ML20101F040

Forwards Executed Signature Pages of Affidavits of M Kaku, DA Schlissel & W Eddleman Which Constitute Exhibits 3-5 to Intervenor 841210 Application for Stay Pending Administrative & Judicial Review Filed in Proceeding

ML20101F040
Person / Time
Site:	Catawba
Issue date:	12/17/1984
From:	Guild R CAROLINA ENVIRONMENTAL STUDY GROUP, GUILD, R., PALMETTO ALLIANCE
To:	Moore T, Rosenthal A, Wilbur H NRC ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL PANEL (ASLAP)
References
CON-#484-805 OL, NUDOCS 8412270003
Download: ML20101F040 (4)

Text

C _ . . . _ . -

hy ,

ROBERT GUILD'

^"omtv at Law g.g g 2135 Devine Street " #C COLUMBIA. SOUTH CAROUNA 2920 5 w .m o ' P12 :43

~ "'

TELEPHONE m 254-8132 "

December 17, 1984 C~rc C3 R TA G CC:'W[_f a);E H "

. Alan S. Rosenthal Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-Thomas S. Moore Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Wr.shington.-DC 20555 Howard A. Wilbur Administrative Judge

. Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board US Nuclear Regulatory Commission WIshington, DC 20555 Rs: Duke Power Campany, et al, (Catawba Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2)

Docket Nos. .iO-413 and 50-414 g, L Daar Sirs:

Enclosed please find the executed signature pages of the affidavits of Dr. Michio Kaku, David A. Schlissel and Wells Eddleman, which are Exhibits 3.'4 and 5 to the December 10, 1984, Intervenors' Application for Stay Panding Administrative and Judicial Review filed in this proceeding. The Affidavits were originally filed unsigned because of the need for filing at the earliest possible time.

By copy of this letter I am transmitting these documents to the Court of Appeals and to all parties.

E erely, I

f.

Robert Cu Counsel for Palmetto Alliance and Carolina Environmental Study Group 4

0 jf3 PDR a D.

3 50

m

20. Consequently, I conclude that even the routine operation of the Catawba reactor at up to 5% power presents a significant safety hazard-to the surrounding environment and to plant workers and poses a risk of the irreversible contamination of the reactors.

4.

Michio Kaku SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me th:.3 / day of December, 1984.

'4d/M , _

Notary Public for New York My Commission Expires:

Pub ' . 6 t c c .v 'crk Ho. ? '-41Ysik&

@#J E. v2 *1 Ji LIW Cenuret.s.cr. Es;in; lis?:n 2J.1006 I

l

/ ( '.

It is clear that no harm will be realized by Duke customers from a-stay of operations during the pendency of this review proceeding.

Wells Edd%' man SUBSCRIBED AND AFFIRMED before me this - day of December, 1984. -

Alla 2T eld Notary Public for NoVdh' Carolina .

My Commission Expires:

ll I b* $

s l

L

o previously unanticipated locations through previously  :

unanticipated pathways. Thus, potential contaminants may, in fact, concentrate in areas tha.t the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board now believes unlikely. Furthermore, welds in the primary-loop of the Catawba plant are not the only reasonable location that one might look for IGSCC. There are also numerous small diameter piping systems, some of which connect to the primary loop piping, which, themselves, can be locations for the concentration of potential corrosive contaminants.

If an independent inspection of the welds in IGSCC susceptible piping lines at the Catawba Nuclear Station is to be conducted, it is prudent to complete that inspection prior to the initial criticality. Once the piping becomes radioactive, the inspection becomes more difficult, more time consuming, more expensive and constitutes more of a hazard to the individuals involved, n Y 0 NA David A. Schlissel

. Subscribed and Sworn to before me EEis /4s day of December, 1984. j vez \ # .

J'otar'y P6blic for Massachussets VMy Commission Expires:

MMRef gy