ML20081B768
| ML20081B768 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Zimmer |
| Issue date: | 11/08/1982 |
| From: | Reinsch H BECHTEL GROUP, INC. |
| To: | Dickhoner W CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC CO. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20081B738 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-83-77, FOIA-83-A-13 NUDOCS 8310280231 | |
| Download: ML20081B768 (48) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:m. . .
~: :' Bechtel Power Corporation 3 q* .
Engineers - Constructors t
.g
- Fifty Seale Street l g San Francisco, California g, MadAccren: P. o. Ben 3965. San Francisco.CA 94nt ,
; ~
Nove=ber 8,*1982 . [* . p.g. .. . .. . .. , :.
- Mr. W.E. Dickhoner, President Cincinnati Cas and Electric Company 139. East Pourth Street ,
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202 ,
Dear Mr. Dickhoner:
.v I
We appreciated the opportunity, the frankness, and the cooperation of yo;r
,l personnel in discussing the status of your project last Friday. Ve agree that j .this is a critical time in the schedule for the ce=pletion of the W.H. 21==cr j pla nt . The co=pletion of your project is vital to your co=pany as well as the g ,
future of the U.S. nuclear utility industry. Bechtel is prepared to =obilize j our full capability .and experience to help Cincinnati Cas and Electric co=plete the project. ,
} -
We believe that our manage =ent experience at Fer=i, VPPSS, South Texas; and
] <
s Diablo Canyon can provide you with the assistance your project' organization the Quality needs to r'e solve the current proble=' areas and co=plete 5 . _ I Confir=ation Progra=. I describes the i==ediate steps we vould take to identify Appendix A
'crganizational, procedural, and actions that are needed. This Phase I of the E
initial verk is expected to take three weeks , in which ti=e our senior people
.vould further design the approach and a staffing plan for the co=pletion of l i the project. Generally, those sa=e people, upon ce=pletion of this phase, vould be available to carry out the i=ple=entation of the plan.
j l Appendix 3 includes the resu=es of , the Phase I tea: =e=bers. You'll find the= In very experienced in nuclear power plant, and particularly EWR, projects. J j selecting these candidates, ve have e=phasized the need for experience in: 3 ' ( % g) .
-[ 1. Project manageEent and construction =anage=ent
.l ,.
' ' ;f..; , - Integrated project control .
QA/QC programs . d .3.
'.n y
- 4. Construction co=pletion, systens turnover, and startup .
Appendix C includes su== aries of Bechtel's nuclear experience, whi ch , as you t 3 know,'is approached by no other co=pany. l .
'E -
d -
~
l 9 e,
'4 '
8310280231 830824 ~ PDR FOIA l DEVINE83-A-13 PDR I _
- - - --- a
Li ,
. P.r. V.11. Dickhonar, Pr sident *
- j ... Envrbar 8, 1982'
, Pcg 2 -
Bechtel Power Corporation a f, . . s
.So=e job are:
of Bechtel's in-depth capabilities that ' we think are i=portant to this hi - 2 1.. Co'nstruction~ manage =cnt and direct,-hire construction ' " 1,
- 2. Quality control progra=s -
j i e u
- ggtro. ject control syste=s for int egra tion of quality, schedule and cost priorities -
1, J, 4 Reactor contain=ent expertise . 1
/
.t
- 5. Welding expertise and national code relationships
- 6. Nuclear regulatory licensing expertise
'0 . 7. Labor relations
- q *
'a t-3 ,8. Operating power plant services 4,
. 'In Appendix D, for your convenience we have included copies of two c ont ra c t for=s. The first is a technical services agree =ent which is, our nor=al cont ra c t for studies si=ilar to the Phase I effort.
t nor= ally use for = ors broad-based support of The second is the for= ve nuclear plant project
- f. co=pletions. This Phase II contract allous assign =ent of the activities tha t >
A. ve can f oresee f or successful ce=pletion of the project anri allows Cincinnati 1-Cas and Electric, at their dis:.retien to utilize any of Bechtel's capabilities
& that =ay be required. .
4 In the event that additional support services are needed after project
) c e= ple tio n ,
ce==ercial ter=s are included that allow Cincinnati Cas and { Electric to use our Operating Plant Services organization after ce==ercial operation for whatever help =ay be needed. ,
'h, I have found it useful to personally intensively review our perfor=ance and -(
la eve rall project progress in periodic executive reviev =eetings with your counterparts in other utilities. I reco =end a si=ilar progra= on the Zi==er i project.. n Bechtel is prepared to provide expertise and resources, to assist Cincinnati
~
4 Cas and Electric in the successful co=pletion of the W.H. Zi==er Nuclear y Station project. We'do have sufficient experienced personnel to acco=plish it d in conjunction with the projec t's existing capable personnel. We look fo:vard j F.. uerking with you towards that end.
.u Sincerely, 1
' N.O. Reinsch h President .%
P.OR/1sv
'.f Enclosures *i cc: E. A. Borg= ann
O D 0 9 G, 9 e
+
t 9 e 9 4 5 e e O 4
'AD ,,
e e O l l . I l 1 i i l l p 1 ATTACHMENT 12 O O e, m= 'A
CG&E - BECHTEL OFF-SITE MEETINGS - DATE ATTENDEES November 5, 1982 CG&E - Messrs. Dickhoner, Borgmann,
& Sylvia
, Bechtel - Messrs. Murowski, Wahl, & Henry November 8, 1982 CG&E -
Mr. Borgmann
, Bechtel - Messrs. Wahl, Henry, & Trommerhaust November 19, 1982 CG&E -
Mr. Dickhoner Bechtel - Messrs. Henry and Jones , November 24, 1982 CG&E - Mr. Borgmann , Bechtel - Mr. Trommerhauser Dec&mber 17, 1982 CG&E - Mr. Dickhoner Bechtel - Mr. Jones . .- _. November 17, 1982 Joint Meeting - NRC Region III Bechtel CG&E l - o l t i I e l I
- -, -, w- * - - - r e + e ,,, - - ,--yww - y e w, , ,.-eyygp,. p- p,g.ww.-y-**#-r-M9-te 9 **-R"'tWPD' e gire w" A w'v-9 v'w=W-t verf t-t-
h ATTACHMENT 13 O O 6
e s . .
,. SITE. VISITS BY BECHTEL PERSONNEL
. AT THE WM. H. ZIMMER NUCLEAR POWER STATION November 15, 1982 November 19, 1982
' , D. Stover .
C. Rixford - R. Soderholm - R. Soderholm G. Stanley D. Stover J. Trommerhauser December 2, 1982 R. Scott J. Walker G. Stanley . R. K. Vassar R. Scott C. Turnbow R. Soderholm G. W. Stanley , L. Campbell - L. L. Campbell W. Brown G. Jones- , December 9, 1982 November 16, 1982 G. Stanley G. Jones R. Soderholm . C. Turnbow D. Stover D. Stover G. Jones R. Soderholm R. Scott C. Rixford M. White L. Campbell M. Krupa , R. Scott
- J. Walker December 10, 1982 G.
Stanley , G. Stanley November 17, 1982 R. Scott ~ ~
- D. Stover L. Campbell R. Soderholm R. Scott -
G. Jones
, G. Stanley M. White J. Walker M. Krupa W. Henry .
