t. L e 1 B 1 d r0 1e0 'T 5 I 5r ~r 0 aa g F 0s d Fly x* R F ~ M. p r s i a ~S ~9 O T g 3 i 3 n T 7 a S g M2 is -] e q 2 iva lect to t 33 Q'ALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES ' EbEd8bdNME EL.MMEMEM AF1@JMEfm tocA weA wcA Test - Sequential Okonite's Engineering Peport A. Deficie,ncies: No.141 dated February 29, 1772 Qualifiestion document does not address

1) Accuracy of variaties and test data

2) Test monitoring sensors

3) Test facility B.

Solutions:

1) Accuracy of instrument even though not stated would commonly be 11%

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to comply with Industrial Standards for their type of application.

3) Test facility, even though not identified, could be determired vendor's records.

EM M TemperatJre - Analysis S&M Calculation ES-189

Equipment temperature Transient Same as above Maximum esiculated surface temper-for Okonite Tape Splices" ature during limiting MGLB is 2700F which does not exced qualification temperature of 32b F given in s

Okonite E:2gineering Report No. 141. Pressure and Radiatian - Test Befer to LOCA qualification 4 3ka QTggT DFSCFIPTION & iuBK NO. EgjIyION_OF_Dg!_BOlifE3T O@EILIT_Y, RggIRDGIR Eaychen heat shrir. Amole field Loss of Cooiant Accident]LOCA_} Ifrf splicir.g paterial WCSF type coated g with Type-N adhesive 280 F 0 to 30 min 120 days @ 150 F Red xe from 230 F to 150% 30 to (20 min McLB 150 F >c;0 min ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 45 psig O to 30 min 120 days d 150 F Inside Containment Reduce from 45 to O psig 30 to to min O psig /cs0 min 7 7.2 x 10 rada (1) OPERABILITY ID40NSTRATEDQ) Spray: 0-k hra solution of toric acid Iaca~~ (2000-2100 ppm Loroc) buffered to a pH of 8.5 to 11 with saou=4 tr simiur aalution 212 F for 100 days with a pli of 7 to 9 gn,yt_eam Line break _QCLb] Post IDCA thermal agirg is greater than 2.9 years @ 1500F k30 F 0 to 2 mirt 280)F 2 to :20 min mLE 150 > 60 min 45 psig O to 30 min See above Redace from 45 to O psig 30 to oO min O psig .* to ada Ay@CY ERJIRDLE2m p]IFOfjMF3T TO bD1ICH_ EQIIIP. IS gjALIFIED Not reqaired ILCA & MSLB Irrad.iated ty cotalt to gan=a source at 0.27 Mrads/hr to total dose of 200 Mrada. 3tA F @ 70 psig $ hr 320 F @ 70 psig c hr 250 F @ 21 psig 24 hra and 0.2% Boric acid spray Luffered to a Pli of to bh hk b s o I a i c @5 13 i n.b; i MNA m o. Lal h g n,; - [6} i

5. e,.

i ut i b y.1 a > h a sr 4 v. i f I 1 i t 1 m O n dy e a e +> b N f p + ,,t m i L': .-4 i v, e 1 .h 6 E i p S t g9 l 1 - Nd f 1 A e a 4 kV. > 1, a 9 4 6 t 4 e d 3 -% m >> Y$ d ^ c6 h O ch 4 +4 e ea *4 W - S W 1 - a u e.,s - 4 "", fj as 4 g b,,. L m g.z TE D l I 'I N *b r.s.' 1 on-L 4 ep t,a f C. s e.. 4 3 '[ g fG M 'O a bi I - o.a E m k. ) W e4 e 0 kj O C! a 44 & C S E.b i [;f

i J y at,=Ly i

- 8a 1 4' c h m.1 O fa, @ m s I I t 4 ] r 1 i O O g 8Rg88888888888s8s888888s8s nr rr tt.vytyttyvvvvytttttttttyy i U hhhhhhhkkhhhhhhhhhEhkkkhhh Sk f g e i: n h. rf,g g 8 8 s y g L;t p hu n s g u r t y

q" q a

9 s..py c y,,, tL.ydcy g g i., EE E RE E D. $ na u .3 'B " U ab a

7. W '? T 7. { T 7 P R "' $ D 7. p ? 7 7 7 7 7 9 P "' $ p L" # g}e g.,;-gg4

.gr g~gg4 u, y W- [ r" g " n* y m m p N R ii R { " [ E * !i m li [, t.' W. A* -e mz "- : rena un - M (( e, g ~ 0 4'" g

f !': 4 { { L' F E j! 4" g
l4 M 7 N

I !M

na ma e.

c n es - n EU fE!! a re p

,a l. - a ug,ek,.g,r., m~er gp d.f geg-y n

a ggy 5F:ege.~sn r -,,, p y c s m s n s h <,3 r a p yn e< s a g / E; < ? e g y.$ w s a ng <gn V ',.: 'd n R g., ' w 4 g I e ng: n-< s ye ... - E - p gs-8 T.. p ss g g s-s<<< s<s G

0 $ cp%

P Aft 4 TI At EE : 'g r.

~ m l Jl uf,(a

.o U 2# ; ./.. p g - n =.. g r 3 - sn r ai: w r gg e iS t En ~ n p; F [r, lsi [. h P4K .~, n a p 'pl n 1 b hh d W b X c n n r' n -g <.3 r. {g< F g a r .( J, = a s E k. a s N p @s l E P-E ~ 8 88 b; 5t g =y n 4 3 y s". v q a s o p' ~ a

i..

.U.- g *~ =. n ~ ~ 3 7 a7 8 [2 T ,01 'S1 v v MWNOM*mo

c SWo Er" S toS to

[,"-esp gES y gvE o O ii -En rF "UR c *8y g 't' U ~n g; *w w w nn p SU a <T S SE, Cc 2GG ,C n" Gum n" n,". y.[ a

y. n g6

,, n h g gn F R,, 9, E..n k 8 3 ig it (.. g, .g E < L.; 8 ,+ Hg, tr .,?:

t e

I"; f; B f $#,h 5 fi B" 9 d n"% c 5 i ~ Ch" 6 E . E :t 16 E' i n $S b, 4't1 5 n ,,B g, a Tg Li J1 gRn p y w .o 5: 5, i E2k y n t; -c u;.- l

8 tt o Y

4, !.a n -x P, ?" is CE ~ cn .r b O O } 35 i A I Q@LIFICATION DEFICIENCIES PAMMER OF QUALIFICATION gIFICATION DOCg' ret l" AND IL DED SOLL ID,104 IDCA & MSLB LOCA & MSLB IOCA & NSLB Sequential Test hanklin Institute Research A. Defielencies: Laboratories (FIEL) Test Report F-Cf539

1) valves were not subjected to a chetical spray

( 6 Radiation followed by Envinmmental Exposure

2) Badiation exposure ditring test is below accident dose of 4.2 x 107 rada plus 1:0 yr dose of 3 x 107 rads.

