|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20151L5181997-08-0505 August 1997 Order Prohibiting Involvement in NRC Licensed Activities (Effective Immediately) Re SL Nevin Deliberately Falsifying Records of RECW Sample Documentation on 960207 ML20151L3671997-08-0505 August 1997 Order Prohibiting Involvement in NRC Licensed Activities (Effective Immediately).Orders That SA Blacklock Prohibited from Engaging in Activities Licensed by NRC for 5 Yrs from Date of Order ML20203H6891997-06-0202 June 1997 Transcript of 970602 Enforcement Conference in King of Prussia,Pa ML20083N3971995-04-26026 April 1995 Comment Supporting Proposed GL, Pressure Locking & Thermal Binding of Safety-Related Power-Operated Gate Valves ML20081B3811995-03-0101 March 1995 Comment Supporting Proposed Suppl 5 to GL 88-20, IPEEE for Severe Accident Vulnerabilities ML20058K7381993-12-0303 December 1993 Memorandum & Order CLI-93-25.* Commission Denies State of Nj Petition for Leave to Intervene & Request for Adjudicatory Hearing Filed on 931008.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 931203 ML20059B0301993-10-22022 October 1993 NRC Staff Response to Commission Questions Posed W/Respect to State of New Jersey Petition for Leave to Intervene & Request for Hearing.* Denies Petition to Intervene & Request for Hearing.W/Certificate of Svc & Notice of Appearance ML20059B1111993-10-20020 October 1993 Philadelphia Electric Co Response to NRC 931014 Order.* State Failed to Demonstrate Entitlement to Hearing to Challenge Util Amend to Permit Util to Receive Shoreham Fuel ML20057G2141993-10-14014 October 1993 Order.* Requests for Simultaneous Responses,Not to Exceed 10 Pages to Be Filed by State,Peco & Lipa & Served on Other Specified Responders by 931020.NRC May File by 931022. W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 931014 ML20059A4581993-10-14014 October 1993 Order Requesting Answers to Two Questions Re State of Nj Request for Immediate Action by NRC or Alternatively, Petition for Leave to Intervene & Request for Hearing. Operations Plans for Marine Transportation Withheld ML20059B1291993-09-14014 September 1993 Affidavit of Jh Freeman.* Discusses Transfer of Slightly Used Nuclear Fuel from Shoreham Nuclear Power Station to Limerick Generating Station.W/Certificate of Svc & Notice of Appearance ML20045D8121993-06-14014 June 1993 Comment Supporting Proposed Rules 10CFR50 & 54 Re FSAR Update Submittals. ML20126F2721992-12-21021 December 1992 Comment Endorsing Positions & Comments of NUMARC & BWROG Re Draft GL, Augmented Inservice Insp Requirments for Mark I & Mark II Steel Containments,Refueling Cavities & Associated Drainage Sys ML20062C6561990-10-22022 October 1990 Affidavit Requesting Withholding of Summary Rept on Evaluation of Recirculation Nozzle to Safe End Weld Indication & Proposed Disposition to Permit Unit 1 Cycle 4 Operation, from Public Disclosure,Per 10CFR2.790 ML20246J4521989-08-30030 August 1989 Memorandum & Order (Terminating Proceeding).* Terminates Proceeding Per Settlement Agreement Between Limerick Ecology Action,Inc & Licensee.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 890831 ML20246F1011989-08-25025 August 1989 Joint Motion for Termination of Proceedings.* Board Moved to Accept Encl Settlement Agreement,Dismiss Limerick Ecology Action,Inc (Lea) Contention W/Prejudice,Dismiss Lea as Party to Proceeding & Terminate Proceeding ML20246F0121989-08-25025 August 1989 Memorandum & Order CLI-89-17.* Staff Authorizes Issuance of Full Power License to Licensee to Operate Unit 2 After Requisite Safety Findings Under 10CFR50.57 Completed. W/Certificate of Svc ML20246F1471989-08-25025 August 1989 Settlement Agreement.* Certificate of Svc Encl ML20246E3431989-08-22022 August 1989 Opposition of Intervenor Limerick Ecology Action,Inc to Motion by Licensee Philadelphia Electric Co to Set Schedule for Discovery & Hearing.* Requests That Schedule Be Replaced W/More Reasonable Schedule,As Proposed.W/Certificate of Svc ML20246C0271989-08-18018 August 1989 Notice of Appointment of Adjudicatory Employee.* Informs That D Nash Appointed as Commission Adjudicatory Employee to Advise Commission on Issues in Proceeding.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 890818 ML20246B7721989-08-17017 August 1989 Correction of Memorandum & Order of 890815.* Advises That Refs to 49CFR2.730(c) on Page 1 & 49CFR2.710 & 49CFR2.711 on Page 2 Should Be Corrected to Read as 10CFR2.730(c),2.710 & 2.711,respectively.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 890818 ML20246D7411989-08-17017 August 1989 Transcript of 890817 Meeting in Rockville,Md Re Discussion of Full Power OL for Facility.Pp 1-58.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20246B7571989-08-16016 August 1989 Order Responding to Limerick Ecology Action Motion for Reconsideration.* Denies Motion to Reconsider,Stay,Suspend or Revoke 890707 Order on Basis That Order Appropriate.W/ Certificate of Svc.Served on 890816.Re-served on 890818 ML20246B7751989-08-16016 August 1989 Memorandum & Order.* Denies Rl Anthony 890623 Request for Hearing for Intervention in Remand Proceeding & for Stay of Low Power Authorization.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 890816 ML20246B7931989-08-15015 August 1989 Memorandum & Order (Request for Expedited Answer).