ML20099K354

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Complete & Unexpurgated Copies of Three Diary Entries Previously withheld,841119 Ltr Advising Aslab of Action & Motion for Stay Pending Appeal
ML20099K354
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 11/19/1984
From: Gallo J
ISHAM, LINCOLN & BEALE
To: Bloch P, Grossman H, Jordan W
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML20099K356 List:
References
CON-#484-336 OL-2, NUDOCS 8411290398
Download: ML20099K354 (6)
v • d • e


Text

_

33M L:

ISHAM, LINCOLN & BEALE COUNSELORS AT LAW DOCKETED e

it20 CONNECTICUT AVENUE. N W.

SulTE 84 WASHINGTON. D C 20036 CHICAGO OFFICE EDWARD S. ISHAu. t&72-t902 202 833 9730 THREE FIRST NATIONAL PLAZA ROBERT I ONCOLN. 1872 1889 ep,e

f. m, e 7 ; !b 9 yis CHICAGO. lLUNOIS 60002 n

WILLIAU G. BEALE. 1885 1923 v4 ds TELEPHONE 312 558 7500 TELEX 2-5268 j

\\

November 19, 1984 Peter B. Bloch, Chairman Herbert Grossman, Atomic Safety and Licensing Alternate Chairman Board Atomic Safety and Licensing U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Board Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Washington, D.C.

20555 Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Walter H. Jordan, Member Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Wasliington, D.C.

20555 Re:

In the Matter of Texas Utilities Electric Company, at al. (Comanche Peak Steam Electric Sta Eon, Units 1 and 2), Docket Nos. 50-445-2 and 50-446-2, Application for Operating Licenses Gentlemen:

On November 17, 1984, I prepared and served on the parties a motion addressed to the Appeal Board requesting a stay pending appeal of this Licensing Board's Order of November 16 requiring production of the materials as to which Mr. Lipinsky had asserted attorney-client privilege, namely Mr. Lipinsky's diary notes of November 30, December 1 and December 8, 1933, and Mr. Lipinsky's memorandum of January 9, 1984.

In preparing that motion, I re-examiaed those materials with regard to the scope of the privilege asserted.

I determined that my assertion of privilege on behalf of Mr.

~

Lipinsky as to the entire diary entries of November 30 and December 1 had been overbroad in that only portions of those entries concerned conversations between Mr. Lipinsky and Mr.

Reynolds.

With respect to the memorandum, it was directed to O.B. Cannon's quality assurance files with copies to Messrs.

8411290398 841119 PDR ADOCK 05000445 0

PDR SSO3

L Letter to Licensing Board Novcmber 19, 1984 Page 2

-Roth, Trallo and Norris.

Because I had determined that the representation by Messrs. Reynolds and WatKins did not extend to.O. B. Cannon, an assumption:I had made on October 18, 1984, I concluded that-the attorney-client privilege, although valid.in the first instance, was waived when the memorandum was distributed within the company.

I provided the Appeal Board and the parties with the January 9 memorandum-and-with revised expurgated copies of the diary entries as an attachment to'my motion.

On November 18, 1984, I met with M'r. Lipinsky and we discussed the Licensing Board's Order denying -

attorney-client privilege as to the remaining materials.

Although we still believe that the privilege validly

. attaches to these materials, Mr. Lipinsky has decided to l

waive its further assertion.

Accordingly, in compliance with his decision with the Order of November 16, I am.

i attaching, with one exception, complete and unexpurgated l

copies of the three diary entries previously withheld, as well as the January 9 memorandum.

A letter to the Appeal Board advising them of this action is attached as well as the Motion For A Stay Pending Appeal.

The exception stated above refers to a four-line note recording a health condition of Mr. Lipinsky.

Mr.

Lipinsky views disclosure of this matter as an invasion of privacy and does not wish its disclosure.

In counsel's view, the item is beyond the purview of the Board's subpoenas and therefore not subject to production.

Mr.

Lipinsky has agreed to show the passage in camera to the Board if it is deemed necessary.

~~

Sincerely, M

Joseph Gallo cy:

Service List 4

I --

I o.

r e.

November cc:oo.r u.

..,is m o.c.mo.r Wednesday s u r w r,r s 5"'*f

  • s sarwras e r i..3 4 i2 S

p3 i

2 24 sers

.,. 7,,,,

1314 og is gp t i og

,,ey,3,,,g,g,p 9 to ii 9713 to 4 3p

's it 'a is 2o si.r 2e 23 ::: to 2s M is '* 2o ti 72 rs 2 25 26 27 28.N 27 78 29 38 25 M 27 25 29 30 3.

p.

