ML20071F021
| ML20071F021 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Harris  |
| Issue date: | 03/10/1983 |
| From: | Read D CHAPEL HILL ANTI-NUCLEAR GROUP EFFORT |
| To: | CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT CO. |
| References | |
| ISSUANCES-OL, NUDOCS 8303150413 | |
| Download: ML20071F021 (7) | |
Text
.
t o
s r r w cu.u c s o.<ue.w...
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
.,,. ;. r..,
g.
NUCLEAR HEGULATORY COMMISSION
'83 tira 14 All:12 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD si.iilcs$kf;c-
- -[Y Glenn O. Bright Dr. James H. Carpenter James L. Kelley, Chairman l.
In the Matter of
)
Dockets 50 400 OL CAROLINA POWER AND LIGHT CO. et al.
)
50 401 OL (Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant,
)
Units 1 and 2)
)
I a -c >.. ' O, 1 c, 8')
)
.e.r.e.w..ce_. v ;. C r.
'. ".T 'O.
.C.... T C e". ".. '..c., '
_7
- 7..c '.
.c.. s' '- r. r
~
^
t s
I:TE3:2.Cf'*."CO. irs On Jenuar: 31, 1983, Applicents ser"ed on Intervenor Crhpel Eill 5.nti-Euc13er Group Effort ( CE.'J.:cE)/Environmente.1 Lu: Froject
( EI.F ) (h treine:f ter "CFAESE") = "First Set" of interrorcc. tories.
?nis filine is in responsa to the c.ne.stions "ronouni=f. there-in.
ncrc7g1 intoy7a-= toy 1oe: cc7,tc7,t$c7 LL 1(e). Focts relied on: confusion about rc.ter 1:.31 ft
'_'..I-2.
Kr es of n:-rsons with first-h nd knc.:ler. c un::no..;, Fac h m n r-
_F 1 R = "or t O T '> - :- v. e t.= n t ' = S c ~ $ e t n o -
t': '.ccLE=nc F: hr e
.:ile Is199d I hcrcina.f t'.or "En. n; R=nort" ), 116-19, 122-23, 127.
1(b).ani li.c). Sea cnsxcr to 1(r).
2(c.) :nd 2'$). rot
- liest >.
3 ' a ), 3 f t ) e.i 3 ( c ). "c t n -
_ c-tle.
~
e<r3 r m. ~.
- . 0.., cer_.,,...r. _ n..., en., m_v.s.
4,.
-s t-830315041b"babbio U'
~
'CP U"'
^
'~~
PDR ADOCK 05000400 G
Page 2 Eocks, 1981), 74-75, 131, 129, 125 26, 139 41, 4(b). Contention 44 4(c). Allegation of noe:d, both docum:nts; allecation of confusion, both documents.
5(a). see answers to 1(a) and h(a) above.
5(b). Res?cnsss to general interroca. tories.
6( a). ITUE! ^: CH2628, ev :.ilabl2 at FA/SS Documsnts hoon, Uilson Litrary, Univ?rsity of Forth Carolin, ChSpel Hill, 1.'C.
6(b). Answer to interrogatory 4h-1.
7(a). Documsnts identified in ansuers to 4(a) and 6(9) above will te used durinc cross-exaninstion. I'o other documents pres-ently planned for use, nlthou;;h r-search on this contention is still on:foing.
7(b). Contention 44 Sneci'ic Inter"or'. tories: Contencion-44 4h-1. Fo. Th nest rarciti"e scric of the '.iVLIt, vn ter level s"ste. includes c nargin of arror of 19,' ( +2 5 f t), 15F7.10/C3-2628, p.
- 16. The core cssently for the SE':F. cre on1" 12!7" high, ?SAE Tirure h.2.2-3, so e.ssumin; ucrst-caso coniitions
...e.
q"v uI n.
- e. y r
+w et
.r~,o.
.m.. e.
