ML20104B601

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Evaluation of Eroded Service Water Joints on 1 1/2 Cu-Ni Piping for Structural Integrity
ML20104B601
Person / Time
Site: Millstone Dominion icon.png
Issue date: 11/18/1988
From:
NORTHEAST UTILITIES SERVICE CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML20104B598 List:
References
85-127-1013-GP, 85-127-1013-GP-R, 85-127-1013-GP-R00, NUDOCS 9209150418
Download: ML20104B601 (32)


Text

._ _ _ . _ . . . . _ _ -. _ . . ._ _ ._ - . _ - -_

(

e OP)#?6 . 0-99 p l HORTHEAST' UTILITIES SERYlCE COMPANY f NUCLEAR ENGlHEERING AND OPERATIONS GROUP P M i

GENERATION MECHANICA1. ENGlHEERING .

l i

ASME SECTION lli CLASS 2 AND 3 I

AND ANSI 831.1,0 PIPING' ANALYSIS i

i i

l PROJECT ASSIGNMENT: EI'/27 i

CALCULATION NUMBER: b ' 7" M/3 i

PLANT: M /ZL STO M UN/7 .3 1

TITL E: EVALUATiod OF ERODGD .SERy'lCE.

l WATER 301dff ON lYl Co-Al i f)PldG FOP, .STAVCfvML MTE(rA ITy QA CATEGORY I REVISION O n , ,

A .' -/5-77 5 b -l8-8b REYlEW ME THOD . AP ' VED sBY D M a g' d /O GAT FOLL PEJICV) PGA NE to 5.0fo fM /N/ 'w) fQ&J/ /A.bA_ /

REVISION 1 '

PREPARED BY DATE REVIEWED BY DATE j RtVIEw METHOD APPROVED BY DATE

{ REVISION 2 PREPARED BY DATE REVIEWED BY DATE REYlEw METHOD APPROVED BY DATE 9209150418 920910 PDR ADOCK 05000423 p PDR

.__ ___,_.,___m . _ . - . - . , _ - ~ , . . . - . _ . . ~ . ___.

NORTHEAST UTILITIES SERVICR COMPANY suestes Et/ALUATjod DF GRODEb SEAUKL as JVD. ca,e 10-2y 82 WATER SDWT5 od llz Cv-di P///d6 cm er ~Bt C. earg l)- 13 -gg MP3 este no. [{C-)2 y Jo)3 sp ,,,, o swert wo. 2 or . ZZ TA BLE. OF CD& TEA T.S P&.

rint. PA&E I 7tnLE CP CONTE 471 2 OS36CTlVL 3-4 PsEFEPldCLS 5 ANALy'S)5 - LO CA TION, LOADS b

L OADING.S , COMal$A tl0AS,4 LLOWA 6 LE S 7 PJPidG PROPERTJES , WALL LO 55,MODEL 8-ll

.S1RESSES - SENDMG J2-R A>(IAL 15 SHEM M -I8 fPL550PL boddbARy, S LIcXLJN&,FMCTVPl. I'l-2O SUNARy 2l CatJCL V.S)CA.S 2l-22 ATTACHMESTS AI

1. LOAb TABULAT10d A2-A3
2. LISTOF GA0alb .30ldf.S A 'l
3. GAD 5tod jdFo A 5-A9 ED4297 5 80 ( C IFIED) IBM PC Reproduction (CME /SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

l -NORTHElST UTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY euenct EVAL VA1/Od - OF FA O DE er' E D. Oste //-/ SET 5FJVICE L/A76A - Toldf_5 - OM 172 curn. er- RC oatt Il-I8 86

. U b

  • N i fIf ! d 6- cAtc. no. 75-12 7-1013 GP .nEv. O j /*1 f 3 - sMcEt no.- .3 or - 2 Z.-' ,

a 3

5- '

f OSTCCT)LE i

l 'To BVALVATE. TFL. STRUCWAAL -/412&RITy of A MovP CF MODLb .

l SERVlCE WA7ER f) PING -TOINTS. THE FOLlould& 1.5 A LUT/d6 0F l 7)fE So/Mij 70 0E. Ot/AltfJEb /d 1NU C4LC VLA1/OAl.

~TAbLG. l 4

l SSo WE t.b LINE Calc DMA NCR l ' S SWP-L60- X -3 III]9'NPlf)- PT l CP3 I9 000I FW 11 X OGH 621-XD 24] 3-88-106 i

CP 3\ 903\ FW % -0 64 3So 3-88-170 l' FQ 9 O G 'i 260 '3-28-169 FW /3 069 330 3-F8-169 ' ,

i Cf 317033 FW /-l 071- 6Z7-XD /22o 88-/05 cf 3190lo FW 6- 07/L 780 3-f8-167 l . CP 3 lc10 \ \ FW2- l 06l- - 622 -XD/5 3-88-108-

                                                                      #                                                                     1I02                3-88-16 5 FWH                    OG \ -
CP311030 FW2 OGI l122 3-27-103 FWH .ocI ll20 3-82-108; f

71

~
               ,             CP3l9008                         FWS2 -                0 72 ^-                        6T7-Xh                -204                   3-88-104 l

i !, C P 3 l'l132 FWlj 10 3 923 -Xb /40 3-88-13'1

FW2. /03 15.5' 3-88-13 8
                      # /Noll.4 TLS cut (FAT TWhlSli->Jht. UoSjod h

ED4297 5 80 (McDIFIED)1 IBM Pc Reproduction (GME/SAE 8 88,. FILE: ED4297 M)

NORTHEAST UTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY sueJEcs EVALVAftos/ OF F.Roaro hc9tige ,, Jt /D ,,,e /o.j p.gy WATEA 3Old13 OA) lY2 ~ { v Mi flf/df cuo, as TAL. oriE ) ,- 18 -86 MI*3 cate, un. 7.c./2-). lO)3 Sp ,7y, c) swtEt No. N of 22 OLTCCTIVE Codf 'o ALL f//Jdf /.S GA CAT 5 !?f 1 LOCATG /M TNL AUX /LMAy AMD f.1.F SVILD/dGS. TN)J PJf)d$ SfALlLLS i TNE .CPAR(r/d6 fV,mA (CCL) AMd SNCTy

     /N36L fnM (&cZ) &oot LU, 9/J f L/AlvATIOM VILL CONSIOLR WL PMStdf CodolfloAl Of 7?/L f/f/dG AMb /WL)/ s+yM6Ip3 70 Attou FCA fuA TMLR EXfLCTLb 0EGAhO/TJoM 70 y'lf LD A SLT ce soVdo>HS co80irioMS fo8 HoLL. si2L Ap'o Ptr*C wetL.

TMi&l(WESS, '17/E.SL \lALvES wl;.L BE USEb AS ALLowAOLLS, AMO If NOT

       &)(CLLDED WiLL 6L co$s1&)~ LO /CClPTA6LE (OB ALL F-foDEa APLAS /MA 'W QJAllfILA TICAI fADV/DED HEAL-It).

