ML20087J272

Forwards Info Re Experience Level of Individuals Assigned to Shift Operating Positions,In Response to Request. Tabulation Showing Experience of Shift Engineer,Shift Foreman,Station Control Room Engineer & Operator Encl

ML20087J272
Person / Time
Site:	Byron
Issue date:	03/19/1984
From:	Tramm T COMMONWEALTH EDISON CO.
To:	Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
8317N, NUDOCS 8403220133
Download: ML20087J272 (7)

Text

--

1. h Commonwe:lth Edison

- ) one First h!ational Pitza. Chicago. Illinois C 7 Address Reply to

Pest Office Box 767 x / Chicago, Illinois 60690 March 19, 1984 Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555

Subject:

Byron Generating Station Units 1 and 2 Operating Shift Experience NRC Docket Nos. 50-454 and 50-455 Reference (a): February 28, 1984 letter from T. R. Tramm to H. R. Denton.

Dear Mr. Denton:

This is to provide information regarding the experience level of individuals assigned to shift operating positions at Byron Station. This information is submitted in response to a request from the NRC Commissioners to the Utility Group Jn Operating Shift Experience..

Enclosed is a tabulation showing the relevant experience of the various individuals who will work as Shift Engineer, Shift Foreman, Station Control Room Engineer, Nuclear Station Operator, and Equipment Operator during the initial operation of Byron Unit 1.

This tabulation conforms to the shift operating experience assessment methodology discussed with the Commissioners on February 24, 1984.

A similar tabulation for the Braidwood operating staff is being prepared and will be provided as soon as possible.

Please direct any further questions regarding this mat'cer to this office.

very truly yours,

//hs r/ M =

T. R. Tramm j Nuclear Licensing Administrator 1m cc: H. Thompson Attachment l

l

! 8403220133 840319 l

8317N PDRADOCK05COOg

, A

l P

DATE _N 9- N OPERATENC SillPT FIPE AIENCS I PLAert anAME EyRese )

UTELST1 h wamarLpg [Datwo) 20e TSTits $/ry" b d> M r* S o.s.. o4TE 6. -I, - P4- '" "'

,,octt,, ,0,,En P u,,7 EiPrm:EisCE rOR OPERATING SestFT PO9ITIONS (NOTE il ENTER DATAs P08fffts/MO'eTNS 3 trE3CwTt98G PACTOR WEICNTING MAstmLg g S 6 7 8 0 le TYPE OF EXPERIEECE FACTOR CPEDl? I 2 1

1. SAME TYPE COMMsRCI AL SB0 1.00 NO LIMIT

2. OTuCA COMMERCIAL SRO .75 m0 LIMIT

1. SArtE TYPE COMMERCI AL RO 1.00 No LI4t? g

4. OTNER COMMEPCIAL RO 0.75 No LIMIT S. NAVT (MELITARY) NUCLEAR 4.50 16 MONTNS g'[

(110. EWS EOOW. PPWS) g [ gs/g f If ICTNE*> @*E1

(

a. StMutAfon 1.00 st McnTNS 112 MtwfMSI

,gg,'Qg,gjy,,z4 x ,ay/sr , srj2r (REFERENCE PLANT)

(SINILAR) 3.00 ( 9 miteTMSI y M*J h3hys dsf pK 27 NN 7. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIEMCE M SMIFT (C'ee PIANT) 2 4 MeacTis$ g y g g yj,[g* g/jfg*

ILESS T? TAN 1 t/2 1EAPS P1104 TO F.L.I 1908E TilAN t 1/2 TEAe3 .*1gOm TO F.L.D 0.75 0.54 t il w".?isS t (12 PhMPsil g/g l 4,/f g dl, f M/l_ 4e // 2.,

g b li *

9. LIC SED Ct.AsSenCM TRAt*aING AND EXAM 0.13 9 **C9?itS p fj ggf fgf f f  !

) .

3.75 12 MCNTNS  !

