ML20107J786

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Licensee Proposed Findings in Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law on Dieckamp Mailgram Issue Submitted by TMI Alert & Nrc.Log of Radiation Readings Encl
ML20107J786
Person / Time
Site: Three Mile Island Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 02/25/1985
From: Blake E
GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP., SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To: Linenberger G, Smith I, Wolfe S
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML20107J790 List:
References
CON-#185-765 SP, NUDOCS 8502280019
Download: ML20107J786 (11)


Text

'

~

. 765 ..

w.

'. SHAW, PtW)TWAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE

. P..TNE1.hM P ,NCLuo oN.6co.*on.T.oNs l ' ; seco uId . N. W.

WASHINGTON. D. C. 20036 F. s V o.poTTS No. -

  • E M.uTM.N svLvi. M

.YEv .?L. PeTTM N. p c. "'SCob.

S urLL.

  • C Cu B e o.NNETH J voo L *mENCE p,LLE.

st.rrmr.y LotREen sNL.vogn..

GEORGE r. Taow sTEpwam o poTTs p RioGE. PPC.C. moe mo.rEn? nv E.

N

.. 2sTE Ns. R. Jo.L.E...

p C.. p c. . "f g F#f of 8C E L MLEIN 8' VE N * ' ' ' ' "

o 4vL NNE

""'um o. ponrE m NoE 25"'J!s, nT ov Jc

".'."o.sch.*.C. vcTo,... 3 M'TJ" ". T.#.f.2..

-T o,E: ,e. e izob ei24cm ezzieo "L

-.t'*"."f

'E 1."iti"'" i

.r;t.v..s ^ 2.c*?'",N a . a. .. .. N7.o s. . .. c s

T-o- N c=L uNo N LsTc oro oc .T - NL.o.

o s.c .c.

.. o.v o - N.-

!aERt C,th;Eh ,.e $?"" LS",i'hyc" "' Fic (F4ECRETARY Le#^tL'!"JIto.N cJP*??:12a"u..N Lf.Si

  • 2,"ci.R*W.J. -e
  • NTIN o. mm L # C. M 8

'Jl GL di.c.'RV 1,'.a'PpN. c G ** E G E L ING ** J..'.oL uost- E.c R"h*".

s

-.N

  • J 8". ".lit.JI."
  • fR 's #^s" TON W'AP9(F. .EOc L E *G ,8 CT.!Jit'%'ts5TT c.  ;"a"*J .r!#2.""'c" . 0"?."."*o'! Et it "N"R'C M? #'""'"

?!?st".rstPI% c." Eh'."AT". " "A"?AM ~ .az m is~.-L.~*sa Ja*J.fo",R8"'" ""- M2"'J" IsiVf."."'c"

,...c^"._$***'.**,-

~ ~

7 #L t "H.~ it .M.o.'T".c'"'o-*,... "/.c::tl:M

%J.5.h.v,o*.*N.nc . c '""<! S J. . c.

"Et.u.t

- 8.'.u?..f. ". , - 0 oo-oT~ e..t.. *4,c.;c o .ll.* ,8 5 ..

. . LNotl'*"/;"s"#c 1": *

"8"E".'s" terW's ~; y ,.o. .

.. o ,,,c . . y' 5 5".%'.1" "o."c'"* " e8"^ol".WJ^ 7.oc.

1*.?"*! ^J"^".s 25c. Efra"f ".*;'Mi""'" < isoi r' - c eoi? o=#a "'Ot * !?A"4 . "e"c^r"%^::!:^c"'"*

i re";11 nc",'.'i,7.c. e af2nti^~'"I'"% .-w4a wmmoei- r Era',e'n.^.*::a. c"2"! t ". W . '

52!.'s iu"fc'i'!"c "' !an,". '.".9"at. ... - hi4' #,.c'""c"- c a WRL*. y*J."'si"..'N c TJ/~"?/ht,?s .... , c.. 81 ."PJ cvti""o'2"' "" ** "o*" or a'" D*":?c!.

