ML20058K980
| ML20058K980 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 07/24/1990 |
| From: | Thomas Scarbrough NRC |
| To: | Stark S GENERAL ELECTRIC CO. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19330E829 | List: |
| References | |
| IEIN-90-040, IEIN-90-40, NUDOCS 9008030300 | |
| Download: ML20058K980 (16) | |
Text
,
7 R
fi TO:. STEVE STARK 7/24/90
{
1 GE t'
FROM: TOM SCARBROUGH NRC AS WE DISCUSSED TODAY, I HAVE ENCLOSED THE CRITERIA USED TO
-EVALUATE THE CAPABILITY OF THE MOVS WITH SMALL VALVE SIZES THAT WERE NOT TESTED BY THE NRC.
THE CRITERIA FOR THE LARGER VALVES ARE PROVIDED IN INFORMATION NOTICE 90-40.
VALVE TYPES NOT TESTED (SUCH AS CRANE) WERE ASSUMED TO OPERATE IN THE SAME MANNER AS.THE l
_ TESTED VALVES THAT REQUIRED THE LEAST AMOUNT OF THRUST.
IN OTHER
'l WORDS, I WAS OPTIMISTIC IN MY ASSUNPTION THAT THE UNTESTED ~ VALVE
[
WOULD PERFORM SIMILAR TO THE BEST VALVE.
ONLY GATE VALVES WERE EVALUATED.
IDENTIFIED GLOBE VALVES WERE ASSUMED TO OPERATE
-PROPERLY.
AS WE DISCUSSED, DISK TYPES OTHER THAN FLEX WEDGE (THE TYPE IN THE TESTED VALVES) MIGHT IMPROVE PERFORMANCE TO SOME EXTENT, BUT NOT SUFFICIENTLY TO REMOVE ALL OF THE IDENTIFIED CONCERNS.
THE THRUST INDICATED TO BE-REQUIRED FROM THE NRC TESTS (AND ANALYSES FOR SMALL VALVES) WAS COMPARED TO THE TORQUE SWITCH SETTINGS PROVIDED BY THE BWR OWNERS GROUP FOR EACH VALVE.
WHERE
'THE TORQUE SWITCit SETTING WAS SIGNIFICANTLY BELOW THE ESTIMATED l
THRUST REQUIREMENT, THAT VALVE HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED AS A CONCERN.
THE RATING OF THE ACTUATOR WAS COMPARED TO THE ESTIMATED REQUIRED THRUST.
I AM AWARE THAT LIMITORQUE IS IN THE PROCESS OF.
4 INCREASING THE RATING OF ITS ACTUATORS AND I TOOK THAT PLANNED h
INCREASE INTO CONSIDERATION.
FOR THE MOTOR SIZES, I ROUGHLY
. ESTIMATED THE TORQUE THAT COULD BE DELIVERED FROM THAT MOTOR SIZE L
'AND COMPARED THE RESULTING THRUST TO THE ESTIMATED THRUST L
REQUIREMENTS FROM THE NRC TESTS.
THE EVALUATION OF THE MOTOR h
SIZES ARE-OBVIOUSLY SUBJECTIVE, BUT I DO BELIEVE THAT THIS HAS IDENTIFIED CERTAIN MOTORS THAT SHOULD BE EVALUATED MORE CLOSELY..
y l-ATTACHED IS - A COPY OF THE MOV TABLES SUPPLIED BY THE BWR OWNERS U
GROUP WHICH I HAVE MARKED TO INDICATE THE MOTORS, ACTUATORS, AND L
TORQUE SWITCH SETTINGS THAT ARE OF CONCERN ON A SHORT TERM BASIS.
I HAVE INCLUDED THE MOVS FROM THE NRC STAFF SURVEY FOR COMPLETENESS.