4

% l f 20 ift.r'(OT) ul So[f 3 T. Gaed. ul/ *

v. us,a w. ass (u,te).sif H.tx.m *m-r a.14 oF Mu.rea ( soo au ea///r.t CH 'C+4 e J Ao 66( A.c at sw At;f*cAme,J.was (Acea v) nt. w 4

d Chut.T Ae Ma =-- 'A" AE /ACM) 5 A' M 4kMTaniul c'A., f tankD'% (.*){MK ~ C*"!4tT* ( ad. t Jassh Ceuwe,-)

sMTan e.sr -fa Mxo s**** /J' f*y kis N at ).lk o& pia arma' r>nw.uc mas Ma.'&r k ap Ada 1

n)aas b Jutr.enn..uar-70 Gird ytwsus' Aur

\\.k., M

JJt rase
rtru mm ir comuu 6e ro nu.

e,.

heta:ir is*c /f. Tart.N of AAffiR2tw r F4s.tr Howa ~ Allo sicum ns Mee A*T'D Cofy * "/^3in/J3 s'tb 7xAw.rexfor-

-f.g. Dic Marper %)ew Ms. mk/ od i o)l2. A.

3 ff 4 5'J G (ES T njso{s.L T. co n M.

^

}

5 H. - CA ro c4ss..

Qpng.ae,j) 1.JaxJr pvaA. ~r. ened.#lyd.beu.cne W/46. n

?. sy jarzx.asr.a' ME Aoj $A M'd'D Wt Q gung 7 stet Y*

YNAt M.24 4*7)f'*iflll[afE' Rl'rWMr

.]

7 i

. n ~ 1 r % e, a. o s e w,, ~. ~ -

me w ~g J y

  1. 4 l"-l% ""W '$l)' od.97;97W -ten-M 9 p,ii.a sgir:a ro ww.)u *s **

U.%

,i MSmy'j"j&,i pihor as7v.ad cau-NG vi gw 7:eair) wim

>j

,7,,.ro I

S E

1 e

3, i

e I

4. ~

r

~-

q

.,.-..-,w"-------.-----,-,.--.---------------v

-v-**-,-m.--

.,--ee--,c'e.-

,m-

--.--..w-<--e

,--w--

)

t c

I 3

~

c '.

h.

. w:"..

1 December

.~

i

' {

annuny iss4 F.enary unen sui =t as swtwtas sarwras Thursdav i

)

2 34 58 7 1 2 34 1 23 T

0 91011121314 5 8 F S 910 at a S8 7 8 9 'O 1S 16 tF to 19 20 21

  • 12 ts 14 is to 1F is et 121314 vg is IF 23 23 24 25 N 2F 28 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 5819.N 2122 73 24 31 In i C'M 4Y25 N 2F M 29 30,&

bd M 38 31 N 27 N N r

.}

g g 55 ptv. u:2r) t*l sua.1:eadtlFa.y 9

a mr w we muaer

.yya m. sau -au wmv wwr an a n

,u a m m it. 4. v n c m r< m.:.a g &

p WfGco yas ff.oDC MA/T%'* M (re lll M 307 GE?rak-66d of i.3 fo6L

.x y ncew) ut,fa 1*d *lw oW ".,,

q 5

N

"y;$,ll$$?!"YA"""

~

f T#*'#'*'I###'~

i et# err)/d///73 usa. max T *y,(y3 e TJds' } W-ru 7%2 q.

g 4 m. m*

.-m. "

r-wv w w e emaer f f l, T S j ? 0 $ Y.

a

~

e r

i t

l l

l t

l Hanukkah l

J

~*

t b

l.

V l

V

]

c u.

l I

1 March Aoni -

December F e n a r/

1.

    • '"',',5, Thursday 2

=,.>.2

,,,.,,.,.,,,.,,,,.9,,,,,,,,.,.,

i nnnnnun 25 24 27 2 29 J. u, nn.unann

,.,, : v n n 3

29 3

. M 2, N 29

.=

I kHfe disd 7.cadd. $..CA.

l i

p c.,

,4/ usa.

%(Dm463Tueerr.Accr#Ae.**eth. us Tuc ap u p

['l

~i l

~

    • o u M nie, ru, asa

.ut. =

i r.-

wous.svacs re S.rurrio J Lm&

i my mm m pms.

Mia M SA Am. MK' A L

g St. M xa,. T o T n s.Ji~ f u e t t w A t

- ~

Wiu tamnce #Ae. aneducy Act a*y 44 se ewo *cr wa.vo, NAt fbC4AMVU Nt**f47e'

& ddt,,,, Atu cD t% &DUT*

An waiaa ser up.,suo m aab eataa 2.

o sua. y~

tbtut ~Mt. As't' TD datt w /o p d Ar nel'A j J Is. hoss.uor wsenir se ym.se,*seur me,. x opect.D 7tu. M4a 4Emmne se m & fyap..gop,s4gg ggg, MC5 AtXO if JJL HAD MCMD /swt pg.gzu;g,

@ & CUTJ.V M4IE'E.L.id' EN.rN M &NOlJ f67' % t sJjeJ4

(&Alta rashtD Ut. 00ff). JJL 440 ftiba, to roto u4 rt.17-Men 7e /o as doe 4b uastussr, in Arxad.

l oam.