. o.,
4 r.. e. a. cu ".=. +.,. v.- "
- r. '- 1_.. + o
- e. c +,,u..'. '," " a -
nort actur.1 coverinc.of the core or urcoverin~ of thr. core o
in s.n ec_uilibriur stats. Additionally, :IREC-/CE-262E ?.ocs r.ot r.nr. lyze the e ffects of bloch. :e or corroeien or re-4.ini.s fror the 97LIS svetan.
Eh 9
- r.. o. " o *. v..
- 4.,-
.u.. '.4 e, r. u.e
~w. a.. + 1.,
e,
.e. ow.- c v... e.
- n.... m. e..~.. a..
. v A v.
r..+_. e s..se v.?:,',
e,'v. v u.r. _4 c.. P.
"s 3.r. ', 't..
a e.
.w
. u.
n 5
Page 3 Ganeral Interro~atori'=n: Contention ?C(c) 3 1(a). Hanss of p rsons with first-hnnd kno.: ledge of revern-nent re ul. tory costs and indirect subsidies are not known to CHAEGE, principc117 bec.uce these are not rec 11y sutjects sus-ccptible to first-hand kno.:1di e. CH5.FC will E.ttenpt to pro-t vide such nn.ncs if Ap. licants cer. tetter define what they mean tv. " first ha".d knowledc.e" in this conter.t.
1(b). Sea answ'r to.1(e).
1(c). See ancuer to 1(a).
2(a). Not srnlicable.
2(b). Pot a7 licable.
- 2. (.,). r. o
,. i e, w, c...
y m
4
.<o e).,m. t,1.t..e4 o +,, w.. u.i.c-e, 4.a s t,.4 m..o.
.r.
- w e ~
o W, s
- 4.. 9, ', c ).
.S. e a.
=.".s.. ". t.o 3 ( ^.).
,t c
4 ( e ). l n r 4 i l.
...,1. m.a to s".,li t.
O_.'..
c '. '. 3.."."e" c ^.c. '., s, "
- 7. '. ' a. i s
n P.a,ce e r...a.r u..n. n..., r..,
%...,, t, 4.. c.. s u. c. - n ~..c.c n ),
.1.t,,.2 1. - _,. c,,u..,. 2 n.,,. _ e s
4.f a.
.e.an-D c v.
., ~.o. =. go.,
,,a=nu -,,
a4 c 1 ^ v '.."a.., " ". !.C s~u' "y 9,
' =, 0 0^ ^d, e"
- S i-m
--u-.
A.. 4,.y.
n 7., a -... ),. 3 n :.,.,,,.,.,_4,,.-......-.--.c..
,c
, _,,,s e,. x., n.. 3 a.
.m.... :..,
. s
- .. v..
1.,.z..
- 1. C, * ',' OA,
- n..
a, ( *4 v :.s 4 v..-
1;:,, e ' c.
o r.. - ". c".. n + '.,
- m.. a. s '. o.r
~
4 n
n w o. 4 c.
- h. 4 >..e.
co. u. 4. w..= 4 b-
,*gn.oco+
A e,4
- n.. c.- 4 e.
v..n c.
. e.. e N.
. -v. c w c. 1
..w s
.. 9
. w+
w v-
... v
.u 5.0^_".)*,
" ".a - l '
~c.'.'v^ e. c.* '. ^. u~'.i. "..
.e M.. i. '.
' n * ". c '...0.",,"
.".-C.'.*.
C.,
.','O^
^
~
[ e. O.,s e., & $ =. 7 - a. c f.3 r*..~..* - 1.i. c %, 4 *. 4 a,,,
. u.n n n. ;. 1 4,~ a -a a.....'. 2 c e.,i M a.
n.'.
we -
.=
n.1. n..e. '., re....". '.- ". e ". s Y.
.C. U ". h.. ".".'. A., " ". #.' C keP, '
O,,
- 10. 5. 0 ' C. *...".". " C-c'..e
- ^"
l.
a r
v.
