ML20092G807
| ML20092G807 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Beaver Valley |
| Issue date: | 06/15/1984 |
| From: | Woolever E DUQUESNE LIGHT CO. |
| To: | Knighton G Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| 2NRC-4-083, 2NRC-4-83, NUDOCS 8406250243 | |
| Download: ML20092G807 (10) | |
Text
,I 2NRC-4-083 (412) 787 - 5141 (412)923 - 1960 Telecopy (412) 787-2629 June 15, 1984 Nuclear Construction 0lvision Robinson Plaza, Building 2, Suite 210 Pittsburgh, PA 15205 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 ATTENTION:
Mr. George W. Knighton, Chie f Licensing Branch 3 Of fice of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
Beaver Valley Power Station - Unit No. 2 Do cke t No. 50-412 S.E.R. Outstanding Issues Status Gentlemen:
At t achment 1 is a current li s t, as of June 1,1984, s ich provides our unde rs t anding of out s t anding issues ident ified in Table 1.2 of the draf t Safety Evaluation Report. At tachment 2 is a current list, as of June 1,1984, dich provides our unders tanding of confirmatory issues ide nt if ied in Table 1.3 of the draft Safety Evaluation Report.
It ems ide nt ified as are those for which res ponses have been provided and no confir-
"c omple t e" mation of status has yet been received fr om the staff.
We cons ider these items satis factorily closed unless not ified otherwise.
In orde r to pennit "c cxnple t e" which may not be t imely resolut io n of items ide nt ified as resolved to the staf f's satis faction, please provide a specific description of the issue which remains to be reso lved.
Items ident ified as "c los ed" or "c onf irma to ry" are based upo n formal or informal communic a t ions or agr eeme nt s with the staf f.
Ple ase inform us of any dif fe ring opinion of status desc ribed on the att ach ed list.
At t achment 3 is a current list, as of June 1, 1984, d ich ide nt i-fies draft SER sections not pr ov ided in the March 1,
1984, issue of the draf t SER.
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY By E. J f Woolever Vice President GLB/wjs At t achment Mr. H. R. Denton, Director NRR (w/a) cc:
Mr. D. Eisenhut, Director Division of Licensing (w/a)
Mr. T. Novak, Assistant Director Division of Licensing (w/a)
Mr. G. Walton, NRC Res ident Inspector (w/a)
Mr. M. Licitra, Project Manager (w/a) 8406250243 840615 f
{DRADOCK 05000412 PDR 0p1 a
n AT1AQ M NT 1 CUISTMOItG ISSLES Pf0EOSED OUISTMOI!C RESPO!EE ISSUE SUBJECT DA1E STAIUS IErIER NO. AND DATE 1
Ibtertial for floodirg fran local irreme precipittion 1
2 Flooding fran Peggs Rm 1
3 Alequacy of the Iroposed tech spec for drought conditions 4/30/%
Canplete 2tR04-0@, 4/30/M 4
Mequacy of inthe structure silt monitorirg prcgran 4/30/%
O2nplete 2?RCr4-0@, 4/30/%
5 Botniaries of the Appalachian Platea2 Tectonic Prcvince 4/30/%
02nplete 2tRO-4-048, 4/27/%
6 Matiman eartiquake 4/30/%
Canplete 2 FRO-4-048, 4/27/M 2NR04-072, 6/1/%
7
&amd notion tAirg soil propertis into consideration 4/30/M Canplete 2?RC-44)48
/84 2fRCr4-072 84 8
Actual eartiqmke tine historis 4/30/M O2nplete 2 FRO-4-048 4/27/%
2NRO-4-072,, 6/1/M 9
Shallow earthquakes 4/30/%
Cmplete 2tRC-4-048, 4/27/84 10 Ver;ical seismic design accelerations 4/30/%
Omnplete 2 FRO-4-048, 4/27/M 2NRO-4-072, 6/1/M 11 Tbrnado pressure drop rate calculations 4/30/M Cmplete 2tRC-4-047, 4/27/84 12 Q)ncrete missile barrier design Qmplete 2!Rcr4-018, 2/27/%
13 Site-specific reponse spectra 4/30/%
Omnplete 2?RG 4-047 4/27/%
2NRO-4-072,, 6/1/M 14 Justification of red spreafirg of floor response spectra Osnplete 2tRO-4-018, 2/27/M 15 3-canponert seismic irpte vs. 2-conponert tupte 6/15/M 16 Soil-structure irtera tion analysis of con-tairmert ani inthe structure 6/15/%
