ML20087C759

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Nuclear Plant Experience Tables for Shift Advisors, Shift Supervisors,Assistant Shift Supervisors,Reactor Operators & Shift Technical Advisors.Expected OL & Fuel Load Dates Are 840701
ML20087C759
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 03/08/1984
From: Clements B
TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
To: Harold Denton
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8403130160
Download: ML20087C759 (8)


Text

TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY MKYWAY TOW EN e 400 NORTH OLIVE MTHEET. L.B. M1

  • DALLAM. TEXAM 73201 v.a" .UI."OI".5"I.*r. March 8, 1984 Mr. Harold R. Denton Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Ccmmission Washington, D.C. 20555

Subject:

Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Docket Nos. 50-445 and 50-446 Shift Operating Experience

Dear Mr. Denton:

Enclosed are the nuclear plant experience tables for shift advisors, shift supervisors, assistant shift supervisors, reactor operators and shift technical advisors. These personnel will operate Comanche Peak Unit 1. All experience listed is as of March 1, 1984.

Although shift advisors are not required on all shifts to meet the

" hot participation experience" requirements proposed by the Utility Group on February 24, 1984, a shift advisor will be present on each shift as previously committed by the applicant. Expected operating license and fuel load dates are July 1, 1984.

Sincerely,

' Y 7,a, Y ERC:msc Enclosure c: Messrs. D. F. Schnell H. Thompson Moo 3

'I B403130160 840308 PDR ADOCK 05000 V

A inEVENION OF TEXAN t*TELETERN EEJCTNir COMPANY

Assumptions and Additional Notes:

1. Fuel load 7/1/84
2. Simulator training times include times operating simulator only.
3. Degree column includes hours of technical subjects and months of applicable credit.
4. Numberr. are rounded so multiples may not be exact and may be reduced due to category limits.

aa g

TEJarch 1. 1984 ptJurf NAME COmanthe Peak- OPERATINc $NIPT EuPERIEhCE -

  • UTILITY Texas Utilities Generating Company .

0.L CATE 7 /I /M JOm TITLE: cthi t e e - - t---

NUCLEAR PONER PIANT EXPERIENCE FOR OPERATINt*, SHIFT POSITIONS (NOTE ()

ENTER DATA:

MON 7WS/ MON"1tS X NEIGNTING rACTOR teEICHTING' MARIMUM TYPE OF EXPER!EteCE PACTOR CREDIT '1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 IO

8. SAME TYPE COpetERCIAL SNO 1.00 NO LIMIT JI. OTHER COMMERCI AL SRO .75 180 LIMIT b SAME TYPE COMMERCIAL 30 1.00 NO LIMIT
4. OTHER COMMERCI AL PO 0.75 - NO lit 117
5. NAVY (MILITARY) NUCLEAR 36 94000THS ERO, Ews, EOOne, PPeeS) 0.50 tOTnER: 0.25 4 SIMULATOR _96/24 12 MONTitS (RErERENCE PLANT) 5.00 (12 MtweTHS*

tsIMItaR) 3.00 to MtarrnS) 1. 0/3.1 1.0/3.1 1.0/3.1 1.0/3.1 1.3/3.9 1.0/3.1

7. NUCLEAR PtaNT EurER ENCE On SutrT (ONie rIANT) 24 MONtnS stESS TuaN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR 70 r.L.) 0.75 (12 MoNTnS' ~ 15/6.5 17/6.5 17.5/6.5 15/6.5 17/6.5 15/6.5 (MORE TnAN : t/2 YEAR 3 PRIOR TO r.L.) 0.50 (12 MONTHS) 35/17.$ M ML535/U.5 35/17.5 35/17.5
s. LaCENSED CIASSROOM TRAINING AND EXAM 0.50 9 MontrHS 10.5/5.2 10/5' s.714.3 10.5/5. 2..10/5. ln_m 9
9. PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT 0.75 12 MONTHS .25/ 2 .25/.2 .4 / _3 .25/ 7 El 3 UI7
8. OTHER NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE 0.25 12 MONTHS ,
1. CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 9 MONTHS
2. DECREE (ENGINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR EaDIvAtrNT .