* Denies Licensee 890811 Request for Expedited Answer from NRC & Limerick Ecology Action on Basis That Request Lacks Good Cause.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 890816 ML20245H8491989-08-14014 August 1989 Notice of Change of Address.* Advises of Council Change of Address for Svc of Documents ML20245H8061989-08-14014 August 1989 Supplemental Response of Intervenor Limerick Ecology Action, Inc to Memorandum & Order of Commission & to Memorandum & Order of 890807.* Requests Further Extension of Time in Which to Reply.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20245H5991989-08-11011 August 1989 Memorandum & Order (Terminating Proceeding).* Dismisses Graterford Inmates Contention Re Adequacy of Training for Drivers Responsible for Evacuating Graterford & Terminates Proceeding.Certificate of Svc Encl.Served on 890814 ML20245H7341989-08-10010 August 1989 Motion by Licensee Philadelphia Electric Co to Set Schedule for Discovery & Hearing & Request for Expedited Answer to This Motion.* Divergence in Positions of Respective Parties Emphasizes Need to Conclude Proceeding.W/Certificate of Svc ML20245F7511989-08-0909 August 1989 Reply by Licensee Philadelphia Electric Co to NRC Staff Response to Commission Questions.* Commission Should Rely on Licensee Cost Analysis in Response to Question 5 & Rc Williams Affidavit.W/Certificate of Svc ML20245F7161989-08-0909 August 1989 Reply by Licensee Philadelphia Electric Co to Response of Intervenor Limerick Ecology Action,Inc to Memorandum & Order of Commission Dtd 890726.* Environ Benefits for Operating Unit 2 Outweigh Small Risk of Severe Accident ML20245F7341989-08-0909 August 1989 NRC Staff Response to Commission Memorandum & Order of 890807.* Advises That NRC Will Provide Comments on Limerick Ecology Action 890814 Filing Prior to Commission Meeting Scheduled for 890817.W/Certificate of Svc ML20245F7291989-08-0808 August 1989 Affidavit.* Discusses Costs Incurred While Plant Inoperable. Allowance for Funds Used During Const,Security,Maint & Operational Costs Considered Proper for Calculating Costs for Delay ML20248D9241989-08-0707 August 1989 Memorandum & Order.* Extends Limerick Ecology Action Response Deadline to 890814 to Respond to Five Questions Re Severe Accident Mitigation Design Alternatives.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 890807 ML20248D7871989-08-0303 August 1989 Correction for NRC Staff Response to Commission Questions.* Forwards Corrected Page 5 to NRC Response to Questions Filed on 890802,deleting Phrase by Nearly Factor 2.5 in Next to Last Line.W/Certificate of Svc ML20248D7111989-08-0202 August 1989 Response of Intervenor Limerick Ecology Action,Inc to Memorandum & Order of Commission Dtd 890726.* Commission Order Fails to Provide Intervenor Adequate Time for Response & Should Therefore Be Revoked.W/Certificate of Svc ML20248D5391989-08-0202 August 1989 Affidavit of MT Masnik.* Advises That Author Prepared Response to Question 3 ML20248D5671989-08-0202 August 1989 Affidavit of SE Feld.* Advises That Author Prepared Response to Question 5.W/Certificate of Svc ML20248D6451989-08-0202 August 1989 Affidavit.* Advises That Author Read Responses to Request for Comments by NRC & Knows Contents.W/Certificate of Svc ML20248D4721989-08-0202 August 1989 NRC Staff Response to Commission Questions.* Provides Info for Use in Commission Effectiveness Review of Plant Full Power Operation,Per Commission 890726 Memorandum & Order. Supporting Affidavits Encl ML20248D4971989-08-0202 August 1989 Joint Affidavit of Gy Suh & CS Hinson.* Advises That Authors Prepared Responses to Questions 1 & 4 ML20248D5311989-08-0202 August 1989 Affidavit of Rj Barrett.* Advises That Author Prepared Response to Question 2 ML20248D5981989-08-0202 August 1989 Response by Licensee Philadelphia Electric Co to Commission Request for Comments by Memorandum & Order Dtd 890726.* Licensee Requests Commission Issue Full Power OL for Unit 2 Conditioned Upon Outcome of Pending Litigation ML20245J1321989-07-27027 July 1989 Transcript of 890727 Meeting in Rockville,Md Re Facility Severe Accident Mitigation Issues.Pp 1-130.Supporting Info Encl ML20247N3261989-07-26026 July 1989 Transcript of 890726 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote in Rockville,Md on SECY-89-220 Re Order Requesting Info from Parties for Immediate Effectiveness Review of Full Power Authorization for Limerick Unit 2.Pp 1-4 ML20248D7331989-07-24024 July 1989 Second Rept of Parties & Request for Dismissal of Graterford Inmates Contention & Termination of Proceeding.* Requests Board to Enter Order to Terminate Proceeding Based on Parties Agreeing to Dismissal of Remaining Contention ML20247Q4621989-07-23023 July 1989 Response of Intervenor Rl Anthony to Answer of Philadelphia Electric Co (PECO) to Request for Hearing on PECO Application for Low Power Operation of Unit 2 & Stay of Any Operation in Keeping W/Us Circuit Court Remand Of....* ML20247B7261989-07-20020 July 1989 Notice of Appointment of Adjudicatory Employee.* Advises That H Vandermole Appointed to Advise Commission on Issues in Proceeding Re Severe Accident Mitigation Design Alternatives.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 890720 ML20247B3821989-07-18018 July 1989 Memorandum & Order.* Orders That Severe Accident Mitigation Alternatives,Per Nepa,To Be Considered Include Containment Heat Removal,Core Residue Capture & Venting.Certificate of Encl.Served on 890719 ML20247B7641989-07-13013 July 1989 Motion of Intervenor,Limerick Ecology Action Inc,To Reconsider/Stay/Suspend/Revoke Order Authorizing Issuance of Low Power OL for Limerick 2.* Consideration of Accident Mitigation Alternatives Imperative.Certificate of Svc Encl 1997-08-05