.a.
- 7. ".I t c *
- m. =. ". ^... 6.
u^ w..
c ".'. :.." = " a.. '.^ ) - " U. t.,_4 ' '. ~. d e. "r e..a..e:,
. k.. e.. t., o.
+^
4q,H f+f'. ( s g 7 1*
- 1. },
4 C. O Q ( 4 e.v.
- p. ai * -. 4*r-7 n.*.A 4.- r H 4 v..t4. r.w o. e *
- w t t 7 n.,
- ..H T
~
. w
.c. e ". n. e r. v..,).
n.? e. c 5,,1,.3.,. A,
- v. uA{9-
- ve o.g
- v 4 +.,7 w
p.oa...
- e. 4.:, w c h..4 %.4_ %.
g,.4 + k.'
v e
'l e..g
- 1. - 0,u
". ' C. n.w e S 7, *_ L, 8 9,
83,'. o.. '. 'c. c ',, c # *** + "..
P.".. c..". ".4 -
4 c 9 C '., ). u t
- r.,
M. 2c v..5 6. s *. r. m
- v..s.1.
- e., n ' '. <..(
.Y g. %.
- 1..Q.,
.* sy G s Cv.s lLf14au L
P 4
.. _. u n :..),. St.r.o.,
.c, g~ o.,
la.t..
\\'
.w..
+c..7 g > 4 1_1.i o,.
e.= 4
.w 1-
-7 n.,...
-m-4n.. e. 4 1 y a..
- A, - o..
r w e e. *.
..=s*
_-.c6.%.--
i.42- -.. f., y A. e 6y,,
,.3*,
c. v, :..p s...
' +..h 4.4.Y.'""
..N d..",-
- g
- b.,O..M ('h N'
6#
w Y
b $.$ '.
4
...%.g
.D 9
38'"
.i.
g,
,,g'.s y[
d.
g g
,.,,,4
- t., 4 H f C'
- ft )
- ', f 7.,
h (gP.'. pg J.
,e."'
. s
- c..
- s.
- v.
wa..
,. 4,a y ey..
p m e..
vt g, s
---..e.
.v
rage 4 purch,ses);10"Uhite House p1r.n to -'.id c1cctric utilitics won' t seck r. jor chane.s in stete powers," '.:SJ Oct 8,102, p.14 (pvoposed federal ne;;otie. tion progran to encourare cost-sharing);
U" Utilities see.k refinancine plan of ')2.25 tillion," USJ Sep. 24 1982, p. 4h (WPPSS seeking federal aid to runrr.ntee bon #.s);
12'.' Price relief civen buyers of urar.ium," ULO Aur, 22, 1982, p.
24A (governnent providin unwarranted price relief to purchasers of uranign) bUtilit.y shares hold up well despite troposals in tax bill that could scell troutic for thsc," FSJ Aug 27, 1982
- p. 53 (effect of 1989 tax 7roposels on tax-fras reinvestgent of dividende)
"Utilitiac rushin:. to k. sap tax breek," !!LO July 21, 1^82, p. 5 (siniler), "!:uclear fuelc cro~ran faces opposition as Cor.~ress onc-ries 97 billion Chio n1nnt,". SJ 94
- v.. e... / m.,, 1 c, 8 2, ".. h ( :~.,^. ". a.." *.. r.... *..euk.e. # d i ~ e f. c a". +.r _4.fu r a. - "'..'.)-
"40 a
Eillion free ride for nucler ".ouer," Oriticel ass In.rry Jour-ne.1 ( har-inaf te" " 0"ZJ" ) Jr.n. 1?S1, n. 5 f"T.1 E".ilout Fr.chade D a 'u.4 1_ a. '., "
"a.". ".J,
r.
