ML20084D065

Affidavit of ML Miele in Support of Util Motions for Summary Disposition of Contentions 16.E,J,K,L & M Re Public Educ Brochure.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML20084D065
Person / Time
Site:	Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png
Issue date:	04/26/1984
From:	Miele M LONG ISLAND LIGHTING CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML20084D046	List: ML20084D043 ML20084D048 ML20084D052 ML20084D058 ML20084D065
References
OL-3, NUDOCS 8405010175
Download: ML20084D065 (1)

Text

-

LILCO, April 26, 1984 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Fbtter of )

)

LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-322-OL-3

) (Emergency Planning (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station. ) Proceeding)

Unit 1) )

AFFIDAVIT OF MICHAEL L. MIELE IN SUPPORT OF LILCO'S MOTION FOR

SUMMARY

DISPOSITION OF CONTENTIONS 16.E, J, K, L AND M (PUBLIC EDUCATION BROCHURE)

Michael L. Miele, duly sworn, deposes and says as follows:

1. My name is Michael L. Miele. I am employed by the Long Island Lighting Company as the Radiation Protection Section Supervisor in the Nuclear Engineering Department. In this capacity, I have experience using dose control, dosimetry, and whole body counting.

2. The dose levels requiring evacuation (5 rem) are extremely unlikely and have never been experienced by the public as the result of activities of the commercial nuclear power industry in this:ccontry.

Micftsel L.' Miele'b Subscribed and sworn to before me this. day of m , 1984.

I i J3 fd yuan., n ca Mycommissione*Lres:nonie on ry ,

2 c G . .o' 'Mrfa, 93f) //

bk tot 5 Y?/ S c4id u.N 8405010175 840427 DR ADOCK 05000322 PDR

& l l

Keeping Current l' l l I

l An open hne for ne:qhbors of the Shcreham Nuc! ear Pcwer Stat on i c ' ";

• W

'.3 ~ .s.

. ; - , :,u :. ~.

r .y ~gn. =

t l

.- t< --

t' e' - 2 . i  ;

r --.. '

"s . ,, ,

.f. , ,

. p. yv7 . - .

J

..-.ye.,;.

==._og. . m.  ;. . .. i

- ,. 1

. . ..o..>s . ;.. ..r~. .

9 8 \

C ers ye : ,y  :.s -,

x) [

i , .- , ; e- . 3 ,.e .

I $ o ';3 ;;c' < s '.' t ' . . .

\

c= . m s. ~ C c :.  : .. m. i

.U -

...~,..s.,.

g 1  ;

i

c. . m . :. , . , . . ..- ~.e ;~.m. ;u , -

t

. ' .N ;0 > 9 ' ^ 0 = " .3 . 's 1? '" 1 m :. v :...

4 f .

.m .:, - .~ .

3'a -11.o" '. F 11 ,Jr l',. O JJ 2 ;;c) 4 ;

• I"Je O' gaf" 9 ) - - I'

~ *' ' '

. - , . . . . . . ' '!] =. .* ;l i' .. c c 1 , \ . ca .- ..y  ; y ev*

, .. t CommunitF Groups ParticiPate in - = M ~7.i,,2L4~~G

. , , . , .. ~ ,.

Emergency Plannh1g for Shoreham .7;,.;;;g;;;g.L. .,.

..,.<r. ,.e ,.m

.

• y. i ,e '

,, ,; 3 g-, g r ,,, y , . g i ,;c3 g.ege ;o ;, in '3;! *e A ad 'eyn ";*

r;r . y -i v. i ** n' ra ~ .) ;-- So Q, ;f ;y ;r ,, :K  ;; 3 6' = " 1.en A is '"O ' '

• 5..;" l': ; .

r <c r y. , 'e

• eq , ,, , a_ t .

.n 3 .p. . ,y 3 q ; ,,,~ ,w. y T r ' ee ',' e ! $ )* j * 'T9 Ne f Y 12 . , .