[Table view] Category:PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20059B0301993-10-22022 October 1993 NRC Staff Response to Commission Questions Posed W/Respect to State of New Jersey Petition for Leave to Intervene & Request for Hearing.* Denies Petition to Intervene & Request for Hearing.W/Certificate of Svc & Notice of Appearance ML20059B1111993-10-20020 October 1993 Philadelphia Electric Co Response to NRC 931014 Order.* State Failed to Demonstrate Entitlement to Hearing to Challenge Util Amend to Permit Util to Receive Shoreham Fuel ML20246F1011989-08-25025 August 1989 Joint Motion for Termination of Proceedings.* Board Moved to Accept Encl Settlement Agreement,Dismiss Limerick Ecology Action,Inc (Lea) Contention W/Prejudice,Dismiss Lea as Party to Proceeding & Terminate Proceeding ML20246E3431989-08-22022 August 1989 Opposition of Intervenor Limerick Ecology Action,Inc to Motion by Licensee Philadelphia Electric Co to Set Schedule for Discovery & Hearing.* Requests That Schedule Be Replaced W/More Reasonable Schedule,As Proposed.W/Certificate of Svc ML20245H8061989-08-14014 August 1989 Supplemental Response of Intervenor Limerick Ecology Action, Inc to Memorandum & Order of Commission & to Memorandum & Order of 890807.* Requests Further Extension of Time in Which to Reply.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20245H7341989-08-10010 August 1989 Motion by Licensee Philadelphia Electric Co to Set Schedule for Discovery & Hearing & Request for Expedited Answer to This Motion.* Divergence in Positions of Respective Parties Emphasizes Need to Conclude Proceeding.W/Certificate of Svc ML20245F7511989-08-0909 August 1989 Reply by Licensee Philadelphia Electric Co to NRC Staff Response to Commission Questions.* Commission Should Rely on Licensee Cost Analysis in Response to Question 5 & Rc Williams Affidavit.W/Certificate of Svc ML20245F7161989-08-0909 August 1989 Reply by Licensee Philadelphia Electric Co to Response of Intervenor Limerick Ecology Action,Inc to Memorandum & Order of Commission Dtd 890726.* Environ Benefits for Operating Unit 2 Outweigh Small Risk of Severe Accident ML20248D5981989-08-0202 August 1989 Response by Licensee Philadelphia Electric Co to Commission Request for Comments by Memorandum & Order Dtd 890726.* Licensee Requests Commission Issue Full Power OL for Unit 2 Conditioned Upon Outcome of Pending Litigation ML20248D7111989-08-0202 August 1989 Response of Intervenor Limerick Ecology Action,Inc to Memorandum & Order of Commission Dtd 890726.* Commission Order Fails to Provide Intervenor Adequate Time for Response & Should Therefore Be Revoked.W/Certificate of Svc ML20247Q4621989-07-23023 July 1989 Response of Intervenor Rl Anthony to Answer of Philadelphia Electric Co (PECO) to Request for Hearing on PECO Application for Low Power Operation of Unit 2 & Stay of Any Operation in Keeping W/Us Circuit Court Remand Of....* ML20247B7641989-07-13013 July 1989 Motion of Intervenor,Limerick Ecology Action Inc,To Reconsider/Stay/Suspend/Revoke Order Authorizing Issuance of Low Power OL for Limerick 2.* Consideration of Accident Mitigation Alternatives Imperative.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20246P4951989-07-0303 July 1989 Licensee Memorandum Re Proposed Design Mitigation Alternatives for Which Agreement Among Parties Could Not Be Reached.* Only Specific Alternatives Being Considered by Licensee & Should Be Given Attention.W/Certificate of Svc ML20246P3321989-07-0303 July 1989 NRC Staff Memorandum Supporting Staff Position Re Alternatives to Be Litigated.* Board Should Reject Limerick Ecology Action Suggested Items for Litigation Considered Outside of Scope of Remand.W/Certificate of Svc ML20246N9971989-06-30030 June 1989 Memorandum of Limerick Ecology Action,Inc,Per Prehearing Conference Order of ASLB of 890609.* Proposed Alternatives for Severe Accident Mitigation within Scope of Proceeding on Remand.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20245D2691989-06-21021 June 1989 Applicant Reply Memorandum in Support of Motion for Clarification Or,Alternatively,For Exemption.* Commission Should Determine That NRC Fully Authorized to Issue OL for Facility & Be Directed,Per 10CFR51.6.W/Certificate of Svc ML20245A5981989-06-15015 June 1989 Opposition of Limerick Ecology Action,Inc to Applicant Motion for Clarification of Commission Delegation of Authority & for Issuance of Ol,Or Alternatively,For Exemption from Procedural....* W/Certificate of Svc ML20245A5811989-06-15015 June 1989 Opposition of Commonwealth of PA to Motion of Philadelphia Electric Co for Clarification of Commission Delegation of Authority & for Issuance of OL & Opposition to Motion for Exemption.* W/Certificate of Svc ML20248B7471989-06-0505 June 1989 Applicant Motion for Clarification of Commission Delegation of Authority & for Issuance of Ol,Or,Alternatively,For Exemption from Procedural Requirement That License for Limerick Unit 2 Cannot Issue Until Contention Remanded....