9. PARTICIPATIOff AT OPEAATING PLANT

18. OTMER NUCLEAR PLANT EIPE81ENCE 0.2% 12 MONTHS g ( g y g f [ 3[ [ ff*/

14. C040UCT188G LICENSE TRA!'#ING 0.25 9 904TMS e

12. DECPTE (ENCINEEetNC. APPLIED SCIEfeCE OR '

COUIVALE1TI 12 aeCMT*tS /g (SACi!ELCSS DECDEER (12 TagNSI -

0 t6 s *sT'131 i

tAJSnctATES egcert)

TOTAL WUCLEAR Pt. ANT EXPERIENCES Vf25 MS MT75 41X 495 S*4 NOT PARTICIP ATICes ErPf BIENCg g

//8-[ J(N)

TIf6

• 20% pate/ pres gwEgl STAatur a SnuToome (TES/N06 WS Vis MowTuS Oss Sarr. .76 94 NOTS 13 CEE *tWSTRUCTIONS F0e USE OF NUCLEAR POWER PLA8t? EEPERIENCE FACTORS FOR CNECE ChE OF TWE FOLI4mr!IIG OPERATIIBG SulFT POEtTtossS (OL APPLICANTSl*

• 18 84 f t het petticipetles 3073 2s INCLUDE ALL SWIFT SUPErv!SOAS (SSI. Su!PT S AO'S, REACTOS OPERATORS (ROI , g, , g g, g{FP .

AND SEIFT TEOINICAL ADVISORS ISTAI .

O m- Satte ad toer int er==== r me re2 i .d. et see.t e. , ee.e o ir e.

.g y ,,

Gs,rr J ic u ber a u .e A*J"wn4 Q c. De not ples to use shaf t edelsere unless some unfereseen cites s=

,,/et ePf //N etence etteen.

• ]*g*ugg pery s2 Ss4ffb e& W N#

% Q ,,g

,,- g e 4, J 2 ,,. w ,s.% u e w n JS ee w h AdrwJ

~

o r

> i ,. _

e

• A. r S

Og,-@_ .

a, d& j .

I ~

'r-

',l t e

-f . .

t 2 f k / g 3 r .

9 M

f d- ra//. I J_ ,

j L

E.

r.

o Y  ! ,

= x .

ra d g /

n a

//# [, /

f P

=.

dby . .

e y 4 .

f

/ 4 j n .

a p r i i a y f = -

R O /ag f

h

'g g /

g/ g f/

f u T.

r r

T C

A T

f s.

a

[7 J f h m.

• - F f f.

t r

i.

Gs e e /j2 [  !/2 p V2 f

t

.

4 r

T G

t m

S di r y

p F

A /

1. p t n o

r P

?

ua e

t r

a e s

• g p G t

s .

/

g u .

d a p t q -

i d S 4

/*g ((/ 7 8 g w

o . .

m M

T 4

d.c :, .

3 t.

L O

r r y-O M

t.

g g y 7

2

[a/g f P

E e

n 4 5

g

/

S M

0 e s,

lj /

y, f f

/,f H T

• .i r e

'f T N f P r t._

=

7

/

O M y j p y

r C

t . s i

a g

!w,fg s

E f C )

A /p C I

w r [#t A g

1. , , g f //

7 E C

• a .- -

sa Z T f E s y t

r L

T A

D f f

/j N

C 0O a

E I

T p g

2 g f, u 7 f

/ f 3 R p

o p

t B T , O e O N g F (

g .

J k (,

t s

/j p S s

i S R e u

[ O o ,

c n

T I

, y g /

E T C

A F

f A

R E

A P e F O r C r ) i) N R o S *Ss h

SS33 S S S s SSt E O T '

)

1 M f T I T TI E I "uu HHt t M u n u nnn I R C U? T 'TT TTT T T t f Tti E A E Ml t

M M M I M NI "Nn NW s 4 N n e' wM i P S ET D I I O oOu OrMos o O o o ocm MM 3

C I S -

CO IRr L L L L M "MM MMM M M M M u E NN Ap 422 2 2 9 226 t . #

O o o o s2t 9 T s E( MC 4 3a( t t#S N se u s s 1 n1f 8 231( (

1 1

a t

N A. 'o EN G P t p f PO N I P S a Ij I E

• d CT Ta Rl T I Nn 05 00 50 0 5 5 9 tu ES F TS GT 0 5 0 5 5 7 2 2 O WT  !

NO IC 0 7 0 7

s. 2 00 75, I ON u AP EA T PA S L

PT F

WF 1 1 0 .0 SS I

00 0 0 4 0 A P

I aI AL C

I)

,. C-RI T C EP SA EM N I LP ST A A CA (S WS L T R c ( 'W O P19 PG n A uL S "

7 n o P O Rs Rt N L. L. r( Oa n At WFF MA E 7 oS Sc o d Ea C 0 IS J

Lm (OO TTT E t m E

8 Ees SO Rw Vt a

UP 7  : uI E0 s

[p C E NO R

F IMOC SII mA D N

A fs A EC L

C S

s E

C eI U T PA oS SL PO A i

f O

lRR P m o N p F t PP G e E G C E l o sr P TCFt p C l G : N I R . p eT Is GS W nE I L t Wu wM u P re l

EPR u t N P E /

0 i P P P S. S T IE Sc 9 0 RS CAA t f s A A I

l X . E c S 3 3 A- NfE A p Al t

E R DE E . Y o S LTL 4 de w - EP ETV . Et (

sG TN AT

) I f E T .