12 MnNTnS 28/2 AS/6 (RACIttt4RS DEGREE)

(12 MONTOS)

AS/6 (ASSOCIATES DECREE) 16 M,mS)

TOTAL NUCLEAR PIANT EXPERIENCE:

34.5 38.3 31.7 38.5 57.2 32.5 NOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE TIME o 20t PNR/preR (NES) 1 1 2 1 2 1 CTARTUP & 3HUTnONN (YES/NO)

N N N N N N MoNTuS ON SutrT

.25 .25 .5 .25 .5 .25 NOTE 1:

SEE *:NSTpuntONS raR usE Or NUCLEAR PoNER PLANT EXPERIENCE rACTORS roR .

OPERAFING SHir? POSITItetS (OL APPLICANTS)* CnECs Oste Or Tut rOLImeetssGa NOTE 28 a.

INCLUDE ALL SHtfT SUPERVISOpe ISS), SHIFT ERO'S, REACTOR OPERATORS (RO) O Shift advisors must be used to satisfy the

  • hot participation AND SHIFT TECHNICAL ADWISORS (STA). esperience" requirementa of the utility plan.

@ b.

Shif t advisors er111 probably be required, at least for some shif ts.

O c.

Do not plan to use sh&?t advisors unless some unforeseen circun-stance arises.

1( '

i i

l DATE Harch 1. 1984 PLAnf NAME Comanche Peak OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIFMCE prILITyTexas Utilities Generating Company t 0.L. DATE7/1/84 JOs TITLE: Amalarmar Ehift C"=aruia^*

NUCIZAR PONER PLA8f? EXPERIENCE ENOTE 2)

FOR OPERATING SHIFT POSITIONS (NOTE 1) ENTER DATAs MONTHS /fDNOTNS X NEIGHTING FACTOR TYPE OF EXPERIENCE WEIGHTING MAXIMUM FACTOR CREDIT 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 le

1. SAME TYPE COfWlERCI AL SRO 1.00 NO LIMIT
2. OTHER COMMERCI AL SRO .75 NO LIMIT h
1. SAME TYPE COpWeERCIAL RD 1.00 N3 LIMIT q
4. OFNER COMMERCIAL RO 0.75 NO LIMIT
s. mAv7 eMILITARY: NUCLEAR 35 MONTuS tRo. Ews, EOOw, PPwSi e.50 30/15 (OrNER: 0.25 60/15 103/21 60/15
s. SIMULATOR 12 MONTuS (RErERENCE PLANT 3 s.00 (12 MONTHS (SInILAR 3.00 (9 surrHSI 1.3/3. 9 .36/1.1 .9/2.8 1,0/3.1. 1.0/3 1 1 0/L 1
7. NUCLEAR PIANT EXPFRIENCE ON SHIFT (ONN PLANfl 24 MONTHS (LESS THAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L.) 0.75 (12 MnNTHS) 17/6*5 17/13 11.5/8*6 17/11*5 15/6.5 17/6.5 (MORE THAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L.) 0.50 (12 MONTHS) 35/1 7. 5 14.6/7.3 12/6 25/12y 35/17.5 35/ 1 7 . 5
8. LICEN ED C ROOM TRAINING AND EXAM 0.50 9 PD)NTHS jg gjg ggj ggfg
9. 'ARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT 0.75 12 MONTHS 29/12 O. OTHER NUCLEAR PLAPT EXPERIENCE 6.25 12 MONTHS .

1, CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 9 MONTHS 2 rt;GIEE (UlGINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR ,

E3UIVALENT) 12 MONTHS (BACHELORS DEGREE)

(ASSOCIATES DEcsEE (12 is MONTHS,D ve ins 12/1 12/1 AS/6 36/3 TfrtAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCP.:

33.9 81.7 63.6 34.9 47.5 32.1 NOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE TIME = 204 PNR/sPfR (Na$s 160 ETARTUP & SHUTDONN (YES/NO)

Y MONTHS ON SNIr?