I HAVE DISCUSSED OUR RESULTS WITH THE CONTRACTOR j
L
.THAT PERFORMED THE TESTS AND WE CONCUR ON THE VALVES THAT NEED L
ATTENTION IN THE NEAR TERM.
j>'
I BELIEVE THAT YOU HAVE SUFFICIENT INFORMATION TO REVIEW THE MOVS jm IDENTIFIED IN THE ATTACHED TABLES AS QUESTIONABLE.
WE ARE l&
REQUESTING THAT YOU BE READY TO DISCUSS THE CAPABILITY OF THE IDENTIFIED MOVS AT THE AUGUST 1 MEETING AND TO PROVIDE Lj INFORMATION FROM THE INDIVIDUAL LICENSEES ON PLANS TO CORRECT ANY l
IDENTIFIED DEFICIENCIES.
ALSO AT THE AUGUST 1 MEETING, THE STAFF WILL-DISCUSS THE DRAFT 50.54 (f) LETTER REGARDING THE EVALUATION OF THE MOV DATA.
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ON THIS MATTER, PLEASE CALL ME AT (301) 492-0794 OR TAD MARSH AT (301) 492-3288.
,,. c ~ _.
L{9002080306 A
^
4
--emm-- - -
-e erw--
-'a z
,'.C s
lWithout specific design inforsation we estimated the fleir area, stem.
sizeLand packing loads. The disc factor.is repsuentative of predictable valve behavior.
No effort was made to include possible loads resulting from
[
valve damage during the closure. All calculations made at 1000 psid:
' Size. in-Disc Disc
' Sten Total ib MFA fnehen Egigg M
Rainction P,gking Thrust I
Velan 3
.5 2655 994 500 4149 4
.5-
' 4701 1484 500 6685 Walworth 3
'4-2543 785 500 3828 4
.4' 4536 785 500 5821 A/d' 3
.5-2584 745 500 3869 5
4593.
745 500 5878 4
Powell 3
.5 2743 994-500 4237 4
.5 4877
<1484 :
500,
6881-A/d*
8
.5 19518 2405 1000 22923
- The tested 6 in. A/d tripped out without completely closing at 13 K.
Some margin should be added ta the above calculations for unpredictable behavior.
o i
. Y DS O
hk, f-N -
~,4Q
\\
ghk
~ Df N-
'* 1 MN b
M d horn. t MwvTA &an
~
p _j :
1
~
BWROG SURVEY RESULTS FOR HFCI STEAM SUFFLY LINE 1501aTICIlm
.[ ["
-1.:
~ :
Oceaina Closina h
Valve /Tvon Valve / Size Motor Manuf. Hasar Ooerator all I
m: I Toraue Sritsh Basta Ients/r Bania cansa 1
(in)
.(ft Ib)'
(psig)(F) (poig)(F) Eggag (Ibe)-
(poig) i A
Walworth 10 Limitorarse 40 SMB-0 1000 550- 1000 550 28,135 998 (1).
HOWATS -
A Walworth 10 Limitorarse 40 SNS-1 1080 550 ' 1000 550 20,339 998 (2)
- HOWATS F
Fowell 10 Limitorerse 60 55-2 1110 MO 1110 560 52.733 STATIC HOWATS.
F Fowell 19 Listaorarse 100 SBD-3 1110 560 1110 560 84,110 STATIC HOWATS G
Anchor Dar11og 10 Limitorque 25 SNS-1 1091. 563 1991 M3 39,416 MpWATS t
l (AC)
G Anchor Darling 10 Limitorque 40 SNS-1 1991 %3 1991 M3 37,723 NOWATS-(DC)
I J
Crane 10 Limitorerse.
.- 60 SNS-1 1250 575 1250 575 38,997 VUfES f
J Crane 10 Limitorarse 60 SMB-3 1250 575 1250 575 38,634 VerES L
Anchor Darling 10 Reliance g
SNS-1 1136 560 1136 M0 32,622 CAI4 Cats L
Anchor Darling 10 Porter /
25 SMB-1 1136 560 1136 560 34,072 Fearless M
Crane 10 Limitorarse 40 SNS-2 1200 550 1200 550 (17.460)
LInitsequE N
Crane
.10 Limitorarse 80 SNS-2 1200 550 1200 550 22,540 ~
IJNI1sRQUE i
MDWAT5 O
Anchor Darling 10 Limitorarse-150 SMB 4 1337 582 1337 582 116,000 g
NDWATS O
Anchor Darlins 10 Limitorapse.