ALL 110RlisWy fifL LOAOIMf.S lb& EACH f0)MTLl3743 /N TAall. I d)LL BC GMVELOfLA TD OLTCYldt (MX/MVin f0ACLS AMO 80M^lTS IM EACH /N0/VloVAL DiflCTIOd. 7/CSL LOADS WILL CL com&/dla AMD EVALVATED MA T}ll. ASn6

                                           /

cobs (AEF.1) AND THE O&lG/AAL DLS/6d CAIT[AlA (MF.Z) fDA fMLLSTudl VM I1 2 . fIPldF LOADS i+fL ExTPAc'Tha FBGn 7}/L SW43 AMALy'S/3 CALC vLA7/odS OF AEc09A (AEF.3) f80fEATIE. of THE P///d6 /d TNG E80D6b CcWol7/04 WILL SC CALCULATTA L)SidG EQVATio/JS FAOn ACARK (BEF.4) TH).S CALCVLAT)od SUPPDAT.5 PLAdT PEGUES'f.S TO DkoM17/A7L 'T797 'ThL S2AVIcl VA%& L/ DES A*L CMABLL 0F PLRfOAM/d6 fil!JA jd764ED FVSL7lON By ttAlafAld/M6 .siducTV9AL INTC&RITf IN TIC fAOMa COMA lT/od. TM.S fl%f LS DOCVP1E/1Eb J \/lA A lcR 3 FRot') MP.3 fd6/dLEAldG AS L157td JW TA3LE f. l THC PRO &h8tL CAtiLL OF THE PIf/NG EAosto,d /.5 fv&SuLEdcE. Of TIE. 1 WOANIN(r FLUlb A'T FLOW' fATH l'HAdfL3 (ELBOW 3,7ELS) cAVSEB 47 l EK(.L CsivL Ft.OW WLocI1/ES. l ED4297 5 80 (KDIFIED) IBM Pc Reprodxt'on (GME/SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

l NORTHEAST UTILITIES SERVICE COMPANI eunacs. EVALUA7/od of (200cb SEADcE er A V.D oAsE /0 -/Mt WATfA avidfS CAI /Pz' Cv i@ p>pid6 .Cua. er Ot.C onsE \ \- \ '6 66 Yb . CALC. no. E -/E l=lO/3 & ~ngy, O

                                                                                             $HEEs no.             I                         _ or         ' 2 2.-

RE FEA&dLS __ la Ast,c sLcrion'1tl 1971 ED. rnRov&H SvivW 1973 A0DENDA . L.

21. l974 lb. TASIL UHF 23.2
2. /VSTP1 % 'flPE STRLS.S AdALYSIS CR17EAIA Docvmta1-tvlLSTONE
                         /

JLICLEAA PowEA STArioM - VMI13 ** PEV. 2 id&Luo1,r/G CHANGL NoTICLS.

3. .S t k/ .STRES$ CA L C ULA 7/@s - ALL /MCwb/N5 CPMGE N0f/CLS A l2/79 -MP(f) $2)-XD REV, 4
6. - (azz-X6 3 C. - 62 7-XD 2 B. - 62 7 -Xa i E. ~723-Xb. 2
                    .4. "FcRmtiLAs fo& stivs.s /No STRAIN ~ S" 20. - ROMK 4 yoval&

5 A/SC HAND 600M 8 " Gb, 4

                                                                                                                                                                                                'I l

ED4297 5 80 (MODIFIED) . IBM PC Reproduction -(GME/SAE 8+88, FILE: ED4297 M) I.

  , , _ . .                                         , . , _ . . .           -,,, cc,_m..mmr,m,...,b...-,.<,_,,m_                ,.m.,.m.m.--            v.,,-..,.,,.rm..,-,,.   ~y_~     r.~ --

! NORTHEAST PTILITIES SERVICE. COMPANY O suanct _ EVALUAT/0Al QC fA00Eb 'SCRVicL . er NO wrE JO-2D-78 >

                                                                                                                                             +

WATEA 301d73 - OJ l8 Co-ML PIPid6 cm. er TA L nrE I1-l8 BB - MP3 cuc. no. 2tS-/Z7-10/3 GP nEv; o SHEET Wo. b 0F 2E

. +
                 =

1 AMALVSIS t

                                                                                                                                             ?

1 LOCAT10d 0F EVAtukfloal THE MERS GXPLRIEdCING EROS /Os/ APE IDEt)Tiftsb by Isot*41RIc. *, F)fLb WELD (FW),L IHL ) 57RLSS CALCULAT/oAl AMb S7thSS DATA Poidf LocATlod 0tJ 1DL PjtE.17 PES 3 vogKSNETCit.1'HIS /dfWrA7/od ).5 Sup%ARJ2Eb /d TABLE- ). ALSO SEE ATTACRNAT 2.

                 . LOADS LOABS APL fXTMC7EO FAon 1HE dup 2PL Sv/ Rud4' rec 0Ao FAQ 1716
                   .LA7EST PEVISIOd Of TEL - S7Pf SS CALCVLATIOMS (fff,3)I
                       . FCA ConPv1tA P,VA NUmetAS ,DA7ES, AMD A X460LAT)0d OF Alt. APPLIgbott.

FDRCES Nf10/1 CATS l.SLE ATTACMEAlf /. T}/L FOLlod/$d- TAot.E. SuntWI241 7)lE /MX)t)vm SWLLOPla VALULS

                     /d EACP DIPLCT/04 Faun ATIACHradf ):

PRIP1MyLOADS local CoofJ)lNA76S T)/6 E I FORCES (LLS) . hCp1EdfS (PT-LSS).

LOAD CASE fx Fy /*g h hy. F1r DUOLOAb 25 # 58 2(a i3 8* JO^

OSE INEATIA 22 fo8 32 3'1 ~ 23 ^HO: L{ 3 Cl g ^l y OSE. AncHOPc

sSE //ER7lA 28 # GO I2 T 33' 31 M \

AsE ARCHOA 3 2 6  % Z 2 NO Tlir1E. HIST @y EVEMS kFfLCT. 7PIS POP 3/04 0F 1NE SWP SYSTEn:

                 # THf6L FORCES +M0MedfS 1/kfAl fran AH FRobED 3 WIT 1NAT ktAS / EPA 1Mb ED4297 5 80 (MColFIED)   IBM PC Reprodaction ~ (GME/SAE 8 88, F1        ED4297 M)

I

_ . . _ . . _ _ _ . . _ -. _. . _ _ _ . . . _ , _ .. ._ .. ~ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ . NORTHEA8T M ILITIES.'8ERVICE COMPANY i-1 sueac, EVAltJA7)os/ DP EBObtb EAncE er A VD - on,E 'lo-zo .gr I. WA7fA 501473 - ON IPE cv Ni P)P)MS cua. as OLC onrE \ \- lB-8o AP3 ' cuc. no. 8's-J27-IoI3 GP nEv. O i swEn no. ~7 - of . . 22 ) i AWAL YSIS cod 1 'b i l TO .SHOW S180cfuAAL. /MfLGAITf of 71/E PIP /d6 /S MNd7A/WLb ' /d T?/E EAOD&D CCHO)1/od,'fML PIPJH& Witt BE OVAuf12o POR . i I- ). MEcAAdl&AL LOAuld&.S Y 1. 6&dD)d& M0/1ENT.S l 2. AX/AL 76&Slos/lcorfALs.s>ON' i 3 SHLAR LOAb S Ada foRstod l1 fhESL LOAbidGS WlLL- BG QUAL /f/ED VSId6 THE FOLLOWidG j LDAD C0t1&WA'flodS (RLF,2) i i i A. NORMAL ftV.SSURE + bEhbLOAb i-l 8, UPSET PPgssvRE +DEADLOAD + OBLE > OB&A s ( l C. FAULTED PRE.SSVRE +bEADLOAb + SSSI +.SSEA ? i AL LOWA8 LES i a l' PIPE f1AT68ML. SB %6 CBA '706 ^ Sa ' E700 fsi (REF.3) (AEF.3) ,59, g 7on ps,; .}