* ML20151T6901988-04-25025 April 1988 Response of Intervenor Rl Anthony to PECO 880331 Response & NRC Staff 880404.* Denial of Applicant Motion for Summary Disposition & Application for License Amend Urged ML20150F8721988-03-31031 March 1988 Licensee Response to Order of 880317 Requesting Clarifying Info.* Clarifying Info Needed to Decide Parties Submissions on Licensee Motion for Summary Disposition ML20149K9821988-02-18018 February 1988 Response of NRC Staff in Support of Licensee Motion for Summary Disposition.* NRC Agrees W/Licensee Motion Because No Genuine Issue of Matl Fact Exists to Be Litigated. Consolidated Contention & Proceeding Should Be Dismissed ML20196D6751988-02-0909 February 1988 Response in Opposition to Licensee Request for Summary of Disposition of Air & Water Pollution Patrol Opposition to Licensee Application for Amend to License NPF-39 & Exemption to App J of 871218. * ML20235A8101988-01-0606 January 1988 Licensee Opposition to Intervenor Rl Anthony Request for Extension of Time for Discovery.* Intervenor Request Should Be Denied as Intervenor Had Adequate Opportunity to Review Responses & Pursue Addl Discovery.W/Certificate of Svc ML20235A8041988-01-0505 January 1988 Air & Water Pollution Patrol (Romano) Reaction to Licensee time-defaulted Response for Production of Documents as Ordered by NRC Administrative judges,871120.* Requests That Util Be Reprimanded for Defaulting on 871120 Order ML20238D1601987-12-20020 December 1987 Intervenor Rl Anthony Request for Extension of Time for Discovery.* Extension Requested Due to Listed Obstacles Which Have Prevented Study of Matl Provided & Matl Missing ML20236T1781987-11-23023 November 1987 Licensee Memorandum in Support of Motion for Summary Disposition,Preliminary Statement.* Proposed Amend Does Not Downgrade Reporting Requirements for Iodine Spikes. Consolidated Contention & Proceeding Should Be Dismissed ML20236T1611987-11-23023 November 1987 Licensee Motion for Summary Disposition.* Forwards Util Statement of Matl Facts as to Which There Is No Genuine Issue to Be Heard,Memorandum in Support of Motion for Summary Disposition & J Doering & Js Wiley Affidavits ML20236P8241987-11-12012 November 1987 Air & Water Pollution Patrol (Awpp) (Romano) Objection to Licensee Objection to Intervenor Awpp Request for Opportunity to File for Discovery & Motion for Protective Order.* Failure to Monitor Proceeding Inadvertent ML20236P8971987-11-10010 November 1987 Intervenor Rl Anthony Objection to Philadelphia Electric Co Objection to Anthony Discovery & Request for Protective Order Dtd 871030.* Only Essential Matl for Appeal of Granting License Amend Requested ML20236N8971987-11-0909 November 1987 Response of NRC Staff to Rl Anthony Discovery Requests & Licensee Objections Thereto.* ASLB Should Deny Request,But Protective Order Not Opposed.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20236N8351987-11-0909 November 1987 Response of NRC Staff to Air & Water Pollution Patrol Motion of 871027 Concerning Summary Disposition & Discovery & Licensees Objections Thereto.* Motion Should Be Denied. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20236L7471987-11-0202 November 1987 Licensee Objection to Intervenor Air & Water Pollution Patrol Request for Opportunity to File for Discovery & Motion for Protective Order.* Certificate of Svc Encl ML20236H3911987-10-30030 October 1987 Licensee Objection to Intervenor Anthony Request for Discovery & Motion for Protective Order.* Certificate of Svc Encl ML20236H4091987-10-27027 October 1987 Memorandum & Order (Memorializing Special Prehearing Conference;Ruling on Contentions).* Motion for Board to Summarily Dispose Util Request Instant Amend & for Exercise to Discovery ML20236H3401987-10-25025 October 1987 Intervenor Rl Anthony Response to 871009 Memorandum & Order.* Author Has No Further Requests for Info in Addition to Items Recorded in .Util Should Provide Listed Records ML20236R7731987-08-26026 August 1987 Suppl to Petitioner Response of 870702 to Board Notice of Hearing & Order of 870729.* Petitioner Lists Contentions Opposing Granting of License Amend to Tech Specs for Plant Re Matter of Radioactive Iodine Spikes ML20237G9731987-08-21021 August 1987 Air & Water Pollution Patrol Suppl to Opposition to Radioactive Iodine Amend for License NPF-39.* Concerns Expressed Re Unusual Sensitivity of Thyroid to Iodine. Licensee Does Not Merit Amend,Based on Util Past Conduct ML20235M1751987-07-13013 July 1987 Staff Reply to Licensee Answers to Petitioner Requests for Hearing & Motions to Intervene (Licensee Second Argument).* Air & Water Pollution Patrol & R Anthony Failed to Meet Stds for Intervention in Amend Proceedings.Aslb Denies Petition ML20235G5851987-07-0505 July 1987 Awpp (Romano) Answers Licensee Argument II as Per Order of 870522 Re Representational Standing.* Urges Licensee to Show Cause Why Cable Pulling Necessitates Greater Air Leakage from Reactor Openings ML20235J0491987-07-0202 July 1987 Response by Intervenor Rl Anthony to Board Order of 870622.