G. Jones December 13, 1982 C. Rixford R. Soderholm G. Jones D. Stover M. Krupa G. Stanley November 18, 1982 D, Stover M. White' . L. Carrphell R, Scott W. Henry G. Jones December 14, 1982 R. Scott R. Soderholm G. Jones
. G. Stanley
- G. Stanley D. Stover D. Stover !-
C. Turnbow R. Scott J. Walker - M. White M. Krupa - Page 1 of 2 O
a a i
- SITE VISITS BY BECHTEL PERSONNEL AT THE kH. H. ZIMMER NUCLEAR POWER STATION (Continued)
December 15, 1982 December 20, 1982 D. Stover G. Stanley R. Scott J. Baramvi ~ M. White R. Soderholm December 21, 1982 G. Jones M. Krupa G. Stanley G. Stanley J. Baramyi December 16, 1982 December 22, 1982 G. Jones G. Stanley M. Krupa R. Scott R. Soderholm G. Stanley
- D. Stover M. htite P. Dallas ,
December 17, 1982 R. Scott . .- .. G. Stanley D. Stover M. Krupa R. Soderholm
. M. White P. Dallas 7
i ( - Page-2 of 2 m m
O 9 . ~ ATTACHMENT 14
4 Y (LOCATION) f
/-J2 -73
.. (DME) s ,
~
I,,
, hereby make the following sta ement to v d M 8 .~5 #~ (// # [ M C M who identified h-se to me as en- Investigator @f th( United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
I make this statement freely with no threats or promises of reward having been made to me. , ,
/ th W M & pyre /
Jw di - f}m=d!4* 4 pi i. Y N #d & G..y .
? h& g .
/N #
! ~
-idd.z 61/. - _. , , _ .
tm'L .-. .
\
W ( j. , .. > a. -- - -
~
i
<r .
.. - . - .. . ,a is .,
~
i'
, , _ . . - . ,, . . ~ -
T upe ff, g ,shg~.y/p &u da'Y 9 4,
,,u n/ a--b-A m - x w n
' - pan
% klL d ' a s a w.o
~
Ad titA.-a c %o' u dzte zvd c9 & & qd 6 6>sA amo ,. Page 1 of pages. O ee
- e
___- ._-w- - _m~..._nm_ma..
. . - . . . . . . . - - . a-.-..'_.. . . . - *
-l.
-: kW
'^ '
l
. . l
\
e ~.
- e I a;o &2e - i
.<< A & drSW ik Q J2 '
zlcr.e. 4 & m' ~ms4 AMLH Adztt A d4/k-
@ c/c) M A 2 M a sJ
& /
n
- ~ -
24 m,na.4-a Sz0S As h ^j E b m -
- c WMy y - <
S NY
~
i
\ m2sg 64 Zwa,/ MzY 0e -
/
o M- & fe o M # w s zxt aa ztS jn;ftadm % d W
' M.sF- m J &ad&
.f. "[g "y-
'$7" Wf f 1
~1%fd w- - -
n zd AJ wen sk
/m a WWa ds Ad/W /n 2;VW z;p _
- Q ,a t > < w m , e 1
am2 19 4 ze
.a6 A E Sw & zzi wit nw ~b aq, 4W
-w - w -w mveree,--+,... .we, w,--n. . , - , . e e ,e ..,% f y t. , 1 =
. . S 4
1 6 D ' M d $11 ' sed - d ' Am es z'xt TJ4
~~
. ~~L A~~ J ,n w .p s cauC~ Jd-Jf dm,n J/ w &,.d_wn M of zai w \
,j((
~
~; c 4 [ '
32YJ'AMD/'
.M z$ M ,A "l@ < 4 Mu , &o &.b/- 5.
,w [ ,Ja
~
r~z W o f A k G k s-A 2 4 w s s or d ' A -
# e s-Y I Ys-4 ..Zw%f m,-ye'x d at ~
. p m . J a s d z?n.. Z os- k & w je
/
- A ;- 3 2 1 ,se+ A '4'
^
e >. sdb % 4r m&J
~~~
l . e.a s,/ d wm - m n. m ss J n
~
of # d z: 4 o r e ' <. A E M g/ 42iA4~ w]JA se Mdane6~zat v n.df sso W A w L ~a~ a / w M a w ' M - J ^ b > ossd af24M
&Sfm; web 4& akM wej s&n. Owk
&&.A &f 26 d4- A s ~ A ' A d e., cs . # 4
.is(
- ~ . ----~--.........m,,,.,
b , 1 . N
% nS oW i.
w . Y/ ' (M g, i l p - s._.. p . J ,,33 g -
,O'
, el>%k - o
% M w act/o *
- z z i m .s ) & M e e.> a k % V % 2 -,
#4 ." J2 erg rnicada zM& -#2&.> '
-Ao 4 M 4 d~.a.,aAaXa.)*.ws.
A-fa fsv '$ aeeJW
% czt ,a27,LdLw zat FA-s ,
,N t ra s AJ.Ad- s
@ u.3Cu w a sra s afzzbs 2.2 e am?- s z;;~/w k ,.&s.wa.D-
, $ 6' ' o %' /b , /6b z.em AfaJ* , edEw dm; M s 3 A c/a fa25~s & a m a, M3, &n c am. cfMAhu o16 4 '
21 a:KD
- - s- -
a w w sy J x m s- -
& - Ad aufA&
( A~~ av .)- o s f M s-2' 2Je i& nf i
8 e e .,g 9 9
.A a
. w s -[-o zat .A
'n ba6 snw n d~- -i & d m & Ofs sa **
W u eJ6o a
;E M ' A c-s & n r
- Wc,, *Y#
f ~/62A-a t m Asi 1 4 -fm C A-1 /Mu WM
, d 43c64 Md lf b h h .Az-c=w! CsA>cursn,m- A;r-B M/
~
d@.Zwffd & &6 y Ad & /did es/u nd Wn g &t Ahi ~/Jky \ t3 - n dw4/ m, n z& AJs c,; 22i ~A mAz%~f 6L-e c;aG-D e2J~
% % k aso a:-d' Wn f M ASu%d f w wwa_a, w -w l o af M aks we M
. 4 &&n:/ - e zzb c d a..
Q c. A p - M l -) ~$ s.> 4,, EVn ' 47
% 2 a ss. a u /~'
% m e k # daM nY4& g 'z% & ( A/ n&s' a ~
42tpasad fu M s E d emse R . 4 s 2 dWs MMe -
'I w m J m - A h ." 4d> A D w -~ rw~- e
- . f,
- 4 in n x c- a f M . M ' M I
k W ode ~
#a/'e M n A ' M W d zM sJam saw ? fA f} n d 4 c
a's ya' nfatA. MBe l c}- M L s&o &p . M cs-/c 2 LAW ds
- l. -/8 ) k o M.ey e M d A p ~$ %
t 2M '
.Ae,J#CJs mA W a d.o A d 4 m n' %
OM'.aws Mztt //c2Aas9- - -
\! s-a-4/'/e.--, G<-<' ausefaf~14ai & ..15
! A o i D w m co/ m Q./s, i~
! F WA-4
,c a d k AAcok Cde > ow55a am y 6
~
ndsk i y w W fw &JM 6-4 /r- M.~W
', 4
. a :c9 J A b c- a Q-
\ 1 Aed ' ~ 4,,,a .1 2-o pcs yAc~4JJ wo .e z26 FA dVs4 <A cJ-=*6 & si /n M / (M, Dn*JmA z;21 s#' / x cu' -sn IcoAd aa zQ su 2]
^
,D-Q&T __
O
e MM# wAdeJAk# MJ a-Aa' zLO w/ A . e52 z; % A ' A A
%. sex & zVs s n d b
& s?w - .
c%y M 42= um- '- M zM <& 'ca A & R A W J A o' s a A s
&J -D-Nk 27DefM
#fat cm s9wdaA 3 c) M .2 W e A y w>
h"r&Waaw"&4
~
~ ~
l i 1
', '! .f J
{ ! -d l m' zQ sAMe
- z7 W L21 43A en M 26.a> A 721 *n~z'~D YwAJ'wo-t Ek o
my zRt f
- z94 m &
/- Y z%fzMc =.- A./n J *
/ ."D ' sam nona M e 4 ~~6. 2 w as,e> M
/ & .~6 1 Y EhY . . . -
4 O g , 4 _x ' g '
-. . . .,9 -
M ) sv $y ' A s- d
/ ' wu
- d y <J
~4.Aej asy M.s><o sad , e 2163Gy,o dad c> f & y CEM W +W dLee., &
'2/socan
~l ;
1.' .W A.sk 4 - f
, & C-w -mm .
l z2i e nd w1-4 J4 Mr I
! A 2 & &W '
~
\
i Wh WW l .y; -# , o .3 c-4 /vog g c,,wd]M 4
$$a- . -
s x z% Jz ch./J ens adam-22 % doz. d w Aw d36o y,no f7ZID z/.fd'C w AA Yd Wf& / w ass y l m 4,z% w e c&M* f' do Ccfx CGfs #sn /6$@ary zt~o <jA, w4m & GAf w k-g A
\
s _ 0 y- +=e+n*, y.g, m%. %wum e w
-- ----wwwemm y e_ss, e1 g
8 e O P O e
- t e
o
+
4
- N m, 9
e 1 l O e ATTACHMENT 15 N O r. I
- - _ . .w __.
