ML20114F359
| ML20114F359 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Three Mile Island  |
| Issue date: | 09/17/1992 |
| From: | Jandovitz J, Torborg M GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20114F353 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9210130059 | |
| Download: ML20114F359 (82) | |
Text
-...
6 4
Attachmsnt 1 Revision 0 Page 1
- 1 I
i REPORT ON THE 1991 EDD1r CURRENT EXAMINATIONS OF THE THI-1 OTSG TUBING L
Prepared By:
/
/r _/
Mark T. Torbor I
(IN [
Approved Dy:
hnSg,dandovis'z y_f-7. Q F
9210130059 921004
}DR-ADOCK 05000289-AW1.TDR-.
PDR Wv r-5 s
am
+
nW ry---r 9$
Tap yb
e Attachm2nt 1 Rovision 0 Page 2 TABLE OF CONTENT 8 PAGE NO.
I.
11tTRODUCTION 4
II.
METHQDR 4
A.
DATA ACQUISITION 4
1.
General Tube Examinations.
5 2.
Lane /Wedae Examinations 5
3.
Specialized Tube Examinationg.
6 4.
Tube Sleeve Examinations 6
D.
DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS.
7 1.
Data Analyst Oualifications 7
2.
Data Analysis Secuence 7
3.
Data Analve,in Software 8
4.
Recordina of.Indicatio.ng 8
III.
OUTAGE 9R EXAMINATION CATECORIES.AND RESULTE 12 A.
EXA..INATIONS REQUIRED BY T.S.
4.19 12 1.
Ecoraded Tubgg 42 2.
Tech. Spec. Random Samples 17 D.
GPUN ELECTIVE EXAMINATIONS 18 1.
Tubes with Indications Not Confirmed by 8:t 1.
18 2.
Lanc/.Hedae Tubes (Pre-Sleeve Examinations) 19 3.
Lane /Wedae Tubes (Post-Sleeve Examinations) 21 4.
Tubes with PInvious Small Amolitude Indications 22 5.
Tubes with Previous Non-Relevant Indications 24 6.
Tubes with Distorted Suonort Indications 26 7.
Eggnected Leakina Tubes 12 7 8.
RXIIg.
28 C.
DISCUSSION OF RESULTS.
29 1.
Characterization of Indications.
29 2.
Re>iew of Previous Data 30 IV.
CONCLUSIO.Rg..
39 s
-1060ATTI.TDR.
-)
e Revision 0 Page 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continue (1 I
V.
REFERENCES 40 t
Figure II-1 THI-1 OTSG Outline
_10 Figure III-1 OTSG A Tubes Examined 9R 31-Figure III-2 OTSG B Tubes Examined 9R 32 Figure III-3 OTSO A Tubes Sleeved 9R.
33 f
Figure-III-4 OTSG B Tubes Sleeved 9R.
34 Figure III-5 Distribution of Indications By Axial Locations
' 3 5.
Figure III-6 Indication Rates By Region 36 Figure III-7 Distribution Of Indications By Percent Thru Wall 37 t
Figure III-B Distribution Of Indications By Amplitude 38
+
N Table 11-1 Listing of Probes Used During Outage 9R.
11 Table 112-1 Comparison of Indications in Degraded Tubes.
36 Table III-2 Comparison of Statistical Evaluation to Previous Evaluations 16 PAGES Appendix I DDR-4 Analysts Codes 3
Appendix II comparison of Previous Exam Results.-........
15 Appendix III Tubes Plugged During Outage 9R 2'
Appendix IV Tubes With Indications 220% Through Wall.
13 Appendix v Outline of Data Analyst Indoctrination 2
Appendix VI Tuben Sleeved During 9R.
6
+
l l
i,-
I L
a e
i Revision 0 Pago 4 I
I.
11GRQP_ MCI 19E l
During Octcbor 1991, whilo TM1-1 was uhut-down for Hofueling. Outage 9R, GPUN performod Eddy Current (ECT) examinations of tho once Through Stoam Generators (OTSGs). The Lcope of tho examinations includod tubing, plugs and sloovos.
Tho tubing examinations woro required by Technical Specification 4.19 (Referenco 1), and CPUN ongincoring requirements.
During Outage 9R, a total of 1792 cxaminations woro performed on 1243 tubos in j
OTSG A and 1519 oxaminations woro performed on 966 tubos in OTSG D.
Based on thoso examinations, one tube in OTSG A and two tubes in OTSG D were removed from service by plugging.
This brings the total number of plugged tubos to 1268 in OTSG A and 372 in OTSG B.
This report was prepared to satisfy the reporting requirements of Technical _
specification 4.19,5.b (Reference 1)..The data was extracted from GPUN TDR 1068 (Referenco 10)
II.
tiEIll0Da A.
phTA_ACOUISJI1Q1(
The Eddy Current (ECT) Examinations woro performed using the Zotoc M11-18, Digital Multi-Frequency Eddy Current System. The data was recorded on digital tapo and later coplod to optical discs for data analysis.
The examinations woro performed remotoly using D&W " ROGER" in-head fixturos and Zotoc Model 4D probo puchots.
During thin outago, "ROGTR" fixturos were installed in all four OTSG heads permitting the examinacion of plugs in both the uppor and lower tuboshoots and allowing the examination of tubing from either head.
This arrangement also.
permitted the examination of tubos from tho. lower head while tubo sleovos woro being installed in the upper head.
This is the first time ECT oxaminations have been dono from the lower head at TMI-1.
The ECT examinations utilized a variety of techniques and probos which wore tailored to the specific area being examined. The examinations woro performed under GPUN surveillanco procedure 1300-4B (Reference 5) and are discussed in the following section.
The specific probo models used aro. listed on Tablo II-1, l
1068ATTI.TDR-
...a...
_ _.. _ _.- _,_..__.___,_..,_..~.._,;_.
Revision 0 page 5-A.1 Epy ral Tube Examinations The general examination of the tubing material is performed from the inside of the tubos using the bobbin coil probo, This prebo is the noct durable probe available and permits examining the tubos at speeds up to 24 inches por second.
The data from the bobbin coil probes is used for the detection of most types of degradation including ICA, ICSCC, tube to support plate wear and can also be used to measure tubo diameters and profilos.
In the case of tubes with no previous degradation, the examination is-performed using a.510" diamotor probe with an examination speed of 24 inchos por second.
For tubes with previous _ indications, the examination is performed using a.540" diameter probo at a speed of 12 inches per second,_ This.540" diameter probo is also used to disposition indications recorded as 30% through wall or greater using tho.510" dianctor probo.
Following the bobbin coil examinations, tubes with indications 40%
througn wall or greater are examined using an 8x1-ADS probo.
This probo has eight independent coils, referred to as pancake coils, which are especially suited for the detection of circumferentially oriented degradation.
The 8x1-ABS probe is less durable than the bobbin probo and also requires a slower speed of 6 inches por second during data acquisition.
The data from the 8x1-ABS probe is evaluated to confirm the relevancy of the bobbin coil indications and is also used to determino the circumferential extent of the degradction.
(Referenco 8)
The !inal disposition of the tubes is based on the eddy curront results (bobbin coil and 8x1-ABS), tho axial location of the degradation, and the location of the tube within the tubo bundle.
Tho eddy current input is based on the percent throuch wall as determined by the bobbin coil probe and the circumferential_ extent as determined by the 8x3-ABS probe.
1 A.2 Lano/Wedae Examinati2HE The tubes in_the lane / wedge region of the OTSGs are subject to high cycle f atigue f ailures at the 14";and 35" tube support plates and at the secondary face of the upper tube sheet. These failures occur very rapidly during OTSG operation and_the detection'of part through wall,-
high cycle fatigue is considered unlikely; however, the significance of a high cycle fatigue. failure warrants performing specialized examinations which are designed to detect-both high' cycle fatigue and-its precursors.
The fat. ares typically occur at the edges of_the support. structures _and--
are circumferentially oriented ~hich limits the sensitivity of the w
bobbin coil probe in this area. To overcome the limitations of the-bobbin coil probe, those arcas are examined using a pancake coil probe.
The coil orientation and surface riding design of the pancake coil probe improve.the sensitivity for detecting circumferential flaws and minimize 1068ATT1.TDR d'.
a e
4 Revision 0 Page 6 the negativo offects of the support structures or any denting which may be present.
At present, thoro are two basAc designs of pancake coil probes available for this examination, tho 8x1-ADS probe and the Motorigod Rotating Pancake Coil (MRPC) probo.
The 8x1-ADS probo has been used for.this examination sinco 1988-7R and was used for the majority of those examinations during Outage 1991-9R.
The 8x1-ADS probo has always been prona-to mechanical failure and has inheront limitations in the extent of coverago around the tube's circumferenco.
Those shortcomings have lod to an industry wide phane out of the Bx1-ABS probo and its replacement with the MRPC probo.
The MRPC probe is designed to be more durable than the 8x1-ADS probe, provides completo coverago of the tube's circumferenco and provides the best data analysis capabilitics of the available probos.
The MRPC probo's data acquisition process is more complex and slower than the 8x1-ABS probe (0.2"/sec versus 6"/soe) which requires a chango in the data acquisition motnods.
In recognition of this, the HRPC probe was used to examine about 40 lano/ wedge tubos in cach OTSG to determine the feasibility of replacing the 8x1-ADS probe with the MRPC probo.
A.3 Dimp,1.f111 red Tube Examinations During the conduct of examination using both the bobbin coil and Ux1-ABS probos, ambiguous indications aro detected and require further ovaluations.
Those indications are resolved by examining tho suspect area using tho MRPC probo and correlating the results of the various examinations to determine the disposition of the tubo.
A.4
'Lybe Slarve Exantinationi During Outage 9R, GPUN installed tube sleeves in 125 tubes in each OTSG, In support of the 81covo installation, eddy current examinations woro performed both prior to and after sloovo installation.
Sinco all of the tubes to be sleeved were part of the lano/ wedge region, no. additional examinations were required prior-to alcoving; however, additional data analysis was required.
The additional data analysis consisted of measuring the diamotor of the tube in the locations where the sleevo roll expansions are to be placed',
This process, referred to as " Bobbin-Profilometry" was performed using the data from tho.510" bobbin coil probe, Following the sleeve installation, tho.431 inch innor diameter sleeves were examined using a 400 inch diamotor combination bobbin coil and cross axis coil probo with a fill factor of 86%.
This probo.was used to examino both the parent tubing and the sleeve material for degradation.
In addition, the data was evaluated to measure the diamotor of the roll l
expansions-using the " Bobbin-Profilometry" process.
I l
1068ATTI.TDR
_ _ _ -. _ _. _,. _. _. ~ -
.u._..,
_._...u,__,,
/7 Revision 0 Page 7 D.
DATA _ ANALYSIS PROCESS The data emalysis process is baJed on the recommendations of the EPRI
/WR Steam Generator Inspection Guidelines (Reference 6).
The process included the use of written interpretation guidelines, which are filed with the examination data site specific training and testing and independent two party analysis of the data.
B1 Data Analyst oualifications The data analysis process was performed by a combination of B&W and Conam Huclear personnel qualified and certified to at least Level IIA, in accordance with their approved programs. As a supplement to this qualification, site specific indoctrination and training was attended by all data analyst personnel.
The program included both classroom Icetures and hands on practice using oddy current data and experience from both TMI and another B&W designed plant.
The training covered generic OTSG degradation mechanisms and examination methods and aleo specifically addressed both the Bobbin Coil and 8x1 Absolute methods which aro used at TMI.
The total indoctrination process encompassed approximately 16 hours1.851852e-4 days <br />0.00444 hours <br />2.645503e-5 weeks <br />6.088e-6 months <br /> and was conducted by the designated lead analyst.
At the completion of the indoctrination, each data analyst was required to pass a performance demonstration for each method to be analyzed. Appendix VI is an outline of the program.
B.2 Data Analysis Secuence The data analysis procons was performed in accordance with the same s
guidelines used for the data analyst indoctrination and training.
The process was performed-in three (3) parts with at least'two-(2)' separate-data analysts evaluating 100% of the data for each examination.
The only exception to this was the tube profilometry examinations, performed for tube sleeving, which received only a single analysis.
The data analysis process included:
1.
Primary Aanlygla:
The primary analysis-included a 100%
evaluation of the ECT data and the recording of all attributes identified in_ Appendix I.
_This analysis included recording the phase angle, percent through. wall, voltage,-
circumferential extent and' location of the indications.
2.
Sgpondarv Analysis: The secondary analysis also included a 100% review of the ECT_ data for the attributes identified in Appendix I.
This analysis, performed as a blind review, was performed in the same manner as the orimary analysis.
1068ATTI.TDR.
q
Attachm nt 1 Revision O' Page 8 3.
Ensolutl.on Analysis: To completo the analycia procese, the results of both the primary and secondary analyses are reviewed by the designated lead afinlyst.
This review combines the primary and secondary analyses results and niso resolves any discrepancies.
For Outago 1991-9R, this function was perforned by a Level III Data Analyst.
B.3 pata Analysis Software The dats from the tubing examinations was ovaluated using the Tetec Eddynet Analysis software, Version 2-Revision 1, for the primary, secondary and resolution anslysis.
The pre-sleeving and post-eleeving tubo diameter checks Woro evaluated using the Zetec DDA-4, Fevision 12, Tube Sheet Profilometry software.
D.4 ggcordina of Indications when analyzing the oddy current data, various indications are recorded by the data analyst.
These indications fall into two basic groupL,
" Indications from Tube Wall Degradation" and " Indications from Possible Damage Precursors". A complete list of all abbreviations and definitions used to classify indications is included as Appendix I.
Indications from Tube Wall Dearadation During the evaluation of the ECT data from bobbin coil examinations, indications of tube wall degradation are recorded by "porcent through wall" or by a throo letter code to indicato a probable flaw.
Indications which are recorded as 40% T.W. or greator, DNI, DSI, DRI, DTI or NQI are all re-examined using a pancake coil probo (8xl-ADS or MRPC).
The indication la then dispositioned based on the combined results of the two probes.
Indications which are from 20-39% through wall are. recorded for monitoring during future examinations.
In addition, a one volt recording threshold has been established'for inner diameter initiated indications.
Indications below this threshold are recorded as "BVC" and are monitored during subsequent examinations.
In the case of outor diameter-indications of less than one volt, a pancake coil examination is performed following the initial dotection of the ind! cation.
If the indication is determined to be acceptable based on the combined results of the bobbin coil and pancake coil examinations, the tube remains in service and can be monitored as a
'BVC", using the bobbin coil probe, during subsequent oxaminations.
1068ATT1.TDR
,.__-..u_
L Revision 0 Page 9 Indications from Possible Damaae Recursors l
The analysis of the eddy current data also identifica indications which are not attributed to tube wall degradation.
These indications may be i
the results of irregularitics in-the tube wall profilo (IDC), changes in the magnetic permeability (PVH), denting (DNT) or other changes not related to tube wall degradation. These indications are recorded ~for information only and do not require follow-up examinations.
Indications Recorded durina Snocialized Examinations The data analysis for specialized examinations such as 8x1-ABS or MRPC probos requires a process which is different-than the bobbin coil examinatione.
In the case of these examinations, the data is typically.
ovaluated to confirm a previously recorded indication.
As such, the data is recorded to support dispositioning a given indication by length, size, depth or location on a case by case basis.
Indication Locations:
The locations of the ECT indications are recorded to identify their "olevation* or ' axial location" in tho OTSGs.
_For-free span indications the locations are recorded in inchos above "+' the tuboshoo; surfaces or tube support plato center.
For-indications located within or adjacent to the tube support plates, the indications are recorded as *+" or * " from the center of the T.S.P.
The.relativo locations of the tubesheets and tubo support plates (T.S.P.) are shown in Figuro II-1.
l l
l L
1068ATT1.TDR c, _ -._
..._.a_.,,
~.
Revision 0
)
Page 10 FIGURE 11-1 TMI-1 OTSG LONGITUDINAL SECTION 36" INLET--
~
16'MAPMAY 6"lNSPECT10N HOLE ETANCE ECT (INCHES)
DESIGNATIOtJ UPPERTUBE SHEETa '
24.0 nem m
Ollllllllllllllllll ou e
16.631 tNCONEL TUBES -
36.0 lllllllllllllllll'"
="
y ""IlllP' 38,0 011 1
36.0 40.0
's'"S*^f!?"Lk lL E
S 39.0 y
008 007 I
39.0 006 37.0 006 39.0 004 l
40.0 003 el!!llllll l..a ll 002
- lllllllllll lllll ill
- 6.0 LONERTUBE SHEET g73 24.0 28" OUTLETS (2 16* MANWAY SUPPORT SKIRT. -e-
--..m.-
ew-m
-,e
-w-m we 7
y.7
-.c.
e.-.
.,_m p
Attachnient 1 Revision 0 Page 11 TASLE II-1 LISTING OF PROBES USED DURING OUTAGE 9R PRODE COIL NAME ffsOBE MODEL COIL DESIGN DIAMETER USE Bobbin A-540-LC/NF/M/HF Boubin
.540" Tubes with Indications Differential Dobbin A-510-LC/NF/M/flF Bobbin
.510" Tubos without Indication 1 Differential Profilometry Exams Bx1-ABS BC-5240-555-A0187 Pancako
.187" Lano/Wodge 8-Coil Tubos with Indications Absolute MRPC B-510-MRPC/PH Pancako
.125" Lano/Wodge 1-Coil Tubes with Indications Absolute MRPC B-520-MRPC-3C/7Pil Pancako
.125" Lano/ Wedge 3-Coil Tubos with Indications Absoluto L;dDO 2AX-400-6FLC/DIFF Bobbin /
.400*
Installed Bloovos X-Axis Differential All PRODES WERE MANUFACTURED BY ZETEC INC.
l 1068ATT1.TDR l'
.-_.., _.. _ _ ~..... _
.- ~
i
Attechment 1 i
Revision 0 Page 12 III.
