ML20090F452
| ML20090F452 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Farley  |
| Issue date: | 03/05/1992 |
| From: | John Miller ALABAMA POWER CO., BALCH & BINGHAM (FORMERLY BALCH, BINGHAM, BAKER |
| To: | Bollwerk G, Carpenter J, Morris P Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20090F456 | List: |
| References | |
| CON-#192-12678 91-626-02-CIVP, 91-626-2-CIVP, CIVP, NUDOCS 9203110048 | |
| Download: ML20090F452 (21) | |
Text
.
/2677 B A L C H & B I N G H A.,M
. J t M.b,.. N_.
m.
, t m.~ m.
,.m.N... -
.,, - as. tu eo,m - s
.,.~~o
- e...; n klj
-3*G N. S Bi -~4 *f s
..*si T h
.,m N
.o...
-.em
.. ~..-mo
,a s, e e c m =
3
.~'..s
, - o.a.f tri.. ~c
$h1 S t.N4 E'1 M
,M AD.L AND.9..f.M.N M o
94.R./ak D W4 L..MS
(' a. 'D. 5"pv D k.Ri, Ek MO.'wt 4 ( L T(W W Su s T sch.% D C.8%5.Na.M DIRMIPvGH AM. AL AD AM A 3B2Of
- u.8= N E.I
+ru '.N*:as.ti a c.tt % 3 W.0cttt e tu t.9.&.4D.NW S J4 f.s ?.i
... :, g
,so..% y wa 60 M.phy 0 %.sif.e
[ Sm l.1 LP.at N (
W..t '[ t.1 A D W5t k..e4 s yb.f$D
..O..ME R' M,C,OL i NS,
,1 P.*m**'i o.4 92 tL.Q a
5 4s h
s ? O *v 5 P3i til
- C.'(.
m.
W,
No. -
s
~. - m o- ~
g g tu.e3 c t u u.N ggsu,g M 4 tt re t.attJ c ifWooo s.pt s = w%.d a. en v
$ { T FO'ht L R W.L a. t.m.* 1 T f t N8 6( L t'.
sV#b.N m..I G J.4 s.Mr.$ E ti.4:EUf 5 au JO *.= 5 thww.JR 4
S'E v5 N G M<.oMNt Y A E. b. L.'.s 94 pt #5. m (..s 15 p 6
. L.. v t,N DI # C s tM A L Gag mot, (. C'{ia m
.E.t('w l b F C.*=f f T DM.$ % 9*.d.f4D sM
- II"%MfTI
,1 { I l '.
L D.M tW W pie >N
.(tti Dg g.a.i g.t
.t Cfh u 4 t'.aeuTH.t t C H. A f B n. T MOO.
,s t,.uuuo o c..aet ectoi s.
.% s n,t.oo
...,.... m W.q,,, p
- w. uA.s p.ti e,at rWv,io to.t.eso
- o si.m.* t % s N ow, u~~
1 W m...o o,
, o.en,mx.u s.*tt.n.n.u o40
" b l.4 D.n. c
.***u%
6 to.uN u..t t o.W.*a s.u t i.
C$+"'I' * ' W **#0 e.aveA 44..nts p'c, a
- v. *..at t u.w t.9 w wC a.av...
W par
- e. cxx> pas m..<*
o m 0,. s, u t,~ t
- r. ~
.m,cN.
s.m.....m.,-.
A.u A% Ts.ML HS s.M C 5.* *1. N.i DC 9i Mi & L) 6P( h.67.5 h sit s
J 4.f
- N. ** 8 8 bF0tt N O 4..
4(
( Wu...ON S.& ( 5
- t.L '.$
P MPT I
W.,
N
- N.&.W 4'O'*i (2 m 226-v.22 M a5l 6. web'4 L D6)(
^*
M it Gi
. o u,. o...
<...m. u < u.c m.
-m
_m~...
,,,,,,,..,,m,,
.. N. o.N E.T. ~,-
- m. m..
,$ M '.'rm ho. N JD.*N JR Je*N I M.
W.{ I(R 4 $4( A((, je 4,
5_
. _m. ~
March 3, U( 9,.
om, o
,~..D, mt.
. u,
.n 1 -, m a.
r.
m
,o w - m.
S,~c o so,w as t,w.
a,$ ~c-.s ra.~os s.i t, 4...u v.t
. ~ xm 2
,, s 1..c,-
,m....
m _,
G. Paul Bollwerk, Ill James H. Carpenter Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board J
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Peter A. Morris Administrative Judge 10825 South Glen Road Potomac, Maryland 20S54 IN TIIE MATI'ER OF Alabama Power Company (Joseph M. Farley Nuclear Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket Nos. 50 V.98.CivP; 50-364-CivP ASLBP No. 91626 02-CivP
Dear Administrative Judges:
Please find enclosed the following: (1) Alabama Power Company's vertical timeline as requested by Judge Carpenter;(2) a revised version of the Alabama Power Company List of Duplicated Pre-Marked Exhibits field March 2,1992, and a description of the four revisions made to that list; (3) proposed corrections to the transcripts for the February 11-14, 1992 and Februaty 18-21,1992, hearing sessions; (4) report outlining the nature and results of Alabama Power Company's efforts to ascertain the status on November 30.1985 of the silicone oil in the GEMS level transmitters and the lubricant used in the containment fan motors and room coolers outside containment; and (5) duplicate samples of Alabama Power Company Exhibits 103 and 107.