.  !"Sc*".c. "an ':, "".15&"L.,

"9N "II.c?t# ..c. tot"si "?.".fr*-c.. "'c "^ " * " ' ^ * ^r.'I^o'i 'afv"o"Jf;*ze,u.

tJ 1E .5M2 .?c.

ocuss.  :: aioow.,v

^.5.* E c "" "o'i"."# meg "'0"."'.'^"*

s.if"#.#."

ucs "ftJ""d.

m.uvN. p " "' cou

"' 's'c L t!'.J.11.!:s og g . u,,orm ^ &ti'. "8,."2':7 o c s.s:1.?.2?;",'t pino.

.......c

......s ....c,...L ...

822-1084 February 25, 1985 Ivan W. Smith, Esq., Chairman Administrative Law Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Sheldon J. Wolfe, Esquire Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger, Jr.

Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 In the Matter of Metropolitan Edison Company (Three Mile Island Nuclear Station Unit No. 1)

Docket No. 50-289 SP Gentlemen:

During the remanded heat. on the Dieckamp mailgram issue, Licensee referred to a statement in NUREG-0600 8502280019 850225 PDR ADOCK 05000289 0 PDR hY . - _

  • SHAw, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNER $Mtp Or peorgSSION AL CORpCRAT'ONS Messrs. Smith, Wolfe and Linenberger February 25, 1985 Page 2 concerning offsite and onsite radiation maasurements. Tr.

30,420-22. Licensee intended to rely on this statement to dem-onstrate, if necessary, that any 3mR/hr reading of which Walter Creitz learned prior to 11:00 a.m. on March 28, 1979, must have been an onsite reading.1/ The pertinent part of NUREG-0600 stated:

Radiation levels measured by land-based onsite and offsite teams first began to in-crease at 1020 on March 28, with an onsite team in the North Parking lot reporting a radiation level of 3mR/hr.-

Offsite radiation levels reported during this period, with the exception of 50 mR/hr measured at 1548 on PA Route-441 about 1500 feet south of northgate . . ., were not above background until 2238 when a radia-tion level of 13 mR/hr was measured near Kunkel School (5.6 mi. n.w.).

NUREG-0600, JME 1(c)(62) at II-3-81.2/

In preparing Reply Findings, Licensee noted a discrepancy between this statement and Table II-C-1 in NUREG-0600, which records several above background offsite readings after 11:00 a.m. but long before 1548 or 2238 on March 28th. Licensee then reviewed the accident radiation survey log for the 28th and 1/ In its proposed findings, TMIA has attempted to establish that before addressing the PaPUC on the day of the acci-dent, Mr. Dieckamp was informed by Mr. Creitz of a 3mR/hr

offsite radiation level that allegedly had been measured l before 11
00 a.m. Thus, Licensee found it necessary to address this issue in its Reply Findings. See Licensee's Reply Findings, dated February 25, 1985, 11 30-35.

2/ The Report of the Special Inquiry Group similarly stated,

" Measured offsite radiation levels generally remained l below background levels except for a reading of 50mR/h at 7:48 p.m. on the road east of Unit 2 near the Observation Center." Report of the Special Inquiry Group, Vol. II, Part 3, at 868.

i

< ~

c .

s

  • SHAw, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PAeTNEasMIP or poorgss40NAL CompoeAttoms Messrs. Smith, Wolfe and Linenberger February 25, 1985 Page 3 determined it confirms the NUREG-0600 Table that in fact levels above-background were-detected offsite shortly after 11:00 a.m.

-The radiation survey log3 / is attached for the Board's informa-tion.

{

It still remains Licensee's position that any 3mR/hr radi-ation level of which Mr. Creitz learned prior to 11:00 a.m. on the 28th was an onsite level. However, Licensee does not wish to cite a statement in NUREG-0600 that appears to be inaccurate in other respects, or for the Board to be misled. Accordingly,

! Licensee in its Reply Findings (LIC Reply 32) cites Table II-C-1 of NUREG-0600. This table is in evidence, although it was not noticed for citation by Licensee during the hearing.

In. addition, Licensee takes the opportunity to alert the Board and parties to several additional references to the Joint Mailgram Exhibit which were not noticed for citation during the hearing. Licensee found it necessary to cite these references to reply to TMIA's " time gap" theory (TMIA PP 200-202) -- an argument which TMIA. raised in its findings. These citations are JME 1(c)(67) at 17, JME 1(c)(62) at I-A-89 and I-A-103, and JME 1(c)(10) at 21. The citations appear at LIC REPLY 39.