QVIAgjL1]Lg&MI NARQ1LCMK99MER_ANDE6ETE r
The locations of the tubes and plugs examined during Outago 9R are shown on Figures III-1 through III-4.
The examinations were performed in two major groups, based on the examination requirement.
A.
Examinations Roquired by Technical Specification 4.19 D.
GPUN Electivo Examinations These groups aro further divided into specific categories of tubes.
This section definos the examination scopo, purpose and examination results by category. When classifying the tubes by examination category, some tubos may satisfy the criteria for more than one category and may need to be examined with more than one probe.
In those cases, the tube is placed into the first category which applies following the sequence of this report.
As a result of this sequence, some tubes may appear to be missing from a catoe,ary because they were previously examined.
For examsdo, a lano/ wedge tube may.have been examined as r
'SI tube and will not be re-examined as a lano/ wedge tubo.
A.
EXAMINATIONS _BEOUIRED BY TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION 4ill A-1 PREVIOUSLY DEGRADED TUDES Data Sets:
ISI, ISI-8R Probo:
.540" - Bobbin Ext =at:
Full Length SCOPE In OTSG "A", 286 tubes were examined.
In OTSG "B", 39 tubes were examined.
REASON FOR EXAMINATION The examination of the "Dograded" tubes serves a dual purpose.
First, new examination results are compared to the results of previous examinations to determine if there is evidence of an active degradation mechanism occurring in the OTSGs.
Second, the examination provides assurance that no tubes with indications exceeding the plugging criteria remain in service.
I 1068ATTI.TDR
Revision 0 pago 13
,gCTION CRIT.EElh The 'Dograded Tube
- population was solocted to moet the requirements of Technical Specification 4.19.2.a.1 which requires tho examination of all J
incorvice tubos which have previously identified tube wall degradation of 20%
T.W. or greator.
During the period of loS1 to 1988-7R, tubos were scrooned with the bobbin coil probo nd all indications woro then oxamined using the 8x1-ADS probo.
Tubos with. dications a20% T.W. which woro confirmed by the ax1-ADS probo were then cor::dorod to be degradod and woro included in this population. Those tubos a identified as the sub group of *ISI".
one of the inhoront limitations of tho 8x1-ADS probe is the variability of the oddy current field based on the coil to discontinuity orientation.
This variability is most pronounced for small discontinuities and using tho above=
method, tubos with small indications tended to drop in and out of the "Dograded ';ubo" population.
To reduce this variability, starting with the 1990-8R examinations, all insarvice tubos with bobbin coil indications of 20-39% through wall are included in this category.
RCSULTS The results of the 9R exmainations of the "Dograded* tubos. wore consistent with previous examination results.
The majority of the previously identified indications showed no evidence of change from previous examinations, In two j
casos however, the reported t through wall values excooded tho.catablished plutging critoria and the tubos wero-romoved from service.
OTSG A ono (1) tubo (A-95-126) had an indication of >40% through wall in the froospan portion of the tubo and was removed from service by plugging.- The indicatien in this tubo was 1-coll in circumferential extent.
CTSG D Ono (1) tubo (D-24-63) had an indication of >40% through wall in the freospan portion of the tuba and was removed from service by plugging.
The indication in this tube was 1-coil in circumferential extent.
TRENDING OF I.D.
INDICATIONS
~
To monitor for evidence of continulug dogradation of identified indications, t,1 1991*9R oxamination results woro compared to the 1990-8R results. =The indications included in this comparison were previously recorded indications with through wall values of 16% lor greator in both 1991-9R and 1990-8R.
The breakdown o' the indications is shown in Table 1 and Appendix II.-
In "A" OTSG, 190 indications mot the above critoria.
The mean chango in the indications was -2.2% of wall thickness betwoon 8R and 9R (standard deviation 7.28% of wall).
The amplitude of those indications showed a mean chango'of
-0.08 volta (standard deviation 0.34 volts),
96k"4
-w
-em
-ver' e&
WT 96-dwe er+d-m bw'-r
=s'i g
-4
'=
-W'rt vT
-P'***
11 9 T'-
'TTN' "W*1T*""*
- 'T 4
"f7-
'Y'*f=9*-'$aye
-tyw+ v yw--1-^-7w' w
^
y-
-g-W
Revision 0 Page 14 In "B" OTSG, 39 *ar41 cations met (
criteria.
The average change in the indications was -0.8% of wa?1 thickness between BR and 9R (standard deviation 5.02% of wall).
The amplitude of those indicatione showed a mean change of
-0.01 volta (standard deviation 0.07 volts).
When combined, the averago chant,, por indication for both OTSGw was -2.0% of wall (standard deviation 6.96% of wall). The mean amplitude change was 0.07 volts (standard deviation 0.31 volts).
To determino the significance of those changes, the data was compared to similar ovaluations performed during previous examinations.
Dased on this comparison (see Table 2) in which the mean chane,e has been both positivo (apparent increase in the depth of the indicatAons) and negative (apparent decrease in the depth of the indications), ths identified changes are considered to be within the qualified repeattbility of the CCT process, and do not indicato a trend of ongoing degradation This variability is discussed in Reference 3.
i 1068ATT1.TDR
- - - -. - ~, ~
... - -..... -,. -... -. _ _. -.. ~ - ~..-. -.. _. - -._.
Regision 0 Pago 15 TABLE !!1-1 COMPARISON 0" INDICATIONS IN DEGRADED TUBES NUMBER OF TUDES l
OTSG A OTSG B TOTAL Degraded Tubo Population 286 39 325 included in Comparison
- l'1 26 167 Excluded from Comparison **
145 13 158 Comparison includos only indicationo >16% T.W.
in'BR-and 9R.
Excluded indications were not recorded as >16% T.W.
in BR DI 9R.
%.Throggh Wall Cgmoarison No Indu No. Inds No. Indo Hoan Std Nutuber
% T.W.
T.W.
% T.W.
Chango Deviation Indica-Increased Decreased Unchanged
% T.W.
-t T.W.
OTSC tioha 8R-9R BR-9R BR-9R BR-9R BR-9R 1
A 190 76 97 17
-2.2 7.28 8
39 14 16 9
-0.8 5.02 Doth 229 90 113 26
-2.0 6.96 A&D Amnlitudo colpnarison No. Inds No. Inds No Inds.
Mean Std Number Volte Volte Volta Chango Deviation Indica-Incrossed Decreased Unchanged Volts Volts OTSG tion OR-9R BR-9R 8R-9R 8R-9R BR-9R A
190 129 57 4
-0.08 0.34 D
39 16 21 2
-0.01 0.07 Doth 229 145 78 6
-0.07 0.31 AEB r
1068ATT1.TDR.
g A..<,
.-n.'.
s.
m
.-e.,
.-m
.v.,
-,.wr-,
,,wx n,,, -,
--,e--g
~,-a--w.
4,
p vl, a,n p -w yn.,,
m Revision 0 Page 16 TABLE III-2 COMPARISON OF STATISTICAL EVALUATION TG PREVIOUS EVALUATIONS Number Mean STD Maan
'*D Indica-Chango Deviation Change stion Period cioni.
% T.W.
% T.W.
Volta
.s 1994/1986-5M 152
-2.6 6.1
-0.2 0.3 1986-SM/1986-6R 118
+1.1 6.6 0.0 0.2 a
1986-6R/1988-7R 119
+2.6 5.5
+0.2 0.3 1968-7R/1990-8R 291
+0.2 7.43
-0.25 0.35 1990-8R/1991-9R 225
-2.0 6.96
+0.07 0.31 e
_ E 1984/1991-9R*
73
-2.8 7.65 F
Previous data extracted from GPUN TDR 1026, Revision 0 (Referenco 7).
HQIU1 For oitagen 1984 through 1988-7R, all indtrations were examined with both the 8x1-ABS and.540" bobbin coil probes and only indicat's 2.9% T.W.
and confirmed by both probes were included.
[
This cr.teo<
ainsed the data by elAminating indications which showed a w Anase in % T.W. or were affected by the variability of tho 8x1-ABS probe.
For 1990-8R and 1991-9R, all indications 216%
gg_
eg.
T.W. were includ4A, which allows for the variability of tho procesa end accounts for the increased number of indications.
Indications selected ucing 1991-9R criteria.
Voltage data not in computer data base for 1984, 1068ATTI.TDR
_yws g _ -
m Revision 0 i
Page 17 A-2 TECH. SPEC. RANDOM SAMPLES Data Sets:
3%-TS Probo:
.510" Dobbin,.540" Dobbin (Limited)
Extenti Full Length ECREG In OTSG "A", 468 ubes were examined.
In OTSG "B", 470 tubeh ero examined.
FVASGN FOR EXAtilNATION The tubci. in this sample have no history of degradation below the kinetic expansion, They are examined to monitor the overall condition of the steam genetator tubing.
%$CTION CRITERIA nitial sample included at least 3% of all the tubes in each OTSG.
As ved by *.S.
4.19.2.a.2, at least 50% of the tubes were located in the m.
perip.e ar of the OTSG which is an area where experience has indicated cial problems.
(The outer periphery is defined as the tubes located
.s
- e the radius of the outer support rods).
The remaining tubes wero eted to provido a representative sample of the tube bundle.
As directed by Engineering, the samples were selected to include tubes which have not been examined since the 1984 examinations (65%) and tubes which had bef. examined since 1984 (35%).
ECB]lV20 QISG A In OTSG A, the examination of the 3% T.S.
samplo revealed indications exceeding 20% through wall in two 'ubes (A-1-14 and A-49-110).
The indications in both of theta cubos woro recorded as 23% through wall and the tubos will be added to the degraded tube population of the next examination, QTSC D In OTSG B, the examination of the 3% samplo did not reveal any indicat. tons exceeding 20% through wall. One tube (B-121-7) had a small amplitude I.D.
signal recorded as a DVC (Bolow Voltage Criteria) and will be scheduled for rc~ examination during the next examination.
r 1068ATT1.TDR
Revision 0 Page 18 B.
gfUN ELECTIVE EXAMIMATIONS D-1 IEBES WITH INDICATIONS NOT CONFIRMED BY 8x1 ADSOLUTE EXAM IN PREVIOUS EXAMINATIQlm Data Set:
8x1ACC Probe:
.540" Bobbin Extent:
Full Length SCOPE In OTSG "A",
I tube was examined.
In OTSG "B", 0 tubes were examined.
BEASQN,_IOR EXN11 NATION O
This tube was examined to continue monitoring the status of the previously recorded indications.
EFU CTION CRITERIA Since 1981, GPUN has used a two step process to identify and disposition indications.
In this precess, indications are screened using ths bobbin coil probe and are confirmed usi ug the Ex1-ABS probe.
Indications which are screened by the bobbin probe but are not confirmed by the 8x1-ABS probe are considered to be either relevant indications which are below the required threshold of detection or non-relavant indications caused by something other than tube wall degredatian.
The tubes with these indications are placed in this category until additional data becomes available and the tubes are either repaired, moved to other categories or returned to the general tube population.
This tube has an indication which appears as 40% through wall or greater using the borbin coil probe, but appears to be non-relevant using the 8x1-ABS probe.
In the future, only tubes with indications which appear 240% through wall by bobbin probe, but are determined to be tci-relevant by other orober,, will be included in this category.
Tubes with indications <40% through wall will be examined as "ISI" tubes.
RESULTS OTSG A In OTSG A, the indication being monitored in tube A-36 103 continues to appear as a non-relevant indication based on the 8xl-ABS probe. This tube will be monitored during the next examination.
OTSG B There are no tubes in this ca.cgory in OTSG B.
1068ATT1.TDR
-J
. 4 a.
-Attachacnt 1L
~
-Revision 0-Page 19 1
B-2 LANE /WEDGEJUBES IPRE-SLEEVE EXAMINATIONS);
Data Set:
Lano/ Wedge, Sleevebase j
Probe:
.510" Dobbin Extent:
.510" Bobbin Co'il - Full Length 8x1-ABS - 14th T.S.P.
co Upper Tube Sheet' MRPC 14th T.S.P.,
15th T,S.P.,
UTS Face SCOPE
- i In OTSG "A":
.510 Bobbin - 206 Lane / Wedge tubes, 198 Sloovebase tubes, 8x1-ABS - 393 tubes j
MRPC - 22 tubes In 0TSG "B":
.510 Bobbin - 214 Lane / Wedge Tubes, 199 Sleevebase Tubes,-
8x1-ABS 385 tubes MRPC - 32 tubes REASON FOR E. AMINATION OTSGs have typically experienced degradation in the lanc/ wedge tubes.
In-consideration of possible accelerated degradation in this area, GPUN clected to examine all of-the lane / wedge tubes in accordance with Paragraph 4.19.2.a.4(1) of the TMI-1 Technical Specifications (Reference 1).
In addition to the regular flaw analysis, the bobbin coil data from the "SLEEVEBASE" data set was also-analyzed to metsure the tubo diameters in support of the sleeve installation task.
The 8x1-ABS'and hRPC examinations were performed to examine.the tubing at the-14* and 15" tube support plates and at the f ace of the upper tubesheet. The examinatient1were originally scheduled to be performed from the upper head q
using the 8x1-ABS probot however, the tubes located under the indexing fixture-
=
were cy'imined from the lower head using the MRPCiprobe, The MRPC~ probe is considered equivalent to-the'8x1-ABS probe and was used to compare the-'apeed' and durability of using the MRPC probe in place of the Bx1-ABS probe.
ELECTION CRITERIA This examination included all incorvice tubes in the Lane and Wedge area
.The lane area includes the tvb's in three rows c9 cach side of theTopen inspection lune (73, 74,- 75, 77,
~3,
- 9) from: tube 1 to the center of the OTSG, The i
wedge tubes _ tre the -baos included in the wedge formed by drawing-a line from Row 66 Tube 1sto Row 75 Tube 15 andLfrom Row 86 Tube 1 to Row 77 Tube-15.
Sc '-
Figures III-5 and III-6.
s 1068ATT1.TDR J
", + =.
~
,e-~
m-e-s, o
re,---
ne
Revision 01 Pace-20 BESULTS OTsc A-In OTSO A, the defect analysis identified a 37% through wall indication in one tube (A-66-1).
This tube had previously been examined as an ISI tube (Section A-1); therefo:0, no additional action was required.
In addition, two other tubes (A-74-23 and A-75-26) had indications (BVC and DST) recorded.. Normally these indications would require follow-up examinations; however, since both indications were repaired through the normally planned sleeving, no additional actions were taken, i
The evaluation of the tube diameters for the "SLEEVEBASE" tubes revealed no unacceptable conditions and the data was turned over to the Sleeving Task l
Manager.
l OTSG B In OTsG B, suspected tube wall degradation was identified in four'of the tubes. This degradation included tube support plate to tube wear in two tubes (B-75-2 and B-75-4).
The wear in tube B-75-2 was located at the 4",
5",
and 6" tube support plates and, based on follow-up MRPC examinations, was L
determined to have a maximum depth of 28% through wall at the 5" tube support plate.
Since this area could not bo repeired by existing sleeving methods, the tube was preventively plugged.
In tube B-75-4, the wear w(s located at the 15" tube support plate and based on the MRPC, the wear was determined to be 37%-through wall. This tube was sleeved as part of the original sleeving scope, which repaired this area of the tube.
One tube (B-75-23) had a-distorted tubesheet indication reported at tne face of the upper tube sheet.
This indication was not confirmed by either the 8x1-ABS or MRPC probes and the tube was preventively sleeved as part of the original sleeving scope.
The fourth tube with an indication was tube D-74-43.
This tube had a 1-coil 8x1-ABS indication ' recorded at the 15" tube support plate.
This indication was not confirmed by the MRPC probe; however,.the suspect area was preventively l
sleeved.
The evaluation of the profilometry data for the "SLEEVEDASE" tubes and tube B-l 74-43 revealed no unacceptable conditions and the data was turned over'to.the L
Sleeving Task Manager.
COMPARISON OF 8x1-ABS AND MRPC L
The comparison of the 8x1-ABS and MRPC prutes indicated the overall exami.ation speed was the same for both probes. The 8x1-ABS required-a longer set-up time with a faster examination rate than the MRPC.
The tube sample size was not large enough to evaluate the probe durability.
t L
L l
L 1068ATTI.TDR l
4 4
Revision 0 Page 21 B-3 LANE / WEDGE TUBES (POST-SLEEVE EXAMINATIOUS)
Data Set:
Post-Sleeve Prebe:
.400" Combination Bobbin Coil and Cross Axis Probe Extent:
Lower Sleeve End to Upper Tube End SCOPE In OTSG "A",
125 sleeves were examined, In OTSG "B", 125 sleeves were examined.
BEASON FOR EXAMINATION Fo}lowin the installation of tube sleeves, eddy current examinations are performed to verify the diameters of the roll expansions and to verify there are to unacceptable flaws in the pressure boundary.
EELECTION CRITERIA All sleeves which are installed in the TMI-l OTSGs were included in this examination.
EMLLIE OTSG A and B No tube wall or sleeve degradation was identified during this examination.
The sleeve expansion profilometry results were submitted to the Sleeving Task Manager for evaluation The engineering evaluation identified three sleeves in OTSG B with expansjons exceeding the acceptance criteria of the sleeve
-installation procedure.
These expansions were determined to be within the design parameters of the B&W sleeve and were accepted to be used "as is" and documented on MNCR-91-0042 (Reference 9).