58 piOTE la SEE

  • INSTRUCTIONS OPERATING FOR USE OF NUCLEAR SHIFT POSITIONS PONER PIANT EXPERIENCE FACTORS FOR (OL APPLICANTS)* CHECK ONE OF THE FOLLONING:

If0TE 2: a.

INCLUDE ALL SHIFT SUPERVISORS (SS), $NIFT SRO's, REACTOR OPERATORS (ROI O Shift advisors w at be paed to satisfy the

  • hot participation AND SHIFT TECHNICAL ADVISORS (STA). experience
  • requsrements of the utility plan.

@ b.

Shif t advisors wil1 probably be required, at least for some shif ts.

O c.

Oo not plan to use shift advisors unless some unforeseen circun-stance arises.

w

- tmTEATch li 1984 etANT NAME Comanche Peak cPERATING Safr7 EaPERiceCE gTILITT T exas Utilities Getrerating Company .

. o.L. DATE_ 7/1/84 - - JOB TIT!ze Reactor Onerator ~ '

NUCLEAR PrWER PLANT EXPERIENCE (NOTE 2) ' '

FOR OPEAATIISC SNIPT POs!TIONS (180TE Il_ ENTEll DATAe MONTHS /MONTNS X NEIDITING FACTOR TYPE OF EXPERIENCE NEICNTING MAXIMUN FACTOR CR(DIT I 2 3 4 I -5 7 0 9

?. SAME TYPE iv.wsRCIAL SRO 30 1.00 NO LIMIT OTHER COMMERCIAL SRO

.75 NO LIMIT SAME TYPE cOsetERCIst 90 1.00 NO LIMIT e

CTNER COMP 0ERCI AL RO 12/12 0.75 NO IIMIT i, seAVY (MILITARY) NUCLEAR (RO. EWS, ECON. PPNS) 26 MOlmt3 (OTHER) 0.50 66[33 3k/II 0.25

s. S!nutATOR 56/14 48/12 60/15 36/9 26/6.5 84/21 (RErERENCE PLAT:T3 12 MONTNS (SIMILAR) s.00 (12 MONTNS' 2.00 (9 m mTHSs .9/28 1.1/3.2 .2/.7 1.1/3. 2 .9/2.8 1.1/J. 2 1.1/3. 2 1.0/3.1 .9/2.8 .9/2.8 -
7. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE Off SHIFT (ONN PLAps?) 24 MONTffS (LESS THAN t/2 vEARS PRIOR TO r.L.) 0.75 (la m arHS) 15/11.2 (MORE TNAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L.) 0.50 15/11. 2 14 /10. 5 17/12. 7 17/12.7 17/12.3 17A2.5 15/6.5 1 7/12. 7 17/ 1 2 . 7 (11 M wTHS) 4/2 R. LI DC 22 .4 /11.2 18N9g 4/2 Z3N11.7 2 3 /11 . 5 35/ 1 7 . 5 !5/7.5 12/6 ROOM TRAINING AND EKAM 0.50 9 MONTHS 8.4 /4. 2 10N5.43.5/1. 7 10.8/5.4, 8.4A. 2 9.1/4.5 10/5 9.8/4.9 8.4 A . 2 8.4 /4. 2 9 PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT 0.75 12 MONTHS 41/I2 9/b'7 lu. *PTftER NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE 0.25 12 MONTHS 12/3 ,
11. CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 9 MONTHS .
12. DEGCEE (ENGINEERING. APPLIED SCIENCE OR EQUIVALENT)

(BACHELORS DECREE) 12 MONTIIS (ASSOCIATES DEGREE) [12 MONTHS)

(6 mmmS)

TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE 32/3 29/2 21/2 34.2 43 39.9 63.6 36.7 41.4 41.* 32 52.7 48.7 NOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE TIME a 204 PNR/pPfR (NgS) 140 25 STARTUP & SHUTDONN (YES/NO)

Y N MONTHS ON SHIFT 53 9 seOTE 1s SEE

  • INSTRUCTIONS OPERAFING $NIFT POSITIONS FOR USE OF NUCLEAR (OL APPLICANTS)*

PONER PLANT EXPERIENCE FACTORS Ff1R CNECR Opie OF THE FOLIm tsfGr 300TE 2:

a.