150 SNS-4
,1337 532 1337 582 177,000 I
6 OG1/543A-01
~'I I
.t
~'
_________;____z a
'v
..,,. _ +
-y--.-
s,%._
9,.y.,
' ' ' ~ " * *
-eg-l.
i TABLE 1 iCoatinued) i BUROC SURVEY RESULTS F1R HFCI STEalf SUFFLY LINE IS01ATI@ Ma Openingt Closina
'h Valve / Type. Valve / Size Motor flanuL Hotor Onorator 9/1
'I 9/1
-I' Toraue Switch Basia Test D/F Baala Calca l
(in)
(ft Ib)
(Falg)(F) (peig)(F) Ihoist (ibs)
(Pois)
I F
Anchor Darling 10' Reliance SMB-1 r136 560 1136 560 31,325 CAK F
Anchor Darling 10 Porter /
25 SNS-1 1136 560 1136 560
- 37,183 Cag Fearless i
R Walworth 8
40 SMB-O 1116 583 1116 583 20,100 HOWATS-R Walworth 8
Limitorque 40 SMB 1116 583 1116 583 26,000 NOVATS S
Anchor Darling 10 Limitorque 40 SNS-1 1157 565 1157 565 36,602 NOWATS l
5 Anchor Darling 10 Limitorque 40 SMS-1 1157 565 1157 565 42,823 MUTATS T
Anchor Darling 10 Limitorque/
40-38-1 1250 545 1250 545 26,271l Vergs y
'l Reliance T
Anchor Darling 10 Limitorque/
60 SS-1 1250 545 1250 545 k20.326j t=vras Peerless MOWAN l
U Walworth 8
Limitorque' 40 SMB-0 1116 583 1116 583 28,227 i
i NDWATS U
Walworth 8
Limitorque 40 SNS-1 1116 583 1116 583 29,158 Worss V
Crane 10 Reliance 60 SMB-1 1250 575 1250 575 l24,017 l
50f85 l
10 Peerless 60 SMS-1 1250 575 1250 575 35,524 V
Crane
'MGWATS W
velan 8
Reliance AC 60 SMS-2 1104 560 1104 560 29,916 A
NGWATS U
velen 8
Fearlene DC 60 SMB-1 1104 560 1104 560 34,300 I:li s
OC1/543A-01 w
vv
. =g..
=g:
-- ;~~
,,.;;;x.,
s:::
n m ;
c.,
_m g:~
- Tanty 1 ( g gg----g 4
5 u:
- 3. [
- -i
'~
. = -
- n
- ... ;_
=
r51% ammawEi lie RTS FOR HPCI STFMt SUFFILY n taar genaarnas MDvs
- Doenine Closina Plant Valve /Tvoe Valve /stra Motor Mananf. tigsgi Opsutator DR - ' I pH ~ I Teresse Switch Basis Test B/F Beala Calms (in)
(fe Ib)
.(psig)(F) (psig)(F) Ihrnast (Ibe)
. (psig).
99 Anchor Darling 10 Limitorque
-40 SMB-1 1157 565 1157 565 36,602 MDUAT5 Q$
Anchor Darling 10 Limitergine 40 SMB-1 1157 565 1157 565' 42,823 asunTS t$
Anchor Darling 10 Limitorque 40 SNB-1 1350 1350 41,473 NGWATS
[29,654h MORATS~
?T Anchor Darling 10-Limitorque' 40 SMB-1 1350' 1350 4
O 6
ocl/543A-01 E
~~
^
N
.,.-, i eco.e n -m
- y '-
~
nunoc - -.ai a--..Tc rum' nFc1 swM SUFFLY uma IcauT1GE MDVa -
y Dassing closina oosrator am -I - na I L Terene switch : n..is rese n/r sasis Cales llang; valve /Tvo, valve /siz. noter u-=r. noter (fe Ib).