1068ATTI.TDR
L.;
-Attachment il
. Revision 0-Page 22
- B-4 TUBES WITH PREVIOUS SHALL AMPLITUDE INDICATIONS Data Set:
S/N-OLD, S/N, Probe:
.540" Bobbin,.510" Dobbin Extentt-Full iength SCOPE In OTSG
'A", 71 tubes were examined.
In OT3G "B",
26 tubes wc;c examined.
REASON FOR EXAMINATION These the tubes were examined to verify the minor nature of the indications.
SELECTION CRITERIA During OTSG examinations performed during 1986-5M through 1990-8R, poor._ signal to noise ratio (S/N) indications of less than 1.0 volt have-been detected and evaluated using the bobbin coil probe.
During the examinations performed in outages 1986-SM, 1986-6R and 1988-7R, these S/N indications were also examined using the 8x1-ABS probe and any tubes with indications confirmed by the-8x1-ABS probe were re-examined during the subsequent outage.
Those tubes with indications not confirmed by the 8x1-ABS probe were returned to the general sample.
Starting with the 1990-8R outage and continuing this outage (1991-9R), GPUN no longer.uses-the 8x1-ABS probe to confirm these less than 1.0 volt indications.
Instead, all less than 1.0 vo.it indications, with phase angles of;6' to 110*
and a signal to noise ratio of less than 3:1, are recorded as "BVC" (Below Voltage Critoria) for monitoring'during future-examinations.
These indications are considered relevant indications; however, the amplitude and signal to. noise ratio prevents assigning an accurate through wall depth, The inclusion of all indications, whether or not they were confirmed by the ax1-ABS probe, is intended to improve the repeatability of the examination process by eliminating the variabllity in the discontinuity to' coil orientation, which is an-inherent limitation of the 8x1-ABS probe.
This variability is significantly less of a factor with the bobbin probe thereby improving-the repeatability of the examination.
JAs=a result of the above changes, the data set of tubes-called S/N-OLD was
. examined in: addition to the S/N' data set.
The S/N-OLD data set contains-tubes with previously recorded S/N indicationsi which have;not been confirmed byithe+
8x1-ABS probe, and have not been monitored during subsequent outages. -With the inclusion of this data set,.all tubes with previouslyLrecorded indications, which-are considered relevant based on the signal-amplitude-and phase angle, were scheduled for examinations.
1068ATTI.TDR-
Attachmsnt 1 Revision 0 Page 23 BESULTS OTSG A The indications in 25 of the 71 tubes continued to appear as relevant indications but are below the threshold for evaluating the percent through wall depth and the indications were recorded as "BVC" (Delow Voltage Critoria). The indications in these 25 tubes will centinue to be-roonitored during the next examination.
In 16 of the 71 tubes, the-indications were outside the recording criteria, but, the tubes will be re-examined during the next outage based on the 1988-7R or 1990-BR examination results.
In the 30 remaining tubes, the indications are outside the recording criteria for relevant indications and no indications have been recorded since 1986-6R.
OTSG B In 15 of the 36 tubes, the indications were recorded as "BVC" and will be-monitored during the next examination. The indicatione in 5 of the 36 tubes were outsido the recording critoria but will be monitored during the next examination based on the 1988-7R or 1990-8R examination results.
In the remaining 16 tubes, the indications are outside the recording criteria for relevant indications, and no indications have been recorded since 1986-6R.
I 1068ATTI.TDR l.
i; L
Revision 0 Page 24 i
B-5 TUBES WITH PREVIOUS NON-PEISVANT INDICATIONS Data Set:
GE-20-OLD Probe:
.510" Dobbin Extent:
Full Length SCOPE In OTSG "A",
7 tubes were examined.
In OTSG "B",
6 tubes were examined.
RJASON FOR EXAMINATION These tubes were examined to confirm there are no relevant indications of 20%
through wall or greater.
SELECTION CRITERIA During previous examinations, indications have been detected and evaluated, using the bobbin coil probe, and determined to be 20% through wall or greater.
Subsequent 8x1-ABS examinations have not confirmed the indications and, therefore, they are considered to be non-relevant indications.
Since the indications were not confirmed by 8x1-ABS, only those indications which measured 40% through wall or greater were monitored as 8x1-ACC tubes during subsequent outages.
Experience has shown, however, that the variability of the 8x1-ABS probe may change the disposition of these tubes from outage to outage. To reduce this variability, all tubes with previously identified indications, evaluated as 20%-39% through wall or greater using the bobbin coil prole, were re-examined during this outage, RESULTS 2
OTSG A In OTSG A, one of the seven tubes had an indicatjon evaluated as 20%-39%
through wa11.
This tube, A-126-1, sill be considered a degraded tube during the next outage. One tube, A-90-118, had an indication of 40% through wall or greater recorded during outage 1988-7R.
This indication has been outside the recording criteria for relevant indications in both outage 1990-8R and 1991-9R, therefore, the tube will be examined ab an 8x1-ACC tube during the next outage.
In three tubes (A-99-62, A-132-7 and A-136-29), the previously recorded indications have been outsids the recording criteria in both outages 1990-8R and 1991-9R.
These tubes will also be re-examined during outage 10R.
In the two remaining tubes, (A-119-94 and A-106-69), the previously recorded indications have been outside the recording criteria for relevant indications for three consecutive examinations.
106dATT1.TDR
- - - ~..-.-.--
. ~.. ~.
-Attachment-1 Revision 0 Pago 25-'
i
- 0TSG_J!
In UTSG B, tne' indication in one tube (B-24-11) was evaluated as_.30% through' wall using the bobbin r:oll probe. This tube will be examined as a degraded-
. tubo during the next outago.
The indications in the. remaining five-tubes--
(B-30-47, B-57-53,'B-104-2, B-104-7 and B-112-85) were not recordable and have been outside the recording criteria for-relevant indications for three
-l consecutive outoges.
a l
l
..I t
l l
(.-
4 i
l l-1.
u i
1058ATT1.TDR
. ~ -
e.,-
Revision 0 Page 26 B-6 TUBES WITH DISTORTED SUPPORT INDTCATIONS Data Set:
DSS /DTS Probe:
.540" Dobbin Extent:
Full Length SEQF1 In OTSG "A", 4 tubes were examined.
In OTSG "B",
1 tube was examined.
REASON FOR EXAMIN7sTIOU During Outage 8R, distorted tube support plate (DSS) or distorted tubesheet (DTI) indications were recorded during the bobbin coil examinations. The suspect areas were then examined using an 8x1-ABS probe and the indications were dispositioned as either being flaws or non-relevant indications.
Indications which were determined to be non-relevant are monitored during the next examination.
SILECTION ORITERIA All inservice tubes which had DSS or DTS indications recorded during outage 1990-8R were re-examined during 1991-9R.
BESULTS 9159 h In OTSG A, the distorted support plate signal (7" ar.d 8" T.S.P. ) in three of the tubes are no longer distorted.
This would indicate the probable cause of the distortions was foreign material or deposits on the tube support plate.
The remaining tube (A-150-24) continues to show a distortion at the 10" T.S.P.
The distortion does not appear " defect like" and has not changed since the last outage, so no further actions were taken.
The tube will be re-examined during the next scheduled examination.
OTSG B In OTSG E, the distorted support plate signal (12" T.S.P. ) in tube B-113-114 continues to appear questionable.
This support was examined using the MPPC probe and no degradation was noted.
This tube will be re-examined during the next scheduled examination.
1068ATT3.T'
Revision 0 Page 27 B-7 SUSPECTED LEAKING TUBES Data Set:
Drip-Tebe Probe:
.510" Bobbin Extent:
Full Length SCOPC In OTSG "A",
1 tube was examined.
REASON FOR EJAMINATION Prior to the start of eddy current examinations, the OTSGs were subjected to a
" bubble tost" and a " drip test".
Tubes suspected of leaking are then examined using the eddy current test method.
SELECTION CRITERIA All tubes identified as possible leakers during the bubble or drip test are scheduled for examinations.
RESULTS QTSG A one (1) tube (A-91-122) was examined and no degradation was noted.
A subsequent leak test identified an adjacent plugged tube as the source of the leakage and the leaking tube was replugged.
l 136BATT1.TDR
Revision 0 Page 28 B-8 EXTRA Data Set:
Extra Probe
.510" Bobbin Extent:
Full Length SCOPE OTSG "A", 5 tubes were examined.
OTSG "B",
2 tubes were examined.
ItJJSON FOR EXAMINATION During the course of the examinations, eddy current data was acquired on tubes not identified on the ECT data sheets. The tubes were examined as a result of the typograpt.ical or interpretive errors on the part of the data acquisition personnel.
Onca the ECT data is recorded, it is evaluated and the tubes.
dispositioned accordingly.
SELECTION CR!TER Q These tubes are randomly located.
"1SEE OTSG A In OTSG A, one tube (A-129-66) had a 23% through wall indication recorded in the lower tube sheet.
This tube will be treated as a degraded tubo during the next examination.
No indications were recorded in the four remaining tubes g
and the tubes will remain in the general sample for the next outage.
OTSG B In OTSG B, no indications were recorded.
1068ATT1.TDR
g_
r-
_.m_.
L
~
l IAttachment is Revision 0.
Page 29:
i C'.
DISCUSSION OF RESULTS Characterization of Indications The indications reported during 1991-9R were characterized by location, percent through wall, amplitude, and circumferential extent.
(Sco Figures III-5 through III-8).
This charactorization showed that the.
majority of indications are inner diameter initiated and are located.
towards the top of the OTSGs.
In OTSG A, the'irdication rates are higher
= 1 towards the outer periphery while the distribution is more uniform across OTSG D.
This is the same distribution of indications as identified-during the previous examinations.
The amplitudes (voltage) of the 1990-8R indications.were typically small,-
' l
<2.0 volts; The characterization by percent through wall shows most of-the indications are pa).ial through wall with 98.49, of the indications-
- i recorded as <40% through wall.
The circumferential extent of the 1990-8R-indications was 1 coil for all indications ercept two 2-coil indications.
This characterization in consistent with previous. examination-results.-
In' addition to the inner diameter indications, _ two types ef outer diameter indications were also detected.
In OTSG B, two lanc-tubes (B-75-2 and B-75-4) had indications of tube to tube support plate wear.
These wear indications spanned the entire 1-1/2" thickness of the tube support plate,_and, based on the MRPC probe, are the width of a single broached support plate land.
This wear is typical of wear identified'in other OTSGs and is similar to the wear identified in-_OTSG B during outage 7R, These two tubes were-repaired by the installation of-alloy-690 tube sleeves.
The second_ type"of outer diameter indication-is a[ discrete, small amplitude indication which appears at.a_ tube support plates During this outage a total of seven of'these indications _were recorded-.four-in OTSG A and three in OTSG B.
These indications were' recorded-in' tubes in the-degraded tube populations and in the lane / wedge. tubes.
No indications of this type were recorded in'the 3%-T.S. samples.
In OTSG.B, the three tubes were examined using the MRPC probe to evaluatof the indications.
In one tube (B-82-14), the indication was confirmed as a small rounded indication of about 22% T.W.
at-:the 6" tube support
- plate. In the other two tubes, (B-113-114, B-144-49), no indications; were detected by the MRPC technique.
In OTSG A, the indications were covered by tube-sleeves in two tubes, (A-75-17, A-75-26), therefore no--
additional examinations were performed. :In one of the tubes, (A-70-1),-_-
the-suspect area was examined using the 8x1 probe and-the indication was not confirmed.
In the fourth tube"(A-105-94), the subject-indication has.
~
- been_ monitored since 1984_and.has not shown any change during the seven examinations; therefore, no additional examinations were performed.-
1068ATTI.TDR m
~-
m v
+s c
-m-e-
- w r
+-v-- - '
t Tt
~
n.
D
\\l
.c.
RevisionLO
.Pajo 30-r Egy,few of Previous Data j
f
'The ECT-examination' process-included a review of the ECT data from previous outages.
This review was performed to better' characterize and understand apparent changes in the ECT results from previous outages, j
J 1.
Tubes with Inner Diameter Indications
-l I
The previous examination data was reviewed for a total of three tubes with ihner diameter indications. These_ tubes were all ISI
'l tubes which were evaluated as being 240%.through wall during the 9R examinations.
In alli cases, the indications showed no apparent change from the last examinati7n and the change in'the o
assigned percent through wall is attributed to the variability-of the ECT process.
2.
Tubes with Outer Diameter Indications The previous examination data was reviewed for a total of three tubes with outer' diameter (O.D.) initiated indications.
These included one tube (B-82-14) which had a discrete O.D. indication at the 6" tube support plate. This indication-was essentially unchanged from the last examination-(8R)=. No additional' action is required for this tube.
The other two tubes (B-75-2 and B-75-4; had tube to tube support' plate wear. A review of_the past data shows the indications'had~
been present but not recorded during:the previous examination (8R),
Since the-wear-indications span =the entire _ length of the-tube support _ plate, the eddy current' signals tend to'look more' like a rotated tube support plate than a flaw.
The detection of these indications during-outage 19Riis attributed to improvements in.the_ analysis software and to increased analyst awareness for support plate indications.
During this examination, any' questionable indications at support
. plates were' examined using~the KRPC_ probe.
Using this_ approach, the wear-indications can be readily screened with the bobbin probe and-characterized with the MRPC probe. This processLwill~
be continued during future examinations and additional emphasis will be placed on vear indications.during the analyst's F
indoctrination.
T r
1 1068ATT1.TDR' l
=n E*:,zE=.*:444 a._.,
g w' t ~m.--
ROW JE:.- J. ~ ~~'
TUBE
,, = -. -
.2 t--
20
=*-
2 f
,=
_.... *......:=..::::: ^: u =.......
....r..
..~
x=.=..,-v.
~
a:=-....^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ '.-.. ""...=.. -....
. ~.
aO i
n
. - - _____-_y_
. -w
..-._ =_
40 3
i
- Ts::
^~n --
-+.~. -a*-- _ -
_.= g--
- o
_3 y-
,c
_.. _ =..-~ --
=
50
- g 1
- g...
...= ::::= ~
E. :-=3
..4
+-
c4_
60 i:
-45i :; _ ::H
-*r: :1 --
.=. -
i
............... :u- =
_ _ =
__p.m_
- mang.g.
- :
e-
- m.g 70 a
i
-m
--)..
4
- ~ -
2; 80 g
.. =.
-... t,g.:
i
= -..
..u.
=g qq -
p
,=- =
1
.=. rrr r---.. -.r.= r ---
-x_m 90 g
.. ~
~c
_.,a,
_. =
[
-_1-
~ _-~
=.-
-m
,y a@,m7. N,
.; ;r
^
- _ =
~.
~f" 100 1 a i
Im i
r
$$9 Il vy-
.=.
=-
=
_
1
=
. = = - _
=-
- = =
- = =
=
=
=
m r.3.....
=
=.
a n g
.. - f,. =..;
.. ;.,y.
.....r....-.......--o...
...,. =. _ = _ _ -
J y
M
"':-~
. a - -I-IEhZ-
__ _jg,((,j*]t ;
"?] - ;,-]u.x.g..g.p-.......{
W:'t +xr-I-m:.- r=xr A=*.r-~-";
- .:.:..c......__.'::g' =-
y,p
,oe
&~%F55-:-Ir '4"----' " Jit....
- ::::...Z' ~ ;;:m"fr==-p e
c4 g
~___,_T--e--~~=:=*-- -~~-Jt----~-~
- 4,;;;;,
Q > *,
-f-l3 "
e a
~ ~ = ~ = - -
_... n
-t._.
MXX
- ~ ~
msewmQ,+_.x=
ne
+
D oe
-: 14288: TUBES NOT EXAMINED 9R O-1243: TUBES EXAMINED 9R GPU NUCLEAR CORP.
THI - UNIT i ONCE THROUGH STEAM GENERATOR: A 07/09/92 um ms nm
{
l
?
bi w
m; R. l.
w to al en en
.tn..t.n.
HC.
tv '
mml CD th
] ilb
' f i
c l,,l
,. l 1
mz l
i.
,l "1
j; i,
>< o d'
i i
r l
i l
>H n
s is Z
.l', l lI (l
l l);
I l'
l l
Hm i
.l-g;.-
3,,
l z >:
l i'
3
. i.
'l
.,b
,j l!
U.
};;
l..
i m
o lj l<l ll, D,
l,l ll i,i ta =
i
!:'A, l i i
mm l
l C
i
!'l
's e
u ll l<
ir "4,
,i i ll n
1 to f
m
-m.
l i
l l
It i
ii ll t
g,:
i is
,i I
h i<
li 5
I.
ie n
i<
i.
u ld
,l l
l:!
1 ll ll l
i
'<o hilj l<-
j
>s-i i,:
u 4
lc n.
m g!
l-i
' g'!
4 l
w i
i, II l
l n
i, n-h, j-i
.,y"h.
i l
ll ll
,u, o
ii. J..
ll
\\
o i
ll i
i
. f ii d
'li i'
I
'l 1
II i
.ll
)>
'I
.iN I
ll o o cn m
m Hzo l
NnC I
?
8'-
l l
om ca z l:.
-l:
l,'
NHC m5r-
.l
- u a
o n, j to n
u l
o rf'.!:
om c>
l l
l s'l il, i,
l en x n
l u
M z
,1 j );I 3
O lll1
. p:
l co a 8
Hm
- l U
mt 4
j;t a
g-E mH I
g gr
.H m
i 21 HC i
oz l
~r4 H H
l I
m-r a
r m
m a
o m
m Y
m m
A W N O
o o
o o
o o
o o
o o
o I
l GSNINVIS S3Hn1 E OS.I,0 E-III SunDId EE abed 0 uoysTADH I queuryou44y
d w
m N r' T
nn
- l,.