                                                                                                                     .Sy = 13000 pcj             AEF lE.
                                   .L AOR/ML              /0Se = ??oo pi                                             Su : 3%o00fs1 A

ll .y.. UPSET I.2 s o Jo y40 psi

                                  .m.FAucEo               2.4s u = 20280 psi 1

ED4297. 5 80 (MODIFIED)- 1BM PC Reptoduction .(GME/$AE 8-88, FitEt ED4297 M)

                                                                                -_.__.._.~....___._.._._,.._.__.,2-_.u..,-..;

NORTHEAST' UTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY sunacs BVAll/AT/od DF ER00&b SERVICE- as A ll.D. Om /O-21-Et WAl'EA ' Told 73 OM IW Co -Ni f/P/dcr cuo. as DLC Dnst \ \- \S *BS MP3 crtc. wo. W-/27- 10/3 6P nEv. O sxEEs wo. 8 oF - 22. , An/AL YS/S CONT'o

   . /1DD) PIED P)Pld6 PeoPLRT)ES ThL fifidG PR0fLRTILS OF 1NE EAODEa f)PE /WA.C AFL CAtcuLdrio BELOW Tb ALL0vJ jnAR6/d3 FOf f*VTVAl fAO.SIOA/, fbkt. QUAL /ff THE. SY37M UNTIL. SUCH T//1E ThAT 11tESE Lim rr.s Am ExcLEAEb OA 1NE Ple/d6 IS fEff\ANENTL,V FCPAlfLb.

VLTfhodlc sw (vlT.) ANb Eaby cutFENT (Ecr) 1&S7ld6 M7A /1 AVAluntL FOR T& *EAOOLD 3/d75 THAT A&E 407 FA09ts.Vb TO 7?M0 t/fB - WALL LEAKS (197TACHNAIT 3) N& JOINTS CUMENTLf LEAKIM, No 'TEsf DA7A ).S AVAILABLL AAD OMCE DATA 15 7A)<td ThL ACCEPT /9BJL)y CP 17/L TOl&T V/LL CL DETEmisco, WALL LOS3 flMPE AFE TWO AREAS of coacter) wi18 w. EAobrA PIPE.

                                               }. SIEE OF THR0LISH-WALL                 HOLE Z. WALL fMICKNE.SS LOS.5 Adol /Nb f6KIME1"ER OF HOLE A AI ENVLLOPED cop /b 1'TjoM foA AL L Vz ' f)ff Jo/ HTS , 'f/Us
       '70 Gt/Allff GVALUApod Wst t A774/1T 70 SHOL./ TNE FOLLOV//f L/r!/1.S NL ACCEPTMlE.

A ALLOVASLE HOLE DIAMETER = L ALLOWASLE WALL THICKMSS = .l0 A f Any polpf ovwoc soit ED4297 5 80 (M@lFIED) IBM Pc Reprodxtion (GME/SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

       ,                                           NORTHEAST UTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY stostes MALVA 7)od Of-ERobEO SERQlcE                                                                  er Jt/.O                                   Dnt 10-21-88 WATEA TOIAf1S Od lY$ Cv'Ai                        l f/P/A6                                    ' can, as       'DLC-                        Due l \- \ 8 ' S 0' MP3                                                                       exte. no. KC-127-10/3 69                              nev.         o      .

surtt no. 'I oF 22 i4 4LfS/3 Coff'o MODif/ED FOPld6 PAOffAf/LS cos/T'o CAL CVLAT/d6 'T//E. ff 0PERTIES Ot* 17K REn4/d/d6 SEc7AW USING DE FOKMULAJ FRom ROAAK (ItEF. Ll) FOR A SEL72V -OP McLLOW C1AC LE. (4QUA 7/oM I *1, NG. 6 ?) G)V4.s ' AOmEd'T OF jdEA'TJA

                  .Z, = R t ()                         r        -
                                                                            ,          MrsidMco.sM                             ESf #                      t
                            ^<-

3R*M(2-Vp) 9.gfoA.x,))1 u VlhERE M = }MLF /tdGLE OF AEnAld/gG SEc7)od (AAbtAsis} X = h/ALL 1k}Ch'Nf.S3 Of REM $/d/AG SEC.1/04 6

  • OU'fSIDE RAD)t/S 1
                   -C - CEfffRDib                -To OVTER FIBLR DimEHsjok' C Y GREA%                        of Yi, en nf                                   wi>Eps 2.rax                                                  I               bl. STANCE sEL.oJ k*                     '

3M I~ f$# 2 2/ CENf80)O (RER H)

                 ~
                                   . $ IWW                                                                    _2 sta x ~3M ca.s[ DL57A41 M Y,E L._3"(2-%) + (/ y _/'\fj8                                                 3g                            C&TRolD (REF 4) u1rn ~>R 4 t A.s ossisso Aeove ED4297 5 80 (MColFIED)                !BM PC Reprodact1on (GME/SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)
         , - . -         --             , _ . -          ..      _ _ . . . - ~ . . . - . - , - , , , - - . -                         . - - - - , - .        . - - , . . . _ _ .          , , , , -

NORTHEAST DTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY suencs _EVALVAT)Od CF GAOMb SERviu- er Ap'D on,e _jo-21-N WATf]t 30kl1S DVJ J W C u-A!i f/PIs/G cm er CAL _ onse i1-\S-6S MP3 cuc. no. 8C-/2 7 -lo/3 GP nev, O swers no. 10 or 22 AdALYS/S CON 1'h A10 DEL n Yis

                                                                    &               n                         M      v a

Yg , PEMAltJW6 566 IlOd PlfL X-56CTiod WALL LOSS \Yz f5 P)fL O , 0, = }. 9 CIACVnfLMACC 1Td = S #l7 ~ HOL&. 5122 - Y4 /M -P LAt)E.

                                                                                                                 ='  'll,' flPL SV/ffA:E PIPL.1.05.5 =                                    . 7G,/               = 12. 73 *]o 6.97 12.7.1                           '?. of 3 60' c)R c t.E. = 4 fo
  • I4ALF At%LE *< =

2 = } $ ') * = 2.74 RAblAtl5 flPL PROPEP3]E5 -INPJT FOR ROARK c< = 2.74 MotAalS Jt = .10

  • MOD) PIED -A.LsunE UNIFo@ VALt. L OSJ O VfA R& h A M 4 X-SE C.710d
                                                                       ~

R= NZ = 76 . ED4297 5 80 (MODIFIED) IBM PC Reproduction (GME/SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

NORTHEAST t!TILITIES SERVICE COMT)?.NY susacs EVALt)AT)os/ OP FAODfb SEN)cf, nr lVb ons /O-2+77 WATEA 30Wr3 ON llz Cv-All f)Pld & coa . er Dt.C ons l l- l S-80 MP3 cate. no. 85-/27-1013 GP niv. O su rt wo. Il or - 22 AAALVTIS Cod 7'O D&1 WINE p10MEdf of JdEAT/A 1, = . /G (, in " Fat SE C*TOA 0F A h0LLCJ CJACLE D E TFA n/dC C DIMEdS100