B. Solutions: 1

1) Valysa not subject to spray since valves will have performed their intended function prior j

to initiation of sprity. i

2) Replace valves inside the crane wall prior to 10.07 yr epsure. Take radiation reading i.

for rate of dose during plant operation. These measu W.s will provide a ecre accurate exposure rate end, thereby, increase or decrease i the period of repiscenent. s O i a i I 1 I =. f E si H l 3 5 l n,.e t d I (i R o i m 6 ? .t =E is g .r jnr" h J ? t 1 .e 3 k h 5 s i.s b a E u w r

T e

a ~I

0 h

h p-g = y q

Id go n

an g ~

m.

+y R R l 'g ll - P E .a w A s a tE 3 I:4 3 p E IS J. 5l 4 .W 0 2 4 2 E[ ll Es E s!! 9, <. u,W e e 6! 5 n F 'E E I y b ~C i E

tt n

H e e d CJ l 10 3 0 A' s;r i s je 1

l a, k

a n <- E

b*

~ a b P p E" <;P j; f'1! 6t-V e "3 y-i ,a 1 fi se 1 g 4 i l '" "!1 ~1 EE 4 2 '!a l n e n s,. i N \\ GE

I l=

n c a -g a o } f ie a" 2 ri E P. P. n E lJ* d 5i 5 O O 6 e r 3 u ta n r o e i p ta. e rl t ei pa B of L ro W it e e ht h ti t ds d ee n t s a eu M. t l a e rc ITn me t t E n i cr I w u C = et I t va o ar F s n h e ED, e p ~ m i l l c l l NO n i n i t = I e w o w T =. i i e A c s t sr u o C i 'V 'V f I = f l F e O o C e I D S S Sb D_ L L AU C A B Q u *. B e "r = g TS= a P t C= n C. e 0 D. m 3 n o N =- O r g I i o T =. v l A. n a C-- E t I-a F l C I a L B m T e r A L n o S U-S o N A Q F N se Ne Tm-i O r I o AC t e F= r T n o e. b I.=. s I r a L A e U r Q= i s v r e F r O-P t E-i R l r a w ? B m r J L e r e n o d S. o N W-F N Un G ,lli llllI'It l lll' 37a _DEECRDTm _N__O_F _EN.V._L_B_CFM.._. OPF.R.ABILIT._Y R%U.m c_FIES m ~ mm m IREM IO m i_F.OC. _DFE._CR_IIT.I_ON_4. _}'A.._RK _NO. KUI - m Ioss of Coolant Accident (LOCA) 10CA Solenoid Operated Valves Automatic Switca Co., hiel #!EP302h1U 1 x 10" ra.is (based on 120 day IDCA). SOV will perfom its function of closirg isolation valve within to see of In additipn, the l'O yr radiation dose of 4 x 10 rada arwst be considered for receivirg sigratl. SGV-IA-lOCA B.O. S ap Pp Disa EV-SO-1 COB Presure Liquid Space Isol Vlv a total possible radiation dose of SOV-53-lO2B PRI Coolant. Cold Leg Sacple Isol Vlv 1.04 x 106 rads. SOV-S&-lOLA,B Press Felief TK Gas Space Sample Isol V1v lbrmal Envircrrent SOV-SS-lot.B FRI Coolant Hot 1.e6 Sacp'e Isol Viv SOV-SS-ll2B Steam Generstor Semple Isol Viv Normal Enviroment 13fr SCV-SS-200B Pressure Liquid Space Isol Viv I PSD-202B PRI Ccolar:t Cold Leg Sample Isol Vlv 50 to 1RPF 0 SCV-SS-204A,B Press Relief TK Gas Space Sample Isol Vlv SOV-SS-2OO PRI Coolant Eat Leg Sample Isol Vlv SOM& 212B Steam Generator Sample Isol Vlv ENVUOWEar TO k'ri1CH IEUIP. IS QUALI)TED OPFJABILITY MEMUERES M Inca Auxiliary Buildirg Radiation exposure 5 x 107 rads Functioned properly for 14 days at 1500F after 50 Mrad radiation exposure and will not misoperate l if SOV falls due to radiation. Norval Er.vironment Type lff suitable for ambient tar.perature Nomal Enviroment as high as 1760F 1760F _ACCUF.A_CY R.14. UI_RD._E_N_TS m ~ Not required ____...._.__.s ._m mm.. ..m..._..--__. i d it' i I 1 i l' i' 37 I = f I t t t QUALIFICf4rION DEFICIENCIES l PANNER OF QIALIFICATION QTRLIFICATION DoctPTNT g SqJ _RI gO I None -ItcA r IDCA Franklin Institute Research Test t g Laboratories (FIRL) Test Report F-C'539 [ 4 t I NormaJ Environwnt Tbmal Envirorssent Formm.L En.v.ironment~~~ None i i Industrial Starxlard Asco. Cetalog #30, par.e B. = Underwriter's Laboratory l A i l \\ i t t

e i

3 3 1 1 I I k t I l ( i e t k Me NM__@EREQf8dj0 E@CRIFTEN CF ET. IIET37Xi OfggILIT_Y R34UIR&ECS Scienoid Operated Valve Loss of Coolant Accide::t (IDCA) LOCA Atatic Switch Co. 6 1 x 10 rada (based on 120 day I4X3). SOV will perfom its function of closing isolation valve within to sec of In gtion, t:.e M yr radiation dose of rads must be considered for a receivir4 signal. b x lv Model #FT83201A101 total posgible rah 11ation dose cf 1.N x 10' rads. kmal Enviroment 2CV-SS-103A,B IQIR Outboard Isol Viv SCW SS-203A,B 133 CA:tboard Isol V2v O Somal Divirornnect 12O F 0 AnrHisry Isaildirg 5(P to 120 F 0PEliABI_L_QT LDO! W __J LOCA cr/IBO;F.ET. To i41TCH qJIP. IS QTIALITIED none b b Envirormaent Mryl Environannt AN ype PT is suitable for ambiest temperature as high as llODF. AT RACY RFQTIREMENT Not required O fo noe 33 a i t al l loa sF i glna i r s, oi l s c y f r oiv nioe e. S icv ES t el IN

c. r a CM v

,. f M f on

1. M t

s, ep lO tco i a e t,_

r. S t

s r ny DD n E r0t ND or c r i o f t r OI rn I J eil i_ d4 f 1 pnl v C0 t i n I0 li w F_ FE l w IR i V l L veO e vL e n vl AD n UN rv o

o o

QAu aef f M 8 P e T r. r' a h P t t C r r O e 0 D n 3 r N et O r g I i o r v l e t n a C E t I a I"j F l C a L e m O AH n r C U e. o S Q N A y N o O t I a T dr A t re C n at I e de F n nL I ar a L o ts A

y U

i r Q v le F n at C E ii L_ rr R e tw sr &r r ue A r dd C c R O lo o nn P L L jL G 9 O E EE HE =F%T u a i* a Va t y Hy Ty s c Cc c i n h t P d e e e t e m m m =E N C I n h T o n i i D n .c g g. t n n FJ a f i v v n o o B ,I m l l P e t t r a a T g g cI t n,O e e

