ML20083D962
| ML20083D962 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 12/13/1983 |
| From: | Quamme D CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
| To: | Baranow S STONE & WEBSTER, INC. |
| References | |
| CSC-7081, NUDOCS 8312280376 | |
| Download: ML20083D962 (5) | |
Text
-
s (l'%
L.!((7)h-Pat'!Ei' o~ ' ou mma
~
O ' ~ / C0mpElly
$3L w
J Midfand Project. PO Sca 19E3. Mediand. MI 48E40 (517) E318650 I
b-IPAL STAFF I
December 13, 1983 j
h DY{
Ul2<@'
4A pppp DE h '.bb
/@'4)
Mr S W Baranow
.'3 L
Stone & Webster Michigan, Inc 3
IFile.
P O Sox 1963
~
Midland, MI 48640 4
MIDLAND ENERGY CENTER GWO 7020 CIO OBSERVATIONS 36 AND 37 File:
Bl.1.7, 0655 UFI:
53*50*04, 99*08 Serial:
CSC-7081 3
Attached is our partial resporse to observations 36 and 37 which were identified in your Report No. 24.
As indicated, further information will be provided on these issues.
.i
'ai,g l
l DLQ/DDJ/ kip cc:
RAWells, MPQAD w/a NIReichel, MCC w/a l
BHPeck, MEC w/a RJCook, NRC w/a l
JGKeppler, NRC w/a JJHarrison, NRC. w/a i
i l
8312280376 831213 j
PDR ADDCK 05000329 A
PDR OEC 1^0 l
IQ J
4t
-~
ccu...g... s POv tg CO c;7 i
Bechtel Power Corporation l
- 4. f-i; hy g.n 2
i
.i g
'.._. L : -
4 D!dC 0" M i_V";--
- s: ott.ce so, 21e7 L__
t/iciand. Echigan 48640 Site 1057'
! _l- _.L -
-I Md Pro,ed L_
i recember 9, 1983 t
i_
-+1 1g2 fh Consumers Power Company P.O. Box 196 3
/
r--
,. n g' Midland, MI 48640 L
~ - -
Qt -M/
Attention:
D.L. Quamme
\\
~ Job 7220 Midland Project
~~-
CONSTRUCTICN REVIEW OF STONE &
WEESTER'S CCP OVERVIEW REPORT NO. 24 ECCC-8632
Dear Mr. Quamme:
Censtruction's review of Stone & Webster's Overview Report No. 24 identified two (2) open (Construction) action items, specifically Hos. 36 and 37.
Detailed below is our partial response to the subject observations.
Obs. No. 36 Discussion between Construction's Site Quality Department, Stone &
Webster and CPCo SMO has revealed that this observation as written is incorrect.
Per Stone & Webster's J. Barr on December 9, 1983, this observatien will be revised and resubmitted in S&W's re;. ort No. 26.
construction will address the revised observation upon receipt of S&W's report No. 26.
Cbs. No. 37 NCR C00925 referred in this observaticn has been dispositicned.
The disposition is in the process of being implemented.
Please r.ote that the as stated condition in S&W report No. 24 is not the same as the condition stated in the NCE.
Disposition implementation is projected for completicn on cr before Decem ber 14, 1983 Further correspondence =; hic subject will bc forwardea to you on or before December 2' 1983 In reference to the above NCR, T.C. Valer.:sne issued the attached memo (0-6E66, dated 12/7/53) directing the field for strict adherer.ce to hcusekeeping procedure.
ir
Bechtel Power Corporation o.t. cua=c ECCC 8802 Page 2 If you have any questions concerning the above, please contact B.T. Foote at Ext. 7507.
Very truly yours, I
G.A Hierzer Site ihna t.r
- f;c.Brr.y,3 GAH/ MAD /BTF/lec
Attachment:
Stone & Webst.er's Observations O
Bechtel Power Corporation Inter-office Memorandum To All Superiritendents/ General Date December 7, 1983 Foremen T. C. Valenzano sub.iect Job 7220 Midland Project From GENERAL HOUcEKEEPING of F.ic!d Construct. ion 0-6866 Copies to Distribution At Midland, Michigan Recently, an NCR (#C00925) was written because two (2) boards with protruding nails were found lying in a "Q" cable tray.
This condition resulted in damage to the "Q" cable in the tray.
Through various means of communications such as memos, tool box meetings, training and superintendent / general foremen meetings, housekeeping is continually stressed. Therefore, there is no excuse for the neglectful condition that initiated NCR #C00925.
In ceder to prevent damage to plant equipment, it is essential that we maintain good housekeeping. This practice is the responsibility of everyone on the project.
As supervisors, is is your responsibility to make sure that the people under your supervision are conforming to housekeeping procedures.
Your cocperation and irra.ediate attention to this concern wi!I be appreciated.
)
Wi
.C.Valedzar TCV//.!N/IJg Distribution:
G. Hierzer R. Cote M. Dietrich F. Haluska T. Rcbertson S. Estlack J. Reinsch
ST0llE & WEDSTER l-11ClllGAtl, litC.
I-MIDLAllD fl0 CLEAR C0GEtlERAT10tl.PLAtlT CIO 00 SERVAT 10tlS bservation Originating CPCo Response
. Status Close-Dut Umbor Observations Document /Date Document /Date Open/ Closed Document /Date 034 flIR 000 issued on flovember 14, 1983 to Report flo. 22 Open address five unsatisfactory conditions 1.1/14/83 g
observed during the review of 50 traininD
, levels assignments in the System Team Training Matrix of the Construc.tlon.
Training Program.
l 035 CIO observed that dielectric isolation Report flo. 22 Open spacers for galvanic protection of copper 11/14/83 pipe to galvanized steel pipe supports I
were m:.ssing in some areas on this system, Sc.all Bore (Instrument Air) KAC Systems, drawing-FSK-J-30-0220 Sheet 2 Rev. 7.
03'6 At team meeting of teams 26 and 27 held on Rcport.flo. 24 Open ilovember 22', 1983, a decision that FCils 11/29/83
~
would no longer be issued for "noh-Q" items was discussed.
The method for con-trolling changes has not been finalized.
037 CIO observed that two boards with pro-Report flo. 24 Open truding nalls lying in Cable Tray 1AKA019 11/29/83 (Q Tray) had punctured the cable jacket of a "Q" cable.
The cable is Q-channel A,
'480V. MCC.
flCR C00925 was issued by MpQAD on November 22, 1983.
C10 w111 track thIs item to assure that corrective action (repair) has been performed to approved procedures.
l
.