9203110048 920305 PDR ADOCK 05000348 k
O PDR s
w ww m.m non a w - ~ a s.a.w om. n es. t.w
..w
. a.e $ s t
4 4
t
I hiessrs. Bollwerk, Carpemer and hiornis hiarch 5,1992 Page 2 Items 1-4 above are being distributed to the attached service list by copy of this letter; Alabama Power Company Exhibits 103 and 107 are being sent only to Judge Bollwerk.
Respectfully yours,
.]
/
,,,., a y
^' ' /( _
Q
/
~
James H. hiiller,111 COUNSEL FOR ALABAMA POWER COhiPANY Enclosure cc: Certificate of Senice
Yi
?
7f UNirED STATES OF AMERICA
/
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
/
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOAR 12 In the Matter of:
)
)
Docket Nos. 50-348-CivP ALABAMA POWER COMPANY
)
50-364-CivP
)
(Joseph M. Farley Nuclear
)
Plant, Units 1 and 2)
)
ASLBP No. 91-626-02-CivP CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of (1) ALABAMA POWER COMPANY'S VERTICAL TIMELINE AS REQUESTED BY JUDGE CARPENTER; (2) REVISED ALABAMA POWER COMPANY LIST OF DUPLICATED PRE-MARKED EXHIBITS; (3)
- PROPOSED CORRECTIONS TO THE TRANSCRIPTS FOR THE FEBRUARY 11 14, 1992 AND FEBRUARY 18-21, 1992, HEARING SESSIONS; (4) REPORT OF ALABAM A POWER COMPANY ON THE LEVEL OF SILICONE OIL IN THE GEMS LEVEL TRANSMITTERS AND THE GREASE USED IN FAN MOTORS ON NOVEMBER 30, 1985 relating to the above-captioned proceeding have been served by Federal Express on the following as indicated by an asterisk and othenvise by deposit in the United States Mail, First Class, this 5th day of March,1992:
G. Paul Bollwerk, Ill*
James H. Carpenter
- Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Peter A. Morris
- Eugene J. Holler, Esq.*
Administrative Judge Office of the General Counsel 10825 South Glen Road U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Potomac, Maryland 20854 Washington, D.C. 20555 Office of the Secretary (2)
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Panel Washington, D.C. 20555 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Docketing and Service Section Washington, D.C. 20555
Adjudicatory File (2)
Office of Commission Appellate Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Adjudication U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Mr..W. G. Hairston,111 Regional Administrator Southern Nuclear Operating Company, U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission-
- Inc.
Region 11 Post Office Box 1295 101 Marietta Street Birmingham, Alabama 35201 Suite 2900 Atlanta, Georgia 30323 James Lieberman, Director Office of Enforcement U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washinynn, D.C. 20555
/'
ll /
s
_,. g James H. Miller,111 Couns:1 for Alabama Tower Company 1
i m.-.h_ _ - -___-.... _
l*
1 ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION CllRONOI.OGY (Vertical timeline) 1977 - Union of Concerned Scientists petitions the NRC to address environmental qualification concerns May 31,1978 - Issuance of Circular 78-08 (APCo Ex. 4)
January 17, 1980 - Issuance of IN 79-OlB (APCo Ex. 8)
~
August 29,1980 - Order modifying license for Unit 1 (APCo Ex. 85)
February 5,1980 - Issuance of NUREG 0588 (Staff Ex. 23)
April,1980 - EO Branch is organized September,1980 - Inspection and audit for Unit 2 for purposes of issuing a full power license (Trip report is APCo Ex.10)
December,1980 - Gibbons inspection of Unit I and Unit 2, which found "no violations or deviations" (Report is APCo Ex. I1)
December,1980 - Norm Merriweather Technical Evaluation Report (APCo Ex. 32)
February,1981 - Unit 1 equipment evaluation report by NRR (APCo Ex.13)
March,1981 - SER issued for Unit 2 saying Master List is " complete and acceptable"(APCo Ex.15)
March,1981 - Full power license issued for Unit 2 May,1981 - SER issued for Unit I saying Master List is " complete and acceptable" ( APCo Ex.14)
I;tte 1981 - APCo hires Mike Lalor to assist in EO compliance effort 1982 - APCo submits documentation to Franklin Research Center January,1983 - Franklin issues Technical Evaluation Reports ( APCo Ex.1h & 17)
March 31,1981 - Unit 2 license condition ( APCo Ex. S3)
A EO Chronology Page 2' February,1983 -- Staff issues Safety Evaluation Report transmitting to APCo the Franklin TER (APCo Ex.18 and 19)
February,1983 - Issuance of EO rule (10 CFR 50.49)
January 11,1984 - APCo has meeting with Staff to discuss resolutions to Franklin TER February 29,1984 - APCo sends letter to Staff documenting discussions at January 11,1984 meeting (APCo Ex. 20) 1984 - Staff begins conducting first round EO inspections December 13,1984 - Staff issues SER concluding that Alabama Power's EO program is in compliance with 10 CFR 50.49 (APCo Ex. 21)
January,1985 APCo submits to the Staff a letter certifying that Farley Nuclear Plant is in compliance with 10 CFR 50.49 (APCo Ex. 22)
May 1985 - EO License condition for Unit 2 is met (APCo Ex. 84)
November 30,1985 - Deadline for EO compliance and for what licensees " clearly knew or should have known" 1985 - Issuance of Generic Letter 85-15 (Staff Ex. 7) and SECY 85-220 (Staff Ex. 6) 1986.- Issuance of Generic Letter 86-15 (Staff Ex. 9) and SECY 86-122 (Staff Ex. 8)
March 27,1986 - Issuance Of inspection module (APCo Ex. 93)
July,1987 - APCo submits voluntary licensee evaluation report on V-type taped splices (Staff
'Ex.16)-
August,1987' Seminar for EO inspectors conducted at Sandia National Laboratories (APCo
' Ex.- 1) _
September,1987 - Staff conducts " reactive" inspection at Farley Nuclear Plant I
September 24, 1987 - APCo has meeting with Staff to discuss V-taped splices (APCo Ex.
