ML20073T088
| ML20073T088 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 05/06/1983 |
| From: | Bauser D METROPOLITAN EDISON CO., SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE |
| To: | Buck J, Edles G, Kohl C NRC ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL PANEL (ASLAP) |
| References | |
| ISSUANCES-SP, NUDOCS 8305100310 | |
| Download: ML20073T088 (13) | |
Text
_
t b
SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDG p\\
og A PARTNERSMlp OF PROFESSIONAL CORPORATIONS 4
1800 M STREET, N. W.
N(f@
b
& ) OAnoREw D. EL wismNoTO~.O.c.zoose 4
( O2)8224000 JErrERY L. YAstON RAMSAY D. POTTS. P C JOHN A. McCULLOUGH P C.
@ft RGE F. TROWERIDGE. P C GEORGE P. MICHAELY. JR., P C JACM MCKAY I %4 RICHARD A SAM RTEUART L PITTMAN. P C.
J. PATRICK MICKEY. P C.
THOM AS M. McCORMICM V TMouAsK.CROC JR-M MALD CMARNOFF. P C.
STEVEN L MELTZER P C pMeypg,gggygy-\\
d' f, 9, LTEPMEN D. POTTS. P C J TMOMAS LENMART. P C TELECOPIER JOMN L CARR,JR (
C#
WENDE(eft 4. W
?#.~ STANLEY M MA PHILUP D. DOSTW'CM. P C.
DEAN O. AUUCM. P C.
(202)822-1099 & 8228899 ROSERT M GORDOk dhrpmRgSTtLUM I
N"RG$"MI "R$eN"s'. $R. P C.
CULESDEMMIN. P C g
SARA J. MORGCN\\
.ggggg g, gggg NIE S. GOTTUE S VIRGINIA S.RUTLEDGE FRE 4 A. UTTLE. P C STEPMEN S. HUTTLER. P C.
A IFAM 800 MWARDH SMA M RMAN.
ggyggyggp gyggg JOMN 5. RMINELANDER. P C.
WiNTHROP N BROWN. P C.
JANICE LEMRER-STEIN L RUCE W. CMURCHILL P C.
JAMES S. MAMUN. P C (202)S224072 ANENeE 1
MARTIN D. KRALL P C ROSERT E. ZAMLE R. P C.
OAMRRELLM'LLEIER
' d T RAVIS T. BROWN. J R.
LETUE A. NICHOLSON. JR., P C RANDALS. KELL PC.
N N MOOGASAN
- RICHARD M. KRONTHAL KtCMAND J. MENDALL P C.
RosERT e RosalNS, P C.
SMEILA' McC MARVEY STEPMEN5.MEIMANN JAY E. SILDERG. P C STEVEN M LUCAS. P C.
TELEX SANDRA E. SRUSCA' EILEEN L BROWNELL C
E V AL EN PC C
RD E GA EN 8 9-26 93 (SM AWLAW WSM)
ENNETH.
UTMAN FRE @ DRASNER. P C LYNN WHITTLESEY WILSON
'E.8
'A DAveD LAWRENCE MILLgR AMELAM ANDERSON ALEMANDER D TOMASZCZUK R. K1NLY WESSTER. P.C.
MATIAS F TPAveESO-dea 2 FREDERICR L MLEt.N NATMANIEL P SREED, JR4P.C VtCTORIA J. PERKINS STEVEN P. PtTLER PMfUP D. PORTER MICHAEL A. SWIGER MIRMAUGENSUCK.PC JOMN M O NEILL JR.
R'CMAND J PARRE.NO ERNEST L. BLARE, JR., P C.
JAV A, EPSTIEN ELLEN A FREDEL ELLEN SHERtFF MANNAM,M.LegggmMAN ANITA J. FASSAN l
CAktETON 5 JONES. P C.
RAND L ALLEN JOHN F. DEALY, THOMAS A. BAxTER. P C.
TIMOTHY s. McSRIDE SANDRA E. FOLSOM EILEEN M CLEIMER JAMIS M SURGER.PC EUSAGETH M. PENDLETON COUNSEL JUDITH A. SANDLER DAVID R SAMR
(
OMELDON J. WEISEL P C.
MARRY M. GLASSPtEGEL EDWARD D yOymG, sti C. BOWDOIN TRAIN
- *eot aceerrvto ese o e WRITER S DIRECT DIAL NUMgER May 6, 1983 822-1215 Administrative Judge Gary J. Edles Administrative Judge John H. Buck Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Washington, D.C.
