ML20083J701

Forwards Bechtel in Response to Issue Re Bypassing of QC Hold Points.Ack Requested If Response Acceptable

ML20083J701
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	12/22/1983
From:	Quamme D CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To:	Baranow S STONE & WEBSTER, INC.
References
CSC-7110, NUDOCS 8401050371
Download: ML20083J701 (8)

Text

f.

~

COOSumBIS Power oat *--

Site Manager Midland Project M4tand Project: Po Box,1963. Mediand. MI 4864o * (517) 631865o

3PRINCIPAI'. STAFF

50. M4 v

(4DPRP 1

M -)$

!DE W

'DRMSF

/ E' 4.DRMA December 22, 1983 "A0 scSy N

jGA_

yt G

-NF, pggg f

l Mr S W Baranow Stone $ Webster Michigan, Inc P O Box 1963 Midland, MI 48640 MIDLAND ENERGY CENTER GWO 7020 BY PASSING OF QC HOLD POINTS Serial: CSC-7110 File:

Bl.1.7, 0655 UFIi 9908, 53*50*04 Attached is Bechtel's Letter No BCCC-8837 dated December 19, 1983 in com-plete response to the issue regarding the bypassing of QC Hold Points.

Please advise if this response is acceptable to close out this issue.

DLQ/DDJ/ kip cc:

JGKeppler, NRC w/a JJHarrison, NRC w/a RJCook, NRC w/a RAWells, MPQAD w/a BHPeck, MEC w/a NIReichel, MEC w/a 8401050371 831222 PDR ADOCK 05000 N.

6 Bechtel Power Corporation Post Othee Box 2167 f.8.idland. Michigan 48640 December 19, 1983 Consumers Power Company

_,JP.O._ Box 1963 Midland, MI. 48640

,D.L.

Quamme Attention:

Job 7220 Midland., Project REVIEW OF STONE & WEBSTER'S CCP OVERVIEW REPORT NO. 25 BCCC-8837

References:

(1) NCRs 'C-00628; C-00640, & C-00650, By Passing of QC Hold Points t

(2) Meeting between Mizan Majumder (BPCo), Ed Jones (MPQAD)

Dick Schaut,_(MPQAD) and Mark Johnson (MPQAD)

Construction's review of Stone & Webster's Overview Report No. 25 identified one (1) open (Constr_uction) action item, specifically, the meeting note "B" on Page 2, concerning by passing of QC hold points.

Detailed bel.ow is our complete response on the issue We have conducted an investigation on the subject which revealed that the QC inspectors concerned misinterpreted the provision of hold points as stated in PQCI E-5*.0, Rev. 13, as it related to the actual field situation at the time.

After careful examination of-the facts, the QC inspectors and their respective supervisors agreed that the hold points were not by passed (Ref. 2 above).

Since the NCRs contained other nonconforming conditions apart from this issue, revisions to-the'NCRs were initiated by MPQAD on 12/16/83 to delete the hold point violation portions..

Based on the results of this investigation it is concluded that there is no generic problem associated with Construction by passing QC hold points.

If you have any questions concerning the above, please contact B.T. Foote at Ext. 7507.

Very truly yours,

' M b*

G. A. Hierzer Site Manager f){6' / /V7M CAH/:'AD/BTF/MRM/lec Attachments:

Copies of revised NCRs C-00626, C-00640 & C-00650 CC:

N. Reichel'

16 MCR NO.

g, C-00640

'xled.rorRo.ncT p'r.c*oRD COPY 17 nArt 155utD 2B RET 8

' quai. m ASSURANCE DTPAR1 MENT NdNCONFORMANCE REPORT SEPTENBER 30. l983

-MW

.'Ot r

19

,3

%,g PAGE I 0F

!.t./u 83

?

I ITEM LOCATION AuXTUREY El%.- ElEV. SW-EOUTR 2 Clbb -UNii' E~

2 ITEM ORAWING/PART NO.

3 ITEM PART MAE pfffg7p(l./g.2.RLC-f./92g 4, ITEM SERIAL NO.

FSK-EGI-Sil.II, Riv 9 to-d&-Z 3 CRELE ORIO4bD-la N/A M0KfL TUBTNG THAT'IS INSinliO OH BRA [N kITEE.

PEFERENCE DOCUMD(T j 8

6 ASME A.N.I. REQUIRED VQCT-E'-5.0 REV.!3/ FSK-EGl, REM.$"'y"p 6 ITEM STARTUP SYSTEM NO.

7 D TE5

& NO OMM 9 INSPECTICN' RECORD NO..

LOG NO.

REY NO.

