ML20090L110
| ML20090L110 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Beaver Valley |
| Issue date: | 05/22/1984 |
| From: | Woolever E DUQUESNE LIGHT CO. |
| To: | Knighton G Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| 2NRC-4-061, 2NRC-4-61, NUDOCS 8405250121 | |
| Download: ML20090L110 (8) | |
Text
.
2NRC-4-061 (412) 787 - 5141 (412J 923-1960 Telecopy (412) 787-2629 Nuclear Construction Division May 22, 1984 Robinson Plaza, Building 2, Suite 210 Pittsburgh, PA 15205 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 ATTENTION:
Mr. George W. Knighton, Chief Licensing Branch 3 Of fice of Nuclear Re::ctor Regulation
SUBJECT:
Beaver Valley Power Station - Unit No. 2 Do cke t No. 50-412 S.E.R. Outstanding Issues Status Gentlemen:
At t achment 1 is a current li s t, as of May 15, 1984, which provides our unde rs t and ing of out s t and ing issues ide nt if ied in. Tab le 12 of the draft Safety Evaluation Report.
At t achment 2 is a current lis t, as of May 15, 1984. which provides our unde rs t and ing of confirmatory issues ide nt i-fied in Table 1.3 of the draf t Safety Evaluation Report.
It ems ide nt ified as " complete" are those fo r wh ich res pons es have been pr ov ided arri no confirmation of status has yet been received from the staff.
We cons ider these items satis factorily closed unless not ified otherwise.
In order to permit timely resolution of items identified as " complete" which may not be resolved to the staf f's satisfaction, please provide a specific description of the issue which remains to be resolved.
Items ident ified as "c los ed" or "c onfirmato ry" are based upo n formal or informal communications or agreement s with the staff.
Ple ase info rm us of any - dif fering opinion of st atu s desc ribed on the at t ach ed list.
At tachment 3 is a current list, as of May 15, 19 84, wh ich ident i-fies draft SER sections not provided in the March 1,
19 84, issue of the draft SER.
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY
[
. By O f
'E. /J. 9foolever Vive President GLB/wjs At tachment cc:
Mr. H. R. Denton, Director NRR (w/a)
Mr. D. Eisenhat, Director Division of Licensing (w/a)
Mr. T. Novak, Assistant Director Division of Licensing (w/a)
Mr. G. Walton, NRC. Resident Inspector (w/a) o Mr. M. Licitra, Project Manager (w/a) 8405250121 840522 PDR ADOCK 05000412 1
.E.
1 AITAQ M NT 1 OtJISTANDIE ISSIES PHOPOSID OUISTANDIE RESIDEE IS9JE SUlUFLT DATE STA1US IEIV R NO. AND DATE 1
lbteitial for floalirg fran local irteme precipitation 1
2 Flooding fran Peggs Rtn 1
3 Mequacy of tic proposal tech syc for drought coniitiom 4/30/84 Canplete 2mO4-0@, 430/84 4
Meqtney of intike structure silt mnitoring pr(gran 4/30/M canplete 2m0-4-049, 4/30/M 5
110tniarim of tte Appalachian Platen Tatonic Prorince 4/30/M Canplete 250-4-048, 4/27/M 6
Maxintra earthquake 4/30/M 2
2mC4-048, 4/27/M 7
Q uni rrotion ttkirg soil propertim into ccusideration 4/30/M 2
2m04-048, 4/27/M 8
Actual earthquake tine histories 4/30/84 2
2mC-4-048, 4/27/84 9
Shallow cartirpnkes 4/30/84 Canplete 2mer4-048, 4/27/M 10 Vertical seismic desim a celeratiom 4/30/84 2
2mC-4-048, 4/27/84 11 lbrnalo presure drop rate calculatiom 4/30/84 Canplete 2m0-4-047, 4/27/M 12 Omcrete missile barrier design Canplete 2mC-4-018, 2/27/84 13 Site-specific rmpose spctra 4/30/M 2
2mer4-047, 4/27/M 14 Justification of ptk spreafirg of floor rmpome spctra Canplete 2m0-4-018, 2/27/M 15 3-canp3ncit seismic irptr vs. 2-contonert irptr 6/15/M 16 Soil-structure interaction analysis of con-taiment ani irtike structure 6/15/M 17 Significance of tic cou ling in structural response beten mutual y orthornal axes of structurm 6/15/M 18 Ibviatiom of cortairraert design fran A5ME Cale Section III Division 2 6/15/84 19 111timate capacity analysis of contaiment 6/15/M 4
20 lbviatiom fran ratuironerts of ACI 349 code as aignertal by Reg. 01ide 1.142 4/27/M Canplete 2mO4-047, 4/27/M 21 Structural audit action itans 4/27/M Canplete 2mC-4-047, 4/27/M 22 Affects of cra ked panel on dynanic nodelity ani design Canplete 2fR04-018, 2/27/M 23 Megtney 'of re-assessed safety factors against sliding armi overturnity of contairr-nert, aux buildirg, ani intake structure 4/30/84 Canplete '
2fR04-047, 4/27/M.