NW!
i
+-
i
.mpth::: ; :Np-Ep;"eE-h. i :-pp
,,.-l; y,
ac,,.........c.....,,.-..-.......e.....,,,,,. i, m m....:....
c c-
- s.,, -
o.
..:..,=.=...
... :. :. :. ll ;...... :.,
w 8 :..:.:.:.:.
m m ;.::.
7-I..
.. ; b+ +.F.t t t t.+.....
m - F..F.t.b.! !.F E.b...b.! :c+. b F.
t.
mc
..... ".=.=.=...
u....
< w <....
......n.
........=.... =.
a m !::...=....=.".*.......
- .:a..:::::..n...:.....
mm..
- .:o:::.
- . :::..:::o:::::::::
s...:.
o e
=
x b:i E:t +:.: p:.F F: F: F:.F:; &
- F:FFi+:.:1 b:bt:+:. i
+ ;-
+
..... ;i
,:.:.;.:........S.:
. p= p.: :..
1 h.:- -D
,.*.....=,
...=...=<...c *..
- .............=.;
=....=.....a..-
o
".....=...
...... o...
t a.....
~. =. a.....
1.,%. 1.r.o1+.......
...~...== 1 =- % y.1>1.%.1..........
..o.....o.........
..u
.*.. o
......I
.. n..
,1 ====..
1,.:. -.:.:-.:.. u.......:....... s.:....
%. 1 1
==-
.........,. e..I
=.-
- ..I
- ... -.
....:.:.:...,......,...:.:.:.;,.... :. ;l. i D....., : :..........
...... :.. ;l m.
,....:.:.:.r.:.:.:...
. =. =. ". =.
........ D. E i
- +:D. D. D.+.*
D. D... D. I D. E+N,. D.. D.D. D.
...T.
D,i s.=..=.'..
=.=..=......=..=.=......=.
=.....*
.=
=.
t oo,m
..m o m_.,i:.=.=.=.=....=.=.=.=....=.=.a.=.=.=.
- m....=.'..
.=
mz
=...s sac s a c ! e.. :. :. p.. :.. :. :...... :..
m
' : 4.... =...... =............. =.... =...
s...i s.................... s.......:.
............iq....::: s. i..!!
h.:s...i+R. C. !.!:
+.- :
exa m m,;::: :.:.: :..:.:.:.:..:..:.:..:...: ::
c a.
g w e. p...........................,...:...............
z n.;...
.:.p.:..................:.....................
.:.:.;;.p..:...:.:.:.:..:.:.:.:..:
-m; m,.,,
i.s.i s.. 9. 9. 9. $... ! :. !.:. ! : e.. e..
.::. :!:!:.is.. 166....66
=
i 9
c m-
~...........,
...+.........
~x
~..........
...... ~..........
=~
m, m i e n. s..i H..:s.~.........,
.........~.......
.... ~..........................
n a = ;!=...........
~.
~
.......... ~.8
".:.=.:...
=... ~...=.....
~c
=
,.m
... ::: s..i s.. e.=.=. e..":!:! s... H..=.i s.=. qr..,
.=.
um
- - - e i... s.:.. e....
u.
i W
CD N
C)
O O
o o
o k
M6 G3A33'1S S3En1 Y DS10 i
i l
E-III 3'dnDId l
l EC obed 0 uoT8MOH I guamyovaav l
lr
Revision 0 Page 34 FIGURE III-4 OTSO B TUBES SLEEVED 9R o
o o
o o
o n
m m
e wm j
p.p.... ip.....h. h. i h..i+!+i;......h:,.h:,t h.'p.
l
.ts*......
i
... :h... i : h
...... :..... p. pp. :!
Q
+
.:..:........:.......... v.....
2a or
- i.. :...:..,..:.::.:... :.:.
4
..::.;:.:..l
?... :.:..
....=.v:.,...=: :.:.:.:.' )
s........v:.:
........=:..,.
........w 25 te.h..ip.':.:g.....:.
I I;. p.:i h..,..h.:....o:p. o sw
..p..Fh+o
.: t i
v....:::,:
,.....;..v.....:......:....;....=....:...:
.x y
............ v..
v,
- a. w n
{p,.,.........
er
, am
.,. v...
.v..
...=
....... v.....v. r....
- u g
. v............... v
...v z
a......... :,,, c e... v i..s:...:v.... v
....u :. v.
u
.v.
i <a
- ......:i p. t. h. i p.
<.t:-:::'
- ..
- .
- ............ s.
- m........ h. +..in. :t. ip:h..t.. h. q.
.. I az m
.........., I m
a
........ v,s......,.:.:.:.:.
.:.:..:.l:.....;...:.
m
- i. v..v..~........:.
wa v......v.......,..........., i m a s
..v
.... v..
..........! ;, a. z n eoa
=
1.a..?... v...-
w
.a. 1.........,
v
- . v
....v... 1 1
- ,....u.1...
. v.....
- 1. 1
. 1...
.:.:.: :..:....,...... 1. 1... :
t as
.....,4,;
c.. v...:...
.j
- i..
1 1... v. =.......... v...... =. =..
...... v....... v..
.........*.. v. v.t.
.. 1..',.
....v..........
i....
..v.....
.v.
.v
,.. g. s. p. p. p.,. y. p. ;,. :r,.rvp. t, r. =.:. y.
v.
.;.....,...vpp;g..;q r
..y, i:..:..... v,.......,...
~
v.. v... -
. v.. v..., v,.........
c.
... v.......v v.
.. v...........,
- 1......:......:.".:.
l e..i4.................:. 4. 4. 41. 44-R
. 4. D.I.l. 4. 4. 4.......!4.'.
~-
I
.:;: : l
{
...l.i 1
. v.'...*...........v..
.......... v..... v......
x l...:. v.....
...........'. '..:.:. 7.:. v.....
. v.
i:......
.-.. v.....
........ vl. :......... ;....::.lma m
.., v :.:.:..:. :..:
...... l v..-
......iww t
.-v e,.. v... v
.... :. v._.2
........ v :... v......, a w
.. v....-v m>
- r.......v, 1.....
.... v.c...
.v..
a,s..- -a
.......;..=....s.._.u.J r w
..a......
- s...
.a
..,...=...u..,=..... v..v.....
........ =.=.......v., a a
......,...... =....... v. v.-.. =...=..
....v.,.....-..w
. v. v... v..... w m. v.a
.v
..v,
.. v a
. v.. -.v.Om
.......... v.... v.
-v v
.v,
. a.............:.-
- v...- v..... v a 2
" - -* ji *h* k.
.~y"a.
T*h*. -
l j
- a. -
p
.j. " "l, ".*3 =
{
A q
~
{
- - - - - ~;- -
I,
- mm i
,w-l I
.L l
lM61 y
w w
w w
R
Revision 0 Page 35 FIGURE III-5 DISTRIBUTION OF INDICATIONS BY AIIAL LOCATION (INCLUDES PREVIOUSLY IDENTIFIED INDICATIONS)
OTSG 'A' UTS-UTE 012-UTS E
V 008-012 A
004 - 008 O
r SM N LTS-004 E 8R LTe-LTS l 9R I
I I
I I
I I
I I
il 0
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 NUMBER OF INDICATIONS OTSG'B' l
i UTS-UTE 012-UTS 008 - 012 A
004 - 008 O
t SM N 1.TS-004 E 8R LTE-LTS 9R I
I I
I I
I i
l 0
50 100 150 200 250 300 NUMBER OF INDICATIONS l
.... -. -. _. -. ~.
Attach:sent 1 Revision 0 Page 36 FIGURE III-6 INDICATION RATES BY REGION TUBES WITH INDICATIONS / TUBES EIAMINED (INCLUDES PREVIOUSLY IDENTIFIED INDICATIONS)
OTSG 'A' 35 _
T P
U SM 39 -
E B
i a BR
'l R
E C
S 3-
- 9R N
E w
7 N W 20 _
di T
I 4
E Y
E.
A T
15 _
G H
Ti E
to _
l
- v. -
01 - 30 31 - 43 44 - 53 54 - 61 62 - 68 69 - 76 RADIAL LOCATION (TUBES FROM CENTER)
OTSG "B" 35 _
T P
U SM 30 -
E B
" BR
^
R E
C S
25 - E 9R E
N W M-T 1
A T
15 _
G H
E jo _
O N
R o
WkY e
01 - 30 31 - 45 44 - 53 54 - 61 62 - 68 69 - 76 RADIALLOCATION (TUBES FROM CENTER)
T4 8
Attachmsnt 1 Revision 0 Page.37 FICURE III-7 DISTRIBUTION OF INDICATIONS DY PERCENT THROUGH WAIL (INCLUDES PREVIOUSLY IDENTIFIED INDICATIONS)
OTSG "A' 300_.
7
- 5M
- 250_
- 8R D
=== 9R 200_
.t j
g C
t.
A 150_
h x
's N
I 100_
O s..
N
.so _
g O
I I
i i
a 1
I S/N 20 - 29 30 - 39 40 - 49 60 - 69 60 - 69 70 - 79 80 - 89
> = 90 l-PERCENT DEPTH OTSG*B" 300 _.
.y 3.
ISM i
250
- BR D
===== 9R 200_
.g
....t C
A 150_
I 100_
O N
50 _.-
g 0
1 I
I t
a a
a i
S/N 20 - 29 30 - 39 40 - 49 60 - 59 60 - 69 70 -79 80 - 89
> = 90 PERCENT DEPTH
Attochment 1 Revision 0 Page 38 FIGURE III-8 DISTRIBUTION OF INDICATIONS BY AMPLITUDE (INCLUDES PREVIOUSLY IDENTIFIED INDICATIONS)
OTSG"A" 400_.
r 3
SM l
350_
N
- BR 00 -
D
- 9R I
250_
..(
C A 200_.... -
l T
150_
g
\\
O j og _
N S
50 _
0 e
i i
i i
< 1.0
- 1.0 - 1.9 2.0 - 2.9 3.0 - 3.9 4.0 - 4.9
> 5.0 l
AMPLITUDE IN VOLTS OTSG*B" 400_..
7 s.
I 350_
N
- 8R 300_
D
==== 9R l
l 250_
.5 2
C A 200_
T 150_
O j og _
50 _
n l
1
< 1.0
- 1.0 - 1.9 2.0 - 2.9 3.0 - 3.9 4.0 - 4.9
> 5.0 l
L AMPLITUDE IN VOLTS l
i
Attachment1 Re,1mion 0 Page 39 IV.
CONCLbSIONS Based on the results of the 1941, Outage 9R, ECT examinations and data evaluations, GPUN was able to reach the following conclusions:
1.
The examinations of the previously " Degraded Tubes" did not indicate a trend of ongoing degradation.
2.
The examination results of the Tech. Spec. random samples'did not reveal a trend of new or continuing damage mechanisme.
3 The examination of the lane / wedge region indicates tube to tube support plate wear is occurring in isolated cases.
The current techniques are capable of detecting this wear; however, additional emphasis needs to be placed on this damage mechanism during the analysis procese.
o
(
m..
Attachment I Revision"O' Page 40 V.
REFERENCES 1.
Appendix A to the TMI-I Operating License, Amendment 153, Technical Specification 4.19, 05/29/90.
O.
GPUN TDR 421, Rev.
1, R. Barley, J. Janiszewski, G Phedrick, M. Torborg, "Three Mile Island - Unit 1 OTSG Tubing Eddy Current Program Qualification," 03/15/84.
3.
GPUN TDR 642, Rev.
2, M. horborg,.G. Rhedrick *Cualification of Conversion Curve for Inner Diameter Discontinuities," 10/31/85.
4.
GPUN TDR 999, Rev.0, M. T. Torborg, " Evaluation of:ECT Probes for Use in Examining the TMI-1-0TSGs", 01/09/90.
5.
Three Mile Island Nuclear Station Unit No. 1-Surveillance Procedure 1300-4B, Rev, 6,
" Eddy Current Examination of OTSG," 09/30/91.
6.
PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines, Revision 2, August 1988, EPRI.
7.
GPUN TDR 1026, Rev.6, M. T. Torborg, " Outage 8R and BUI OTSG Eddy Current Examination Results", 10/12/90.
8.
GPUN TDR 858, Rev.0, B. Bader, "Circumferential Extent of Flaws as a Function of 8x1.187 inch Coil Coverage",.10/19/87.
9.
GPUN TMI-1, Material Nonconformance RSport, MNCR-91-0042, Revision 0, 10/14/91.
09/09/92.
1068ATT1.TDR
+..
ATT.
1,<: APP.JI' REVISION 0-Page :;
1-O f' 3 DDA-4 ANALYSIS CODE 3 TO BE PUT IN-PERCENT COLUMN Absolute Drift ADR Indication Not-Reportaole
-INg -
Retest Bad Data RBD Iwtest. Incomplete Exam RIC Indication Below Voltage No Detectable Discentanuit)
~NDD-Criteria BVC Non Qualifiable :na; cation-NQI-Dent DNT Permeability Var 14.non PVN-Dent With Pos sible Reteet PVN
.gpy
- i Indication DNI Plugged
-PIA -
Ding DNG 4
Obstructed OSS Distorted Roll Transition W/ Pass Indication DRI Sludge
- SLc Distorted Support Signal DSS Retest Tube N:'moer check RNC-Distorted Support Sigaal DSI with Indication Distorted Tubesheet Signal With Indication DTI Expansion Transition
. Location.
ETL Fixture RFX ID Chatter IDC Retest IDC RDC 1---
i
' Indication Not Found INF i
i
i ATT.
1, APP. I REVISION O Page :
2 of 3 EXPLANATION OF DDA-4 ANALYSIS COCES Normally refort to drift in the crevice of non-expanded Absolute Drift (ADR) tubesheets. Can also be used for tube to tube wear in free standing section of tubing. Possible indicator of Inter Granular Attack (IGA).
Recorded in low frequency absolute.
Bad Data (RBD) - Self explan&*.ory.
Below voltage criteria (Bvc) - Low level indications wnten are below the establish voltage criteria for assigning percent through wall values.
DENT (DNT) - Tube I.D. smaller than nominal I.D.,
occurr nc at support plate.
Intersections or top of tub sheets. Recorded in differential mix.
Ding (DNG) - Similar to dent but in free-standing part c: tuDe.
Either caused in manufacturing or by mechanical cause.
Recorded in prime :requency.
Dent With Possible Indication (DNI) - Possible discontinuit/ andication associated with dent but is not measurable. Recorded from differentiai mtx.
Distorted Roll Transition (DRT) - Self explanatory.
Distorted Roll Transition With Posaible Tndication (DRIi - A distorted roll transition that has sufficient distortion that a discont nutty may be creating the distortion.
Distorted Support Sional (DSS) - An indication at the Intersection of a support plate which may be indicative of a possible discontinuit.
The signal may be distorted by deposit, dents, or saturated drilled hole supports.
Distorted Tubesheet with Indications (DTI) - An indicat;0n at the intersection of the upper or lower secondary tube sheets which may be inc; ative of a possible discontinuity.
The signal may be distorted by deposits, aenta, or saturated tubesheet signals.
1
~
ATT. 1, APP. I REVISION O Page.-:
3!Df 3 i
EXPLANATION OF DDA-4 AllALYSIS CODES Distorted Support Signal With Indication (DsI) - A distorted support signal which appears indicative of a discontinuity.
Expansion Transition Location (ETL) - Used to record the.ocation of-the kenetic expansion.
Fixture (FIX) - Used when tubes cannot be examined because the fixture foot is obstructing tube or the fixture will not reach a particular tube.
ID Chatter (IDC) - Caused by manufacturing process (pilgering).
Characterized by long areas of horizontal motion.
Recorded in prime frequency.
Incomplete Test (RIC) - Tube not run to the extent requireo or complete tube not recorded.
Indication Not Found (INF) - Indication that has been preytcusly reported but is-not found-on current examination.
Indication Not Reportable (INR) - Indication that has been previously reported but.
'does not meet current reporting criteria.
1 No Detectable Discontinuity (NDD)
-Entry not required it OSASE system used.
Tube that is obstructed by foreign materaal, i.e.,
dirt, chunk of obstructed'(OBS) metal, broken off probe head, etc.
l-Permeability Variation (PVN) - Self explanatory. Recorcec in prime frequency free-l~
standing tube, measured in differential mix at support plate intersections.
" lugged (PLG) - Permanent mechanical plug, not to be confused with obstruction.
\\
L Sludge (SLG) - Accumulation of ferromagnetic material en top of tubesheets or support plates.
Recorded in lowest absolute frequency as per specific plant l-cequirements.
Tube Number Cheel. (RNC) - Used when the tube identity is un doub*..
ATT.
1, APP. II REVISION O Page :
1 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exnm Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Dog T.W.