L OR L A 0 C LP R22 P f s G Ep  ? . e T z F r

f V

8 f E ud m h*

E C C E

A N

A I

R E A M

M C S

L R I

I C

E M

M CR 9 U L

A I

88w

)o TC S

o tr A

L P

E//

P11 X

E11 TNs O

E N

R S

T O

A e

as sAE a

xS P

E t

N E

C t

a rC tso ET wwSE p0 cE A S

tf L

P R

A t

i m

D T T r U

M a t

S I

sTA US R

EE Co EP Du E!

L Nn m

p 4

O A . E. 8 NAAs L iEnT S S SO IA r

- MO TE P E O R C E C E TS Iwt mh A1tH  ! cLoA nALt *.

E

. A A M M sA LTT C T t G 0 & m J N YT AD E M EP M OLEs nnL oEI P A c n i EvEc C e .

E E SE 0 P (tnO U 2 P s s p E

f I fa L . F P

Y O

C Y C M I

.EH rFN RSP AEO I

C

'n T C E2AS uCS N

. U S a 3 .s O T T (

oT uEI ELM a co m EEsI T u T

A MI T L. E R

E E h

Ti(

nO u((

SS L4(

I T t iA L A R A u T E r

S T g D P U 0 E P

Y M

A T A H M u t

T A V

t" a

C U

M C

I L

R A

P u n c r o t o C e T

o T =SM T o o m

C u

I f,

T S O S O N 0 t 2 S

• 1 0 9 1 3 1 0 1 t 1 M -

N -

DATE J* P- FJ OFFRATING StitFT YtPERIFNCE

~

PIANT NAME E920d UTILITY d. - wmW Ages JOR TITLE 8 [ M 7" ~M {f

• O.L. DATE d** D

• F # ' '

NUcunR POWER P W EXPERItseCE FOR OPERATING SMT FT POSITf 0NS (NOTE 1) TNTER CATAs MONTitS/MONTNS X WE!CNTING FACTOR Mf!CNTING MARIMLM TYPE OF EXPERIENCE FACinn CREDIT 11 S2 3 4 S 4 7 8 9 le

1. SAME TYPE COMMERCIAL SRO 1.00 NO LIMIT pp

2. OTHER COMMERCIAL SRO .M NO LIMIT

1. SANE TYPE COpeERCIAL RO 1.00 ?so LIMIT g

4. OTHER COMMERCIAL RO 0.75 NO LIMIT S. NAVY (MILITARV) NUCLEAR 16 M00f7MS tRO. Ews. ECOW, PPwSI 4.50 (OTNERI 0.25 A. SIMtJLATOR S.00 12 MONTHS (12 MONTHS)

Jg ,gg (REFERENCE PLANT)

(SIMILAR) 3.09 19 tervsTHSt fj g/g

7. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIEMCE ON SMIFT f f*e6 PLANT) 24 MO"t?tts jg ILESS THAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L.D 0.75 f t 2 M("# Tits t 6  !

(MORE THAN 1 1/2 YEAPS PRIOR TO F.L.I 0.50 112 #80MTilst h/j, ,

i

9. LICE *ist0 CLASSROOM TRAINING AND ENAM 0.50 9 MnNTHS {

(OWM PLANTB .

I

9. PARTICIFATIOct AT OPERATING PLANT 0.75 12 MONTMS

10. OTHER NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE 0.25 12 MONTHS g/g g

11. CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAIN!NC 0.25 9 MO'ftHS

12. DECREE IENGINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR E201 VALENT) 12 MOettfis (RAcitE14RS DECREE) 112 MONTHS) --

(ASSOctATES rECREE) (6 MOWTH3)

TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPfE1ENCRs 99.f 4K75 NOT PANTICIPATIOef EXPERIENCE g y TIME

• 20t PN;e/w'R (tsas) M MY STARTUP 6 SNU M (TES/NO) E/ _f[gL seOesTMS 088 SNIFT $ (, f4 sport la SEE

• INSTRUCTIONS FOR USE OF NUCLEAR POWER Pt. Alt? EEFER!EWCE FACTORS rnR CMECR ONE OF TME FOLI4WIteG OPERAT!teG SWIFT POEITIONS GOL APPLICANTSl*

• seOTE 2s IseCLUDE ALL SNIFT SUPERVISC99 (SS), SNIFT SRO'$, REACTLR OPERATORS tRoi $ a. Shif t advisors must be used to satisfr the

• hot part!Cipation esperience* regoiremente of the utility plan.