.(psig)(F) (paig)(F) Thrust (1bs)-
.(psig)-
=
7_ ;
- (in)-
26,000)
~
~
1080 56'OL I
latch 1 Crane
-10 40 SMB-0 latch 1 Crane 10 40 SMB-0 1080 560' 23,055!'
@ SMB-1' 1090 560 28,564 datch 2 Powell 10 40 SMB-1 1090 560 31,006 Hatch 2 Powell to
'1120 585 23,700
@ SMB-0 Monticello A/D 8
'25
-SMB-0
.1120 585 22,380 Monticello A/D 8
60 SMB-1 1250 575 40,000.
IC 1 Crane
'10 40 St18-1 1250 575 31,555
@C 1 Crane 10 1250 575 37,'729 60 SMB-1 QC 2 Crane 10 1250 575 38,208 40 SMB-1 QC 2 Crane 10 1110 573 34,633
.80 58-3 Duane A/D 10 Arnold 1110 573 35,905 60 SB-2 Duane A/D 10 Arnold 1337 582 116,000 150 SMB-4 AA A/D 10 1337 582 160,000 150 'SMB-4 AA A/0 10
4-l
{
TAB 11 2 l-BWROC SURVEY RESULTS EUK RCIC.31EAM SUFFLY LINE ISOEATION NDVs Goening Closina Umg; Valve /Tyne Valve /Siza notor Manuf. Motor Operator D/E I
D/1 I Toreue Switch Basis Test Bir Baala Calca I
(in)
(ft Ib)
(peig)(F)-(psig)(F) Thrust (Ibs).
(psig)
{
A Walworth 3
SMB-000 1000 550 1980 550 0.000 (2)
NOMB NOVATS I
A Walworth 3
SNS-000 1080 550 1000 550 7.700 NOMB NOVATS i
B Velan 8
Reliance 60(3) SB-1 1165 575 1165 575.23.960(4)(6)
STATIC GATIS S
Velan 8
Reliance 60(3) SB-1 1165 575 1165 575 28.220(4)(6)
STATIC GAT 13 ljin NOWATS C
Powell 10 Limitorque 40 SB-1 1250 575 1250 575 35.640 C
Fowell 10 Liettorque 40 SB-1 1250 575 1250 575 36.095 MUWATS VENeot
.l E
Velen 10 Liettorque 60 SB-2 1158 560 1158 Me 32.000]
i NDUATS LI E
Velan 10 Limitorque
- 60 SB-2 1158 560 1158 560 45.000 NDWATS E
Velan 1
SNS-000 1158 560 1158 560 2,657 1
F Fouell 4
Liettorque-7.5 SNS-00 1110 560 1110 %0 11,579 STATIC NDWATS j
F Fowell 4
Limitorque 10 SMB-00 1110 560 1110 560 9.709 STATIC IWWATS I
1100 NSWATS C
SNS-000 1991 563 1991 563 (2.980
... f (AC)
C Anchor Darling 3 Limitorque 5
SNS-000 1991 563 1991 563 3.600 1100
.HDWATS-
{
(DC)..
b
~NDWATS j
1150 550 9.016 4
Limitorque/
7.5 SNS-00 H
velan Forter-Feerlese l
I OC1/543A-01
(
j
~
,l L
TAB 12 U Cont W )
_ ~~~~#~ fl i
=
4.-
BUROG SURVEY RESULTS FUE RCIG_SIIalL30FFLY LINE ISOEATION Novs f_
Geening Closina
~
t glang Valve /Troe Valve /Sizg Motor Manuf. Hagag Goerator 9/I I
9/l. I Torque Switch Basis Test A/P E6, (in)
(fe Ib)
'(poig)(F)--(poig)(F) Thrust. (1bs)'
.(psig).