20555 Administrative Judge Christine N. Kohl Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 In the Matter of Metropolitan Edison Company (Three Mile Island Nuclear Station, Unit No. 1)
Docket No. 50-289 SP (Restart)
Dear Chairman Edles and Administrative Judges Buck and Kohl:
Pursuant to the procedures outlines in Licensee counsel's letter to the Appeal Board of October 1, 1981, the following facts with respect to personnel changes since the close of the record on management issues are provided for the Appeal Board's information and the information of the parties to the TMI-l restart proceeding:
1.
At paragraph 362 of the Licensing Board's August 27, 1981 Partial Initial Decision (" Management PID"), 14 N.R.C.
381, 505, the Board identifies and describes the qualifications of Mr. Richard Dubiel, head of the TMI-l Radiological Engineering 0305100310 830506 l
PDR ADOCK 05000289 9
'^'
G PDR l
o SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A IB48tTNEstSeetP OF PetOFE55 TONAL COstPORATIONS Administrative Judge Gary J. Edles Administrative Judge John H. Buck Administrative Judge Christine N. Kohl-May 6, 1983 Page Two i
group of the TMI-l Radiological Controls Department.
Mr. Dubiel has left Licensee's employ.
The current head of the TMI-l Radiological' Engineering Group is Mr. Roger P.
Shaw.
As indi-cated in the attached resume, Mr. Shaw has a bachelor of science degree in nuclear engineering technology, with a minor in health physics.
He also has had extensive post-graduate health physics training.
Prior to joining GPU Nuclear in March, 1982, Mr. Shaw worked in the field of radiological safety at Battelle-Pacific Northwest Laboratories (1980-1982), and at Rockwell Hanford Operations (1976-1980).
2.
As stated in Licensee counsel's March 11, 1982 letter to the Appeal Board, Dr. Robert Long was appointed the acting i
Vice President of Nuclear Assurance in March of 1982.
Dr. Long now has permanently assumed that position.
Replacing Dr. Long i
~
as the Director of Training and' Education is Dr. Richard P. Coe.
Like Dr. Long, Dr. Coe is an experienced educational professional.
See Management PID at 1 262, 14 N.R.C. at 472.
As indicated on the attached resume, Dr. Coe has worked as an educator in both academic and industrial settings.
j 3.
Within the TMI Training Department, the following personnel changes have been made:
The Manager of Plant Training, i
Dr. Ronald Knief, whose qualifications are discussed in the i
Management PID at 1 173, has assumed the position of Manager, Special Projects.
In this capacity, Dr. Knief will continue f
to report to the Director of Training and Education; however, l
he will be concentrating his efforts on the development of j
resource materials, such as the TMI-l Plant Systems Training Manual, simulator training program development, testing practices i
and instructor development.
Dr. Knief will continue to teach courses within the TMI Training Department, specifically, Reactor Theory, Criticality Safety and Accident Analysis.
Replacing Dr.
Knief as the Manager of Plant Training is Samuel Newton, whose qualifications are summarized in the Management PID at i 175.
Replacing Mr. Newton as the Operator Training Manager is Bruce P.
Leonard, who has been working for Mr. Newton as a technical programs specialist.
Mr. Leonard, like his predecessor Mr.
Newton, has a bachelor of science degree from the U.S. Naval Academy and is a graduate of the Navy Nuclear Program.
Attached is a copy of Mr. Leonard's resume.
The supervisor of Licensed Operator Training, Mr. Nelson Brown, who testified during the reopened proceeding, see, e.g., Partial Initial Decision (Reopened Proceeding), July 27, 1982,
(" Reopened PID") at I
SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNERSMir OF PROFESSIONAL CORPORATIONS Administrative Judge Gary J. Edles Adminstrative Judge John H. Buck Administrative Judge Christine N.
Kohl May 6, 1983 Page Three 1 2337, is now working on the development and coordination of emergency drills at TMI.
Mr. Brown's replacement as Supervisor of Licensed Operator Training is Mr. Edward J. Frederick.
Mr. Frederick has worked at TMI-l and TMI-2 as an instructor and in a licensed operator capacity.
He is a U.S. Navy. Nuclear Progran graduate.
Attached is Mr. Frederick's resume.
Pir.
Frederick's former position as the Supervisor of Non-Licensed Operator Training now has been assumed by Mr. Charles Husted.
Mr. Husted's resume is also attached.
4.
One of the subjects in controversy during the Reopened Proceeding was the so-called VV and O incident in 1979.
See Reopened PID at 11 2190, 2272-2320.
In April of 1983, Mr. VV submitted his resignation; he no longer works for GPU Nuclear or any other GPU subsidiary.
5.