17 Significance of the couplitg in structural response between mutually orthogpnal axes of structures 6/15/M 18 Deviations of cortainnet design fran A91E Code Section III Division 2 6/15/M 19 Ultimate capacity analysis of containrent 6/15/%
20 Dviatiors fran regtdrenets of ACI 349 code as a2grnertal by Reg. 02ide 1.142 4/27/%
Canplete 2fR04-047, 4/27/%
21 Structural a2dit action itens 4/27/M Cmplete 2fRC-4-047, 4/27/M 22 Affects of cracled panel on dynanic sodelirg ani design Q2nplete 2rRO 4-018, 2/27/M 23 Alegtacy of re-assessed safety factors against slidirg and overturning of contain-nurt, a2x. buildirg, ani irt&e structure 4/30/M 02nplete 2rRCr4-047, 4/27/%
(
IHOPOSB)
ORSTRODU RESIGEE ISSJE SURIECT DATE STATUS IETIER NO. NO DATE 24 1hrougM1 leakage cra:ks in moderate energy lins in cotainnert 5/15/M C1med 2m04-4052, 5/8/84 25 Selection of postulated break locations 5/ 15/84 Closed 2mC-4-4052, 5/8/%
26 Jet inpirgement ef fects 6/29/%
2 2mo-4-4052, 5/8/%
27 Break exclusion zones 5/15/84 03nfirmatory 2mC-4-4052, 5/8/84 28 Pipe-to pipe inpact 5/15/84 Canplete 2m04-4052, 5/8/M 29 Limited bre A areas 5/ 15/84 Closal 2mC-4-4052, 5/8/%
30 Saturatsi or subcooled water blowbun 5/15/%
Closed 2mer4-4052, 5/8/84 31 Design of pipe rupture restraints 5/15/%
Closed 2mC-4-4052, 5/8/M 32 List of transierts 5/15/%
Closai 220-4-4052, 5/8/%
33 location of systens to be nonitoral dtrirg prm testirg 6/01/%
Closed 2mcr4-4052, 5/8/84 34 Criteria used for detenninirg ac ptbility of vibration levels 5/04/84 C1med 2m04-4052, 5/8/%
35 Vibration nonitoring progran 5/04/84 Clossi 2mC-44052, 5/8/84 36 Canbinirg 3 conponerts of earthqtate notion 5/04/%
Canplete 2mo-4-4052, 5/8/%
37 Modes included in seismic analyses 5/15/84 Clossi 2mC-4-4052, 5/8/84 38 Denonstratirg seismic qtalification 5/15/%
C1 al 2m04-4052, 5/8/%
39 loadits carbinatiors, systen operatirg tran-sierts, an! stress Itmits 5/15/%
2 2 2 0-4-4052, 5/8/84 40 HVAC systen design 5/15/M 2
2mC-44052, 5/8/84 41 Design of safety ani relief valves 5/15/%
C1 ed 2m04-4052, 5/8/%
42 Design ani construction of NNE Class 1, 2, ani 3 canponert support 5/15/%
Canplete 2mC4-4052, 5/8/%
43 Preservice ani irservice testirg of ptmps ani valves a-6/84 2
2mC-44052, 5/8/84 b-1 %
c--6 85 44 Effects of rod bow on DNB 6/29/M 45 Flow measurenert capability ard procedure 6/29/84 46 loose parts detection progran report 6/29/84 47 Ibetanertation of conplete ICC systen 6/29/%
48 Preservice inspections progran a--6/84 49 Oxopliarre with Appenlix G 10CFR Part 50 6/29/84 Canplete 2m04-0@, 4/30/%
50 Canpliance with Appeniix H 10CFR Part 50 4/30/84 Ccurplete 2mC-4-049, 4/30/%
51 Pressure tsoperature limits 4/30/%
Qinplete 2m04-0@, 4/30/%
52 3
53 0)ntrol roon h4iteility 6/01/84 L
r PIOPOSID OUISTM 01tC RESPOPEE ISRE SUBJECT DATE STATUS IEr1ER NO. NO DAIE 54 Inservice impection of Class 2 ard 3 caponents a--6 84 c-6 85 55 Design modification for aitamatic rextor trip 02nplete 2tRO-4-033, 3/30/84 56 Anticipatory reactor trip on turbine trip 5/25/M 57 P4 interlock Qinplete 220-4-O'B, 4/10/84 58 1hdetectale failure in online testirg cir-cuitry for ergineered safeguards relays 6/29/84 59 Service water systen isolation on low healer pressure 5/31/84 60 tbnnal letdom line relief valve 5/25/84 61 Switchover fran injection to recirculation 5/11/M Qinplete 2tR04-056, 5/14/&
62 Main feedwater isolation 5/25/84 63 Grtrol roon isolation 6/ 29 /84 64 Stean generator level control and protection Canplete 2tRC-4 032, 3/2/84 65 IE Bulletin 80-06 conmrm 6/29/84 66 Indeperrien between marual ani aitanatic action 6/29/M 67 lbwer lockout for motor-operated valves Carplete 2tRC-4-032, 3/2/84 68 lbnote slutdom capability 5/25/84 69 anergncy response capability 5