N Velan 10 Limitorque/
60 SMB-2 1150.550-37,400 NOVATS--
4 Reliance K
Rockwell 1
SMB-000 1150 550 1150 550 7,214' NOVATS q
K Anchor Darling 8 Limitorque 25 SMB-0 1150 550- 1150 550 22,583 NDWATS K
Anchor Darling 8 Limitorque 25
- SMB-0 1150 550 1150 550 25.018 NGEATS
~
'L Anchor Darling 3-Reliance 5
SMB-00 1136 560 1136 560 4,481 CAIC l
3
!a
'[i CAES L
Anchor Darling 3 Forter-Fearlese 5 SMB 1136 560 1136 560 5,312
^
NetATs-N Crane 3
SMB-00 1200 550 1200 550 5,800 MetATs" l
N Crane 3
Limitorque 7.5 :SMB-00 1200 550 1200 550 5,350 NDVATS 1i0 Anchor Darling 4 Limitorque/.
10: SMB-00 1140 575 IMO 575 8,669.
aJ Reliance NSDATS N
Anchor Darling 10 Reliance
{25$ SMB-1 1146 575 1146 575
{31,231 i
-NOVATS O
Anchor Darling 3 Limitorque 10 SNS-0 1337 582 1337 582 9.457-
'NOVATS j;l O
Anchor Darling 3 Limitorque 10 SIS-0 1337 582 1337 582 11.320
>l CAls.
[
F Anchor Darling 3 Reliance 5
SNB-00 1136. 560 11M %0 5,117 L>
a OC1/543A-01 a
i
A.,
o
- J+m 7.sw
. =,- ;.. : - l _
TARE F' 2 (rwI---J
-Y 5svr.i meisTS FOR RCIC STrAM SUFFLY 53mm law ATION HOVs i
Openian Closina flagg Valve /Tyne Valve /Stra Motor "-- O Motor peerster D/I I
9/1 I formue Switch pasis Test 9/F Baalm _Calca (in)
(ft Ib)
(psig)(F)-(peig)(F) Thrust (1bs)
(pois) -
jj P
Anchor Darling 3 Forter/ Peerless 5 SMB-00 1136 560 1136 560 7,156 Calf
.i
~ NOWATS -
q Anchor Darling 4 Limitorque/
10 SMB-00 1140 575 1140 575 8.450 I.eliance NDWAT5' Q
Anchor Darling 10 1.1mitorque/
\\25 \\
SMS-1
'1146 575 1146 575
{23,47
..u co NDWATS R
Walworth 3
Liettorque 5
Sun-000 1116 583 1116 583 6,100 NOWATs.
R Walworth 3
Liettorque 5
Sus-000 1116 583 1116 583 4.480 NOVATS S
Anchor Darling 4 Limitorque 7.5
'SNS-00 1157 565 1157 M5 7.425 NOWAYS l
S Anchor Darling 4 Limitorque 10 SMB-00 1157 M5 1157 565
>=,677 varas fyT Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque/
58.00 1029 545 1020 545 9,354 me11.nce 11.465\\
VUTES f
pw
\\T Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque/
\\15 k S5-00 1020 545 1020 545 Fe.rles.
'f
.NOWATS 3
Liettorque 5
SMS-000 1116 583 1116 583 4,680 i
- NDWATS
.j U
Walworth 3
Linitorque 5
SMS-000 1116 583 1116 583 5,140 t
NDWATS -
l.
U Walworth 3
Reliance 10 SMS-000' 1104 560 1104 560 5,480 i
A' i
U Uestinghouse
-(AC)
-NDWATS l
3 Feerless 5
SMB-000 1104 560' 1104 % 0 6,269 W
Velan (DC) i OG1/543A-01 i
~
. v :x -
.,=
P ~ I.
