Applicant Exhibit A-18,consisting of to NRC Re Clarification of Response to Confirmation of Action LtrML20083C972 |
Person / Time |
---|
Site: |
Vogtle |
---|
Issue date: |
04/17/1995 |
---|
From: |
Hairston W GEORGIA POWER CO. |
---|
To: |
|
---|
References |
---|
CAL, OLA-3-A-018, OLA-3-A-18, NUDOCS 9505230170 |
Download: ML20083C972 (5) |
|
|
---|
Category:EXHIBITS (DOCKETING AND SERVICES BRANCH INFORMATION
MONTHYEARML20100B7601995-10-11011 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-39A,consisting of Case Number 2-90-020R Re List of Exhibits ML20100B7631995-10-11011 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-97,consisting of Case Number 90-ERA58 Transcript Re Deposition of K Mccoy ML20100B7641995-10-11011 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-111,consisting of Procedure Number 00057-C Re 900711 Event Rept Entitled, DG 2A Start Failure ML20100B7651995-10-11011 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-272,consisting of File Number 90-ERA-30 Transcript Re Deposition of LB Glenn ML20099L3881995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-23A,consisting of Transcipt Re Intervenor Exhibit 23A Tape 29 Side B, ML20099L3711995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-8A,consisting of Transcript Re Joint Exhibit 8A Tape 8 Side B, ML20099L3831995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-21A,consisting of Transcript Re Intervenor Exhibit 21 Tape 32-1,dtd 900404,TR 41-44 ML20099L4041995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-153,consisting of Cover Sheet & Page from CRC Handbook of Chemistry & Physics ML20100B6781995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-222,consisting of Cooper Outage Logbook ML20099L4311995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-216,consisting of 900511 Interoffice Memo Re Enterprise Engine S/N 76021 Loss of Offsite Power on 900320 ML20100B6821995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-225,consisting of Correspondence Re Jul 1990 Starting Air Valve Problem ML20099L4291995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-215,consisting of History Re Alnor Dewpointer Model 7200U Serial 24355 Calibr ML20099L4331995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-217,consisting of Handwritten Statement Re Events of 1A DG Loss of Offsite Power ML20099L4081995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-170A,consisting of Transcript Re Intervenor Exhibit II-170A Tape 207,dtd 900717 ML20099L4001995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-94B,consisting of Transcript Re Intervenor Exhibit 94B Tape 32,dtd 900404,TR 46-49 ML20099L3971995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-94A,consisting of Transcript Re Intervenor Exhibit 94A Tape 32,dtd 900404,TR 46-49 ML20100B6801995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-223,consisting of RA Johnston Personal Outage Notes ML20100B6831995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-227,consisting of Correspondence Re Pneumatic Control Component Testing ML20099L3801995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-9A,consisting of Transcript Re Intervenor Exhibit 9 Tape 10,dtd 900323,TR 22-23 ML20099L3891995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-51A,consisting of Transcript Re Joint Exhibit 51 Tape 7,dtd 900322,TR 20-21 ML20099L3691995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-4A,consisting of Transcript Re Intervenor Exhibit 4 Tape 99,dtd 900508,TR 43-53 ML20100B7001995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-237A,consisting of Tape 218 Re 900725 Conversation Between Mosbaugh & Horton ML20099L4031995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-118A,consisting of Transcript Re Intervenor Exhibit 118A Tape 24A,dtd 900330 ML20100B6901995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-232A,consisting of Tape 3,side a of 900223 Conversation Between Bockhold & Mosbaugh ML20099L3041995-10-0606 October 1995 Applicant Exhibit A-181A,consisting of 900404 Tape 34, Beginning of Side B ML20099L4131995-10-0606 October 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-196,consisting of Nuclear Plant Maint Work Order Re DG 1A That Tripped Twice Following Two Actual Loss of Offsite