* Licensee Opposed to License Amend & Request Hearing to Form Basis for Board to Deny Request.Reduction of Control Over Iodine Spikes & Levels Is Threat to Health of Public ML20215J7661987-06-16016 June 1987 NRC Staff Response to Licensee Answer in Opposition to Request for Hearing & Leave to Intervene by Air & Water Pollution Patrol.* Board Should Reject Licensee First Argument & Anthony Request for Hearing.W/Certificate of Svc ML20216D3641987-06-16016 June 1987 NRC Staff Response to Licensee Answer in Opposition to Request for Hearing & Leave to Intervene by Air & Water Pollution Patrol.* ASLB Should Reject Licensee First Argument & Anthony Request for Hearing.W/Certificate of Svc ML20215D9491987-06-0808 June 1987 Intervenor Rl Anthony Response to ASLB Order of 870522.* Licensee Position Mistaken Both in Relation to Correctness of Petition to Intervene & as to Intent of Citizen Participation Specified in NEPA & Aea.Served on 870616 ML20214W5531987-06-0202 June 1987 Response Opposing Util Request for Legal Loopholes to Prevent Groups w/long-term Commitment to Insure Licensee Does Better Job Abiding Rules Re Public Safety ML20214G6271987-05-19019 May 1987 Commonwealth of PA Opposition to Graterford Inmates Petition for Review of ALAB-863.* Graterford Inmates Failed to Prove That Aslab Decision Erroneous W/Respect to Important Question of Fact,Policy or Law.W/Certificate of Svc ML20214A9491987-05-18018 May 1987 NRC Staff Answer in Opposition to Petition for Review of Inmates of State Correctional Inst at Graterford.* Inmates Failed to Establish That Issues Raised Re ALAB-863 Warrant Review.Commission Should Deny Review.W/Certificate of Svc ML20210C1011987-05-0404 May 1987 Petition for Review.* Review of Aslab 870417 Decision ALAB-836 Requested to Determine If Reasonable Assurances Given That Sufficient Manpower Will Be Mobilized in Event of Evacuation.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20212K5141987-01-23023 January 1987 Response of NRC Staff in Opposition to Graterford Inmates Appeal of Licensing Board Suppl to Fourth Partial Initial Decision.* Certificate of Svc Encl ML20207P9441987-01-12012 January 1987 Commonwealth of PA Brief in Opposition to Appeal by Graterford Inmates of Suppl to Fourth Partial Initial Decision:Preliminary Statement.* W/Certificate of Svc 1993-10-22
[Table view] |
Text
m.m z., x wp - ' '
W . ie -
'.,'o
'WW t&h p [y wl-si w "
l- "
L -,
c -
- _ ,, ( ?5' hl- ~
~
L:,z
- ~ ~
+ .
. . . . . . _ s.y
'~
- . 00CKETED -
- - =
usnac.: . H m
~
' ~
A -
'84 JET 19TA11129J ~
~
~
Y = -
- g .
- r 01 C
, P . UNITED STATESiOF[ AMERICA- Ad 3 h'. ,_ ,
~ NUCLEAR REGULATORYgCOMMISSION ' MRANCH
}
s ATOMICjSAFETYfAND) LICENSING' APPEAL 1'BOARDI w-e '. . .. ; / .
.C A
' Int.the:Mattersof: , -) ..
EPHILNDELPHIADELECTRIC) COMPANY ; Docket . Nos . :50--352, 50--353 g~
- );
'(Limerick Generating' Station,' --) .-
Units 1 and.2).
)f -n g
~ * .'
MOTION FOR SUSPENSION OF.. LOW-POWER t FACILITY: OPERATING' LICENSE NPF-27' Limerick.Ecblogy' Action, Inc. (LEA) , - intervenor in the labove -
captioned licensing proceeding, moves the Appeal-Board.for;.an, Order suspending the authorization for'a' low-power operating; y license for the above facility, and sets forth the:followingsin.
support thereof:
On or about. September 3, 1984, LEA filedLa-timely appeal to this Board. from the Partial Initial Decisionf(PID) ,' of the V Atomic Safety and Licensing Board - (ASLB) , which, inter 'alia, .
authorized the Director of the Office of Nuclear. Reactor Regu-lation.to issue the operating license. .
.On or about October'3, 1984 LEA filed-a briefsin'~ support
'of its appeal, setting forth in detail-various errors in-law, and.' violations of the_ National Environmental Policy'Act, the Administrative Procedure Act and Commission regulations by the-8411200022 841115 PDR ADOCK 050003S2
.0 PDR .-
3)s~o3
~ .
m gg7
, ,, 7 ,
j; _ _
. ; -<r '- .
\- ' Y si .._ [k( ,
,t. -
- p. .- .g- - _ . - - - -
gy i ,
.em a ,
y ,
, . l...
~
u e f, ~-
.ASLB. 1 lek's arguments therein are hereby incorporated?in theiri
! entirety bynreference thereto. -
- Bas'ed.upon:thefarguments; set ~-forth'in' its'Brief,' LEA be .
lieves<that it'has-made-.a " strong showing"-thatLitzis~likelyEto
~
prevail on the' merits ofJitsiposition. . -
-Irreparable Injury'to LEA 1 _
LEA will be' irreparably. injured unlessgthe suspension is. e granted. Among.the bases which' LEA set forth for. reversal;of the ASLB partial initial: decision below is- the failure of; the environmental' review.for Limorick.to considor design alternativos;
-to mitigato the risk of sevoro accidents. LLA's-membership is among the population exposed to this risk, and'would be I among the beneficiaries of a reduction of this risk.. ,
Hidden.from NEPA review and excluded from licensing con-sideration are Staff analyses of a range of potential risk re-
. duction measures which may be available for implementation at Limerick. However, the cost-effectivencss of such' measures, the~
practicability of backfitting.such measures into the Limerick
' design and the radiation exposure of workers involved inthe
' implementation of such measures will all-be adversely affected by low-power operation of the facility-which will contaminate '
l plant 1 systems.
1 i
l 5
2-l
- y :
w
- W /%'
kg7 m,aWi b @W ~ .%, % m ?& ' , f :Q L M Y 11em * /
,' - W W: g4
/ - F ? - ^4 , V. '
P':%.. u. ; o, % f ~k p gg ne_s ,- % >T: - m {j g. - -
- ~ .x -
c,; 43.:e n, .
