ML20095D616
| ML20095D616 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 08/19/1984 |
| From: | Hoggard S TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20095D591 | List: |
| References | |
| OL-2, NUDOCS 8408230411 | |
| Download: ML20095D616 (10) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:!- {~V ._ Q j {~ 7 V . ., . .J,.. p -'
~ . c . . . , . i
. 1 _
< s '
s , 74,017 g - , s UNITED STATES"OF-AMERICI
'I L J
' 'I -
?."
1 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ^
..-( 2
^
M % ?; lBEFORE THE ATOMIC' SAFETY'&' LICENSING DOARD -
=- 3- .d i-'
m#-# - , ,. . .__. y.Z;
~
r k. < ~ 4 ;~ ,
..f
-- t 1 s
_.x. "..H r, .
- m n u na. 4 5' LIn IEhe.'_ Matte r of r ) i e.n v i,( , . q 's )s _
,y _
'6 TEXAS. UTILITIES]SLECTRIC.'
-) .
; COMPANY, et al ) Docket Nos.);50-445
'. /
^ f 7 .
) 50-446 ..
~
(Comanche' Peak Steam Electric () "' 8 Station, Units 11 and 2) ) . r
* (U 0 "% '
5 w, r x sg p% \ a 10 -
~ n
-:*. - s ;~ w . W,
~}
Bif 4. u' A : . 11 r s rr ,. S/ 112 . DEPOSITION - i, e.
-4
_ . hj j 4 13 - u- - op -
- n.
LO+ ~
. . .~ '14 9 : .
' SAMUEL HOGGARD o
. , .c t. 4
;< '15 -
~
- g. \
16 m , i7 ' DEPOSITION;of. SAMUEL HOGGARD, taken on-the ' ~ 18 19th: day of August, 1984, in the'above styled.~and . 19 numbered cause: at Glen-Rose Motor Inn,-ilocated at
,. '20 Hi<fhway 6 7 . & FM Road 201,;in the City of.; Glen. .
21 ' Rose, County of Somervell and State'of Texas .
- t22 before-Janes'Schaffer a-Certified'S horthand
'23 Reporter in and for the. State of. Texas.
t- -, , ~
-24
' ~
25 'B408230411 840821 .
' PDR ADOCK 05000445 ,
PDR b T , t I m - u; <
, YUUERAL COURT REPORTERS 3' '
DALLAS,. TEXAS ex a- . -
{$ .
~ "
c.-
- i
.y t. .
7 4 ,'0 1 8 3
' ;f , . t- e p
c 1 (APPEARANCES' ,- k,.. -
-L
's1
'N h /'
. "2 .
J3 .s ' C s ,' ,. BISHOP,ELIBERMAN,- C'00K PURCELLi & ,REYNOLDS:
' g-4 ' Attorneys'ati law 41200iSeventeenth' Street, Northwest-i # '5 ^
Was hingtion, D.-'C. 20036
. -By: Mr.-Bruce 1Downey '
j 3 , s .,
.a -
r m
~ '
7 , K> - 8 APPEARING FOR-APPLICANTS - 9 INDEX ,
~
.10 "
i
-11 EXHIBIT '
MARKED = 12 No: exhibits' marked ~ v.
.. 13 '
...p '
Af , t 14 MR. DOWNEY: This-is;the resumption
- 15 -of theTdepos'ition of Mr. SamueluHoggard, 16 H-o-g-g-a-r-d., -
Mr.' Hoggard testified ^ earlier in 17 this. proceeding ~ about-..certaiu matters relating to
'18 the saf ety apparatus on L the . rotatiing a platform '
T p 19 ' rail. The Applicant.has recalled /Mr.-Hoggard to
~ '
~
20 - testify -about certain: allega'tions miade by Robert
,21 Hamilton concerning-incidents'that-were alle_ged to
- .i; .
22 have' occurred-involving.Mr. John Moon'. , n-
-23 'I:will remind Mr. Hoggard thatthe?was a:
l _ 24 previously sworn as a' witness'in'this1 case and
'25 remaina.'under; oath. ,
4 c
' , b FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS 4
DALLAS, TEXAS ' i
, .. ,. .--.: . . - . . , . , . - a' . ... . _.
g, ~ . _ m . . . . . . . . - - . - - - 1
- t: . ~ .; .
. z-s ,
+"J.' o ,
.- 1. \
e
; :.y 3 . 7.4,019*
- Q m
,g -:,, ..
4(BY;iMR. DOWNEY) r1 . -Q./ xMr..Hoggardlin your' c , a .,3 2 ;
; earlier test'imony:you ind'icatedLthat you
< yf( [ j2 .