108)-
. Octobec,1987 - Issuance of Wyle test report on V-taped splices (Statf Ex. 25)
November,1987 - Staff conducts second inspection of Farley NucIcar Plant (Staff Ex.12) u
._.... _-......-. ~ -.. - - - - - _.... - --.----- _.-_- -
.=
EO Chronology Page 3 August,1988 Staff issues Notice of Violation (Staff Ex. 2)
October,1988 - APCo responds to Motice of Violation (Staff Ex.15)
November,1990 - Staff issues Order imposing Civil Penalty against APCo (Staff Ex. 3) _
November 16,1990 - APCo requests hearing t
E f
i
- ~,. <,..,
-y_, -. -... -, _.,
_-__x..,.
-m4 s.,
..., ~
.. 4
~.__m._.-
4 APCO LIST OF DUPl.JCATEDl%ihiAIMED EXHililTS (Supplemental List)
(Cross referenced with corresponding staff exhibits)
APCO */ STAFF #
1.
Agenda,8/26-28/87, regarding EQ seminar at Sandia APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p. 947 2,
4.
Generic letter to All Power Reactor Licensees and Applicants from Frank J. Miraglia -
NRC, dated (M!O7/88, regarding Modified Enforcement Policy Relating to 10 CFR 50.49,
' Environmental Qualification of Electrical Equipment important to Safety for Nuclear Power -
Plants * (Generic Letter 88 07); List of Recently issued Generic Ixiters attached Staff Exhibit reccited into esidence, p. 304 3.
04/13n8 Petition for Emergency and Remedial Action; CL178-6; 7 NRC 400,420 APCO exhibit received into esidence, p. 947 4.
IE Circular 78-08 to F. L Clayton, Jr. - APCo from James P. O'Reilly - NRC, dated 05/31n8, regarding Environtnental Qualification of Safety Related Electrical Equipment of Nuclear Power Plants: List of I.E. Circulars issued in 1978 attached APCO exhibit received into evidence, p. 947 5.
10/1108 letter to James P. O'Reilly transmitting Farley response to IE Circular 78 08:
Qualification ol' Electrical Terminal Blocks; Unavailability of Test Report Due to Terminal Blocks Inside Ccmtainment Associates with Containment isolation Valves, Wide Range and Narrow Range Temperature Monitoring, and Power Operated Relief Valves APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p. 947 6.
Letter to F. L Cir.yton, Jr. Alabama Power Co. from James P. O'Reilly dated 02/0809 regarding 1.E, Bulletin No. 79 01: Environmental Qualification of Class.lE Equipment; attachments: 1) lE Bulletin No. 79 012) List of IE Bulletins issued in the Past 12 Months
- 3) List of SEP Plants.
APCO exhibit recelsed into esidence, 947 7.
27.
Bulletin to F. L Clayton,Jr. APCo from James P.O'Reilly NRC, dated OM)6n9 regarding Supplement I.E. Bulletin 79 01 A; attachments: 1) 1.E. Bulletin No. 79-Ol A 2) List of 1.E.
Bulletins issued in the Past 12 Months 3) List of SEP Plants-Staff exhibit reccited into evidence, p. HM9 8.-
Bulletin to F. L Clayton,- Jr.
APCo from James P. O'Reilly_ -NRC, dated 01/17/80 transmitting 1.E. Bulletin No. 79 01B Regarding Environmental Qualification of Class 1.E.
Equipment; Enclosures dated 01/14/80 APCO exhibit recel ed into evidence, p.1894 4
9.-
CLI.80-21 dated 05/27/80
- APCO exhibit received luto r$1dente, p. 947 i
l i
, ~.. -,.. - ~.-..- ~.-.._~
Pte marked exhibits Page 2 10.
hiemo to Z. R. Rositoc7y from Frank Ashe, Joel Paige, William Boothe, and hiaritec l
Slosson, dated 05/27/81, transmitting Trip Report Audit of Alabama Power Company's Test Data and/or Documentation Concerning Environmental Qualification of Eicctrical Equipment Per NUREO.0588 for Farley 2 Nuclear Station APCO eshibit recched into esidence, p. 947 11.