,y, ,
- w w% a i J W' p%y' f,y
. 'y , , <~ '
Mygfy1 l~
N %y R Q , g g ,' [m .J m,p s
' ' ogy
- p .
- v
-3 ; -
g,3,+ .
m_ . s-
? - _ ; , -:, p+ v
, [_ c ;Qy Qf'Y u ,' zy-
]s f y-@<~
- ,' :54 ~
-4 ,
vs , ";.; , s sg g-a; E, ,
4r m'a.+
3 ;l * .. i- u
- 6 v, .
g,y; . 'S 4- - ;; , ;w ,.<
.. m x < Ay v
,; . V ' "
.*1,':
E A
~ 3, y ,- , W 3 4, ,
s ' , . . . .iH' +
f N'$? *'
+-
. .. %wg n :ur 4ey e : ;-
a, .'
4 w.g- : ' ,' = 4.
x J.;p- ,, ,c
- m . -
- . >< q-s ,
l l-(. .: [ ' je ~' '
.q _, ; ., - e [
~*
^
G y!
gy v , '4 ~ ,h' - c W(4 ' 'e
~, ' .g~?
p f: ,
q s ,
eQ.. L;. /
n , &, + ,< ,
_ - + . ,
y j"' ;e. s v -
.. ~ .x
. . +
.~1 s
3~/.:Thus m 4-bibs--power 'o'perationlmay[foreverimake; onw - .
unavailnle
.Y ,. ( ,. ' ,[ ,. , ,.
..f. . , .,
f g
'h' '
M, '
"N- 4 f
> t t
' M
~ Talternatives
- ' , 7 . , . . w ,whichicould?substantiallyfreducel'he
- publictrisk
. ;. . " L 4 :.
J.. . .!
< - j h y g5,
, w m toELEA'sJmembership Fi,AsctheHASLB(stated 1below:
1
.z: ~. ~
r 3 '
L .n Y
k .2 ,
JItLis commonly recognized!thatLasfcon? :s ,e (,m ,
c g('
A
- EstructionNcon.tinu'esivthe costificorrective >' '
C# " /
1.: action to1 minimize 1 environmental-harm.~may. y a m W
%, 4 - -
' increase , even ? to ithef point 1where isuch c ack-r e e a tion:is:notireasonably possible'.
3x- . p.
p, <%; . _
- ~ , .. >
_3
~
1 WND' , 4 ',%+
Philadelph'ia . ElectficiCo. T (Limdrick ' Generatin.'g ~
i Station) LBP*l82- " ~
_g
,s , , ,
7 , d' ., b I g .T-
- 92A,jl6fNRC(1387p(1982). :Plantroperation , -
mayjwell cause7ans# T s - .
m
.h '
I " irretrievable and' irreversible? commitment" 'to t a paiticulaf,f a'n'df
- ,v needlessly r'. sky, plant design. ' ' ,
1 .. #7< '
+
<s 4 .
Thepublicacciden{ risk'fromoperationofLimerickexceeds-that .of any; fa'cility in the UnitedLStates 'with the .solelexception;' m.
of Indian ' Point in New ' York.c See NUREG--0974, . f Final rEnvironmental[
4 Statement' related' tio- the operation of the ~ Limerick Generating ' .
Station, pp.; 5-116_- 5-124.. .
Remedial risk-reductI6n measuresL
- unavailable at Indian - Point duc- to its history of plant operation may still be availableJfor Limerick.~ ~
?
.In addition', the'NEPA, APA, and regulatory vioIationalset,
~
forth'in: LEA's Brief,,unless' corrected prior to plant ~ operation, willi ,
firreparablyl harm LEA's interest in: lawful decision-making for
'the. Limerick ^ facility.
Harm'to'~Other Parties The granting'of: suspension will not harm the cognizable .
s m ?"-~ p( 3
_9-L u
. . . a
.- +
..3- .-
% s-I _,
~
s
~~
+( _
- a i
p =3 g, . g = 3_
- , n c - ;g. n y'vg<'
y& _ :. ~ - n; -
w' '
-& . - < - 1
~
Q:: ~ yh ? ,
, + di >
a ~
, -O ,e .
+
_s, ..
~ -
7q -
"g- :.g .
g-
- b y 3; -
_ s l 4 P'
,y k , e
'5 ,
< ' .-interests;of 'othertparties. . The_only/ party whoselintere'sts may1
~
4 < -
- reasonablyLbeisaid toibe}adversel/ affected byfsuch aLsusoensi5nt Yet the'oniv suchV interests ~ah d5'acteh, "
would beithe' Applicant. . .
are solely.. economic Lin' nature: - concerns .which,T as this1 Appeal '
~1 Board has~' expressly 1noted, are'"not withinLthe properfscope of' i~ssues litigatedLin NRC proceedings" ; Philadelphia:-Electrici
' Co. . (Limerick. Generating Station) - ASLB-789, - NRC. -(November ,
^
5~,11984), slip. of. p.-5l(rejecting.such~ concerns in'the. context; of a stay.of'a-license).
To the extentithat~such solely, economic-interests-are
~
- deemed cognizable, LEA submits that the: interest in the: health:
and safety of the public must-necessarily. outweigh the monetary!
and private interests of~the utility. Further,'suchLeconomic impacts to the utility are speculative at best,'becauseithe
~
ultimate full-power and.commerical operation of Limerick cannot now be presumed, in the face of extant challenges-to the adequacy of off-site emergency planning which remain to be litigated as Indeed, it would be arbitrary and capricious.fo'r th'e Commission to consider claims of economic harm to the utility caused by a licensing delay,'yet exclude claims of economic harm-to the rate-payers and the public occasioned by the licensing of a nuclear
~ facility, which like Limerick, the need for which is dubious at best. ~If the Appeal Board. intends to consider such claims of economic harm to the utility, LEA respectfully requests an oppor-tunity to set-forth the economic harm to its membership and the public resulting.from facility' licensing and operation. .