Volt Volta Dapth 1
4 ISI 9R 17044 013+
6.6 5
17 1.79 ISI BR 12856 013+
6.5 7
23 1.95
-00.16
-6.00 ISI 9R 17044 015+ 36.4 5
17 2.29 ISI 8R 12856 015+ 36.0 10 33 2.22 00.07
-16.00 2
6 ISI 9R 17045 015+ 24.6 6
20 1.08 ISI 8R 12857 015+ 24.5 8
26 1.11
-00.03
-6.00 ISI iR 17045 015+ 25.2 7
23 1.13 ISI Mt 12857 015+ 25.2 10 33 1.26
-00.13
-10.00 2
25 ISI 9R 17046 012+ 36.0 7
23 1.18 ISI 8R 12858 012+ 35.9 1
36 0.95 00.23
-13.00 ISI 9R 17046 013+
9.1 5
17 1.47 ISI BR 12858 013+
9.3 11 36 1.23 00.24
-19.00 ISI 9R 17046 013+ 10.2 7
2, 1.32 ISI 8R 12858 013+ 10.3 10 33 1.17 00.15
-10.00 3
17 ISI 9R 17144 015+ 32.9 9
30 1.01 ISI BR 12959 015+ 32.9 8
27 1.08
-00.07 03.00 4
29 ISI 9R 17047 015+ 27.6 9
30 3.87 ISI BR 12861 015+ 21.1 11 36 1.97
-00.10
-6.00 5
3 ISI 9R 17048 015+ 44.7 6
20 1.46 ISI 8R 12862 015+ 44.8 10 33 3.67 "1.21
-13.00 ISI 9R 17048 015+ 45.3 8
27 4.45 ISI BR 12862 015+ 44.8 10 33 2.67
-00.23
-6.00 5
5 ISI 9R 17146 012+ 26.9 78 47 0.46 ISI 6R 12961 012+ 27.2 87 50 0.53
-00.07
-3.00 ISI 9R 17146 015+ 34.7 t
27 1.10 ISI BR 12961 015+ 34.4 7
23 1.29
-00.19 04.00 6
43 ISI 9R 17050 UTS+
3.8 8
27 1.44 ISI 8R 12864 UTS+
3.5 11 36 2.08
-1.44
-9.00 ISI 9R 17050 UTS+
6.5 6
20 1.49 ISI 8R 12864 UTS+
6.3 7
23 2.33
-00.84
-3.00 6
47 ISI 9R 17051 015+ 19.9 8
27 1.04 ISI 8R 22865 015+ 19.9 6
20 1.49
-00.45 07.00 ISI 9R 17051 015+ 23.2 6
20 1.10 ISI 8R 12865 015+ 23.0 7
23 1.34
-00.24
-2.00 ISI 9k 17051 015+ 33.4 8
27 1.37 ISI BR 12865 015+ 33.8 5
16 1.88
-00.51 11.00 Continuea Next Page =>
ATT. 1, APP. II REVISION O Page :
2 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Dag T.W.
Volt Volts Depth 6
48 ISI 9R 17052 0T5+
0.5 8
27 1.93 ISI BR 12866 UTS+
0.4 10 33 1.46 00.47 6.00 8
2 ISI
>R 17053 012+ 16.2 5
17 1.11 ISI 8R 12867 012+ 16.2 9
30 1.15
-00.04
-13.00 ISI 9R 17053 012+ 29.2 7
23 1.35 ISI 8R 12867 012+ 29.3 10 33 1.45
-00.10
-10.00 ISI 9R 17053 012+ 33.3 7
23 1.79 ISI 8R 12867 012+ 33.5 9
30 1.81
-00.02
-7.00 8
43 ISI 9R 17147 015+ 24.1 7
23 0.97 ISI 8R 12962 015+ 23.8 6
20 1.30
-00.33 03.00 ISI 9R 17147 015+ 24.5 10 33 0.95 ISI 8R 12952 015+ 24.3 10 33 0.72 00.23 00.00 11 4
ISI 9R 17054 015+ 21.2 10 30 0.97 ISI BR 12868 015+ 21.2 9
30 1.10
-00.13 00.00 13 1
ISI 9R 17055 011+ 35,5 8
27 1.14 ISI 8R 12869 011+ 35.2 7
23 0.53 00.61 04.00 ISI 9R 17055 013+ 23.3 5
17 1.51 ISI BR 12869 013+ 23.3 11 36 1.31 00.20
-19.00 15 77 ISI 9R 17148 012+ 30.5 7
23 1.06 ISI BR 12963 012+ 30.5 9
30 0.80 00.26
-7.00 16 2
ISI 9R 17056 015+ 42.5 5
17 0.96 ISI 8R 12870 015+ 42.3 6
20 0.99
-00.03
-3.00 17 82 191-8R 9R 17334 014+ 32.2 6
20 0.77 8X1ACC 8R 13130 014+ 32.6 7
23 0.84
-00.07
-3.00 18 1
ISI 9R 17149 004+
5.1 7
23 1.02 ISI BR 12964 004+
5.1 11 33 1.17
-00.15
-10.00 18 3
ISI 9R 17150 015+ 25.4 6
20 0.96 ISI GR 12965 015+ 25.1 11 36 1.04
-00.08
-16.00 Continues Next Page =>
- _. ~,
ATT. 1, APP. 11 REVISION O Page :
3 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Deg T.W.
Volt Volts Depth 18 84 ISI 9R 17057 015+ 32.6 6
20 1.10 ISI 8R 12871 015+ 32.6 10 33 1.11
-00.01
-13.00 IS:
9R 17057 015+ 33.1 9
30 1.27 ISI 8R 12871 015+ 32.6 10 33 1.11 00.16
-3.00 ISI 9R 17057 015+ 34.4 8
27 1.23 ISI 8R 12871 015+ 34.4 7
23 1.43
-00.20 04.00 ISI 9R 17057 015+ 38.1 6
20 1.48 ISI 8R 12871 015+ 38.1 9
30 1.06 00.42
-10.00 ISI 9R 17057 015+ 40.8 11 37 1.03 ISI PR 12871 015+ 40.8 9
30 1.10
-00.07 07.00 l
'i h 17057 015+ 41.9 6
20 1.33 ISI 8R 12871 015+ 41.8 5
16 1.11 00.22 04.00 20 1
ISI 9R 17152 005+ 21.4 5
17 1.07 ISI 8R 12967 005+ 21.5 7
23 0.99 00.08
-6.00 ISI 9R 17152 005+ 31.9 6
20 1.00 ISI 8R 12967 005+ 31.9 11 36 0.92 00.08
-16.00 20 56 ISI 9R 17058 015+ 33.3 7
23 1.02 ISI 8R 12872 015+ 33.5 6
26 0.97 00.05
-3.00 30 85 ISI 9R
.7059 010+ 18.0 8
27 1.26 ISI 8R 12873 010+ 18.3 11 36 1.31
-00.05
-9.00 ISI 9R 17059 010+ 31.8 5
- 17 1.09 ISI 8R 12873 010+ 31.7 7
23 1.00 00.09
-6.00 ISI 9R 17059 014+ 31.5 8
30 0.84 ISI 8R 12873 014+ 31.4 11 36 0.72 00.12
-6.00 27 78 ISI 9R 17156 015+ 30.1 7
23 0.93 ISI-8R 12971 015+ 29.9 7
23 0.99
-00.06 00.00 27 96 ISI 9R 17061 LTE+ 22.0 9
30 3.86 ISI 8R 12875 LTE+ 21.7 88 37 2.40 01.46
-7.00 l-28 78 ISI 9R 17062 015+ 14.6 6
20 2.59 l
ISI 8R 12876 015+ 14.5-
.5 18 2.43 00.16 02.00 ISI 9R 17062 015+ 28.5 10 33 1.01 ISI BR 12876 015+ 28.3 9
32 0.04 00.07 01.00 39 58 ISI 9R 17157 015+ 29.9 6
20 0.01 ISI 8R 12972 015+ 29.8 7
23 0.74 00.07
-3,00 ISI 9R 17157 015+ 33.9 9
30 0.93 ISI 8R 12972 015+ 33.5 8
26 0.83 00.10 04.00 30 23 ISI 9R 17063 015+ 13.2 5
17 0.79 ISI 8R 12877 015+ 13.1 11 36 0.79 00.00
-19.00 l
l Continues Next Page =>
l
ATT.
1, APP. II REVISION O Page :
4 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Detta Delta Roanon Out Numb Location Dog T.W.
Volt Volta Depth 31 1
ISI 9R 17158 008+
6.5 6
20 1.04 ISI BR 12973 008+
6.5 11 36 0.94 00.10
-16.00 33 102 ISI 9R 17186 015+
5.7 6
20 1.07 ISI 8R 13001 015+
5.8 9
30 0.89 00.18 410.00 34 1
ISI 9R 17284 006+ 15.6 6
20 1.00 ISI 8R 13099 006+ 15.5 9
30 1.07
-00.07
-10.00 34 3
ISI 9R 17065 UTS+
2.0 9
30 1.22 ISI 8R 12879 UTSt 2.0 9
30 1.13 00.09 00.00 37 109 ISI 9R 17160 015+ 39.0 9
30 1.01 ISI 8R 12975 015+ 38.9 11 36 0.80 00.21
-6.00 38 29 ISI 9R 171G1 012+
3.8 5
17 1.52 ISI 8R 12976 012+
3.7 8
26 1.41 00.11
-9.00 39 101 ISI 9R 17067 015+ 34.7 8
27 0.99 ISI 8R 12881 015+ 34.6 9
30 1.02
-00.03
-3.00 39 110 ISI 9R 17068 015+ 39.9 9
30 1.00 ISI 8R 12882 015+ 39.6 11 36 1.89 00.11
-6.00 42 114 ISI 9R 17191 015+ 34.9 7
23 0.23 ISI 8R 13006 015+ 34.5 5
16 0.75 00.08 07.00 ISI 9R 17191 015+ 43.6 6
20 0.57 ISI 8R 13006 015+ 43.3 6
20 0.7P
-00.22 00.00 46 88 ISI 9R 17192 015+ 30.3 7
23 1.15 ISI 8R 13007 015+ 30.4 7
23 1.16
-00.01 00.00 48 83 ISI 9R 17286 UTS+
6.2 10 33 1.02 ISI BR 13101 UTS+
6.3 7
23 1.09
-00.07 10.00 48 118 ISI 9R 17072 014+ 29.6 7
23 0.87 ISI BR 12886 014+ 29.5 9
30 0.94
-00.07
-7.00 ISI 9R 17072 014+ 30.5 8
27 0.54 ISI 8R 12886 014+ 30.3 5
16 0.61
-00.07 11.0L 49 73 ISI 9R 17073 UTS+
5 10 33 1.48 ISI BR 12887 UTS+
9 30 1.69
-00.21 03.00 49 85 ISI 9R 17195 015+ 36.3 7
23 1.34 ISI 8R 13010 015+ 36.3 6
20 1.52
-00.18 03.00 Continues Next Page =>
- - ~ -.
ATT. 1, APP. II
)
REVISION O Page 5 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLANDsDNIT 1 COMPONENT SG A OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Deg T.W.
Vi lt Volts Depth 15 0 102 ISI 9R 17075 015+ 16.8 9
30 1.36 ISI 8R 120d9 015+ 16.6 9
30 1.34 00.02 00.00 51 2
ISI 9R 17162 015+
3.1 11 37 0.88 ISI BR 12977 015+
2.9 11 36 0.78 00.10 01.00 52 34 ISI 9R 17287 013+ 23.3 5
17
- 1.02 ISI 8R 13102 013+ 23.0 5
16 0.96 00.06 01.00 l
56 93 ISI 9R 17203 015+ 39.4 11 37 0.80 ISI 8R 13018 015+ 39.4 11 36 0.70 00.10 01.00 57 63 ISI 9R 17076 015+ 36.9 8
27 2.01 ISI 8R 12890 015+ 36.9 7
23 2.03
-00.02 04.00 57 65 ISI 9R 17077 015+ 37.4 10 33 0.97 ISI 8R 12891 015+ 37.5 8
26 1.15
-00.18 07.00-58 94 ISI 9R 17205 015+ 44.1 7
23 0.90 ISI 8R 13020 015+ 44.0 9
30 0.80 00.10
-7.00 58 117 ISI 9R 17207 015+ 40.6 5
17 0.66 ISI BR 13022 015+ 40.8 5
16 0.76 - -00.10.
01.00 60 65 ISI 9R 17210 015+ 37.4
.7
.23 1.07 ISI 8R 13025 015+ 37.3 9
30 1.14
-00.07
-7.00 60 125 ISI 9R 17078 015+ 25.7 5
17 1.02 ISI 8R 12892 015+ 25.3 6
20 1.19
-00.17
-3.00 ISI 9R-17078 0".5+ 26.3 5
17 1.38 ISI 8R 12892 015+ 25.9 5
16 1.51 00.13 01.00 63 96 ISI 9R 17163 015+ 38.9 5
17 1.10 ISI 8R 12978 015+ 38.9 9
30 0.99 00.11
-13.00 63 126 ISI 9R 17288 015+ 23.0 8
27 1.01 ISI 8R 13103 015+ 22.8 10 33 0.95 00.06
-6.00 64-66 ISI-8R 9R 17339 015+ 40.5 9
30 0.84 8X1ACC 8R 13141 015+ 40.0 8
26 0.91 00.07 04.00 i
65 94 ISI 9R 17080 015+ 35.9 7
23 0.o0 ISI 8R 12894 015+ 35.8 5
18 0.84 00.04 05.00 Continues Next Page-=>
pe-g-
.==-g
.wy-r p
y
%p.w y
e g-.w-e-amppye m
-wwr e-%-www, w.=w...w ee,w w-
-t a-
-t
. - =.. -.
ATT.
1, APP. II REVISION O Page :
6 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EX1LM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Deg T.W.
Volt Volts Depth 66 1
ISI 9R 17081 004+ 27.7 9
30 2.25 ISI 8R 12895 004+ 27.7 9
30 2.60
-00.35 00.00 66 127 ISI 9R 17082 015+ 45.2 9
30 1.14 ISI 8R 12844 635,44.9 7
25 1.18
-00.04 05.00 67 93 ISI 9R 171<4 Otb P C..
5 17 0.93 ISI 8R 1297a y.is 16,1 6
21 0.90 00.03
-4.00 70 88 ISI 9R 17216 OL5+ 39.6 5
17 0.66 ISI 8R 13031 015+ 39.9 6
21 0.66 00.00
-4.00 72 21 ISI 9R 17217 015+ 35.7 7
23 1.02 ISI 8R 13032 015+ 35.3 10 33 0.98 00.04
-10.00 73 22 ISI 9R 17220 015+ 41.7 5
17 1.27 ISI 8R 13035 015+ 42.2 5
16 1.09 00.18 01.00 74 28 ISI 9R 17084 UTS+
6.0 9
- 1 1.67 ISI BR 12898 UTS+
5.7 6
20 1.51 00.16 11.00 74 30 ISI 9R 17085 UTS+
5.8 10 33 0.98 ISI BR 12899 UTS+
5.8 7
23 1.20
-00.22 10.00 75 122 ISI 9R 17222 015+ 45.1 8
27 1.43 ISI 8R 13037 015+ 44.9 5
18 1.39 00.04 09.00 77 126 ISI 9R 17089 015+ 18.1 8
27 1.29 ISI 8R 12903 035+ 18.5 8
28 1.01 00.28
-1.00 81 92 ISI 9R 17092 UTS+
0.8 5
17 0.87 ISI SR 12906 UTS+
0.6 8
26 0.75 00.12
-9.00 82 32 ISI 9R 17093 UTS+
6.3 10 33 1.80 ISI 8R 12907 UTS+
6.5 1
23 1.70 00.10 10.00 82 128 ISI 9R 17227 015e 8.0 5
17 1.18 ISI 8R 13040 015+
7.9 7
21 0.96 00.22
-4.00.
83 17 ISI 9R 17094 015+ 35.5 10
-33 1.30 ISI 8R 12908 015+-35.3 10 33 1.14 00.16 00.00-84 103 ISI 9R 17228 015+ 32.3 7
23 1.22 ISI 8R 13043 015+ 32.4 5
16 0.97 00.25 07.00 Continues Next-Page =>
1 i
. ~., -.
ATT.
1, APP. II REVISION O Page :
7 OF 1.5 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Dog T.W.
Volt Volta Depth 87 1
ISI 9R 17996 012+
7.1 6
20 3.85 ISI 8R 12910 012+
7.0 9
30 2.93 00.92
-10.00 ISI 9R 17096 012+
7.4 6
20 3.55 ISI 8R 12910 012+
7.0 9
30 2.93 00.62
-10.00 87 20 ISI 9R 17229 015+ 33.4 7
23 0.91 ISI 8R 13044 015+ 33.0 5
16 0.92
-00.01 07.00 88 124 ISI 9R 17230 015+
3.6 5
17 1.15 ISI 8R 13045 015+
3.5 7
25 0.90 00.25
-8.00 90 128 ISI 9R 17097 014+ 15.1 6
20 1.26 ISI 8R 12911 014+ 15.2 7
23 1.12 00.14
-3.00 ISI 9R 17097 015+
2.1 9
30 1.27 ISI BR 12911 015+
2.0 0
26 0.96 00.31 04.00 93 27 ISI 9R 17171 015+ 38.2 5
17 1.14 ISI BR 12986 015+ 38.0 8
26 0.96 00.18
-9.00 93 90 ISI 9R 17234 UTS+
0.7 7
23 0.56 ISI 8R 13049 UTS+
0.7 11 36 0.90
-00.34
-13.00 93 123 ISI 9R 17292 015+
7.1 9
30 0.92 ISI DR 13107 015+
6.7 5
16 0.86 00.06 14.00 94 113 ISI 9R 17293 015+ 33.1 5
17 1.26 ISI 8R 13108 015+ 33.6 10 33 1.09 00.17
-16.00 95 123 ISI 9R 17100 UTS+
2.1 6
20 3.73 ISI BR 12914 UTS+
1.8 9
30 1.31 02.42
-10.00 95 124 ISI 9R 17294 UTS+
2.4 8
27 0.99 ISI 8R 13109 UTS+
2.1 11 36 0.82 00.17
-9.00 95 126 ISI 9R 17295 UTSt 6.2 7
23 1.00 ISI 8R 13110 UTS+
6.2 11 36 1.00 00.00
-13.00 ISI 9R 17295 UTS+
6.8 13 43 1.75 ISI 8R 13110 UTS+
6.8 8
26 1.90
-00.15 17.00-95 127 ISI-8R 99 17346 012+ 13.4 6
20 0.77 S/N 8R 13192 012+ 13.2 7
23 0.63 00.14
-3.00 Continues Next Page =>
- - -. _ - - _ _ _ - - - - _ _ - - - - - - - ~ _
ATT. 1, APP. II REVISION O Page :
8 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT SG A OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Deg T.W.