AND SNIFT TECHNICAL ADVISORS ISTAl .

O

• satet ad taar= tit Probanir me e.g.ir.s. .t i...t ror .Raf t..

y w ,;,, a .wn as xrpf m

• rM*d "7'

1. f d f & 'ar 2 pe d Al** 8 4 8'4 0 * **ppat Oe aastance a** Piaa ta === =h t* ad'i=a'* =a t*** so o =a rares..a care = -

arises.

4t % g,,y,yy g,7 ppggggr og b asTob %W AW 9

% .--==---

t M jk k e  :

ggi 0 .%.

l.

n

• L 2 o _. __ . . _ ...

• 3 5

2. 3 v -

sl 12 *. .

r? ? *

.  :: s :

3I E :

h h h

32 :;

'Q .

'i l! 3 s

)11,$4 1g i~ M 4, I hh h h h ..l1=i j

l -'j. }s ks N 4  % I Ig :5 :: I 5:!

- e 4 1 f ha h E 3- 3 S s '

N ( n 3 .j i i  :

l. 't. ]

< s ..

83.

2 ia q a:

I s

d s_ =

~

ll - - t ) y 4  %

s : 5. ::

is e2 ,

E ~. 8 4  % 9 R isao E

e gi j h <4

{.'$ 1_ i< ' S g i

~

i _ l t <

i i e a,

_ , ,;; ,;; . , ,, ,;_ g s tt: 2 =E 3EE 1

[ *E E5E E

$ I$! k E

M

=

gf ~

Ll 555$ $ $ g 5

, N

=-

=== === -

==- ===- =. g ., g 22

.! l

::  :: :  : : : s .--._ E 5g 8l r.. :::: ;e ss sa se a aee g 1[ =

= = .: -

h, .__

lkEE _

1232 [55 E E

(

-3 -

y $ ll T

4 =:a 8 [RR

_.. . e c- _

"Ij-I su  ;

$g g- $

!a '

A22 s 8::

.=2 a i_nse  : ve g

-t I:

le ne 's s

~~

4

, p@. .

a :E 3

M:0 - 3 3:3 - .c 58ge a

+

t g

. s a y.

[ vvs - e :g $ --

s .v:

g u ue g e'

• gi

_: g

- 1

y. ..

e_

ss

-l--s-._. <=c3 a

- {lt -

.a ng ~3 1

s v v 2.

832 5 *'

" s*

4 1(gs -: e: gi.s. .IEE ,, -355l:v: " E e'n" 88

a i

a l =E . .

" u e[e. ae: si5 5 ""E" 5 SEi 53 I 8 r I-

s ate s.lat:es-r a

n y :t-s:E :s a :n" s usi iI 4'

: ::: a 4  : aiss z

V f ,

5 .

m

• g .. .. ._ _.

3,;

' . $. . $% e 4 s 1: !

e ~  % ,

E n I:

4 ( e w ~ %I i; I* l g s. t l'* * '

h 8 N d $ ~$ i i i  :: : )

@l~ ' 'I i 1 ! $ 4 p4 e2 h ji ;- i 4

E

!~

r N3 u m s 4

.l*i il l -

+ . <<  % sa b" g tljf E 3 t

d. '

3 "r w- w l3 :l !2 _

T.

3e Ne ~ <R k l$$U .. . g g Y U N La b N 3'0 IT _

~

1. i$ 3 )) 14 I. . .

! f k[$j g g $5b5 i

i

!=ti!

n <

e se.

~

<9 x+ i i

GaI 1 - S 9 '  % m I

2. 2% - ~

r 2

I __ __ __

l g:' g,

=

g eeeei ris  !!! ! $

$Il hh5 h !jj isi ,

gl Gl $'$ 5 b M 1- aaavx === === - ==-

Fhh

] l ll e ,

~ ~~ ~

'e EI H E t $=

c.

lI v. - 3. $ $- $. $. $. ' $ E.-- $

[t k E

!2 32 -

E

! g5II

{:I 1 =3 i33

-3 8

V I =.8li_2 gg e 8 E.,.: 3 "

8:

$ 1:! a I~ gi p

53

.. , 9 9. g . l _ f s% e. ~

". 2 2 : E53 3

~

-I 2 g

C I ggg 3 3 3 g I _c l.