N m

t .oi e =% r =M c m r in ,h c a s w o t u,N n t O n o e .r c a tors CT M tt iT L F 4 it p4I1 L D o e o oore O T o o o n O n7J n r r t rr C r sx x C =. f t m m ag am A U m s a A R i1g1 t i i a ladi R _a b0 0 =I 4s n l min O 1 1 ~P t E oat t 3 2 l a dr aa i tm T 1 0 E e t rir I _n ou i n n i i v raoe C," r v eso o i F s o. on n T i a d,n d .i 1 i da s 2o s _r ou s r O T o i fp i. y fro & O n F aut( cf e y t ht 2e m r i ea C t C E .e a C n ot a to n mano IT t n 4e I =G in t ten ~ on l n C L0d n e OOme l de I bJ a c i o y o O c t t scen i o r Oeo g t eoa t r a rr nr1 s s dMis g os 2 i .a r a ? fir 0 ? al da ds 1edd g . ria a 0eay i 4dt p n e g iL xfoO ra a onC hc L 1r A oo I 0 d) ut F "ao. ra I s l E rt e D ao w* t dt o .a a f l a O N 1 L O I 3 A _C hBi 2 / P o O F C r x E E r .0 C D o 0t t m A R 4 s 4 A r i l a 1 A 0 a 5 e A 2 'l 0 S l x E I q C 5 I 1 L 2 E 1 L % ~~E a Y T n r I 0 n 0 i T v a T ov M r Y i d Y F i e ~r s r r d U o E a a R r d E I n D a q m F m f e ~~ 3 e g 'n n R _t D S t TR 3 EC

a ATED 3

9 .._.....m.__ ._____m m..___ _.m_m.. .m-..-m__..-. .~. .~ -m.. 39 QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIES MANNF,R_OFg,IA,L,I,FICATION (,1ALIFICATION DOCLKENT AND RECOTP_DED_.SOLL7 IONS _ ==- -an - .-----r-LOCA LOCA LOCA Feychem Report #71100 Bevision 1 A. Deficiencies; Test: Therm 1 aging followed ty irrediation for HVT and IPOE Letter from Baychem dated k/24/79 and EPSERT FBO Bayches Feport

1) Accuracy of variables and test data RT1503/1

2) Test monitoring sensors

3) Test facility N_ormal,Em,ironment, B.

Solutions: N._o_r.m_1. Envir_orne_nt AST'4 D 76 Baychem RVT catalog U-012 dated June 1776

1) Accuracy of instrument even though h

not stated would ecumanly be t1% IEEE W

2) Test monitoring sensors, even though not identified, are assumed to comply with Industrial Standards for their type of appliestion l

3) Test facility, even though not identified, could be detemined fran Vendor's records.

Norwal Emrironment Kone

e,,

. a-- Da M EIPTIGN_OF ENVIte 33rr CPM W TY g tp g g r EQPCT ITECFIK!ON A'G MRK NO- = = = ~ LTA Soleniod Operated Valves Loss of Coolant Accident (U)CA) Auto:natic Switch Co. ~~-~[-'~~~~ ' ~ ^CV will perform its f.ar.ction of .dodel *HT'3320A102 1 x lo' rsds (tese or 120 day L')CA). clost::g isolation valve witnin radiatior. dose (O sec. of receiving signal. Ir. additign. the 160 yr. SOV-LM100A Cort. Press Taps of 4 x 10 rada must Le considered SOV-Ra00B Cont. Press Taps for a total possitle radiatioc. dose of SOV-CGOOC Ccct. Press Taps 1.04 x l@ rads Nor al Enviror.ze..t' ' ~ 504-CilOOD Cont. P resa Taps ~~ ' ' ' ~ ~ SOV-GG00E Cont. Presa Taps 120 F i i SOV-Lv.100F Cont. P ress Taps SCV-CCOOG Corit. Press Taps Mrmal Envirtmmer.t SOV-LMlCO! Cont. P ress Taps O_PE7J_EH.ITY_I;E_GN...G...... SOV-LM200A C ont. P ress Iaps hxA SOV-U42005 C ont. P ress T aps ~- Sov-L4200C Cor.t. P ress T eps D3ggTjo MJggMS,qgqED None SOV-La Cant. Press a sps SOV+IJ4200EC ont. Press Taps (OCA SOV-LM200F C ont. Press I sps the Mormal Envircr. ment SOV-I.r200G Cmt. Press Iaps ornal E.;vironment SON-C O OQi Cx.t press ?aps ~~~ 17t,*F Type TC s itatle for ascier.t Auxiliary Eldg. ten:perature as Lign as 17,0F AfMC1__Q____ggig 50t req 2 ired O .. ~ - or F W

, qc a M i-

....., -.. ~..-....... 1 ) 1 3 1 l no f Q'EIFICATION DEFICII"iCIES % W1.T_ $ N; @ CATigN_ g[ALIFIgATjoj,DOjC. g QD ggiDgjGJTJgf3 wcA mca LOCA r None None 30V will perform its function of

!ormal Environment closing isolation valve within W sec of receiving signal. Failure of SOV

( Normal Environment ASCO estelog $30, page 8 will not reopen valve. j ) i Insiustrial Standard Underwriter's IAboratorY i Normal Environment 1 None 4 t k i i l i 't i i i h r i I i t k I t b t 't i i i 6 Y E " [ [fE s t! V9 nr - g =" II 3 liif ? q $ St $ ((a'd $lB,2 b e es g s s - tre g r E 8 f I k I Ib h !f h f I E W r l i i 5

f 3

3 4 ( g id ?l 9 E fi I l 9 5 a t G O h hb

~ lb 3

I 5 E 5 !n 2 n 9 [f k ik p fi E O O I 1 i 41 QtPLIFICITIDN DEFICIENCIES {ANNER OF QUALIFICJAT ' gIALIFICATIDNDOCLRE!O AND NNENDED SOLITTIONS 12c" wCA mcA kne Mne A. Deficiencies: w No nuclear qualification Itamal Enviroment Nomal Environment Industrial Standard Specification NAS-1Ch B. Solutions: ND1A-ngl

1) Replace aw.or

2) Shield motor Nomal Enviroment A.