5 4
O . W L ^
y ~';,f> [ [;"}w.% g
, ; y -
jh W:
g . _ -cy, ,4. ; g, ,
y,
- e
}'; :% . . , .. '*
v
.. . sk ' '
l k
. . . ;.y m
- m.
7
? '-
s c,'4 o
- l wh .* s..~s -..b l
- m. S .: q# , 4 l * , -ib
-' ~ . .
, 4,] ~$y? -- ^
y r . '1 ~* - # 8
^
d'] ' +
% ;t
~
m, z .; ' ,ih" '-;-
q
(.1, n J
,1 up. , '
,- sic lM- $
m >
7 , ,
._, .. &^ r . + ,r3( ,
m p, ' , '
NY
~~
[hh e 2 ,
- i. --W .
~
- w. _ :- -
. . g . ,- 7' -
%q
' ~
i "
,34 } - '
i ,
- ;[ . ,, ;
ahco dition to[ full-powernoperation and}whosetoutcomelc'annot? ,
7 J .. * '
$ . +_..i~.'
.gr . . . ,
~
g.
n.d F ipermissibly'be~ prejudged. . Indeed~,zthe" Appeal) Board-hasspreciselyj u . ; . ., - -
~
- irejectediaTclaimJtihat evenithe' grantLoff a> low-power fli'censeibeginsi
~
L
%w m~ .
theJ" inexorable"Kprocess"to full-power licensure.-1 Philadelphia 7
.7 "
Electric ' Co 2 , ? stipra ,7 slip.' f oy , ip. [52 ' '
N
, x,
, . . c. - -
s The Public' Interest 4 -
'The~ requested suspension ~would. serve thelpubliclintere'st,' 1
- because Lit - (1) protects the public interest (in avoiding-undue risk 7
{innuclear'powerplantooperation; (2) permits time toffaislyjand' .
. comprehensively considor risk mitigation Taltornativos' ? (3) avoids ;
an !" irreversible ' and;irretriev'able commitment"5 t6 resources' :in . -
the= face of violations of National Environmental Policy-Acts'afe-- '
. guards; (4) . protectaithe public interest in principled and_ lawful" 3
decision making.
Wo' anticipate the Applicant's arguments thatitho public -
' interest would be disserved.by any asserted increased costs due :
to delay in testing and commerical operation. -Thoroforo,.wo reiterate the Appeal Board's-rejection of the'cognizability of
'"a nuclear plant's possible.effect on rates." Idj,. slip, o_p.:p.d5. '
- And,.in:any event, whether the Commission will authorize full power operation by such time so as to make the suspension' LEA -
l croquests a material' factor-in any delay of commerical operation-impacting rates is utterly speculative; even more.speculativeEis-k . )
J
. k.
w .
c.
w.
$g, y ,*,.,.,p y,. - , - - - .m , , , - ve-,,, .,,,re,.i.v ,g w-,.e. ,-%-e,,,-,--.--,rw-r~9 v % r- --w.,,...,yw ,c- , , . . , -e. + , . m .,-r,,,s*m+.
, e mp gy _
.e g, . r y
- s. , ,
+ . ,
c
/e n>
_y
, ' y , _ <
,; p,3 g.
- ,, ~ .~
vquy 7 .
. 7-.
. a.
p m_ , .
,e ,
n:, .m a ,.
, - .v.
w n . . : w;p &. . : ~. s;; .
+ -
2 "
.;; - - - 1 l n5 ?. " 9.,C, ,w'.
e e .' i b .
< '.y C l
. ~.m ; . ,
i .
NT ' . .y',
.f , i,\< $ , , ,
' j 4 g ,
O c; - ,
5-r . ,;.
s - ,
'^
im . , ,
y,_ , , l" !
sy ,
p;p
, , , , , , . , _3w ;
.( ,4 V \
(79 - f what ? a'ctual=: significant impact , J if t any ,'7 such a ; delay !mightJ '
g- x ,,
k *,~ '[actuallk hsvetupon rates -w-
'" ~
+
n . 7. .
y-1 '
g ,
. - - r
-b. factSthat contaminationLofs
{
~
. . iWhatLis not'-speculativetis the -
e .. _ , , m ~
i pla'nt'.csystems- by;;1ow-power. testing willt,make..desighichange i
- o-l . .. .. . , . . .
~ backfitting moreidangerous, ~more difficult,i.'andJ more1 expensive, -
p .
_and may thus; irrevocably shift'a Elose cost-benefitirStio;ag5 instr-2 3 F- riskKreduction'..
~
l- ~
- t. ,
t e i
' ^
For alllShese reasonsk Limerick Ecology: Action,;_i Incl' respect ~ ,
l ' -. - -
fully. requests this. Board.to_ suspend theJ ow-powerLlic' ens'e. granted.
- i. , -
1 3 ,
. , . s. .
to tho ApplicantSpending?:~ adjudication 6f; LEA's*appealion the' '
merits.
e l~ l.'.
t Charles W. .Elliott, Esquire, i-l_ 1101 Building' '
l
- Easton, PA ~18042 (215) .258-2374 Dated: . November 15, 1984 , _
4 i
i i
- p. , !
F
}"
. r I
l-i - -
6 --
m- -
hh "
- h. ; ~
afc i 2 gy :g m -v M+ % @ :ph @3 w p~ n
- n +
,1 ,
3;;
- - w m, - ' O
, . : :N -
N
~
w
._ q ; , ,a Q+ [.
} ;-{
r wm e >
~
9:.