Start Conditions ML20099L3821995-09-28028 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-19A,consisting of Transcript Re Intervenor Exhibit 19 Tape 25,dtd 900330,TR 2 ML20099L3861995-09-28028 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-22B-1,consisting of Transcript Re Intervenor Exhibit 22B Tape 89 Side A,50%,dtd 900502 ML20099L2111995-09-28028 September 1995 Applicant Exhibit A-120A,consisting of Transcript of Audiotape 72 ML20099L2121995-09-28028 September 1995 Applicant Exhibit A-133A,consisting of Transcript of Audiotape 69 ML20099L3581995-09-27027 September 1995 Applicant Exhibit A-202,consisting of Re Licensee Suppl Reply to NOV & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalties ML20099L3601995-09-27027 September 1995 Applicant Exhibit A-203,consisting of Licensee on NRC Demand for Info Re G Bockhold ML20100B7541995-09-26026 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-270,consisting of M&TE Traveler Re Alnor Derpointer W/Last Calibr Date of 890907 & Next Calibr Date of 900307,extended to 900407 ML20099L4111995-09-26026 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-183A,consisting of Transcript Re Intervenor Exhibit II-183A (Joint Version) Tape 99 Side a, ML20099L4021995-09-22022 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-95,consisting of 900823 Interoffice Correspondence Re NRC Areas of Concern, Log:SRBS-00044 Security Code:Nc ML20100B6991995-09-22022 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-237,consisting of Tape 218,side B at 70% Re 900725 Conversation Between M Horton & Mosbaugh ML20099L1411995-09-22022 September 1995 Board Exhibit Bd-10,consisting of Drawing W/Related Info ML20099L4051995-09-21021 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-169,consisting of Demonstrative Aid 4 (Rev 950713) Re Dew Point Data,Diesel Air Sys ML20100B6971995-09-21021 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-235 Sup,Consisting of Transcript of Pages 83 & 84 Re OI Investigation ML20100B7501995-09-21021 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-266,consisting of Final Rept, Enhancement on On-Site Emergency DG Reliability ML20100B6921995-09-21021 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-233 Sup,Consisting of Transcript Re Page 689 ML20099L3541995-09-21021 September 1995 Applicant Exhibit A-199,consisting of Affidavit of Ja Bailey Re Vogtle Project ML20100B7431995-09-19019 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-262,consisting of Amount of Water in Humid Air at Any Pressure ML20100B7411995-09-19019 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-260,consisting of to NRC Document Control Desk Re Plant Special Rept Invalid DG Failure ML20100B7421995-09-19019 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-261,consisting of Estimate of DG Daily Air Leakage ML20099L3461995-09-19019 September 1995 Applicant Exhibit A-195,consisting of Professional Resume Re Ht Hill ML20099L3481995-09-19019 September 1995 Applicant Exhibit A-196,consisting of Paper Re Vogtle Experience W/Calcon Sensors in DG Trip Circuits ML20099L3511995-09-19019 September 1995 Applicant Exhibit A-198,consisting of Rept Re Plant DGs Airstart Cap Evaluation,Log 95-MT 039 ML20100B7471995-09-19019 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-264,consisting of Water Formation in Control Air Supply Typical Conditions (Early Apr 1990) ML20100B7461995-09-19019 September 1995 Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-263,consisting of Amount of Water in Humid Air at 240 PSIG (17.3 Atm) 1995-09-28
[Table view] Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20196J3291999-06-28028 June 1999 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Industry Codes & Standards ML20206M7291999-04-30030 April 1999 Comment Supporting Draft RG DG-1083, Content of UFSAR IAW 10CFR50.71(e). Licensee of Listed Plants in Total Agreement with Comments Provided to NRC by NEI HL-5717, Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50,52 & 72 Re Changes, Tests & Experiments.Util in Total Agreement with NEI Comments to Be Provided to NRC1998-12-18018 December 1998 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50,52 & 72 Re Changes, Tests & Experiments.Util in Total Agreement with NEI