-%-+-
i, s (location) - - ' 1-22-83
.- (date)
I, ereby make the following statement to John R. Sinclair and Edward C. Gilbert, who have identified themselves to me as Investigator (s)of the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission. I make this statement freely with no threats or promises of reward having been made to me. . This statement is provided to furnish information concerning my knowledge of the presence of representatives of the Bechtel Corporation
. at the William H. Zimmer nuclear project during a period ranging-from
. .. t approximately August 1, 1982 until
, 'My employment it Zimmer and exact duties as ag -
i
- i
\
, My specific
)
knowledge of personnel from Bechtel being present at Zimmer pertains - to some personal observations, a first* hand discussion with a Bechtel
. \
representative, and discussions with lpersonnel ; iwho also were aware of Bechtel's presence at the site. As I recall, the first time that I observed new personnel at the site was on or about August 1,1982 and possibly as late as August 3rd. At that
- time I beli' eve there were six individuals who arrived, at the site, who were wearing Gincinnati Gas and Electric (CG&E) hardhats but were obviously visitors and gave every appearance of being Bechtel .
employees. My reason for saying this is that despite the hardhats one 1 of 6
, . r.
of the described individuals carried a briefcase containing the Bechtel Corporation logo and another wore a blazer embroidered with the same logo. When these individuals, all wearing suits, arrived at the. Zimmer site they originally entered through the main gate about 9:30 AM. . This was the Southgate and was the gate designated entrance for construction and QC personnel assigned or working on the project., The first day on the s'ite I did observe the same individuals wearing visitor badges, however, I do not believe that the individuals were wearing the visitor badges when they were observed on subsequent
~
. occassions. On this first observation, all of the individuals, who were wearing suits, walked past the Personnel trailor and the First ,
Aid station into the permanent building known as the " head shed." The t new people on site initially " stood out" to me, and,others, because all _. of the everyday or routine work was being done by three groups basically-- CG&E, Kaiser and Catalytic. During the early period that these individuals, believed.to be Bechtel employees, were on site the group totalled approximately six. Later,
~
the same group increased to approximately eight and then twelve which . was the number on site prior to my leaving the Zimmer project. From my observations and others it is believed that the group remained at the Zimer site continuously during the period August through November. This does not mean they were observed daily but they were seen on a regular basis. I also recall that the described individuals first 2 of 6 - i t . O 9 A
-_ .-- -- s o__.
. .. . - . . .+ . ,v . , . .
.- - .c._.n. . a. . .. v . - . . . = ~ +
worked out of the main offices where all of the site construction managers were located. This continued until a new " double-wide" trailer was set up at the site around August 15, 1982. Then these
. individuals were observed working out of the double-wide trailer.
The double wide trailer did not contain any specific or unique markings, such as a Bechtel logo, however, individuals belonging t~o the described group' were observed, by me, entering and leaving this trailer. Recently, I and other lat my present job viewed an aerial photograph' a . y of the Zimer project at which time we all independently identified o the same trailer as being the "Bechtel trailer." During this in.terview this trailer has been described, to me, as trailer #152. 2s.
~ '
. - Sometime after these individuals arrived at the site, and after the i ,
trailor was brought to the site, I had a personal conversation with one of the .ndividuals. The individual was a man in his mid twentie's, approxima'.ely 5'11" in height,180 lbs, light average length hair, clean shaven with no distinctive characteristics such as scars, tatoas, accent or glasses. I would be able to recognize this individual if I were to see him again. In addition, he impressed me because of his wel.1 dressed. appearance (like an executive). - I also met this individual on other occassions and in fact had my
" jump started" with his assistance. On that particular day my battery
~
had run down and this individual started my fith jumper .cables from his car which was parked in the North parking lot as was my I, My 3 of 6
.__- _J _ _ -. . _ _ _ , _ _ _ _ , _ _ . _ - , _ _ - _ _ . _ . , _ , _ - _ . -- - _ - _ _ . _ . . ,
- . ._ _ _ . . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . , _ . _ _ _ . . _ _ . . - ~ . . _ .
reason for having to park in the north lot was that the main p'arking , area was full. As I recall, his car was a maroon Datsun 280 Z with black louvres and California license ' tags. This car and other cars with California license plates had been repeatedly observed, by me, in the north parking area. Based'on this I and others assumed that these individuals entered the Zimmer site through the North gate. . During our initial conversation, this individual and at least four others were in the containment building on the 5th floor. I questioned him as to why they were at Zimmer. His' response, as I recall, was
. someth' i ng to the effect that he work for Bechtel Corp. and "that their job was to study the plant for ccde compliance and accountability
- - and to see if .the plant could be completed within normal quality assurance requirements ' He also said they were doing a management review. This same individual aise t :plained that "Bechtel would submit their findings in a report to the number one man." I assumed he f meant Mr. Earl Borgmann of CG&E. As I recall, he also said that "Bechtel had 200 men on stand-by ready to come to Zimmer." At some i
l point I also-learned that a Bechtel executive in the construction area atthebidlandprojectvould"runtheauditatZimmer," This individual's name wa: something like $oderholm. l I bel.ieve there are many employees who were at Zimmer who were aware of these representatives from Bechtel. , d Concerning my previous statement identifying a Mr. Soderholm: I believe he was identified to me by two DC inspectors who had come from the ,, 4 of -a :-
Palo Verde nuclear project which is being constructed by Bechtel. 8 They had informed me that they had been in constant centact with Bechtel regarding future e'mployment at Zimmer and they had actually been advised that they would be hired by Bechtel and told what their salary would be. I cannot recall their names at this time but I do remember their descriptions. One of the QC inspectors looked " exactly" like the actor Dick Van Patton and the other inspector had.long hair, a beard, and often wore a shirt with a Har. ley-Davidson logo. The exact date of the conversation I cannot recall, however I believe it occurred before August. At my present assignment as a ?
- . . i
~
I
, The consensus of most of the individuals is that the purpose of the Bechtel people on site was that Bechtel had come to Zimmer with the intention of replacing Kaiser on the project if the
.results of their report showed that the " job could be done feasibly."
Discussions and rumors concerning Bechtel coming to Zimmer had started
~
prior to August 1982 and had been so " widespread" that when the new group l of people arrived on approximately August 1 noone was surprised at what - 1 appeared to be Bechtel employees. Again, from my observations and others this group had complete independence and total access to any area of the site.to include retrieval of any documentation. One other observation of some members of the group occurred approximately September 1,1982. At that tim 6 I saw about three memb ers .of the group l l of six or eight standing just outside the " material hatch" of the containment l . - 5 of 6 .,
(~-.~.-_-...-.....- .., s e building at the ground level elevation. One member of the group was the same individual with which I had previous conversations and drove the 280 Z. In addition to the group, one of the NRC inspectors, Fred Christianson, was also present. Additiona11y, there was an
' unidentified CG&E engineer ~ two unknown CG&E inspectors and a Kaiser QC inspector. The activity that they were observing pertained to the removal of a " hanger" from an area immediately ins'ide the building.