INCLUDE AND ALLCAL SHIFT TECNil! SHIFT SUPERVISORS ADVISORS (STA). (SS) . SNIFT SRO's. REACTOR OPERATORS (RO) experience

  • tequirements of the utility plan. Shift advisors must be used to satisfy the O e.

Do not plan to use shift advisors unless some stanca artv.g. unforeseen cirrwe-9

. -m

' DATEJren 1 1 9454 PLANT NAME Corner.che Peak oPERATirsG Surrr ExPERi m yTgtITTTexas Utilities Generating Company '

.IOe TITLE, Reactor Operator

  • O.L. DATE 7/1/8/8 NUCLEAR PONER PLAss? EXPERIENCE FOR OPERATING SNIFT POSITIONS (FTE II ENTER DATAs NOIFFNS/ MONTHS 2 NEIGNTING FACTOR TTPE OF EXPERIENCE' NEIGHTING MAX' MUM FACTOR CRFDIT 1 2' ) 4 'I O I O S IO
1. Sant tTrE cw-RCIAL SRO 1.00 NO Lin!T 30/30

.T. OTHER COMMERCI AL SMO

.7% NO LIMIT

1. SAME TTPE COsWtERCIAL RO 1.00 =  !

NO LIMIT 36/36

4. OFNER COMMEltCI AL RO 0.75 NO LIFtIT S. NAVT (MILITARY) NUCLEAR (Ro, ENS, EOON, PrNsp. 36 MnNTHS 6/3 (OTNER) o.50 0.25
a. SrmUt.aTOR 60/15 61/15.2 24/6 5 7/14. 2 12 MaNTuS sRErERENCE PLANT: s.co (SIM LAR) sta ManTuse
3. co is rearruS1 1.1/3.2 1.0/3.1 .2/.7 .9/2.8 .9/2.8 .9/2.a 1.1/3. 2 2 9/2.8 .9/ 2. 8
7. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE On SnarT (Osm PLANT: 24 MoNTnS tLESs TNA* 1 t/2 TEARS PR OR 70 r.L. 9.is tia sawstuS) 15/1 1. 2 '. 6.5 14 10.5 14.7/ 1 1 15/11.2 15/11 . 2 15/6.5 17/12.7 15/11.2 (MoRE TNAN 1 1/2 TEARS PR OR 70 r.L.: o.so ga2 MONTuS) 2 .5/11.2 35/1 7 . 5 11.7/5. 8 7/3.5 4.7/2. 3 35/17. 5 17/8.5 5.5/2. 7
e. Ltc DC ROnM TRA NING AND Ex^M p o.59 s MONTuS 10.8/5.4 9.8/4.9 3.5/1.7 8.9A. 5 8.4/4. 2 8.7/4.3 8.9./.4.5 8.9/4.5 14.1/
g. -

7 9 PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT 0.75 12 MONTHS O. OTHER NUCLEAR PIANT EXPERIENCE 0.25 12 MONTilS .

1. CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 9 MONTHS
2. DEGREE (ENCINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR EQUIVALENT) *

(BACHELORS DEGREE) 12 MONTilS (A5sOCIATES DrcREE (12 MONTHS:

  • ts MorrnSi 20/2 56/5 32/3 TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE:

36 _ 32 78.9 39.1 37.2 31.8 34.2 31.2 35.2 NOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE TIME

  • 20t PNR/ren (NuS) 180 STARTUP & SifUTDONN (TES/NO)

Y MoNTNS ON SNtrr 66 NOTE la

. SEE *ENSTRUCTIONS OPERATING SHIFT POSITIONSPOR USE OF NUCI.EAll (OL APPLICANTS)*

PONER PLANT EXPERIENCE FACTORS FOR .