_i c. P.. ',,.
h,-
"U k.e +., '.h =. >mtif. m t. - m e fo."
iner v, " _Id c.t 6 b," n..-i_l,
e_
" nrono tin,re, !!vele.nr :-ower D03-Stv, le," 0:3J e,
I:ov/Dec 1991,
- 7. 5 (federal inforn~ tion nd tronotional efforts);
N"Three.'ile Island Ouner's da age suit a". inst reactor tuilder
.e a t 'u o s ' a."'
t ~- 4..v., "
7.0.~',.'.'. o ",
_5,
.m, 89 p.
6 (
v- ' a..". '. 4 a _1
.c o. ' a..e l e
, i,.> i l 4_.,s..
. o, 1., i. m...,. & rc. u,,
,io ).,2
- v..a.
e i.
ev v et. i.., l e._. c. _4 n e a
.s in tact," Yo"k ( Fn. ) D = ily "ecord, 1:c". 30, liS2 (2efusal of d _i e '." i c ' c ^,u" '. ' o ei.i.....i. e.e. ~. 1.4.~.. ". c =.. c u i '
- 5. -.'..c'.
m.t*."..e..n.t.),-
m e.
li n.%o. era 1 3u
.c.44.4.2s
+e.
s
.v.ue._.y -
...... n.., n
.e. t.. &.,. c.. &.
u..
n....+c,_
w m
- u. n e,m...c. 4. m. em..,. w,. D.".
.. ~ ^ ". - '.
.T. o. 4 v.., r i"... ' - ' r ". e
'..k.'
'. > 4 e " _4 e. 'u s
Oourt of E07 rs County,'Chl:.hona, "ov.
20 21, 1r;??.
blh). Contention 7?!c).
E l. C ). i..
F., ^. ".. '. a.". ' 4 on M,.'." '. ' m# #.. _4 + 4 ont.'6 "o.."Ul 9 'so"'
."1 ' ". ".. 4 'v v " _4 "4.'
v.
6 y : w. e. r v r.a..l
../ r,, ?_. n e. e. d..w 7 1.- _ +e_e o.1 E.. 2.s4 - t..s.
.1,
- o
.em.. C 1 e. i n e
v.
i w.
.2 a
-4
"=fer?nc^.
Q (u' ev r. n. * *
- v.. n~, n.~. m c. vv. _A v. ~
- q. u e n..
- *c-m
~-
. - n -.e
,.e.
e. vs.m.
. e.e i '. n.a. c p.1 2.'.,
j,
.c. 9.e v- "'.2 C.1 * ' "
~c'.'..
.k o _' _# - " ; n" '
C..#
.v 2
. s2,
1-s h. o g. _.k.
_T
- k.. e...
v > &.
y. A.
-vi e n n..,.., v....
.e. a, ha.:-..a..
s wv 3
g..
w e
(
v j..C(
T m =..e}A.
.v.,6 e-w..
.. Q
__.Ay.
P m.ve
.Pr>.?,
m %
1.,~ _ m.. v.. *'.r.v..'
q.
A..
. e.m
\\.
,y-
. c 4..
,e-r_f A
,. a s
q n,. e.,..
.v
,,,ea...... e. -../y e',
2 e.
...v..
- ;,,e gg
'T.
. e
/
c Pe.5e 5
- 4. Contention on other costs: fe6.eral, subsidy of cleenup costs for eccidents at SE?P, see itens 1, 2,Gf. proposed f=deral help for ?".I); general financial subsidies, itans 3, 10, 16, 21; possible 'rovern1ent liability for negli ent re;;ulr-tion, itens vtb 4, 19, 20j possible Lovernment involve:cnt in caintaining nunicipel bonds iscusd to buy share of nuclear plents, ite.y 11 (proroced backin[; of'.C-F.".S bonds); fuels su?.sidies, itens 12, 15, 16; insurence subsi-lies, iten 21 p. 2; cronotionel subsidias, items 5, 21 p. 2; insurance subsidi;s, itec 21 r.
2.
5(a). See answer to h(a).