? ; .3 -supervised [the firstI aid'. activities oftthe site',
pm - J 4 ' i's t t h a t correct?- < _ e 1 a
.A(
- .5 .Yes, sir, itlis. -
x -, 16 Q. Mr. Hoggard, would you-please describe- .
,57
~.
- the first aidMfacilities at comanche Peak? .
M _ -_
- > .8 A. We-have.a firstraid treatment. facility'
.a ^
, 1
~
'9 ,which.Ilhave staffed with five medical personnel, f'
-?
. A ' '10 two of(whom'are registered nurses. The r e s t' 'a r e i
~
11 .! paramedics. Oil day shift-I haditwo-registeredE 12 nursess wh'o . aid ' a ; parame'dic. - There. are -.two - - e -
- 13 paramedics.at night.
7ff)- w_ f- _. :a a _
,During what hours is the firsti aid;" 7 c.
..l~ 4 2Q.'
~ ^
,, :: l5 ls't a tiod . ope'r able ? e
- 16 .
A.. First. aid atat' ion:is.:.open(24-hours afday. - t c.7 s m 17 ~~seven : days (a 4 we'ek. - , a e ..g. _ . .
-i" J18 Q. How long has it 'been open 24 hours a day -
- -19 ' sevenidays a. week? -
A.','Since the. onset =o'f the projact.
~
1;{ ' 20 1 f ~ 1 2 . _. . . b
. r21 ,Q.. Are any other' medical-facilitiesion'the .
d ( v j22 ,1 site other1than the.o'ne thatsyou supervise?: {} 4
.> 1.- -
i 23
, y ;A. . No,, sir. - ,
x m
!s ,
4g ,
!24 Q.', Mr. Hoggard,-~are;you(aware.ofzthe . .
12 5 1 allegations made by Robert-Hamilton concer'ning an
- m (t; , Y EUERA L .L G O U RT ..RE P ORTE RS '
y.- fo . DALLAS, TEXAS o - s
, n._'._ _,_,1 . .-
, . ., n -- -. . . -
r .. 74,020-N J )1 inspector named, John' Moon? .._
+
. ;'b!
. /^V :2 A. eyes ,' a i r , - I am. '--
A..e ,
-E ,
.3 Q. 'What isfyour understanding of Mr.~
J 4 . Hamilton's allegation? .
~
~5 :A. It's my. understanding.th'at Mr. Mo.on
~
.c 6 supposedly, received a chemical burn to.theiback ,
4 m*nr 7 side of his body and for'which he was reportedly 8 treated at'~the~first aid-facility;by job' site
'9 paramedics.
~ lb Q. Mr. Hoggard, have you reviewed lthe s -
>11 records of the medical facility at Comanche Peak' 12 Lo t determine whether Mr. Moon.was._ treated in,the
<,w 5 - ,13 ' 'way that Mr. Hamilton alleges?
h.))
~
I did reviewLthose' records'. 14 ,Yes, sir. f" .lf A.
. i 15 Q. And for what:. period of time did you.
.16 review the recordis? _
17 A. From February.1979 to- January :1982. . 11 8 Q. ,And what records did you review? 5.
~19 A. The' Drown & Root first aid ros'ter and ,
, 20 :also the OSHA Form 200.
w .
~ 21 'Q. Mr. Hoggard, what information.is 2'2 -maintained :on-'the Brown. & Root first aid ~rost'er? ,
- z23 A. Employee comes in, reports an injury.- 3 l I; 24 His name'is recorded, his' age, craft that.he works F1"') '.e. a25 for, his badge. number, what type of ' accident l
^
FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS DALLAS;: TEXAS '
- . ~ . -, . -- . . -
o :. ,
.74s021
, .1: ' occurred, type of.1.njury received, type-of~
d
.G 2 treatment received.-
And the medic or registered' , 3 . nurse that gives.the treatment initials at'the d
'4 end.
N ~
<5 Q. 'A'nd is this log maintained in any ,
6 chronological order?.
~7 ..
A. Yes,'it is. s. 8 Q. Are all first'ai'd; treatments recorded on s . 19 i this log? m,
-10 A. Basically, yes. We don!t record just a 111 common'. eye flush, someone comes in with dust in
~
12
~
Lthe : eye, 'somethinglike that. We don't record' 13 those, 'If there 's something! in :the eye tliat t h'a y' b~ ,
+
14 have to.go.to'a physician to remove, then that is , 1
.But basically, it's basic first aid
'15 recorded.
16 treatment-that-is recorded. 17 Q'. And would'that include.the ' recording.of Ia
- [3 18 any chemical burns'treatedmat the facility?
- 1. .
'19 . A. Yes, sir. y
~
~20 Q .' -In reviewing the first-aid log for'the.
- 21 period ~ February >l979 through: January ofc1982, did
, 22 you find any recordiof'Mr. Moon being treated at-9' 23 the-facility? 3..