                   % = . 621 is.
                  '//f = . 9 )I /d.
                              . ' . C = . WI /d.         Dl.S14NCE FRon OUTER FIMA To CENTAolb OF HOLLOW Cl&CULAR SECTM DETEP,n/ME LOADS TO CALCULATE BEdOWG FOMESTS 10 ILE APPLIEb 79 7K $0alF/ED P1PL c.AoSS SEc.7/od

().51d(r Eat /ATIGd5 A,B 4 C Ft1on P6. 7 AHb LOADS Ftton PG. 6 TASLL 2 ConSIdING AS : t'1a = (fir l + nyl rn, VMfE Q = ro7AL P1cmEJT PM LOAo cone >)dAT)od, ADDEb ASSOLUTELy, ny 4 fig 5jplLAA ED4297 5 80 (wrlFIED) ism Pc ReprocOction (GME/$A8 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

NORTHEAST tTTILITIE8 SERVICE COMPANY suenci EVALUA1/od DF EA0bEh -Y;ERVich. ~ as JVL) ansg jo.24.n VATEA 50M13 Od )W Cv-Ali f/PldG- .c m , as hi _ anse l1.lS 86 MP3 cxtc. no. 842 7-10/3 H) nts.._ _O - SWEET no, /2 oF- 22 ANAL YS/S CoalT'D BENDlt)& AOMEdfS ha, = { l3'+ 8 f /O"h = D FT LB, i) NORiML Meg = 228 ip-t o . Y

      ))) UP. SET           na u - (S H *+ 32 '+M                                                  =
                                                                                                      ' 8*)3 z.

FT-l.& l

                             /% = 9% /4-to JLL) t=AUL1Lb          ng,.=h8*&Hl'+&$'                                                      =

92 Fr-a Ae,, = // OMin-i B

  /. CALCULATE S1AESS
                                                                                    ^^'

f=OR BENDId6 Q='1 fD* - FOR - PRLssvRE Ctp f = Joo psi (AEF. 3) LodG1ruotpAL

                                                                              '9 4                                                        .
                                                                                                                                              .l fDA kl =.10 '
                                                     . % _-h. 7fpsi PGA setJ DldG 51tEsst.s (AVEM6C. ACROss X-SECT)oN)
                 ]=2,1 FDA -SocMET FJ Y'nd6S - ELBotJS 41EES ED4297 5 80.(MODIFIED)  IBM PC Reproductlen (GME/SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

j NORTHEAST TTILITIES SEF.VICE COMPANY i

                                                                                                                    . es ll/h
                                                                                                                             ~

i suencs EVALVATION OF BROD&b ERVICE onsE /0-2ti-87 i a WATEA 50h/fS ON $l CV-Ni ?/P/AS ~ ca. as 'DLC onsE \ \ W BP3 cuc. no. 85-127- 1011GP nEv. O-i snErs'mo. /3 oF . 2 2. .I '

AMAL'/S/S COAT'O
BEHbidG 1PLS.S (AVERAGE)

A $0RnAL q, = 'Y ' K ey= I97l PSL =- Iblo - B. 06S6 7 6s', = 'WlI NAIO cq , , ggag ,,; C. FAULTEb G,, = ' '0(lNN$0 - Q = 951/3 p.si

                                                                                                            ./6G OVALJFY 1D A.SME E QUA*f/0M.s NO W L          69.8                475+ 197I
  • 24% ,esi < 2700psL .'. O.K.
                               - U P.5ET         EQ.9y                L175 + 8609 = 90M psi 4)O440 psi                                                                                              , ' . D,}<.

FAULTEb EQ. 9, 47$+95% s 100/8 psi '4 20870 psi ,' O.}(. l ED4297 5 80 ( G IFIED) IBM PC Reproduction (CME /SAE 8 38, FILE: ED4297 M)

    . . _ . - . . ,                         ,,             ,~ m         . _ _        ,        _   . . . - . , . . - _ . . . _ _ _ . _ . . . . _ _ . . _ , . _ . . _ _ _ . , , . . . . . . - , _ .                          _ _ _

NORTHEAST' UTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY suenes EVAltlA1/od bP ERODED .sEAvicL er R.D. onst /o-2 4-88 WATEA 50/4T5 OAl- /4* Co-di f///dG cuo. er DLC- oAte 11- 4 BB Af3 cAtc. no. 25-/27- 10/3 GP :nev. O suert wo. M or . '22 ANALYS/S codTW BENbid6 S1PESS (LOCAL) N I 70 GvALIFy THE f)PL VITH AN ASSUntD / HOLE 9 (PG.8) FDA LOCAL STRESS L6VELS AT 7?% 01.5 CONT /dviTf, A*PLf- 5/F FOR Ad VdPEIHFORcLD TEE 3,p ; y 3 J_. *f: WALL THicxdES3 = ./O %0DIFIEO A"' k Ri flPC i+1EAN RADivS = l'9 *l ,,9p" 2. i= 5.90

                                                                           - 5? ,,5 ~=                                    p. 13000 +32o00 QLIALIFy/dcr TO AN ALLOdABLE                               Of                 2.                                            2 ALLotJ. = 25,500 pn VIH\cH IS THE FLOW S7fLSS fMfLSHOLb VHlCH ALLodS LIMITEA PLASTIC DGFORMATrap (ST&A!N NA60fNING.         TNLS /.s AccEPTAaE LOCALLY /d 7})E AffA OF 7})E. E,K/.57/M-                                                             _

_ NOLE QUALIff kCSST CA.sc (FALILTEh) LOhb

20. 9, = 47sps; + M3 ,g, y p fnoW.916 ,
                         ,+

18197pn < zssoops; ,. ACCEPTABik '

  • SUFFictENT PWWIt3 Ex/17.510 NET 7FE ASnE So,9F ALLDJ.- OF 20280pi-ED4297.5 80 (MODIFIED) IBM PC Reprodxtlon (GME/SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M) l

i -l- NORTHEAST tITILITIES SERVICE COMPANY suanct EVAt.Ukflas! DF M4GLb SbRVIG av dll.O. ute 10,2Y-88 WA1EA 501475 od /Y Cu-M ////#6 can, av bLC ute 11-in.8A Bf3 ' crte. no. 85427-1013 GP Rev. - O-

                                                                                              *rri me.       18                         oF . 22 ANALyS' /S COM'O
2. AXIAL S1 MSS Q= f = Fx -0.Sw&- L.oAb conMWAT)0N Ftton PG. 7.