70 Direct irrlication of relief arti safety valve positiom 5/18/84 71 Bypass arx! inoper a le status panel 5/25/84 72 IE Bulletin 79-27 5/25/84 73 ketor coolart systen loop isolation irter-locks 6/29/M 74 Primxy canp>nert coolirg water is)1ation fran FG' thermal bariers 6/29/84 PID contr ller modification 6/29/84 75 o
r y line breds ani conseqmrtial 76 111gh ens a control efsten failurs 4/27/84 02nplete 2tRO-4-Oz0, 4/30/M 77 0)rtrol systan failure caused by malfmetiom of cannon power source or imtrtunert line 5/25/84 78 Procedure to estimate extent of core danage Canplete 2tRC-4-042, 4/18/84 79 Backup post accidert sapliry ttrougi gra amples for inline analyses Qinplete 2tR04-042, 4/18/M 80 Measurirg radionuclide concentrations Canplete 2tRC-4-042, 4/18/84 81 Perfonnance of PASS imtrunertation ard analytical procedure Qxnplete 2tRO-4-042, 4/18/M L
4-1%DPOSED CUISDidOIM; RESIDEE ISSUE fUBJECT DATE STATUS IETIER NO. AND DATE 82 Fire hazards analysis 5/15/84 mnfinnatory 2mC-4-063, 5/23/%
83 Fire brigade 5/15/M mnfinnatory 2m04-063, 5/23/%
84 Penetration seals 5/15/M Closed 2mC-4-063, 5/23/%
85 Safe slutdown 5
86 Alternate shutdown 5
87 Hydecgen pipirs 5/15/84 5
2m04-063, 5/23/%
88 Csle tray suppression 5/15/84 Closed 2mC-4-063, 5/23/84 89 lbwer supplis for comrol roan vertilation 5/15/M 5
2m0-4-063, 5/2VM 90 Fire detection 5/15/84 Confinnatory 2mC-4-063, 5/23/%
5/15/%
C1med 2mC-4-063, 5/23/%
91 Valve supervision 92 Ika: tor coolart peps ard separation of safety-related canponerts in containnett 5/ 15/84 Confinnatory 2m04-063, 5/23/M 93 control rocin emplex 5/15/M mnfinnatory 2mC-4-063, 5/23/%
94 Chle sprealirs roon 5/15/%
5 2m04-063, 5/23/M 95 Exemption to 10CFR 70.24(a) ani description of alternative to required criticality nonitors 6/01/%
6 96 Types, nebers, specificatiam for port &le ard laboratnry HP instrtunerts 5/15/%
6 97 1rainirg/retrainig for health physics gro-fessionals and vertfication that contractor trainirg ineets 10CIR 19.12 requirenerts 6
98 Procedures generation package /1MI I.C.1, short-teun tcident analysis and procedures revision 7
99 Ihysical security 5/ 16/84 Complete 2mC-4-051, 5/04/84 10 0 Initial test pecgran 5/30/M 101 Radiological consequences of cootrol rod ejectton DM 5
102 Rsliological conceqtences of a small line brei DM 5/15/84 103 Raliological consequences of a stean genera-tor tube rupture DM ard review of operator actions arti systen perfonnance 6/29/M 104 Raliological conseqtences of a steanline breA oteside seconiary containnert 5
105 Radiological consequences of a loss of coolart DM 5
1%
Radiological comeqtenms of a ftel hanilirg DM 5
107 3
108 3
109 3
L
4-Iwn)SID OUISTM: DING RESIO!EE ISSUE SURIECT DATE STATUS IEITER NO. NO DATE 110 3
111 3
112 Tectnical specifications 8
1D Detailed control roon chsign re/iew 6/01/85 114
. Safety paraieter display systen 8/01/M 115 Sncnpack load on roofs 6/29/%
116 Extrane temperatures for site area 6/3/84 1 17 Affects of relocation of met. tower 6/29/84 118 Iorg term diffusion estimates 6/ 29/84 119 Deviations to R.G.1.52 6/29/84 120 03rtainnert va uun systen exhanst iodine reirwal capability 6/29/84 121 Evaluation of 16ET failure 5
122 Water ledcage irto safety-relatsi equipnert cubicles 123