'r r '. OP , e - y y .- p 3 3 t, ..m - i ,, ,) C"C P"e"t C' E"C' ) . 00"? ~ 0'e ' ' l^

0 ; .. .

• i c .;, ~, 7, . p 1, -

C rTJ,e ;r tcec 3 sts 47"

' g

'. ,y < i ;.3 y-  % ,7 .,

.g ) g.3.,yg ggr y. .c g r . -. "' *; 4r : f 'r e ; f" , ' S I' ' yo *.' o [

q : . .v - " y '

o, ,

, yty crp,s.

.. .g ; r, ) .,. ~, ,, ,, - ) ;. . p. c

's tr':1 '; e cr ?:' 1"O 1: c y '1] r 'a >

\

[ ' ,' l ' 3 4 . '

". A J S r g,e im pdQ, n 3.

, . . ." *

• P " ] '" e r ,,C .1 F

, } ! ,}{ [ 3 0 "' e je[n'" ) ; r 4 , og} ;* 'r e 3 p ge,) .er .,3-. S ' , e " ) , 0 #'" M d d 'Q } ' Al'<lS3 f 1 JCCde C l ' i *;' C l , [ '.*,e ,; g y [ y' g g r *.y,* g a <1j,

,  ;;) 5'Y d C , 5' l' 4 5 " e 0. 0"' ! A 13

.) ; * ' ' " .'. C u ; . '. \ f e *P :00 '3 't? SCC ?d i: '"e ' )%)

.c g m Q" *;*e 3 y'(3 3$#g5 y qr'* ,,y , a, $

TO ::e'a"e eo 3r, e l'e ' a c.,t c .r,,

~,r.-%. ..*g.n

. e , -. c., ,,,.*n a -

r0 ';er' y G rra ic ey 3'P Cn

• l i

O .50'0 **" C 0 , ^+

1" t c ;eN P 19M $ AXreste' (

Carf Ppd Cn CQ 2 I i

l l >

EWGffenC)' Planning fot' Shorehatri CCrevved ? rom ca;e f 6

If an emergercy occurred at tre atmosonere and " C enuronmert Acu!d re y rea6 on tre arCA'ecge Shoreham. tre Deortmert of O'rers wouid rema n x tre Lao to and emert se of tre Decar' ment Cf Energy's RAP team at Broorha,en assess tre rreasuremerts And =n tre Erergy s RAP team n t e e,ert v an would te avasace to respond at any Case Cf Shorenam st J Ctrers Acad aCC:dert at ' e SrCreram NLC er t:rre. day or n4grt A*er a Care'ul aCt as adesCrs to tre LeCa Power StrCr PeCCm eacy Ces 'Cr assessment of tre e-ergency tre Emergency Pescorse OrganiCyon sceC'C crctect we a:tCn sucr as RAD feam CSC!a n on dut, at l' add t. oral 'edera R AP sreter ng Cr evaCuMCr acu a Ce Brocura.en CCud avCoy Crgan<Ce eersonrei Aere reeced e.ce'erced cased on tre nformxCr tra errorgency response teams Eacn team memters CCud te sert from assessments prov ced c, :re team team Aculd te Comer: sed of tre CeCaamert of Erergy ' acnes suCr Used Stres Cecr'mert st Ere'g, s aCCroDnWe persCr'rel for tre as tre ENr0rrrerta; *.teasu'ements RadciCgca+3% stance P'ogram par

• Cuar inCldert Ire 'nlat resCorse LabCrxCry n New YCr* C.!, KnoS foCSed at Br0C*ra.en Ny Cea team woufd CCrs st Cf af eas! $n Atom C LacCryory n $Crenectady Cr LaCCrTOry 's :Ls! 0"e 'aC9! of CCa peCDie tre Be"$ AtomC LaterxCry n Commun.!y par'.C cat Cn in emerge Cs

$orre merrters of tre team Pascury p! ann.n] 'Cr tre SrCrena- N C ey would go out :rto

• e 'eid to aCt aly 80ta L:LCO and " e LoCa Power jtyCn reeasure !"e r"ou rt of rad m on n EmergenCV Aescorse Organ.Ca!Cn Radiation - Where it Comes From

- and - How it Affects Us A uf 0^ "h teen A in us s nCe A stard t'd treasu*er"cr! of r3d;at.on is about 200 rmrem caCh

!"ea te_] Pr'eg ;' ? me We Me fld T Cn s Ca'ed tre tem 3 nce ye3r CCPsW'N MINe] *c ra j Y on ' rem rPCs! e CCsv r es 'ew!