A = /*)ETAL AfEA OP f%%Ald/d6 X SEC7/od QIAuff WORST CASE ; Faul7tb f = SG ' A = k 0F..l*)'0.0 ,.10~ W4U f)fE A = . %3 M ' ,

                                                                             =

f 1 A Xsd = /c 6 )Vf fsi

                                                                   .H93
         . ' . AX/AL STRESS AccEf 7ASLE of /dSfEC7/o/V-I a

l ED4297 5 80 (MODIFIED) IBM PC Reproduction (CME /SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

NORTHEAST OTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY suostes Et/ALUATION DP EA0Dlio SEMICE as A LI.D out /0-2 4 88 WA7&A SCINTS ON VE Co-A' A P)f/N6- cua. er DLC- out im8 96 f)f3 cuc. no. 85-12 2- 1013 &P nty. O sntes n. l& a 2 2. ANALYS)S COWT'h _

   .3. SHEAR STAESS A. SHEAR FROM LATF_ML FOACES FM n MAK 5HEAA 1t+ECAf                   cQ = A FV A

WHEPE. Fy c (Fy'r F,' 'fV5 INS- LOAb Cor1BWATIOd F19on fG.7 A = METAL APEA = . 493 in' LOAb S7RESS NORtVfL Fv, =- (E8 *r26 ') * = G 4,/b 2 6 0 psi LIPSE T Fv, = (129 * + 67 *) * = 1%.h 593 ps' FAUL7th Fv, = (12o*+ 6o') * = 13-%lb 547 pu' S. SHEAR FRon ro8sJo_n FoA ToRsloN 7 = ry . A f(g (REF.9) WHut. J =/.O FOR ALIEMSE T i'AcAoss 11/c SLcT)0d A = N,+M 2 (Q)+K 3 (& + Kg (2f FOR LOCAL T (AT hoLL) T= htr local 70RSlofAL nonEW1' FRon PG.fo ,TA6LE 2 r = R A blt/S DF HOLE *//2= 4" D = 0.D OF P)PE = l.9 ' d = $.D. OF PIPE = l.7 " N, = 4.0 x2= -G.793 + I.)35Vo ./26 {#/a)z K3 My == 3 8.322

                                    -49.s76-7        42gto                    -7.2        42"Po +-6.494/[ ),
                                                                                    +st.6s(%

ED4297 5 80 (MODIFIED) IBM PC Reprocbetion (CME /SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

\

NORTEEAST TTTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY

                                                                                                    ?

sumatc1 EVALVAflos/ cf EAoDEb sEAWG er _ A VO ong ; J0 2 y-tr WATEA St>WTS C# ffCg.N2 hp/fG t c,. , ,,- Et ,y,- n. i g , e, s . MP3- ente. no. 75-127- 10/3 &P nev, o saast no. 17 or . 22 AA/ALYS/3 COAT b S TORS /04 CONT b EQllATICA LinTAflods /g=.8*156.*10 O.K

                                                                                                            =  .3c)C 6.40         O.K.
         -A n oWALLE.S MEPAGE. . SHEAR                                                            .45y         .4(13000) = .5200 psi               REF 5~

I,0 CAL SW .8S y = /3000 tsA Mt. I - C SHfAA FRon Hoop situs Q= FOA P" loo psi- <G=95*0 psi L AVEM6L S W (p),o) -LOAD STPLSS g ,o,j t)0RML 'T= hy={L3ensy/2)=/5GINLB 323 psi UPSET T* n n = (E4rr-a)(12) w 6%a i392 pi FMLT@ Tc hxp 7(Wir-tsfl2) = $76in La }}'13 pn TOTAL AVEM6L SHEAR 3A +3B +3c ' (secrio.as) . tnoasr cue. . (Ty3 : 87.3 + /342 + '/50 GQg 2.88$ psi 4 C200 psi .i A CdfTMif. ED4297 5 80 (Mcm!FIED) IBM PC ReprodJction -(GME/SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

NORTHEAST t!TILITIES SERVICE COMPANY-westcs EVAtt/A7/0Al DFEAODG .S W)G er AVN Dnst /O 2'l ?? WA7 Eft 30/M.S OA/ 18 ^ Cv -Ai l P)tH6- cua. er- 1* L Dare n-te es N3 cate, no. RS-127-/0i3 '6P nty.. . O

                                                                                                           . snets no.                              /8                           oF                                        .

ANAL lS)S Ca$1'b SH6% cod 7h

                    .2L. LodL max SHfAL LY1EM)WE               A~                         K,= 4.0lK2= -S 28 ,' Kg = 37/03JXn c-4 239 ToAstod;                                                                                    .S'TPLSS NORFAL Ti 15G w4                                                                       2300pi 0fSET             7'* 64[(ta-a                                                         9552p.ti
                                   )=4vL7th             *f = 5 7G is -un                                                  849] tsi l                               TOTAL LOCAL SHEAR                                       3A+3B                                       (stemm) kim7 cast i

Tv= u $1.3+95S2 SA0 MDP S7A'S CA DfEt) SEc'T109) p \ Gv~[= lOll][pt 4 }O1l00 tn . . AcCEPTA&d [

 ~

ED4297 5 80 (MODIFIED) ~ IBM PC ReprochJction.. (CME /SAE 8 88, FILE: E04297 M)'

                                                                                                                                                           ~
     >-y ,.  'gr         1  g9  y-  e,    yn.e       y9      ,,.-g,-    g wvfpg.y,q+     ry*gyr'<,7gir       y a sure yey -y wwy W  g imyt gyyy sy-  (p T t- gity w'wp rw$t    v  'gP   g , N         v#   #'yt     V'Mg"   'm' ('"v'tgt'g"-Cyyk F": g/

I MORTHEAST tJTILITIES:8ERVICE COMPANY. 1 l auencs EVALVATlod CF ERooEb.56WICL er R.O ' use /0-2'/Gr WA1FK 301473 04 - Jh* Lv-Mi f/Pld& ' cua. er btC urn '11. s a n s .

                                   -AP3            -

cuc. no. 25-127-10/3 GP nev. O- l [ sacri wo. M o, . 22 l 1 4 i PRES.svPL SodNohky [ AT PRESMT ,, THR00&H WALL HOLE.S &X)ST AT SEVEPAL 301413(,sEETAsikl) l TH&SE lblES Af& 0P' V$D6TEAMINLD $/26. T/NJ ' CALCOl.AT/od OVALIfM 7?M. , , fIPW6 FCA A R' HOLL :DIAN7tA. TD /gSvM THAT SUFF)C)&dT METAL AfM EX/.51.5 N 7M 20NE. SVR-ROVND)d6 1HE HOLL 70 fA0V)d6 /fblQUA76 - /4ESSWE PEldf0ACENAT, 1 N E f c LL o w / S'S /.S .S B o W M MiMFDRCEPEH1 AREA REQV1AEa An= 1.o'?(kn$dd .w. I . ,. PElrJFORCE/1ENT /%EA AVAIL 4Sil AfA = d z WA - Amu N. In WHEPE 4, = L D. CF 6 RANCH (HOLE) = /y' (60VNblNG) ,

                                        $nk= nld. WALL Of f)fL '* N*                                 +A 2(SE + Py)

P= DESIGN PASSSWE = 100 psi 0, /.'7*

                                                  .5 - 8700 pu y 1.H .

h = O 103CORRO.Stod ALLOWAt /CL E = /.D

                                                           ~
                                       & = .Oll -(M/M. WALL) ..
                                       .Tg = /VotilHAL PIPE THIOol&SS = .l0 (60VNblN6) 4, = f = /q              conPARIMG CobE CFOlCE.S ED4297 5 80 (MootFIED)       IBM Pc Reprochetton ' (GME/SAE 8+88, FILE: ED4297-M).