'Ibstirs of ftnctional capability for water-tight seals 124 Accessibility of intdce structure for safe stutdown 125 Adequacy of water stops for construction jotrts 126 Floodirg due to failure of non-seismic Catgory 1 equipmert 127 Fan blade missile 128 Missile barrier for turbine driven aixiliary fea! water punp missiles 129 Pressurized container missiles D0 Ibmperature ani pressure sersor missiles 131 lbrnsio missile protection for aixiliary buildirg 132 lbrnalo missile protection of main stean vert panels D3 Postulated pipe breaks oteside containment
'D4 Fuel pool maciman heat loads 135 Light loal harriling systen 136 Han11irg of heavy loads 137 Marine growth in standby service water systen 138 Verification of instrtnert air quality in caigressed air systens 139 Equipent arul floor drainage systen 14 0 Conformance with Regulatory Qaide 1.95 L
4-PRDPOSID OUISTROI!C RESIO!EE ISSUE SUBIECT DATE SIAIUS IETIER 10. NO DAE 141 0)nfonnance with Regulatory Guide 1.78 14 2 Seismic Catqory 1 requirenetts for can-pressed air systen 14 3 Bwitanne:tal qtalification ard a:oessibility of essential equipnent haussi in fuel buildirg 14 4 Safety classification of motor carrol certers 14 5 Air exhaust rafiological nonitoring systen 146 Protection of energency switchgear roan vertilation systen 147 Supplerettary le* collection ard releme systen requirenerts for safe slutdows 148 Water hanner test of condensate and fea! water systen 149 Auxiliary feedwater system, 'IMI Itsu II.E.1.1 15 0 Seismic qtalification of equipmert 151 Ptnp and valve operability assurance progran 15 2 Bwirornertal qualification of equipmert 153 Analysis of ccabined 10CA azul seianic loads 154 lbstirg ard irspection of new ftel 15 5 01-line detection metind to nonitor ftel rai failures 156 thderclat cra kirs of forgirgs in rea tor vessel 157 Review of structare, systens, ard conponerts under Quality Asa2rance Prcgran 158 luy setpoint values 159 HIR operation ratuirenerts outside cortrol roor 160 RHR overpressure protection systen 161 Q2alification of RHR ptnps inside catainnert 162 Natural circulation test 163 Prcgrams arti procedtres for catainnert step operation 164 Review of off-site eneryncy plans (FM%)
16 5 01-site ene gerry plannirg L
IE ES:
ICurrently evaluating letter fra T. M. Nwak to E. J. Woolever dated April 11, 1984 2Supplanertal submittal to be prorided 3Not provided in draft SER OFirtler resoittion beirg discussed infonnally SStaff action only 6msponses informally trwided ard accepted at RAB meetirs (5/1/84) 7tb response required 81XC is ctrrertly arrargirg a mantgenert medits with IRC to discuss this its PIOGRM PIO DURES KR VALVES & PUtfS c SI PIOGRM I
L
i ATDOMNr 2 GNFIIM@RY ISSLES OUISINOi!C ISSUE SUlUECT STA1US IETIER 10. NO DAIE 2RO-4-072, 4/27 /84 1
Operatiry basis earthqtake O'tglet e 3RO-4-047,6/1/84 2
Stress and strain levels of key structural etaients ccuplete 2fRC-4-047, 4/27/84 3
Floor remporne spectra accomtits for 3-crmponeit' earth-qtake irpte 4
5 Buanination of stean generators 6
7 Main IW isolation 8
CR isolation on high radiation sigial 9
kromatic openirs of service water systen valves 10 Accident monitorirg instrtmentation positions 11 (bid leg acctmulator MN position inlication 12 Table 1.9-2 by prodtet, source, ani special ruclear material descriptions nine months prior to fuel loaliru Q471.14b 13 Verification that cobalt use in primary systen has teen minimized Q471.10 14 0xtainnert h rarge raliation nonitors six nonths prior to ftel irg Q471.14a 15 Verify that INS airborne radioactivity nonitors 16 Qaality asaranm pecgran requirenerts 17 pea pellet design basis 18 Specification of ftel parameters 19 Rod bowiru analysis 20 Fuel rad irternal preare 21 Claiding collapse time 22 the of alstenitic stainlesa eteels i
l
- the provided in Draft SER l
l
f l
l
.+
ArDOHNr 3 L
IIIAFT SER SECTIONi Am I*lES 190VI!ED l
Section.