I have no further information related to this observation. I cannot provide any additional information concerning this matter. I have. read the foregoing statement consisting of 9 handwritten / typed pages. I have made and initialed any necessary corrections and have signed my name in ink in the margin of each page. I swear that the foregoing' statement is true and correct. Signed on 1-22-83 at 8:28Rd.EST (date[ (time) SIGNATURE: - original signed by . < y Subscribed and sworn to before me this 22 day of Janua ry, 1983
. .--l .
at _( ~ , INVESTIGATOR: - original signed by John R. Sinclair - - WITNESS: - original signed by Edward C. Gilbert - O eree 6 of 6
.. t
h.e-4e sLAmen f h 7 g e e ., ,w have w 6 I'W es"Mm- - $1 a wb _wOww-
- 44 4 m'#A h6b4+E 9M4 - m . e aor.,,
- e G
9 0 0 K 5 e S e
'M
'* h e 9
e e o e en O 4 e e e e l ATTACHMENT 16 - t 4 L e e w , - , ._ _
_____,.. 7_. ,
, a 9 : . . . ; ,.. ' _.. , ,
- :. :.' ':.. '-ice,%:.:.:.C .cN'.2.* :1.'.'".'Ul..b.i . .. . . . . . . . . . _ . .
g 9
.
- 4*
g - l/
/> . r c2 sgr y, . aw
/
A,f 26 dxbtJ A u Ms dao
- --u a6 2 #A 4
. 6- J y s=% yM % a WA &w f '4 as ~J
,4/4 .A i
g A a,A ,. W " h WUpo
-J ~n4s & he waw' I
' W d &2i
~
X s Wd A Msp A p nan ._,/a f &%6 _A>Adld/ at
-wsx
- J#
WJ h.sas6V ;9% J-faab i
! Am c -
's
..%p ~ aasesk: A s yeumxn c
sys. . 33 yydsatan xa-c4%w 44 nLu.
,<&). n n>> a W # wdu- &
sp - a p a
\ M. *.o i
_ -- _ .. __ __.__..__ .i
,y
- - - ~
v / q
.L 4 -, -
- a. :w r t:. - - 2~22 ::.
.. ': 2.wi. . - .- -.. :. .
a . m Gl . n '.. w ,
. \ kJ8
^
e
- * * * . = .e .
g
?
Ne=> l
.. ~
. n e
m.e Y , &cf2EW /d - fce.di s am .&P's
& V
\
b Y&&D L m ahaC%U WWs VdM de
- a &A$/
,A edu' > > ^re-: r/>i .
x
- 74 m A. .
a
,u gaf D
\
l wr.r> i __
.. - -.- . . . .--..--n.. :-- - - c.=_= =
... . . . . . . . . . r . . i:: -
- .: :.'* h? NS'. ' ? :' * ' ' :..? "'.. * - - .
y ,. ... g 4 e '
/. ..
N a - wms & wh a.,,) 4 w a m - m ,a J A 7se> *s~d zxf s-s &AXM
,M -
& 4.L,,
Vsa-M/ A-as ~944 a .u-a m u'a: c A A m
&& ZFf *WWWNd&_./
LAJ.5 W e- A-m&D p {&m'
- ea wr at L M W&A-z., ' '
-g4 Wade dlmaQ d h2 . . ..
. w c7aC /m2s ns e
~'
d
/redt hNW & '
WO#f RA'Rf,as$Qn/OW e ap.m.ea . m . 4&4 C+ ~ 4 # w ] $:rd & u W
\..
O **M .WW . 6 wee @ -6. .M9 eh4 W.
~
g , i) -- . .
. . : u.:.2asa=..u.1.hl'.'.: "T. . " " * . 3.~.: .'.".
. . . . . .--- .. 1: . : .... ..... .
- e e
- O
, he
. Ne> .
, &md da2C2 dt.s/< -L X- J -
wd -6 z b K s a, e,s2Co f& A dc9u L; - Af w -d/w J Au w A #s . m & f snMJa% si, M y, b&c hs.6e.P o Y n Ab
, e
; A6 -
w o,.as +
.i n
JR. Ma 0 - an a b w Kys . j,
~
&?oA5$0e ~
w ,d ',cd d> M s.a/ Mw W 737] W 5U
\ c a >
f&lYw o$g. m'2Q
,dys
.\
W fs'"'Ti "Ei _ Aa
~sfdu ...FfLy
, s %(atoe-(h" f j&,' g g-ps ~4ce ess-,Jwaxw
' D sas -
e wdM w AA c} M i&lw' &Aun- afA' s 4.a'd<' M ..dA 4 4 f m f;tb ' 4 A A M -v'o.~u3Rf-e ka-s i WljQ '
/N '
j -) WO l/' .,
"WM+t
- y e ~l4 ff)
F
. . . . . . . . - .: w . ,... - . ..._ . ::c w a. a a .= r. .:. ~ 2: :.u .
s x ks s t i
\ 1 A./f# U 4 C~ f f" hsb hM
.Ww , ccr e ed% ]w m' ngca/
1
#. Arm .~/ .
D z/A . L f f" , f ~'" f ' ' A z: M w A d n n a
, A n A d g d i Z a~syfqc
; A xw ec nnaa/>h nAAw. om ~ -n ad
)4
- JeAdaa&4eAA
$ W $
W R f?AC~~em/wM I s \ kj-u4 mas 33 sya L ~ , / 9 e.3 R T/ (f~
~
\ _ ,
6%Cm~~ Edu~ 0 c. & 0$ k UAd ca )s k i . _ - -
r .. . i ATTACHMENT 17
t .i
- ~
,i
)
23 January 1983 12:39 am
. Date I,
hereby.makethefollowingstatementto John R. Sinclair and Edward C. Gilbert, who have identified themselves to .me as investigators of the U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission's . Office of Investigations. I make this statement freely with no . promises of reward or' threats having been made to me. Prior to any questions Mr. Sinclair advised me that the areas of investigation concerned a recent allegation that representatives of the Bechtel Corporation had been engaged in work at the Zimmer project prior to early November 1982. I was also advised that the Office of Investigations (01) was investigating alleged falsif.ication of quality _. control (QC) documentation and intimidation of QC inspectors. I began my employment at the William H. Zimmer nuclear project in for the project contractor Henry J. Kaiser (Kaiser) and remained in that position through After
= -
.f
. 'I accepted a posit' ion with .
s korkingfor
.i . ;
I remained in that position until J
~~
. \
i 1 of 4 -
.) .
u .- ,
~
\'
I
- .. ..--..Iwo...uld like' to respond to questions e
^
relating to the Bechtel presence at Zimer before providing. other information. . I.believe that one of the first encounters with individuals iden ified .
. .as Bechtel employees occurred in September 1982. This knowledge was the result oft . sometime in - _
September and being introduced to three individuals who were presented as Bechtel representatives. I cannot at this time recall the names of the individuals but distinctly recall them being introduced as Bechtel employees . I also recall that at some point in time several individuals were wa1 king around the site with Bechtel hardhats. This also occurred sometime before November 1982. The' reason for the presence of these original three Bechtel people was to set up or conduct an audit or something to that effect. Sometime shortly after the original meeting, probably October '1982 I was informed by an individual named ~ I that there were eight Bechtel employees on site and that j e 2 of'4
- - - - = _ _.es.*,*m_- e w 2e = , - , , pme.gu ,e%
r . . .