Deficiencies: HI h ambient tenperature E B. Solutions:

1) Replace motor

2) Provide area with ambient terperature monitor that will signal at 1010F and ele m e+ Id Or w

i W-la ET$[,ETE936{pg1Q. gF((Wp OF YJPiINMG OlpAEILITT F2QUIPJEFI'S P.O. HA 10!.1010 LOCA 120 days W 150 F NMlear' Steam S yply System 2300F 0 to 30 air. Westinghouse Electric Comp. Red ee from 233 F to 15(FF 30 to to sin OmdEILITY LEXtiSTFATED (2) Steen Generator Flcar Trar.smitters 1500F > 50 min ' ~~ ~ k5 paig O to 30 min 124 cays @ 15CPF FT-lh74, 2374 Ped ace frog 45 M-1475, 2b75 to O psig 30 to to min M-14%, 23604 0 psig > f 4 min FT-lk35, 2L35 42 x 107 rada ACCURACY PMUIFFSFS ^~ FT-1AA, 2h% M-1495, 2495 Spray: 0-A r.rs aclation of toric t.% acid (2000-2100 ppa toron) buffered to a pH cf 8.5 to 11 with NaOH > 4 hrs similiar solution with ACCURACY OFAr2iSTRA_TED Rosemour.t Model ll52DP-M a pii of 7 to 9 t.2% xits I+30 F 0 to 2 min 0 2SODY 2 to t0 min Inside Contairment 150DF > t4 min A5 psLg O to 30 min Bed se from 45 to O paig 30 to (4 aln O paig

00 min 3 x 107 rada ENVIRahMOff TO W!CM EQL'IP. IS QUALIFIED

LOCA, 350%

0 to lo sin 31:PF 10 min to 1 hr 303 % 1 br - 8 hr 230 F 8 hr - 50 hr 0 ti psig O - 10 min 70 psig 10 min - 7 hr 55.4 psig I hr - 8 hr 6 psig 6 br - 50 hr 5 m 10 rada Spray: None MSLB See above W-1 QUALIFICATION DEFICIDICIES AND RECOMMENDED SOUJrIOGS MANNER OF y LIFICATTON gCALIFICATION DOCUMENT LOCA & MSLB TACA LOCA Test Rosemount Test A. Deficiencies:~ Report #117t15

1) Accuracy of variables and test data 6

2) Test monitoring sensors

3) Radiation level MSLB B.

Solutions: Rosemount Test

1) Accuracy of instrument even though k]

Beport #117415 not stated would commonly be +1%.

2) Test monitoring sensors, even FSAB Section 3C though not identified, are assumed and response to coment 7.17 to emply with Industrial Standards for their type of application.

3) Transmitters are Sood for 40 yr.

radiation dose plus 200 hrs. into a LOCA. Optimum solutiUn is still being investigated. I;CL_E A. Deficiencies:

1) See items 1 & 2 for LOCA.

2) Temperature envelope B.

Solutions: w

1) See items 1 & 2 for IDCA

2) Qualification test of 350 F for ten minutes. 3160F for one hour0 whereas the environment is 430 T g

for two minutes, then dropping to 280 F after two minutes. The temperature environmer.t does not exceed qualified limits due to ther: sal inertia and internal temperature. See calculation #,$-t w M-2a KUUv.T DESCRI?? ION & MEK 70 DESCRI? TION OF &&!JC7f OPERABILIT JY{g loss of Coolant Accide::t (IDCA) m P.O. NA-10/10lO j 280DF & 30 min 120 days @ 1 W j hiear Mm My Sysm Rede.ce frtun F300F to 150 7 3&th mit 0 1 150cF W4 min We%1ryme Electric Corp

45

&% min l O P*i' d^>

i pMgm@g y

'( t**'* k5

Pressurizer Level TrarMtter LT-1459 7.2 x 107 rads fi)

Inca LT-1Wl Spray: 0.4 hr solution of boric acid (2000-2100 pp: 212 dass s iW 2 I2-1kO LT-2kS9 boros) buffered to a pH of 8.5 to 11 with NaOH 24 tr similar solution with a pH of 7 to 9 i LT-2 do Main Steam Line Break (FJ) ACCURACT 6 p. M S 430 F 0 to 2 min i 0 Parton 3E/752* 260DF 2 to 60 min il$ for 5 5 min 150 7 260 min 45 psig O to 30 min Inside Contaimed Reduce from 45 to O pais 30 to to min O psig >60 min ANUM @M 3 x 107 reds O to 5 min <5% E'NN M MG MM I3 WN '386/752 is prototype of 764 Lot 1 testing is applicable to prototype. O to 2000F O-3 see 260 F @ 75 psig 3-1200 sec 0 2600P-200DF 20 min to 24 hr 220 F 1 to 15 days Radiation: 5x107 rada Spray: 1.14 vt $ boric acid and 0.17 wt % NaOH dissolved in water for 24 hr b 3ao F e 75 psia o 100$ F3 naMiation: 1.13 x 105 rads W-2 QUALIFICATION DEFICIENCIIS AND REXX1td2fDED SOInfION_3 PlLNNER OF QUALIFICATION ELIFICATION DDCthfE2ff MX:A }DCA LOCA West'ry; house Electric Corp. A. Deficiencies: Test - Sequential Radiation level to which equigrient was qualified [ N".rT!%-1950 is below that of LO yr plus IDCA dose. Anderson to Stolz B. Solutions: ?G-TPA-2120 IDCA eguipnent was qualified for a 3evel of 5 x 10' rads. This means that equijnent will be able to withstand the IffA dose of Anderson to Stolz 4.2 x 107 rads with a 8 x lOb rads level for norr.al life. Therefore, since the 40 yr Test life is 3 x 107 rada ard this is a fairly constant rate, the equipnent is qualified for greater than 10 yr. We will either obtain further qualifiestion data or replace equignent before the loth yr. E A. Deficiencies: Qualified to 3000F PELB, peak tenperature is 430 F. 0 B. Solutions: Temperature qualification is acceptable since tec:p reduced to M after 2 min, due to themal inertia, 4 internal tecperature rise stays within qualified limits. See Tenperature Calculation #ES-169 f i i W-3a i E _'EPMENT LECCRIPTION & f: ARK NO. DESCRIPTION OF EWIRONMENT OPERAHLI_TY_PpUIREME@ P.O. T.A 10/1010 LOCA helear Steam Sqply System 280 F 0 to 30 min 120 days @ 150 F Westinghouse Electric Corp. Redxe from 2% F to 150 F 30 to to sin Steam Generator Level 150 F pt,0 mic OPERAfiTLITY DD40NSTRA_TED (2) l (Narrow Range) transmitter 45 psig O to 30 min Reduce frcus 45 124 days @ 150 F ) LT-lk74, 2474 to O psig 30 to to min LP LkT5, 2475 O psig yto sin LT-lk7c, 2476 7.2 x 107 rada (1) A_CCbTdCY R_FfI_R_E._T_NTS_ LT-1435. 2kd5 Spray: O-4 hrs solution of baric 2.5% 1 LTalW., 2436 acid (2000-7100 ppm toron) t,uffered LT-1494, 249k to a pH of 8.5 to 11 with haOH > h hrs ACCURACY DEMONSTFATED r.T-1495, 2495 sinilar solution with a pH of 7 to 9

