ML20058L635

Forwards Safety Insp Rept 50-341/90-09 on 900514-0706. Violations Re Inadequacies Associated W/Emergency Diesel Generator Surveillance & Process Computer Changes Noted,But Not Cited

ML20058L635
Person / Time
Site:	Fermi
Issue date:	07/26/1990
From:	Beverly Clayton NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
To:	Orser W DETROIT EDISON CO.
Shared Package
ML20058L644	List: IR 05000341/1990009 ML20058L635
References
NUDOCS 9008070366
Download: ML20058L635 (2)

See also: IR 05000341/1990009

Text

'

p ,

e , ,

' '

IEC 0/ D C /3 L(. AID 51

'

-

,

1, .  ?. 0 s

. .

.

c

h 1

e ,

,

e , ,

!

'

-

"

QUL 2 61990

.

U e 1

!^

V- - Docket No. 50-341

,

,

, .

y qf -

4*

n >

? . T h'Ye Detroit Edison Company '

,

I ,1 - . ATTN

William S. Orser 1- -

, .

i

'

II ~ / J Senior Vice President s '

',

C

( . Nuclear Operations

'

3

'l  ;' i i ~

J 6400 North Dixie Highway 7 ' '

kg/

,

[ ,

7 f Newport, MI '48166

'

-

ee -:

'P

'

[ aG'enilemen: ,

"'

i -

ii ,,w ru -

^ '

,  ;

i .

3,*.',.'ThItsreferstotheroutinesafetyinspectionconductedb D. Butler, J. Jacobson, J. Gavula, J. Smith;; D. Schrum and

'

F.nBrush, J. Ulie ', N

'

t S. Stasek of this office on May 14 to July 6, 1990, of activities at Fermi 2 C .

5 T authorized by Facility Operating License No. NPF-43 and to the discussion of -  !

.

• 1

our findings with you and members of your staff at the conclusion of the 1 *,

inspection. .

The enclosed copy of our inspection report identifies areas examined during 4 , ,

b,

"

'

the inspection. Within these areas, the inspection consisted of a selective' ' >

examination of procedures and representative records, observations, and F

interviews with personnel.

- Two of your activities appeared to be in violation of NRC requirements. The

t first dealt with inadequate material review controls associated with solenoids,

for valves E51-F025 and E51-F026, allowing alternating current'instead of

direct current solenoids to be authorized.for installation, contrary to

10_CFR 50, Appendix B, Criterion VIII. The second. dealt with implementation 3

inadequacies associated with an emergency diesel generator surveillance and.

- process computer changes. The first violation'has-been categorized as a .

licensee. identified Severity Level IV violation and the second as a Severity

Level V violation. Since you have initiated' appropriate corrective actions i

"Y before-the inspection ended, in both cases, a notice of violation wi11 not be 4

y issued. You are to notify us in writing within 30 days, of the date'of this

- letter, only_if you disagree with our statement ~of your corrective actions- .

' for these violations (Paragraphs 3 and 5) of,the enclosed inspection report.

l

Otherwise, a reply to this issue is not required and weldo.not have any

1 - further questions at-this time.

- In accordance with 10 CFR 2.790 of the Commission's. regulations, a copy of

,g. this letter and the enclosed inspection report will be placed in the NRC

Public Document Room. ,

. .

,

.

,.

8070366 900726 l

0 mock osooo m '

3

t

FDC q

y= ,

1 -

Mg ;;.y 1- v' .

,

m.,r  ;

"

c, ~% O U C M-

As

..

.ph apo n. n.

.n s yw

a 3, .-

.

s-

.

1-

.

.

, , . ,

,

.

',?,..

a y. ;o , ,

, - s

< w: v

.

- <

,

o

, ,

' a- .

-

.. .

g yyv * a-

.L.  : ;g '

- L i

'

+ <. , . .~

,e g4

, , < , v

-

_ /' $)3

.. .

'

~ .. . .