24 Through-wall leakage crmka in moderate energy lins in catninnert 5/15/M Closai 2m04-4052, 5/8/M '
25 Selection of postulatai break locations
- 5/15/M Closed 2mC-4-4052, 5/8/84 26 Jet inpirgemert effects 6/29/M 2
2m04-4052, 5/8/M.
, IMDEOSED OUISTANDI!C RESIO!GE ISSUE-SUBJECT DATE SIAIUS IETIER !O. AND DATE 27 Break exclusion zones 5/15/84 Obnfinnatory 2tRC-4-4052, 5/8/84 28 Pipe-to pipe impact 5/15/%
Canplete 2rR04-4952, 5/8/M 29 Limital bre4A areas S/15/M Closal 2rRC-4-4052, 5/8/84 30 Saturatal or subcooled water blowim 5/5/84 C1med 2tRCr4-4052, 5/8/84 31 Design of pipe rupture restraints 5/15/84 Closed 2rRC-44052, 5/8/84 32 List of tramierts 5/ 15/ 84 C1mai 2tRO-4-4052, 5/8/84 33 location of systens to be conitoral durirg pre-op testirg 6/01/84 C1med 2tRCr4-4052, S/8/M 34 Criteria used for detenninirs ac ptbility of vibration levels 5/04/%
Closed 2tR044052, 5/8/84 35 Vibration nonitoring progran 5/04/84 Closal 2fRC-4-4052, 5/8/84 36 Qxrbinirg 3 congnerts of eartirpate notion 5/04/84 Canplete 2RCr4-4052, 5/8/%
37 Modes includal in seismic analyses 5/15/84 Closal 2tRC-4-4052, 5/8/M 38 Deroonstratirg seismic qtalification 5/15/84 C1med 2rR04-4052, 5/8/84 39 loadirg carbinatiom, systen operatirg tran-sierts, arti stras Irmits 5/15/%
2 2 PRO 4-4052, 5/8/M.
40 INAC systen design 5/15/84 2
2tRC-4-4052, 5/8/84 41 Design of scfety ani relief valves 5/15/84 C1med 2PR04-4052, 5/8/M 42 Ibs tgn ard costruction of kNE Class 1, 2, ani 3 conponert supprt 5/15/84 Canplete 2PR04-4052, 5/8/M 43 Preservice ani imervice tetirg of ptmps ani valves a--6/84 b-12/84 c--6/85 2
2rR04-4052, 5/8/M 44 Effects of rod bow on DNB 6/29/84 45 Flow mesuranert capability ard pro dure 6/29/M 46 loose parts detection progran report 6/29/ 84 47 Ibetnertation of conplate ICC systen 6/29/84 48 Preservice inspections progran a--6/84 49 Qxnpliance with Appenlix G 10CIR Part 50 6/29 /84 Canplete 2tRC-4-049, 4/30/M 50 Compliance with Appendix H 10CFR Part 50 4/30/84 Complete 2fRC-4-049, 4/30/84 51 Pressure tenperature limits 4/30/84 Canplete '
2PRC-4-049, 4/30/M 52 3
53 Cortrol roon heiteility 6/01/84 54 Inservice impection of Class 2 ani 3 canponents a-6 84 c--6 85 55 Ihsign nodification for aitomatic rea tor trip canplete 2rRC-4-033, 3/30/84 56 Anticipatory reactor trip on turbine trip 5/25/84
POPOSID OLTfSTAND1tU RESIUPEE ISSITE SLTIUECT DATE STATUS ILTIER NO. AND DAIE 57 P-4 interlock Cmplete 2tRC-4-038, 4/10/M 58 thdetectzble failure in online testirg cir-cuitry for ergineeral safegtunis relays 6/29/M 59 Service water system isolation on low healer pressure 5/31/84 60 tbrmal letdown line relief valve 5/25/84 61 Switchover fran injection to recirculation 5/11/M canplete 2RG4-056, 5/14/%
62 Main feedwater isolation 5/25/84 63 Cortrol roon isolation 6/29/M 64 Stean generator level control and protection Canplete 2tRC-4-032, 3/3/84 65 IE Bulletin 80-06 concerm 6/29/84 66 Indeperdence between marual ani a2tomatic act ion 6/29/84 67 Ibwer lockout for trotor-operated valves Canplete 2tRC-4-032, 3/2/84 68 Pemote stutdown capability 5/25/%