( .-;.._,- .m.- , _ _ ..,..._..a. . ,.,_;_.. ,-.;,. ..._._,_..___._._.,_._._,;.,.._....w.. -

NORTHEAST hTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY n> ester EVALVATJod OF EADA*D .3EAviQ- as )VQ, __ oars = JO-2 +8? WATEA 70WTS CA/ 17/ Cv-Ni ///W6-- cue. ar Dd care h la-se MP3 cuc. no. 75-12 7- /0/MP net. O suter no. 20 oF . 22 PfUS&E 60MDMy con 7 'b JA g = ).O'7(.DiI)(.75) = .009 pI* A, = . 7s [to .o11] = . oa 7m

  • S/N T AA"'OIO? M # .009Y* bA. . . AccEPTAsis -fesssues PEIdfoRc6 HEAT LOCAL McKLING WHEAL A
                                                                                                -4 31 -

tYf. C - S&c:1/. d JS FULLY EFFEC.7)VE Oo . p[ SEc. l.9,2.

                        .d.9=933x75,/3 000
f. ')

M && M*5

                   .'. AC1PM6LE MirnL FMcTUPE B&l*f7LE fMcTUPk I.S db7 A cadCEfd FOR NOA-FEMOV.S MWlU TJHicH /t9L Dt/CTlLE AND fdLLf 6KCCib CHMPf //WACT L/M)fj t

ED4297 5*80 (MODIFIED) IBM Pc Repr .* tion (GME/SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

NORTHEAST tJTILITIES ' SERVICE COMPANY . wasEcs Et/ALUAT/od OF EAobEb sERvjcs. ,, Jy.A ,,, jo .29.g.y WATER 50ND Op jh ' Cv -Ni P)P)AIG_. eno. ,,

                                      .                                                     DLL                 an, I ). , g. g g AP3                                              cnte no. 8C-/27. JO/3-6f                              nEy. O l                                                                       SWEET wo.           21             oF .        22.-

i l 5d/1 *1AR,V

                  /

l 'GtE- &RObfD ffP/d6 SGCf/odS TABVLATEb//t 'fA6LE I (P&.3) HAVE &EEN 6VALUA'rtb AMb oval)f/Eb FOR /lLL P&lnAAf LOADS 1MCy ArtL St83Ecl~10.

.           By tbEErid& Asr L. code. (PEF.I) ALLoJA&E.S FoA /h/EthK. X-SECf/oM i            SrebssES i 1M P)PE SEcriodS HME. SEED .SHOWd 70 nAldTA)W .57 Roc 7vML-
                                                                                                          /

INTE6R17y FDA 801H SUSTAldEb (bEADLOAb,PfESSVAL) At b OCCAS/OMAL

                                                                                                                 /

l (Eff7HQt/A}<E) LOAOS, LOCAL BVCKLtd&' of THE EA06F.D M&4 At b t'Pt SSvPE P&ldFOACEr&)1 PEQV)PEnE47.5 MVL ALSO &LJsnowd Acese7mte.. P/fid+ }' ntHIMdn VALL ff.G(/lfffb)T.3 FOR fMSSUPE 60VHDA6f /M7E&RJTy'AM QUAliflEb. SAITnf FfACTuth OF THE ofEd SLcT)od FAS LEEd S/bWd 907 y TO &E A CDt)cERS,1 OCAL S7fLSSES /d 7PE 20t/E DF 1kl GAOS10d /%/E SEld j QUAL)FIEb FOA. STRUCTUPAL /dTEGAlry AL30 t J i t I CodCLUSJON THE EA00Eb SGC7/MS OF JYz' Co-Ni Pif)dG JT nt3 /Ls LIS7th 14' 7A6ts l i (ts.8) wE eets auAurito re sl eottowists sodsoiac caso>rions. A nAXir30m HOLE. 5)2E = /q

                                                                                        ~
2. nidinun una ryicmEss = .to ArAny Poid7 ov7.sM6 TBE PRO 3E& RED Hotf. slaE. SPEC)f>&b /cl */ ABoVE
            $EsE co rso triod.s nasr BE nST FoA 7M. SEMllE. L/A7EA Sy.57Ch TD PEF 14/W L?UAllflGD TO SUPPOAT f.0$f/NVEb PLAtJT DPERAT)0$. ANY ERobE.b 30td7 NOT fYETidF 7pl Accol CAI7tPJA WJLL ALGU/AL fE-GVALVA T/Od i

ED4297 5 80 (MODIFIED) IBM *PC Reproduction (GME/SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M) i

                                                           , , - . _           -...,.          ._ _,_,           ......-.....m-.        . . - . - . . ~ , , . ,

.i NORTHEAST VTILITIE8 SERVICE COMPANY sueacs EVALLIAT/od 01: ERohEb Y6evlu. _ er . kD, one /0 2'/-88 WA1FA JoiMs 04 /Y fu-Ni ////d4 cue. av DM our 11-io-86 MP3 cuc. mo. 8542710/3-GP nev, .o sutti wo. 22- or . 22 CONCLOS10$ COMT 'b

        'TNE P)ffN& /d TN/.S CONDIT/od NAS 6;EEN .SHodN 70 (CET All b6.S/64 CAlfEAIA AND ASf1L CobE ALLouA6thS .SfGCWido /d 7NE CAIGIMAL. Mf 3 PLAMT DES /6d /L@)/ ret %VTs 1?lEPCFCfE., ThE /VCR 3 ~ AabPldSId6 'f>iE IN , f/Pld& EAO.S/od 0?l&L ))

t%Af 6E. DJJPOS/770MLo "t/SL ,4S-/3 .S0 Lod & A.S 80.5/04 CAAI && Mrwd-

      $1PATGb 10 /1LET 1NE. L//)17.S Sf6CIf/60 Del PG.

I l

  ' ED4297 5 80 (M00lFIED)                            IBM PC Reproduction (GME/SAE 8 88, FILE: ED4297 M)

4 NORTHEAST DTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY SUBJECT BY DATE CNd). BY DATE cAtc. wo. 95-/2 7-/0/3 GA nEv. O _ SKEET Wo. dl or ATTACliA1EN1.5 i I 1 i i l 1

  - !!D4297 5 80 (MC21FIED) IBM PC Reprocketion (CME /SAE 8 88, FitE ED4297 M)

{

                                                                                                                                                      , PG. AZ
i. ATTALHMEAW l E
 .                                                                                                                                                      t j                                                                                                                                                       k,-      -

m t c-. 4 . O O g- - -

                            ,,.                                                                                              Zig-3 x ,.g-                                                                                                     o o                   x                             os 4

7 c o g~

                                     =      g                       *****

J (x r-N M PN N - d ns s .  % s - et - @c s+ - l { \q e -e-oe~ ~ h s [' g h9 -

                                                                                                                                           -!=M E M be

( o o o oo-- o-o o O 'c. 0; oo ~@ j} p e o o - 0 0 0 o oo* O O O- o o 0- , og to 1 O OO O oo o ooo O O O Oo . O o o g_ b k hO aR ..r-- - h .:- r h h '- nr1sqNM oo \q s f hSq _ NhN o rTd' b - Nj)- - M N M-( a- o 3heo~ 7 r O' N h 0- ~- - nysg en O ') O NN O r-- d - - % g-- k' -M- -' Nn y e . , - ~_ e e e eO e o O u we e-

       '(               . .O         0      0      .:7-        OO               O         o    OO             N O              .o- u_ G. o                        N bo-
                            ..,                                                                                                       s.

e ku M d w dj

o. r f' o n y n g. 4 N

o h -

                                                                                                    'a_       r
                                                                                                                    ~
                                                                                                                    - N.        J[o)- el N-d
                                                                                                                                                    ~

o- ?4...Qg , , , A 9 0  :,-. q %- o C E u s- % ki % o g n u, oa os .y oa ui c$e a e ,3 Pg~ ef og o o -to l v N y.- 4 N N c- N > 1 M i kh , $) $b k $ *g $ l

P& h3 ^ ATTACHM%NT I g,. . ,_.. .

