ML20080G595

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Nonconformance Identification Rept 013 Re Review of Electrical Field Change Repts & Field Change Notices.Eight Discrepancies Found
ML20080G595
Person / Time
Site: Midland
Issue date: 02/03/1984
From: Karr J
STONE & WEBSTER, INC.
To: Quamme D
CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
References
SWOC-84-024, SWOC-84-24, NUDOCS 8402130463
Download: ML20080G595 (2)


Text

.

STONE AND WEBSTER MICHIGAN. INC.

JRINCIPAL STAFF

,3[

N A* Q34<P P.O. BOX 1963, MIDLAND, MICHIGAN 48640 i

=

O/RA 3E lear

  • J 2 Y

,}

A/RP DRASF la * ~o-14509 1C DiNA j

l o an-N/A SAO ses v p-c.Ujf-3 l'va ao-SWOC-F% OW va IGA

'4 L l/

I"'.

N/A p

'gfF Filo ! _./) M DEAR SIRS:

Twe rou.ow-s a s O arrac-so O i.<~r sa aaarstv, D. L. QUAMME, C0Co Midland (site) 70

.,_ co fts PasNes E ooucaBLE ERTu g camos sac o-O oaa-.~as O saggi IcaroNs L

0 oocu==~r.

O aoris o co~

==~ce STATUS l

PLEASE NOTE I

SENT FOR YOUR O

.~a6 0

oveo 1 O arviso~s O o->=io~s O a ova' O co--e~r l

I O no.-..=,

O ovro as vis==,,*,",~,1,*, _

l O aoorro~.

O co aier o~s O us.

O. o -ario l h No cote-SNT UN CCI TABLE Co-ENT*

, ales O co~co

.~es j

10.uwen.o~ as ~ovio in CLOSED n

I VOUR ATTENTION IS DIRECTED TO THE FOLLOWING:

nats A=ED POR; O a...cario~ O u c-ass o ~ ace====> =ar= =.*'s 0 6 ass aevi== a~o sv.-<r

~rs ar aoouce='as

->c o i6-

=vuas c===s.

O 6sas: su.-rr

-rs as ooucis'as

- cao >'- a ru== caans o-O occu-e~rs O== --a s O

-o. = => 6 -

O tsair arcu ~ o~a co v a*ca o vais aria >=6 s===== vou

=ovat o co-- -rs.

l 0 ' mans ac ~o-t==

asce, v o v-

- re a6 =v =>a~~o =~o rvu

~s 1 e =~c' esso co, o v is o==.

! O ~r r ust vaar t~ess ~oris=== - acco oa~ce - r-voua u~o==sva~o-a.

~or.

' ease moviss um 1

IMPORTANT **e mITIt" Eda *'S"ztoER TMt Evissoa. -aoS wf7MouT cost.E S E"e"'v"w'rrS" v"i. S E

a Pu cM*=E Wfu. co~

The following closed CIO NIR(s) is (are) forwarded for your infomation:

O/3

  • The corrected first sheet of NIR 013 is attached. Please remove and destroy the first sheet of that NIR transmitted via SWOC-84-023, dated 2-2 ano replace witn the attached.

The verification signature was incorrectly dated.

A E. Karr CIO Program Manager

/

cc: LJGKeppler, US NRC JJHarrison, US NRC RJCook, US NRC RAWells, CPCo CIO Site File k k 0 K OS 7

0 TEB 8 1984 - -

~. l-STONE AND WEBSTER ENGINEERING CORPORATION NONCONFORMANCE IDENTIFICATION REPORT I DATE OF NONCONFORMANCE: 1-25-84 NIR NUMBER 013 IDENTIFICATION / LOCATION OF ITEMS:

Review of Electrical FCRs and FCNs/ Document Control DESCRIPTION OF NONCONFORMANCE:

During the review of Electrical FCR/FCN there were eight discrepancies found that are not in accordance with FID 2.400, Rev. 3.

1) FCN E-997 Sheet No. of affected drawing in Block "C" is missing (Attachment 1).
2) FCN-E-1052 & E-1657 Block "A" addressed one drawing. Resolution Sheet addresses more than one drawing (Attachments 2 & 3).

e

3) FCN E-1647 & E-2003 Block "A" was left blank (Attachments 4 & 5).
4) FCN E-1951 Corrections were made on Resolution Sheet without MPQAD's l

concurrence (Attachment 6).

5) FCN E-7689 Block "A" plus Block "B" did not equal Block "C" (Attachment 7).
6) FCN E-8810 Reviewed By Block on Resolution Sheet was left blank (Attachment 8).

Rd hw INITIATOR PROGRAM MGR

/'

DATE

-\\

'A 5 - 8% '

DATE

/ 8 l

CORRECTIVE ACTION BY:

MPQAD IDENTIFY ORGANIZATION TAKING CORRECTIVE ACTION CDMSuhAERS FthNER COMPA NY TRAMSMI.TTAL NUMBER.

C. S C.

T 2. C 7 OATED

\\ - 2. l - B4 W1LL SAT. ISFAC.TORILY CLOSE. THT,5 NIR NO. OL'5. SEE.

ATTAC.MED

RESPONSE

VERIFICATION SAT [ UNSAT NEW NIR#

CONCURRENCE fINITIATOR h A e^ P h _

PROGRAM MGR/-fM~

{DATE 2.-

-BH DATE DATE 4 4 -84/

\\

1 wm j

REMARKS l

~ '

= - - - - -

-