Comments to Be Provided to NRC HL-5715, Comments on Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Monitoring Effectiveness of Maint at Nuclear Power Plants.Util Is in Total Agreement with NEI Comments1998-12-14014 December 1998 Comments on Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Monitoring Effectiveness of Maint at Nuclear Power Plants.Util Is in Total Agreement with NEI Comments HL-5702, Comment Supporting NEI Comments Totally on Proposed Draft RG DG-4005, Preparation of Supplemental Environmental Repts for Applications to Renew Nuclear Power Plant Ols1998-10-23023 October 1998 Comment Supporting NEI Comments Totally on Proposed Draft RG DG-4005, Preparation of Supplemental Environmental Repts for Applications to Renew Nuclear Power Plant Ols HL-5695, Comment Supporting Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) Comments on 10CFR50.55(a) Pr, Streamlined Hearing Process for NRC Approval of License Transfers1998-10-13013 October 1998 Comment Supporting Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) Comments on 10CFR50.55(a) Pr, Streamlined Hearing Process for NRC Approval of License Transfers HL-5690, Comment on Integrated Review of Assessment Process for Commercial Nuclear Plants. Util in Total Agreement with NEI Comments Provided to NRC1998-10-0505 October 1998 Comment on Integrated Review of Assessment Process for Commercial Nuclear Plants. Util in Total Agreement with NEI Comments Provided to NRC HL-5983, Comment on Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Reporting Requirements for Nuclear Power Reactors. Snoc in Total Agreement with NEI Comments,To Be Provided to Nrc.Requests That NRC Provide Guidance to Application of NUREG-1022,rev 1 as Listed1998-09-21021 September 1998 Comment on Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Reporting Requirements for Nuclear Power Reactors. Snoc in Total Agreement with NEI Comments,To Be Provided to Nrc.Requests That NRC Provide Guidance to Application of NUREG-1022,rev 1 as Listed ML20153B2391998-09-15015 September 1998 Comment on Draft NUREG-1633, Assessment of Use of Ki as Protective Action During Severe Reactor Accidents. Endorses NEI Comments HL-5682, Comment Opposing Draft NUREG-1633, Assessment of Use of Potassium Iodide (Ki) as Protective Action During Severe Reactor Accidents, & Endorsing Comments Submitted by Nuclear Energy Institute1998-09-15015 September 1998 Comment Opposing Draft NUREG-1633, Assessment of Use of Potassium Iodide (Ki) as Protective Action During Severe Reactor Accidents, & Endorsing Comments Submitted by Nuclear Energy Institute HL-5602, Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Industry Codes & Stds1998-04-0303 April 1998 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Industry Codes & Stds HL-5586, Comment on Proposed Generic Ltr, Year 2000 Readiness of Computer Sys at Npps1998-03-0404 March 1998 Comment on Proposed Generic Ltr, Year 2000 Readiness of Computer Sys at Npps HL-5582, Comment on Draft Reg Guide DG-5008, Reporting of Safeguards Events1998-02-27027 February 1998 Comment on Draft Reg Guide DG-5008, Reporting of Safeguards Events HL-5564, Comment on Draft NUREG 1555, Updated Environ Standard Review Plan1998-01-30030 January 1998 Comment on Draft NUREG 1555, Updated Environ Standard Review Plan HL-5554, Comment Supporting NEI Comments on PRM 50-63A by P Crane Recommending Emergency Planning Standard for Protective Actions Be Changed to Require Explicit Consideration of Prophylactic Use of Potassium Iodide for General Public1998-01-15015 January 1998 Comment Supporting NEI Comments on PRM 50-63A by P Crane Recommending Emergency Planning Standard for Protective Actions Be Changed to Require Explicit Consideration of Prophylactic Use of Potassium Iodide for General Public HL-5546, Comment Supporting Proposed Rule & Direct Final Rule on 10CFR50.68 & 10CFR70.24, Criticality Accident Requirements1997-12-31031 December 1997 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule & Direct Final Rule on 10CFR50.68 & 10CFR70.24, Criticality Accident Requirements HL-5529, Comment Opposing Rule 10CFR50 Re Codes & Standards,Ieee National Consensus Standard1997-12-0101 December 1997 Comment Opposing Rule 10CFR50 Re Codes & Standards,Ieee