Date Section Date Section Date Section Date asction Date i
2.1.1 5.2.1 8.4.8 10.4.7 05/22/84 15.3.3 2.1.2 5.2.2 06/01/E 9.1.1 05/22/84 10.4.9 05/22/M 15.3.4 2.1.3 5.2.3 06/01/E 9.1.4 05/22/84 11 05/04/84 15.4.5 2.1.4 5.2.5 05/22/M 9.1.5 05/22/E 11.1 05/04/M 15.4. 6 I
2.2.1 5.4.1 9.2.1 05/22/M 11.1.2 15.5.1 f
2.2.2 y/
5.4.7 06/01/84 9.2.0 05/22/M 11.2.1 05/04/M 15.5. 2 l
2.2.3 5.4.11 05/22/E 9.2.3 05/22/M 11.2.2 05/04/E 15.7.1 2.3.1 05/04/84 6.2.1-9.2.4 05/22/84 11.3.1 05/04/M 5.7.2 2.3.2 05/04/04 6.2.2
- 9. 2.5 05/22/84 11.3.2 05/04/M 15.7.3 05/04/E 2.3.3 05/04/E 6.2.3 9.2.6 05/22/84 11.3.3 05/04/M 15.9. 1
.f 2.3.4 05/04/84 6.2.4 9.3.1 05/22/M 11.4.1 15.9.2 2.3.5 05/04/84 6.2.5 9.3.3 05/22/84 11.4.2 15.9. 3
[ 2.4.13 6.2.6 9.4.1 05/22/84 11.5.1 05/04/84 15.9.4 2.5.4 6.3.1 06/01/84 9.4.2 05/22/84 11.5.2 05/04/M 15. 9. 5 2.5.5 6.3.2 06/01/M 9.4.3 05/22/84 13.1.1 13.9.6 2.5.6 6.3.3 06/01/E 9.4.4 05/22/M U.1.2 15.9.7 3.2.1 6.3.4 06/01/E 9.4.5 05/22/h 13.3.1 06/01/84 15.9.8 3.2.2 6.3.5 06/01/84 9.4.6 05/22/M D.3.2 06/01/E 15.9.9 l
3.4.1 05/22/84 6.3.6 06/01/84 9.5.2 13.4 15.9.10 3.5.1 05/22/84 6.5.1 05/04/E 9.5.3 0.5.1 15.9. 1 1 l
3.5.2 05/22/E '
6.5.3 9.5.4 15.1.2 15.9.12 l
l 3.6.1 05/22/E 8.2.1 9.5.5 15.1.3 15.9. D 3.10.1 05/18/84 8.2.2 9.5.6 15.1.4 15.9. 14 I
3.10.2 05/18/84 8.2.3 9.5.7 15.1.5 17.1 06/01/84 l
3.11.1 05/18/84 8.2.4 9.5.8 15.2.1 17.2 06/01/84 l
3.11.2 05/18/84 8.3.1 10.2.3 15.2.2 17. 3 06/01/84 j
3.11.3 05/18/84 8.3.2 10.3.1 15.2.3 17.4 06/01/M 4.2.1 06/01/04 8.4.1 10. 3.2 15.2.4 19 4.2.2 06/01/84 8.4.2 10.3.6 06/01/84 15.2.5 20 4.2.3 06/01/04 8.4.3 10.4.1 15. 2.6 21
,.~4.2.4 06/01/84 8.4.4 10.4.2 05/04/84 15.2.7 22.1-i
['4.2.5 06/01/E 8.4.5 10.4.3 05/04/84 15. 2.8 22.2 4.5.1 06/01/84 8.4.6 10.4.4 15.3.1 22.3 4.5.2 06/01/84 8.4.7 10.4.5 05/22/84 15. 3. 2 23 i
I
?
__