D LT-14%. 2k90 MSLB MODF 0 to 2 min Rosemount ggtsppha 230 F 2 to to sin 150 F

> 60 mLn 45 Psig O to 30 min Inside containrent Bedace f.am 45 to O psig 30 to to sin 60 min Opay 3 3 x 10 rada ENVIRONMENT TO WHICH EQUIP. TS QUALIFIED LOCA 350 F 0 to 10 min 316)F 10 min to I hr 303 1 hr to 8 bra 230 F 8 hr to 50 hrs 60 psig O to 10 min 70 psig 10 min to 7 hrs 55.4 paig 1 hr to 8 hra o psig 8 hr to 50 hr f 5 a lO' rada Spray: None MSLE See above 9 w-3 QUALIFICATION DEFIFIENCII3 MANNER OF QUALTFICATION QAgIFJCA LOM,Q ('Tr Aggggy SOLUTICNS LOCA & MCLB

LOCA, LE Test Rosemount Report A.

Deficiencies:

117415

1) AEcuiney ~oTveriables and test data

2) Test monitorirg sensors

3) Radiation level KLB Rosemoett Report B.

Solutions:

117415

1) Accuracy of instrument even though FSAR section 3C not stated would cormumly be 115 and response to comment 7.17

2) Test monitoring eensors, even though not identified, are assumed to caiply with Industrial Standards for their type of application.

3a) Transmitters were operational at 0 5 x 10 reds, need further testing to assure compliance to the 7.2 x lof reds. The results of the existing testing indicate that radiation does not adversely effect the transmitter. 3b) Eeplace with qualified transmitters. %LE A. Defleiencies: ~ r

1) 5ee~itimaI l 4 2 for LOCA.

l

2) Temperature envelope I

F E. Solutions ; i

1) S=e items 1 & 2 for LOCA i

2) Qwlification test of 35CPF for ten minutes, 31t0F for cme ho tv j

( whereas the environment is h3 M I for two minutes, then dropping to l 280 F after two stinctes. The temperature environment does not exceed qualified limits due to theral inertia and cterral temperature. Calculation s.}. E3-1 9 l l l &4 4 ft! ff* f 14

U J

N N h I I '< ti b I) l* r 9 yy n#E Y i g r ~~ !"? >t n ;y n u n e y f 99?? p d}'4 [8 ri o gann a t' ", Ee B 0$ hi?$ N ansa y' t ~ s4 ii m m .p s n isg8 9 8

ya Ii![5s fp jy y g 9 g s o m t,;g w g om e

ydc ~ y ys F g Ep N g;. % % F 4 am~ h; pu<i. v 2. g r.E,W w w. >8 8 >m e 6gx ., 9 y E,. g g J n. - g a r n i tg..g H P,. 6 8 n n g,P g ud te g c-F.ta 4 ", 3 d ar au - g .H

y-

f. s g

a" a" r1,t a g qp ~ ,, i! gng g 4 n p3ii 'aH I

,,r 3

2 E liE E s g i ?> 3 y E* 8' s R E! @d hr., 5 4' K E a E 5: J !R' E d EcE e 1 a g' >m [ n L, ~p' 5o e. r q,. ^ 3., n y-r e' $ y r r s .8, 4 d afhR d 4 4*. % " h.. il'g p "<a n .a: tt" p'.g u sa ir .,k 2 Err S

b3 "d? k B' l' pj n

"Mf Sy?$y? 3 v v v o $8o8"o ) "O 0." "E g4 h3 E[. g 4E"EG EE r' b y) U, r E n E E "$N t W j nS EE w th SgEgm Eg8 tr r. gE g a> ed EL EE-wu e .g EE at EE

twf.

g-as e 8 R.2 k s- [n0 4 nl? 'T .a i = ji g 5, 8 m ,o }*re. g C 9 d flQ rI g 5il g 5 c 5 u En E-8 8 mna lh. 3 fe t i: lel g l na I ha b il Rg u. k ER f I It B ii es tin G G m W Is i QUALIFICATION DEFICI2iCIES MANNER OF Q'ALIFICATION Q'JALIFICATION NFEfr AND REtIM81NDED SOLLTIOI1G_ men mcA mea Sequential Test Report entitled: A. Deficiencies: " Qualification of NAM 00 controls limit 1 Accuracy of variables and test data switch Mode FA-180 to IEEE Standards 3W 2 Test monitorins sensors (*75),323 (*7k), end 332 (*72)," dated 3 Test facility 3/3/78andrevised4/7/78 B. Solutions:

1) Accuracy of instrument,even though not state 4 would commonly be il$.

2) Test monitoring sensors, even thCPJgh not identified, are asstaned to comply with industrial standards for their type of application.

3) Test facility, even though not identified, could be determined fran vendor's records.