CNECK ONE OF THE FOLt& ItsG NOTE 2:

INCLUDE ALL SHIFT SUPERVISORS (SS), Sil!FT SRO'S, REACTOR OPERATORS (ROI O a.

' AND SHIFT TECNNICAL ADVISORS (STA). Shift advisors must be used to satief experience

  • requirements of the ott!! y plan.the " hot participation

@ b.

Shif t advisors w111 probably be required, at least for some shif ts.

O c- o= rat Ptaa to N shifL advisors t.se so.e ..fo,esee, circ.

stance arises.

, DATE Jarch 1. 1984 PLApr NAME Comanche Peak OPERATING $NIFT EXPER M .

UrILITT Texas Utilities Generating Company 0.L. DATE 7/I/ M ,yOs TITIz Shift Technical Advisor = .

. NUCLEAR PrerER PLANT EXPERIENCE FO9 OPERATING $NIFT 6CSITIONS (NOTE 1) ENTER DATA:

MONTHS / MONTHS E NEIGHTING FACTOR TYPE OF EXPERIENCE NEICHTING MAXIMUM FACTOR CREDIT 1 2 3 4 S 6 7 8 9 10

1. SAME TYPE COfotERCI AL SRO 1.00 NO LIMIT

.?. OTHER COMMEllCI AL SRO

.T5 - NO LIMIT

1. SAME TYPE COpetERCIAL RO
1. 0tf NO LIMIT
4. OTHER COMMERCIAL RO 0.75 NO LIMIT
5. NAVT (MILITARY) NUCLEAR (RO, ENS, ECON, PPNS) 36 MCelTHS (OTHER) 4.50 0.25
8. LINULATOR 12 MONTHS NIM!E $.'N NEN .68/2.03 .68/2.0) .33/.9 8 .73/2.18 .38/1.13 .36/1.1 3 .38/1.13
7. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE or Sutr7 (ONN PIANT) 24 MONTHS (LESS THAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L.) 0.75 (12 MONTilS) 2.m/2.Fe 2 3 .76 3.Q/2.25 1.1/.83 1.05/.79 .95/.71 .95/.71 (MORE TNAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L.) 0.50 (12 MONTHS)
e. LICENSED CLASSROOM TRAINING ANo EXAM (ONN PLANT)

. 0.50 , MONTNS '10:2f/ 10.28/ 9.68/ 10.53/ 9.93/ 9.93/ 9 73/

%_14  % _ li, 4.R4 5.27 A 97 a 97

. 4.97. j --

9. P'.RTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT 0.75 12 MONTHS IS. OTHE3 NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE 0.25 12 MONTitS 27.02/ 15.75/19.99/ 11.64/ 10.07/ 9.74/ *
31. CON'WCTING LICENSE TRAINING 6,76 3.94 5.0 2.91 2 57 7 'A 9.74{

76 0.25 9 MONTHS

12. DECIEE (ENGINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR EaulvALENT)

(iACHEIORS DEGREE) 12 MONTHS

( ASST <! ATES DrGREE) (12 MONTilS) BS/12 BS/12 BS/12 BS/12 BS/12 BS/12 BS/12 16 kmTnS)

TOTAL NUCIZAR PLArt EXPERIENCE:

28.07 24.87 25.07 23.19 21.41 21.25 2i.25 HOT f%RTITIPATION EXPERIENCE TIME e 204 pWRflygR (Nggg STARTUP & SHUTDONN (TES/NO)

MONTHS ON SHIFT NOTE la SEE

  • INSTRUCTIONS OPERATING SHIFT POSITION 3 FOR USE OF NUCLEAR (OL APPLICANTS)*

PONER PLANT EXPERIENCE FACTORS Fnm - . .