TABLE 2 (Cont M )
l
~
t-SistDG m-wr.x artsfLTS FOR RCIC ST*Am SUFFLY t int 1_e_rnat1GII IDra -
Openinn Closina h
Valve /Troe Valve / Size IIntor Ilanuf. Egger Operator 3/Z I
g/Z I'.Toraue Switch Basis Test 9/F Baala Calca (in)
' (ft 1b)
(psig)(F) (peig)(F) EnEllag (1bs)
(psig):
~
.i 1 Anchor Darling 4
~Limitorque 7.5 -Sats-00 1157 %5.1157 MS -
z7,A25 sesvATS t{ $
Anchor Darling-4 Limitorque 10 5168-00 1157 M5 1157 M5
>7,200 IIpWATS S1
-Anchor Darling
'4
-Limitorque 10 - 5818-00 1350 1350
.6.848-aletATS.
-l Q1 Anchor Darling 4
Liettorque 10 -$185-00 1350.
' 1350
' >6,%7 (Design) 11081T5 -
~
+
n.
i
.- l
^
i l
l i
h.
k i
OC1/543A-01
- - r-"
F 2"P
'4
~-
L
~
5'"
M*'"*-
c. _ __"__ _ _ _, _ _ _
a
TAB 12 2 (Contimmed) 4
.BUROC simwr.i #FtULTS FOR RCIC STFAM SUFFLY L1Ma ISOEATION MOVs Openina Closina Basis Test D/F Basta Calts h
Valve /Tvee Valve / Size Motor M--4 Bater operator m _ I n =
I.. Toraue Switch (in)
(ft Ib)~
(psig)(F) (psig)(F) Thrust (Ibs)
-(psig) 10 SMB-00 1080.560 9,827 riatch 1 Crane 4
10 SMB-00 1080 560 10,176 Hatch 1 Crane 4
10 SMB-00 1090 560
'7,050 Hatch 2 Powell 4
10 St1B-00 1090 -560.
12,653 Xatch 2 Powell 4
5 SMB-000 1120 585 6,220 Monticello A/D 3
5 SMB-000 1120 585.
6,260' Monticel10 A/D 3
l 5
SMB-000 1250 575
'5,121 QC 1 Crane 3
4.5
'SMB-000 1250.575 5,299 QC 1 Crane 3
5 SMB-000 1250.575 5,576 QC 2 Crane 3
4.5 SMB-000
'1250 575 8,627 QC 2 Crane 3
10 SMB-00 1110 583
.9,025 l
Duane A/D 4
1110 '583 6,073 Arnold 10 SMB-00 Duane A/D 4
j 1025 535-37,509 Arnold 60 SB-1 X
Borg Warner 10 1025 535 36,151-60 SB-1 X
Borg Warner 10 1337 582 17,580 3
-10
.SMB-0 1337 582
'12,280 AA A/D 10 SMB-0 3
1450' 590 4,600 AA A/D 10 SMA-00 4
1450 590 4,600 AB Powe11 10 SMA-00 4
l AB Powell
~
W
.cv.e_
r.oq w.-,e.ny
-s u.
g,_
j l
TABIZ 3 l
l BEROC mur.1 arturvs ytm maars: SUFFLY 13ana lens
- TIM IENs Onenina Closina Flant Yalve/IYDe Valve / Size ll0ter ManuL llg.ligg Operator BIE I
R/,2 I formue Switch a m in Test B/F Baala Calca (in)
(ft Ib)
-(peig)(F) )peig)(F) h (Ibe)
(poig)
A Fowell 4
SMB-000 1980 550 1000 550
~.7,745 (2)
Nout CAIss A
Fowell 4
SMB-000 1080 550 1000 550 7,480 NOWE CAIs3 8
Velan 6
Reliance 25 53-1 1250 -575 1250 575 15,833-Nous CatsS(7)
{14,250 )
sone CARES (7)-
S Velan 6
Reliance 40 55-1 1250 575 1250 575 C
Powell 6
Limitergene 25 SNS-0 1250 575 1250 575 14,545-LINI1esqua CAIK LINI10BquE C
Fowell 6
Limitorqise 25 SMB-0 1250 575 1250 575 14.545 Cats NOWAYS TEST
{12,300 l
D Anchor Darling 6.