4 ,,~.. ~. ------ --- -- - -- s RII a e u V W N .P I CC n .O s y VV l s c U v t l m 21 U i e i e d k M T e 22 n a 3 00 P c. r C 11 os o S 1 C o 2.I t 0 Eh w n i 2 t e / O t O s1 E a C l i I I I o 0 r em c E 1 C n t t l S 0 E e dd S e u I n oo w c p ? ww i t p r n r_ t r l I e i y D t c N C o r w r p U X fr 4 M >b0 S 7 E41R2 L L I E 3 OR4 pM3 r a ba - p e55e6 o E C e e5 C A' x pd 0 i rk r 2 d 0tc s t n r o a up Da P s Q A U arp F anh y x c aFcF 1 i ag q e C 0 dei S )r 1 g f ei e o U u M M 7 s t s f e ibs 0 f f T al o 7 r r C I O mdl r r a i i e o o C c m W i f f r m m o E i i C a l f u. L aet a l e e d d T 4 i rri d k 2 a O r F V .t O 5 r eo a 5 e sdn E M t a ( t i o B lto 1 o F A i r uof ) c V C O e t O t c U H a iat o i p k c o r d Cp s npr s 1 e i i 5 n ii t i ( U g M w c g 0 t D I C ic D (L f L tfa F f .P ) h c S O a.S i C d I A 3 5 ) gt2( i4 i o0 5 s 2 03O 20 o 0 0 0t3o 00 f10 0 o0 - _L E to oo 7 2 m0st c t tt 1 - 3 3 u r w1 i iO do q s 3 02 ti0 nmn a t 0 0 ot0 i mi o m h0 n in n m mi 9 hp mi in in n aI n an i L O_ E C g M 0t v E A Ts re C O_ t c t A 3 r W e A g q .C a G Y M g M D-l u S i i L F f r .A B i e E ]E e d ~U d .I S p E .a 2 M .n P c M 2' ? s W -$a .........m_... .m _.. ._4 .m m__m.. .m. 6 I v-5 L QtM.IFICATIDN DEFICIECIES PANNER OF glALIFICATION QUAIJTICATIO_N D_OCU!_G.. M.rS.. AMD P5_77_1ME_NDE_D SQL_f?lIO_'t3 IDCA & MSLB LOCA & DCLB IOCA & MTd Rone 5one A. Deficiencies

1) NA3RD D-MX not qualified for accideri environmert.

B. Solutions: Limit switenes provided for indication only and, do not verform a pefety feciten. Was to raquiremnts to te q alified for accident errvironment. I h i e L 9 r 9 I 4 4 k a l l 4 [4 r* ',d M 7, ${ %, &#J bQ )7 l A.' ' $5 l1 ? $$' % 5 l Y m 4 5. f< ' P 'M

t d t o

[ !" g lf*" .2 C Ti A, \\ ue \\ m ,h t/s, x) -a e t; a..:1" -er o "C*Q "n 1-OD 'l# I l1 ii

4-i w

,q b.a y l I WO*PMN,F,'b -4 y r*

v M

-4 0 e to r e m rv (* y 3 d,yp:;; mg t hP,P

o, " a 3 ', v & # c K y d $'

up MN N v g '" B o r o0 I" g*8 ,1 m =

oht h

$1 a-t

1
G h * + ?:1' n

. f%G b6 ~

PK fGER*

n. g g cg nege s ce a

t.,

. " 3 8

s a 'g l3 {$$U R (? e ,e 1.5 rs : 2 3r-4.9 E Pa 4x g r, ;> p M F, !J4 o' = 5. 4 8 / w ou o t b e e" m o v t0 oo o

" S 8 o..

B-o e,4 ? rd rr 9 g - o o oo fto USNS* y.. "Is n'h. E t. O E O o ti E c- ~ m -~ f.M ~s r k ?. 18 9 id g k;c v ~ go o 1 e s !?w, Yd g ~ .1

n w

t

[1 m

g !<m y e 'M;: 4 l"M

3.,i,

o eQ e? in, p, c, ej li b Mg IR k O O i i W-6 QUALIFICATION DEFICIEiCIES & PECO*4 ENDED SOLUTIONS Pf_UERJF,,q[gIFICAT(ON KMLIFICATION DOCtHFST LOCA & W NCAP- @ LOCA ~ Test NS-CE-c92 None t 35LS A. reficiencies t Temperature envelope [ O In accordance with 79-OlB " Guidelines for Evaluating Environment QumLirication" page?, paragraph k.2.1, " Equipment qmlified' for a IDCA environment is qualified for a ICLB environment...". 4 i G l l l l l e !F 7 %: P

'h $

N;f N y;)N n b lg s pm w; s yr w3, - s y gg + 4 A a ea p g~; 3 g' gj g ~ ~ o a0 g 4' g @J n W

7 e

N . 3J7o a 3 Tj l 10 N ?! !L. .,o

u u

[ 41 h a-Y fY t i N tr[d" %(r.e4E lb : a b $ id g% k .rj 1 g g ~ ~6 S & id

T hw 4 %'3.

3 S g.n-! s c A. ~ ~, ~ n, *- o g ,e gr g ges u sc.. ~,s 4 h] p g a sEe ~ g, t .s ~ r g g. g~> is = a 2 ~c p g a a s a,S a na s a rt r; r

h -

a at R n e a c f M O b j O aE',n-g a s o o ~g- <a n V 3 "E, ll[, T ^ a h, tr 1 r fi 3, r,

e i3 w",

4, id 4 g + r. 5o 2 o ag V E t1 d "X 5' kB 1: ~ E* jf l + o J Stosmo et$ v v suvsw? "'849 E,r" bp p,En&& nT8nYW Ed; w o., ;r o. a s e c mw-m n"d

r. tr g g, o

8 u w i. to $ it b hE 's kn E w" = 4 8 il lp-Mrs ij>B J &+ u >> N w O O na

I%

8 C B s & Ei "a W "a j#a tc r b e s ,. in t.% a 5 't :I" d ld " dd h"E "W $y s c i t, s npij

u g

F9 g:!$ h o fd 2 g-1 n in r g H b to Ei Tv O O i i w-7 QGEIFICATIDH DEFICIENCIE3 MANNER OF 4,UALIFICATIDN QUALIFICATIDN DOctfEff gT_RECJD ggtf_f1D3 Test - Sequential Westinghouse Electric Corp. LOCA N M }%-1950 A. Deficiencies: Radiation level to which equipnent was qualifiel is below that of LO yr plus IDCA dose. Anderson to Stolz N M MA-2120 B. Solutions: LOCA e72ignent was qualified for a level of Anderson to Stolz 5 x 10 rada. This reens that egalpnent will be able to withstand the LOCA dose of (Test) 4.2 x 107 rads with a 8 x 106 rads level for nomal life. Therefore, since the 40 yr life is 3 x 107 reds and this is a fairly constant rate, the equipment is gaalified for greater than lo yr. We vill either obtain further qualification data or replace equipment - before the 10th yr. 4 E A. Deficiencies: Qualified to 3800F MSLB, peak tersperature is 430oF. B. Solutions: Temperature Taalification is acceptable since temp reduced to 280DF after 2 min, due to themel inertia, internal temperature rise stays within qualifiei limits. See Temperature Calculation IES-169 E bbbNf .l1 o 4,'. " ". E o A a D r r s' u + s 'U N05N N. 1.hj n w e g5 q b. I, t,i 2 $,M 5 9 si, g o i n H sM s .] N 11 E ? N e he M lk +*