CHECM ONE OF THE FOLLONING:

NOTE 2s INCLUDE ALL SHIFT SUPERVISORS (SS), Set 1FT SRO'S, REACTOR OPEllATORS (RO) Q a. Shilt advisors must be used to satisfy the " hot participation AND SHIFT TECHNICAL ADv! SORS (STA). experience" requirements o! the ut!!!ty plan.

@ b.

Shif t advisors w!!! Probably be required, at least for some shif ts.

O e.

Da not artene, irlanca Plaa to == sha rt ad saar= unies. ome ontoreseen circ- -

i 1

-9 DATEJrch 1. 1984 oprRAf tNG Su!PT EnrERIEsect -

PLAle? MAME COsmanche Peak , ,,

UTILITT Texas Utilities Generating Company JOs 7 TLE Shift Advisor O.L. DATE_J/1/84 NUCLEAR PONER PLANT EXPERIENCE roR OPERATING SHIFT POSITIONS (980TE II ENTEli DATA: MONTNS/MONTNS X I8EIGIITIBIG FACTOR IfEIGBITING MAXIMUM TveE Or EXPERIENCE rACroR CArDIT 1 2 3 4 5 s T e o to

1. sAseE TvPE COnnERCI AL SRO . 1.co NO LIMIT 99/99 60/60 98/98 15/15 23/23

.t. tyrNER COMMERCI AL SRO .75 NO LIMt?

1. CAME Tvrt COMMEsiCIAL RO 1.00 NO LIMIT 3gj)g 4gj4g
4. 011tER COMMERCI AL RO 0.75 NO LIttlT
5. 88AVT (MILITARY) NUCLEAR 36 MONT11S 40/20 (RO, ENS, EOON, PPNS) 4.50 torNER) 0.25 43/10.7 12/3 96/24
s. sa m v0R 12 mw?HS (REFERENCE PLANT) 5.00 (12 MUNTIIS) 1*5/7*5 1/5 1.5/7. 5 2/10 (SIMLAR) 3.oo (9 MuNTisS) .25/.75 1/3 l .5/4. 5 .25/. 7 5 3.7/9
7. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE Ix SMIrr (ONN PIANT)

(LESS TNAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L.) 0.75 24 MoNTi S (12 MONTHS) 9/6*7 9/6.7 9/6.7 9/6.7 6/4.5 .

IMORE THAN 1 1/2 vCARS PRIOR TO f .L.) 0.50 (12 MONTitS) 12/6 12/6 _

4. LICENSED CLASSROOM TRAINING AND EXAM o.50 9 HONTf!S 74jg /4 g gg[$,

8f4 O. PART:CIPAT oM AT OPERATING PLANT o.75 12 MONTHS 4/3 9/6.7 6/4.5 21/12 60.2/12 C. OTHER NUCLEAR PIANT EXPERIENCE 0.25 12 MONTIES ggfy g gf_7 3f,7 26/6.5

1. CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 9 seONTHS .3/.1 8/2 , 1
2. DEGREE (ENGINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR , .

EQUIVALENT) 12 MONTHS taACHELORS DEGREE) (12 mNsTHS) 20/2 (ASSOCIATF1 DEGREE) (6 MtNfTitS) -

TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCES 149.1 88.1 136.9 111.5 120.5 .

HOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE TIME

  • 20t PNR/prfR (Mus)

STARTUP & SIfUTDONN (vCS/NO)

MONTNS ON SHIFT NOTE 13 SEE " INSTRUCTIONS FOR USE OF NUCtI.AR PONER PLANT EXPERIENCE FACTORS FOR CHECK ONE OF TIIE FOLI4H!teG

, OPERATING SHIFT POSITIONS (OL APPLICANTS)

  • INCLUDE ALL SHIFT SUPERVISORS (SS), SHIFT SRO'S. REACTOR OPERATORS titO)
a. shif t advisors omst be used to satisfy the ' hot participation 1807E 23 experience" requirements of the utility plan.

AND SHIFT TECHNICAL ADVISORS ISTA).

O= pa act Plan to use shif t advisors unless come unforeseen circure-stance arises, o