Volt Volta Depth 96 32 ISI 9R 17101 015+ 37.7 10 33 1.76 ISI 8R 12915 015+ 37.6 7
23 1.68 00.08 10.00 ISI 9R 17101 015+ 43.4 11 37 1.29 ISI SR 12915 015+ 43.2 10 33 1.08 00.21 04.00 ISI 9R 17101 UTS+
4.1 5
17 1.47 ISI BR 12915 UTS+
4.0 5
17 1.24 00.23 00.00 90 93 ISI 9R 17102 UTS+
6.3 6
20 1.36 ISI BR 12916 UTS+
6.3 5
16 1.27 00.09 04.00 99 1
ISI 9R 17103 004+ 24.2 8
27 1.32 ISI 8R 12917 004+ 23.8 7
23 1.27 00.05 04.00 ISI 9R 17103 005+ 12.6 5
17 1.78 ISI BR 12917 005+ 12.5 5
16 1.56 00.22 01.00 ISI 9R 17103 008+
5.1 5
17 1.00 ISI 8R 12917 008+
5.0 9
30 0.93 00.07
-13.00 99 17 ISI 9R 17104 015+ 33.3 6
20 1.82 ISI 8R 12918 015+ 33.0 9
30 1.21 00.51
-10.00 100 122 ISI 9R 17105 UTS+
5.1 8
27 1.83 ISI 8R 12919 UTS+
4.8 7
23 1.42 00.41 04.00 101 16 ISI OR 17106 015+ 31.3 7
23 1.24 ISI 8R 12920 015+ 30.9 6
20 1.14 00.10 03.00 101 51 ISI SR 17107 UTS+
4.3 11 37 1.18 ISI 8R 12921 UTS+
4.0 11 36 1.06 00.12 01.00 101 61 ISI 9R 17109 015+ 29.4 7
23 2.07 ISI 8R 12923 015+ '9.3 6
20 2.23
-00,1G 03.00 103 121 ISI 9R 17110 014+ 12.4 10 33 1.14 ISI 8R 12924 014+ 12.2 10 33 0.96 00.18 00.00 ISI 9R 17110 014+ 15.8 6
20 1.07 ISI 8R 12924 014+ 15.6 7
23 0.98 00.09
-3.00 ISI 9R 17110 015+ 43.7 8
27 2.29 ISI BR 12924 015, 43.8 9
30 2.16 00.13 3.00
(
ISI 9R 17110 015+ 44.0 8
27 1.17 ISI 8R 12924 015+ 43.8
.9 30 2.16
-00.99
-3.00 104 75 ISI 9R 17173 015+ 29.4 9
30 0.72 ISI 8R 12988 015+ 29.4 8
26 0.67 00.05 04.00 ISI 9R 17173 015+ 33.1 5
17 1.12 ISI 8R 12988 015+ 33.1 5
16 1.05 00.07 01.00 I
ISI' 9R 17173 015+ 39.7 5
17 1.18 ISI 8R 12988 015+ 39.5 8
26 1.09 00.09
-9.00 l
ISI 9R 17173 015+ 40.9 7
23 0.60 Continuos Next Page =>
l u
ATT. 1, APP. II REVISION O Page :
9 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Dag T.W.
Volt Volts Depth 105 94 ISI 9R 17111 014+
0.1 93 25 2.32 ISI 8R 12926 014+
0.0 90 28 1.09 01.23
-3.00 106 2
ISI 9R 17112 015+ 10.6 8
27 0.91 ISI 8R 12927 015+ 10.3 7
23 0.92
-00.01 04.00 107 116 ISI 9R 17241 015+ 43.5 7
23 0.88 ISI 8R 13056 015+ 43.2 6
20 0.66 00.22 03.00 107 120 ISI 9R 17116 006+ 23.4 6
20 1.17 ISI 94 17116 UTS+
4.9 7
23 1.22 ISI 8R 12931 UTS+
5.0 9
30 1.10 00.12
-7.00 ISI 9R 17116 UTS+
4.9 5
17 1,.43 ISI 8R 12931 UTS+
5.0 9
30 1.10 00.33
-13.00 180 52 ISI 9R 17118 UTS+
1.1 6
21 1.1?
ISI 8R 12933 UTS+
1.1 6
20 1.25
-00.12 01.00 112 116 ISI 9R 17120 012+ 22.3 9
30 1.64 ISI 8R 12935 012+ 22.1 7
23 I.39 00.25 07.00 114 113 ISI 9R 17175 013+ 29.5 5
17 2.31 ISI 8R 12990 013+ 29.4 5
16 1.98 00.33 01.00 115 26 ISI 9R 17122 015+ 25.6 11 37 1.43 ISI 8R 12937 015+ 25.6 11 36 1.12 00.31 01.00 115 109 ISI 9R 17123 UTS+
5.1 6
20 3.04 ISI SR 12938 UTS+
5.1 7
23 2.84 00.20
-3,00 116 2
ISI-8R 9R 17332 006+
3.8 10 33 2.22 8X1ACC 8R 12135 00(&
3.3 10 33 2.01 00.21 00.00 117 24 ISI 9R 17248 015+ 33.8 5
20 1.87 ISI 8R 13063 015+ 33.8 5
16 1.59 00.28 04.00 ISI 9R 17248 015+ 42.3 5
17
-2.15 I..
8R 13063 015+ 42.4 5
16 2.00 00.15 01.00 119 77 ISI 9R 17125 015+ 28.8 9
30 1.72 ISI 8R 12940 015+ 29.1 6
20 1.72 00.00 10.00 119 107 ISI 9R 17126 015+ 38.8 7
23 1.92 ISI 8R 12941 015+ 38.6 5
16 1.81 00.11 07.00 120 67 ISI 9R 17127 015+ 35.9 10 33 1.33 ISI 8R 12942-015+ 36.3 7
23 1.23 00.10 10.00 122 30 ISI 9R 17130 UTS+
1.0 5
17 1.24 ISI 8R 12945 UTS+
0.8 8
26 0.86 00.38
-9.00 Continues Next Page =>
~
-e y,eq r,yn-cew e g-m--
- i, g-y--
w-e m e--
e e
w-
- s ar p
-ww meeebvm-'*-iw-i--
--r--
w-
~. -
ATT.
1, APP. II REVISION O Page v 10 OF 15 THkEE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT SG A OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tubo Exam Exam Exam Indication 2nd Ind Delta Delt?t Roanon Out Numb Location Dag T.W.
Volt Volts Depth 123 85 ISI 9R 17279 015+ 45.4 9
30 1.19 ISI 8R 13094 045+ 45.1 6
20 1.02 00.17 10.00 124 1
ISI 9R 17131 012+ 23.5 8
27 1.74 ISI 8R 12946 012+ 23.6 7
23 1.57 00.17 04.00 124 99 ISI-8R 9R 17336 013+
8.4 5
17 0.69 8X1ACC 8R 13134 013+
8.4 7
23 0.62 00.07
-6.00 135 97 ISI 9R 17298 015+ 40.9 10 33 1.02 ISI 8R 13113 015+ 41.0 9
30
-0.96 00.06 03.00 136 94 ISI 9R 17265 015+ 36.0 11 37 2.28 ISI 8R 13080 015+ 35.8 10 33 2.14 00.14 04.00 126 97 ISI 9R 17266 015+ 26.4 7
23 1.26 ISI 8k 13081 015+ 26.6 5
16 1.05 00.21 07.00 130 41 ISI 9R 17133 015+ 27.7 9
31 1.32 ISI 8R 12948 015+ 27.8 7
21 1.84
-00.52 08.00 130 46 ISI 9R 17255 015+ 22.9 5
17 1.65 IEI SR 13070 015+ 22.7 5
16 1,51 00.14 01.00 130 73 ISI 9R 17268 015+ 41.5 9
30 0.78 ISI 8R 13083 015+ 41.8 11 36 0.75 00.03
-6.00 131 1
ISI 9R 17300 013+ 13.8 5
17 1.20 ISI 8R 13115 013+ 13.3 5
16 1.03 00.17 01.00 131 82 ISI 9R 17262 015-0.1 10 33 1.02 ISI 8R 13077 015+
0.0 10 33 1.02 00.00 00.00 132 39 ISI-8R 9R 17356 015+ 30.9 9
31 0.82 8X1ACC 8R 13118 015+ 30.7 7
23 1.03
-00.21 08.00 134 1
ISI 9R 17135 004+
2.3 7
23 1.47 ISI BR 12950 004+
2.3 9
30 1.13 00.34
-7.00 ISI 9R 17135 004+
?5 6
20 1.14 ISI 8R 12950 004+
6 20 0.91 00.23 00.00 134 65 ISI 9R 17282 015+ 37.2 8
27 1.63 ISI 8R.
13097 015+ 37.5 9
30 1.55 00.08
-3.00 Continues Next Page =>
.=
ATT. 1, APP. II REVISION O Page :
11 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R l
COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Deg T.W.
Volt Volts Depth 135 2
ISI 9R 17136 013+ 33.5 8
?7 0.95 ISI BR 12951 013+ 34.0 6
20 0.74 00.21 07.00 ISI 9R 17136 015+ 11.5 9
30 1.11 ISI 8R 12951 015 + 13. 6 9
30 0.80 00.31 00.00 ISI 9R 17136 015+ 35.9 6
20 1.29 ISI 8R 12951 015+ 35.8 9
30 1.10 00.19
-10.00
-i 135 5
ISI 9R 17137 014+ 27.6 6
20 1.55 ISI 8R 12952 014+ 27.5 6
20 1.19 00.36 00.00 136 2
ISI 9R 17138 014+
9.4 5
17 1.15 ISI 8R 12953 014+
9.2 5
16 1.08 00.07 01.00 136 5
ISI 9R 17139 015+ 39.3 8
27 1.48 ISI 8R 12954 015+ 39.1 10 33 1.37 00.11
-6.00 136 69 ISI 9R 17269 015+
8.8 6
20 0.73 ISI BR 13084 015+
8.9 6
20 0.69 00.04 00.00 ISI 9R 172f9 015+ 11.5 6
20 1.26 ISI 8R 13084 015+ 11.6 8
27 1.09 00.17
-7.00 ISI 9R 17269 015+ 33.0 7
23 1.15 ISI 8R 13084 015+ 33.4 10 33 1.11 00.04
-10.00 ISI 9R 17269 015+ 37.1 8
27 2.36 ISI 8R 13084 015+ 37.6 11 36 2.08 00.28
-9.00 137 53 ISI-8R 9R 17338 015+ 18.5 9
30 0.88 8X1ACC 8R 13136 015+ 18.7 11 36 0.79 00.09
-6.00 138 65 ISI 9R 17270 UTS+
6.1 10 33 1.85 ISI 8R 13085 UTS+
5.9 11 36 1.73 00.12
-3.00 139 67 ISI 9R 17302 015v 45.9 11 37 1.53 ISI 8R 13117 015+ 45.8 11 36 1.44 00.09 01.00 139 71 ISI 9R 17271 013+ 25.7 8
27 1.90 ISI 8R 13086 013+ 25.9 11 36 1.77 00.13
-9.00 140 67 ISI 9R 17272 UTS+
3.6 11 37 1.19 ISI 8R 13087 UTS+
3.4 10 33 1.09 00.10 04.00 141 60 ISI 9R 17273 015+ 44.2 6
20 1.01 IDI BR 13088 015+ 44.1 9
30 0.87 00.14
-10.00 Continues Next Page =>
..~
ATT.
1, APP. II REVISION O Page :
12 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGd a 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
- 4 Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Deg T.W.
Volt Volts Depth 143 55 ISI 9R 17283 UTS+
3.1 9
30 1.30 ISI 8R 13098 UTS+
3.2 10 33 0.98 00.32
-3.00 143 57 ISI-8R 9R 17335 015+ 42.9 7
23 1.15 8X:ACC 8R 13132 015+ 43.3 10 33 1.10 00.05
-10.00 I
145 50 ISI 9R 17274 UTS+
4.4 5
17 14.05 ISI 8R 13089 UTS+
4.2 10 33 3.47 00.58
-16.00 146 1
ISI 9R 17141 004+ 35.5 8
27 1.88 ISI 8R 12956 004+ 35.6 11 36 1.47 00.41
-9.00 146 43 ISI 9R 17275 015+ 33.8 8
27 0.93 ISI 8R 13090 015+ 33.9 11 36 0.85 00.08
-9.00 ISI 9R 17275 015+ 35.0 11 37 0.94 ISI 8R 13090 015+ 35.2 11 36 0.83 00.11 01.00 ISI 9R 17275 015+ 36.0 6
20 0.89 ISI 8R 13090 015+ 36.2 9
30 0.85 00.04
-10.00 146 50 ISI 9R 17276 003+ 35.8 8
27 1.91 ISI 8R 13091 003+ 35.8 11 36 1.74 00.17
-9.00 147 2
ISI 9R 17142 012+ 10.5 10 33 1.13 ISI 8R 12957 012+ 10.4 7
23 1.12 00.01 10.00 150 8
ISI 9R 17177 015+
3.5 8
27 1.08 ISI 8R 12992 015+
3.5 7
23 0.94 00.14 04.00 ISI 9R 17177 015+ 18.5 8
27 0.96 ISI BR 12992 015+ 18.4 7
23 0.92 00.04 04.00 Continues Next Page =>
Total Tubes Included 166 Total Indications :
243 Voltage Summary :
Tubes Compared :
141 Number Increased :
129-Indications Compared :
190 Number Decreased :
57 Number No Change :
4 Mean Change :
0.08 Std. Dev. :
0.34 Porcent Summary :
Tubes Compared :
141 Number Increasod :
76 Indications Compared :
190 Number Decreased :
97 Number No Change :
17 l
Mean Change :
-2.19 Std. Dev. :
7.28-
-.. ~.
i ATT. 1, APP II REVISION O Page :
13 OF 15 THREE MILE ISIAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG B OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Dag T.W.
Volt Volts Depth 6
4 ISI 9R 13005 UTS+
5.2 7
23 2.31 ISI 8R 11443 UTS+
5.3 7
23 2.51
-00.20 00.00 7
42 ISI 9R 12984 012+ 12.2 7
23 0.88 ISI 8R 11421 012+ 11.9 7
23 0.87 00.01 00.00 1
ISI 9R 12984 013+ 11.4 8
27 0.99 ISI 8R 11421 013+ 11.2 10 33 0.98 00.01
-6.00 ISI 9R 11984 014+ 22.9 8
27 0.81 J
ISI 8R 11421 014+ 22.9 10 33 0.82
-00.01
-6.00 8
44 ISI-8R 9R 13019 014+ 16.3 11 37 0.80 S/N 8R 11460 014+ 16.5 10 33 0.69
-00.11 04.00 ISI-8R 9R 13019 014+ 29.3 10 33 0.65 S/N 8R 11460 014+ 29.4 9
30 0.62 00.03 03.00 i
l 9
22 ISI 9R 12985 015+ 44.6 8
27 1.19 ISI BR 11422 015+ 45.0 7
23 1.22
-00.03 04.00 19 44 ISI 9R 12986 015+ 41.2 8
27 1.72 24 63 ISI 9R 12987 013+ 14.1 11 37 0.83 ISI 8R 11424 013+ 14.0 11 36 0.86
-00.03 01.00 ISI 9R 12987 014+
9.3 13 43 0.64 ISI 8R 11424 014+
9.4 11 36 0.64
-00.00 07.00 30 13 ISI 9R 12988 015+ 45.2 9
30 2.17 ISI 8R 11425 015+ 45.2 10 33 2.26
-00.09
-3.00 30 71 ISI 9R 12389 015+ 32.0 6
20 1.71 ISI 8R 11426 015+ 32.0 5
16 1.76
-00.05 04.00 ISI 9R 12989 015+ 32.7 9
30 1.14 ISI 8R 11426 015+ 32.6 9
30 1.17
-00.03 00.00 38 72 ISI-8R 9R 13018 012+
7.7 13 43 0.81 8X1ACC 8R 11459 012+
7.3 11 36 0.80 00.01 07.00 ISI-8R 9R 13018 012+ 35.8 9
30 0.85 8X1ACC 8R 11459 012+ 35.7 11 36 0.78 00.07
-6.00 44 75 ISI-8R 9R
- 13017 013+ 29.0 7
23 0.90 8X1ACC
-8R 11449 013+ 29.2 7
23' O.92
-00.02 00.00 Continues Next Page =>
-_~ -.-
ATT.
- 1. APP II REVIS? ?N O Page i 14 OF 15 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG B OUTAGE : 9R COHPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Deg T.W.