Respectfully submitted, SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE

$. t -

Ernest L. Blake, Jr., P.C.

Counsel for Licensee Attachment cc: Service List t

3/ This log was produced during discovery, and the second page of the log was admitted into evidence as part of TMIA Mailgram Exh. 32B. The radiation readings of interest here, however, appear on the first page. Because the first page of the log is not in evidence, Licensee has not relied on it in its Reply (even though it may be the best evidence on this point).

v.

1 N d iii M of/MYk) M c[M 5~w _.

9L33 ]

I i if d'. k W _idd % d,_-

ICL561 - Il !/ b40. ! C 1 l161c2l - s- .NANDN4Gl0" I d2Hil. % C+. is

\1%I ?)J;h_'?

/t d N -t 4 ' " b F E b?lc c t j4'/ ,

! 2 /l ,

_l.E M I, hh.,;

/A' J J I <

o

\

ll-

'E9\S-fhbk I o

q w _z xi.>-

a JO0D' l \ l' /. 5 ]4.4 C4 h r

//)$\ \ I /- if,gft/&

c  % Gkh l ) fgj _

Q_____,_.___a_

. /D 9 ! _ Gh6 l 9,0 E i14/ai i ~ & s-

'/ A W I i i ,

lAY\l I O '

W- $,1 /- v 2 '6 l L W 6t A P

///ls' I -

i /\

l

-w

//S[

, wM. , f.cae,uiu M/ ,

! i  !

- w"c j

/// Z.! l .

W/. '

i jht scZ}/:OE#

>,g' 3  !%  ! l ~ fM6bi dh.

,1 b di ,

% d M M .*

.009 -

M .

m\ Wwir 3 ~l l iio7 2 p a--n v~ar ll0bf h I

\

~ ~ l4t$ d (J M lE. W W

/04'fr 5~. ./aod i

i OW/n M am.M i'_'* *

//Oy,,

$]. _,, l  : <

_ g y (34 ,f_g f ,4/ ,a

_3 (j

/ 06'T i -

i  !  !/ !  ;  ! I dp -h -  !  ! ___

loff I l  !//

1 l

i l

hHo%6%'.' . ,

,, .a,...s x

k [:

//J l/(/.  ! i <!  !

Mi ' T i

!4 wh 8W _-

/0't'9 i l3 l

/[)f ' I

, k/ l l HM ; b b" '

2 -3 A/ SmA>A N _-

A .E l- _2 - .ll/ l. 'bbAO"- '

A!9.  :

z/ -bzWJ9 i 42/gg.:w,:ktefo.J

, i i - b et K 1 W ._._

g/a wr .

,  ;$#f g g _

l  !  !

l l .l >

  • k -

I

. I t  : a,/~2.V Q)

?t) l /AI84+*

& xMit& Qt Taws

~

Ln W %3ti LC9b, t A.74/h4Agd J)SizKulf&f%

bVso s= Asks 4nsu \dk. :ktAW v x &&wM

~

oiva /

iM9 , ..... 4/ JZ& M iiCL  %'

/m2 /$2 f G E , / o N' Am  !

w , h %g

~

l iM~ f'l ef

/JS3 (f M

'o?l$l l l

.[L i t$: 98F-VMke!

2/!

/

(Mha_.

K \ k545-Chdled W2M-66b Wf.

/ast

. /&fl I l El 2 /' l _ l AN#/S

/Mi!  !

!! b !l A&4DP9E@%Zh$

t3N,i I l i ild'I l  ! A'TaMoM/

vg h sL# '!

s  !  !!l Id~il l j

%r2J \  ! 2-3; \ \ M % 2n w /is& an h .

/39 '7 I

3-4! >

l5M /hDi / ad EAic i

'/309 I  !

!& 3: I Md ])wd H'\ujeAu%2.

/32b ' ' -

4 '

!  ! i  ; W far)W .

x. PasA MLc Ass  ;

'4 i 1 gn i > 4

<a i  : i

.ay 44. kh sn1

, /3Jo  !  : i /o i  ! .