?C n

a b c1 0 9 ON 'e

g ou Y, N N

, 5., -a. n mA s P d 9 9m $e m> wJ '- am W NMNO

9) w O r* wrwNY 4

eomm -4 O e*

t, r w <* 's N,

~ h~ rc ,r-+ -n 6 o m M xs oow a s oms. ww f6 Y nM n >r* ,.f, HM b OO w w QM NM n 6 se , fn e t# mp en 31 er bm m% o 1*4 m O i t$ oob r l ' o n<e se oa ad -o e+

r>

C .sw e 0% e d o N-u- nk +n 0 r.*e r* m e*+ e-r* N 4 J. Q P4 y4 .M O s % TJ tt r 4 1 ' q* r 5' 4) at o $) 7 -4 se W r* i > M M M dm +q d I Q Q 9W .c.d.s ' 3 ,' e* o8O 1 D r* M O-4 % M'% t"'i g 3 4 a4 O, o.** 9 M 1 Nw c o e o .o 4 N --P g E V N i >4 W W s C'* t4 W T1 w p fa v ,; 21 H k s M r M att u g a v , 3 v M O q a, 't' y ;I O O %4j 3,; g,.. ~ M T Q t' 4 7' M 1.

1 W

w n.- H M o aq e yg* o G" IJ T O M M 9 0 9 J r V N >^ 8 (O ]

s Q: w e-

\\ 4 4.t q p F' n 4 O 2 ~8"o i 70 ob"o O ~ r t". o og ft o ',/ e o -s % eo o e o -+ 3,.l ~ i,. o s s n.. a M n ss a~ o oEo$ o n m - - g oEoo T no

o e

r.- n w na no ono e 5"tw 1,., E-t"6" ~ *" 12 ws-t g 3 K U g 8 ': f* o E

'. " 2 o o o i

g , g f' E s ri " Ega E E E E a l .N. p a ~. v a n o r. tr 3e h h. ) M y; n M n i M t*-'M + ap g, b e+ V +e ,. h N ,o pI p e0 i N N \\O iO N M .fO dM

0*

O APR M j$ Ld tdh" 3,. ao 4!

. ;U R

n,. p. M ,o -o , o.< e = < ge s l<a J.

4 V

o, l.< r ; to u e s.: V e tr e< S r i,i !,n e, c-e 6* 5

P e4 p'U

'U M h P*8 i 9 o 1 O +j V

j. N p

d fd ?E h.I o 9 J' o il T" $m Gi

E

p 8

m I r-9 b s m a G d' G.. b44 = a k e I l O O 4 i ( w-8 QUALIFICATION DEFICIBCIES g y J J 39IFICA Qff q4ALIFJ Q Q311gg AJ DJ g g ED_SOLJL I Q Test - Sequential Westir.ghouse Electric Corp. IWA NS-TIA-1950 A Deficiencies: Anderson to Stols !<adiation level to which eq11pment was qualified is t,elow that of 60 yr NS-tfA-2120 plus LOCA dose, Anderson to Stolt B-Solutions: (Test) LOCA equipwnt was qualified for a level of 5 x 107 reds. Tttis mPen$ the LOCA dose of h.2 a 10ge to withstand that eqaipment will te ab reds with a 8 x 10' reds level for normal life. Therefgre. since the 40 yr life is 3 x 104 nds and this is a fairly constant rete. the equipment is qmlified for Ereeter than 10 yr. We will eitber obtain further goalification data or 5 replace equipment before the loth yr. 24SLB A. Deficiencies: Qalified to 380 F ELE. peak terpreture is b30 F, 0 E. So12tions: Temperature qualification is ecceptable \\ sicce temp. reduced to 2% F after 2 min, due to therral inertie, internal gf temperature rise stay within qualified limitt See Temperature Calculation EES-Ir_9 li-9a MUInEE NEGIP IO:3 & FARK HO. MEC,R_I_PTION_OF E.N. _IBO_TCE_C_ OPE _RAB_ILI___TT FKUIPd}5ES mm mm, P.O. M-lO/lOlO Ioss -f Coolart Accident (LOCA) IDCA & FCI3 Muclear Stess Supply 2FRfF 0-30 min 120 days e 150 F Reduce from 2SO F to 150*F 30-60 min D Westire:ouse Electric Corp. 150 F > 60 min 0 k5 psis 0-30 min Solencid Operator Begen Hz Outlet Reduce from 45 to O psig 30-60 min O psi 6 >tc min HCV-12rr3A 7 rada (1) Oy,B,ILITY La0ggg HCV-12OOa 7.2 x 30 HCV-12 OOC IKA & FELB HCV-2200A Spray: HCV-22OOB D 0-4 nr solution of boric acid (2000-2100 ppn Functioned properly for 14 days at 150 F HCV-22 OOC boren) buffered to a pH cf 8.5 to 11 with HsOH after 50 )srad radiation exposure. >4 hr similar solution with a pli of 7 to 9 ASG) #1CS3OOMAEU {_in Stena Line Break (K LB) ACOIRAC_Y R(TIPgg Inside Contairment 43G T O to 2 min Not required 280DF 2 to (o min 1500F >(O min 45 psig O to 30 min Reduce frus 45 to O psig 30 to 60 min O psig 2o0 min 3 x 107 rads ENVIBO;4G7T TO WHTCH EUIP. IS GalAgw 9 m 460 F 0 to 2 min 0 Reduce from b60 F to 3kO F 2 to 8 min D O Reduce from 3kODF to 240 F S to 35 min 0 150DF 52 min to 14 days 129 psia O to 2 min 118 psia 2 to 32 min Reduce frcan 118 to 25 psia 32 to 34 mia. 13 5 psia 52 min to 14 days Radiation Exposure 5 x 107 rads ESt.B Encompassed by above IDCA test w-9 r QtALIFICATION DEFICMIIS AND PlXXtHENDED SOLUTIDNS MAfOGlR OF QUALIFICATIDN SUALIFICATION IDCtFIITS IOCA & ISLB IDCA & MCLB IDCA & MSLB Franklin Institute Besearch A. Deficiencies: (. - Sequential Test Laboratories (FIRL), Test Report, F-ch539

1) valves were not subjected to a chemical spray

2) Radiation exposure during test is below accident dose of h.2 x lO'I rada plus 40 yr dose of 3 x 107 rada.

3) Time, teperature envelope is not adequate.

B. Solutiore:

1) Valves not subject to spray since valves will ha e performed their iz: tended function prior to initiation of sprsy.

2) Replace valves inside the crane wall prior to 10.67 yr exposure. Take radiation reading for rate of dose during plant operation. These measurenents will provide a mre accurate exposure rate.