13

?d4 y ,

8 a gg

~

!tI Igl d g

t E 8 i'g- l l l I vre_ .

ESS j E]"liE((

2. :_ . g e ra is ~

A I=O.

ll!j4 =E inlli!_gg!!!aili=jlill s

rie: 3,_l .. .- v ! g5I--e- vy

i I EI H )

IIw$

• e: "if 5:! , -  :

e 8

r ! E I -E c- g-isi El 5 .-EgE g

. . H E

!l<t g . .: .: sgg g f

-,.n. _ - - . - - . . . . - - - , , , , , . ~ , - -

. . a e e

o e

DATE 3~bb oyERAT nc S ttr? EurEntrNCE Tb Aosh JOS T!TLEs I 0.L. DATE 4

• h - d NUCLEAR PoNEn PLANT EXPERIENCE FOR OPERATgNG $NIFT POSITIONS 1 NOTE Il FNTES DATAs MONT11S/MO4TNS X ttEIGNTING FACTOR NERGNTING MAKIMUM TTPE OF EXPEnttNCE FACTom CREDIT ll II )) le is 14 ft /S 19 10

1. SAME TYPE COMME 3CIAL 390 1.00 NO LIMIT T. OTHER COMMERCI AL S AO .75 NO Littt?

1. SAttE TTPE COMMERCIAL 20 1.00 MO LIMIT

4. OTutR COMMERCIAL RO 0.75 go Ltst? f S. NAVT eMILt?ASV) NUCLEAR 36 ogfMTMS ano. EwS. Eoow. PPwS e.se l t0TNEsa 0.2s I

a. SIMULATOR IntrEnENCE PLArtT 5.0e I2 rMT4 in2 + 23,3S M 4' 15 ass /gzs A2y4zsazs/i 50.26/425 AZ8425  !

AS//.5 ,0.5//.5d.5 A?st-U AS//.S .A25AE es * : m .'

estMILAnn 3.co __ _

N

r. v;C EAn Pt.w? rxPEn!E?:cE me rietr7 v <w rIxsti s . es ,5/3,73 15//us 't3Azt _ ..

( LE S S T' TAN & t/2 Y?%P

.et TuM i in v:A,S 3P1t

.u:en

?O F.L.I

'9 to r.L.i 0.?s

2. n iu

• • 4*

, ' S/d~40/ 8 /2 ;14/f

t. .te: .iro cuss =mm TutMnc Ano t c.,

t M4 PLANT)

1. . ) .-- ..

lo/5 . bl5 'l8/5 !/o/5 I6/5 /d/5 -

1. PART! CSP 4 TION AT OPERAftNG PLANT 0.7% 12 "";743

13. OTHER NLCLEAR PLANT EXPERIEMCE 0.25 12 C.::ia !f3//#2 29/7.25 74 // 2 12 /3 ZI/J75' 35/T 0.25 9 "i?'it i  !  ! I

11. C*J'IDUCTIMG LICENSE TAAIMt18C

12. DEC9EE tENGINEERING. APPLIED SCIENCE 04 C OUI'/A LE:8TI t 2 't ";" '3 i i g, SACHELCDS DECDEEl i12 ~ !.7346 '

- i

[ L (A330CIATES PE*REE9 !4 1"e

• 415 i I TOTAL MUCLCAA PLANT EXPERIEleCEs 4

]

• NOT PARTICIPATIOBf EEPEntE*8CF

! t TIME o 206 pun / yen NES) 1 STARTUP & SNUTCOHt$ YES/)gQ)

MS Cet Sutr7 IsoTE 1s SEE *IstSTF.7CTh0NS rom USE OF 3BUCLEAR PofER Pt. ANT EIPEstENCE FACTonS FOR CNECE ONE OF TEE FOL5488tNGs OPERAT188G SWIFT PostTIcess ICL APPLICANTSl*

geoTE go IseCLUDE ALL SNtr? SUPE 9VISOAS IS$9, SutFT SRO'S, DEACTOR OPERATORS (DOS O a- S a i r *** * =*r = == = = ** ==** t a == t i e rr tn.

espertence* requiremente of the stataty plan.

n.E partie:Patica AND SN!r? TEGINICAL ADVISORS ISTAl.

O b. Shif t advisors will probably be required, at least for saw sa4f te.

M 9&d*e es pfetd hy4 & Ne#. O " 0.0 Ce t "" ** ' ' ' ' ' "" "" " '" ""'" '"" " " *

, ..