10 RESPdNSIBLE ORGANIZATION ORIO%3-la 11313 1 0

CONSTRUCTION

.o _a... rt 11 NONCONFORPANCE DISCOVERED DURING:'

O DE31Gx 0 RECEIVINE M NST Y RELEASE FOR INSPEC O @7 0UUEVER O OVERINSPECT O POST INSPECT

-O TURNOVER b PCST TURNOVER 12* 'A' L ~73 3 (3,3,g,,3 3ggyg,gg3,n NOL-b-70[48-FDR-RC-T-I4'I-T-Y-4.A $ 4 12 ntquIRuui

2. FSX~ EGI-5H.II 2.7 : INJutRTE DERIN WIRE WITil MRECEL INSULRTING SLEEVE 3OTH END.s TO PREVENT FERYING.

13 NONCCNFORMNCE I33Hy gt,,g$yjgy pgg39,q 79_qfn((7,qg u,,,,__

-_ma

.u v I*W 2

P.C 'ET 1? PR :N TC L'!'?[ f?::C[ED.'S.

THE?? REVEL. INJutRTEAG JLEEVE THRTIS INSD7afD ON THE 3 RAIN W TTEn2 :

NDT HAVE TAP [ RPPNEh TD EITRER ENA EDTH FNSENDS RPE FERYEb.

-fi 14 NCR CRIGl. TED BT (PERSON)

'o9-Je-E e

m O

DATE 15 NCR ORIGIMATED BT (DISCIPLINE)

ELECTETellL 20 NUF3ER OF HOLD TAE5 (IF APPLIED) 21 TJC OF HD 5

g g ff

/

K HOLD TAC-5 hTTACHEh

, DNE G 2 C 1 DNE G? DP.DVLT75A I C E) ' ED VA 22 POTEXTIAL 50.55(e) 24 ACTION ITEM NO.

26. ITEM PRIORITY CODE NO.

~~

SO3363 3'

23 REPORTED 10 r.FQA PANAGER 25 DISCIPLINE:

27. TREAD CODE DATE:

m

/m-g g -3

& -s - a 3 CONTINtTED ON RD*IRSE T-2M/lA (Rev 1) e

DLAND FEUJECT W

DATE ISSUED REV

,QUALITI' ASSURANCE' DEPARTMENT 3 E P T. 3 D J 9 3 3

HONCONFORMANCE REPORT CONTINUATION SEEE'T I ' I t.DC M B

• A BtDCit 11 Arlb 15."

EXPiminTIOU OF DELETIl3G O F ITEM r I IFJ ELOffi 1.L t.13.

d n (2 Iv 6s v

T APINC-OF f7 ARKEL IMTULRTDE 3f.IEVE tdRI MOT bOAJE B7.

CDLDTRt1CTIDN DJRELTi1G OC T03PECTTOU OF TMT.5 MOLD T*0ItJT

-~ RCTTUITT. ITEM 1 tuA5 LJC ITTG13 DJ EBOt.

ma4 mum h

m-e e

m m

m, eme em-

==

h a

e w

+-

-6 4

9 o

O e

1 F-2M/1E (Rev 1)

. "Il.u InoJECT

[llL,VK L.) kt)r Y.

17 ;Tt 13s:.a u RE g W

- QUAI.rr! AssIIz1Ncz 10-4-83

.tEr em NOi4CONFORMANCE REPOR i mv zg

/ /h3 FAM i ci g

T_;nDt LocAnca f_LE. (oS9; AUXII.tARY DLbS, AREA 3, UNIT.Z., EQUIf?

• fClL4o U ITDL DRAMINE/PART MD. -

3 ITE4 PART KAM 4, i a. M EC.

P QC I E-5.0. REV.13 REFER'TD CWR I4LC-E 1948 N&

75K-EG1. Sh.11;REV 3 CABLE OAIO45A-Ic.

s m.x cEscRI m os -

- -~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

INSTAU_ATION OF MARKEL TUSIMS bN DRAlu WIRE.

l5 AIXE A.3.1. c.wIR3 6 ITDt STARTUF ST5TDi MO.

7 REFER!DC DOC:.DCENT OGLH POC.I E 5.0,REV.13 F3K-EG1, R.i i

O TE5

2. M0 J S' ir.:w uCM REC:RD no.E-5.0 Les so.

ary 30.

10 RssPonsa:.I csArIZATIc:t O AIO45,A-la TL3!30 O

c.o kt3 T R O C.TIO L1

,,,,f n xacanrumAnc: DIscavaEn swu.u-O DEsIa Orem d# @'

in

% Ix:Per A

FTKAL r -- O Pcsi IxsPeri.