- 25 550-0 1020 575 1250 575 (DC)
NOWATS TES1 D
Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque 58D-0 1020 575 1250 575 16,100 (AC)
E Velan 8
Limitorque 80 SS-2 1050 575 1050 575 E
'Velan 8
Limitorque 80 55-2 1200 575 1200 575 6
Limitorque 25 SNS-00 1100 560 1100 560 15.334 STATIC' NOVATS F
Fowell Cats 6
Limitorque 40 SSD-0 1100 560 1100 560 12,626 b
FIAirt BRSIGN F
Fowell j
G Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque 15 SNS 1091-575 1991 575 13,354 (AC)
OC1/543A-01
=
~.i & *
.--..,,, n -
. e,,,,
n w
-..2.
Tams e' 3 (Conte l--- S EBfROC saatumi Reanvs yon puru supy1Y uma isogM10s MDva Opening Ocairy flang; Valve /Tvoe Valve / Size h h Meter Onerator 9/1 I
R/I I Torous Switch Basis Test 9/P Basta Calca
-(in)
(ft Ib)
(psig)(F) )psig)(F) h (1bs)
(peig)
FUUff DESIt;W C
Anchor Darling 6 Limiterque 15 SMB-00 1991 575 1091 575 13,354 (DC)
N Velan 6
Limiterque/
-40 SNB-O 1965 533 11.655 k LIN11EsquE Porter-Fearless 1
LIN11caqua 1065 533 1,655}
N Velan 6
Limitorque/
40 SMB-0 Reliance 1
Crane-Chapman
-6 Limitorque 40 SB-1 1030 575 1030 575 12.397
- i 1190575}10.039) h SNB-0 1190 575 1
Anchor Darling 6 Lietterque VREOR 8
Limitorque 40 SNS-0 1250 575 1250 575 21.388 WElect J
Crane B
Limitorque 60 SNS-1 1250 '575 1250 575
-21,749 NSWA23 J
Crane 1960 %1 1940 541 24 h
SNB-00 K
Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque NouaTS 1960541{14,928]
SNB-00 1040 541 K
Anchor Darling 6 Limiterque CALC 1150 562 h 3.233}
h SNS-00 1000 562 Reliance N
L Anchor Darling -6 1150 562 h3.220)
SMB-00 1000 562 L
Anchor Darling 6 Perter /
Peerless NSWATS 6
Lietterque' 25 SMB-0 1250 M2 1250 % 2 18,400 6
NOWaTS 6
Limitorque 25 SNS-0 1250 %2 1250 % 2 19.324 N
Velan N
1250575ll3.%
N Velan SMB-00 1250 575 6
Reliance N
Anchor Darling OC1/543A-01
- ~
i
~..
a...,.
TABLE 3.(Continued) t EMOG StRVEY RESULTS RR EIMM SUFFLY LIM ISOEATION HDVs 1
i i
m ig M
Valve / Type Valve /sima Motor ManuL Noter Operator Egg I
.R I Teraus Switch Basis Test D/f Bastalaisa :
(in)
(ft Ib)
(psig)(F)' )peig)(F) h (Ibe)
(peig)
. j 1250 575 1250 575 {13,405 }
~
TBOOE D
Anchor Darling 6 Reliance' j7.5 )
SMB-00 i
O Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque 60 58-2 1360. 542 1360 582 47.900 NGWAYS O
Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque 60 58-2 1360 582 1360 582 37,700 NsWATS f
F Anchor Darling 6-Reliance SNS-00 1000 M2 1150 %2 16.06 Cats 1
F Anchor Darling 6 Porter /
SMB-00 1000 M2 1150 M2 13,786{-
' Cats ~
l j
Foerless 13,405k gemon 7.5)
SMB-00 1250 575 1250 575 Q
Anchor Darling 6 Reliance l
Q Anchor Darling 6 Reliance i
SMB-00 1250 575 1250 575 13,405)
Tages Worss l
R Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque 60 58-2 1100 555 1142 555 34,662
{13,700 }
NDWATS R
Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque-25 SNB-0 1100 555 1173 555 2,000)
Cats l
5 Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque SNS-00 1025 535 1025 535 f
Cats 5
Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque SNS-00 1025 535 1025 535 12,800}
l 7
WUrss 4T Anchor Darling 3 Limitorque/
2 38-000 1250 545. 1250 545
{3.300
)
Reliance i
18FE8 l
' {t3C DT Anchor Darling 3 Limitorque/
5 58-000 1250 545 1250'545 A
j 8
Fearles.