5 m.. ). o.u =....,
- o..c. 4.. ), 4 ( c. ), 7 H. e )
1-4.. (. o. ). U. n. nc e t'
& %.. e ~.. y c. w. &.. e '. A. i &.,1 o* n. ' rn. me.,:..w a k.
gl_ o. v_.. e *t.
4 s
_a p w ).
.e
,.,, e,....w v-6 ', c. ).
u-
~.,.....
- : e. ). n.v.<..:~....-.
u n. e v.e 4 u_,., s., _a e.ae. A.. ' u..,
r a
i +,, 4, r =., m..;. e to w c, n...a w ~ e f
v
.s m
c.e r g.
o.,s.u.. $ m., +. s. v....e ~..-a n.
_<v..~,..w..a..c.
+ o v n.. =.
r a.
u..s. _, gm.a c..n...+. c i a.. w..+. 2 -
2 n
s
'i-i in 4(a) cbo.e in c=0ss a:&-ination, plus others as they
- c.. e
.va. n..,
- r..v a. w = e =. n. c...a.
-w u
'.p r '. ). C o".. '. <.".. +.* o".
T. '. c ).
v' e e o. v...".'.. *.~. c *o h>o) -"' h.c\\, ' n. " ~.
r
- m. s.. 5.we.
r
.c e: C
- c. 4 C 2
nW
.c..4.4.... _.. /
.c')
.c 4 a w w n..
.:: uv o w.-c: n.
w.....
e r
"; ' t C )
- 1..
's '..'/.
"..'s*.- f. i L'u "..$. ".
"..v"..'.',_*"..'.' a 4_ ".. " '. C..'.. e*. '_,.a
~.
^".'1
w.
g
- e. _... " '.. " -
~
i.w *,
S h. e.,
r c
.e.,.
1_ A 4 v., c '. ". #' ' '"a ' ~. '. 0, ". g' ' ",. c" c ',,'
'..,c~.."*.'.'.,c.'*e
'6,'..'.
a v
-v
- - ^
.s O 'f '." ',.4 o".. O.#
.O U.. '.I I.
- b.. '. C".."."*"..*..'",.*.
D..^._'"'."~'.'c
".. ^. *. "". 1 "
- w.k. '..
g w e. t, n l., A. g w...
v 9.e. e A. 4 w o_ s. _1..
- 4.,: w 4..
1 ;.- b 3_
A n
e r
4,.k. c.
.m,
.. s._q., &,
- s... e.
e w
.u u
- n. s %. a :.w '
o'< r s. wr. r..,. s- - 1 c e.,.c &. e..
- r. n., u~.4
.:. s.'".'
- ..e..
. 1 - ~. &.
"%.. e u
s...
-a.
T a, r p4 I e nwA w n.
~'. c..y.
- o %.....w 00 -
v..a i r,,.r.. +:
e e _ ;,,. 4.- i n,., _;..,
s
~
v.
.s.,_.
.s
- .. a.
gy }..
"?., s
,.7.-v e, C p.., 1_
.e n..
f w.
(, ?
p p.
- L,,*, r>
.?
~w
,y "I 20 (b.r.," "Ot"'.c.").
".'.h... w e '../.v n.
- . d. e.. r ". v _.r. 7 n..e.. c c'
. a e.. o.,
.4 v
2 e. e.e.. 7., 7 p..,..
c c
,,,us.., c.4,, 3 3
.u
,, g.. g r. ij,.,
.....,y u...,,,,.
... a
. n.. n,e,
+n....
.e,,.. :
~n..<,,.,,.
w.
4,....
,..,1,..
c h..
.,'..,,ae' o-w..
t.
.g
.....A..
- m. P
- . e. v..s. -
n m.
c
.5.*
p.
-,s.. e,. ' 1
_*b,.2 P.,,
s.._w..
L 1 i_
2 r.
o w
a
.v, s. s
- b
.',g(. p f *, ).
s,/..
g..,.
g og 8'jg)
.-w....