Volt Volts Depth ISI-8R 9R 13037 014+
9.8 11 37 0.75 8X1ACC 8R 11449 014+
9.7 8
26 0.88
-00.13 11.00 ISI-8R 9R 13017 015+
1.3 8
27 0.62 8X1ACC 8R 11449 015+
1.3 10 33 0.62 00.00
-6.00 ISI-8R 9R 13017 015+ 35.3 6
20 0.94 50 39 ISI-8R 9R 13013 000+ 34.0 8
27 1.22 CONFIR 8R 12900 0086 34.0 8
26 1.13 00.09 01.00 60 83 ISI 9R 12990 015+ 39.3 11 37 1.01 ISI 8R 11427 015+ 39.3 11 36 1.09
-00.08 01.00 64 83 ISI 9R 12991 015+ 31.5 10 33 1.23 ISI BR 11428 015+ 31.6 10 33 1.22 00.01 00.00 74 56 ISI-8R 9R 13016 014+
2.1 10 33 1.46 LANEWE 8R 12566 014+
2.1 10 33 1.44 00.02
-00.00 79 47 ISI-8R 9R 13010 004+ 25.0 79 33 0.63 S/N-7R 8R 11522 004+ 24.9 83 31 0.60 00.03 02.00 103 33 ISI-8R 9R 13015 014+
0.0 8
27 1.53 3%-TS 8R 12345 014+
0.0 11 36 1.47 00.06
-9.00 104 77 ISI 9E 12992 UTS+
4.1 8
27 1.62 ISI BR 11429 UTS+
3.9 10 33 1.64
-00.02
-6.00 s
105 8
ISI SR 12993 UTS+
6.5 8
27 1.22 ISI 8R 11430 UTS+
6.6 10 33 1.18 00.04
-6.00 109 11 ISI 9R 12994 015+ 44.9 6
20 1.12 ISI 8R 11431 015+ 44.8 10 33 1.17
-00.05
-13.00 ISI 9R 12994 0154 46.0 7
23 0.89 ISI 8R 11431 015+ 45.7 6
20 1.00
-00,11 03.00 ISI 9R 12994 UTS+
5.3 9
30 1.12 ISI 8R 11431 UTS+
5.0 11 36 1.00 00.12
-6.00 109 112 ISI 9R 12995 004+
0.0 7
23 1.88 ISI 8R 11432 004+
0.0 7
25 1.74 00.14
-2.00 ISI 9R 12995 004+
4.9 9
30 1.21 ISI 8R 11432 004+
4.9 10 33 1.23
-00.02
-3.00 Continues Next Page =>
I
ATT.
1, APP II.
REVISION O Page :
15 OF 15 TEREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT SG B OUTAGE : 9R COMPARISON OF PREVIOUS EXAM RESULTS Row Tube Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Ind Delta Delta Reason Out Numb Location Dog T.W.
Volt Volts Depth ISI 9R 12995 005+ 20.5 5
17 0.96 ISI 8R 11432 005+ 20.5 5
17 0.85 00.11 00.00 l
117 56 ISI-8R 9R 13008 012+ 14.3 5
17 1.36 8X1ACC BR 11456 012+ 14.2 6
20 1.33 00.03
+3.00 122 44 ISI 9R 12996 UTS+
3.0 6
20 2.21 124 36 ISI 9R 12997 015+ 45.3 10 33 1.17 ISI 8R 11434 015+ 45.1 10 33 1.17 00.00 00.00 131 27 ISI-8R 9R 13011 011+ 10.5 8
27 0.90 S/N-7R 8R 11527 011+ 10.4 9
30 0.95
-00.05
-3.00 136 40 ISI 9R 12998 015+ 40.7 6
20 1.37 ISI CR 11435 015+ 40.5 6
20 1.48
-00.11 00.00 143 43 ISI 9R 12999 010+
8.1 9
30 0.75 ISI 8R 11437 010+
7.7 7
23 0.76
-00.01 07.00 ISI 9R 12999 012+
0.1 11 37 0.90 146 37 ISI 9R 13001 012+
7.5 9
30 0.98 ISI 8R 11439 012+
7.2 10 33 0.99
-00.01
-3.00 150 25 ISI 9R 13002 007+ 25.5 8
27 0.98 ISI 8R 11440 007+ 25.4 7
23 1.02
-00.04 04.00 ISI 9R 13002 015+ 19.9 6
20 0.75 ISI 8R 11440 015+ 19.6 9
30 0.76
-00.01
-10.00 Total Tubos Included :
28 Total Indications :
43 Voltage Summary :
Tubes Compared 26 Number Increased :
16 Indications Compared :
39 Number Decreased :
21 Number.No Change :
2 i
Mean Change :
0.01 Std. Dev. :
0.07 Porcent Summary :
Tubes Compared :
26 Number Increased :
14 Indications Compared 39 Number Decreased i 16 Number No Change :
.9 i
Mean Change :
0.82 Std. Dev. :
5.02
.=.- -
ATY. 1, APP. III REVISIOli 0 Page :
1 OF 2
THREE MILE ISLA1TD UliIT 1 COMPoliEliT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R TUBES PLUGGED FOLLOWIliG ECT Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent Row Tube Reason Tech Reel Location Deg Coils Volt Tested SS 126 ISI S40-MIZ18 A010 UTS +
6.2 7
23 1.00 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 UTS +
6.8 13 43 1.75 LTEUTE COliFIR 8X1-ABS A047 UTS +
6.9 10 1
2.18 UTE015 Total Tubes :
1 e
i I
l 1
ATT.
1, APP. III REVISION O Page :
2 OF 2
T11REE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG B OUTAGE : 9R TUDES PLUGGED FOLLOWING ECT Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind Sir, /
Ind Extent Row Tubo Reason Toch Roel Location Dog Colla Volt Tested 24 63 ISI 540 MIZ18 B002 007 + 20.8 7
BVC C.57 LTEUTE ISI 540 MIZ18 B002 012 + 21.4 6
BVC 0.67 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 013 +
6.5 5
BVC 0.55 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 013 + 14.1 11 37 0.83 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 013 + 30.7 14 BVC 0.66 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 014 +
0.3 23 BVC 0.88 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 014 +
5.0 13 BVC 0.61 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 E902 014 +
9.3 13 43 0.64 LTEUTE CONFIR 8X1-ABS Bu36 014 +
9.7 7
1 0.26 UTELTS ISI 540-MIZ13 B002 014 + 14.5 15 BVC 0.68 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 Old + 18.2 9
BVC 0.55 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 014 + 21.4 7
BVC 0.65 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 014 + 27.5 11 BVC 0.64 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 015 +
3.3 12 BVC 0.57 LTEUTE ISI 540*MIZ18 B002 015 + 15.9 9
BVC 0.54 LTEUTE 75 2
LANE \\W 8X1-ABS B004
+
0.0 0
NDD 0.00 014UTE CONFIR MRPC B016
+
0.0 0
0.00 004004 SLEEVE 510-MIZ18 B010 004 +
0.0 0
ADR 3.63 LTEUTE CONFIR MRPC E016 005 +
0.0 100 28 0.43 005005 SLEEVE 510-MIZ18 B010 005 +
0.0 74 NQI 3.01 LTEUTE SLEEVE 510-MIZ18 B010 006 +
0.0 0
ADR 3.12 LTEUTE Total Tuben :
2
ATT. 1, APP. IV REVISION O Page :
1 OF 13 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT SG A OUTAGE : 9R INDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent Row Tube Reason Tech Reel Location Dog Coils Volt Tested 1
14 3%-TS 510 MIZ18 A036 012 + 25.9 7
23 1.69 UTELTE 2
6 ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 015 + 25.2 7
23 1.13 LTEUTE ISI 540 MIZ18 A004 015 + 24.6 6
20 1.08 LTEUTE 2
25 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 012 + 36.0 7
23 1.18 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 013 + 10.2 7
23 1.32 LTEUTE 3
17 ISI 540 MIZ18 A007
>15 + 32.9 9
30 1.01 LTEUTE 4
29 ISI 540 MIZ18 A007 015 + 27.6 9
30 1.87 LTEUTE 5
3 ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 015 + 45.3 8
27 2.45 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 015 + 44.7 6
20 1.46 LTEUTE 5
5 ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 012 + 26.9 78 47 0.46 LTEUTE CONFIR 8X1 ABS A047
+
0.0 0
NDD 0.00 01301:'
ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 015 + 34.7 8
27 1.10 LTEUTE 6
43 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 UTS +
6.5 6
20 1.49 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 UTS +
3.8 8
27 1.44 LTEUTE 6
47 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 19.9 8
27 1.04 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 23.2 6
20 1.10 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 33.4 8
27 1.37 LTEUTE 6
48 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 UTS +
0.5 8
27 1.93 LTEUTE 8
2 ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 012 + 33.3 7
23 1.79 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 012 + 29.2 7
23 1.35 LTEUTE 8
43 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 24.5 10 33 0.95 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 28.7 7
23 0.87 LTEUTE ISI S40-MIZ18 A007 015 + 24.1 7
23 0.97 LTEUTE i
11 4
ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 015 + 21.2 10 30 0.97 LTEUTE 13 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 011 + 35.5 8
27 1.14 LTEUTE l
Continuen Next Page,>
ATT. 1, APP. IV REVISION O Page :
2 OF 13 THREE MILE ISLAND 1 UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R INDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
I INCLUDES BX1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent i
Row Tube Reason Toch Reel Location Deg Coils Volt Tested 15 77 ISI 540 MIZ18 A006 012 + 30.5 7
23 1.06 LTEUTE 17 82 ISI-BR 540-MIZ18 A006 014 + 32.2 6
20 0.77 LTEUTE 18 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 004 +
5.1 7
23 1.02 LTEUTE 18 3
ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 015 + 25.4 s
20 0.96 LTEUTE 18 84 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 32.6 6
20 1.10 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 34.4 8
27 1.23 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ15 A006 015 + 38.1 6
20 1.48 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 33.1 9
30 1.27 LTEUTE ISI SEO MIZ18 A006 015 + 40.8 11 37 1.03 LTEUTE ISI SiO-MIZ18 A006 015 > 41.9 6
20 1.33 LTEUTE 20 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 005 + 31.9 6
20 1.00 LTEUTE 20 56 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 33.3 7
23 1.02 LTEUTE j
20 85 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 014 + 31.5 8
30 0.84 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 010 + 18.9 10 33 1.16 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 010 + 18.0 8
27 1.26 LTEUTE 27 78 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 32.8 11 37 1.21 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 30.1 7
23 0.93 LT2UTE 27 96 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 LTE + 22.0 9
30 3.86 LTEUTE 28 78 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 14.6 6
20 2.59 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 28.5 10 33 1.01 LTEUTE 29 50 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 33.9 9
30 0.93 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 29.9 6
20 0.81 LTEUTE 31 1
ISI 540-MIZ10 A004 008 +
6.5 G
20 1.04 LTEUTE 33 97 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 36.0 10 33 1.02 LTEUTE Continues Next Page =>
i
~
I ATT.
1, APP. IV REVISION O Page :
3 OF 13 THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPO! TENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R I!TDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent Row Tube Reason Tech Reel Location Deg Coilo Volt Tested 33 102 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 +
5.7 6
20 1.07 LTEUTE 34 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 006 + 15.f 6
20 1.00 LTEUTE 34 3
ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 UTS +
2.0 9
30 1.22 LTEUTE 36 103 8X1-AC 540-MIZ18 A006 LTS + 35.4 5',
78 0.91 LTEUTE CONFIR 8X1-ABS A047
+
0.0 0
NDD 0.00 001LTE 37 109 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 39.0 9
30 1.01 LTEUTE 37 110 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 33.2 6
20 0.97 LTEUTE 38 29 ISI 540-MIZ18 A005 014 + 10.5 11 37 0.90 LTEUTE 39 101 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 34.7 8
27 0.99 LTEUTE 39 110 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 39.9 9
30 1.00 LTEUTE 42 114 ISI 540-MIZ18 A00ti 015 + 34.9 7
0.83 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 43.6 6
29 0.57 LTEUTE 43 82 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 007 + 37.6 8
27 0.90 LTEUTE 46 88 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 30.3 7
23 1.15 LTEUTE 48 83 ISI 540 MIZ18 A007 UTS +
6.2 10 33 1.02 LTEUTE 48 118 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 014 + 30.5 8
27 0.54 LTEUTE ISI 54 0 -liIZ1C A006 014 + 29.6 7
23 0.87 LTEUTE 49 73 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 UTS +
5.1 10 33 1.46 LTEUTE 49 85 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 36.3 7
23 1.34 LTEUTE 49 110 3%-TS 510-MIZ18 A031 LTS +
1.8 7
23 2.03 UTELTE 50 102 ISI 540-MI710 A006 015 + 16.8 9
30 1.36 LTEUTE Continues Next Page =>
a ATT. 1, APP. IV REVISION O Page :
4 OF 13 T1 3E MILE ISLAND UNIT 1
,OMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R INDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ASS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent Row Tube Reason Toch Reel Location Deg Coils Volt Tested 51 2
ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 015 +
3.1 11 37 0.88 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 015 + 20.6 11 37 0.82 LTEUTE 56 93 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 39.4 11 37 0.80 LTEUTE 57 63 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 36.9 8
27 2.01 LTEUTE 57 65 IS1 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 37.4 10 33 0.97 LTEUTE 58 94 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 44.1 7
23 0. *i 0 LTEUTE 60 65 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 37.4 7
23 1.07 LTEUTE 60 126 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 014 + 21.3 6
20 0.57 LTEUTE 63 126 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 23.0 8
27 1.01 LTEUTE 64 66 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 40.5 9
30 0.84 LTEUTE 64 129 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 45.2 11 37 1.3ti LTEUTE 65 94 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 35.9 7
23 0.80 LTEUTE 66 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 004 + 27.7 9
30 2.25 LTSUTE SLEEVE 510-MIZ18 A019 004 + 27.7 11 37 1.19 LTEUTE 66 127 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 45.2 9
30 1.14 LTEUTE 72 21 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 35.1 7
23 1.02 LTEUTE 72 54 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 32.7 6
20 1.33 LTEUTE 74 28 ISI 540-MIZ18 A004 UTS +
- 6. 0 9
31 1.67 LTEUTE 74 30 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 UTS +
5.8 10 33 0.98 LTEUTE-75 81 ISI 540-MIZ18 A007 015 + 34.9 8
07 1.23 LTEUTE Continues Next Page =>
ATT.
1, APP. IV REVISION O Page :
5 OF 13 TIIREE MILE ISLAND:tTHIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R INDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent Row Tuba Reason Tech Real Location Dog Coils Volt Tested 75 122 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 45.1 8
27 1.43 LTEUTE 75 123 ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 21.1 8
27 0.72 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A006 015 + 24.8 7
23 1.68 LTEUTE 77 126 ISI 5ts MIZ18 A010 015 + 18.1 8
27 1.29 LTEUTE 81 92 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 41.7 10 33 1.32 LTEUTE 82 32 ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 UTS +
6:3 10 33 1.80 LTEUTE 83 17 ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 35.5 10 33 1.30 LTEUTE 84 103 It'I 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 32.3 7
23 1.22 LTEUTE 87 1
ISI 540-MIt.18 A009 012 +
7.4 6
20 3.55 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 012 +
7.1 6
20 3.85 LTEUTE 87 20 ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 33.4 7
23 0.91 LTEUTE 90 80 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 30.9 10 33 1.19 LTEUTE 90 128 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 +
2.1 9
30 1.27 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 014 + 15.1 6
20 1.26 LTEUTE 93 90 ISI 540-MIZ18 A048 UTS +
0.7 7
23 0.56 UTELTE 93 123 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 +
7.1 9
30 0.92 LTEUTE 95 111 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 39.8 6
20 1.05 LTEUTE 95 123 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 UTS +
2.1 6
20 3.73 LTEUTE 93 124 ISI 540 MIZ18 A010 UTS +
2.4 8
27 0.99 LTEUTE 95 126 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 UTS +
6.8 13 43 1.75 LTEUTE CONF 7n 8X1-ABS A047 UTS +
6.9 10 1
2.18 UTE015 Continuos Next Page =>
ATT.
1, APP, IV REVISION O Page 6
OF 13 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE 9R INDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent Row Tubo Roanon Toch Reel Location Dag Colla Volt Tested ISI 540 MIZ18 A010 UTS +
6.2 7
23 1.00 LTEUTE 95 127 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 A010 012 + 13.4 6
20 0.77 LTEUTE l
96 32 ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 015 + 43.4 11 37 1.29 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 015 + 37.7 10 33 1.76 LTEUTE 1
98 93 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 UTS +
<>3 6
20 1.36 LTEUTE 99 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 004 + 24.2 8
27 1.32 LTSUTE 99 17 ISI 540 MIZ18 A009 015 + 33.3 6
20 1.82 LTEUTE 100 122 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 UTS +
5.1 8
27 1.83 LTEUTE 101 16 ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 31.3 7
23 1.24 LTEUTE 101 51 ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 UTS +
4.3 11 37 1.18 LTEUTE 101 61 ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 29.4 7
23 2.07 LTEUTE 103 121 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 44.0 8
27 1.17 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 014 + 15.8 6
20 1.37 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 43.7 8
27 2.29 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 014 + 12.4 10 33 1.14 LTEUT11 104 75 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 40.9 7
23 0.60 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 29.4 9
30 0.72 LTEUTE 105 94 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 014 +
0.1 93 25 2.32 LTEUTE 106 2
ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 10.6 8
27 0.91 LTEUTE 107 29 ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 015 + 77.7 7
23 1.41 LTEUTE 107 116 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 43.5 7
23 0.88 LTEUTE 107 120 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 UTS +
4.9 7
23 1.22 LTEUTE Continuea Next Page =>
-1
ATT. 1, APP. IV REVISION O Page :
7 0F 13 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R INDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
i INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent Row Tube Reason Tech Real Location Deg Coils Volt Tested ISI 540 MIZ18 A010 006 + 23.4 6
20 1.17 LTEUTE 110 52 ISI 540-MIZ16 A008 015 + 40.5 11
'38 0.96 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 UTS +
1.1
-6 21 1.13 LTEUTE 111 51 ISI 540 MIZ16 A008 015 + 38.0 8
27 2.06 LTEUTE 112 116 ISI 540 MIZ18 A010 012 + 24.9 11 37 0.98 LTEUTE ISI 540 MIZ18 A010 012 + 22.3 9
30 1.64 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 012 + 35.0 11 37 1.04 LTEUTE 114 93 ISI 540 MIZ18 A0*8 015 + 40.0 10 33 1.50 LTEUTE 115 26 ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 015 + 25.6 11 37 1.43 LTEUTE' 115 109 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010.UTS +
5.1 6
20 3.04 LTEUTE 116 2
ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 A009 006 +
3.8 10 33 2.22 LTEUTE 116 109 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 36.9 11 37 1.12 LTEUTE 117 24 ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 015 + 33.8 6
20
'1.87 LTEUTE 118 67 ISI 540 MIZ18 A009 015 + 37.5 10 33 1.22 LTEUTE 119 77 ISI 540-MIZ14, A009 015 + 28.8 9
30 1,72 LTEUTE 119 107 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 + 38.8 7
23 1.92 LTEUTE 120 67 ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 35.9 10 33 1.33 LTEUTE 121 104 ASI 540-MIZ18 A010 015 +
4.3 8
27' 1.22 LTRUTE 122 26 ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 015 + 45.9 9
30-1.18 LTEUTE 123 85 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 45.4 9
30 1.19 LTEUTE 123 96 ISI 540-MIZ18.A018 015 + 41.5 6
20 2.03 LTEUTE Continues Next Page =>
l l
l I;
..x-
-.--.....-...-.;_,,.:-~=-...,..,
ATT. 1, APP. IV REVISION O Page :
8 OF 13 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R INDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
- m Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent Row Tube Reason Tech Rool Location Dog Coils Volt Tested ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 42.5 10 33 1.23 LTEUTE 124 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 012 + 23.5 8
27 1.74 LTEUTE 125 82 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 34.7 7
23 1.06 LTEUTE 125 97 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 40.9 10 33 1.02 LTEUTE 126 1
GE20-0 510-MIZ18 A035 012 + 21.2 11 37 1.03 UTELTE 126 94 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 & 36.0 11 37 2.28 LTEUTE 126 97 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 01.5 + 26.4 7
23 1.26 LTEUTE 127 94 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 UTS +
4.7 10 33 1.13 LTEUTE 129 66 EETRA 510-MIZ18 A028 LTE +
7.2 7
23 9.23 UTELTE 130 4.
ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 015 + 27.7 9
31 1.32 LTEUTE 130 60 ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 33.8 8
27 0.98 LTEUTE 130 73 ISI 540-MIZ18 A013 015 + 41.5 9
30 0.78 LTEUTE 131 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 013 + 25.6 9
30 1.28 LTEUTE 131 82 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 -
0.1 10 33 1.02 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 42.3 7
23 1.42 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 37.3 8
27 1.80 LTEUTE 132 39 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 A008 015 + 30.9 9
31 0.82 LTEUTE 134 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 004 +
2.3 7
23 1.47 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 004 +
3.5 6
20 1.14 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 004 +
1.5 6
20 1.02 LTEUTE 134 65 ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 37.2 8
27 1.63 LTEUTE 135 2
ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 3 17.5 7
13 0.83 LTEUTE Continues Next Page =>
-.m____.._
___.__.__-_________-__._.____m_m.
I
)
ATT.
1, APP. IV REVISION O Page :
9 OF 13 THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT SG A OUTAGE : 99 INDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS
'E 40 % T.W.
I j'
Row Tube Reason Tech Reel Location Deg Coils Volt Tested Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Exte:2t 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 35.9 6
20 1.?9 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 013 + 33.5 8
27 0.95 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 014 +
0.6 10 33 1.05 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 16.3 6
20 0.84 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 11.5 9
30 1.11 LTEUTE 135 5
ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 014 + 27.6 6
20 1.55 LTEUTE 136 5
ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 39.3 8
27 1.48 LTEUTE 136 6
ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 015 + 36.9 11 37 1.65 LTEUTE 136 69 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 37.1 8
27 2.36 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 3 3. 0 7
23 1.15 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 11.5 6
20 1.26 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 +
8.8 6
20 0.73 LTEUTE 137 53 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 18.5 9
30 0.88 LTEUTE 138 65 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 UTS +
6.1 10 33 1.85 LTEU.'E 139 67 ISI 540-MIZ18 AC18 015 + 45.9 11 37 1.53 LTSUTE 139 71 ISI 540-MIZ18 A010 013 + 25.7 8
27 1.90 LTEUTE 140 67 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 UTS +
3.6 11 37 3.19 LTEUTE 141 60 ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 44.8 9
30 0.55 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 44.2 6
20 1.01 LTEUTE 143 55 ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 UTS +
3.1 9
30 1.30-LTEUTE 143 57 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 A018 015 + 42. 9 7
23 1.15 LTEUTE 146 1
ISI 540-MIZ18 A000 004 + 35.5 8
27 1.88 LTEUTE 146 43 ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 3 3. 8 8
27 0.93 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 36.0 6
20 0.89 LTEUTE Continues Next Page =>
ATT. 1, APP. IV REVISION O THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A i
OUTAGE : 9R INDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent Row Tube Res on Tech Reel Location Dog Coilo Volt Tested j
ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 015 + 35.0 11 37 0.94 LTEUTE
)
146 50 ISI 540-MIZ18 A009 003 + 35.8 8
-27 1.91 LTEUTE 147 2
ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 012 + 10.5 10 33 1.13. LTEUTE i
150 8
ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 015 + 18.5 8
27 0.96 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 A008 015 +
3.5 8
27 1.08 LTEUTE 250 24 DSS /DT 540-MIZ18 A009 013 + 32.7 6
20 1.07 LTEUTE l
Total Tuben Included :
149 total Indications :
203 Note Thia list includes only indications greater than or equal to 20 % through wall during outage 9R.
l l-l l
l-l
l l
ATT.
1, APP. IV REVISION O Page :
11 OF 13 THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG B OUTAGE : 9R INDICATIONS >- 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 10 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extant Row Tube Reason Toch Reel Location Deg Coils Volt Tested 6
4 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 UTS +
5.2 7
2 '.,
2.31 LTEUTE 7
42 ISI
$40-MIZ18 B002 012 + 12.2 7
23 0.89 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 014 + 22.9 8
27 0.81 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 013 + 11.4 8
27 0.99 LTEUTE 8
44 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 B002 014 + 29.3 10 33 0.65 LTEUTE ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 B002 014 + 16.3 11 37 0.00 LTEUTE 9
22 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 015 + 44.6 8
27 1.19 LTEUTE 19 44 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 015 + 41.2 8
27 1.72 LTEUTE 24 11 GE20-0 510-MIZ18 B023 005 + 31.1 9
30 2.14 UTELTE 24 63 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 013 + 14.1 11 37 0.83 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 014 +
9.3 13 43 0.64 LTEUTE CONFIR 8X1 ABS B036 014 +
9.7 7
1 0.26 UTELTE 30 13 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 015 + 45.2 9
30 2.17 LTEUTE 30 71 ISI 540-MIZ18 B014 015 + 32.0 6
20 1.71 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B014 015 + '< 2. 7 9
30 1.14 LTEUTE 38 72 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 B014 012 + 35.8 9
30 0.85 LTFUTE ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 E914 012 +
7.7 13 43 0.81 LTEUTE CONFIR 8X1-ABS B036 012 +
7.7 0
NDD 0.00 UTELTE 44 75 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 B002 015 + 3r 3 6
20 0.94 LTEUTE ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 B002 015 +
1.3 8
27 0.62 LTEUTE ISI-8R 54 0-MI"'18 B002 014 +
9.8 11 37 0.75 LTEUTE ISI-8R 540-MI418 B002 013 + 29.0 7
23 0.90 LTEUTE 50 39 ISI-8R 54 0-M* " 3 B002 008 + 34.0 8
27 1.22 LTEUTE 60 83 ISI 540 tIZ18 B002 015 + 39.3 11 37 1.01 LTEUTE 64 83 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 015 + 31.5 10 33 1.23 LTEUTE Continues Next Page =>
I
ATT.
1, APP. IV REVISION O Page :
12 OF 13 THREE MILE ISLAND; UNIT 1 COMPONEN7' : SG B OUTAG6 : 9R INDICATIONS ;= 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent Row Tube Keason Tech Reel Location Deg Coils Volt Tented 74 56 ISI-BR 540-MIZ18 B014 014 +
2.1 10 33 1.46 LTEUTE 75 2
CONFIR MRPC B016 005 +
0.0 100 28 0.43 005005 75 4
CONFIR MRPC B016 015 +
0.3 95 37 1.01 015015
'.63 LTEUTE 7!
47 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 B002 004 + 25.0 79 33 82 14 CONFIR MRPC B031 006 +
0.6 1
22 0.70 006006 103 33 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 P ^e ! "
014 +
0.0 8
27 1.53 L2surs 104 77 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 UTS +
4.1 8
27 1.62 Lrsurs
'.22 LTEUTE 105 8
ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 UTS +
6.5 8
27 109 11 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 015 + 44.9 6
20 t.12 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 015 + 46.0 7
23 0.89 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 UTS +
5.3 9
30 1.12 LTEUTE 109 112 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 004 +
0.0 7
23 1.88 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 004 +
4.9 9
30 1.21 LTEUTE 122 44 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 UTS +
3.0 6
20 2.21 LTUUTE 124 36 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 015 + 45.3 10 33 1.17 LTEUTE-131 27 ISI-8R 540-MIZ18 B002 011 + 10.5 8
27 0.90 L'1EU"'E 136 40 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 015 + 40.7 6
20 1.37 LTEUTE 143 43 ISI 540-MIZ18 B014 012 +
0.1 11 37 0.90 LTEUTE ISI 540-MIZ18 B014 010 +
8.1 9
30 0.75 LTEUTE 146 37 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 012 +
7.5 9
30 0.98 LTEUTE 150 25 ISI 540-MIZ18 B002 007 + 25.5 8
27 0.98 LTEUTE Continues Next Page =>
I,
l i
ATT.
1, APP. IV REVISION O Paue :
13 OF 13 THREE MILE ISLAND UNIT 1 CCMPONENT : SG B OUTAGE : 9R
-l INDICATIONS >= 20 % T.W.
INCLUDES 8X1-ABS FOR INDICATIONS GE 40 % T.W.
Exam Exam Exam Indication Ind
%/
Ind Extent i
Row Tube Reason Tech Reel Location Deg Coils Volt Tested j
ISI 540-MIZl8 B002 015 + 19.9 6-20 0.75 1UTEUTE Total Tubes Included :
31 Total Indications :
43 This list centains only indications greater than or equal to Note :
20 % through wall during outage 9R.
E ATT.-1,'iAPP.LV~
REVISION-0 Page'si il;of 2 GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES:
THREE MILE ISLAND PLANT,_ UNIT-#1.
SCHEDULE DAY'ONI llE
- 30 -12:30 - 1:00 Introduction
- Course-Objective
- Overview-
- Schedule of Activities
- 30 1:00 - l:30 Miz-18 Bobbin Coil Guidelines.-
(Class' Reading Assignment)
- 15 1:30 - 1:45 Break
- 30 1:45 - 2:15 Miz-16 Bobbin-Coil Guideline Lecture-
_ Instructor Directed)_
(
- 30 2:15 - 2:45
-8XI Analysis' Guideline (Class Reading-Assignment}.
- 15 2:45 - 3:00
-Break-
- 30 3:00 -.3:30
.8X1 Analysis Lecture (Instructor Directed)
- 45-3:30 - 4:15 Set-up Equi ~pment E
I ATT.
1, APP. V REVISION 0 Page :
2'ef 2 1
SchtDULE (Cont.)
DAY TWO 4:00 8:00 - 12:00 Practice Tape Lab Session (Class Reviews Tape)
- 45 12:00 - 12:45 Lunch 4:00 12:45 - 4:45 Practical Examination (Night Shift)
DAY THREE 4:00 8:00 - 12:00 Practical Examination (Day Shift)
Times shown could be subject to change nr modification.
1 l
ATT.
1, APP. VI REVISION O Page :
1 OF 6
THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R TUBES SLEEVED DURING "9R" Sleeve Sleeve Exam Exam Exam Extent Row Tube Location Length Reason Tech Reel Tested 58 1
Inist 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 68 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 68 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 60 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 69 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A052 LSEUSE 69 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COM30 A052 LSEUSE 69 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBv A051 LSEUSE 70 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 70 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 70 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 70 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A052 LSEUSE 70 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A052 LSEUSE 71 1
Inlet 60" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A052 LSEUSE 71 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 71 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 71 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A052 LSEUSE 71 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 72 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 72 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 72 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 72 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 72 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 73 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A052 LSEUSE 73 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 73 3
Inlet 80" POST"SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 73 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 73 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 73 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 73 7
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 1
Inlct 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO AOS1 LSEUSE 74 2
Inlot 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 3
Inlot 00" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-CCMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 7
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 0
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 22 Inlet 00" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 23 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 24 Inlet 80" POST -SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 74 25 Inlet 00" POST-SLEEV 400-COMSO A051 LSEUSE 75 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 7
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 8
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 9
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 10 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE
hTT.
1,_ APP.-VI REVISION O Page :
2 OF 6-THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R TUBES SLEEVED DURING "9R" Sleeve Sleeve Exam Exam Exam Extent Row Tube Location Length Reason Tech Reel Tested-75 11 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 12 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 13 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMEO A051 LSEUSE 75 14 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 15 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 16 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A0s1 LSEUSE 75 17 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE-75 18 Inlot 80d POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 19 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 20 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 21 Inlet 00" POGT-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 22 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 23 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 24 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE' 75 25 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 26 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 27 Znlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 75 28 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A' ail LSEUSE-75 29 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 7
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 8
Inlot 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 9
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 10 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV '400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 11 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO
.A051 LSEUSE 77 12 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 13 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 14 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 15 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 16 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 17 Inlet 60" POST-SLEEV; -400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 18 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 19 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 20 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 21 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV-400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 22 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 23 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE-77 24 Inlet 80" POGT-SLEEV-400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 25 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 26 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 27 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 28 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 77 29 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 70 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 78 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 78 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE
y
-O ATT.
1, APP. VI REVISION O Page :
3 OF 6
THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG A OUTAGE : 9R TUBES SLEEVED DURING "9R" Sleeve Sleeve Exam Exam Exam Extent Row Tube Location Length Reason Tech Reel Tested 78 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 78 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 78 7
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 78 8
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 78 22 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 78 23 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMDO A051 LGEUSE 78 24 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 78 25 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 79 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 79 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 79 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 79 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 79 7
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 80 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 L3EUSE 80 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 80 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 80 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 80 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 L3EUSE 81 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 81 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 81 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 82 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 82 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 82 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 40C-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 82 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 83 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A052' LSEUSE.
83 2
Inlet 8v" POST-SLEEV 400-COMLO A051 LSEUSE 83 3
T.nlot 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COM3C A051 LSEUSE 83 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COM%
A051 LSEUSE 83 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 84 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 84 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE 84 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO A051 LSEUSE Total Tubes :
125
=
0 ATT.
1, APP. VI REVISIOh 0 Page :
4 OF 6-TMREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG B OUTAGE : 9R TUBES SLEEVED DURING "9R" Sleeve Sleeve Exam Exam Exam Extent Row Tube Location Length Reason Tech Reel Tested 67 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038
-LSEUSE-68 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 68 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 -
LSEUSE 68 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE-68 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 69 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LbEUSE 69 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 69 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE-69 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 69 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 70 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 70 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B03P LSEUSE 70 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 70 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 70 5
Inlet 80r POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 71 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 71 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE-71 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 71 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 71 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 71 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEE7 -400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 72 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 72 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 72 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO D038 LSEUSE 72 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO
=B038 LSEUSE 72 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 72 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038' LSEUSE 73 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 L3EUSE 73 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 73 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO
'B033 LSEUSE 73 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B030 LSEUSE 73 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 73 7
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 1
Inlet 80h POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE.
74 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 7
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE-74 8
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 22 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 23 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 24 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 25 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 74 43 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE o
ATT. 1,-APP. VI REVISION O Page-:
5 OF 6
THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG B OUTAGE : 9R TUBES SLEEVED DURING "9R" Sleeve Sleeve Exam Exam Exam Extent Row Tube Location Length Reason Tech Reel Tested 75 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 9
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 10 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 11 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE j
75 12 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 13 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 14 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 15 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE-I 75 16 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 17 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 18 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 19 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 20 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 21 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 22 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 23 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 24 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 25 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 26 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 27 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 28 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 75 29 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77
.10 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 11 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 13 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 15 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 16 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV.400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 17 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 20 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 21 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 22 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 23 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 25 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 26 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 77 27 Inlut 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE I
77 28 Inlet 30" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 7 '7 29 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 78 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 78 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 78 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 78 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE l
l
ATT.
1, APP. VI REVISION O Page :
6 OF 6
THREE MILE ISLAND: UNIT 1 COMPONENT : SG B OUTAGE : 9R TUBES SLEEVED DURING "9R" Sleeve Sleeve Exam Exam Exam Extent Row Tube Location Length Roason Tech Reel Tested 78 7
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B030 LSEUSE 78 8
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 78 22 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 4 00 '-COM30 2038 LSEUSE 78 24 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 78 25 Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 79 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 79 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV COO-COMBO B030 LSEUSE 79 3
Inlet 60" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 79 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 79 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 79 7
Inlet 80" FOST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B033 LSEUSE 80 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMEO B038 LSEUSE 80 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 80 4
Inlct 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 80 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 81 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 81 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 81 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 81 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 81 5
Inlet 80" POST-SL2EV 400-COMBO B038
-LSEUSE 81 6
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 82 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO 11038 LSEUSE 82 2
Inlet 80" POCT-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 82 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 82 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 83 1
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 83 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 83 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 83 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 83 5
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 84 2
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 84 3
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE 84 4
Inlet 80" POST-SLEEV 400-COMBO B038 LSEUSE Total Tubes :
125 l
.J