National Consensus Standard ML20199J0031997-11-24024 November 1997 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule Re Financial Requirements for Decommissioning Nuclear Power Reactors & Draft RG 1060 HL-5424, Comment on NUREG-1606, Proposed Regulatory Guidance Re Implementation of 10CFR50.59 (Changes,Tests or Experiments). Encourages NRC Not to Abandon 30 Yrs of Effective Implementation of 10CFR.50.59 for New Positions1997-07-0707 July 1997 Comment on NUREG-1606, Proposed Regulatory Guidance Re Implementation of 10CFR50.59 (Changes,Tests or Experiments). Encourages NRC Not to Abandon 30 Yrs of Effective Implementation of 10CFR.50.59 for New Positions ML20148N0741997-06-19019 June 1997 Comment on Proposed Suppl to Bulletin 96-001 Re Control Rod Insertion Problems.Util in Complete Agreement That Incomplete Rcca Insertion Not Acceptable HL-5407, Comment Opposing NRC Proposed Strategies to Address Licensees Need to Establish & Maintain safety-conscious Work Environ1997-05-27027 May 1997 Comment Opposing NRC Proposed Strategies to Address Licensees Need to Establish & Maintain safety-conscious Work Environ ML20137C2581997-03-18018 March 1997 Summary of Director'S Decision Under 10CFR2.206 of Mb Hobby & AL Mosbaugh, ML20137C4261997-03-18018 March 1997 Director'S Decision Under 10CFR2.206 Re Petition Re Allegation of Illegal Transfer of OLs to Southern Nuclear Operating Co.Petitions Filed by Mb Hobby & AL Mosbaugh Denied HL-5268, Comment Supporting Draft RG DG-1047, Std Format & Content for Applications to Renew NPP Ols1996-11-27027 November 1996 Comment Supporting Draft RG DG-1047, Std Format & Content for Applications to Renew NPP Ols ML20133H1131996-11-25025 November 1996 Petition for Enforcement,Per 10CFR2.206,to Revoke Northeast Utils Operating Licenses for CT Nuclear Power Stations Due to Chronic,Systemic Mismanagement Resulting in Significant Violations of NRC Safety Regulations ML20129J5481996-10-30030 October 1996 Order.* Extends Time within Which Commission May Take Sua Sponte Review of Memorandum & Order LBP-96-16 to 961129. W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 961030 ML20129K4291996-10-0202 October 1996 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR25 & 95, Access to & Protection of Classified Info HL-5247, Comment on Proposed Generic Communication, Primary Water Stress Corrosion Cracking of Control Rod Drive Mechanism & Other Vessel Head Penetrations1996-10-0101 October 1996 Comment on Proposed Generic Communication, Primary Water Stress Corrosion Cracking of Control Rod Drive Mechanism & Other Vessel Head Penetrations ML20128K2791996-09-30030 September 1996 Order.* Time within Which Commission May Take Sua Sponte Review of Memo & Order LBP-96-16 Extended Until 961030. W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 960930 ML20116J8921996-08-0202 August 1996 Withdrawal of AL Mosbaugh.* AL Mosbaugh Voluntarily Withdraws Intervention,Opposition & Contention in Proceedings.W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20116J8551996-08-0202 August 1996 Joint Notice of Termination.* AL Mosbaugh Voluntarily Withdrew Intervention,Opposition & Contentions in Proceeding.W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20116J8431996-08-0202 August 1996 Intervenor Response to Georgia Power Motion for Reconsideration.* Intervenor Supports Motion for Reconsideration.W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20116N5881996-07-31031 July 1996 Comment Re Proposed Rule 10CFR26, Mods to Fitness-For-Duty Program Requirements. Supports NEI Comments ML20116A4931996-07-15015 July 1996 Georgia Power Company Motion for Reconsideration of 960628 Memorandum & Order Or,In Alternative,For Certification.* Gpc Requests That Board Not Require Submittal or Approval of Settlement Between Gpc & Mosbaugh.W/Certificate of Svc ML20115H2671996-07-0808 July 1996 Comment Supporting Final Rule 10CFR51, Environ Review of Renewal of Nuclear Power Plant Operating Licenses HL-5195, Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Financial Assurance Requirements for Decommissioning Nuclear Power Reactors1996-06-24024 June 1996 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Financial Assurance Requirements for Decommissioning Nuclear Power Reactors ML20114E6491996-06-20020 June 1996 Joint Motion to Defer Issuance of Initial Decision.