- 1) -
2.4 /A. . No,. sir, found.no record at all.
': 0 .
G 25 Q. Mr. Hoggard,-you testified.that you;also 3 a. 4 + rEasuaL c0URT REPORTERS.
; DALLAS, TEXAS ' -1 g
, y j. - _- - - [ x.7 w , t 3 n . . i 7 4 ,~0 2 2 1 Trevi'ewed the OSHA Form 200's, is that correct? , 4 fy. ,p .2 A. . Yes,. sir, I did. y. s 3 What;information,is maintained on thos. LQl. . . w > . 4 records? .,c LS
'A . , OSHA Form 200 is'requ' ired by
.x .
1 6 'O c'c u p a t i o n a l . S a f a t'y and. Health Administration. . . On 7 that log.are named those. people that are sent to "8 the physician for medical' treatment beyond firsts
~9 aid treatment. It-also has a specific area where .
10 you log if'it wasfa chemical burn:or'if it was ,
- 11 exposure for chemicals causing" occupational 12 1111 ness.or injury. <.
13[ Q. -And: doe's-the site have a policy , xj ' . 14 concerning referral of employees to physicians-15- when the employe'freceives e a'. chemical burn? -
~
- r 16 A.' Yes,. air.
If it.'sLa chemical burn'that:
+ , ,
J17 -i s in'a tender area of the skin, an uncovered
.,? w portion;of.the. body, 13 it covers;an areafsuch as 18 "19 full' arm,. full hand, full back side, buttocks #
~
20 area, somethinglof that nature,ithey;wil'1 be
. .21 referred to a qualified' physician. -
I , 22 -
.Q. Now,'is that especially true ~in the case -
23 of a second' degree burn on these areas? v , 24 A. Yes. p
,d .25 Q. 'In your review.of OSHA Form 200,-did you
' FEDERAL CDURT.REFORTERS ,
_ DALLAS, TSXAS
~ ' - -
f3 .. ; "- r y 4
= ;< -
s ut -
" 7.4 , 0 2 3- 1
+
o h -3 ' g; y r
'N.', e Y 41 7
find any indication" that -Mr.J M'oon h'ad been treated
-[
- , s 9 <
[] y 2 Jforechemical burnfat congacheJPe'ak,during
?
t'he , u.' ' 3 ::peridd February [479 through Ja'nuary 19827_
~
7- ~ s b . p
=
-4 lA. .. N o ',
sir,. I found no. record of such 7
- a-3 .
5/ reporte'dLinjury.- , o -
. ~ Bas.edion your.. review'of the records'ofi 4 . . .
6 .
,, -Q.. ? #
.# , t, s ,
. m - 7 f the medica,.l f acilities at ComancheJPeali,- havaiyou -
,, ~)
- - '8 Jformed a: judgment'about whether Mr. Moon was 4 .,
1
~
.v
- 9 treated for.'a. chemical burn.during-the period l e f -10 : February-197.9^through January 1982? .
m -
- t. - [11 ~A '.
- Yes, sir,sI have.
^
c 12 .Q. ~ And what!s your judgment on this matter?
~ ,
e - 13 JA. In myjjudgment,/.Mr. Moon did not report- *
. Q..
v > 14 !any such;juziy to theJfirst-aid facility or[the i job 15 shtemedic's;.th'erefore,hewasnot treated for 16 iisuch 'inj u ry. - . - I "
+ < -
7 , , j e .17 - 3 .'y - c. t s
# 18 .-
n a.
.t -
19
~
w i; . ,
. 20 I, SAMUEL HOGGARD,1ha*Je read:the foregoing ~ .c' -
k; . ,1~ . e e - , 21 depositiondand hereby affix my signature thatosame ' ' ' 4
- 22 - 'is/true and correct, except as noted herein. w 1'
- 23 '
z_ _' 'L.-
~
e .l ^
- 24 ' '
~
l; y ; .x , fif ' -- 25 i
- SAMUEL HOGGARD.'.-
g P y I E
',h ',
2
, FEDERAL 4.GOURT.RSPORTERS ,,
J
+" '
g' '
.i ,
- g. 2~ DALLAS,fTEXAS' ,
y_ . y . e '
. m ,
-74V024
. ;.=
1 . -
? * .
N
. 2
- r;\% )!- '
r'.,e . 0: "3 . SUBSCRIBED;-AND" SWORN-to"before me this'the~
- 3 1s 3- ~
4- ' day;of ,.198.4. 5
~
n ,, , .
- s 7 ^
HOTARY PUBLIC{IN AND FOR THE
'[ ' STATE:OF' TEXAS 8
a n :, 9
' ~
. : 10 Mp commission expires: _ ,
. 11
-12 13
-; s_) . t 14 ,
n ;
'~
15 , s 16 . 17 . 18
-19 t - -
+ -
20 , 21 , . p 22 ,
.?