, I real esta'te in the Cincinnati area. This conversation occurred just prior tog l
\ -
t (. . . _ . . . _ At some point in time.the exact date which I cannot recall, a new trailer
~
was brought on to the ~Zimer site. This trailer I initially thought was to be used by one of the Kaiser departments and in particular the training group. As I recall h.ade a coment to the Kaiser
, 1 .
. training supervi,sor, Jim Danner as to whether training was going into the new trailed - _
( Danner's reply to me was that the trailer was not for training but was in fact for Bechtel ._ _. employees working at the site. In response to' questions pertaining
. to my knowledge of consultants utilizing the described trailer, I wish to state the consultants that I am aware of working for CG&E were primarily working in the individual CG&E departments and mainly in. spaces primarily utilized by CG&E.
One other employee who worked at Zimmer and was himself a consultant was Gary Shrader. I believe that Shrader in fact knew the names of some of the individuals. 'Shrader also quit the Zimmer project even though
~
he was making a very large salary, approximately one hundred thousand, p + .w w.r.* . - .
.~
. , .. . rm S M .5 i -
3 of 4' (. ., , , . a ,,.
~
e
- . - ---- w w -p--- -y - . -- w----m
e . . t . because of frustration in working for Harlan Sager, Quality Assurance Manager, CG&E and the company's refusal'to listen to his recommendations. I think Gary Shrader took a position at the Susquehanna nuclear project. I have been advised that NRC desires to schedule an additional interview regarding my knowledge of intimidation of QC personnel and alteration .
~
of-QC documentation. I am willing to be interviewed on these subjects and have no objection to providing a statement. I have read the foregoing statement consisting of 5 handwritten pages. I have'made and initialled any necessary corrections and have signed my name in ink in the margin of each page. I swear that the foregoing statement is true and correct. . i
- oricinal sioned by -
~
l r i Subscribed and sworn to before me this 23 day of January,1983, at r Witness -original signed by - John R. Sinclair (-original signed by) Edward C. Gilbert Investigator t 4 of 4 M*
e , t e
- e 4
e 9 e 9 G 5 9 0
*N g, G
G e G e O ATTACHMENT 1r 6 4
%#- Y V V g
F O a s. s
= > >s > -
; w M NS -
\
N .... .s l . J T I M % .
\
; li i t t .
# 3 e
~
. R .Y. .
S a 1
.a
.l.1
=- Ys -
. g . -
5 , N
\
=
' ~
x 1 1- . 1:
!! . t- q 's
%w .
\
=0 sa i
3 db .
!*" g Q
na . . .
-~
_m ?. . ns N. {$U
~55 N
=1 "U
dy .
, . Ny { b s s
m
"=. O h
4 tq$ E t . s. jt M \
}k v
\
akN \\ y
.Rf ~ .
4 o a V -
\ O
. != kD$
N. \
\
bfY
-w 1 = y i
- - - w -*' = ,v., ,,,.3 ..,m, . ., - .g _ v e , g n.-m s ;., ~ ,, ,
- O t e * .
4 0 1 i e s e e e G G e h e == m. 9
- e G
ATTACHMENT [5 O
,_ _ . . _ _ ._ _ . _ _ _ _ - _ . . - . . - ..- --- m - _
es. N N'. N. O l
'~
5E ' hkhh k sk k h, dh5 , N 'g% 3 5
~
i
,- w-
's
=E'0 w w % w o% -w%s wDd %t 4 4 % 4 A > ;s ';s, - 's v c kh k h, cy s k CD
( 4k (Y @< d 5 is 7 b% s h e y% bkb h%k d'. % %, % v% # %. Ns 'N N
= t
~ t s k h
.i I> . \/1 ~~
m' --
< y 4
- r. %
~
~, .
q.L -> N
,,3 s,
s . s., ,C y N- 4 - 3, 4 - 4 h * *. v ' % $ 0%N, 0 i } k i f h h % M U .
.$ % 9 i g 9 y .g v x x
== d s c, 5 Sf e y < .t 4 \
i b "? g -; o 3 5= z -<. -< q 4 4 i 4 .<- $ .t h-u h
\
g I 1 I
-(,
I.' a
$kr
~
3
't X
) :
l 1
$s i k' h
(,k k* k
+
o y N N x ( Nt C. 3 v
$$ E ) 4 . y ; , : 3 % '
d '4 528 .,, J ( ss 4
< sx ?
y 9 q 4 q
)s 4 4
< %,. b. r- 0 ..
83 c ;j n E m 4 y N 5 4 x D s $ D k $ D 4 h , I)q k b $ u
$g t- t x e 1 -- -
M y55 O d i { f $ )- Qy '<
. y i D %, 'E
. :g := y s s s '
e .s R s :/ y T s,, o
== eq*v , y - = 4 a 5 v p. s
=-
E w x4
} q 5 k) $ N \'
o e v. o 't : 4 :, )s t( 2; ;. 2< g-c t
-N 5 -
i x x{ s( ) e': t - - . l ig 4 '4 4+ 4 2 4 4 u a a- y a s: a
+
u y 4% -5
~ 3 v s) ,) s Q :t
^
%e L {^
>. s R R q R R q R R a R Ns' '^
l 5 0 %
% % \ h g %. %; $ % h s [::-y$ .$so us y ' 'g? g T4 c- '
> 9 -
= ..
e y s e s
- s. s
. s.
s, s
. s i
3 . a O M R T (' V T 9 % N $ % k- s? V d Y L y 2 5 C.- Y %
" t h
't 0 x
- T
- h I $Q-r: @
I N y w S x ds x s E R x;c
-4
" 5 Q
4s 4 6
-i-
%q Ni Q l D s :
s g Y < v o L -
.'5
q t hc 'ic * ' 4 r3 %'t 5 t a t t t , s x ; x x < s xs sq c s 2 9 S e 4 4
. (R k
u s' b -g e 3 x 1 4 Lq s j m, -c c
-4 hN k 9 h' \. i N u \ X M ,. % i d!
o 5$
> c. OA.Y N _./
s 4 y V M % % v V V 4 % g i s - w--
0 g & 4 f e e g o e G Y e o
*h g, o
e e e o ATTACHMENT 20 e 9 O b
- - -- W- - _ . - , _ _ _ . _ , - _ ---
,, g l
1 , c t :- - E. L, . . . i = .c w 1 v a g is N . %.l,) e:
%, i 5 1 0 0 ( t2l WJ ( Skg
%. .n '.x. 1
. A s q 4 W y is. c q[l -%e s a is iQ o ! 'i .s , a 9 N I
h IE Q'N k 'M
-h' N (g k 4 b h(h bY h{ (1 t k
\ S k
.k.
4 %
~
$ }( $ 64 9 'b( $$ {
i ...t .. R 'O d 4 4D l t{il c y g; .
% h;.3 <c .;
.e ~ >
5E ' N,
.t fi
- 3) a , 1 jNii-k i.Y N
~.
.( v- t Nx. :.N !
5 t 1
~ k j k t* .
'& * (N k Ely Th Is 3
S-u t %(* X . N jg {8 . i t 4 q g x g 'g g 5
%) x:9 A 1
~
._ _ . . _ . . . _ . . _ . ...l. . l 6.I:.g-1 2i l .- k'o v 9 1 g 2 R g_h tr 4 b . s S 0 k h t '1% i< , .N -
\)
C X i R. %y fe .N -
. y p4 N z .\ LN Sj& y W -
3( l s,. s a 3 N C. .x. :..... .q 'd os N t- 'ri >s n -
\s A a M -. <
} e.,
3
$ s.
t , tl0-r z e is v v w s , q.n .y yu: N is sx I > . g s e-I M \c i 9 i[ .dj:- ( g %x Rl .
, ; bl '
r u 4 .. .
- j. s I5.g'-; '4
% N N h .k h h hE $~) K @ h Qc c h ts (
'g M (",.
j - 17 h m h D. g n 0 n : h D Cs 4 k k 4 & w E d . i M i h A. di ( 4 & A q d et c .) :. .