* Requests That ASLB Defer Issuance of Decision in Proceeding Until 960920,in Order to Allow Gpc & Mosbaugh to Reach Settlement Agreement.W/Certificate of Svc IA-95-211, Transcript of 920507 Interview of Mc Wilkins in Waynesboro, Ga.Pp 1-391996-05-0707 May 1996 Transcript of 920507 Interview of Mc Wilkins in Waynesboro, Ga.Pp 1-39 ML20129H7151996-05-0707 May 1996 Transcript of 920507 Interview of Mc Wilkins in Waynesboro, Ga.Pp 1-39 HL-5103, Comment Supporting NEI Comments on Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-63 Re Planning Std for Protective Actions for General Public Includes Stockpile or Predistribution of Ki for Prophylactic Use1996-02-0606 February 1996 Comment Supporting NEI Comments on Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-63 Re Planning Std for Protective Actions for General Public Includes Stockpile or Predistribution of Ki for Prophylactic Use ML20096A4911995-12-22022 December 1995 Georgia Power Co Reply to Intervenor & NRC Staff Proposed Findings of Facts & Conclusions of Law.* W/Certificate of Svc ML20095D9821995-12-12012 December 1995 Georgia Power Co Motion to Correct Record of Exhibits of Diesel Generator Reporting Issues Allegation Hearing.* W/Certificate of Svc ML20095D9771995-12-0808 December 1995 Comment on Proposed Generic Ltr Boraflex Degradation in Spent Fuel Pool Starage Racks. Request for Licensees to Demonstrate Subcriticality Margin in Unborated Water,Seems Inconsistent W/Stated Benefit of Borated Water ML20094S2751995-11-30030 November 1995 Intervenor Final Statement of Fact & Conclusions of Law.* Board Finds That Util & Applicant Failed to Meet Burden of Proof Re Ultimate Issue of Character,Competence & Integrity. W/Svc List ML20094S2411995-11-22022 November 1995 Georgia Power Co Response to Intervenors Motion for Continuance.* Intervenor Motion Unjustified & Prejudicial & Should Be Denied.W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20094S2931995-11-21021 November 1995 Intervenor Motion for Continuance for Good Cause.* Requests Deadline for Filing Post Hearing Brief Be Extended Until 951130.W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20094K1161995-11-0909 November 1995 Intervenor Motion to Admit Supplementary Exhibits.* Moves That Naslp Admit Encl Documents Into Evidence for Listed Reasons.W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20094J9301995-11-0606 November 1995 Georgia Power Company Motion to Correct Record of Diesel Generator Reporting Issues Allegation Hearing.* Moves Licensing Board to Order That Corrections Be Made to Transcript.W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20094J9281995-11-0606 November 1995 Gap Proposed Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law on Diesel Generator Reporting Issues.* Findings of Fact & Conclusion Accepted.W/Certificate of Svc ML20094J9201995-11-0101 November 1995 Affidavit of Ck Mccoy to Correct Info Contained in Intervenor Exhibit II-97,which Consists of Portions of Deposition in a Mosbaugh Complaint Against Gap 1999-06-28
[Table view] |
Text
. - - . - - . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
c.e.; e a o-. :: :a ,
333
- e: c- a.e e u . , cec.c a n ace l} -/8 '
GPC EXHIBIT t
weaoa. 4on sa ms CXETED g,MccoY EX P USNRC :
wa, vaa.ns ,Q 'h
.o .-. ,, c . ~,. .. . . . . ,
4 35 MY -3 P2 M8 i E'8;'.'lr*
- t. cae- *s' .7.3, 33::.
en sei dy $ef.4 ;
August 30, 1990 geC4,soJFf1CE GF-SECRETARY-W. G Hearsten. lll M & SERVICEI se c. v :c e.c :,- .) BRANCH sciea, coe r: s 4
/
NUCLEARREGULATORf ro- v t y- e t.4 -3 b
Docket No. 50-424 % p D eket No. FC'h5-ou -3 0fficial Exh. No, - M in tha rnatter of_ tA4 f4 W :+s ;41 fb 1
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Connission Staff IDENTIRED v l Region iI Apphcant 7 RECEIVED v.-
101 Marietta Street, N. W. In:crvencr - REJECTED Atlanta, GA 30323 contg 0ffr ATTN: Mr. S. D. Ebneter i contractor DATE o v-t 7 -q s-
Dear Mr. Ebneter:
Other witness Mc %
Reporter 5. 2.' l.,5 k :
V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT CLARIFICATION OF RESPONSE TO CONFIRMATION OF ACTION LETTER ,
i By letter dated April 9,1990 (ELV-01516), Georgia Power Company (GPC) responded !