! In$hdL%%

lld i

1320 I i  !

L l GR;Mih@oS_

A yl !I M71EifAh6 i MsdifJE

' lb!M'

,ey IFiII y ,

wii .

(M n ,

W 1.

w kl' f '

l l \ F /0 SRn /2alH ap c)WJW/A%

n M,

((+c..; L

~,

a i d.

W a,mr-2

$ - $ $ &w?fi.$$ ~

/00$ ' \ i 1 G*li/6l N h4

. N a 6 n i n u u fl 3 ! R f ,

Ou2&T T r w w " (r#JaAwuAEA>Q p% m m

_(3 . .

i i nl

.=.

3/23.

(,

i l

I l '

_ a t ,# % U m h

, l'////W L/ L MI -

ih2

~

g33 $o L, n /1 ,

(2, W )

~'r' 746% ~7[ 243 E -Oai6%

  1. /0 Q 7135/F/MM N..# .

~

iW '1 1 7~\A 2RE-2 1 Het VM  %

ig41 T\ ~70 WLJ 'i I i M M~ ~

/W7 i l l 'P 2- #4 hm %

$U2 i l I SD M 0/M M_S-5

~74 _ ! \@IdluA-

/54/Pl  :

i Z/ I I 70 l

/p//  !  ! i l l <  : i 16Lj& I l l0' J/ym [s i z h h g h 4 ) j , g g y

_/&N[ $il$'l l

lJhef $mttY0?Edj f

/6Td ,

i  : K/:  !

If . L-)lo424 sist-b /' ~

L/ l M Af/ W jfho$

l l is//\ ,

i 20 ' '  !

l YMs/Aulu&. L

//o M 4

40 ;  ! l l  : , M 40l'  ;

1 2<WS-i%dACC W M  ! I' l

$ U/0 i l  ? i i 45'IN \ l

+ SQh u r [ d M .s (b.ft

/(bOl '! T A4.N'7/ W Y a d it'd NijiF N S

//)//f I INi I i M SedvMMW Wro  ! l  !  ! 2 / !,d/ A/v M/ h'

' 2/ja ddo!. ' '

I ' ' I

/%2O l ,

l  !

, rt2O l l  !  ; / 2 /O m8 '

! I-

(@ <To Wh-fo /

/7 o ' '

i V /o  ;

,/ "'!  !  !

! l 9'O  : l M XI _

, /-i 3Y I I 2Y'f TA//1 .

i .giMfR W i ,

~

1 .

' ' "{ '  ; iii l l l l i i

i T[ks t lRJAA&, * ~! OR 9'WoesIw

'73 M.-we!!llem'$I.!FI + i Mffedt^W

%1 . PM' i

sd e! -

'cw' -

l 3 b ?' MltlMVfW N,$hTf s , il

, ,. N k t 4[ .

N L_ _. 0_Q . k ke ~

. '. &q L L W % k Ju.+.L L s: s s 3 '

I h a'r i  ;

! I<lJ/hi1 L.r,4 e i '

i

! n><! . .-d.LS,? --

& N kva_w % - ._

.l

  • i I i 'l l

_k $

~ t

!tt10  ; t % ur inet '

f i i '

g ,

- l *

(taa . .

qs m,/m i

w e .c r<

. tT.5 d

<.O's weltt<3. u CATG _. _ _

l 'g3p _

4, o @  ! i "t.A N d -

b lig35 _

4l  ! .

h[ .3c ..

u I

!}9 if  ;

dl' l

]

f '/ flc ms firicl> e .h*? N. C"h

. If Yiy '

d'. 9 5 , p/ Q B., f_ fluj W

(7tG &I 19L7 '

l2 4 hic w_

se r,w a ~j _

62 o. /3-%/ hr.6, . . --

t'yya I \ '5 l /

k l [9'O '

C{' kf=wth (1 1 4 < &.. - .. -

  • i  ;

(tyo

  • __J _ 2Adr_f - -

k .. i1D YQ~#'f a N -- , B_d < a d_.EL u y\

tw , . , ~ .. .

Aklh .

Q

3/ 2. D -W l

_/.9 f _

Y

., i i i i i  : i-! i  ! i . . i .