. #n @f Oc '% 9 %{ '% :Q
..: c .
)
I h h >' 9 i. % g 4
- k % %
!l v. [% A h A)* tN. :- 4 .~ tQ l l Q
- l i
f .Q,. t - il . tu,, .f'.4 w- .. R[ C s ... . . . - . ... .: .
... s.
I r;
- c. -! :( :. :. .c. b ,? O. ; :.. -
g Z r.' r* ;' ;
. !! :.' ;. . r. : .5 :: :;, :.
. o y es: o g. 'O -
D ; O o o
.i..
s.. ..
.s. . ,. s-1 ,,._r: .s -
1... s.
,. c.s
.L.
s s 8, .
' .4 s
. ., .. .3 L.4
. y . ..
-l ,!
-- l -I ,
i 5 1. . ' . . ,. I i
! i
- ; J i
. !- l I : > !' - 1 1 ! i i ! 1
HENR J. K A I S E R COMPANY
.P.p201. MOSCOW. CHIO 45153
"' "* "' O
THIS ORDER ISs
- MATERIAL P.ECEIVED REPORT
' 1 O. 1 ~
PAG E OF COMPL E TE O' a0 :40. NOT COMPLETE @ Pio. $d.
- REC. DAMAGED *O DAM. AGE REPORT NO DATE RECEIVED 9!1/02 ORDER FROM, Willia =s Mobile C A RRIER Vendor
~
F7tElGMT BILL N O. EXPRESS BILL WGT. Same PARCEL POST DATE SHIPPED BY
, PREPAID . ? AMT S j COLLECT l L
AMT.S Jobsite . RA!L LINE l SHIPPED TO: PACKING SLIP NO;- CAR NG Vendor VIA .# F.O. B .
*1 000X N0l 'l -
P3 ITE M. N3 CUANTITY UNIT , DESCRIPTION LOC ATION ACCOLNT NO.
~
Rental I ea 12 x 64 Trailer, KII 971-100 S/N 11491 Jobsite IS31.95IO.? i (one sectien) *
\
a i - l ( 9/22/82 Sharen List DWG. - CnECxEn er O I'#' b A S S '. W H S L --SU P T.
~
. [-
REO. ORIG . wg3g, 3,n g, ,g _
-~ -
Zres'rvir,sv FMNns l COMPANY . O. IOX'201. MCSCOW. CHO 45153 MATERIAL P.ECEIVED REPORT l THIS ORDER IS .
- PAG E OF CCMPL ETE P. O N O.
NOT COMPLETE E REO.NO 7070-4774!
. REO. DAM AGED O -
DAMAGE REPORT NO N/A _ DATE RECEIVED 9/'2/82
~. . .
Willia =s M bile C ARRIER Vendor ORDER FROMr
. FREIGHT BILL N O.
EXPRESS BILL WGT.
, f 58"' PARCEL POST DATE SHIPPED BY: ,
PREPAID . AMT. S COLLECT : ' AMT. S . RAIL LINE ' J bsite - ' SHIPPED TO:_ PACKING SLIP NO. CAR NQ
' Vender
- DOCK "
VIA F. O. B .
*\
PO - g7gy go OUANTITY UNIT DESCRIPTION LOCATION ACCCLNT HC. Rental 1 !ee 12 x 64 Trail er. KET c71-101. S/X 17490 Jobsite 7E31.954Q.7 5
~
(one section) .'
- o. j l
l I , I f
.. j l
~
Sharon List 9/22/S2 WG. .' -
. CHECKED BY 10 ASS'. WH SE. SUPT.
- . ORIG '
weiss. S 'PI OA IN S F.C T O A
~ -
___m_ _. , _ _ -..---,,,,,m.m
i .
; ,l ,
OPRPEWTER S'uar 10q .
%rAsusero travez.rEo sv:
BATE [cc o ~
- m i- L o n v e c e o h'o 61 '
Fenmu$ foe: Ci a r.Gid .- 1%x" - KEP.4n:5 RC R U E;ST - DWounm lDrDVER EO Cggg 2 - 77[MSTo EC SE5ED. 9- E'-& 7-f-r7- ' Ko a B n. wos). 3 &D 9'- .DemJ Git. Rat pp.soF
- g.g -
y --
~4 s.A e,L z>.a4 r it s aceCAGjgETC R e cr u. u i n F a E 9)-@22 -1 :'.ish.'=> . "7e?-n7- W o cm,m 7 f2uz et0
~
'l' 9'- F, - T-7' f2 - -Jiz.Lae. ass 4 7AtracN6 Lsr'~~69 ppd GE Gt;.
J// // s o c.c=s : I o 6 4/ms.~ 9 '- P F v - fTr7n x,07 ' C & t b= Mebx is ' V - Y f2- ? -f- l2 - ('/FAM='Eliis.weira hRth< CTG d T>'OUG(z. $To A4cG Jg g .(g- ~ . Cpe/act ai EcP 4'iW NCO S MTd p o p. C f L'c - G o T D~Ti~ - )p M d SEffR. 2"l3 D' :- A. MG/-Pk-/O - anun& 9 -t'- P1 E W '1 ' FT2.r=o ( % e e s< L J ,/ ~~6 9 G iul- K -
.TiV
('4 . i- ~:::: . : 1T- k - ? v ' ~:~ ' 2.2/ Y-22/1 5' age at-t wi L L. Pw./L td P W - P- 7 2.- 9L P-2'2 - -77;'s d' fnn(2xi t.- / 29 F7t-E -(k'S/G7 'f*- D RM d C
. . .L c- TI d K .S i:74
^
W
. GE
(fd2 .1;'ii-c. C,4.d.v g; .m.
~ yw 6B-L. 9::[T& C.~-LT.~~5 .; GT7/4 .24rs'* ' Fin S.PGof *
"TRGYd'4;M?'
9- 7-es 9 F:- 6@w KedGA^) / En Ftf 2. Cnn.o CA 's /M7^
- gg '
- t. > t+CG .
r
. SS .
9=72 s A
%tKb l*7b
'l d,Fv ~'. 1f 2 9(,2.D .
- . 9'"Pfrs- Y - F- P Ne L Munnf &ao ALM,N .
caxitu . h + =-?=bW:M -- - - Rcw t.. .y 9.;79 . . ;
. . . . g: c. 9-tga ;2g/5 g.aa_fh._y,Jgs 2.
. . . . .. f. ,; m .a.eQ7-7
. g.m,.
9 9f~ - T.&P7) 32asr W ai.ecod R[fot,.7~I<B14... t~6P :..& y:.. i. ..
. . g. .. , y...-
4,< cut.as . 9.-grr p .> . : . + % 2-6 .Y 6 2. o . -. . -- . ~~i~rz~. L O M ///L'~;-.--=r: - .. . 9 =r 72- 9 -f' 5t& v' YNzet41 - FGGS; %;; L^) 2 X /0 X 21'-c 1 . y... .
-g . .'-- ~ . :. . . , , '
_p,g _ [q.Yrf.:f-5ff > y . .w.7 - .=7P.2d 'rs 2.-w )T 54;LMMd.E'2-J . . -
. - ~ :
- 9 "V tv 9 -fr = F2:. M e. Lid /V'G.L rb^) 6~6. Sn'7s
- 8 " M ' )( F '. PLuf LJ cpt w p g. -4y.. . : . . . .. - .
- { .. .
- p. .n.- . --- ::- +.. - {E 7 W i % .r.%. % . 4GL7.crp,,;<.a Thm e.En a.S dcB- B.i" 6 9-e s 9-F En A in::, 3 i : In w we cr . :w<2a=ew .
..4- . ;g-- -_
~ ~
w w .'.f r ! : ;- . :;: .: : :- :.