to a Confirmation of Action Letter dated March 23, 1990. In that letter and in our meeting notes, GPC reported that Diesel Generator (DG) 1A had been started 18 times and DG 18 had been started 19 times with no failures or problems between March 20 and April 9, 1990. Similar information was reported in ,
Revision 0 of Licensee Event Report (LER) 50-424/1990-006 dated April 19, 1990 1 (ELV-01545). As reported in our telephone calls to the NRC, we subsequently l discovered that this information was'in error.
l In Revision 1 to LER 50-424/1990-006 dated June 29, 1990 (ELV-01729), GPC attempted to clarify the correct number of DG starts occurring in this time !
. period by using reilulatory guide terminology (i.e., valid vs. successful starts). This rev< sed LER accurately reports the number of valid DG starts during the period of March 21 through June 7, 1990. However, during a recent NRC inspection it was pointed out that the revised LER did not adequately clarify the numbers in the April 9th letter. )
The confusion in the April 9th letter and the original LER a'ppear to be the result of two factors. First, there was confusion in the distinction between a successful start and a valid test. For the purpose of this. letter, a start was considered successful when the DG was started and either ran or was intention-ally shut down due to testing in progress, as: identified on the attached tables.
Our use of the term " successful" was never intended to imply a " valid successful test"-in the context of Regulatory Guide 1.108. Many start attempts were made to test the DG's IA and IB using applicable operating procedures. These procedures and. data sheets do not contain criteria for determining if a start is successful which resulted in determinations of success which were inconsistent with the above definition. Second, an error was made by the individual who perforined the count of DG starts for the NRC April 9th letter.
9505230170 950417 PDR ADOCK 05000424 1 0 PDR 1
- - - - _- - --- a
j
/
l l
I Geoipiahm.cr A l
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ELV-02059 Page 2 The purpose of this letter is to correct the figures related to the number of DG starts reported in the April 9th letter. Attached are tables 1 and 2 which summarize the DG starts for the period indicated. For DG 1A, there was a total of 31 start attempts and 29 of these attempts were considered successful after the two failures associated with the March 20 event. For DG 18 there was a total of 29 start attempts and 21 of these attempts were considered successful.
Further, for DG 18 there were 12 successful sequential starts.
Sincerely
. . 0A W. G. Hairston, 11 WGH,Ill/NJS/gm Attachments xc: Georaia Power comoany Mr. C. K. McCoy Mr. G. Bockhold, Jr.
Mr. R. M. Odom Mr. P. D. Rushton NORMS U. S. Nuclear Reculatory Commission Document control Desk Mr. T. A. Reed, Licensing Project Manager, NRR Mr. B. R. Bonser, Senior Resident inspector Vogtle 1
l i
?
TABLE 1 DIESEL GENERATOR 1A START RUN UNPLANNED L DAII SUCCESS IIM_I TRIP DISCUSSION 139 03-20-90 No 1 min Yes Failure to maintain load.
140 03-20-90 No I min Yes Failure to maintain load.
141 03-20-90 Yes 4 1/2hr No Nanual start, load maintained.
142 03-20-90 Yes 45 min No Normal reserve auxiliary transformer swap method.
143 03-20-90 Yes 5 min No Observation run.
144 03-20-90 Yes 20 min No Observation run.
145 03-23-90 Yes 60 min No Observation run.
146 03-23-90 Yes O min No Started wrong diesel generator.
147 03-29-90 Yes 50 min No UV test start #1.
148 03-30-90 Yes 2 hr Yes* Bubble test #1, high l temperature jacket water '
sensor vented. )
149 03-30-90 Yes 6 min No Trip simulation test. 3 150 03-30-90 Yes 6 min No Trip simulation test.
