ML20086K518
| ML20086K518 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Peach Bottom  |
| Issue date: | 06/03/1974 |
| From: | Ullrich W PECO ENERGY CO., (FORMERLY PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC |
| To: | James O'Reilly NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I) |
| References | |
| AO-74-31, NUDOCS 8401270184 | |
| Download: ML20086K518 (2) | |
Text
--
- - ---- c-c,; :.r i ame. su.
._a6 r
7 x
. ;, 7 '
..~m hE
. f
, r.4d.A. b- /(. k. h
,17314 n'
s"'
/d
. $.a' l' ]',
,, ',v.,:. Juno 3, 1974
- .. +
L/
3.
Mr. James P. O'Bailly, Director' S,
"D q
. United Staten Atocic Energy Co=~.isaion I'g.g-3 p //M
~ r,. f [
}dW c -
. "... Directorate of Ecgulatory Operations
- (l' ;.["ai, k h lbr #
- C '
- !.<,'
.', 631-Park Avenue
.i King of Pruosia, Pennsylvania 19406
- ] '., g;..
'[.J.;4' j;.
.g gy. 7
.r
. g.,f...,.;,,. y.. q,,.
, gp~~ ^.
s,...3
.Dubject:
Abnor-.al Occurrence 24-Hour Notification e ; ,1 ',,,
. Ajsx
,j. '. '"
- r <...
. s.w 0 ;.9 3
lConfiming c:y conversation with Mr. Phil Stohr, A.E.C. Region.1 Regulatory
' (w.. 54.3 m
i N#
'.. Operations Office on June 2,1974.-.
NM.:y,1 y,e
.. n;.,.. r ',
p
....m.
- n... ;,.
,,?
4.9
Reference:
License Number DPR-44, A=end ent Nu=ber 1
' M %., ;l,l.
?.s.
w.
~
("
r
/
,,y.. Technical Specification 3 3.C.1 and Table 3 7 4 e,.. '. r.'. - '
. h.i.
'#y
..s
.o yg,tla.ll n..
. ci -...
.. c...j
.g,,,.,
7,...
s l. - ~,.
3 ; ',
',1.[ Report No.:
50-277-74.
- ..
- g'i._,.."..,.; d[,p; '.,' p ' '
- . Report Date: '
~ June 2,' 1974-1
., m u.
e.
sh@p e,.
' SAir ' ? W... "l3), '.D '.,., '.""
.7
'i( TOccurrence Ihto:
June 1, 19 4 G
O.P J '. F -
.y W.d.M
':Tecility:
e. Peach Botton Atomic Power Station 1 v.,
4
.. :, ),
.L..,.,. #1, Delta, Penr.sylvania 17314.
?.n,;
c, y./.,,
w, i R.D.
W.-
.~
e..
,.. m i...j.,,,.r
. ;,g,
4'.,;
'n ';. i.
,g*;,
7.,
3
, ;" e g
J.
,,' O.Tailure of EPCI pu=p diccharge valve (ID-23-20N
, D.J: n ;.b. ' ?, ',c{ C'C'l
- k., ',
V:
LYY a~
d-G R
.16entification of Occurrence:
7::~
[$ke -
ch. : g s
m, n;;
- .o,
N,.w..LConditionsPriorto'Occurrenee$,,..\\.'
' N' N, ' d' 'O
- U D' '
h'ki' * -
.x W
0
' Reactor shutdown with primary coolani.Mceperature 'leca thaE 212 F a$d the
- f. 7Q
]pgg;
' l:J... : renetor preecure veccol vented.,
g.,
.6,
.;, j,7
.;, y ' ' '.
s ;, ; ;.... : y. ;. :. :.
. :.,4 si.;
pi;g.
.y Description of Occurrence:
-t-F
.y.4
.pl M
- ".+ '. J;.During a routine test of ce=ponents fed fro:n a cotor control center which g;j.>
? ' Rhnd been returned to cervice following the insthtion of scicnic lateral D-
.M -
'.;rcotraints, the EPCI'pu=p diceharge valv'e motor was observed to' operate
.$@k.(.i
..Y'll,, uithout moving the shaft of the valve in or out..The valve stem was
} V ). J
.,, g f...,.. 2, n,.
4$py 4.[J:itrotating freely.
o;q.g.,. 4 C r'.y.,. s.
+
l Q;.('
y,..>,
..g ',.
l"cly.!p.7.
( g' /TM."',.. [g' ""4gl,,.
,.y c}
Q Q :-
p, 7
',T
,,9" designation of Apparent Cause of Occurrence:
Q.g.