Leite to R. P. hicDonald ; APCo from C. E. hiurphy NRC dated 01/15/81 transmitting Report Nos. 50 348,N38 and 50 364/80-49; Special Inspec'. ion Conductad By T. D. Gibbons on 12A12/80 to 12A15/80 Al'CO exhibit recched into esidence, p. 947 12.
Technical Evaluation Report entitled Environmental Qualification of Safety Related Electrical Equipment IEB 79-01B Farley Unit No. I prepared by N. hierriweather on 12/10/80 APCO exhibit recelsed into evidence, p. 947 13.
Letter to F. L Clayton, Jr. - APCo from Thomas hi. Novak NRC dated 02/13/81 regarding Preliminary Results of NRC Review of EQ's of Safety.Related Electrical Equipment at Farley Plant, Unit No.1; attachment: Environmental Qualification Report 4
APCO exhibit reccited into esidence, p. 947 14 Letter to F. L Clayton,Jr. APCo frcm Steven A. Varga NRC dated 05/21/S1 transmitting NRC Safety Evaluation for the Environmental Qualification of Safety Related Electrical Equipment at Farley Unit No, it attachments: Safety Evaluation Report and Technical Evaluation Report dated 11/14/80 APCO exhibit received into esidence, p. 947 15.
hiarch 1981 Safety Evaluation Report - Unit 2, Docket No. 50 364, APCo, Supplement No.
6 to NUREG 75/034 APCO exhibit received into esidence, p. 947 16.
01/14/83 Technical Evaluation Report: Review of Licensecs' Resolution of Outstanding Issues From NRC Equipment Environmental Qualification Safety Evaluation Reports (F 11 and B.60); Farley Unit 1; prepared by The Franklin lastitute APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p. 947 7
17.
01/17/83 Technical Evaluation Report: Review of Licensecs' Resolution of Outstanding Issues from NRC Equipment Environmental Qualification Safety Evaluation Reports (F-1l-and B 60); Farley Unit 2; prepared by The Franklin Research Center APCO exhibit reccised into evidence, p. 947 18.
Letter to F. L Clayton,Jr. - APCo from Steven A. Varga - NRC dated 02/04!83 transmitting E
' Safety Evaluation Report for Environmental Qualification of Safety Related Electrical L'
Equipment Faricy Unit No,1 APCO exhibit received into evidence, p. 947
- 19. '
Letter to F. L Clayton,'Jr. APCo from Steven A. Varga - NRC dated 02M473 transmining Safety Evaluation. Report for Environmental Qualification of Salcty Related Elecincal Equipment - Farley Unit No. 2 i
APCO exhibit received into evidence, pi 947 1
,,--er,
.y-y
-m.
=
w.
4 l're-marked exhibits Page 3 20.
Letter to S. A. Varga - NRC from F. L Clayton, Jr.. APCu dated 02/29'S4 concerning Safety Evaluation Reports and Technical Evaluation Reports Noting Deficiencies Concerning Documentation of Qualification for Sescral Safety Related Items at FNP, attachments: 1)
Summary of Each Deficiency identified in the TER's for Units 1 and 2; 2) Resolutions to Specific NRC Staff Comments identified at the 01/11/84 hiceting; 3) Westinghouse Affidavit Requesting Informatica in Supplements 1,2,3 and 4 To lle Withheld from Public Disclosure APCO eshibit rerched into esidence, p. 947 21.
Safety Evaluations dated 12/13'S4 for Units 1 and 2; proposed resolutions for deficiencies identified in Safety Evaluations dated 01/31/83 and in the 01/14%3 and Ol/17/S3 Franklin TER's and to your proposed that JCO's are not necessary APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p. 947 22.
Letter to S. A. Varga - NRC from R. P. hicDonald APCo dated 01/28/S5 tiansmitting Units 1 and 2 Response to Generie Letter S4 24; Sworn Statement that an EQ program is in place, the plant has at least one path to safe shutdown, and equipment is qualified or operating under JCO.
APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p. 947 23.
FNP Environmental Qualification Program Implementation; FNP-0-ETP 4108, Revision 0 APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p.1060 24.
Execrpt from of The Lineman's and Cableman's Handbook section 33, entitled, " Splicing j
Cable
- APCO uhlbit recebed into evidence, p. 962 25.
21.
Okonite Report No. NORN-3, Rev.1, June 30,1982, entitled, " Nuclear Environmental Qualification Report for Okoguard Insulated Cables and T.45 and No. 35 Splicing Tape
- Staff exhibit recei ed into esidence, p. 442 26.
16.
07/30/87 letter to NRC Document Control Desk from R, P. hicDonald transmitting Farley Unit I Licensee Event Report No. LER 87-012-00 Staff exhibit receised into esidence, p. 442 27.
NEQ Test Report 17859 02P performed by Wyle Laboratories: Qualification Test Program on Ray Chem Nuclear Cable Splices, Okonite Tape Splices, Ketile Tape Splices, Scotch Tape Splices and Amp 13utt Splices as Installed on Various Wire Insulations at Commonwealth Edison Companies LaSalle Dresden and Quad Cities Generating Stations, volumes 1 and 2 (hiarch 11,1987)
APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p. 962 28.
9.