.ui-THer-A,r.t/o inc cis./.k Mrft.f,g.

~

J31.

twr JJe. aa, ose sneuzara.re scgy,;.

Un%gu.14AMA Mib Trtnr.ht Jacurb Anna scu.

fa THkr MC.EU it

  • 0*.4 MC,C"'M's & '!C Q799 C**

tdit.L, Et/4) Uf ILJ 7KCoat.E # dX. 7Mt.x.s:n g p,))t,

,o sr. aae. we weam or onary wan.a 1,jg, e tsewr, Jrum rD ava e of Aur bobN'T~

11E1)nid 70 JN&

@ gtA At.x s iF ~2L W fk'*<b W A W Qiaba'aa.4:ul.,1.lt. 2Mb Alc. ur+ty'? NBA Shah W&

M.!inDet. san.C it.bodHAnsts' ATrneacf

~D4-un,jac]as,uwuh neen. m A.cahoated aL

,a u<t rs.y To nevs diz. esurikx m.gs y,rpiuhzt y gr Ar Luuen if M.,'!Ath

\\

  • ^ ' ' C-Q g9g, g' JJt.ser rtLtArirti; (*f?) APPT Of ^'~'A

@we..bc oe7/er ed la/ efea e c iF M A Wra*J Ms.cf ADec,r sa~m fatr ~re

. p ;.,

+-==...,.a..

sa,. u i._

JSFey4EI) SkT c7 T'c=Id t0/d5' A (eJ.cefr-p %)

g

-9 s.

6 O

A

l l

+

5 t

~

December Novher December 1983, January 1984 7

,, t,, s, s a r w r.,. s.

s. u r w e, s Wednesday swt HER5= 25lllll iiinien '

l

  • / is/shsAER CAU Eb DL IUTO RBA opple""f'm 1;

g Tzt nr.Ac j eo n.curr sa sase. car,re f

Ih o.x 6.uc.) y N44.,42.m a.4 =eur om ros uu To ofunret96 uwent ajuxe

.t USA LA7tcn. 70s a.LN 70 *Givf Alf wno.

/6/s/47.epxAl. tdlf.g.l'A/hy) 6'HAac NujoA(

4 (timur.Wt' 7kar Mas.c Ehl Al/S S-9 M

-as sta ->. xxr.) pMrab,.ui. toem.wa s

/f7h MGA*$4f /ADM s'fn. JhtAr,t (Ao3,.-

77h?"Mb At/ dNd?&C g7-4tJ7)-fMM 7 % Jh,r $ -z 3 c a r r g n/AC GM/EELt gj l.cs r* MEKL&g*

b

/gg gegeo (exr) T'fMdA'd/ANA^#

M A3AJ6 (fad AWW fr78r... fd,C1~j qMA ACAIG G **fM).

d0935(23r)7*. W 'W d ' Y E ll2 dip

/Q}S3 (aoa.13'1~4131) ^IAl ^?"is^ g/*u**YllIMh d

p g y n A p r.ic y 4 m /D f o x/AnssuT klL Amuy%fdL'ezr)Mr/>rerrae'l@'5d MWG

/afy/nt cete.c.z.as -xMe. hd few '"l 13 s o ppceasy with 4210*) Re MAI i

g N R3 tittee s M r a d % S M "AE*[ ^3 g /.,fe Ps x40 'TC.b TB ma.DL. a+s wi 8

n.uis vtanwar

.i opia @sca rwur.ui m.c w hersw. ><ajo,u teo 7tm7 ots#me45, p,u y /r M Aevu.oalAnh.f w 41.

D. var JJ AJ MEga,pq

.,,. ~ ' ~

a-

.)

OprTE,1JL,34 NAO'JC4. Alf.:s't. /%

N0%Wmr 8 -DL MED. ** '* "#E '* *'Y w q een.nu umrico Aur.= om. ea s,esm'ac, our sudi1sr.72 es-7 K454 C AM C(, R..S e M 6 A'/dM. 4 f ULf f."E!h.1 A2:MiO 2>q /,4 MUsit. "'

u C C C AiTE7t'a AC.C.

0EL i

3

/

s.

0

_ _ _ _ _ _. _ _ _. _ _ _ _ _ _. _ _.. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20099K354&oldid=4312571"