69 thergency response capability 5
70 Direct irrlication of relief an' safety valve positiom 5/18/84 71 Bypass arti inoperzble status panel 5/25/84 72 IE Bulletin 79-27 5/25/M 73 Retrtor coolatt systan loop isolation inter-locks 6/29/%
74 Primary canponert coolirg water isolation fran RCP ttermal bariers 6/29/%
75 PID controller nodification 6/29/8'+
76 High energy line bred <s ard comeqtential control systen failures 4/27/84 Complete 2tRO-4-049, 4/30/84 77 Control systan failure caused by malftnctiom of comon power source or imtrumert line 5/25/84 78 Procodure to estimate extent of core danage Carplete 2tRC-4-042, 4/18/84 79 Ba-kup post recidert samplirg tircugh grtb sanples for inline analyses Canplete 2tRG-4-042, 4/18/84 80
&asuring ralioruclide concentrations Canplete 2tRC-4-042, 4/18/84 81 lbrfonnarre of PASS imtrunertation ard analytical procedura Canplete 2RC4-042, 4/18/%
82 Fire hazards analysis 5/15/M 83 Fire brigale 5/15/%
84 Ibnetration seals 5/15/M 85 Safe slutdown 5
86 Alternate shutdown 5
4
?
PROPOSED OUISTANDitC RESIUPEE ISSUE SUBJECT DATE STATUS 1ETIER 10. AND DATE 87 Hydrogen piping 5/ 15/84 88 Csle tray suppression 5/15/%
89 Ibwer supplies for cont-al -~m ventilation 5/15/%
90 Fire detection 5/ '84 91 valve supervision 5/15/84 92 Pemtor coolant pmps anl Pration of safety-relatal canmnerts in contaimert 5/15/%
93 Gwrol roan cmplex 5/15/84 94 C&le spreafirn roan 5/1/84 95 Exanption to 10CFR 70.24(-) ni description of alternative to rquired criticality nonitors 6/01/84 96 Types, nmbers, specificatiam for portile am laboratory IP istrunerts 5/15/84 97 Wainirg/retrainity for health physics Iro-fessionals arri verification that contractor trainirg meets 10CIR 19.12 rquirenerts 6
98 Promdures generation package /IMI I.C.1, short-term accident analysis and procedures revision 7
99 Physical security 5/ 16/ 84 Canplete 2tRC-4-051, 5/04/84 10 0 Initial test pecgran 5/30/84 101 Raliological ecuseqences of control rod ejection DM 5
10 2 Radiological consegmn s of a small line break DBA 5/15/%
103 Raliological consegmnces of a stean genera-tor tube rupture DBA arxl review of oprator actiom ani system perfonnarre 6/29/84 104 Raliological comegmnces of a steanline brei outside seemiary contaimert 5
105 Raliological ccxsegmnces of a loss of coolart DM 5
106 Raiiological consegmnces of a fm1 hanilirg DBA 5
107 3
108 3
109 3
110 3
111 3
112 Ibchnical speificatiom 8
113 Iktailed control roan design review 6/01/85 1 14 Safety paraneter display systen 8/01/84
P10FOSED OlfISTAtOItC RESIOPEE ISSUE SURIECT DATE STAIUS LEl'IER NO. AND DATE 115 Ebowpack loal on roofs 6/29/84 116 Extrane tenperatures for site area 6/29/M 117 Affects of relocation of net. tower 6/29/M
.118 Lorg tenn diffusion stimates ~
6/29/M 119 Deviations to R.G. 1.52 6/29/M 120 Cortairnert vrtain systen exhaist iodine ramal capability 6/29/M 121 Evaluation of 16ET failure 6/29/%
5 ICurrently evaluating letter fran T. M. Novak to E. J. Woolever dated April 11, 1984 2
Supplemntal submittal to be providal.