Generic Letter 86-15 entitled
- Environmental Qualification of Electric Equipment Important to Safety for Nuclear Power Plants.* dated 09'22/S6 Staff exhibit recebed into esidence, p. 304 29.
Jesse E. Love resume APCO exhlbit recched into esidence, p. I191 30.
James E. Sundergill resume APCO eshibit receised into esidence, p. I191
~. -
Pre-marked exhibits Page 4 31.-
General Design Criterion 4,10 CFR Part 50, Appendh A APCO exhibit reccited into esidence, p.1191 32.
Regulatory Guide 1.97, Rev. 2.
APCO exhibit recched into 'sidence, p.1891 33.
2.
08/15/88 Notice of Violation and Proposed imposition of Civil Penalty (NRC Inspection Report Nos. 50-348,364/8725 and 50 348,364/87) transmitted to Alabama Power Company from NRC 34.
3.
03/21/90 Order imposing a Civil Monetary Penalty at Farley Stati exhibit received into evidence, p. 304 35.
Regulatory Guide 1.89, Rev.1 APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p. Il91 36.
-IEEE Standard 3231974, Standard for Qualifying Class IE Electric Equipment for Nuclear Power Generating Stations APCO exhibit received into esidence, p. I191 37.
IEEE 323-1971, Standard for Qualifying Class IE Electric Equipment for Nuclear Power Generating Stations APCO exhibit reccited into esidence, p.1l91 38.
APCO Detail Nos. A-172389172398: generic design details regarding terminations APCO exhibit recebed into evidence, p. I191 39.
25 Wyle Test Report 17947-01 dated 10h87 with Addendum 1 dated 11/19/88 Stati exhibit received into evidence, p. 442 APCO exhibit recebed into evidence, p. 947, 40 26.
05/16/90 Qualification of taped splices for use in instrument circuits subject to harsh erwironments, Waterford Steam Electric Station, Unit 3 StaIT exhibit recehed into cildence, p. 442 41.
Circular 80-10 regarding Failure to Maintain Environmental Qualification of Equipment, dated 04/29/80 APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p.1191 42.
23.
NUREG 0538, Rev.1: Interim Staff Position on Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipmen8 Staff exhibit received into esidence, p. 442 43.
30.
09/23/87 Electric Hydrogen Recombiner Splices -- Justification for Continued Operation Staff exhibit recched into esidence, p. 304 44.
32.
WCAP-7709 L: Electrical Hydrogen Recombiner for Water Reactor Containments, produced by Westinghouse Electric Corp.
Staff exhibit recebed into esidence, p. 529
Pre-matked exhibits Page 5 45, 29; 09/17/87 Electric liydrogen Recombiner Splices - Justification for Continued Operation
- Stati eshibits recrised into esidence, p. 529 46.
. Letter to APCO from Westinghouse regarding 5.to.1 terminations, dated 09/22/87 APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p.1191 47.
31.
WCAP 9347: Qualification Testing for Model 11 Electric ilydrogen Recombiner, produced by Westinghouse Electric Corp.
Sia!T eshibits recched into esidence, p. 529 48.
Letter to Thomas Anderson - Westinghouse from John F. Stolz - NRC dated 06/22n8 transmitting evaulation of WCAP 7709L Re: Hydrogen Recombiners APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p.1191 I
- 49. -
Westinghouse Electric Hydrogen Recombiner Technical Manual APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p.1l91 50.
Wyle Test Report 443541, dated 03J08n9 APCO eshlbli recched into esidence, p. I191 St.
48.
06/15/841.E. Information Notice No. 84 47: Environmental Qualification Tests of Electrical Terminal 111ocks APCO eshibit recelsed into esidence, p. I191 Staff exhibit recelsed into evidence, p. 779 52.
APCO response to Circular 78-08 and Notice 84-47 regarding terminal blocks and loop accuracy APCO exhibit recched into evidence, p.1191 53.
- Excerpt from IPS-107:Conax Test Report IPS.107 Connection NSS3 Terminal Blocks APCO exhibit recched into evidence, p.1191
}
' 54. -
Picture of CR151B terminal block taken from vendor's catalogue APCO exhibit received into evidence, p. I191 55.
12.
= Letter to R. P. Mcdonald ' APCo from J. Nelson Grace NRC dated 02/04/88 transmitting NRC Inspection Report Nos. 50-348/87-30 and 50-364/87-30 Staff eshibit reccised into evidence, p. 304 56.
Graph representing terminal block Connectron Nss3/#16 AWG Wires, Conax Test Report IPS-107; representation of IR values over time.
l APCO exhibit recched into evidence, p.1l91 57.
One-page illustration of Connectron terminal block taken from vendor's catalogue APCO eshibit received into esidence, p.1191 58.
Qualification test reports for GE CR15111 terminal blocks
- 59.
11/24/87 Justification for Continued Operation Unit 1 Termin.il filocks lhed m Instrument
-l Circuits
]
l're nmrked exhibits port 5fl42 2, dated 04'81 Raychem Report EDR 5033/Wyle ic Page 6 e p.KN9 scal.