, , , < _t
_n
((4' _ y ~ c ;
. g gm. v ,-
s ~. ,
e_ [ M ." y; y; ; u . ' -
P- - , ,
, , (, + '
+
- l. 9 g ., f ' -
_},.~~
, ,s f r y .
. _Q %_ , y a an
+ -
3 .
,g ,
^y '
" }- J ln . ,'
~
~ *
.c EUNITED1 STATES:OF' AMERICA' N,.
,u LNUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION!>. 'i ;
a, , f,,-
s( !
gjI ,,
. Y' , p .
4 4 '
R
- InLthe Matter? of..-
~
/ )) . "f ).
b= n- . .
W
. PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC; COMPANY) ) i L Docket 5Nos.D 50-352, J 50-353 '
L(
- ),
c , . < .- .. > . ' ,
- J _(Limerick Generating Station,
i ,
?) _
s tUnits;11and12) '
... F):
>n m
<< + -
7 o ,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
.. LI hereby certify _that copies ofl LEAfsi"Motionjfor Suspension- =
of Low-Power Facility. Operating License NPF-27" dated 1 November 15, o c _1984 in the'captionedLmatter-have been served;upon'theifollowing I by-deposit'in.the' United State's mail this 16th day-of November, l
1984:
z Christine N. Kohl, Esquire Dr. . Richard: F. Cole
~ Chairman,. Atomic Safety and Atomic Safety'and. ,
Licensing Appeal Board Licensing' Board . .
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory.
Commission Commission. . . , ,
Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C.. 20555 Gary J. Edles Dr.' Jerry. Harbour Atomic Safoty and Atomic,Safoty and
'Licensiny Appcal Board Licensing Board .
U.S. Nuclcar Regulatory U.S. Nuclcar Regulatory i commission Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555-Dr. Reginald L. Gotchy Atomic Safety and Licensing
' Atomic Safety and Appeal Board l Licensing Appeal. Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory; U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
,_ Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 l Washington, D.C. 20555 l Docketing and Service Section g l -Helen F. Hoyt, Esquire Office of the Secretary Chairperson :U.S. Nuclear Regulatory ,
- Atomic Safety and Commisasion l
l Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Washington, D.C. 20555 l-
!> . Commission '
b -
' Washington, D.C. 20555 r .
. +
{'- p 7
ym- ' W '"
) %.sK m :, '.
mt:
$((; m j '%. ~~_ F "
i ,
hh kpy kN} '
~
'~ ~
i; , ' , i q;j$, ,,s
, s Qf ^
(A fl l
,t' 3 . & y ' , "y' ~
g
~ f M;,
~
A l~ " X ; 13 3 f l, A
y' , * -jz- . -
, , - , ~
, ..,a
,c ;
'_yiLp + , "M,.m7(3'
}j%
.' y ys.
57" ~ Ey - .
c
~ , _ y __.
t.
- l; 3
,'g.
Y
7 ij
- .g ,_ ~ - , , ;
)w -+
, s ( s g . ; '*- , I
> b
[\
'N - '
[
u[ ::.1:;
M [ -5! g.
.w <
y J ,
. j! . .- + . . N
't , , t ' l +
' ~ '
< 4 1 An' n '.; P .i Hodgdon , ( Esq'uire ; / 'l- -Zori:G."Ferkin,;Esq._ - , .
+.
- L CounselT for NRC ' Staf f), '
? Assistant. Counsel '
-e Office'of:the Executive' <
fCommonwealthjof' Pennsylvania'. -
m~
-Legal: ' Director ' ..
Governor's Energy' Council ' '
'U.S;; Nuclear Regulatory'
?1625~N.aFront.Streeti M
,K %
~
- Commission 1 . Harrisburg,'PAil17102: <
Washington,fD.C. "
20555: ' .
4 iJay.M.sGutierrez,-Esq. ,
Troy:B.iConn'er,JJr. , , -U.S.-Nuclear:Regulatorys
. Conner.& Wetterhahni Commission'~ ' '
~
,1747~ Pennsylvania. Ave ,1N.W. -631 Park = Avenue . . .
cWashington,HD.C.:20006 King of Prussia,..PA:!19.406_
^
~ Atomic Safety?an Licensingi Angus Love'i1Esq..
' Board Panel., 107 East Main Street'.
U.S.: Nuclear' Regulatory.. Norristowni PA 19401. + '
Commission
.W ashington, D'.C. 20555 Robert J.,Sugarman,IEsq.1 ' '.
Sugarman,iDenworth &:
' Philadelphia Electric Company Hellegers ATTN: Edward G. Baueri-Jr.- 16th Floor, Center Plaza-Vice President & 101 North Broad Stroet' General Counsel Philadelphia, PA_:19107<
2301. Market Street Philadephia, PA 19101 Director, Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency Mr. Frank R. Romano- Basement, Transportation 61 Forest Avenue-Amblor, Ponnsylvania 19002 II$and.
rrinburg, SafetyPABuilding '17120 >
.. Mr. Robert L. Anthony. ' Martha W. Bushi Esq.
Friends of the Earth of. Kathryn S. Lewis, Esq.
the Delaware Valley City of Phi'ladelphia-106 Vernon Lane, Box 186 Municipal Services Bldg. ',
Moylan, Pennsylvania 19065-. 15th and'JFK Blvd.
- Philadelphia, PA 19107 Miss Phyllis Zitzer .
Limerick Ecology Action Spence W. Perry, Esq.
P.O.- Box'761 Associate General Counsel 762 Queen Street Federal Emergency .
'Pottstown, PA 19464 Management Agency 500 C-Street, S.W., Rm. 840 s s
- Washington, D.C.120472 s
~
,-D h $ '
~
Charles W. Elliott, Esq.
, ,~.
! P. 4
< - ; a ,
'j