3) aov vill perform its function within (o see of receiving signal and will not misoperate if O

SOY fails due to teperature. b .P N A S b I. I O o e .O Y TT 1I l s W s C uH VV rr e t l i O vV n i

d cC i y-o r

5 5 1l I e g A T b ?1 i 11 44 4L d L@E C ?2 o l /c 22 o 8 n0 C6 O u

O n

3 l 1 ,A,A p s / t 1 e e 1 a t 0 BB r CC r F. E

c. o a*

E 1 i xx nn l E 0 r. cc tt e e N" E. e ee aa LL d c

f ii ee t

ss ss I t t V r mn C ii m dd a i vv ea oo l c 2 D d ee n :r ww v tt nn e C LL s o

II LL r

I f ee M t i ss ii p dd oo mm d oa ll ww aa E nn tt I L ii oo HE oo oo 2 ux nn pp O C. 11 utt llee 22 t t b3 R41 L E F4124 4op N I o n n O e. 55 R3 o e5We d d-s d C OO rr n c

7 p upPAo

. oa s xp r e A t a csFFF rny

sI a

c g s : ei e o M ) 5 c ei g f f ! b f f m y, r = r r C U L y a 1 d.0 m s o r o 1f4 S a j l ae. rrr L 2 a T 4 o 5 er

5 8

n sd 0 t w t o s t c S d-o lto o p A uol c E'I IC O t u O t c H iat o i N p o i p d 5 I e s npo si v E q_I i in nt g w g ioo tff y ( _P L O a.8 bo C IS 5r A ) p i J Htc U o A 2 o a f1c t0 O' 3 O 6 2 0 l 0 0 1i hO p M t tt 7 d dnm*o tomoo w _u. E o i ti( 3n(2 ot2 i a r t 0 O h0 i o m 9 0 n c mi N0 s.i in a - in n O2 n H100 pp

a A

C 1 N E C P 2 t C E 0 A B D-U R R A d M a M C I i Y L s M _E I R T dY Y 1 L D 5 T 4 0 c 3L rt C y D T E E M T Q ~~ ?A =T E D W l Oa O O l-W "t 5 n 7 e 9 e 1d ree .t r 5ai 1l vMEh t rx y-t pit n uee Afd p ai r dSc o e c C t rA S ao ES e dfn I N== i a CO= r ,s iI t 5i n u W= c 5 si. l e 7y C = n l - l sB u L= o l C =- i E 2 aeN

c. G -

Cnv r - t e Al o u D-se s S at E= e c u NeV O ! J i fa s: o d d ND= c n h o I U= I e 1 i r: tNde n i o 6 it dt= 5' i s. ot Cm'=%, f o i rlni c t f t u t el e: I = i q l s f alb 'e eFou FL= e o G k R" Ss I. R = A_ DN d d. O fUI-7 A B Q A-r= E-f= i c= U L= MD-I. E T-L A I. "t C_ F. 4 L= I A M= C ei 0 r t(=. g N O I TA CIFI L A 'Q J F r C l R 4 E A T C n A n o F L g O t,l! l:.

t.

d

'i E tt* W' Lle b. M@ j' t.l tJ iJ ;J i4 ;.1

8 t'

f

' = - * '

g a,, g

g f

R y f3 ? E es:3:s e'y yg3 ; rrrrrr g n k, k I iS E $ 7~$ $ $ $ ',f b lb r) k,, n two-o 8 iE t ? t, I 5 X p % i+ m i as ,.d ff JJ O *1f V W M b' ^ N l 1.6

t}

b M M b E j! EL E Q "' " e t e I Y t J e a t.l 4. E u, .s I

A at w

h d' j% I!3 51 b, in 1* fu a4]

$1 v

v ggOgMo y' r' <> <* re ji;} EE E n,gugM m n" o n, np gu h 8 F' 8 P' > ? "6 !? h 3 y; a i a A l 1: +

q g

M 14 'El M !$d f 4 l,d 1 m.

kh I?t h

l qil m n pn o tr e G n c-d' dl2 !F Ek W til T C, 9 O

l v-n I

i I QUALIFICftTIDM DEFICIENCIES PANNER OF Q1ALITICfsTICII QUALIFICATION DOCtIEJC AND RECXMENDED SOLUTIOiG b N3LB POLB NSLB WC & 9157 A. Defielencies i Ceeparison to Rosemount l'RKF

1) Qualified to >3NPF peak Temperature is h30 F 4

B. Solutions: e

1) In accordance with 79-OlB t

" Guidelines for Evaluatirg Environmental Qualification", page 7, para 6reph 4.2.1 i

Equipment goalified for a IDCA miremt is qmlified for a

cLB environment i

1 A 1 3 1 1 i r a.;4a. m. s. a. q, r -y y g 2 3 M 8 ~ ~ ~ - - -.. rg r g r + tt l y iny m o w d m; t JJ h + ?, o ? "' r P' P' "' [ [ k [n t 8 ennnun g n j Q l'1 O $1 p P-E. il l3 la

t u

e

m

\\" 9 Ii ll 1. 5 ,p; i., o m cv o r x 't, 'N ob !jc.' u r ; A.

r. ~

u

,,N e
u y

e s y g am e

e. r

&'l 8 5 !? l0 x 5 !Pi 5' li E w 3 th

5 o

& J 2 r e [r p n O R id j y ' *l i. 'n v gOfNO .5 k, o-c c s tt in ge s;> p1 v !,ft 8 !" W [j2 0 EE', 4 J h< n iN d: h R I:b 8 c h l N 'gt1 lip f5 f4 $+ b 3 p!g B i 10 ig 5 c ig t 1 iq g c m cn L Y ta l O O \\!Il l', lll1 ii l, ~ ~ 2 r 1 o, f "n -W s e e et r nt t e u hanl. t ce a ei mt t r df pnn e uwe iii al z ~ G qnr mEoo t rr O",ii 1 k vv 1l ae 0a1 nn S - t ee E3 p 3n2,Ab IN. 7e CO r.k C L m LI_ F ht ohIAC IM_ irp C 't CU IC wiaaa JS vr D C_ 1 s. d n pd d engrr F s e cEeoe e t n rff 4 D e ge C? M e7 r ri ee 2 IF_ e i0 ie ot.ii TW. 1 }9 f i cs7ff c A c t ~ ii C L i 1h u al el l I C. f s l acmm FE e us c nra IR D Qi S I Fpqq L s AD t U s QA w A. B C,_ F,_ 2 F.. C. II-M.- O. II-A- 7 C-5 I-1 F 9 I L s F-I-s-t A A. C M,=. y W N O I TAC I 1_ F a I i R n l U.. e;q F a O S W t s e T O}}

ML20126A893

Text

SUMMARY

Navigation menu

Search