Staff ethildt recchrd into esidenc,
testing of Chico NRaythem 39.
u).
h Test Report 2BE 1049 3: submetrenceidente, p.1891 SPCO ethildt irrehed into es hem scah 61.
llechtel qualification IcMing of Rayt p.889 performed by Southwest Staff ethitS recched into c$idence,of Four Inch Ey> Con u e,
dlt 33, 62 02Alin9 Testing and litadiation 8/x8 transmitting
(
889 Research InstituteStaff eshibit recebed into esidence, p.
R P. Mcdonald. APCo dated G f
40.
/CillCO
[
61 letter to D. M. VertcIll NRC fromAdditional Doc tal Quallflutt!cn l y; attachments:1)Correspondenc PCo Rey,arding i
Ray Chem!CillCO 5,calant Enviro 47.
Sealant andTerminalBlochs at Far e 64.
Power Co. to APCo Regarding Eva'aation; 2) Correspondence fromOsalificat i al Blocks ce p 779 e Scal Kite on Stainless l
'. staff cshildt recched into esh en,. hem NEls EnvironmentalInte f
II/20M5 EQ Test Report of Rayt Steel Pfpe (EDR.6063) Staff exhibit recched into eside nd Conduit Orneral Detaih an p,889 d Notes.
35.
65 Bechtel Drawing No. A 177541: Tray a p.889 Staff exhibit re(ched into esidence, hncation D0058, Paris and 2 43 u>.
Limitorque Corporation Nuclear Qua p.643 Staff rshibits recched into eviden<r, e Valve Control Test Report 54.
$7.
Limitorque Report 600198: Limitorqu p.643 Staff exhibits recched into r$1dence,Qualihcation Ty 52.
68.
Limitorq9c Report 600456: Staff eshibit.;; rtcched T)pe Test Report of Multi-p.643 53.
69.
I dated i1/15/82:'Qualincationit rqu WR Service *
(Withdrawn)
Limitorque Report 1M1114, kev. Terminal Sulps for 70.
i 1891 Esperiente APCO exhibli recched into esidence, p. Environmental Q 71.
Point 3 72:
10/28/83 IE Information Notice 8 -Staff p.643 nmental Qualthcati s
i 55.
72.
01/14/86 IE Information No. 66 Operator Wiring of Limitorque Motor YaheAPCO eshibit recche ce,p !191 d
73
' i._
. - - -. - ~
d
]
I i
Plc.! narked exhibits
[
Page 7 4
74.
excerpt from Texaco's 1988 ' Lubricating Oil, GIcase and Antif tecte Coolant Digest' APCO eshlbli rwehed into coldense, p.1891 L
t 75.
Telewpy to F ank Watford from Thomas P. Gregory dated (w!!O!76 regarding Tesaco Lubricant Recommendations Per Equipment Lists APCO eshibit twehed into esidence, p. 574 76.
Wyle Test Report No. 401%1: Radiation Exposure and Accident Simulation Test Program on Texaco Orcases and Oils dated 12A15,H8 i
Al'CO eshlbli recched into esidence, p.189) 77.
Chevron SRI 2 telecopy from lloit/11cchtel APCO eshlbli retched into cildence, p.1891 77a.
Robert O. Ilott resume 78.
Letter to W. O, llatuiton,111. APCo from Caudie A. Julian NRC dated 10/31/89 transmitting NRC Inspection Report Nos. 50 348.59 23 and 50 364S9 23; inspection to Review APCo's Cortcetive Actions in Response to Plevious inspection l'indings (!!ates
- 57180) i APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p.1297 79.
Philip A. Dillenedetto resume APCO eshlbli recched into esidence, p.1297 80.
NRC Order dated 03/30N0: EQ civil penally at 11.11. Robinson APCO eshibli recelted into esidence, p.1297 81.
NtJOEQ Report 'CLrification of Information Related to the Environmental Qualification of Limitorque Motorized Wlve Operators,' dated August 1989 APCO eshlbli reccited into esidence, p.1297 82.
Vincent S. Noonan resume APCO eshlbli recched into esidence, p.1297 83.
License condition for Fatley Unit 2 APCO eshlbli reeched into esidence, p. 305 M.
05/23/85 Evaluation and Status of License Conditions for Joseph M. Farley Unit.2; transmitted from Mr. Steven A. Varga to Mr. R. P. Mcdonald APCO exhibit received into evidence, p. 305 85.
08/29/80 correspondence from NRC to APCO transmitting Order for Modification of 1.ieense APCO enhlbli recched into esidence, p. 305 86.
Memo to NRC Regional Administrators Regions 15 from James Liberman dated OM21/8x transmitting Guidance for the Preparation of Enforcement Cases Related to EQ violations; follow.up to Generie Letter 88 07 describing modified enforcement policy for enoronmental qualification actions APCO eshlblt recched into evidence, p. 305
--u*re. - -... - - ~.-4---u.r. -
/,
Pre marked exhibits Page 8 87.
Notice of siolation for indian Point Unit 2. dated llAR'88 APCO exhibit treched into esidence, p. 305 88.
Notice of violation for indlan Point Unit 3, dated OW21/88 APCO eshibli received into esidence, p.105 89.
Notice of violation for Susquehanna Units 1 and 2. dated 09/19/88 APCO eshibit recelsed into esidence, p. 305 90.
- EQ Scoreboard
- APCO eshibit recched into esidence, p. 305 91.