Nine additional operators recently passed the NRC's i
licensed operator exams, bringing the total number of TMI-l reactor operators to 21, along with 21 senior reactor operators.
Sincerely, 4Am.*-
Deborah B. Bauser Counsel for Licensee DBB:jah cc:
Service List attached i
February, 1983 RESUME ROGER P. SHAW EDUCATION:
Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon - June 1975 B.S. - Nuclear Engineering Technology; Minor - Health Physics CONTINUING EDUCATION:
Attended 80 hour9.259259e-4 days <br />0.0222 hours <br />1.322751e-4 weeks <br />3.044e-5 months <br /> comprehensive radiological engineering /ALARA program given by General.
Dynamics-Electric Boat Division, Reactor Plant Services Section, a technical course involving radiological engineering /ALARA practice and theory.
Attended 80 hour9.259259e-4 days <br />0.0222 hours <br />1.322751e-4 weeks <br />3.044e-5 months <br /> Management Oversight and Risk Tree Analysis (MORT) course given by the Department of Energy, which trains individuals to be able to develop fault tree analyses of accidents and to develop positive tree analyses of proposed projects.
Attended a 60 hour6.944444e-4 days <br />0.0167 hours <br />9.920635e-5 weeks <br />2.283e-5 months <br /> Health Physics Certification Preparation Course, given under the auspices of the Health Physics Society, which covered.every aspect of health physics covered on a Certification examination; took a statistics course and attended several seminars at the Joint Center for Graduate Study, Richland, Washington.
PROFESSIONAL OBJECTIVE:
Apply nuclear engineering.and health physics principles to the management of radiological problems.
EXPERIENCE:
l March 1982 Manager; Radiological Engineering - GPU Nuclear, TMI-1 January 1980 Research Scientist; Radiblogical Safety and to Engineering Section - Battelle-Pacific Northwest February 1982 Laboratories, Richland, Washington Responsibilities and Accomplishments:
Provide technical support to major research labora-tory in area of radiological engineering and health physics, including formulation of proposals and projects.
Maintain Radiation Protection and Radiological Design Criteria manuals.
Completed major rewrite of former.
Responsible for oversight of Occurrence Reporting System.
New manual written for that purpose.
Rogar P. Shaw Page Two 1
i i
i Responsible for coordinating radiation protecticn for all Radiation Generating Devices (x-ray machines, accelerators, radioisotope sources, etc.).
Provide specialized training to personnel on as needed basis.
Participate in safety audits, appraisals and reviews of nuclear facilities and programs.
Proposed and conducted management workshop to improve overall radiation protection program.
Presented DOE-sponsored seminar on x-ray machine safety to local contractors.
Performed external contract work at request of DOE Headquarters, including:
air sampling / counting at gaseous diffusion plant; characterization of DOE radiochemical facility for D&D; etc.
Pacific Northkest Laboratory is lead health physics laboratory for the DOE.
l June 1979 Manager; Radiation Monitoring, Plutonium Production to and Storage Facilities, Rockwell Hanford Operations, January 1980 Richland, Washington Responsibilities and Accomplishments:
Supervise activities of 14-18 radiation monitoring personnel.
Prepare and Unplement routine survey programs.
Prepare radiation work procedures and monitor work for adherence to those controls.
Investigate radiation occurrences and issue reports on findings.
Provide training'to all persons entering facility on radiological protection, emergency procedures, etc.
Establish and implement any supplemental dosimetry.
Review operating procedures, work' plans for special activities, facility design changes and safety analyses.
Provide assistance for radiological emergencies and supervise all decontamination of personnel.
,r
_m._
Rogor P. Shaw Page Three Monitor facility air and effluents for radioactivity.
Ensure implementation of ALARA principles.
May 1976 Radiological Engineer; Radiological Engineering to Section, Rockwell Hanford Operations, Richland, June 1979 Washington (ERDA contract transferred from Atlantic Richfield Company July 1977).
Responsibilities and Accomplishments:
Provide radiological support services to major reprocessing and waste storage operation.
Review facility operating procedures, design changes and safety analyses.
Perform audits to monitor compliance with national standards and company controls.
Provide input and direction for solution of radiological; problems (e.g., shielding, exposure analyses).
Prepare safety analyses.
Monitor ALARA problem implementation.
i' Developed and conducted company Radiation Safety Training course.
Presented Radiation Safety and Prenatal Radiation Exposure modules for all new employees.
Revised air monitoring system (passive and continuous) in plutonium production facility.
Represented Health, Safety, and Environment Function on start-up team for the Plutonium Oxide Conversion operation.
Team leader for exposure and shielding analysis for the operation (including ALARA program development and implemen-tation).