• Criy stral Some AmenCar$ rece.e mCre tre t CtCre'e s J" C ra,s In ' factors Of a rem 're, ye o"en radation If you hed n Cenver 'Cr add!Cn ra3 Ca:! .e eeme"!s soCh 3$ desCr Ced n terres of tre mirem enamp!e you Aculd rece%e more r 3d um and ur a"LM Ci s! *a rCughout - Cr Cre !nCusanct" Cf a rem CostnC rad 2tCn than if you hed at tre ACrtd TF 5 Creyes an env rorr"ent teFeve' bec3use hyer atfAes on ey'nt"at s WA1,9 r3d CaC!T e Exposure Levels 'acewe more natural radiat:en Our soit tre store and erC s Ao use to Dudd ( r PCr#es '*e ' Cod Ae eat The artiCurt Ct rad xCn eaCn of *

• W *N ** #9 a^d tre AYer 40 d' rn Ne al us recenes deceads On def tre N mMeh W e evat Cr's of radCache E.en tre ar Ao trerne *

• C" # 4D#"

CCrta,rs r"&0' a s '"at Ne nMur 19 our homes and wor c' aces and tre amount of rredCal krav$ Ae receae @

C # 'O Stud:es by go%ernfre"t and praxe about onefa:t is from natural sources Understanding Radiation fn [e e f"e

e t no t e otrer ha!f is from man-made Trrough most of our history we 100 mdhrem a year from nxurat " "5 ACr3 una Aare Cf FNur al radat,on rada!;on in our eneror'rvent and being re' eased around us Deons Cf about anotrer 100 matem from Effects of Radiation f.mCS a seCond Out n !!'e Century meOCal and dental procedures

$nce rada!on Aa5 OsCovered it has Using the most Current and in add. ton. government sClerts!s beCorae one of tre most A'de#y estmate that f3 lout from past tests of sophist:CTed techtsQues avalable, studCd and best understood noC: car weapons adds s marem Sc"St5 c3' *d " 3Do3'"' *$

processes 'n al of nature Some Consumer products. IAe from exposures to low levels of R3ECn is easly detected and luminous watches Color te'ev's09 sot $. radation Lke thos0 GsCussed mCasured There are instruments that and smChe deteC' ors W fn strSl We do know that esposure to Can find even a '0w faOcaCtae atoms radoachve CorPoonents gae off very large amounts of raGaton oser a among b*or's of ron-raOcaCtae adalonal Onposure A;together the short period of time (several minutes ones We Can '"eaSure the precise tota! Sverage esposure of most to several hours) Can Cause serious amourts of raJN on to wn>Cn Ao are Americans to natural and man made C: posed injury to Cell t:ssues and even death Continued on og 3 2

\

Larg3 doses of racaton to oregnant TYPICAL RADIATION SOURCES ON LONG ISLAND women can impact the deveicoment of an unborn endd A;tnough there is Sources and amount of annual radation exposure. accorong to no Compar3bte evidence for humans- tj $ gosernment rea.th and environmental experts animal studes show tra! !arge doses Mahrer-can Cause genet.C d3r" age whCn ce conttnues trrougn sescral gereratons 23 C' 0"50MO Cosin.c rays from tre sun .

23 What do we mean ty 1a'ge Natural raccactvty n water. ' cod and a.r .

23 cases of racaton t A persco must Natural raccactvrty in sol and rocks

.64 to esposed to at least 25 000 to Meccal and dental X rays 34 50.000 mithrem within a srort penod Fallout from weapors tests -

fess inan 1 of timo before it 's poss. ele to observe Routre coeraton of nucear pow 6r plants any minor yet resersao4e blood enanges This eiceeds the federa! Total 137138 hmits on pubhc racaton esposure by 50 to 100 t.rres it would require a mass.ve dose of radaton - 350 000 mahrem - Mnin a snort pened of time to cause senous diress or deatn.