,

"

,,

a

y,

,

1. p .

1 T), _ ,

' ,

,

r

j3ng l g4 9,9 p. . . b

\ y.

tc .22-

J 4 ( in- E

u s c f, 9M The Detrolt. Edison Companyi ,

'

-

-

. t 4 . R

i , 1

y s < , 1 ,

,- , j '

. p j., p- 4.

,

m >b.. .

• + ' y '

ij.

e. j e - f

y '"

i ,

,

"

[+ fWe will:

s .. .,

,

n..

gladly discuss any questions you have'concerning'this' inspection. y

,

r . ..

7~ . .

phyM. 7 ' ; fincerely, no

.

'

.

'd v y

vs.,

__

s <

.

.

,

r, . :

g,

<

, ,

Lf,,., '

. .

,

<

,. ., p ,

t". , j ' cgf

& ,

g 4 g  ; y q , j;

m s{.' a

, .

.. r'

.

.

. ...s s .

g .

. A ,, , ~ , Brent Clayton,-Chief , . s 1 * w w M, w;s

,

$; ' .1

.

j+e

L

-

,,',

1 ,

,

Reactor Projects Branch 2 *

i < ' "

1. , ' ' ,M

, .o- ,

,

< ,

, .

'

$j' - J Lsndlosure: Inspection Report

"

[ ,

nI$ $

h%: Nr.; No; 50-341/90009(DRP).

'

t o, i

w' 'w yi. v ., , y ,

t4 ,[

tgl

'

t

,

'#: 'cc w/en, closure.

,

Jm .

'

.

- + ;, a 1

D.-R.' Gipson, Assistant Vice- '

q

'

,

,

L'f

f g' ' 'u President & Manager ~Nr. lear- '

. . 1

J,

W. Production. L.. .

- -x

f^4 N "

'

3'"'..P.DA. Patricia Anthony, Licensing.

,

'

< ,7

'; Marquardt,. Corporate

a1

'&." ;'g

s

,

'

'i s legal; Department <  :

j

p w DCD/DCB'(RIDS)

' * '

'

' '

i n ', s c W Licensing Fee Management;B' ranch

M

&

,

.- ' *,

1 Resident Inspector, RIII , .

, ,

$

p' ,

r James R.3Padgett, Michigan Public: g~ . , %;

m

.

Service' Commission

Harry

. H. Voight, (Esq. ~

, J id

v Michigan Department of

'p"-s $.' ' '

y [

e

'

.

"' 4 .J d

. Public Health .

'

N '

>

~ w"

4 L * /' Monroe County.0ffice of,

.. Civil Preparedness

1[- ' ,[%r[n]}

<

[Y"wu  ; W.

,

'

. Fermi, LPM, NRR ,

4 .

,

>+

, ,

,

1 n a>

'

,o

W,

. t <

e-t

?A*,~ Mtj

.

<( s

w

'

. ., v ,

3 s ['*s . , ii

n: ' '.C

0 l! -

'}

"(' I J E

,

' ,'  :

.e

.

,.

, , .,

7. 4-- 3 > ~ 1. i . j

" ' O

, .e f

. ' . 1'

_,

p n.

'l

.!( ,

l

.

u t .

,n

v

y.: , ,1

.

.

7 m

Qs ,r

7

M ' 4

RIII -R I RIII RIII G -

7a

A/M-

^

,a ge,q - Ss j

g f,$r.Schrum/pb' 'Droui7 e ayette Clayton3 o

4 s :. xr J07hs7901 ;07/tf/90. -07/2J7901 07/Z(/90 <

'

,

, s

fu ,

• ~-d.0 ,,

'

s,4; -

. . ti

.

1 '

L

1

.g 5' k g

, j; i s , y fa :

/

,

8 M'! :: O , >

'

8

, yj.D ilk c'

'

v[ .  ;

x m. i- .

,

_ _ _ , _ . . _ __ _ . _ . .

,.

. _ _ . _ i, ,2