23 ' m s 24 '
~
,q,
! ( . .
;xJ ' '25
.o s v i ,
s
., , rsDERKL COURT REPORTERS 4
-No
& DALLAS, TEXAS' '
s, , ,
"a a -. ..- --
;w , ,-
pq s ' r 4
.. g ;
s , ,
,g
- y? ,. y ; ,
.M-
* "~~ -
7,4 , 0 2 5l [
,4 m. - - - - -
e .
. :.ye fy *1 4
-STATE- OF TEXAS.
~
- ) *
,i n.' s CA[ %f
- '2 :
COUNTY ~dP DALLAS-
')
W ' 3 '
' 1 4 >
I,; Janet Schaffer,s RPR,> Certified -
- Shorthand' Reporter inland?for.:th'e, State.of Texas,.
~
f'. - ' 5 r - s.. . 7 -
.& e
[do1hereby certify'that"there came^before me on the c6 s
!' 19th[ day of August, A. D.,J1984,-at the Glen Rose 7
8 (Motor u I'n', Glen R'ose,' Texas, the following~ named . e . . f9 person,,to-wit: SAMUEL HOGGARD, who was-byfme-duly zl0 - sworn to testify.the truth ^and nothing but thel g ( 11 . truth of his knowledge touching andsconcerning the , m , - Y . 12 .' matters-in controversy-in this causes and-that he H
..~ ,13 Lwas thereupon examined'upon hisicath'and his- ,
.'14 ,"examinationLreduced:to writing undersay; t c ,
7 -
- 15 -s'uphrvisions:same to be.swornJto'and L
.s subscribed:-by: -
i 16 g said<witnessobefore any' Notary'Public. _
~
e <. . N ,
'17 >
g - , [ 18 'I f 6rtiher.. certify /that I am neither
~
k 19 ; attorney;or.' counsel;for,..nor related5to or . 20 employedrby, any of the. parties toftheTac, tion.in ,
- n. . ,
l 21 ,wh'ich this deposition is taken, and further that
~
I. i
- 7g , .t. - c. >
.22 - am1not a= relative or employee ~of 7any. attorney or v
-{,2 3 -
Jcounsel. employed by the parties hereto,~or ; 424 lfinanciallylinterested in the action.
- V}} L c -
-- 2 5 8
+
_, 7 s . , s FEDERlkL COURT-REPORTERS. , ,
"7 DALLAS,: TEXAS '
~
[ ,
~ ^ '
. , . . - . 3- ,
n- . -
~ - - -
p:.
- n , , ,a
<, - -m -
s s 2 '. ... , , ,. . :n a. 74,026 ,
't.n
,4
- n j
+. ~c_ -
')'
j f J'
..g
,r y .
*. ~ . . , TM5 -
.,-A- - - ,.
gw- n , 1EA 3:l i 6 - " In wit'ne"ss?whereofisI have' hereunto. set' . 4# ., . G. - l .-. r.y,;. ' / * ' - 2
': m y L h a n d ; a. .n.id. -a f f i x e d m y .s'e a l ~this 19th: day of-K. ,7. 4 '-3 s . .... ..
. ., s A-s 53 LAugus t ,\A.Dy,.
~19 84. .
%, m - -
r - o - - , - - .. . -n . e4 " w, y ->; ., .. -
* ^
l* ,s lw. :;5
.w ;
License ~-Expires -X.- - g- -
. t e
. -y.
.' f' . 'f '
_ :6 LDecember"31,J1984: ~
"; ^6
'CSRLNo..1543'
[- i ' " ~ JANET SCHAFFER,. RPR,- CSR' '
.7
~
~
. ,I N.' A N D ' F O R . T H E - S T A T E - 0 F ' T E X A S'
~8
?
l226" Commerce, Suite'411 l1 e
, :* :: + :
~
, -> .'D a l l a s , Texas- 75202:
(214) 742-3035:
^
1 9 - s , y V 10 ;
- ' ~
. . . c.
j e 12 a
- . e ~13 + , f()l .e _
e a .
.n v 4 x -, -
14
. i
'15 g, ,
16 .. . 1. j -.
~
^
< - 17 . .
< 1 - p r
~
+
18 . i . .~ m ., o 4 iv j 19 , i . . . I E x 20 *
. L'
, y .
*> , 8 > *
^
- m. < ;21 o a >
- i. .
+
- n. "
+
c 7 22 . o - 23 ' s 2-24 . b s i25 ' 2 1 9 i 7 4
, FEDERAla COURT REPORTERS
. ' , '. ,. ..JDALLAS, TEXAS '
-" ~ ' ~
.. _ , - - . . .}}