2610 0 ~ 7-- los= d L st]< 0 N4 Nc~ e ~

.  ; Ljf d ' i l i

A Jolh ~foY a h Nf~

~

[ ~!i a ,gd-t '

_4 abo  !

Li.i.sse n ghin : GMho  !

$O3(.). _ . -

' f. /MDi9 :

i> ..

^

2t'$fL RO:n

! i l

&yY .

8ib Ai ,,

!W!m  ;  ; ,

! T b i a/4/W.d8* -

2 232 : . m /kmrbr: - ] D & fhdepA Y $$

' . -. h)?2.V f h (M S$.s De $ _.

floo 6mr$r '% i  % hed Ae m (N&T t

& r

......-e. . . . . . .

33is~ Am ear

_2 110 _ '/ war "

  1. l L& M -vw _ n - y2 .
  1. 32o __/04 -/h _ .

2325__ / ($ $p,, N _.Wh _

d2$.30 }6 GeWL '

M ;)

233r ,

l

//pr0v i

\W l

$33) '

23S! 'I l $ /[pu(///

. 3 w flr I

Whd /s& ,

, L -

QA' Xesk/ k den)

Y. ,

S"  !

hf f ' '

_S 005 } ' '

cle-/& _

, , ymft) -

g,%d20.'N 3herlAf L #6rNrQSeb .

v, i

L _.

y -

.~ , ... . . .

c,. . ,.,, , .

j** e ,

e I

' 9' I (

f l/

=

Chox4

< W fM4h Wh E& ,

r's o 3 9 / A, e 3 ,t.

l A v i

i i

, h s

9 0

0 U.

.. t k jg

+ .

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD

~~~f In the Matter of )

)

METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-289

) (Restart Remand '

(Three Mile Island Nuclear ) on Management)

Station, Unit No. 1) ) ""1 6_

SERVICE LIST Nunzio J. Palladino, Chairman Administrative Judge U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Gustave A. Linenberger, Jr.

Washington, D.C. 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board ',

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Thomas M. Roberts, Commissioner Washington, D.C. 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Administrative Judge Gary J. Edles James K. Asselstine, Commissioner Chairman, Atomic ifety and U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Licensing Appt Board Washington, D.C. 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regt atory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Frederick Bernthal, Commissioner U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Administrative Judge Washington, D.C. 20555 John H. Buck Atomic Safety and Licensing Lando W. Zeck, Jr., Commissioner Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 I

l Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Ivan W. Smith Christine N. Kohl Chairman, Atomic Safety and Atomic Safety and Licensing Licensing Board Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission .

Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Administrative Judge Docketirp and Service Section (3)

Sheldon J. Wolfe Office of the Secretary Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission \

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 .

Washington, D.C. 20555 -

.4 L a

' SERVICE LIST PAGE 2 I

l l Atomic Safety and. Licensing Mr. Henry D. Hukill Board Panel ,

Vice President U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission GPU Nuclear Corporation Washington, D.C. 20555 P. O. Box 480 Middletown, PA. 17057 Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Panel Mr. and Mrs. Norman Aamodt U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission R. D. 5 Washington, D.C. 20555 Coatesville, PA. 19320 Jack R. Goldberg, Esquire Mrs. Louise Bradford Office of Executive Legal Director .TMI ALERT U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1011 Green Street Washington, D.C. 20555 Harrisburg, PA. 17102 Thomas Y. Au, Esquire Joanne Doroshow, Esquire

_ Office of Chief Counsel The Christic Institute

-Department of Environmental 1324 North Capitol Street Resources Washington, D.C. 20002 505 Executive House P. O. Box 2357- Lynne Bernabei, Esquire Harrisburg, PA. 17120 Government Accountability Project Michael F. McBride, Esquire 1555 Connecticut Avenue LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae Washington, D.C. 20036 1333 New Hampshire Avenue, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036 Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire Harmon, Weiss & Jordan Michael W. Maupin, Esquire 2001 S Street, N.W., #430 Hunton & Williams Washington, D.C. 20009 707 East Main Street P. O. Box 1535 William T. Russell Richmond, VA 23212 Deputy Director, Division of Human Factors Safety Office of NRR Mail Stop AR 5200 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

.