Notice of violation for Consumets Power Company's Palisades Nuclear Plant, dated 11/2358 APCO eshibit received into esidence, p. 305 92.
Timeline prepared by Alabama Power Company APCO exhibit recched into evidence, p. 791 93.
Tl 2515n6 Inspection hiodule, entitled,
- Evaluation of Licensee's Program for Qualification of Electrical Equipment lecated in liaish Envitonments' APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p. 336 94.
Correspondence from NRC to APCO segarding
- Summary of hiccting lictd on September 24, 1987, Between NRC Staff and APCO Representatives to Discuss Recent Problems Related to Qualification of V.7ype Electrical Splices at Farley Site
- dated 11 A15/87.
APCO exhibit recched luto esidence, p. 442 95.
09/2W87 correspondence from Wyle Laboratories to APCO segarding Environmental Qualification Test Results on Okonite and 3M Tape Splice Assemblies for the Parley Nuclear Ocnerating' Station.
APCO exhibit reccised into estdence, p. 443 9A Correspondence from Jackie Graham of Southern Company Services to APCO dated 10/29/87, transmitting assessment of V type tape splices.
APPO exhibit recched into esideace, p. 451 97, excerpt from Reliance hianual B 3620-8 Al'CO eshlblt recched into evidence, p. 574 98.
excerpt from Reliance hianual B 362019 APCO eshibit recched into evidence, p. 574 99, installation and hiaintenance Manual for Joy Series 1000 Axivane Direct Camnceted Single nnd Two Stage Aslal Flow Fans APCO eshibit recched into evidence, p. 574 10th excerpt from Reliance Manual B 3628.Rev. 9 APCO exhibit recched into esidence, p. !74
-r-r..
..w-,..
.y---.
-,w-w
,.,-_,,v.c,,,,ymg-grp,,,~
ywn,,.,,n,,_,
,,,y,-,,p
,,y o
%y.
men---,.m--%
d j
Pre malked exhibits Page 9
{
- 101, mq t from hchaca.c Manual ll 3628.Itev.10 APCO cahibit imited into esidence, p. $74 102.
Phpical specimen: liA.180 Sci.) (Croucction os lla)t hem boot)
APCO ethibit arcthed into esidente, p.1892 l
t 103.
Phpical speelmen: IIA 180 Namco 1.imit Switch (Full version)
APCO eshibit recelied into cildence, p.1892 JG)
Drawing A.177541 Rev. O, dated 07/lMt2: Procedure for Applying Chico A4 Compound to the Nipple of Namco's IIA +180 Limit Switch Where llaychem 11reak Out h Attached APCO uhlbli recched luto etidence, p. N90 i
105.
Phpical specimen: V type splice APCO nhibit terched into egidence, p.1892
- 106, Phpiret specimen: 5101 splice j
APC. nhibit recched into cildence, p.1892 r
107.
Phpical specimen: T drain APCO nhibit retched into esidence, p.1192
(
10&
0900M7 correspondence from APCO to NRC regarding 09/24/87 meeting APCO nhibit rerched into esidence, p. 947 109.
NUGEQ Report ' Clarification of information Related to the IInvironmental Qualification of Lirnitorque Motorfied Wlve Operators,' dated April 1986.
110.
J. Il Love markup of Incard thhibit 1 APCO nhibit recebed trit <# esidence, p.1223 111.
I page execrpt from Saadia report: Figure 2, Phase il linvironmental Temperature Profile, Jesse Love markup APCO nhibit recched into esidence, p.1223
.=======================================================
I NOTES
. APCO 39 and Staff 2$ have been teccived irco evidence; APCO 39 includes Addendum 1.
.-Staff 32, which has been received into evidence,is missing pages; tefer to APCO 41.
4
--Staff 27, which has been received into evidence, is missing parcs; refer to APCO ?
i 4,.
em.-
,...,c'.4,.
--r,--,%m.~.,m--.~,--,,,c..',---,...,---.r.,-,,
<,.m.,--,
m,--r..m,
,, - -.,,.,,. -~~-,_,...
,,m.,_.----,-
b DliSCillPTION OF CilANCiliS TO Tllli AI AllAhiA l'OWiilt COhiPANY 1,lST OF DUI'l.lCATliD PI(E h1AltKIID !!X111111TS
(_a)
The description of APCo lhhibit 27 has been changed to reflect that the appropriate test report nuniber is Test Iteport 17859 02P,1ather than Test lleport 17859 0211.
(b) llevised list indicates that APro lixhibit 70 has been withdrawn and was not adniitted into evidence, i
(c)
The description of APCo !!xhibit 81 has been changed to tellect that the doeurnent date is August 1989, rather than August 1986.
(d)
The description of APCo lixhibit 109 has been changed to correctly identify the docuinen',
e P
t
?
-,---w-,,
,,, ~..
.-wm,.-~m,..,..w.,,r--w--....--.--_.---.,,,,.~,._y,-,...,_,,,w,
,_,-,..-.y,,-.cw,_yo..._,,,.,,._....y_..,rm-.,.v.