- y-g s . .
.=. ..
. p 7 on.xvct a ...:. % .:S Us 6 .. .. -
9-8:sr- 9.+. y a k r- ( M c-to 3 i 'Y j f y%: Q ,'sg Ofc.,'G~[l.Q> e er+.a
<_c : .;. ,
... . .- .w.
l[ cfi- P S- 7> =~; i ? * .' - l ' GWA .;2 7 I 5 ~~ (' h rz i> - W oP
\ '
. . . i.. - - .
r 0.4RPEUTER SHOP loQ *
. u c lc c *o !)an}liugaro EE-QUES.TED &f:
- hAYI. bxDERED Web 61 For~cw $ &: Cwr9it 5 - Fawck - T(c! Mms WE west
%rR % uniorwato a ta c " .
.TrrmT. Sc Kansa.
9' N. h.- % /4h- % cps.m.it RE- /)nAk6E nc.OTw& g.e.
- g. =. ._
fr- / f-.h .
- :. - ; T 7TPA 2 //5- 772/ r;
- 7/ .
W/Vrfv 9-/Y /~1/ f}fav 7 m.i.pti. . />-/B rc ntird. - M F ,f. .c9 ?l,... W, % - G '= - - . j'):w,a 1 t a c>. Lod. .. . .. 2t 79-Se7 Qi iQ.IL{- h.- > Po s. r> 6 ?-l&.5 2 - ? -/4/-8'2/ (T w .2 h e,r c ' ci? ' MJV4 R.:-G 6%'Mit -f-v rM JY.EktwA l 6 +'
- Co ? y : AA i+/
C5-Pct - N' 9 > l '" :--. 2 4 7 T - I' 9 7 0 9, '<,L) s Dscv .41s in . ac& y.a. Gi.rA f- /4-E'2- ?- J 4' ft. GM q FA <To D P67W?i ..]' 2 8 .c t. H r y_,'+ - T ~o *
.~T~f1~ f-G..
t ,
. (_% @ !il) D C-r.;,;..;. -f.4; ,- . .; -
b) - j:7- $ 2 , 1 ...'. -~ ~~ C"~ 7~77A .: 4 :-{
. . <8/
A. -* i. P .> .19 / 4 LSAO v n. 3?.T 'l F~p6Di'ME~ Y Br T:' 2 A * .
, . ;- ff . ..
.$'*lol/2/3 W. &$lh f=E.$S '7'572--.
~ ' - E'F'Crr 6R'A'US l/C..h/>/ :
c---- -- 1 f 7hi .5- S.55 - /
- G'-l-/-S-C l 9 ~iW'-f~ \ $% BcA;h M $ O]'5 .I'N/ f<i. M ?o . h ??h C.*L,'.Cf~1,. Fk9M l % fo . i
- O
,, ,_g ,,! 'j y f~)g.pI2. 2Lt'.c !<'Efy ~~5. e .p ; '$ >J })?'il d ~T '& t N - 1 V . ,c7r/-9 2//3~~ '
%%P 2 ?-14'-N2 l5l 14GLT4A
\
UU "Ih
-n.... .. . . . ~ . - -- - '
.V 71 t, ,T, r, c
?+1<% ,/
At./e. 4 H At- ./JunM e-ccr in z./'.-n << j_;,4,,.
~.
fq_W q=v g .. ~<.~. .L=:=.(p ..(JE-
. ((?%lWQMWiMit WM:67
- 2. ALS % o f;>J G - -
OSl'f+j' i v- q:jt4P'G- f.L.: Wi--\ 1os) .* #* 6,, . * * *
, mK_L, .g . , s ,. -
if .yqf y . - ~ - T ". .- -
. h ..p y a-t ... p;"h c., G i s . f .. R e ;rf- - r -
4- ty h. 9- l ?.tJ- : % ..' fo.PP . 7%)/ I?;id X ;' N X 'r W W! .C o..l....:.* , *RW - TM cs . ..:. . . .:.... . 6 3< n i . % r... a -c.. .I n. R. p> '~I f
~
- 4. ti, .,h - -:+:.' .f'~7(W b f:!s.* -.
9-IV.F, ? ?./te hi -H. 'Pa r: : .> .m .
. m Ks ~l~M. 'n W'M 6 ^'; E r.A c e , V
...e.
,s. .
6, .. . . ._ ) .R , - ---- - .. . . . ....... . . l qi H 4 , . n. .- : =l :..i :. .: . . " -. .
=.h) l3. ..C on. a c,o . cA .DMCA.. i-lA L U .
9-ly'. C-6 9. !q% -Wp _:$yh/;;n:Gia
- j~Fg*-:St?12AAr(4 : V w ?.u.q u A'. G .
~ : .* .
.c- i
.. : . : . . ..i . . . *
- ; = _. .. . . . -5; .a c:p.i..TTs... 1 .
.1 .n... .,...:
. .../;. :. -. . .
%t;,:g;;c-F
-$- w V. _//7'?:,../M;~D I .... N'.lb.# /.N . . . .
9::M.2=c - WW-Ji. -- .' Bit 3 h]hsti i ? I .: ? . r C.-: ? . W . h $ W .f . ? N h . .
. 9.,s ,T.:...,l ....:
. . ... , . . l : :..
g.9 -- . . . - . , . JJ Q (%znet ' o-s. Da ac.c , n, ,M G
. s.ici . p.z .
pyrr ,e2.1ts~~ i
.'1 - -
OPRPEUTER .S~ H o P l~6<r- , parc Ece'o ?>wAssisaca Keavesrso sv: - mr 1.: onvexeo fec'o 61 Fwsw$ foe: tem-t.Tuk - Fmuci - Kep.wes Weoca bgAnm toeweneo criac *t - Irns M cf~w s" .
'?- /C~ F 'r. 9 ~/i~- 6 4 r.>.s., f a ~ m r3 //)S7ALL 8 A' cc: ( T&)
Sc- q t . .(:c rz. %'t>R'r-( W(At-uR. { .. 6:IC S'i? '1E- % - Gr,7 o i ...-~~~~ ; i.DeLb ' a G~ L. A e N I
?- IC ?t-
- C-- #
9 - 1 P P 7' R-h1LL. L p.c;d
)b *)
~
pas' darsikt . YW^ :k*'"
? :
^I ~
[~g it 9-i p lr9 1 i
& T'r m '1 1 / ( % c4 /-{s L.t.
* $ t' (~. h . ? !.Up h?bu* N51"I'& A 3 -G W l '- W EIN.~, f
&E E -
b:. f~ y yp 744f-} = f / t?-c .x & /S-- W ua ' f%.ri'k.kt?%Vit;&gs#=js--
.2 '-fW' W f f P't /S~-Ev Tou O .n..-2?2 . l.leipcK "fD AL':P .if__f_.K'V.<..
- p. .
- g .c 5
% isw :. i r :- 4 9 2 p. t c .
S v.i P.5 9-i5~-F> ?:<r-? L- ~h ikurs>J .t Ld.t!.# !
/ 2:u"3 D w-- h.
- f , . .. .. - .
[ . > R.c -
,.: .h' 6 .c . - ' ' " '
~i.%g c)pu .e :2sGM b w.ws."Gi.W y q, tr-w . .z.. --.. ; 2s; 7&- Ms-y Ri nr.s &
9 - / 5 ~. f & Q - /[ 52- 3 C R2'5'U 'A ' '
) pC l'y.CY)3 '-//.:'.' S'.y&J J~H. 3>3-Cm C r!// :
Q p g lf7'pis irrnL. l(2.iJt.S
~~'
~~
3 ,.+.. 1 24 7'7 .C'/<-O l 9 "*/E f% 9- /5'~ ~ f V (.,J. p'7?c. 0 iNJJ tS '
^l O ' T N 0/6c E ['/AMf .