151 03-30-90 Yes 3 min No Trip simulation test.
152 03-30-90 Yes 6 min No Trip simulation test.
153 03-30-90 Yes 4 min No Orifice modification functional test.
154 03-30-90 Yes 10 min No Orifice modification functional test.
155 03-31-90 Yes 2 min No Drifice modification functional test.
156 03-31-90 Yes 3 min No Orifice modification functional test.
157 03-31-90 Yes 10 min No Bubble test #2 158 03-31-90 Yes 1 min No Sensor trip timing test.
159 03-31-90 Yes 1 min No Sensor trip timing test.
160 03-31-90 Yes 2 min No Sensor trip timing test.
161 03-31-90 Yes 1 min No Sensor trip timing test.
162 03-31-90 Yes 75 min No Sensor trip timing test 163 03-31-90 Yes 27 min No UV test start #2. ,
164 04-01-90 Yes 1 1/2 hr No Normal surveillance test. ;
165 04-06-90 Yes 1 min No Jacket water temperature test.
166 04-06-90 Yes I min No Jacket water temperature test.
167 04-06-90 Yes 10 min No Jacket water temperature test.
7 TABLEI(CONTINUED)
O!ESEL GENERATOR 1A START RUN UNPLANNED thL._, QA.Il SUCCESS IJE TRIP DISCUSSION 168 04-06-90 Yes 2 1/2 hr No LOSP trip modification functional test.
169 04-09-90 Yes 1 3/4 hr No Normal surveillance test.
- Unit tripped during bubble testing due to one sensor venting and another sensing line being disconnected for testing. This is further described in NUREG-1410.
I i
TABLE 2 DIESEL GENERATOR 18
- START RUN UNPLANNED L Q81[ SUCCESS l(( TRIP DISCUSSION 120 03-21-90 No 0 min No Post-maintenance run, prime fuel lines, 121 03-21-90 No 0 min No Post-maintenance run, prime fuel lines.
122 03-21-90 No 15 min No Post-maintenance run, adjust governor.
123 03-21-90 No 2 min No Post-maintenance run, fuel oil delta pressure high.
124 03-21-90 No 4 min No Functional test run, fuel oil delta pressure high.
125 03-22-90 Yes 6 min No Functional test for maintenance.
126 03-22-90 Yes 1 min No Functional test for maintenance.
127 03-22-90 Yes 15 min No Post-maintenance overspeed test.
128 03-22-90 Yes 3 min No Post-maintenance overspeed test.
129 03-22-90 Yes 5 min No Post-maintenance overspeed test.
130 03-22-90 Yes 5 min No Voltage clamp circuit adjust.
131 03-22-90 Yes 2 min No Voltage clamp circuit adjust.
132 03-22-90 No 1 1/2 hr Yes Post-maintenance load test, high temperature lube oil trip.
133 03-23-90 Yes 7 hr No Post-maintenance load test 134 03-23-90 No 3 min Yes Post-maintenance load test, low pressure jacket water trip.
135 03-23-90 Yes 4 1/2 hr No Post-maintenance load test.
136 03-24-90 No* 33 min No Post-maintenance load test, high temperature jacket water alarm.
137 03-27-90 Yes 1 1/2 hr No Bubble test.
138 03-27-90 Yes 42 min No Trip simulation test.
139 03-27-90 Yes 3 min No Trip simulation test.
140 03-27-90 Yes 2 min No Trip simulation test.
141 03-27-90 Yes 6 min No Trip simulation test.'
142 03-27-90 Yes 57 min No UV test.
143 03-28-90 Yes 1 3/4 hr No Normal surveillance 144 03-28-90 Yes 4 min No Low pressure lobe oil i modification functional test.
145 03-28-90 Yes 4 min No Low pressure lube oil modification functional test.
146 04-04-90 Yes 1 1/4 hr No Post-maintenance load test.
147 04-05-90 Yes 5 min No LOSP trip modification functional test.
148 04-05-90 Yes 2 hr No Normal surveillance.
- High temperature jacket water trip alam was received and the engine kept >
running.
-}}