..mm._,,,-,, _,
Attaciunent 3 r
Proposed Corrections to the transcripts for the February 11-14, 1992, and February 18-21, 1992, l
llearing Sessions L']TNBSS PAG 13 JJb'll CJlANGli I_O FIROM McKinney 900 21
" original"
" reasonable" Jones -
911 10
" modes"
" notes" 921 7
"how did Ben "had it been close" closed" i
Jones 921 25 "him" "them" 928 4
"Kinney" "McKinney" McKinney 937 9
" set"
" sat" Shipman 955 14 "V type" "VTIP" Shipman 958 22 "V-type" "VI'IP" 979 6
" limiter" "Limitorque" Love 982 16-
"that" "there" Love-982 16
" greater than"
" greater voltage drop than" Love 987 4
"with the" "with thread" Love :-
-987-16
" break in"-
"Itaychem"-
Love 988 22
" break in" "Itaychem" 12we 988 25
" break-out in"
" break-out and" Love 1005 16
" power"
" powder" Sundergill 1012 21
" spliced" "specit'ied"
.a_...-.._.__-.-.=--_-.:.,
1 l'roposed Corrections l' age 2 EllfiliSS 1%GE LINE DMNGEfl(Ohl BO Jones 1018 23
" links" "le ngths" Sunde: gill 1021 23 "as we moved "as we used fittings that were fittings that used before" weren't used befote" Sundergill 1030 9
"Section 111.9.5" "Section 3.9.5" Sunde: gill 1033 2
" type of what"
" type is what" Sundergill 1033 13 "end line" "in line" lxvc 1044 18 "past" "shor ts" Love 1044 19 "past"
" shorts" Jones 1046 25 "39" "30" lxvc 1053 20 "ove r" "of our" 1054 19 "h111. hilLLlill"
" hill, ll ACllh1 AN" love 1066 14 "lill" "21111" Sundergill 10S1 3
" table"
" cable" 1083 8
" table"
" cable" s
ime 1084 19
" tables"
" cables" lxvc 1095 22 "isit" "it is" 1102 20 "84-437" "84-47" Jones 1105 11 "50.59" "5 0. W" Jones 110S 13
" acceptable' "unaecept-able"
1 l'ioposed Coriections l' age 3 WITNILSS IMGE 1,1Nii ClMb'Gli_l llOM 10 Jones 1128 22 "Il!O's" "lliN's" lawe 1149 14
" increasing as"
" increasing or" lane 1165
" punching"
" quenching" 1.ove 1165 S
" pull down"
" cool down" Sundergill 1176 5
"a Arr henius" "Aribenius" lawe 1214 21
" hour"
" lit" lawe 1215 JO "195" "95" 1.ove 1216 9
" excessive"
" extensive" 1.ove 1217 10 "S&l "
"SN L" Jones 1217 15 "WITNiiSS
" WITNESS JOllNSON" JON!!S" Jones 1219 6
"J UDGli "WITNiiSS CAllPliNTlilt" JONiiS" Jones 1220 5
"J UDGli "WITNiiSS CAKPliNTlill" JON!!S" Jones 1221 24 "J UDGli "WITNiiSS CAltPliNTlill" JONiiS" lawe 1222 13 "t h e" "t he n" Noonan 1224 20
'"rather' it was"
'"rather it was" Noonan 1224 21
" opinion, the"
" opinion,' the" 1232 4
"l ed lled" "l:cd lleg" Noonan 1236 2
" conclusion"
" concluding"
Proposed Corrections Page 4 i
WITNESS PAGli LIMi C11ANGli FROM IQ Noonan 1239 1
this was plant to
- this plant was safe" safe" 1
Noonan 1247 24 "said" "say" Noonan 1248 15 "have went to "have taken that"
?
that" Noonan 1249 7
" document"
" equipment" Noonan 1259 12 "2206" "2.206" Noonan
- 1262 14 "pla n"
" plant" i
DiBenedetto 1267 20 "ask me every "or may I phrase" rephrase" i
i DiBenedetto 1270 24 "after the" "after leaving the" Noonan 1277 2
'_'I can state" "I cannot state" Noonan 1278 1
"11" "2"
Noonan 1278 4
"11" "2"
Noonan 1278 6
"11" "2"
Noonan 1278
-14
" thinking" "think" I
Noonan 1279 10 "on" "of" Noonan
- 1279 25 "particular" "particularly" DiBenedetto 1281 20 "Noonan as" "Noonan was" Noonan 1290 24 "that in" "that is" DiBenedetto -
1291 20 "different on that" "different than that" 4
Woodard 1302 16 "vice presidente" "vice president" y-4.+,wwy9-,yy-y--gw- - -.
--%y.ws
_p,,yyyy..y,,,.99,.9,9,.p7yyyg.9
,.p.,g
,wy,9.p%,ye--e.g,.%p me,
.ygy,,4mg-y9,,,+w.pe,.w.,9yc
...g-p,q, 9,p_..y.ae-.y-ps.,
g w.,w,9#-e.9,,ypy
s._.-
- ..u..a m
4.--os ap;.sA p-u.sa-._u.
sm,aa_.&M A mma4..e
_..mam4#wm.-...w.--.u.meAh 4,.-w,4h.m%-
a_
4u I
e e
lk) b)b o keh kII)b l' age 5
.MINIESS P60E LLN!!
CLIANGli Flu B1 111 0 woodaid 1.104 ni "g oe s" geis"
-.