.,'..lInvestigatien and dic:.antling of the valvo indicated that the valve stem f'.i' r i.:.; i bad' thcared just above the point at which it connects to tho valve disc.
i jsf'.;'/
I
,}:,4 Additional investigation dicelosed that the limitorque operator torque hM j.
,., evitches were inoperable because of an accurulation of greane'in the bellows
..X.
k.
r
[k[.gY(
g/,"vanherassemblyassociatedwiththetorqueswitchmechanic2. Apparently, o ru a..,
- the chaft had sheared since the motor van not de-energined by the torque M
'~.;,,"cwitch at the end of ctroke.
s.., b
't
.,n,
z'
... %.7e;,..,. e,<, y.q,, 3..
..c ;,. a yQ
,...., w -
eo e: :. a.
s 4.
.;,,. m.
. q3
, n...,
sn if.g,m.
- 7. -,.. o 1
I. nAlys[a of Cccurrence:
YM l.[ N,
", b
I,5;
[ c
'.7
! ([M [!
.., y g $,.,.n:.The inner EFCI pu=p discharge valve la nor: ally in
'(the HICI 10 in standby ready for auto =atic initiaticn. ':he'faildo orgthis L :l M
TT p:galve therefore does not affect the operability'or the EICI?synts anO f., ghA
.so c
4 gg ;,.0;.,<therefore has +N1 safety cignificance, ;4 <.,, ';.e,j'j%'
R.". h' l:./.R.j-
, g,sWm p o
'.;q., M,'i., ca.y g p' l
, j %g em.cn "T
5'
- . e
- Corrective Action:
- .;f A f
4 @.e W r
.4
.m...
- Tollowins investigation, a new vaNo ste
- z was installed idd' valve
' '1 b[ '
.U'
.,.a e...i.. operability verified. In o.rder to. prevent the. accumulation of denne
,,V mic@ *.
. 3.
~ ~ ~
l
, "'; fin.the, bellows vacher cechanim, a grease bypaca line vas added to the j.
.~
M.x.,z.
t
- - p==L 4 _ _-
%g
-. -, - _ - w w n,x_._,= u ; =.n ;;. m. m a T _,.;. >
%.A
. ~,..
,. :, e,. -
m.
.,... ~.......
.n..
., y,
'O
% valve operator.
' codification was done with t oncurrence of I
'E the operator ennufat, "er.
Mdition of the 5rence t,,6co line permits
'the greace to bo pumped out of the Bellville vanher assembly during o
iralve operation.
) l '. '(
jp
/
,e,.
,;.[ [.g 1!
q,,,,,
n
- x.,,.....,,..,,;...c;<e.
.3.
..s. :,.
3
..I/( i -
L.'
- G..,
,.1...,
.c,, i e.!N1ure W a51
. :, ' No previous failuron of this valva have been reported.
- 9.. < '.g. / /. t
.- e.
....3-... ';,...<:...
i
-4 a
.J'+'
.f.t,
r m,,
,... i
' d"
,P;;
/r
. YM.'.s,.. e *.
ed 4.,
e'
'Mi *y.
98,3 * '.
i. (;-
[',' (-'
.),.
. ( (; S
, = ~
n ',
i 3
,e
- . i ya',
.' ' g,f,
1,,',y,..
, c '.
.e..
m.i
, ?,,..>
,r
,3.,.
a,
- y.
4 i
i
..r, a,,...
s
..c.,
m.
. u c....,,,.,,s
.. o..
very truly pura,
, -i,.s
- c. C y'
,.,. y %.; <,
~.
s 6,
,,'.fW2/2.M
'.y Q,. y
.'g e j ' s, O,.. y' S, f, '
' Y.
/ [.
.- : v. T. Ullrich, superintendent m ~, : ' ; 3,i' c 'q,,,
' Peach Bottos Ato=ic Power Station.
Y-MW ',e...
~
.,D
,.*.I' i' '
.,1, q f, eiso' l
=
- r.,
e.
,a
,Y s'
,s'.
v..,
~,,,
r-I.
, s
- p
.'o
.j, s'
it 'o l'
,.p, t.
,,t,,
e.
i 3.
'5,
.=
i,
.,e.,
g, rs e
2,' 8. r,
- A. #,'. s u-i ff
.L..
,o e
t *-
.g.
o er
'+
e
.t.
g,
- 8. s.......
I.,.t,s..',
s.
+
a
.s.