--,3
.p
, 8 q.
p o$g
F o
e
\\
Page 6 othar.:ise naintaining the. inbility of ECII:PA bonds in case of default, fuel subsidies, and insurtnce subsic.ies are properly included within the scope of the contention. "'he sentence added to the ER only r:oes to the noct direct costs, and does not deal et all with thes, additional costs and potential licbilities to which the taxcaycre are ex osad as e result of the proposed license activittns.
70(c)-2 See incier to 99(c)-1.
As I und.erstand the procedure on production of docuacnts, nd ths An;11ctnts' recuest for production et a lece "nutuelly convenient," I believe that allowinc subsequent arrantenents to be mde. rgcriin;; production will be sufficient; they can te crranged by telephone. Since Dr. I.olins' testinony is the only one not.readily avc.ilabl.3, I su onclosinL a ecpy with the filira sent to A.;11 cants.
A?rIDA'IIT I, Dr.niel ". P.end, h-ve read the fore.~cing and i t is to the best of a" Pnowled: c true 2nd correct. I wiP nu, ply furth'r answ5rs to these cuestions as I ettein furthe' r=1 c-a't in f or:.s tion.
f
- % rch 1?83 s.
.n.. 1 u :. = a:.3 e m==-., -.
.
- r.., m..
r=, n.. r s y +1..'.,
ue
..b V.7 t.
u.....s C u-T *4.?..m.. np
.%. t.. m.. =".
s
-I, '.,/ MM-8kM mze l:otary Ful l' c fcr thi St' te t./.4 County n n.
~
. m. c., - i 2.., r..c,,+c,ri._.,
- m..... _vn_,u..-. Du...I 1.
n
..s u.,:re. red t afore..y; c.
m v
'~
.c and -ffir.rd tk.e fore.;cing.
s A{
- %,,,e,,,,,-d.. /f/EW/mx HIS 8
- l. _~ ~T
..F.C H, '083
~
i, c..., c. e.. -. _..,,., [.
5 [.t HOTARY
- i.
os Pu;UC (J[
I,d*\\
4'8
.
- 4l,,-
/
.M C00k
*a
,s UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR 'BEGULATORY COMMISSION
'Mf,}y E
In the Matter of CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT Co.
) Dockets
~
etal.,ShearonHarrisNuclearPlant, Units 1&2f50400, 50-@f1MR 14 All :12 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby cer'tify that copies of (m.t# d MMM G Attkced5kgPs"ENECE Cwif k f af Sn<tneyf<vMt were served this
/0'fk day of Me.f h
, 198 3, by deposit in the U.S. Mail, first-class postage prepaid, upon all parties whose names appear below, except those whose names are marked with an asterisk, for whom service was accomplished by hand dehv?tM (1 Mkkh QMG 2
(m pj l% U (Ldchin)
James L. Kelley, Licensing BoaniEsq./Mr. Glenn O. Bright /Dr. James Carpen Atomic Safety &
(one each)
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washin5 ton, DC 20555 Office of the Executive I.egal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 hs Bace,Erf, Docketing and Service Section
$pp/T Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l D O M W W.
Washington, DC 20555 W Mbihp M, K D O N
$ Mr. John D. Runkle Mr.PhyllisLotchin Conservation Council of North Carolina 108 Bridle Run 307 Granville Road Chapel Hill, NC 27514 Chapel Hill, NC 27514 M. Travis Payne, Esq.
Mr. Wells Eddleman Edelstein and Payne 718-A Iredell Street P.O. Box 12463 Durham, NC 27705 Raleigh, NC 27605 Dr. Richard D. Wilson Patricih/- : c Newman 729 Hunter Street CANP Apex, NC 27502 2309 Weymouth Ct.
Raleigh, NC 27612
]
b Daniel F. Read President l
Chapel Hill Anti-Nuclear l
Group Effort l
P.O. Box 524 i
Chapel Hill, NC 27514 i
_,_