Performance of investigation of radiological occurrences.
SOCIETIES:
American Nuclear Society Health Physics Society 1
.,---.,r,--<,
,._m
_.,_..m,m.,-.v_..-_,
m _ _ _ _. _. _ - -. _ -... -. _.,. _ -._
- - ~
RICHARD P.
COE CAREER OBJECTIVE An executive level position in Employee Relations or Human Resource Development EDUCATION Trenton State College, Trenton, New Jersey B.A.,
1961 - Industrial Education M.A.,
1969 - Industrial Education University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania Ph.D.,
1977 - Educational Administration-Labor Relations
.I PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE e Succession Planning e Training Consultant e Executive Selection and e Needs Assessment Recruitment e Supervisory / Middle Management e Career Pathing Development Programs e Executive Development-Programs e Mancower Planning e Personnel Policy Development e Train the Trainer Programs o Labor Relations e Media Development / Videotape
~
e Organizational Development e Corporate / University Teaching
' MAJOR ACCOMPLISHMENTS e Developed, administered and tracked executive management developmer program.
e Directed development and installation of corporate-wide performance appraisal program.
e Designed and directed individual development programs at executive level.
e Conducted needs assessments and directed the updating of existing management development programs.
p e Conducted executive level programs - interviewing and performance management.
e Conducted " Train the Trainer" sessions for corporate training progt e Directed development and design of programs in Strategic Planning and Finance.
e Developed organization structure of Corporate Group.
e Developed executive selection criteria.
e Directed corporate recruitment and staffing.
e Developed and administered executive development program for r
Japanese subsidiary.
e Directed corporate personnel policy development.
i I
e Supervised consultant programs in subsidiaries and ooerating units.
l e Directed videotaping and media development for management training programs.
e Coordinated purchase and installation of sucervisory training progt e Adjunct Associate Professor - MBA Program i'
s RICHARD P. COE 2
PROFESSIONAL CAREER e Manager - Organization / Management Development ARCATA GRAPHICS CORPORATION 6/82 - 7/23/82 (Position Eliminated - Major Staff Reductions) e Manager - Corporate Training and Development PITNEY-BOWES, Inc.
4/81 - 6/82 s Senior Associate - Management Development INTERNATIONAL MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE 1/80 - 4/81 (Position Eliminated - Economic Conditions) e Manager - Management Development ITT CONTINENTAL BAKING COMPANY 8/77 - 1/80 e Assistant Professor UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH Teacher - Assistant Princioal MAINLAND REGIONAL HIGH SCHOOL 9/61 - 8/77 PUBLICATIONS i
e DCA Technical Publications, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania e Industrial Education Center - Ohio State University l
l s
December 1982
]
RESUME BRUCE P. LEONARD Bachelor of Science-Engineering - Naval Architecture; US Naval Academy 1976.
EMPLOYEE EXPERIENCE PRESENT:
Technical Programs Specialist /82 to present.
Assist Operator Training section head in on-going review, evaluation, and revision of training programs for licensed and non-licensed operators and STA's.
PREVIOUS:
(up to three)
Staff Training Officer, S3G Prototype, Naval Nuclear Power Training Unit, Ballstonspa, NY, 12/81 - 11/82.
Military Department Head for approx. 150 qualified Nuclear Operators /
Instructors.
Responsible for implementation and enforcement of Training Programs including Chemistry, Radiological Controls, Maintenance and Operations for 150 staff.
Leading Engineering Officer of the Wanch, S3G Prototype.
12/81 - 12/82.
Responsible for coordination of training of 35 staff operators and 60 students.
Responsible for maintenance assigned to crew.
Responsible for operational readiness of crew.
Damage Control Assistant, Communicator, USS Daniel Webster SSBN 626, 10/78 - 9/80.
Division Officer.
MILITARY EXPERIENCE U.S. Navy, Highest Rank:
Lieu' tenant, Active Duty Commissioned 6/76 - 10/82 Schools Included:
Naval Nuclear Power T. raining, 1 yr.
10/76 - 10/77; Submarine Officers School, 3 mo. 10/77 -
02/78; Quality Assurance School, 2 weeks, 10/78; communi-cators School, I week 2/80; Drug and Alcohol Program Advisor School, 2 weeks, 6/79; Controlled Material System School, 1 week, 2/80; Engineer Officer Schooli 4 weeks, 6/80; Damage Control School, 1 week, 6/78; Water Chemistry Control School, 2 weeks, 12/79.