,.,.t"
,f.-
f " i,
,de i.
e - '
,., g -
.g;
- ,_i., : g,. : 4-
.e'
. t
,e s r'
... ' - J )
.c I..
L,
....f,,
(, s.
i
'g.,,
,s e
i e
.f..,
i
'l
,J.
'#.h' 1
- i <"
- /.
,.g..
7
,,s+'),,.
'[, i / i
-, ", [
', ~,
{ta y-4g
,'l.' [ ],
i
,g,
..l, e.
e t
, m,
,,..,b.
,..A,
"i,'
tl. "-
f.
,a
- 1
- * - f'
,5,l ' '
s g.
.s i ,.
i
,i g '* '.
t
'f,y F '
- " ; #l y l, i.'
,Y,
.. e.
- g, 5
rp
,., p,
.n e
l.
, t,,
r.,
,,,7.=
,7 ep i. y t..
M,-
t:
J
.g+
,r.
s 1$
,a 8
g.
e
..(.
. 1,;.,. E,,
- e. ',,i.., (,; '.
,1 e
m, t.
J.
.a, k
g,-
. gP.
g.
(. ?* *, i j. g, i
,t
'd.
s 6
e
..' l'. q-5*V.-
f p
.,'.'.,e*
.a
- e., p, a ' *
',s.'
i. -.
,,)..
c
.8 i
e
)
r,
..,s,.,
, I s
,. 4 5. ' 4,,
,,.et-
,'.r g,-
g,
.,..i
.g
.a p
9 1
s,
g.
. t. 5 e...
- [,'
I N', e T
l.
- is.'.
2
[
f a 1I+
j ' ; u, [. >,,
(
f
?e
- * {-
,, j i
, %;').,
s 3
e..
s u.
L'*
- .'.o<
., s, n i
s
,-t,
- j- *' * : o ',
..l i
, c-
.t s
,,,a r
- t 3
i.
.s.
s..
o o
3..
' ~4 e
,' sF ',
="g,,.g".
- i. '
ig
'.P e
...;+.l, 5.
i O
, 3, '
, t,
, 5;
- .g~
,8..
.'l q e,3,, e e -,
s
4gI
,'/.,.',f i-
.W
- l s
8
,t.'
8 L.,
s
..3, a
2,'**
,,,"**'h' a
. 3*
,.j
- 4 g
, ' + ',
'l'
.t-t.
e
.y
. ]...
..l',
de - i4.,
,.[.
I' I e I 9
a i 4
,t..
- s
.t
- ^
' y '. ) '. '. '..
I W-
- 1. ' "
f, t,
's
.~ c. '
"1 -
i as e
- *.. v
,,o,,
.,p, 4
4, i,,..,,
n[",
. 'i
[p.
,.f 9
,6
+"
g s,,
,e
.[
e,.
",. a, 3-i g +,4
,J-e at a
,6
' /%.
- I;.
s p..
. n'. ' 4, l' g.-.,te
,,g o
e t>
t g ' e' p". f..
4
,'P' 6
.t
,,. g(tj;
.,-}-
,(,
.( )
e g
s i
- 5"
.I..
s
- ?***g',.,.)
o
\\,-
s
..j*,
s a l',.
.1 p.
.e..
6
.i e '
.St-
....G'
..\\..
.g"
~.-
e so**
t
. g,1q,,
y
. "t it-* 'i,,. '
.\\
.,p 6.'.N.. 4 8
- .l'.-
a
8 O
... [ '. ' ' 0 6,..
4 t
s, i.,. a g
. s
,ve...
e e
.p,,
q
- ..l.,.-
m.
s r
e
,m ty oi..
...,y",
..n,cr -
e s g et I.
e f,.
'^.....
'. it,
'W
,.es b
^,':. 8 i'.* ;.. '. - v
\\
r e.[ ~ A i "go
- sn i
..i'
.y e.
,,. i s
.g 1, '.
's
, J J'-
g.
i.
fy-e-
e g
, g, A'
. f' I
s J
s'
' il 5
,8,
'lj,'l o.,i,
1..
.,,.i s. ! *
,*i
.. i - d C..,,.,..!A.','
i
- s i
.,,,y i
. -..,.. G, d..o, ' e 1
,i 3
.d*
a s,.
..g.
,6.t 4 de. 'f e.w -
.4...'t..
)
3, '
. b.,\\,,. '. ' 6 g.
,.,,d g
e a...' r A
e t...u
,'.!d:.
a e u. slL a..
1 e
4,,i s
- e 6.sl h. -
e l
tl i
l.-
i, 3r 5
bc 11 iI r
I ti t
4 t-o