There are very 'en sources of racaton from anch ceooie mignt ,

receive doses hign enougn to resuit in racaton exposure Aper more tran 50 notceaDie edects These sources are What about rad at.on teleased as not oresent as a routre part of our years' esperence they recommend a 'esutt of an accdent hke tre ore at hves Escosur e to radaton from tne ,y g, etoioSon of nuC'ea' weapons is ore miltrem a year For members of tre sucn source Treatment of osease pre.ented a ma;or re' ease of racaton Mh radaton treracy. a:Inougn a highty controfed proceJu re. 's another Raoaton and reath experts of 500 merem above tre exposure g

source of hign rese<s of eiposure in a severe acedent at a nucear power ,

piant - cre <n wh:cn a'l tre nucear MJe Island. Even stand ng in tre A ma,ority of the scentsis and fuel would rre't and a:1 of tre many bartcrs desgred to prevent p! ant for 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> a da/ dur:ng a 10 on racaten concude trat trese radoa3se material from en.er.ng tre federal limits on raeabon esp 0sure are day penod, a person would rave environmert wou'd fad - peop'e received a dose of only 80 mArem procaoly very conservatve and ot'er could a'so be encosed to onngerously The average exposure for the an ample margin of protecton.

hign Cveis of radat.on The chance of coulaton within 5 miles of tre piant . Protectve Acton Guidehnes have tn's haopervng is outremely remole. 1 morem There has also been estachsned by the Environmental Protecton Agency for never been an acedent at a nuc! ear power plant in the United States not protectng the general public in the Radiation and huclear Plants m d an aceden at a Mear What leveis of rasat:on emposure w m h W M M has power plant. These guidehnes. which exp sed me public to the level of do people receive from nucear power een a year's naMal radaton incude shewg Waymg odoors) plants? The routne oporation of a and/or evacuation, are irstiated when nucear power olant is actuaffy a the protected dose to the general Radiation Guidelinee minor factor in tasaton exposure, populaton is expected to be between Even the people who hve nearest a Based on the recommendations 1,000 and SM murem, lees wWl plant receive less than i merem a of the international Commisecn on be6ow moes W to result m any Racological Protecton and the effects on human health.

year. This is less than the radaton National Counct on Radaton Protecton and Measurements. the 3

5 LILCO, April 27, 1984- "

k -

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE s in the Matthe of ' '

LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY c .y (Shoreham Nuclear Powec' Station, Unit IT s A

(Emergency Planning Proceeding) .

Docket No. 50-322-OL-3 '

I m _  %,

I certify t! hat copies of LILCO'S MOTION FOR SUMM1Rh DISPC SITIOt.' OF CONTENTIONS ~]6.E, J, K, L, AND M (PUBLIC INFORMATIOP \'

BROCHURE), including an Annex and supporting affidavits'of f '

Carol A. Clawson, Edward,B. Lidberman, and Michael L. 14ie le , -

were served this date. upon the icilowing by first-cliss mai), - )' ,

postage prepaid, or, (as indscated,by one asteriskV Ef band, ior 1 (as indicated by two asterisks;'by Federal, Express. '

3'A-s , - x

' Secretary of the Commis'siin James A. Laurenson, g' Chairman

• x ' } d:

U.S. Muclear Regulatory, Atomic Safety and Licus'ng Com.sission s > ' <

Board 3 \ Washington, D.C. 20555 7 g 3 ,

,(

U.S. Nuclear Regulatori' .- N g , t' Commission ,, Q Atomic Safety and Licensing 1 U(%

i \, , (.