-NDWATS l
U Waluorth 6
Limitorque 10 SNS-00 1100 555 1142 555 15,194-i OC1/543A-01
-,__,-.--.-n
~_y,.
.w. wp
>:e w--
TAB 12 1 icentinised)
.y N,
ElRDG SERVEY RESULTS FM 3MC0 SUFF12 LIM 1sotATim nova Gagalag Closingt h
Valve /Ivne Valve / Size Iloter Mannaf. Enggg Omarater 3/2 - I 3/2
-I Teresse Switch Basis Toat B/F Emata Categ J (in)
(ft ab)-
(psig)(F) )peig)(F) h (1bs).
(peig)
U Walworth 6
Limitorque, h SNS-00 1100' 555 1142 555 20,200 NOVATS ~
1250575..[21.388) vegnet V
Anchor Darling- 0 Reliance 40 SMB-0 1250 575 V
Anchor Darling 8 Reliance 60 SMB-1 1250.575 1250575{21.749k vsgeon 21.749)
TEgmot V
Anchor Darling 8 Reliance 60 SMB-1 1250 575 1250 575 1
'[
- h SMB-00 1135 560 W
Walworth 6
Bellance (AC)
V "E Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque SMB-00 1025 535 1025 535 $12.800\\
CAIK l
1025 535 1025 535 {12.000 !
CAIK j
i 4B Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque h
SNB-00 bT Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque SNB-0 1300 1300
{19,179 IIDEATS IIDWATS I
(17.872 g1 Anchor Darling 6 Limitorque SilB-0 1300 1300
}
i i
4 i
f i
OG1/543A-01
_. - ~. ~
. _ ~ _,..
'Y-'
E :'
- TAatz 3 (Contiamad)
M N N FOR INCE SHFFLY LIIE IS01ATim assys Osenina Closina flagg Valve /Tyne Valve / Size alster Blanuf. Hasar comratog am I-ng I Terene switch Racis Test R/F Baala Calca
-(in)
(ft Ib)
(psig)(F) )psig)(F) h (1bs)
(psig) c Hatch 1 Crane 6
15 SMB-00 1250 560 14,000 Hatch 1 Crane 6
- 15 '
SMB-00 1250 560 14,000 Hatch 2 Crane 6
15-SMB 1250 560 12,000}
Hatch 2 Crane 6
15-SMB-00 1250 560 12,000i Montice11o A/0 4
7.5 SMB-00 1375 585 14.700
~
Monticello A/D 4
10 SMS-00 1375 585 12,000 QC 1 Crane 6
SMB-00 1250 575
.16,506[
QC 1 A/D 6
- SMB-00 1250 575 8,333]
QC 2 Crane 6
SMB-00 1250 575-l 4,004l
~ ^
QC 2 A/D 6
3
.SMB-00 1250 575 [10,190,
^
Duane A/D 4
15 SMB-00 1100 573 6,186 Arnold 10 SMB-00 1100 573 6,136 Duane A/D 4
Arnold X
Borg Llarner 6
25 SMB-0 1195 535 22,643 25 SHB-0 1195 535 19,517 l
f X
Borg Llarner 6
60 SB-2 1360 582 56,360 AA A/D 6
60-SB-2 1360 582 59,282 AA A/D 6
25 SMB-0 1250 575 15,152 C
Powell 6
25 SMB-0 1250 575 15,152 C
Powell 6
, r<
c.-.
_