M.,
                                                                                                                                   ~
                                                                                                                                         . . ~.
                  ~l i                                                                                                               -

(m -: o- o -x 3 -\ -o m -> s 4 0 t wqa) g g s, c_ ghNk oR0" b n: - tthh =c j f ne e et*>  %;;bA S-  :: n k s h A* 1 x n ethw =r krN I@ +h u _c_ e au nw s

     @             o        o      o    ooo0                                                       o o o- o       o     0       00-0        o   a gm 3   p             o         o      nQ                                                             r4 0 o  o         -0         00eo            o       -n e

0NO D O O O g o. , q\ O - -

                                        - O 'to o -                                                        O                                             q ge r         w i,hrm                                                               rbtm           "      v w nr a esa r- rJo o e pn o y               g          c- na0a m                                                            Q hb "                ~
       @           M          rs    o7 : NM                                                        c- d %   3-    5E      -

er s n 6'h ,\a e t [ (4 - a q q g :r o O O_O OC ' ' O _O O O ':: ' - -

      @-            2-          --
                                      -mEE%                                                        Es     oo      g       c~    ge qg ,g e            g re =ms-
                                                                                                    ~r      g      ~      _

m 34 ,, D N k d q P- 'O O- NkQ rd - g h&I

  • s M b% E84n $33g n3 der g h e y o
                       !~                                                                           E a

5-s 3- 3 e 6 e e a o a ~ a

                                                                                                                                                         ~

o

    - ~ -
                                               ----_-_a_-_.wa--.----_u- - - - . -- - - , - - - _ -

L-f&A4

                                      'M1AcVEM 2.

rev.10/13/88 Service Water Piping with .i

             ,                     known Degredation                                                                g          -

Line No.'; FW No. ISO Drawing Location NCR Comments

              !                          .No.                                                               tbLL _ PT, 3-SWP-150-103-03       FWjir';    CP319732        CCE-A,1N                      3-88-139YO 77' .IN ~

3-SWP-150-10/-03 FW .M CP3197 ff CCE-A, . 3-88-138 92 ) I I. 3-SWP-150-103 FW4- CP319715 CCE-A,IN 3-88-109 6t/AtturCo fPEVloWSty 3-SWP-150-103-03 FW3-1 CP319715 CCE-A,IN 3-88 109 f W L8/ M O f C M L [ 3-SWP-150-061-03 FW2 CP319030' CCI-B,IN 3-88-108 c. 2 2 P T. I n 3-SWP-150-061-03 FW4 CP319030 ' CCI-B;IN 3-88-108 (22 f7.IQp 3-SWP-150-061-03 FW2-1 CP319011 CC2-B,IN 3-88-100 Gzz f7.///f 3-SWP-150-061-03 FW4 CP319011' CCI-B,IN 3-88-107 f,2 t. /T.fIv2. 3-SWP-150-064-03 FW19 CP319009v CCI-B,0UT 3-88-106 42l PT. d 7 y 3-SWP-250-064-03 FW9 CP319031 ~CCI-B,OUT- 3-87-054 6,2 s PE &o F 3-SWP-150-064-03 FW13 CP319031 CCI-B,OUT 3-87-054 627 N 33 0 3-SWP-150-071-03 FW1-1 CP319033 e.r w CCI-A,IN 3-88-105 627 fT./2/o gyg og n u rca 3-SWP-150-071-03 FW6 CP319010 CCI-A,IN ' 3-87-054hr, er,7Po l 3-SWP-150-072-03 FW52 CP319008 CCI-A,0UT' 3-88-104 6J7. fr 20Y 3-SWP-150-064 03 FW4 CP319009 CCI-B,OUT 3-88-116 f t/ALV47fO PP6V10V3Ly . 3-SWP-150-072-03 FW6 CP319008 , CCI-A,0UT 3-88-113 cn i [ amp 3-51 ' 150-??2-03 ""i CP'!! "O 22 CCI-^J UT 3--00 111 '?.?? E ,fp d x ht\5I . 3-SWP-150-072-03 FW1 CP319032 CCI-A,0UT .3-88-111 ' G,77 M @Alff0 - 3-SWP-150-064-03 FW5,7 CP319009 -CCI-B,0UT 88-112 421 86. Palm g 3-SWP-150-064-03 LSO

                          -FW4       CP319031        CCI-B,buT3-87-054 Lti g lleaker 3-SWP-          -03                                HVK-B                         3-88-097                                                                    g
  '3-SWP-018-310-03                                                                 3 -38.=4+1"""                                                      problems CCS                           3-88-099                                                 clad problem clamp-
3-SWP-OO2-384-03. FW7- ra19767 HVD-1A ' - *
                                                                                               -131-                                          .221 wall-                              ;

3e 4-384-03 FW5 CP319767 HVO-1A. 3-88-131 .2. ' A _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ . _ ..________.m m _ _ . _ _ _ _.,___.___._..___.m_ . _

AYTMJWNT 3 NY

                                                                                                                                                             ~ g -.--

nownmuunr- ununas . .

                                                                                                                                                               =

_6 <y; O*E72~%~ _ _ _. b g_ July 15, 1988 PSE-CE-88-463 1 i TO: Mr. S. V. Dumas Berlin, V21 FROM: . eNerg Component Engineering j Berlin, V21 (Ext. 5364) SUBJF.CT: MILLSTONE LJNI? SiO. 3 I r SERVICE VATER PIPING TO CCE AND CCI HEAT EXCIIANGERS

REFERENCES:

1) Crisp #1303940 T. E. Davis to R. Y. Schonenberg, 07/15/88.

i 2) Crisp #1303393, R. C. Vittmer to R. Y. Schonenberg, ( i 10/13/87. l

3) Crisp #1302954, R. C. Vittmer t- R. Y. Schonenberg, 04/02/87.  !

4 Based tmon the trr data in Reference 1, all the joints listed in Table 1 need to be ,valut.ed for their structural acceptability. Vhere possible, the anticipated rate of vall loss is also listed. This rate is based upon an evaluation of the ECT data in References 2 and 3, and that currently being gathered. Comparative data was not available in all cases to calculate a rate of vall loss. If more UT data is needed, contact T. Davis. Where possible, it is requeS+-d that the joints be grouped into three catagories:

1) Seismically acceptable now and expected to remain that way until the next refueling outage in 1989.
2. Seismicallv eceptable now but expected to become unacceptable before the i next refue. outage in 1989.
3. Seismically acceptable nov.