East-West Tower, Rm. 402A - Appeal Board Panel 4350 East-West Hwy.. '

,. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory '

3 ,;

Bethesda, MD 20814 Commission m <

s Wash in:jton , D.C. 20 5 5 5'N Dr. Jerry R. Kline* ,., ,

, y A'l h' gl. -

Atomic Safety and Licensing Atomic Safety and Licensiog O Board Board Paral ,

I'! g U.S. Nuclear Regulatory ' -

U.S. i Commission f-Nucl?ar Regulatory',

Ccm.ission ','z ,

s East-West Tower, Rm . , ,4 ?1 Washington, D.C. 20555- ( l  ; N*-

4350 East-West Hwy. }  ; '

Bethesda, MD 20814 Bernard M. Bordedick,Esq.*}F,, \ N David A. Repka,\ Esg.'

Mr. F reder ick J'. ..Shon

• ss

' h Edwin J. Reis, Esq.5 1 /

Atomic Safety and Licensing U. S. Nuclear Reiulatory.,

Board  ! Commission  !

CN' U.S. Nuclear Regulatory h 77 35 Old Georget'own k'o ad .%' ' t' '

Commission (to mailroom)' A 'N f s East-West Tower, R3. 430 "

4 '

Bethesda, MD ,20814%. '\ %*

4350 East-West Hwy.

4 s

\

Bethesda, MD' 20814 , Stewart M. Gla ss , , Esc'. * * .3

• s Regionel.Couns61 .

I Eleanor L. Frucci, Esq.*

Attorney s 9,

i FederaV,EmergtScy Madagement Agency .,ai

\\ '} 3, Atomic Safety and Licensing 26 Peder/tl Plaza, Room 13M y

Board Panel 4 '

New'Yorkh ~ '- New York 10278 u V, U. S. Nuclear Regulatotyg '/

7' , <  %

h -

Commission \ \_ f Steph$n B. Latham, Esq.** Q ' [,/* t East-West Tower, Nor,th Tower Twomey, Lafham & Shea  %'t 4350 East-West Highway '

33 West Second Street '

I Bethesda, MD 20814' b Post Office Box-398 *l s /

i + % R2ischead, NY 11901 i *

.s

• ' -; ) 3 N

,y c.o , c .

g ,

3

~I 4 _y,+

A'* ..

h,_,

7-

.4 i,

o Fabian G. Palomino, Esq.** Ralph Shapiro, Esq.**

Special Counsel to the Cammer & Shapiro, P.C.

Governor 9 East 40th Street Executive Chamber New York, New York 10016 Room 229 State Capitol James B. Dougherty, Esq.*

Albany, New York 12224 3045 Porter Street Washington, D.C. 20008 Herbert H. Brown, Esq.*

Lawrence Coe Lanpher, Esq. Jonathan D. Feinberg, Esq.

Christopher M. McMurray, Esq. New York State Public Service Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill Commission, Staff Counsel Christopher & Phillips 3 Rockefeller Plaza 8th Floor Albany, New York 12223 1900 M Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036 Spence W. Perry, Esq.**

, Associate General Counsel Mr.l Marc W. Goldsmith Federal Emergency Management Energy Research Group Agency 4001~Totten Pond Road 500 C Street, S.W., Rm. 840 Wal tham, Massachusetts 02154 Washington,.D.C. 20472 MHB Technical Associates Ms. Nora Bredes

, 1723 Hamilton Avenue Executive Coordinator Suite K

Shoreham opponents' Coalition

,N San, Jose, California 95125 195 East Main Street Smithtown, New York 11787 Mr.XJay Dunkleberger New York State Energy Office Martin Bradley Ashare, Esq.

Agency Building 2 Suffolk County Attorney Empire State Plaza H. Lee Dennison Building 4

Albany, New York 12223 Veterans Memorial Highway Hauppauge, New York 11788 Gerald C. Crotty, Esq.**

, Counsel to the Governor Executive Chamber State Capitol Albany, New York 12224

&'Renee K./ Falzone  %

Hunton & Williams 707 East Main Street Post Office Box 1535 Richmond, Virginia 23212 3

.% DATED: April 27, 1984 y.

k n