3Not provided in draft SER 4R2rther resolution beirg discussed infonnally SStaff action only b be discussed at RAB neeting 5/01/84 7tb response required 8DLC is currently arranging a managemnt neeting with MtC to discuss this iten aPSI P10 GRAM kSI PBDCEDIRES FOR VALVES & PUlfS cISt muun of
AT1AOMNT 2 (DNFINMA11RY ISSLES OLTISTROI!C ISSLE SlIRIECT STATUS 1ETIER NO. NO DATE 1
Operating b.'ai: certhquake Canplete 2NIC-4-047, 4/27/84 2
Stress and strain levels of key structural elurents 3
Floor response spectra accountig, for 3-canponent earth-quake intt 4*
i 5
Exanination of stean gwrators 6*
7 Main FW isolation 8
CR isolation on high radiation signal i
9 Automatic opening of service water systen valves 10 Acci&nt nonitoring instnmentation positions 11 Cold leg a:ctmalator NN position indication 12 T4ble 1.9-2 by product, source, armi special ruclear I
material desenptiom nine conths trior to ftel loadirg Q471.14B 13 Verification that cobalt use in primary systen has been minimizal Q471.10 14 0)ntairment high range radiation nonitors six nonths grior to ftel loadirg Q471.14a 15 Verify that HMS airborne radioactivity nonitors 16 Quality assurance progran requiratents
- *Not pnwidal in Draft SER 4
d 1
?
ATIKOMNr 3 IEAFT SER SFfrI0tB AND DKIES PROVIIED Section Date Section Date Section Date Section Date Section Date 2.1.1 5.2.3 8.4.4 10.4.4 15.3.3 2.1.2 '
5.2.5 8.4.5 10.4.5 5.3.4 2.1.3 5.4.1 8.4.6 10.4.7 15.4.5
- 2.1.4 5.4.7 8.4.7 10.4.9 15.4.6 2.2.1 5.4.11 8.4.8 11 05/04/84 15.5.1 2.2.2 6.2.1 9.1 1 11.1 05/04/d4 15.5.2 2.2.3 6.2.2 9.1.4 11.1.2 15.7.1 2.3.1 05/04/84 6.2.3 9.1.5 11.2.1 05/04/84 5 7.2 2.3.2 05/04/ %
- 6. 2.4 9.2.1 11.2.2 05/04/%
15.7.3 05/04/84 2.3.3 05/04/84 6.2.5 9.2.2 11.3.1 05/04/84 15.9.1 2.3.4 05/04/84 6.2.6 9.2.3 11.3.2 05/04/84 15.9.2 2.3.5 05/04/84 6.3.1 9.2.4 11.3.3 05/04/ %
15.9.3 t
2.4.13 6.3.2 9.2.5 11.4.1 15.9.4 2.5.4 6.3.3 9.2.6 11.4.2 5.9.5 2.5.5 6.3.4 9.3.1 11.5.1 05/04/84 15.9.6 2.5.6 6.3.5 9.3.3 11.5.2 05/04/84 5.9.7 3.2.1 6.3.6 9.4.1 13.1.1 15.9.8 3.2.2 6.5.1 05/04/84 9.4.2 13.1.2 5.9.9 3.4.1 6.5.3 9.4.3 13.3 15.9.10 3.5.1 6.5.4 9.4.4 13.4 15.9. 1 1 4
3.5.2 7.2.3 9.4.5 13.5.1 15.9.12 3.6.1 7.3.4 9.5.2 15. 1.2 15.9. 13 3.10.1 7.4.3 -
9.5.3 15.1.3 15.9.14 3.10.2-7.5.3 9.5.4 5.1.4 17. 1 -
1 3.11.1 7.6.3 9.5.5 15.1.5 -
17.2 4
3.11.2 7.7.3 9.5.6 15.2.1 17.3 -
3.11.3-
- 8. 2.1
'9.5.7 15.2.2 17.4-5 4.2.1 8.2.2.
9.5.8 5.2.3 19 l
4.2.2
- 8. 2.3 10.2.3 15.2.4 20 4.2.3 8.2.4 10.3.1 --
5.2.5 2L
'4.2.4 8.3.1 10.3.2-15.2.6 -
22.1 4.2.5 8.3.2
' 10.3.6 -
5.2.7 22.2
-4.5.1 -
8.4.1 10.4.1 15.2.8 22.3 i
4.5.2 8.4.2 10.4. 2 - ~ 05/04/M.
5.3.1 -
23 -
i 5.2.1 8.4.3 10.4.3-05/04/84 15.3.2
=
.