- . d p~ ..
/.
- f . . t )%f / ,E E N / ^ C == S , s 3 y y yg.e.o scr css .
4 i5=.5y ...
, :'- = ...-
.. ?- 8n 7,:g O.p,s.. . . :.
. -w ? - .
6 .
.- i /.3 c:c. . E. A' , ., o n. < 2:1 .. .
c- -A
,,c ~
[ - p... g .. _eg g
, fj( . ,.c =
.r.c _
;n? 6 /-
.__..:...._.._...j.
. /- . y.:g I , B ,u L_
m . . p. . - . .~ -- ..
.i, et y.i.-:. , .r=pl.,.T'.7
.. i,_.
l
,b iy;' :M%.y;*/ ' ..-.:.:.7 :
.- -.p . . .. /
- f.M <'s E> c. n*, .
'7. %,g) ;.g :. y c~FMc. . a _ ._ :U.,:c ._ ; __ '. , P%s 3 . .
--,<./.-- . .. .,-<c- j_g;e.2. ;. . . _ _
=& Y. .. .; ,'. . ; . .. . .
.. . .. . (2x . .hs.t.D 4. . :
7 + (?:-/.<..Wj - tC.fv &_v:. N4cl7.<-i_ .E.
? T'G m !*I W <s'? s- .
1 p ra.. . . ... .-. . A!=>l!,
=? Ba_ ; : ~~ t2:. 7.
,5 - - .j;E. r :. . _ . .: . . . ..d -. ....:
.S(. - .' O .
G - t. 3 -l-2/ - - :._ . :. l : ~7;C- -U0h' :. C: :h . . . .. . l o ,$p,; 9- i -D . #'k,wi%:;ti~;ir;im.] 7 8:/:i='.tci. . c.;Je:oces. : . -;. _
. .f. g._
r
- j_ _ >._ ..
. :g !
I
.l: s
- ..s...
) 'i: ff:pp . - :- :::. .: - . . C 717A C.A.,% l .. . . ~~. Z~Lx.G G. f$L.D & . , . . E. , V */f;~. f n - W?i~f4- /d} p.h: f. % 4i/ 4.) C l' l 2 .f? '$ h s.? ? ? 5 . W . 9 0, fP't'?; :: ; : 4?c -:i. . Cees c,kf& 4 ()'Q j b TWe -1'~'~- . Gi l ' 47c/r .. ~7/f() i . ?A W6 ' -
, 4PKPEUTCR Shop lo9 .
D Tc [cc *o Drt}lnignto3 E'EQoEs.TED SY: - g j Dkogg5o
&c*o 61 Famsw$ Ge Cam rSuk - Ps.nuc* - Kee.:n:.s Kreur.sr -
Wi!Cmnnr ;'On vcxeo csec = -IrrNs M c % E" 9-/c. f L 9-IS~-P k 6En /-icm~'stv- caw.x t-w,eq f-lC Cz ;iT - SE ge . .. .
@KW ..
7P2L % 2.c ' Tt?.i rcH94D - 9-/S-E b 9-/c-Fu 'S s e S Nus.re. . D EL / $"_ PLATG FW .
.g gg .
',(?i:;>q. 5/. o e. ..
4-Ilo- W G-77?A *2 A :;/ .2's.n m :a F7. usu .c 9 - I.S'Pw 9- 15~kt R c. ) k H- /5 h* 2- 4 y X /.6 '-- o " - 475 A t Ect - S L3 t%n 0&t o.rTw6 7 S: /7 - 6-E 4~ E gs,. . f.aC . t f rs us : [$-4 S-Eb-i NP " / EI) ' !? I'~ "- %? 4'-E'?l?G Y .i W..
.? c.TTLA Lf/s~ -
~
9- l5~9 %- 9. /f~-8 2- L.2 a d * [e-p.t,. n Eij_pni LA.>J n E53- SMD - .[h,k$
,, ,i.m A
~~.,c.h., .
e'W.,.,?~Ti
*r n. Sco & -
rr . ..- --- . . . -. .
, 9- t.5 b- 9 tr&2 I PW ff -W- hwa ~.:' Oya:.= s. y .7%q l-i&J
] KQ [4l4- /W Pr-n. RTcHO. Sid.q rctt t VFMIdWM i &T'M. M /g-
.WR_ _J. .n{2.%7_.YGM)' Y2.R.
'f-75~h - Q- is -h. --
-s c M E^2K m. M-ci, c.
'P sr. i Ac =
.- g ..-lga "
.r . . -. . . ,
. P.s hir-p.oe t> ~Do o m C Lw. E n.- i
. q .f v p j
-:.u.. y:'1w4 2 66-~ .-
r-'- iv ceT. .
~:
, - - ot_.r.. ra cu 5%._.o :6
'f 7.?t':c - 94;s':- P i: /75/.e* h ., e J. - /M.cg- a-m-ix' 'rrz'l~ M
- %v e&e fl : <!A37% -- -'2-
\.
.g . - . . .. .g , .. .
f:., pgy. ; .' . -
- 1,p.2:.c- m,y n . . i n - % .1, m e.. r+i ..:.at -
9 /5=h.- 'l -/.$-M-3nn on 64rw ' B.c k:' CWW S 3 W-R 5Y f C /?~
,, .g..c- -
-.; ,,i Paon Lots! . 3EE n
&sE- /6.su.a -2b csn: doc s. - = to tj.
ep ;g;W]. : . . . . ?..- .. g 7 t? A & .x / - . 6 o.c..<.u,+ .
?'- 1.C~-Pr. - 9- /r V-u Bnia r3:Ls 'c' 4 d4 8o.:'
. < c. W#~ -
di@-M/MP A'idV6 MN. .f~f. : p/6 "'
. -726-4 to. it ..isy -: .- .- m 2 . s. . 9 t.. w p n. L . . . *. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. -
9 -t g + ;. qqc Pz. - ..c : . . . . - . [ m in f '.cq: 2>y.?.g w ci.;r:.
. . (M .. Up :G2- -
n iG&i:.e- % z ~- : c' - 2Tf7A ;'-X:.c9 fnu T f I. .c. . . -. . . . . . . :.
?':-l : PAINT': YFf_LC.d 9: 19- 9 2.- 9-wrv. ./,4 re si.a -Men, A I p eu v.c r:.. 2+L.q T+6P.
O
- . 9 .- 2. Kr~ers
.gc_ .. -m n: . :. .- -
Fica...?.A!2. 9. t
- t. . . ... . .
-9.'Ic=J1:; , i: M r w - 27774- %J7 i' ' i . '(2Lh "*/S~2-g y -
( ,e / i .,,.4
**4
1 e e O e e j i S e 4 4 8 0 e e V e m m. O h 9 e e S O h ATTACHMENT 21 O b e
UAAJ .aa l .
, . . . . . . .. .- .. . . . - . . i
, . eco- we s:s1 . prtian s a ts oui criv a sista stenti sooetss ,
a ..in .ee .u , l BALANCE FO# WARD
. 1 1
- 2 . 2
- e 3 3 u ,
s s
*: S 5 '
7 7 8 8
- 9 9 10 10 11 11 .
12 12 1 13 13
- 14 14 1S 15 .
16 16 17 17
- 18 18 19 19
* ~ ~-
20 20 21 _2_1 22 22 23 23 24 24 25 2S 26 26 27 27 26 28 l _.. _ . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . _ . . . . . ... .. . .. .._ 1 l 908154 N Lmt . PLEASE P.W ,
~ ~
SIGN.TU.!
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
/ I 5,.E y j j ...i il e
f so .m , _ . L__dr. hLi._, ..,, ..._...,,. I
- m. .. .m, .. .
- 27.38 / i'dS,7. . n ,a.. .G ;
i
,, w= ^-' *w* "fD* '8* .-- - - **N****~8"}}