O Tunava E PCsi TUWrER g P92-CP Q

'3 CYEm5?EC TEsi ~

IURMcVE J 12 REI; IRE s T d

' FRCCI.l_L : C IALT ~~;lC T'dLT. /2//4/83 84((P^: C IO.7 AC ~."Ji7 7 70-

!.trPC C.~ ; 5.0.T~"l2.

O C.5 d NA E S f. !!^' N

~

.Z. F SK-E 61. Sh.11 'REV 4: INSOLATE DRAIM WIRE WITH 17MKELIu5LlRTIN6 SLEEVE TAPEb AT B..S. -TO PREVENT FRAYINE.

N s,. -

U.nancumwAncE

. _, r-o,. nn i, a.,n,-

noc m,

,u,,,,,

,,TQ b.)ORK II0/ P N','O PA'./~ E C 70ST. /z/

(([

.I.

IT EM Z : THE MARKEl_.EN50Utr/N6 514 VE THATIS.TA/STAf I FA ON THE bffAIN WIRE MOT 'M AVE TAPE APPL'IED To EITHER END. BOTH EMbi M NCR Du,TD ET (FGSm OF THE_ LLEEVE.AG_ FRA YED.

A

/

,/

% N.

H.

jib.-

.g c/

t.c is a cR.Iru.uTa 37 (dis:IruxE)

El ech ica l.

LDcATICM CF F.00) TA 5 Hu,xit.*'My /M$b onth t'G of 3 MLHE:ER CF HOLD TAES (IF APPUED)

Z1 EL.*G54' 9' CI'E ?-h 0"3 Coud W.2AJ1554, iso

2. HOLD TMS ATTAC.HED OAJE AT ECJW DCE. AT OFTCoS' 7TA Z2 PCTENTIAL 50.55(e) 24 ACTICM ITDi KO.

26,ITD'.,PRICRITT C":DE NO.

Mc2 REYIEnD ST:

O Trs S no so334s g

h

. s; 4,,, o D R.:v.s:.J TO.W.A MMEER 25 ' DISCIPUME:

Z7 7.0.3 C":DE

.ATF.:

uTt N/A-j=-

y3

-/o-r--83 CONI, _.w e _; CN R.:.. - - SI 7 3/1.A (Icv 1

NCE NO.

~

, dt.au excicz,

C-DO 6 9.B QUA1.1IT ASSUEANCT.-

DATI 155UT.D EIV DrrAr:mr 12.IG.83 d

sweesroznaCz toonx PACE S OF '3 w aruiuATION S M Bloc.k 18 : A

%ck / 2 AJ I S :

ExoLa safioN of De. Latino if I4em a

. q e,..>,., g, _y _ g _g 7 9 p,q,ggsjg I

- _ _.._ _ 7,, y, o.9 m a g 3,,3 g,.g,_ g

-ask.s Lof clone...b v een.s+ rue.+,k ennbliua

- O.C. 'insnec Hon 'of +kis Hol c) Poin4 Re41vi+v 1 T+eff uni %u in encor

'l 1

'~

5

~

.j I

l 1

1 1

l l

l l

l T-1M/13 (Rev 1) i l

,6

...s g;;;EU 6-- sa-t m

i.

• M1314. 2 PRCJICT 17 MTE IIIDED 18 ~l i

Q'C47 7.17, ASS *R.ANCI m-

.3

&g f ~ De* rm NONCONFORMANCE REPORT

~r~i > >

tg A3 Fir:.

/ Cr Y j

i I m LOCATIca ELEV -

659 -- N UX BL% -

/O'E/C,/, c' 7Joig 2CH.6 (N) 3 ITEM PART M/JG 4' ITS SERIAL K0.

2 ITEM DRAWIME/PART MD.

FSK -c4/ gcd 8 C. WR

~2. R t. c - E - /92C J-3/5 Sk8 REO CABLE

• 2AIOO2A-/s db' 9 s m x oEsCxt m an GA BLE > Z CONpucTDR, SH/ELpEp-Ipp 7 REFER. T DOCUMENT

& AsxE A.N.I. M IRED ITEM STARTUP S75 TEM MO. E [ON E 199 RELI 9 7 3 U~i FSK-EGI S//./McNb Q TES )5 no 6

(

S IRSPECTICM RECCRD MD.

LDE MQ.

REY No.