Another list of joints vill be gene' a ~d as soon as the piping to and from the HVQ and HVR heat exchangers is exammed. It is requested that the analysis for the joints in Table 1 be completed by 09/15/88. RYS/beb Attachment CC: PSE T. . Mawsor B. V. Nichole (MP3) l 13.46 . o 570 REV 3 D ' BP0 t

., P6A6 A77A C H/TJ173 i 9

  /

Attachment to PSE-CE-88-463 TABLE 1 CCE and CCI Piping Joints with Vall Loss Line No. Veld ISO Draving Current Rate of Vall Number Number '.411 Loss 3-SVP-150-103-03 FV4-1 CP319715 .150 N/A 3-SVP-150-103-03 FV3-1 CP319715 .098 N/A 3-SVP-150-061-03 FV2 CP319030 .096 .0005"/ month 3-SVP-150-061-03 FV4 CP319030 .090 .0005"/ month 3-SVP-150-061-03 FV2-1 CP319011 .114 .0005"/ month >! 3-SVP-150-061-03 FV4 e/319011 .048 .008"/ month 3-SVP-150-064-03 FV19 CP319009 .090 .002"/ month 3-SVP-150-064-03 FV9 CP319031 .060 .003"/ month 3-SVP-150-064-03 FV13 CP319031 .034 .002"/ month 3-SVP-150-071-03 FV1-1 CP319033 .130 .004"/ month 3-SVP-150-071-03 FU6 CP319010 .065 N/A 3-SVP-150-071-03 FV52 CP319008 .104 N/A ars/b.b 07/25/68 13.47

            /                                                                                                            Ptr. A3 NORTHEAST UTILITIES                                            -

A77ApfprAf 3

                                                                                                                       - g .__

a cw a m.~- q 9 .erim e ..sc cc .- g w- fMi L

                   '     J              .                                                                                      IRAJ j                          -
                       .                                                                                                                                 l To:              R. Y. Schonenberg                                            July 15, 1988 Generation Mechanical Engineering                           CrispH1303940 i
From
T. E. Davis T. y ,D E NUSCO NTE I i

Subjects Ultrasonic Thickness Measurement on MP3 Service Water per Memo # PSE-CE-OG-411 In response to your memo dated 6-23-88, an Ultrasonic Thickness measurement was performed on the 1 1/2" brazed joints that you selected. The results of the examinations are.005". shown on the attached data sheet with a tolerance of + or The clock locations of the readings are in the clockwise direction looking downstream ( direction of flow ). If there are any questions regarding these examination , i results please contact me at Millstone extension 4071 or contact C. M. Peterson in Rocky Hill at extension 4665. cc C.M. Peterson D.R. MacNei11 B.W. Nichols S.V. Dumas i R.C. Wittmer NDE File # 88-024 l T/0 FLEV. 343 i

  -,---y,                      y.                w.-  v  -  - - - - - - , -          , - - -                   y---       , - - - - .   --
        )hc ~

PV A8 A1784/MM 3 r . ATTACHMENT 4 UT ECT CLOCK WELD # BLD READING READING LOCATION FW4-1 AUX .150 70% 11 TO 1 FW3-1 A/X .090 25% 11 TO 1 FW7 *vX

                               .           .145                                  0%           360 DEG FWG      AUX          .145                                  0%           360 DEG FW3      AUX          .145                                  0%           360 DEG FW4      AUX           .145                                 0%           360 DEG FW3      AUX           .145                                  0%          360 DEG FW4      AUX           .145                                  O */.       360 DEG FW2      ESF                    096                          JMX          11 TO 12 FW4      ESF            .090                                 30%          12 TO 3 FW2-1    ESF             .114                                30%          12 TO 1 FW4      ESF             .040                                00%          12 TO 3 FW6      ESF              .147                               0%           360 DEG FW10      ESF             .137                               0%           360 DEG FW12     ESF              .140                              0%           360 DEf FW13     ESF               .147                             0%           360 DEG FW4      ESF               .140                              50i'.       360 DEG FW19     ESF               .090                            >25'/.        6 TO 7         )

FW9 ESF .060 00% 11 TO 1 FW13 ESF .034 60% 4 TO 5 FW1-1 ESF .130 00% 12 FW6 ESF .065 60% 10 TO 1 FW52 ESF .104 40% 3 TO 4 NOTE: ECT DATA IS WRITTEN IN % OF WALL LOSS

_fT7/*CNP&lW 3 gC) U Ae Numbet' Weld Number _ . . .3- SHP /SD '/o 't- 03 ,f*t=' ;'2 Clock l Distance f rom weld (inches) Posi tion * ' sse ?" s ) J //J/ I *

                          ,/Yf              , / YS"          , s Y t,     , s h' f E               , /d 7            , /3 5            , /3 '?       ,sy/
                          ,6 7J             , / */'>        , / 4'5*~    , / 4'd
                                          , t) 9          , / YoL      , i4'o
                          , c, / g,
                          ,/VO              ,/]f            , /J T         ,/Y3 0                 , / YS~         , /V&              /V7         ,/VJ
                            ,Jyf             , IVY           s/Sc          ,/y9 8                 , , yg           ,,yp            , ,y ,       ,/yf 9                ,sy4            ,/W5             , / Yl,       ,/VJ 10                               ,syS _ ,/SJ                   , s y es      l r / $'S' 11              , /S c'           , sv3              sSG        , jj p 12                               ./S/             ,/Yf l
a. - . -
                            ,ss--
                            ..'?
                                                                            , /3 t, Line Number                                            Hyl d             Number l

3- S te h

  • j fC - /0 3 - 0 3 t #4~J Y
                             ,15 /             s / S~/         ,/S/        ./S/
                          . /f /             ,/VS              , /5 /       , / T n2                                                       _
                            , /Sh            ,/VV             ,sVV         , / .%~ /                                                         _,
                             , / Y3          , /I ?           , /J S       , sY 7                                                      _ , _
                            , /) ~?           ,/00            , /0 /         ,/.7 &

g , 0 S *- .497

                             , / U .5          , // O         s/20          ,/SC       ,/VV                                                     _
                             ,/4/   /         ,/3/             s l*/>        s / Yl
              *               ./y?            , / V S"        . t y S~        ,/VC
              '               a /Y ?           . /S~.9          . / S/       ,/YY SO              , sf /           ,/V3           ./39          , /W II              , /V4.         ,197            ,/V7            ./YP 12             .t5/             ,/Y9            ,/y9         a / 4' S t

l . . . .

                                                                                                          - - . _ - - - . -                 _ . - ~ .    -.                 _

4 i l CALCULATION CHECKLIST

1. Preparation Section Preparer's Initial 1.1 Legible, reproducibic, comprehensive 6.1.1 YO

( 1.2 ID Logged in, retrievable 6.1.2 IYA l 1.3 Documentation format and contents l complete 6.1.3 MNA 1.4 As-built information added 6.1.4 (b.

2. Verification Section 1.R1 Initials 2.1 Documentation complete 6.2.1 .

2.2 Prepared in accordance with Section 6.1 6.2.2.1 , 2.3 Assumptions reasonable 6.2.2.2 . 2.4 Method acceptable 6.2.2.3 , 2.5 Input data correct 6.2.2.4 L , 2.6 Modeling adequate 6.2.2.5 . 2.7 Manual calculations correct 6.2.2.6 2.8 Computer calculations correct 6.2.2.7 NfA 2.9 Design requirements met 6.2.2.8 . I 2.10 Solution correct 6.2.2.9 . 2.11 Software validated 6.2.2.10 l 2.13 Review method identified 6.2.2.11 i

3. Comment Resolution l

Commentg Disposition I.R. Initials NA i Rev. 2

 --       -.                               - - . . ,             .. . . . . . . ~ . - _ - - - . - . -                                     -    - _ ,             _}}