CERTIFICATES / LICENSES PRESENT:
Engineer in Training, State of Pennsylvania l
PAST:
Qualification as Engineer Officer, US Navy (Nuclear)
[
l RESUME Edward R. Frederick Supervisor Licensed Operator Training, TMI-l I presently hold a Senior Reactor Operators' License (Federally issued) on TMI-2 and plan to be licensed on TMI-l in December of 1983.
I supervise the development and coordination of all training for Licensed Reactor Operators in TMI-l and am responsible for ensuring adherence to NRC regulations governing Operator Training.
1983
- Supervisor Licensed Operator Training, TMI-l 1981 - 1982 - Supervisor Non-Licensed Operator Training, TMI-l and 2 1979 - 1981 - Technical Instructor, TMI-2 1975 - 1979 - Control Room Operator - TMI-2 1973 - 1975 - Metropolitan Edison Company - Auxiliary Operator 1969 - 1973 - On Board USS Sam Rayburn SSBN-635 1969
- Graduated USN Nuclear Power Program O
l i
1
RESUME Charles E. Husted Supervisor Non-Licensed Operator Training Three Mile Island Unit 1 and Unit 2 I presently hold a Senior Reactor Operators License on Three Mile Island Unit 1.
I supervise the development and implementation of programs for the training of all non-licensed operators at Three Mile Island.
1983
- Supervis'or Non-Licensed Operator Training, Three Mile Island 1978 - 1983 - Instructor, Licensed Operator Training 1977 - 1978 - Control Room Operator, Unit 1 1974 - 1974 - Auxiliary Operator, Unit 1, Metropolitan Edison Company 1972 - 1974 - R & D Project Director, Zausner Food Corp.,
New Holland, PA 1967 - 1972 - U.S. Navy, USS Sam Houston, SSNB 609 i
I
_.. - ~
_. ~. _ _. _ _ _ _. - - _. _ _ _ _, _ _ _. _ _ _ _ - _
/
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
/
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board In the Matter of
)
)
METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY
)
Docket No. 50-289 SP
)
(Restart)
(Three Mile Island Nuclear
)
Station, Unit No. 1)
)
SERVICE LIST Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Gary J.
Edles, Chairman Ivan W.
Smith, Chairman Atomic Safety & Licensing Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Appeal Board U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Washington, D.C.
20555 Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Walter H. Jordan
-John H.
Buck Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Atomic Safety & Licensing 881 West Outer Drive Appeal Board Oak Ridge, TN 37830 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Administrative Judge i
Washington, D.C.
20555 Linda W. Little Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Administrative Judge 5000. Hermitage Drive j
Christine N. Kohl Raleigh, NC 27612 l
Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal Board Atomic Safety & Licensing U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Board Panel Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Washington, D.C.
20555 Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Jack R. Goldberg, Esquire (4)
Office of the Executive Atomic Safety & Licensing l
Legal Director Appeal Board Panel U.S., Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory l
Commission Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Washington, D.C.
20555 Docketing & Service Section (3)
Robert Adler, Esquire Office of the Secretary Karin W.
Carter, Esquire U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Assistant Attorneys General Commission 505 Executive House L
Washington, D.C.
20555 Post Office Box 2357 i
Harrisburg, PA 17120
O John A.
Levin, Esquire ANGRY /TMI PIRC Assistant Counsel 1037 Maclay Street Pennsylvania Public Utility Harrisburg, PA 17103 Commission Post Office Box 3265 Harrisburg, PA 17120 Jordan D.
Cunningham, Esquire Fox, Farr & Cunningham Mr. Henry D.
Hukill 2320 North Second Street Vice President Harrisburg, PA 17110 GPU Nuclear Corporation Post Office Box 480 Ellyn R. Weiss, tsquire (1)
Middletown, PA 17057 William S. Jordan, III, Esquire (lD Harmon & Weiss Michael F. McBride, Esquire 1725 Eye Street, N.W.,
Suite 506 LeBouef, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae Washington, D.C.
20006 1333 New Hampshire Avenue, N.W.
Suite 1100 Mr. Steven C.
Sholly Washington, D.C.
20036 Union of Concerned Scientists 1346 Connecticuu Avenue, N.W.
Ms. Louise Bradford Dupont Circle Bldg., Suite 1101 TMI ALERT Washington, D.C.
20036 1011 Green Street Harrisburg, PA 17102 Chauncey Kepford Judith H. Johnsrud Mr. Norman Aamodt Environmental Coalition on R.
D.
5 Nuclear Power Coatesville, PA 19320 433 Orlando Avenue State College, PA 16801 John Clewett, Esquire 2
The Christic Institute David E.
Cole, Esquire 1324 North Capitol Street Smith & Smith, P.C.
Washington, D.C.
20002 2931 Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 I
i
---.