10 RESPOKSIEUC CREMI2ATICS E~&~0- 2hIOO2 -/s 2 13/29 0

cDNSTRyc7mN y.: T'c.c 3 2 &g%g./V.%3

\\

11 MCMCOMFORXAMCE DISCDYERED CURIME:

O DEsIEx 0 Per rYIME O cCasT gim e FOR W a"T FIMAL 82*

PRE-CP O

W O

TURNOVER CYERIESPECT O Pest IxsP2T C TURRGYER

.F( PCST TURM3YER 7t37 ITEM / : EW7 REV. 'l 1 5./ [ STATES 7H47~ 41.2. WIRE TERH/AMT/tWS 9

WITH C0t/ PRE.45/fM 7f,04~ CONNEc70RS - - W//EA/ /NS74 LLED, 77/d~

fN DEA / TAT /fAI S! A LL }=Alcli~0p7~

l*ll A : FSX ~ E&l S/l.// ?T4 7F.3 T//A7~ oNE~ MUST /NSVL4 TE DRA/N W/RE W/TN @

/A/SULA T/A!&.5L EE VE 7" APED A T Bord / EN.D.T 70 }WEVENTFA'AJ/N6.

/TE/t y: -e:w r:. T - 7"'~ $Cu:r:M~ != '~'/'T

' CC lll '.'

w w== wi-JU.*3 l ' 7*,':i

/lv' ~~CU j7,. j ;icx 14,',";z;; ':,'. '

,?,":,

6% /2//l}f5 13 MORCCNFURFAMCE 17*EHI: CON 7~RA Rf 7"O TffE~hBDVE RE QUIREMEw7~i THE cRofPCP M M

.PDwNWARp -(WH/TE(t) CoAlpoc7en)

/ TEM 2: Co// TRAIL / To i~HC ABOYC REGU/REME1'T HARNEL ALEE"I# $NO A#

TAPEp.

1"

' C* C* 'l**" ** U" 5

/TEff 3.* r r, r *'rri p v re -rne i nm'r e r~riri

~'?A'L'53c.y,5j.'~' C. g

-,fk. &h

- *$M

. ~ i, s. r - - e r r r a-ln,,.,, r., n, N.,,

Frr r>: s>--

a vi --

HPGA P-GC ELEc7~

(Ubb $ E G'l5 64* ff 2D Nine.ER OF HOLD Tass (IF APPUED)

Z1 LOCATICM CF HOLD TAES El.dFA' UA 6/S6 e 2*L/NE 7'b"N Bf2')

fn!f BOTH ENDS OFCA BLE

,-ty.

MA 2-22 PCTEXTIAL 50.55(e) 24 ACTIOM ITEM MO.

26.ITEX PRICRITY CCDE MD.

22 MCR REYIEsCD B7: g O its g MD so33 74 '

S'

.g 23 REPO;:TED TO X?CA PAMAEER ZS.-DISCIPUME:

Z7 U.O D CCDE CATE:

3

/O -#- 83 mx N/^

E~

B 7 CONTDu.: i CS E..dE

~

7 ~ /1.&

(Icv 1)

.M

' " ^ "

• GMDSSe) PEO.TECT

{ ~ b O $ $~0 GWtn AssnANCE DEPARTNENT DATE ISSUED I

RE'

/c - s -PB NONCONFOR2iANCE REPORT CONTINUATION SEET AGE 4 OF

_4 8/ncd' 3/ 8.'

A?o'di-&tona/

Z~n fc < nsn : Prod 24-ent

.1

' h wbck

'h e t-a rm fo J /e, o n r on 2 x n+ Aoyg e,y

/2 nn' ~4 r s3 /un < s o W/L+ ^U L i Al den +A$

/S Ct elno nC+

fe +e em 0.s.J,le d

\\

1m 2 4A :

\\

r7, is is nn-/-- a nnu

<2on-Gi n1 Aio esndb-h'a) 8 + >4 dee /Ane W nr < he Ann, old co' %rN f

reo o ;rm ed 4r-N'ino %h e -

/no<

nn inco)n ~/-lr,0 ' </eeue, na %( e lIn b ki uism.\\

Oho r is u.4-lt>w n/rh& AA./ 0n <sk ueAha j Ahisanthe r k_J

$9fc2 0'S$f A P Lt" - F - /W ass.sibsbei e!r wroaooru as i98m os

(%n Wthna t Ant n/ph ? b 5 7 o :(--

\\

f~Sk'- CA d /Q) u)bihA n tpuiie.s %<e, %><

c!,, h e used shfe e -

0-A>n AR rh pi7' /2.0u19r13 " '

U.//Jan R,a-DE J m n w~Lviy n

f/

f/ /

~

\\

Block /2 ANo G : GKPLAMA T/CN OFD ElET/MG OF /Tui

'5 /HB h

12. App t3 :

~~/AP/NG OF /;fA RK Ct. /A'Sul/Tr/A/G SucEVC WAS Nor.ppWF py c)

.STRucr/cr/ ENA BUN & Q C. /A5PECT/CA/ O/=Tif/SHotO 7347~4cr/y/77,

~// E N 3 WRis / LN //) ERRDR.

gT7.8. /2-/6-83

\\

/

~.

l T-2M/13 (Rev 1)

.